well, we know what a protest against criminal power is, for example, yes, how is this the same revolution of dignity as it happened? and this would be a resource that would change this situation in russia itself, but it is not there, that is why they have the power of the russian criminal power they are able to collect a few more of these partially mobilized, and not only 300,000 , but also more. thank you, thank you, mr. oleksandr kovalenko, a military-political spectator of integration resistance. there are enough russian experts who are liberal and they said that the maximum capacity of the russian army is one post, looking at today and today, when this partially so-called mobilization is taking place, they can really find and send

to the front no more than 60-70 thousand, so that even 300,000 that the russian government is talking about. i'm not talking about a million anymore. the infrastructure is simply not ready to move a million people from point a to point b. that's logistics, that's a huge amount of gasoline. on the cars they go to the railway, then they all have to be loaded onto the railway. i always give a very simple example : a russian station, we can roughly imagine what it looks like, an echelon arrives here, where is it located? well, for example, there are 1,000 soldiers, but they need thousands of soldiers at the same time, because they were traveling 3 o'clock or 5 o'clock i'm sorry for the word, will they pee or are the toilets ready at the station? i'm not saying that they need to eat something, that they need to drink something, something hot, because there will be tea, and when you start to think about it all, you see that

well, it doesn't work out, well, that's the case. let's see how it will go on. well, as of today, you know, putin also announced that for the sake of general understanding , he also announced such a regular mobilization. and experts say that the spring mobilization was also 86 out of 120, and in the fall there were also 120, and no one believes that there will be more than 50. well, we are talking a little about the war, and now about the affairs of the verkhovna rada. health brother and to see mr. yaroslav, i also have the same question. look , uh, sometimes i get the impression that the verkhovna

rada of ukraine, since it is not a military body, and now everyone is engaged in war, somehow it is trying to do something from its side, but it is also so difficult to say that it is such a priority, yes well let's somehow give sanctions lists of russian business. let's help the nsdc and so on. a list of russian businesses and they will then file a lawsuit in luxembourg-stockholm, some dutch, some other, and to what extent is this reluctance, the legally balanced desire of the ukrainian authorities to deprive property and introduce sanctions against the russians, how far after the war, they will not judge back with any

fines i i don’t know, in fact, our key task now is to win the war, what will happen after the war will be determined by who wins the war, and since i am convinced that ukraine will win, prove that it is the fault of russian business that filled the budget that created an opportunity to provide the russian army with weapons that killed people in buch, irpen, and izyum and shot them near zaporizhzhia in the kharkiv region, to prove in the european courts that they are not involved will be extremely difficult, other points that give us guarantees that that we will be able to defend our position legally is that the assets of russians are being actively frozen not only in

ukraine, but in fact, until yesterday, ukraine was significantly behind the developed world from the g7 countries shame on the big seven for freezing assets, but these types of 1,300 people yesterday actually approved a list of more than 3,000 people, but these 1,300 people we are talking about now are mainly oligarchs who have been on european sanctions lists for a long time and ukraine in general looked like this. it is quite strange. but when we say, for example, mr. friedman, who is under sanctions in europe, in the united states, but not in ukraine, well, since yesterday, finally, thank god, it happened, mr. abramovich, a similar situation, ah, in fact, russia itself and its own oligarchs made it significantly more difficult to defend their positions in the

courts. why do you, mr. mykola, remember when they made the decision that russian e-e laws are higher than international law, accordingly, any international structure will be based on this logic and in this case if we do everything according to the law and this well if our democratic system requires it, we don't take away and confiscate, distribute, as the communists used to do, so judge the results, but in fact, we have had a law in force since the end of may that clearly describes the procedure and clearly describes the appeal procedure in ukrainian courts, of course, oligarchs can easily be brought to international courts, but their prospects are not so much, let's say rainbow. since we do everything in accordance with the laws, which as

a legislative body, we try to harmonize as much as possible with international law , mr. yaroslav, see another important question. they just gossiped about him and i'll turn it around here - i already pretended while you were responding to such a sofa expert who is lying on sofia there because this would be the main question of any such and why only now, why was it not possible to immediately adopt a law on february 25, i can imagine it, but for the audience, please tell us why it was necessary to legally prepare a procedure that a we can carry out b that will be consonant that will be based on world experience and we here we studied the experience of several countries, and for this we needed time. so we could do it faster even with the

current dynamics of the work of the verkhovna rada, and we studied the experience of the united states in the fight against funds belonging to drug lords. after all, it is almost impossible to prove that they belong to the anti-narcotics service, so it is the same as the experience of italy in the fight against the mafia, where, in fact, in one and the other case, the key task was not for the state to prove that these are funds that belong to it. and if the state suspects, it arrests, it collects a already a person who is suspected of his responsibility, taking into account the complexity of the structure of the mafia or drug cartels and, accordingly, the presumption, conditionally speaking, they are in a certain way, although, well, if it is not quite correct to speak like that from the side of a democratic society. now, why do we

they did not do this, but i would develop your opinion. and why did we adopt a law in may, and the list of 1,300 oligarchs is still far from all, but only at the end of september, this question is actually much more interesting, and here i would like to say that the authorities are now actively fighting russia on all fronts, an application to nato for sanctions and the like, but unfortunately we have a lot of facts that show that, for example, with the same mr. firtash, they tried- with the same mr. friedman, that is a separate story, so with mr. friedman, they tried to... and agree one with arguments that said everything that now it is not possible to include him in the lists, it was the plans to capitalize the ukrainian daughter of alpha bank for 1 billion dollars, yes, abramovich was involved in the exchange of hostages, of course, it worked out, of course, but hmm

, there was also an argument come on friends, we wo n't arrest them, we won't seize their property in ukraine, well, this means that the contract is capable of co- corruption. it is still in ukraine, well, that is, what official is sitting, some friedman says, listen, you take care of me, i will give you a billion. i do not i'll give you a billion, i'll give you 10 million if you try otaku such and such a solution what will be beneficial for me, that is, this corruption did not happen anywhere, despite the war, from your point of view and from my point of view, the first is the field for corruption has become significantly smaller why, because the state would like it, the government would not like it, the government would not like it, the government would like it to the military framework , there are very few resources, they should be

directed to the army as a priority, therefore, it is trivial, objectively, to steal, which has become significantly less, and the second is the request of the people for the punishment of such marauders, because that's it not corruptors, it is specifically marauders, he is significantly higher and a large part of these people have weapons in their hands , so who does this in fact, hmm, there are chances to fall not under democratic laws, but in fact under the laws of wartime . the verkhovna rada is preparing and preparing a number of draft laws, i.e. is an algorithm being developed? yes , yesterday nato made a fool of itself to the euro, the prospect of all this requires thousands, maybe even tens of thousands of pages of laws, i was told once

in order to enter this european community, 16,000 pages of legislation must be adopted, it is huge and one must understand where to start, what is in the first place, what entails some other changes, and so on and so on. there is such an understanding in the verkhovna rada, in the leadership of the verkhovna rada, that this algorithm and fix it and after the victory, i hope, like you, to very quickly start moving along this path, and in this direction, we do not have time to wait after the victory, in fact, we have a unique opportunity now, there are many things that used to slow down ukraine on the way to the european union, now objectively due to the war, they have become less influential. well, for example, in the field of ecology, we can. but most of the opposition comes from

akhmetov and the big so-called industrialists, who banally kept non-modern, non-modern enterprises, saying that to modernize them costs crazy money and a large part of these enterprises unfortunately, they have been destroyed and now if we need to rebuild them, we will have to rebuild them, then rebuilding them is already content according to european standards, because who needs the old ones soviet steel mills or something like that almost completely destroyed the word mariupol, therefore, in this case, it is important now to lay down the legislative possibilities from i would not say rebuilding is very wrong. for some reason, our government uses it. we cannot, we had, we have once every

third, if not every second bill contains elements of european integration, the only problem is that very often, ah, hmm, the majority is under well, let's say it is trying to creatively approach european integration, and we are also there by improving, for example, ecological control but at the same time, we are trying to bring back some regulatory things that would be prohibited as preventing business from developing. well, if you can't offend yourself, that's why the work is already being done really, well, in fact, in all areas , we need to restart the process that is synchronized with modern european standards and to which ukraine has already made a lot since the 14th year, starting in fact from the period 14-19 years and even the beginning of the 20th year, it was such i would say seven-mile steps in the direction of the european union, why are we so enough

yes, we got this candidacy for the european union quickly, although with a lot of blood, because a lot has already been done, but these technical points that you are talking about, well, there are not even 16,000, but they could have possibly had more pages, we are already working on it somewhere faster somewhere slower in the media significantly slower why because it is comfortable for the authorities to have a controlled media space, but it is far from european standards, but after the victory, we will simply not even have a legislative period, the stage of implementing this and we will simply have to implement it is already at the level of the cabinet of ministers and by-laws, regulations and ugh, now we are already thanking me. i apologize to yaroslav yurchuk , the deputy of ukraine, because i have next experts on energy issues also important. therefore, thank you, mr. yaroslav, next we have mr. gennady ryabtseva, mr. oleksiy ezhyak,

first - this is an expert on energy issues, the second - this is an analyst of the national institute of strategic studies, just uh, on issues of energy, nuclear threats, and so on and so on, i hope we will all see them with you now . we want to see them. good health, mr. gennady. good health, mr. oleksiy, look. i have a question for you on a planetary scale. look, there is an energy balance in the world. if it exists, then the world produces a certain amount of goods per year. as far as i i understand that it produces approximately, i am not saying the exact data here, because probably no one knows them, somewhere around 100 trillion per 100 trillion dollars, the world produces in just one year

to produce it. it takes a certain amount of energy. as i understand it, per day in order to produce 365 days on an eye 100 trillions need a day somewhere in the order of 90 100 e-e-e barils and oil and when we seem to remove literally 5%, i remember i seem to be able if you know where the plane is, where can you take it, how can it be compensated, because these are these barrels, that is, these 190,100 million per day, well, they will not fall from the sky, yes. we also counted azerbaijan, we also counted iran and venezuela and that and that and that and

that is where to find literally 3-5% of the eyes of mankind necessary, and russia does not give its own, its own desire , or because of the desire of our western partners, who simply introduce sanctions and so on and the like. that is, we, the world, humanity will be able to do without russia, that is the question. tell me who i apologize to. gennady, i apologize. if there is no supply of russian hydrocarbons to the world market, then even then the supply will be greater than the demand, and now it is higher than the demand; another thing is that now not everything is determined by the economic laws that at one time were there

invented by adam smith, karl marx, and others , the fact is that, in addition to the trillions that you are talking about, the world produces 10-15 times the number of dollars . financial speculation, we have abnormally high quotes for both oil and natural gas, particularly in europe, and because of this, it seems to us that the influence of russia in the energy sector is greater than it actually is, because after the oil boom , the introduction of the oil bar from this december 5 year and it is prohibited to buy russian oil products by the european union and almost all

the united states and all the states of the british commonwealth from february 5 next year, it is unlikely that anything drastic will happen, well, i know for sure that nothing drastic will happen that would not allow consumers all over the world to receive as much hydrocarbons as they need okay. now let's listen to mr. oleksiy zhk. and to him such a possible question, we have considered those countries that buy gas, receive oil from russia, and if you imagine that there will be sanctions restrictions, what will happen in russia, how painful will it be for them, how much will they suffer, what will they do with it ? maybe they will, on the contrary, gasify all of siberia and the russians will have a wonderful life, maybe they will finally

take me, i was once in iran in the 90s, four cents was the price of gasoline, four cents - this is the 90s, some p5th year, i think maybe they will just give out gasoline and all russians will get into cars, the truth is that it is not known where to get cars, in short, there are a lot of questions, mr. mr. oleksiy, please tell me what it is for russia, this is an energy airbag that existed and that part of the russian population that lives in a deep province, there are no normal toilets there. they may not feel it, they have not seen those cars, that gasoline. well, they will not see it, they will burn it with firewood and something else, but if talk about the incomes of the russian political regime. yes, they will fall, but it seems that the situation is already such that it does not matter to them. power is more important to them than

money, and in part they will solve the problem until what we call green transition, well, it will still be after 30 , in the 30th year, it will be noticeable. and now they will partially redirect the oil to the side of china. sketches of a certain part are more difficult for them to redirect, so they will reduce it, because they are already simply burning it, but they are ready to sacrifice gas now, in general, gazprom is ready to sacrifice in order to exacerbate the situation in europe as much as possible, so here are the revenues. i think that gazprom's external revenues will decrease sharply , oil revenues may not be so fast , but still, they are not by 10-20%, they will decrease, but how much they

will decrease depends on the financial markets and how quickly it will be possible to find a quick, quick replacement for russian oil, so money will decrease, we can already see this from the russian state budget, if at the beginning of this phase of the war they had a trillion ruble title e-e in the annual e-e for a year it was planned there because the prices of energy carriers jumped and they had such a sudden additional incomes. and now there is already a trillion trillion deficit, which means that revenues are falling, but they are ready to continue, well, because of what i said , it seems to them that power is more important than money, eh, the question is again to mr. genna oleksia, see this is more philosophical, eh, financially and economically philosophical

, because of the hyphen, the question means that after all, in the world, i have in mind, the civilized world, the elements of morality, the elements of metaphysics began to dominate the elements of profitability, the last ones, as far as i remember , all write about it, as far as i remember. now, just as the nobel week is about to begin, all the latest nobel laureates in economics, and not only from economy that man plays a role in the economy, fear and man, man's emotions, man's love, man 's hatred affects in one way or another the state of affairs with finances and the economy, i.e. ukraine by its actions has more or less pushed humanity to think civilly not only about profits, but about the moral aspect about the blood money that before we know we were

in africa mostly near diamonds and now blood money in russia just lies in wads and billions and you can pronounce them by dozens is it really so or is it really western business and western under the influence of this business, politicians are beginning to understand that loot does not defeat evil but helps evil and loot and now loot has already started to help loot judging by the uh good i apologize judging by the behavior of the americans who give a lot of money to ukraine let's start now with mr. oleksiy well if to talk about the deep process, then we cannot say that right now we are seeing such changes, so you try to sell a non-kosher product in israel or try to sell a non-halal product in the arab world or try to sell a non-green product the product in the european union, well, you will still sell it in the european union, but with large additional

taxes because of that. and why? well, there was a story earlier when, for example, cotton from uzbekistan was not real cotton, and even in the crimea, when many countries did not buy because of the fact that there are elements of arab labor, ego said now, all the people of the hungarian autonomous region in china do not want to buy, they will also show grace there, therefore, there is a cultural component in this, it has always been, it is taken into account, but what you are talking about, i think here there is indeed an element of the fact that the attitude towards the future economy is being revised from the point of view of the main driver, not simply well, many people doubt that simple profit as per karl marx or the lust for money, it drives the economy, it drives the economy , maybe the earth will not withstand such a movement

further. therefore, they are really being revised now a lot of things and a lot of things are shifting from money, which is increasingly becoming virtual, digital, and in general, what is it, what is it, what is money now and it is being thrown aside, how do we want to live? well, we see that otundar, she has calmed down a little now, but in principle, you can treat such phenomena in different ways, but this is a phenomenon in the direction of the other. the main thing is how we want to live here. i absolutely agree that this war prompted such considerations and such views, mr. gennady, is your version really starting the world somehow, it is more suspicious to consider money, but to people, if the essence is more attractive, now i would not say that it started in ukraine, the fact is that the standards of social responsibility have been operating in european business for a long time, we are not only in

european and transnational, look at those programs that are not financial reports that are published by all companies from general electric to there sometime and you will see that despite the financial indicators, there are a huge number of social programs, and these social programs initiated by the businessmen themselves, and so the number of sanctions that have been implemented against the russian federation, we can look and compare how many sanctions were imposed by the state and how many sanctions were voluntarily introduced by business entities various european, australian , new zealand ones, i don’t know which ones, even chinese ones. by the way, these sanctions will be much more than those introduced by the state, and it is they in the complex that have the same cumulative effect as the

energy effect that is currently making er, hmm, the surplus budget of the russian federation is in deficit , and in addition, in the russian federation there is still a misunderstanding of what european values ​​are, for some reason they focused on parent number 1 and parent number two and throw out the whole thing called good garvermins tool, a concept that has been implemented for a long time in the european union and uh, i need to understand, it is quite clear that a person thinks what to do, mr. oleksiy, but everyone sees shredder, that jennifer the electrician is there helping someone, for some reason, no one sees shredder alone well, now they began to suspect that the angel merkel is the former italian prime minister, but

everyone sees them and says that they are here, they help businesses and this is blood money that goes to mr. putin through them, and putin is all blood money directs against ukrainian citizens well, what can i say to you, i won't tell you anything else, i'll just thank you, gennady, oleksiy, it's very nice that they were with us on saturday evening at six o'clock , normal people, not even on saturdays, but on working days, they finish er, they finish their work and they were with us and answered our questions, so we have to smile and say thank you, we smile and thank you and thank you in advance to iryna koval, who will now tell you about what happened in the world while i was here tereveniv thank you mykola, what will i tell you about the successes of our army at the front. and we will talk about that with russia in a moment