that it will not and will not be possible for putin to mobilize in one day, one week, even one month, first of all , these people will still have to be trained, and we can imagine. ran away in the second and was taken away in beds. are liberating ukrainian lands from these terrorists, and their mobilization, in my opinion, works more positively for ukraine why because finally all the russians who were sitting on the sofa and supported the special opera ugu realized that tomorrow putin

will lead each of them to the slaughter and we will see how they will be now react the next thing finally the whole world understood that with this decree and mobilization putin recognized the failure of the so-called special operation for the whole world and not only the russians understood this, so the whole world should remember that this is blackmail and not play with putin and it is clear and tough to continue the sanctions policy , including in relation to nuclear security, and to draw conclusions that only the ukrainian soldier can finally finish the matter with this mountain snake by destroying it. in the verkhovna rada

, the project is being considered, and half of almost half of this budget has begun to be considered. and this is a trillion 300 billion will go specifically to the defense sector, but i am worried about something else. this is the quality and the efficiency of the use of funds is what oleg mykhailovych talked about preparing for the winter, every problem has a surname, a first name and a patronymic. by the way, according to my information, the last rate of the supreme , it is the commanding officer, the question of preparing for the winter period was considered there. i think that there should be already org-conclusions our industry can sheathe feed and not wait er i agree with the position what to expect from nato colleagues for support in this direction but we say so and the effectiveness of the use of funds further and we will talk let's include only yaroslav zheleznyak, your colleague , people's deputy of ukraine, yaroslav, you have glory

to ukraine, i would like you to share your thoughts on the correct administration of budget funds, so to speak. this is such a psychological blow from putin's side, and i compare it to the blow when he launched missile strikes on the territory of ukraine on february 24, because it is already clear today that missiles, even high-precision ones, even in large numbers, today they are measured in thousands , neither the ukrainian army nor the ukrainian economy can be destroyed, but what did putin count on at that time, that the ukrainians would raise their hands and receive such a great psychological blow from fear that they would simply disperse, and this is his issue of mobilization, it is also a psychological one strike in order to, first of all, literally destroy the ukrainians, and on the other hand, to

demonstrate whether the attack on the western world was successful. of course not. because i absolutely agree with mykhailo mykhailovych, if the armed forces of ukraine crushed the elite moscow units, then these recruits, well, i am convinced that their place is already ready, but as for the budget, well, we were with mr. mykhailo in the session hall when the draft budget for the 23rd year was presented and it was very it's a shame because there are 250 people out of a large number of the so-called monomajority, as they say. well, if there were 10-15 people, there were simply no others, and you had a question, either they don't understand anything or they don't care so much. well, or i, even i don't know what it is when the most important financial document of the country is considered, and the deputies, what a sacred duty to do it, is simply not in the hall

. a vote so that the money provided to the military from february from the road fund should not be stolen for large-scale construction , and we won in the end because it was already clear in the decision made this week it is written that these funds are primarily directed to the defense of the state, but it was necessary to break so many bayonets, it was necessary to raise such a strong public opinion that absolutely obvious things that the money should be primarily directed to the military should be recorded in a document of the ukrainian parliament, and we will definitely fight for such things and fight was at the meeting, tell me because now we don't see your meetings. good day once again, mr. yaroslav, as the deputy head of the budget committee, he is not only present at the meeting

one of those people who actually works at 100%. we are waiting, believing and trusting, mr. yaroslavovych. what is the matter with our budget, well, the fuel excise tax, what will it be returned, this money will be targeted for defense? yes, this, this, we have achieved this . we are talking about military taxes, yes, for them it is, hmm, for local budgets, it is a very important item of income to understand even for mariupol, yes, to support the teachers of immigrants there, this is the only current income, and we leave it for next year without changes, etc., also regarding personal income tax, including personal income tax that is paid to the military units of the 64th budget. well, it goes on according to the distribution, so there is no change at all in the position of the government this year

. in order not to disturb the business now, not to push them to change their tax residence, the taxes for the next year simply do not change, but none of the taxes are expected to change in 2023, there is even a single thing . it is probably a plan to gradually increase the shares but it was prescribed a long time ago, it was agreed upon by them, you know , again, with business, so in this case, on the tax side, you can probably call it a victory as far as the targeted use of the road fund is concerned. it goes to crossings and so on. all this will be in effect until december 31, 2022, 2023, according to the new law on the state budget of 2023. the state

road fund can be used as you like. but again, here you have to understand what we have now martial law and, accordingly, martial law and, accordingly, the ministry of finance. well, if we are very honest, now the powers regarding the distribution of the budget are so great that regardless of what is written in the budget, they can make a quest for each distributor of money and transfer it to the account or to the army, so if the ministry of finance there will be a procedure, so rowing the budget will be under the current circumstances, it already exists, it is effective from the 24th, here is the 23rd, even in february, we previously accepted this opportunity for them a day before the start of the war, uh, they made their own decision are brought to the cabinet of ministers and simply take the money, and if you say so, mr. yaroslav, well, yes, very quickly , earlier it was agreed by the committee and then by the committee of the verkhovna rada, if the money is transferred to another distributor, then accordingly it

required a vote in the parliament, how to change the budget now in pension fund, well, extremely high powers, such as the distribution of the budget and transfer to the military or the special fund, and they use it to understand already approximately 400 billion this year. well, this is an extremely large amount, for sure they secreted 1/4 of the peace budget and took away these expenses, well, i don’t know any fuses , control mechanisms, or whether there is any discussion of foresight in this process or not. well, we can only hope that this discussion is in the cabinet of ministers. i remember the situation. yes, when we all understood that a large russian invasion would be implemented. yes, even then we calculated certain scenarios, understanding that the enemy would hit critical infrastructure objects,

so on the other hand, a separate one appeared then gas cases, then there are local budgets, sorry, you decided to transfer part of the responsibility, now local budgets throughout the country are empty. i don’t know what can be squeezed out of them in x hour, well, in order to, for example, simply insure the owner of the city, which i think well, until the end, no one and he does not know what scenarios are possible scenarios of a rather critical p. yaroslav, what would your procedure be then, look, first of all, i do not really agree with you that all local budgets are empty in your studio, you have two representatives of the lviv region as far as i i understand from the numbers, i don’t want to talk specifically because we see the latter, but for example, the budget of the lviv region is more than planned. and it is logical because of the post that the salaries of the military, according to the personal income tax, come in, and all the other processes are just there. they are so or otherwise, they were partially

moved from east to west. and there are areas in which there are really, well, conditionally there are problems there, very bad , bad situation, for example, as far as i can see from the numbers in zaporizhzhia, and here, uh, again, we need to understand in more detail, for example, yesterday in the evening, i was dealing with the situation that we have students from my hometown mariupol who went to vocational education and those who went to lviv oblast. in other words, this is the same burden for lviv oblast. it is not clear if they are new money. the same in ternopil oblast, the same in ivano-frankivsk oblast. oblasts, etc., that's why the budget now provides for a subvention in one way or another, not recovery plus aid, i'm not mistaken, about 45 billion because we see that the ministry of finance quite often now helps the budgets of local communities to be capable, but once again, we have an emergency

situation, and we definitely have to look at military time, well, conditionally, the situation two weeks ago may differ from the fact that the situation is emergency and it may become, unfortunately, even more emergency. mykhailo well, actually, we should not forget i agree with my colleague that we are living in a period of martial law, and here great responsibility rests with the central body of executive power, the cabinet of ministers, which should have the professional expertise to divide and distribute funds also to local military civil military administrations because they received unprecedented powers we were also once in those offices but there were completely different conditions and then so so so so they headed the lviv regional administration in different periods of course yes but uh, it was extremely

difficult to distribute funds then because there were commissions e-e divisions of the regional financial administration coordinated everything with the regional councils, and then the regional council approved the expenditures during the period of martial law, local self-government and one-person leadership are thrown out or excluded military administrations distributes funds, on the one hand, this is positive in terms of speed, and on the other hand, it is the responsibility of professional people, then the funds are used as needed, if something slips somewhere or there are other nuances, which , unfortunately, there are, then there are questions about the expediency and the effectiveness of their use but after our victory over the muscovites, then of course we will have to sort things out and then those people who did not use the

money efficiently or somehow in the wrong way will be responsible - this is a call from kyiv yes this is the office the ministers can call and say that since everything is decided in the president's office now, it is a complete centralization of expenditures. olezhe is right, we understand where to spend locally, they decide. anyway, now in kyiv, more than centralization prevails, and we are very sorry. the central government continues to attack local self-governance and this is very dangerous for ukraine as a democratic state. if we talk about money, de jure local budgets today operate with fairly significant resources, but de facto they they cannot use them, on the contrary, all these funds today are in a single treasury account and the government uses this money and disposes of it at its own discretion, and based on the situation in the country, it disposes so that there is always a lack of money, and there are

objective reasons for this birds are subjective circumstances, because i am convinced that today the issue of fighting corruption is one of the key issues in the ukrainian state, therefore, to the use of money, to the expertise of those people who make decisions today, in fact, i personally have a question and i i am convinced that after our victory we must ask all these questions because thieves and thieves must answer and no war will ever be an excuse for them. and regarding the attack on local self-government in our country, in fact, in the 15th year, the situation was even worse than now because the gross and domestic product in 2013 was 177 billion dollars, the gross domestic product in 2015 was 65 billion dollars, that is, then the drop in gdp in dollar equivalent was three times today,

even in today's conditions, in the equivalent of any in this case, what government officials call us is much less, but what decision was made by the state at that time, did it go for decentralization in your situation, give money to communities, give the opportunity to effectively manage these financial resources ? united territorial community and hand over the military to the civilian administration yes what is happening in zhytomyr oblast and what is happening in zhytomyr? i understand gostomel, but in the fact that something i didn't do it that way there, and that's probably why i didn't like something tomorrow, then in frankiv oblast, in ternopil oblast, or in some other duties, well, in chernihiv oblast . headed the defense in

your sumy, we know where the police were, there were no representatives of the authorities, there was no one who stopped the ball, people in sumy organized themselves , took up arms and did not allow muscovites to enter the territory of the city. if anyone thinks that in sumy, no one doesn't know, everyone in sumy knows this and sooner or later they will have to answer for it, but for sure today there are other, much more serious issues , and today it is very important for us to put things in order in terms of money, in terms of business opportunities, to give freely without any, to develop in terms of defense capability, to concentrate resources and in the end, to start adjusting the production of products not only somewhere, but here in ukraine, there are opportunities for this, these are the primary tasks that we have to perform, well, at the same time, i would also like to cite an interesting precedent, for example this week, the verkhovna rada will introduce a bill on the creation of an appropriate fund for

the restoration of our native infrastructure destroyed by the enemy, but the specifics of this fund will be in the fact that, of course, if this bill passes, representatives of the donor countries will be involved in it, and they will adequately control the whole thing, well , very much so we hope that it will not fail, so to speak, as sometimes happened with our, so to speak , glorious supervisory boards in quotation marks, mr. yaroslav , what are the prospects for this fund to act honestly, transparently and according to the laws, it is on my unwritten and the european union and it is already i mean these answers this law ah it has already been copied there 20 times will be written again we will be registered by how many on lugannoy to lugan on our presentation of ukraine i am the supervisory board between the

international where do i have should be honest secretaries, and well, for the presentation of the prime minister, our speakers from ukraine had such plans, they are now simply being implemented, the law is frankly speaking if without populism , well, here is the question. it was possible to discuss how to dispose of the second one, we now have one. well, a special fund will be created in 2023 as well, and there is already a proposal by the deputies of the servant of the people to make it in 2022 so that funds from drugs from confiscated assets and such other things that the man this fund will be sent again here, conditionally, local budgets for the restoration of damaged infrastructure are third, it is important to hear the position of our international partners, because once again , i will say that the issue of transparency in the use of the funds they provide for restoration is key and

they are wonderful. believe me at closed meetings on the sidelines. they know all the names of the participants of the great construction. they see them in the photos that the president's office sometimes puts out about the recovery plans and they directly say that the new oligarchs neither this government nor any next one they will not give, we cannot even name them here again, they have their own procurement procedures, which are also imperfect. by the way, but they exist, and while we are leading this position, international partners are all dancing with a tambourine because there will simply be no money. in this regard, yaroslav, i can just imagine what the mood is like now reigns among the residents of irpinia, bunches of raisins and so on, that is, winter is coming relentlessly, that is, something can be patched up, but patching up something is not the same

as preparing a house or a home for winter, so this has become a very unprecedented example when all around broken houses, leaky roofs, and the road is paved in the middle well, we talked about it in the verkhovna rada, and probably the person who made such an inadequate decision should be asked. well, then he should be sent back to the pre-trial detention center. i don't want to offend the non-buchen irpin. but at least they have something to restore. well, i'm the content of mariupol. well, i have everything. well, what my parents earned is not to save for themselves, they stayed in mariupol, it's destroyed . i.e. there are some at home . as far as i understand every force. hmm, the same

applies to my sister. four weeks after the occupation there, after living in the podovals and in a shot car, she broke a green lecture to leave mariupol with her family. well, there are hundreds of such people thousands, yes, and these are people who, well, imports, and even if we return the control of mariupol very quickly, there simply is not there, he got engaged, as you saw in the photo. this really happened all over the city, and many people who still live there gyms, it's also true, there were dormitories with 10 people in a room, eight meters. it takes a long time to count the cities, give money for roads. i also see food on the roads, and i see it too, that they

are not always of good quality, and they should probably be repaired at some point, but the priority seems to me to be a little different, so if we are now in the budget process why do i want to do it and i will convince my colleagues to come up with some kind of mechanism, we should at least somehow place these people in ukraine and give the opportunity, you know honestly, but let the government let it be stolen , even though the construction of housing, even if something is good it will be for that, but well, once again, well, the situation of the police, i understood how it is, dear people's deputies, it is tragic for many people, it is simply tragic, i.e. the money they receive from the state budget, this is money they can survive on, we understand what is happening now in the labor market, i.e. mass unemployment they are talking about this in the relevant departments, that is, how do people survive because well, we have to eat, we have to buy something for winter clothes, that is, we understand that the

volunteers took part of the blow, but this is only part of the blow and i do not see that well, i just saw those that is, this is, well, this is an element of humiliation in these shelters, we understand that everything is being done in the state, but this is still not enough, well, the volunteers really took the hit and now continue to receive a hit from the authorities regarding criminal cases, although there are still trials did not prove guilt, in fact, i must honestly say that the government failed to prepare for winter, and here you mentioned bucha irpin. yes, i met with people there, they say let the state at least cover the roof for us inside, we will repair at our own expense, no they are told to register for actions, carry out examinations, and really no one has given an answer as to how they should survive the winter. the second thing is where the

authorities hit the bar again, and we talk about it openly and demand an explanation of who is to blame. since april, internally displaced persons have been told to register more than 10 actions in the system 000 people registered, but in june their database disappeared, i appealed to the prosecutor general to the prime minister, now the ministry of social policy says, well , the software was imperfect, let them people go to the attention of the social security department at their place of residence and write a written statement, and the problem still exists that they are registered as inside the premises, not at their current place of residence, because they returned home and where they were at that time was transcarpathia, lviv , ternopil, and now they have returned kyiv chernihiv is being visited or send by mail the 2,000 hryvnias that people were waiting for and 3,000 for the baby

they were hoping for, there was simply no need to promise, we all understand that there is no money, register in action people they thought that this is the restoration of mr. professionalism and non-corruption are the two key things that should be the requirements for representatives of the authorities today, and if we do not act very quickly, if we do not make specific decisions very quickly, winter will be winter and it will be difficult, but winter will be even more difficult we see that putin has made a very clear direction of his attack, this is an attack on the infrastructure. and we are not restoring and not even ready for what is there today, or as if they are preparing something there . why are you controlling us? of local self-government is a very good thing. it is a very right thing. the chairman of the verkhovna rada has arrived.

tell me why they gathered the soul-killer of the government there. are those people in tsimbalyuk in the blue? many others who worked in local self-government have no understanding of what needs to be done now. because of the only news, people will be lifted up beautifully, friends, it's all good when it's warm outside and when it's cold in the rooms and apartments and there's snow on the street then well, there's no need to share, there's no need to be with each other we need to find out the relationship, everyone who can and is capable of work should be involved in the work and decide because the state is at stake, millions and millions of ukrainian people are at stake, and today we must together make sure that in the spring we will come out even stronger and more united, and when we we are talking about the fact that the bad procedures in the european union may be very bad, but for some reason they steal there

much less than they do in ukraine and it will not be any other way. and that is correct. donors who give funds have the right to control these funds and the sooner we will understand this and the sooner we agree to it, the more and sooner we will be given funds, these funds are given so that we can embezzle them, they will not be given to us so that we can restore the state and we do not need to think about how to divide this money, there is also a certain amount provided for for restoration however, it is not written down how and where yaroslav zheleznyak is still with us maybe you know where this money will go raisin and quickly transferred either to the region or to the locality but it is 19 billion it is a huge amount of money well it is

not possible 19 billion is a huge amount of money it a huge amount is 500 million dollars, we are fighting for 500 million dollars to the european union to get these results 19 discussion topic not closed of course russian yes plantain for metal viewers conversation zheleznyak thank you for your participation mykhailo tsimbalyuk people's deputy of ukraine retired lieutenant general of the ministry of internal affairs leksenyutka also a people's deputy of ukraine thank you antin borkovskyi thank you well, we will meet with you soon, watch the espresso tv channel, stay tuned for the most important news, the news will be with us further, the market is already gathering the latest information and is running to inform us what is important that has happened in the last hour, what you and i have missed so far, we discussed here quite seriously, ira, we congratulate you on the word, think about the cold, get rid of these

thoughts for a long time, nazivin sensetev acts in 25 seconds and cares a slime-bearer during the life of nazivin, the sun does not need to wait for you to breathe. the leaders of the battle standings have 9 scoring points each. will be able to win against karpaty, leaving their goal impregnable and remain the sole leader of the tournament table, we will find out this saturday , september 24, watch football together with the title sponsor of fc karpaty, go to facebook espresso and take part in the raffle of a ball with autographs of the players live broadcast of the match karpaty lviv epicenter kamianets -podilskyi on the espresso youtube channel