what does this show, well, first of all, about the fact that they are running out of the weapons they were counting on and now they are dependent on the supply of these drones from the side, which is not a reliable source , let's say supply of these weapons well, we need to be more vigilant and develop with the help of our military-industrial complex systems of countermeasures , modern weapons are such a highly mobile er-e cake on electronics and we need to look for er-e countermeasures because it is obvious that drones of various nature are modern weapons and even nu can be considered a weapon in the future, we will thank andrii teter of the cube and this voluntary formation of the war. ukraine is good for all. glory to the heroes. yes, we have vadym chernysh, minister for the temporary occupied territories of internally displaced persons 16-19 years old. good

health, mr. volodymyr, i will not hide the pleasure of seeing you. we are old acquaintances and if you do n't want to read something, read mr. vadym chernysh, if you find what he writes somewhere, it is usually balanced and so wise. i would say the words, he really paid me for what i did now small advertisement well, what to do, you have to live like this, i want to start with mr. vadim, that we just discussed with mykola before the broadcast about the fact that a statement came from one of the collaborators of the head of the movement we are in the city with russia, volodymyr rogov, about what so far the entire zaporizhia region will not be completely occupied. as far as i understand, this logically applies to all the occupied regions of ukraine .

on the one hand, the kremlin says all the time that it will quickly announce the acceptance of these regions into the russian federation immediately after the referendum, and by the way, the zaporizhia, kherson, and mykola regions, they also declare these pseudo-independent states, and on the other hand arise that the accession will take place only after there is an exit to the administrative border. that is, we return to the old song again, then the question arises. why was it not possible to first enter the administrative border and then spend referendum i honestly don't know if volodymyr volodymyrovych got confused because he is all the time in some complicated system, but i was already confused , now i'm already confused, i would add to vitaliy simply , if we take mine in the wonderful month of september, i want to end fortunately for a port, which it ends at last then i would say that there will simply be no referendums for the whole of september, referendums will be postponed to november, then there will be referendums from crimea, there was always this kind

of thing or a chorus in russian, what does this indicate? already portnikov got confused, it's already september for the last five who got confused. it seems to me, that is, i just want you to untangle that i don't believe it and about what in italy got confused but to be honest, uh , i have several explanations for this, there are several reasons, there is not one the reasons for one driver that drives putin, well, first of all, this indicates that there are different opinions in his environment, this is clear for me, that is, this is an external confirmation of the internal contradictions that exist in the kremlin, and we know about it indirectly, that there are different opinions on how to act. well, yes and simple the division there is simple division into hawks and i don’t know who they consider themselves to be or peaceful sheep there eh i think it is too simplified but there are several groups with different strategies i think this is the first evidence that we can be idiots and not security forces

there are idiots this event to you, medvedev, who simply does not give himself an account of the consequences of his actions and it is forever, like, think about it, bukhavski , how many days? it is more lenient to call it the second one. in my opinion, this is still leaving a way out for the trades. and at the auctions, now if you remember these statements, there are several of them. with us on the status of such newly occupied territories, now it is not simply that we will return them to you or you will take them away, now we will conditionally say that the military contingent will remain in the crimea and donbass is not discussed at all, that is,

the possible options are different there but i say that this simply as a way to further hang up in the so-called negotiation process from which, to be honest , there is no normal way out. i would still say the third reason is that, well, it looks very funny when zaporizhzhia , for example, is such a huge city, one of the pillars of ukraine, and they are occupying me. also has significance for everyone, including for donetsk region and luhansk region, that is, uh, and that's exactly why. in my opinion, the goals of special operations were defined in this way. what is the

difference ? any textbook, minister, dictionary of the ministry of defense, there is either a special operation, and there is no special military operation. and they invented it in order to declare that in a war, if you call yourself a war, well, in addition to the rest of the reasons, there must be victory in the war, that is, the overthrow of ukraine or a victory over ukraine, they understand that no, it is impossible, that is why we juggle special operations. i think that all three reasons are at least interconnected , and that is why volodymyra volodymyrovych you listen to people around you all the time because he is already not confident in his own strength, the second attempt is always tactical to announce some goal so that it has already been achieved, remember they already said that our military industry was already destroyed, all aviation was destroyed and so on, already part of the goals were allegedly once on negotiations have been reached and eh the third is still uh, well, the question is that

they will continue to try to continue to exhaust ukraine, but at this time they are preparing and saturating themselves with cannon fodder on the territories they still hold, that is, in order for them to have starting points positions in the future to speak p vadim look at everything we have just discussed, what we will now say, it indicates some kind of tremor inside russia and the epicenter of this tremor of the earth why because here we say in the wonderful month of september in my version and absolutely terrible versions of portnikov, uh, there were just constant gas brake gas brake gas brake yes forward back forward back now they announced the mobilization now i listened to russian sources there today they say that the nervousness in moscow is crazy simply people are crying in the streets and young boys young men and so on. and we still had to

cry about this, they had many years for this, but there are simply optimists who say that this is precisely the sign of the beginning of the collapse, which is full of problems and mobilization problems in russia mobilization to the end, mobilization, the problem is unknown, how many people want to mobilize in ukraine , there will be a referendum, there will be no such conditions , such conditions. that is, we see constant changes and these influences, perhaps, of putin's entourage, and who from him was the last one to leave the order: he should not drink and signs, let's say yes, but optimists and pessimists say it means nothing. on which side are you a pessimist? why are you an optimist? do you see cracks in that building? to the social group of the so-called silovarchs, that is, the

security forces, the tire oligarchs, that is, i don’t see any cracks there yet, but there are cracks in other directions, of course i see them, look at this culture of the fsb members of the former so-called kists who are now with businessmen, well, with the status of businessmen, very this corporate culture is strongly connected so far. well, the so -called culture is, well, not a culture, it's actually mafia laws, and they still hold the top and the middle part of the fsb . and if you look, they don't spare the military especially those who destroyed uh layers of society, but the fsb uh, they uh, they still protect and for his own , in general, uh, no one there takes part. that is, he keeps part of that repressive apparatus, understanding that it can be uh well, it is necessary inside, therefore, there were the nearest deadline. i still do not

see such cracks in this, that is, i see signs. and what can i add, there are other groups of businessmen there, purely politicians of different groups who are not directly part of this narrow cohort there, cooperative lakes there 3:0 or who is already re-reborn in them? i think that so far there is only tension, although events are developing very rapidly and depending on how the event will be, it is to operate, that is, to give candy to someone, to promise someone a future at least some, and to someone not, that is, to disentangle them. i think this is the task of all the intelligence services of political agencies now countries through various, so to speak, unofficial channels. i think there are about a dozen of them there now, i know indirectly from various people that there

are about a dozen such formats where constant negotiations are conducted there with those who are considered so-called internal stake holders and i think that this can also influence this anger and nervousness of mr. putin, well, if he is mr. not mr., but just putin, and i think that this leads to the fact that now there will be a foreign er, indiscriminately applied in russia even to people who are more or less loyal to it in the medium term and without a doubt, it is not the people's anger accumulated. signs but in the near future i don't see it yet, look here is an important question, but the question is definitely not for you, but i will try, i will try because this is

psychoanalysis, it is up to freud, we need such a question , but he died, well, chernysh remains, you will not do anything, but now they everyone went, some voluntarily , some forcibly went to the military commissariats and went to them, this will affect the nation, this contingent, let's call it simple people from yakutsk, from ekaterina yogurt, you can call it yogurt, how do they get irynburg, they are all going now, eagerly from they are bursting with smiles, i see well, we all see it on the networks, but they will go back in coffins or in packages, and it will be in a week 2 3 4 how much it can affect the awareness of the situation of russians, russian citizens, not elites, time will pass until it

can start influence but i want to weigh in. look, i listened to andriy taturuk and the rest of your guests there today and periodically. look, there is an impression that 300,000 will come to the front line, so they will not all come to the front line, that is, part of them will be involved in the repair of equipment near them now a huge problem, nobody wants to repair machinery, machinery, part of it is to vote in referendums, a child will do it, that is, some part will then begin to repaint it . they will hope that europe will now start to offer some negotiations here they will be they will not be not not about it now to

hold back but there is a winter use to the maximum in order to well, it will be more difficult for us and it will be more difficult for them, but in order to slow down the supply of weapons, the right-wing might come somewhere, for example, in italy, eh. with this horse, well, sorry , berlusconi. they are of course counting on it, that's why i think that his so-called respite with mobilization there, with hints of negotiations, after all, is also based on the winter period and on the task of maximum damage to europe, and as for psychology, well, to be honest, there is a whole industry there of political psychology, we have such broadcasters here, and not only here, even they are not able to predict putin. he is, in addition to everything that we attribute to him, he is also. well, unfortunately, he is really incomprehensible

to many. he tries to be incomprehensible to people, to all political figures. they thought he was irrational, irrational, he demonstrates irrationality and the limit of this rationality in order to intimidate, i am ready to use nuclear weapons, and then you will die there, go to paradise there as a righteous person as a result of a nuclear strike, that is, this is this the limit of putin's rationality, which he demonstrates , no one feels it, few feel it, it seems to me that he overestimates possible rationalities precisely in order to create fear precisely in those people who make decisions, those calls are constant, there are persuasions, negotiations, this is just evidence russia's actions combined with putin's demonstration of irrationalism in behavior, and i think that here he really has made some

progress as such a political actor , he has achieved a certain amount, i'm saying a little, because really see all the articles what's in putin's head how does he think, how does he think, that is, everyone demonstrates this irrationality. i think that this is such a factor that many people are paying attention to now. we thank one journalist, the minister for temporary occupied territories of internally displaced persons 16-19 years old, our colleague taras berezovetsky district of the first separate special purpose brigade in the name of ivan bohun, we congratulate mr. taras exaggeration. here he is. well, he will be now as he appears. we can't talk. it seems to me. by the way, among these of the mobilization goals of mr. putin, the so-called

which we talked about with mr. vadim, there is also an attempt to take revenge in kharkiv oblast because you can understand that kharkiv oblast, if he succeeded in taking kharkiv there, the greater part of kharkiv that is being done, was also already in this for the referee, kharkiv is very important because kharkiv was the first capital of the occupation, and the people of kharkiv say nazar is the first capital - this is the first capital of the occupation. so they really want that if we take kharkiv, we can declare it the capital of ukraine again. what is the president already? viktor medvedchuk he's just on a hot horse oh, i don't believe that he'll be fine, if i think we'll be fine there, i'll be preparing for the fact that when the whole of ukraine is occupied, he'll lead it, so don't worry now, let's worry about it again there are no other candidates because i already think that putin trusts yanukovych according to which yanukovych i think about the alcoholic yanukovych, i think otherwise, i think that he and he is the only person who should be even worse

than putin. and why should he be worse? well, because he at all, no one can now extradite him to ukraine he can't give out, he can go to kyiv, he can go anywhere, that is, if he doesn't have a weapon, not to putin, to putin, if there is security, they won't come out, he took the end of the security, it will be in one second, mr. taras , well, let's talk. anyway, what is happening in the kharkiv direction, should we not be afraid of your one of the important reasons for the mobilization is the attempt to take revenge in kharkiv oblast. well, putin can try to achieve revenge, which will happen only in kharkiv oblast. why is only kharkiv oblast donetsk, in the end he can try to run belarus into war for that to try to implement their plans regarding kyiv zhytomyr oblast and rivne oblast, they are simply more comfortable here. here they have better understood the logistics

that they built after 2014 ago. kupyansk with cluster munitions, i have to say that the situation remains quite difficult, every day in kharkiv, the alarm is fired every day, the city of kharkiv is shelled, and a similar situation occurs in most of the places newly occupied for the occupied territories, in addition, the enemy acts against you with all the efforts of the drgs who are actively working on the entire territory. every day, i emphasize this, russian deserters are detained , and both from russia and from the so-called lpr dnr . but the people of neriv , that is, our ukrainian citizens and the russian army , are often detained in populated areas in

forest plantations, but there are even unconscious ukrainian citizens who switch to themselves and make a shelter for russian deserters the other day there were some such egregious facts when our local women hid russian deserters, passing them off as ukrainian men. well, but the shelling. yes, we heard it. it’s interesting. it’s interesting about the drg . which you just said, but there are attempts by the russians to walk through the territory of kharkiv oblast, there is a feeling that they will not only want to shoot but also go on foot, well, actually speaking, that is what war is in its final form, when you seize someone else 's territory, this is also felt when you try to enter

population centers that have just been liberated in the mountains, er, the enemy has intensified sniper combat today, i have to say that our group, which today was on one of the directions of kharkiv, kharkiv, kharkiv, is already closer there to the opposition of russia, er, today we we came under sniper fire and were forced to withdraw from our position. fortunately, no one was hurt. everything ended well, but we understand that the enemy will definitely try to make such points of attack, but they do not demonstrate now the ability to inflict a serious blow and , again, specifically answering your questions, attempts to enter their west with the feet . we do not record such attempts, thank you taras for this

complicated story, i was very interested in a lot of news, well, it is clear that the journalist is thank you, ah, valery ryabikh, a military expert, a defect express of our beloved, let's do this topic without a doubt now if we only see mr. valeriy, you have seen the deputy . still, let's try to understand what mobilization really changes from a military point of view and when , because the institute for the study of vinnytsia said that, in principle, in the coming months it will be nothing at all, but how reasonable it is to be nervous, let's imagine mr. valeriy let's yes, imagine that everything worked out for them, so they collected these 300 thousand, they somehow sent them somewhere, they appeared somewhere, and what happened next. well, the thing is that it is still a big process for them to first collect these mobilized secondly, they went through all the necessary procedures

, namely, they formed combat units or combat units, and i think that this process will go parallel, and some of those who were just mobilized have already been mobilized in a few years, even in a couple of years weeks will be able to appear in separate directions because the operatives are currently uh, a very big problem is uh, the incompleteness of units, those on the contact line, it is said in certain areas that uh, individual units can contain up to 20%, uh -e of personnel ie instead of the companies, they are on what is less than a platoon and therefore of course this will lead, first of all, to such a rapid saturation of this line eh well, to a certain chaos because

eh, those who are not fired on and not ready will come to the eh line of contact before that, it means that the church in the near future will not significantly change the situation at the front, and the rest must be prepared , and the main problem at the moment is not to recruit such a large number of people, but the problem is to organize them to provide everything necessary, and especially for those that are currently uh-uh well, we are going out for the winter season, so we need to dress them, provide them with everything necessary, and the most important thing is to provide them with the necessary military equipment , and after that, it is still possible to form units there, to coordinate them in general. this is a very long process, and it will be well, let's say, if we are serious, as the same institute and

the study of war assesses, then it may take three to five months for these eyes mobilized today to be able to represent at least some kind of force, but you have to understand that the situation is dynamic is changing and it is not known what will happen not only there in 5 months, but what will happen in a month, including thanks to this turbulence, which is currently being launched by these uh-uh processes, uh-uh, that are connected with the announcement of mobilization, but it seems that they are ready and not trained to send about it, because we speak logically because we are here logically - you are a military expert, we are logically thinking people, western experts are logical, and they what was in the libraries in 1941, do you remember from the books in 1941, no one, no one, did they go to hell let's go. my uh, uncle, uncle left. my father's brother and my father's brother killed him right away, and it was called black jackets, because in the family of my grandfather

, my own grandfather. yes, then the jackets were all black , and that's why they were taken away a few weeks later. he died on the kursk dock. what a big battle, a big but huge number in general they didn't know how to handle a gun , many didn't. by the way, grandfather could be as old as 23 years old, it's not the same as grandfather grandfather. it was a boy, a boy . preliminary assessments the largest part of those who are currently called up, these first days we see that there is a very big uh, they uh, they made a shaft, and most of them can literally quickly find themselves on the line in a week. and of course, this is really just what it is called er, cannon fodder and what will be er, well, simply, well, even thanks to the violation of the discipline

of security measures and understanding where they are, these are potential er, two hundred and three hundred, and of course , when they touch and collide with the realities of combat, that's another her e-e with great confidence n- 500 years ago, this is all that has been recruited today. well, what are suicide bombers called? and there is a man. look, mr. valery, we asked about the numbers of the second world war. well , i heard that if you don’t have one, you lose 25% of the squad. it is actually impossible to send them to attack on the second day. people don't go on the attack when every fourth person dies, then n- it's impossible by any means and with guns and threats to barricade the troops, people just don't go on the attack, they sit and that's all. if they come to the front line and start to destroy them,

then what is the quality of this army, well, such as from this one the troops are squeezed precisely by the conditions that are created in this country, so before announcing this mobilization, they made changes to the laws that regulate precisely the behavior during mobilization and martial law, and well , very strictly strict terms have been introduced for violations, and accordingly. well, this is the so-called people who are being clamped down . such pressures, er, what? well, let's say, he is finally forced to get rid of before the choice, er, change the government or die because of it. well, here is a process that was launched by the russian government itself, and everything will be to depend from the very reaction of this people, who

got into these bars without such a significant exit, we thank valeriy rabikh, military expert , defense express, well, let's summarize the first part of our program by summarizing. 21:30 21:30 is the release of our program with vitaliy, and i, well, i wouldn't be against you watching it in the future, despite the fact that now it will be evening, and the second thing that should be said is that today, in fact, in half an hour and we would answer your question where is facebook, please, social networks, youtube are waiting for your questions, and of course mykola and i will answer them, especially since we see that this is a rather difficult day and everything is changing

before our eyes. by the way, did you see this picture of these referendums when you posted there is some kind of pushin under the roof of the house, that is, they didn’t even use it and couldn’t make a normal election commission. they give him a ballot on a box. he writes something on this box and there seem to be some people, but it’s me. i think they are at least in donetsk. they will arrange it as normal, this is a vote, yes, when is the head of the dnr supposed to come there? yes, yes, and sign some kind of ballot. was there a booth for him to enter somewhere? yes, it's nothing, he just gave him a slip of paper, he just scribbled something on it and they took the slip, that is i sent it to me , now there will be news, please