azovstal, which seemed like nazovstal, maybe even more. what do you know about all the people, where they are now, unfortunately for me, fortunately, nothing is known about those whom we gave away, i think that uh, these are heroes and not these heroes, but our heroes who are from the mariupol garrison, these people are worth a lot to us, and that is why all the work that has been done today by all the bodies is directly the work that is in contrast to uh, there is really something to be done, namely uh, to liberate all the boys who remained in captivity i think this is it for today the foundation that was laid, it is a good assessment daria dmytro, tell me about your plans to do further at home, well, in general, at first it is rehabilitation, it

is not even plans, it is an obligation, it is as they said , quarantine, only already with the family. unfortunately, he has there is absolutely no equipment left at all, and he plans to buy equipment, and as he said, it will be my weapon, only what i don’t shoot with, but what i take photos with, this is what he plans to do. thank you very much. thank you for the protection of our country, and we we rejoice with you and share your joy together thank you very much to your brother and all the defenders of ukraine darya, sister of dmytro e.e. kozatsky, is a photographer from azovstalia and the regions thank you radion kudryashov commander of the azov dnipro terrodefense battalion thank you to all the people of azov and all the defenders of ukraine we are moving on andriy osadchuk already ours hears us now we will see him people's deputy

of ukraine first deputy chairman of the committee on law enforcement i congratulate andrii good day we congratulate you i congratulate you well let's continue the topic of the exchange of people's deputy medvedchuk whose one of our soldiers is suspected of treason, and this does not prevent his case in court and the imposition of punishment - said the kid. how do you see this story , its further development? andrei, you can hear us, i can't hear you very well . as far as i understand the question about the subway, it's great . so, what's next with him ? will it be all for us or will the case continue? a good connection has appeared. look, everything should be very clear and i will try to explain this whole situation now. there are just too many events and some important details are a little bit overlooked even by the media community .

in august, the law enforcement committee worked out changes to the criminal legislation regarding the procedure for the exchange of prisoners of war, and in two approaches it was finally voted on by the verkhovna rada of ukraine, signed by the president, and now it is part of the legislation of ukraine, we actually settled the exchange procedure, which was not settled. five years of war, although exchanges were constantly taking place and a lot of procedural and procedural issues were constantly arising, especially regarding persons who had already received suspicion or who would have already received a sentence in ukraine. as you know, such persons were also sent to, and now this issue is settled in principle, the main idea is that exchange is not a pardon for subjecting any person to exchange as a prisoner of war, does not mean in any way that he is removed prosecution, so i think

that the ukrainian law enforcement agencies got everything they wanted from medvedchuk, they documented everything that needed to be documented , they sent him. i'll tell you frankly, it's hard to believe that it happened at all. it's really a huge miracle, but it 's medvedchuk's case of high treason. i think there are other cases. yesterday you heard that rotterdam plus has updated itself. i think he will also appear there somewhere and so on. so on, he will be brought to justice by a criminal court in ukraine , i have no doubt about that, that is, he will be unequivocally convicted in ukraine when he finally gets rid of his deputy mandate. well, i understand that maybe he does not receive a salary, but fulfillment of parliamentary obligations there, and payments are paid to him in general. he receives money, he is still an active member of the ukrainian parliament

, whether i understand it correctly or not. as far as i understand, he is a member of the ukrainian parliament . a democratic country that respects its rules and respects its legislation , in the legislation there is a clear list of grounds for terminating the powers of a people's deputy of ukraine, and i think that the central election commission should show some creativity in this regard, and the political leadership of the verkhovna rada of ukraine should take some political responsibility in order to implement the prescription of the ukrainian legislation on the termination of medvedchuk's parliamentary powers, i just understand it. but before the exchange, medvedchuk could probably have been asked to write a statement i am simply asking , of my own free will, to issue me with the authority of a people's deputy of ukraine.

you didn't think so. no, you quoted one of the articles on facebook yesterday. i read it. i'm just like one of my colleagues. look, these are all very recent events, so let's wait for the next meeting of the verkhovna rada of ukraine. i expect that we will see something important there. in connection with with this, mr. andriy, let's give more to tupytskyi and to the students, since tupytskyi went abroad in a foreign car with a driver and with dual citizenship from the chairman of the constitutional court, so it's interesting that with all of us, with all of us , many judges somehow turn out to have two citizenship that is, the citizenship of the driver was in ukrainian, hungarian, who supposedly had a family there in another car, then came to pick him up when he had already crossed the border. andriyovych. have you seen this video of mykhailo tkach? what is his name there ? streets of vienna i've been reading since may 27th, the

prosecutor general's office announced an international wanted man for him, he lives there normally with his wife and children, he already has a third child there, he is a father of many children, he is happy, he complains that it was taken from him state welfare, the scoundrels who throw mud at him here, it is unfair that students can not go to study, this looks particularly interesting, please, well, look, let's look at this whole story a little faster, a huge problem of ukraine in recent years was that we could not clean our state our central bodies of executive power in the judicial power from collaborators and traitors since 2014. lypinsky he didn't fall from the sky, he was appointed by yanukovych, er, first as a member, then he was elected he was the head of the constitutional court all these years, everything started well in ukraine. i think it is already a certain conquest of ukraine in recent times that people like tupytskyi are forced to commit yet another crime

of illegally crossing the border and hiding in ukraine, and let me remind you that he has already lost his powers as a member of the constitutional court to the court, that is, from this point of view, we are already moving quite well, that is, at the moment, for me, he is an ordinary criminal who most likely committed a bunch of various crimes as related to the execution of his official duties and in the case of crossing the border, that's why it's good that journalists see where he lives, it's good that journalists know where he is , and this is all a signal exclusively to ukrainian law enforcement agencies, which have to work through all this to the end, the only thing that should be taken into account and with a certain to treat our law enforcement officers with condescension, they are now extremely overloaded, it is difficult to imagine the level of load that is currently going to the sbu prosecutor's office, the police, because they are fighting and investigating war crimes and investigating collaborators, and all this is happening at the same time, but the case of tupytskyi, she will bring them to the fore. they

know this very well, no one will forgive this, and believe me, the politicians who are following this will also do their job. i have no doubt that tupytskyi will be convicted and i think that we will get him here in ukraine. it just does not happen as fast as i would like to but this is already an inevitable process, mr. andrii, but regarding the ban on leaving students, well, men of draft age who have enrolled to study abroad, this is a serious problem, because in our country this year, 20 students seem to have entered oxford and this this has never happened before, and these people who are currently enrolled in prestigious foreign universities simply do not have the opportunity to go there to study, a big problem, but this problem is a result of the quality of management of our state institutions, what i am talking about is the third year. some of my colleagues are talking about the third year, as long as we we will not have

quality professional leaders in our ministries and departments as long as we have chaos. and this is exactly the situation when, on the one hand, it was clear to everyone that students studying abroad legally should go to ukraine, but unfortunately, for the last 4 or 5 months, no one wanted to know how to make a high-quality mechanism to control everything, to ensure unhindered access , and on the contrary, all these months there were massive abuses that brought this situation to complete chaos and in me such a suspicion that he simply slammed the president with his fist on the table, which sometimes he does this, and this issue was closed and closed, so to speak, including, of course, for absolutely virtuous young citizens who are actually in the cabinet theater ministers of ukraine stopped the discussion of the question precisely because there were hundreds of cases of direct abuse for the purpose of illegal border crossing anu i think pensions of this word yes, but you saw the video video

of mykhailo tkachai, you saw this number of expensive cars that should drive with these ukrainian citizens with their wives, mistresses and children who calmly left this country without any restrictions. the students turned out to be students. you well, did you see that andrii kholodov lives there with his wife and child and children with all his deputies respected by the people, the same yevhen muraev, former deputy of the regional party, our party, his check there , with his wife, with a new one, with a young woman, you are the same oleksandr, this, well, what kind of man is petrovsky from dnipropetrovsk , from dnipro. the number of hundreds, if not thousands , of expensive ukrainian cars is driven around for the day and everyone is of draft age, everyone left calmly, everyone feels fine there, and 17-year-old students are not allowed, it sounds a little like a socialist, you are all about expensive cars and about some women and so on, sir,

the most important videos have seen it, but you really begged no from these cars. well, i understand. i may be a communist tomorrow in this situation, but i was disgusted when i saw it yesterday. this video weeks of war left, millions of ukrainians left and now there are millions of ukrainians in europe, rich, poor , old, young, mostly women, yes, many men, and believe me, thank god that they are there , because in my subjective opinion, staying in ukraine is risky, especially the closer to the eastern border, so it is good that our citizens are in europe, it's a matter of national security, it's a matter of their lives and their health. another question is how legally they are there, and you and i know the answer that for the first two weeks, they let everyone out and everything was great, only abuses, we know about the fact that they left there with suitcases of money and so on, but

this has already happened, we know with you that in recent months there has been quite clear control at the border. the state border service, our law enforcement officers work very clearly and we must give them credit for that that some students have suffered now, as i already told you, this is a problem, this is a problem, but this problem is not because someone managed to leave in the first days. and this problem is because our state institutions are not capable of solving such tasks. what is the problem? you as deputies, they are under your control, what should the minister of the ministry of internal affairs of education simply check these specific universities to see if they are real or not, and not just forbid everyone to go from everyone liked it as bodyguards cheese as bodyguards of the son of this alexander, they even decided what dniprovsky, what they called him in the criminal circles of dnipro for a year, from hansela viennese taxi drivers, they simply took them on the street and beat them, put them like that, threw them on

the sidewalk and went on their way and these guys are all of mandatory conscription age, everyone left safely and now live safely in vienna, that's right, we want them not to bang their fists on the table, the issue is also not resolved in the rule of law and for the ministries to work and the border guards were working and then everything will be fine and there is no need for manual decisions. i can answer you by saying that according to the law enforcement committee where i work, we had conversations with the leadership of the state border service of the national police based on the results of the six-month war because there were a lot of problems, and there were problems at the checkpoints, everyone has already forgotten about them a little, but there were very unpleasant stories , there were problems at the border. people somehow discuss, but unfortunately the reality of today is the reality of the verkhovna rada and such things, as

they say to us, supposedly on security issues, but we did not see the government during those 6 months of war, we did not see one at a time. sometimes someone came. well, marchenko came yesterday when he presented the budget. thank you for that, but government, we do not see the kind of usual dialogue that has always been between the deputies of the verkhovna rada and its government. unfortunately, there is none. therefore, all responsibility rests precisely on the government and, in principle, on the office that is actually managed by a deputy of ukraine, a faction of the voice thank you for your participation. the conversation is interesting. maybe a little emotional, but i have no anger. when i see this video from vienna, we have serhii kramarenko, a deputy of the zhytomyr regional council. we welcome you, mr. serhiy. i congratulate you. on the eve of the 80th anniversary of the 75th anniversary of the creation of the zhytomyr region, there were celebrations during which the head of the

zhytomyr regional administration, his excellency vitaly bunechko, presented various awards for meritorious services there, in particular, an honorary award for services to the zhytomyr region, and you know who received it, in particular, serhiy ryzhuk was among the awardees, and serhiy ryzhuk, let's start one by one, who is he, a two-time people's deputy from the party of regions of the fifth and sixth convocation, he headed the zhytomyr regional organization of the party of regions, he was also the chairman twice the zhytomyr regional state administration during yanukovych's time. well, it 's still there, well, it doesn't matter. it's the second person, yury pavlenko, was also the head of the zhytomyr oda. well, it was during yushchenko's time, then he hunted the party organization of the party, of course, not the party of regions of the opposition bloc, and later became the head of the zhytomyr oblast party, already opzj, and was elected a people's deputy from this political force in 2019. these respectable persons, mr. ryzhuk and mr. pavlenko

, were awarded for their services to the zhytomyr oblast by the head of the oblast state i congratulate mr. vitaly bonechko to the administration. please tell me . well, he was not the head of the party of regions. please tell me if he is only a servant of the people. i ask for your assessment of what happened there. i will honestly say that for us, this is this event in the region caused a significant resonance. and today, social networks and our local mass media , internet resources reacted very strongly to this event, because really during the war you know, to take such and not such actions raises many, many questions, that is, it is clear that there may be some personal preferences of the governor, perhaps there are merits that we do not know about, but we can absolutely clearly say what to do under time in the distribution it was inappropriate and well, mostly, it was understood

by the ukrainian community, and in social networks, in the local mass media, it condemned such an act of mr. bunichka. he has special feelings for the former representatives of the party of regions there, they have a normal working relationship there. well, for example, they said that in july, on his initiative, the regional council was reorganized, so that they would understand. well, the majority there i was like that in a restaurant and we can just super elect the composition of the regional council of the lviv convocation . in which

group are they themselves? you can burn and the second photo is sergey druzhuk, these are the honorable people of your region of zhytomyr region, all regionals, all upszhniks now have an award for services to zhytomyr region. and now please continue with the redrawing of the regional majority, this is important, i ask. well, if there is someone there who thinks that this is so, you know, the line is not like how to eat. such a, one specialist said, coincidence. i don’t think so, i can say that you know, one of the uh, it’s such a long chain. for example, in july there was a hidden coalition in the coalition, since the election of the council, psg was not included in any of them, they did not have representation in the commissions, so, on the initiative of mr. bunechko , in july, the coalition was redone, and the passenger just entered this coalition, and a number of pro-ukrainian parties and the homeland of the radical party of this very coalition were excluded, that is why he says that the love of mr. daughter for psg and the party of regions is some kind of

random saying it does not happen, but i understand that today during the war. understanding, you know, this is an understandable and conscious trend, this is the situation, the position of the self-confessed person. i just know that from the beginning, even after the elections, he allegedly had positions that were not too strong. well, not too strong in the region. but i see that he, like lenin, lives in all alive there at the head of the oda of zhytomyr. well, actually, i will honestly say that you see, when the war started, there is such a thing as a proverb: the war is to whom one should help one's family, so he feels great , he succeeded, let's say yes, well, local activists in the opposition were very strongly represented the strength is in essence today he is such an authoritarian such a leader, authoritarian princes who, by and large , is beginning to feel a little bit losing his sense of reality, that's why he is such a fool, such a thing, you already know it is essentially personal

you know, impunity is irresponsibility, it doesn't understand the political, about it, practical processes and those processes that come in the state, that is, today he is already operating here no no no misunderstandings there, you know, some kind of unity and understandings, some own ideas, that's why we are already a graduate, a graduate of the sbu academy, a graduate of the sbu academy he knows how to communicate, i understand what i know, but i have such a conviction that ukraine is going to europe, you know , we are for democratic values ​​for the values ​​of freedom for the values ​​of equality for the values personalities today, tens of thousands of guys, hundreds of thousands are fighting at the front. and such a little cell in the zhytomyr region is building such a small autocracy. i believe that our geopolitical choice is pro-european. there are no

such authoritarian military units in it. it will only remain in history. thank you. well, in fact, there are a lot of former regional leaders in the party in power now, because everyone was shunned there then, and if you open up their biographies, even the head of the regional council in sumy oblast, a former regional leader, is a very, very respected person, why not all of them ? if you take the same mr. lord ihor horbaruk already wants to join us, how can you get in our ukraine before becoming a party of regions and then the party of the people's republic of ukraine? of international affairs, igor, we congratulate you. good day, colleagues. i congratulate you well. well, let's get to the economic moments. has the mobilization announced by putin somehow already affected the market, er, the

economy of russia, what is happening there? the mobilization announced by putin of their economy has led to the fact that the stock exchange moscow she just fell, the indicators are possible to be commensurate with what happened after february 24, when russia began military aggression against ukraine, that is why, in fact, what is happening now is absolutely terrifying. that is, all indexes are falling, uh, shares, although some uh, which were once worth something, are sold for pennies, and accordingly, all this directly affects the economy of the country, that is, let's say so, recently the economy has not been all right there, for example, just two figures for according to the results of july, the hole in the budget was 9 trillion rubles, and already according to the results of august, it was a trillion 452 billion , that is, 900 billion, trillion 452 billion, and accordingly

, they cannot reconcile the balances, and accordingly, the hills in the budget are growing more and more. accordingly we understand very well that people who will be drafted into the russian army lose their jobs. they don't work for the state, respectively. it's not that they don't pay taxes, but then they don't buy anything. accordingly, taxes and deductions from those products or goods that they would buy will also not take place . accordingly, all these are examples of the fact that the russian economy will decline even more, it will fall even more on the so-called military rails. companies will be obliged to carry out military orders, they don't want it, they don't want it, they have this opportunity for them, for what money will everything be done, they will be forced that's how we see the economy of coercion and the coercion country of everyone to their will there are certain kremlin rates of igorel's plan it should be noted that at first it was on the stock exchange, the moscow stock exchange and the rts index. they first

fell by 10, then recovered. i there was a total fall of 4-5%. that is, there is no no, well, i do not know if it is possible that this is a catastrophic catastrophic fall for the stock exchange well, it's not 50 and 40% there." accordingly, in russia today, everything related to their national currency is very

strictly regulated, and in fact, what are the indicators in the eu, let's say in their statistics , is completely untrue, on the one hand, that is, in fact, the ruble is turning into a wooden one, as it was once in soviet times , we remember that then the dollar was worth 70 kopecks there, a maximum of 75 kopecks. and at the same time, it was sold on the black market for 10 soviet negotiators, this is one situation, another situation, and they have it today today, they do not need such a quantity of currency, because in fact they have stopped importing what used to be, accordingly, they do not need currency for import purchases, and accordingly, all these factors affect the fact that there is really an artificial strengthening of dollars well, these are currencies in general, but there is no real reflection of this on the economy, i.e. goods are becoming more expensive anyway, and accordingly they say, well, life in them is becoming much

more expensive today, sir, 300,000 mobilization in russia, according to some information, there are secret points that say about 1 million mobilized, well, these are huge funds, someone calculated what additional expenses for the russian budget simply in order to collect these people, clothe them every day, feed them somewhere, settle them somewhere, teach them, then transfer them closer to the ukrainian border , because of the funds, how much money will it cost the russian budget additionally? well, you need to talk about this that the russians simply do not understand that they will pay for all these hotels of their kremlin elders from their own pockets and no one there is counting anything, it is absolutely unnecessary, in fact if, for example, the same ministry of finance announced a budget sequestration of absolutely all ministries by at least 10%, it is simply a reduction of all e-e articles of development on skazhem, yes, everything that related to the russian budget, then the only article that receives additional money is the

indexation of wages for the russian military, they at least somehow they want to attract people to military service, but we all understand very well that one soldier in the rear provides from 8 to 12, let's say people who work in the economic sector, respectively, i say once again if they a million people will be thrown to the front with meat and provide them even with some er uniform or some old ak-47 now it will mean only one thing that these people will not work for their economy they will not pay taxes they will not buy goods and accordingly this everything will affect their economy negatively, and again, i will repeat it again, no one cares about it for them, the main thing is their some far-fetched political interests and that's all, that is, they don't address the question of logic and the validity of what processes there, but how soon colleagues

look, you really see, we all want the sanctions to have an effect, so that today is better than yesterday, i always say and repeat, there is no direct correlation between these things, and again, if our european world partners were really more decisive, they would introduce one single sanction , a complete cessation economic relations with the russian federation, then it would have an effect. and when, even according to the statements of mr. jose bagel, europe pays russia 1 billion a day for energy carriers, what can we talk about, that is, these sanctions affect them affect to a greater extent the suspension of russia's technological growth, but to say that here and today they affect the cessation of hostilities, unfortunately, there is no such thing yet, well , again, everyone talks about gas and oil, and again, for some reason, no one mentions nickel

aluminum copper, palladium, others, but which are also exported by russia, we need to impose sanctions on everything, and the sanctions are tough so that not only russia cannot circumvent them, but also not those countries that help them to circumvent these sanctions. again, it is good. what, for example, germany introduced an external management of e-e oil refining capacity of 12%. but this should be done for gas as well, and this should have been done even today or yesterday harbaruk thank you economist, members of the economic discussion club, here is an expert