to work, if it does not come further, law enforcement agencies should be involved, mr. mykhailo. thank you , mykhailo makaruk, the spokesman for the intelligence community , napalm information, joined our broadcast and we are moving on . of the internet believes that aid to ukraine makes it difficult to achieve the goals of sustainable development of the un will have to declare that russia's war in ukraine is aggravating europe's commitment to international aid and climate action, he also said that the world is on track to fail to achieve almost all of the un's sustainable development goals, which its leaders have pledged to achieve by the

30th year. development, gates said , he admitted that the costs of donor countries to respond to the coronavirus pandemic made it difficult to guide the domestic policy of international aid, but the war in ukraine, i would say, is even worse because of excessive europe's spending on areas from food security to gender equality said and this war in ukraine is increasing their budgets defense costs refugees electricity subsidies and shipping costs told her because the deadlines for replenishing the global fund to fight to fight aids malaria tuberculosis it is important tuberculosis and of the global polio eradication initiative, it is so important for our goal to emphasize that these budgets should not be cut if at all possible, bill gates said it is very important poliomyelitis and tuberculosis. and what else is malaria? it's important. i think that rich americans should also think about basic human

rights so that people not only do not get polio , but also are not simply tortured and buried in the yards of their own houses. in which they lived peacefully until february 24 this year, in the meantime, the committee of ministers of the council of europe made a decision to ensure the responsibility of the russian federation for aggression against ukraine . we will ask the council of europe in ukraine about this in particular and about the crimes themselves oleksandra romantsova human rights activist executive director of the center for civil liberties oleksandr congratulations well, let's start with the weight of this decision. you have a publication about this on your website on september 15. what weight is the most important thing in this decision oleksandr can you hear us

that yes yes please or in this decision that we finally have an international organization that directly supports the creation of a separate crime because, unfortunately, international criminal cases or the international court of justice, the un does not close this crime itself, which is less frightening than us, it is actually the beginning of the feedback of the initiative of a political solution, both by putin and the political leadership of the russian federation, so how important is it that it is already headed by the council of europe, the first the organization that initially said such a resolution of the parliamentary council of europe and now the committee on foreign affairs, which is directly

the main political body of the council of europe support this idea, the question is in the form, that is, how exactly it will be organized, and here i am, in principle, we discussed with our representative office the fear that they will present wholesale e-e options as it is comfortable. thus, the council of europe can support the form further exactly well, in fact, the court directly for the fact that putin painted his game in 2014. how do you assess what is happening now in the liberated izyum, and the mayor of izyum said that only the gumming of the bodies will last for two weeks, that is, there were so many tortured ukrainians and all it is necessary to exhume and identify, and this is a very long

procedure. how do you assess the scale of these crimes that the russians committed in kharkiv oblast? how do you qualify them correctly? well, this is a genocide of murders. what is it with the genocide of legal entities? it is more difficult there. it is necessary to prove that a person actually had the motivation to influence these people. it was, for example, an ethnic sign or a religious one a sign, that is, it is possible in that it is the most difficult, let’s say love. you now that such a motivation is direct at the same time, it is for sure and they really fall into categories, it can be, we have signs suffocation is a sign that a person was tied up while buying what was rivne murder. well, here it is possible, yes, that is, they find tracks or openings or injuries on the

compatibility of life. this is one type of crime, and if it is civil people, this is a violation of the third wife of poets , i.e. prisoners, er, our er, soldiers are ukrainian , that's why we see that they are with a child, well, that is, the program is more accurate. the fourth is closed and if so died from the fact that there was only enough medicine at the bottom, which is why it is so difficult to assess everything in detail, that is, another war crime in the midst of death, that is, all this must be calculated and described so that it is really the conditions of the dock so

that in the future we can to sell all the courts and this, well, no one will point out that this is a bad investigation. that is why it is so important and that is why it is children quickly and it is right, it is better to do it in an office. any quickly and quickly everything will be identified according to the day and therefore so that there are many relatives the nucleus not only wrote a statement to the police, but also gave him dna so that it could understand when it is a 100% match that it is actually a relative, a bad connection. let's reconnect because the words fall out of your story . to understand the general plan. it is clear. but it is difficult to understand the details . regarding the bodies in general and the war

crimes of the russians, russia hands over the bodies of the ukrainian dead in a terrible condition, sometimes there is nothing to take dna from, the patronage service reports everything azov was informed about this by the head of the patronage service of the azov regiment, olena tolkacheva. the russians give us just the remains. they are so damaged, the putrid changes are so deep that sometimes there is even nothing to take the dna material. she said, according to olena tolkacheva, the general staff is engaged in searching for the dead. at the general staff, there is a special service called the situation of the fallen . on the shield it used to be called evacuation 200, they are responsible for this line of work, we cooperate with them when the dead are taken to the morgue we help to initially identify of the dead, because my girls and i have been working since the 14th year, said tolkachova, we personally know a lot of people, so we can recognize acquaintances by

tattoos, for example, olena said, this is only an initial examination and registration, then the knowledge goes directly to the forensic medical examination or the dna procedure or with some special signs, the relatives are called and they already sign the protocol of knowledge that they agree that these are their relatives or we are waiting for a dna match, said tolkachev, and we are waiting oleksandr romantsova is already with us, mrs. oleksandra, we will be able to. that way, we will hear you better, yes, he wants night problems, please, about the bodies of azov citizens who are handed over in such a state that there is nothing to even sometimes take a dna examination well, i understand that i understand that not only azov people, in general, followed the dead ukrainian soldiers returning from the battlefield from the russians, to whom the

russians are handed over, who are handed over by the russians to the ukrainians, and who write to the azov service that sometimes there is not even anything to take dna for, how many cases are common under the time of this war well here in general you have to understand it was a big start to exchange this if it is not so that the agreement there above the front line after immediately between the units of ukraine of the kyiv army yes they immediately agreed after the battle there is which i don’t think that now oh in kherson lordly donetsk or control-offensive yes but before that it was here and then it was, well, the fastest uh, well, it was the most frequently asked question in which it can be recognized in the further

version - i didn’t perceive it differently at all and you saw had a part in it, you also had such, you know, the first moment the side is forced to smoke for the defense , the frankiv assault on train-running exercises, soldiers and the international press are kept so that they don’t want russia by one year, that is, from our side, the letter a, which is enough in refrigerators on the rural side, i was in general, even it may be that you don’t know, and not evil motivations but it's just a poorly organized exercise like this in the whole committee. well, it and the army can be civilized, it's respect, so there are

several options, yes. well, of course, on olenivka. well, of course there will be more. but how the situation is shown to me including indirectly and even willingly in which they are tortured and it is considered that an investigative mission is chosen between us, first of all, it is not just an opportunity to enter a criminal organization, yes , that is, we see that a few years ago, she sought to torture evidence, an example of torture according to pathologists to see and these are broken facts that happened and it was like that can be evaluated so to see russian and also where possible even additional to what russia wants to call its

own crimes well, but somewhere it can be unfortunately we can't hear you normally through the word, we hear oleksandr romantsova defends her rights , the executive director of the center for civil liberties, well, let's continue the topic. now we'll show one video, but first i'll just give you information about the fact that a week ago, the development of the united states found out that moscow is buying weapons from north korea, wait a second this was reported by the new york times, according to classified us intelligence data received by our american colleagues, russia purchased millions of artillery shells and missiles from pyongyang, according to american government officials, this shows that the sanctions against russia have affected the ability of the kremlin to support the war in ukraine. well, now let's watch a video of how the citizens of north korea see off in with what he went out for a boat ride in some japanese or yellow sea and

how he is seen off by grateful citizens, i think that soon this can be observed in russian countries too, let's watch a video of a marathon for you mutsu

asked if it's true it's true it's called what 's it called send the leader to the sea i'm just i think of it as how people can. it's degradation , it's limitation, all that's zombification, how to call it, they're very similar to russian soldiers, but it all starts with glasses from a dictaphone and someone from dmytro kostyantynovich kiselyov , the debilitation of the population, then it's like this. does, and then we later in neighboring countries, people dig up graves and here in izyum, investigators exhumed the body of a civilian man with traces of torture, and the forensic expert reported that after a visual examination, the hands were tied behind the back, the genitals were cut off just a civilian, even this grave among the 500

graves we will remind under the raisin that was found and this is only one place of burial and there are only a few of them there and only here they will be excavated for a few more weeks to work on the exhumation of local people, this is important because every crime must be recorded and every body must be examined they are mostly civilians and all of them have signs of violent death and cake. well, and about war crimes, nine russian soldiers have already been sentenced for crimes on the territory of ukraine. the prosecutor general reported on this in many cases andriy kostin informed us about this, we always communicate with him about this, but i want to note that only in relation to shishimarin there is a sentence for murder, other sentences for shelling of civilian objects, theft , looting, etc., that is, we do not have very many military personnel russia in which we can really condemn , i mean that not in absentia, that is, this

work continues, we are working on each case , said the prosecutor general, at the same time, according to him, many cases concerning the russian military are transferred to to the court for a hearing in absentia if we have collected evidence. we cannot keep these cases. it will be wrong to simply keep it. if there are victims, they should feel the justice that there will be a verdict even in absentia, said one prosecutor, oleksandr slobozhan, joined by the executive director of the associations of ukrainian cities, oleksandr congratulations you good morning good morning please tell me whether to monitor the situation with preparation for the heating season precisely in the liberated territories because we understand what is there the most critical situation is kharkiv region, tell me, in fact, it is the most political situation in these territories, besides, there are many difficulties in the front-line territories, and of

course donetsk, luhansk, zaporizhia, and kherson will face serious challenges in the regions, first of all, one of the serious challenges is the restoration of the destroyed infrastructure, because it was deliberately destroyed, and i want to tell you that in general, the territory of ukraine from february 24 to february was destroyed more than 400 critical objects infrastructures that provide heat water and electricity supply to the territorial community and which city is the most destroyed by the government of course after the liberation when

the hot phase of hostilities passed we faced such the technological situation for the destruction of akhtyr and chernihiv tet, and here there is a similar situation, therefore, for this reason, i am sure that funds should be allocated from the reserve fund of the state budget directly for the restoration, it is clear that the number of consumers of these of communal services, it will be smaller, but anyway, we need to ensure an uninterrupted supply of warm, hot, warm, cold water . oleksandr and in general, the association of cities of ukraine assesses the amount of destruction. i mean the money needed to restore

apartments and houses multi-apartment buildings private houses preparation for winter that is, what percentage of what was damaged and destroyed was financed from the local and state budgets in the plan of restoration because i am there in my own way the destroyed irpinyons, the surrounding area, bucha gostomel, now izyum kupyansk, well, a huge number of chernihiv and i see that there is actually a month left until winter, given the current cold weather, well, there is a month and a half until frost, and a very small percentage has been restored. how do you estimate the overall percentage of restored apartments, houses , apartments well, and critical infrastructure in general, i'm asking utilities, ah, well, first of all, for each settlement , the percentage of destruction is different. the most destruction of the housing sector, if

we talk about chernihiv, then somewhere around 200 infrastructure objects need to be restored, if we talk about financing , funds from local budgets are primarily used, this is the first source of which the second source is aimed at recovery - this is the help of our international partners through various twinning agreements ukrainian municipalities are twinned with european municipalities from other countries of the world and the united states from canada they they provide priority assistance or, for example , direct financing by transferring funds to the accounts of the municipality. unfortunately, for

now, funding for restoration is not systematically funded from the state budget. at the same time, in the 23rd year, uah 26 billion were laid down, which should be directed to the restoration of damaged infrastructure. they are distributed among several programs. 19 billion is directly the reconstruction fund, and the other part will go to credit programs that provided by our international partners this funding will be operated by the ministry of community development of territories. hmm, primarily today, they are concentrated. if we are talking about state funding, then on critical infrastructure, for example, 300 million uah. allocated for the

restoration of the okhtyr church, chernihiv and kremenchug churches. we expect that the government will allocate another 70 million from the reserve fund for the restoration of the kharkiv thermal power plant because, well, these are such priority needs, and in addition, the region the budget, the regional budget, about er, a little more in billions of hryvnias was allocated for er, reconstruction needs, including uah 400 million, which were allocated, for example, in the kyiv region, decisions have already been made, er, er, there was a redistribution of these funds by the municipality, well , that is, directly for example, in the borodyanka guest house, irpenyu in makarov other settlements , but of course this is not enough, i cannot help but say about the initiative of the city of kyiv,

so the mayor of kyiv, mr. klitschko, addressed the mayors of these settlements with offer e-e to provide financial aid for reconstruction considering that, as you correctly said, winter is near and people need to return to their homes, they need to be heated, such assistance will be provided within the framework of the kyiv agglomeration and it is caused by the fact that these settlements let's be honest, they stopped the enemy from capturing the capitals, so i hope that from the next klitschko, i didn't understand. he offered financial assistance financial assistance to these municipalities specifically for recovery of the destroyed infrastructure e-e this allows e-e the budget code of ukraine in us e-e was created in the kyiv region the so-called kyiv agglomeration e-e in the

form of such an association and e-e last week there was the signing of e such agreements between kyiv e- well, many other communities to receive such funding and already in october they receive it and, accordingly, they will be able to direct it to the restoration of infrastructure , either residential or non-residential. this is another spritz of examples . as local self-government among themselves horizontally in such conditions, it helps to solve the issue of centralized funding, well , from the national level, and the housing fund, mr. oleksandr, but you personally evaluate it in ukraine , although in the kyiv region, estimate how much percentage it is, uh, financed restoration well, not more than

10 %. look here, it is necessary to distinguish between the definition of needs and the definition of needs, because these needs are in the billions. let's be frank, these are billions of needs. this is the first block, the second block is the laying of funds from the state budget, and the third block, if you say financed, it means that the funds have already arrived in the accounts of the municipality, and the tender procedures have been carried out, and uh, any of them are there. well, whoever is selected uh, in the tender, starts reconstruction in us. we have only passed two stages, that is, de facto , the evaluation secondly, the funds were laid down and now at the third stage they are redistributed among the municipalities because these are huge funds and a huge scale of destruction, mr. oleksandr, what i wanted to clarify about the budget was that you wrote that in the draft budget. well, there

it is indicated for the restoration of infrastructure and the fact that the tax on the incomes of military individuals remains in the communities because we talked to the people's deputies. they said that they did not take this into account. self-governance , not restoration, i said at the beginning that now, accordingly , all the work related to this is happening mainly at the expense of local budgets, but taking into account what will happen in our country the economic composition, the receipts of local budgets cannot cover those needs, does it also apply to the housing stock and critical infrastructure, that is why the battle turned, and it

lasted for several months, too. submitted a project which assumed that those funds would go to the state budget, this is almost uah 60 billion, that is, to fix the figure, but in the final version according to budget consultations with the local self-government assistance of the cities of ukraine acted in this case, the signatories of this protocol there, and it was decided to leave these funds to local self-government and for 2023, the personal income tax with the military part of the draft state budget approved by the government. situation, in addition, in addition, the percentage of personal income tax credits to local budgets will be 64%.

that is, plus 4% is added, why is this done by me let me remind you that at one time, we signed a memorandum with the central government. the main goal was to ensure that heating tariffs were not increased. but for that, we need help to utility companies, direct financial assistance, and precisely these funds. if it is voted in the form that i said , they will be directed to help, but there is still a problem that has not been solved uh, uh, in the summer, when the changes to the state budget were approved, which we uh, for enterprises, 14 billion hryvnias of subventions uh were provided for stable passage heating season, although the government submitted uah 38 billion , and in this case, we have detectors of these

uah 24 billion for the stable passing of the hot season, and we expect that the parliament will still return the government's version and add uah 24 billion to the state budget as early as 2022 year, because it is important to do it in the 22nd year, if we are talking about the 23rd year, then if the budget is adopted in the form in which we talked with you, that is, the personal income tax of the military remains for local self-government and 64% will be if local budgets are counted, then this is certain will allow us to direct them to recovery programs and pass the heating season . thank you very much, mr. oleksandr, for lobbying for this initiative. it is important that the military tax money remains. well, where they are registered, where their families live, where children go to school, where parents and wives go to the hospital, it is important because the military is very busy now