that, among other things, will affect the defense order , the mode of operation of various enterprises, military orientation, and in this sense, all resources will be thrown into the war. military operation in ukraine it corresponds to the reality, it can really be so, that is, about the fact that he does not even trust his immediate environment, he himself gives orders. absolutely not publicly, because he is extremely afraid of failures, and they will be personally associated with him, that is why it will be announced in the public space that the defeat of the children is the result of the incompetence of commanding scouts, and there is some information about what is happening with the

minister now of defense, that is, what function does he perform , minister of defense serhiy, and chief of the general staff serhiy gerasimov, because before, well, a few months ago, at the beginning of the so-called military operation, they were often shown on on television, then they disappeared altogether and now there is almost no information about them at all to read on the internet, well, the point is that they still exist , that is, putin hasn’t eliminated them yet, and i think that they are just being held to the role of text writers in the famous eh kozlov is released if everything will not work out for everyone and how do you need to put all the blame for the defeat on them and in this sense they are prices for putin how are these cans that can be opened at the right moment and used what can make putin despair well, let's say so well, we know

that there are no moral and ethical limits for putin personally, considering that all such things are in his hands, he has quite large military power if we are talking about nuclear weapons. i am afraid that any decisions can be expected from him, including the people themselves, that is, he maybe, under certain circumstances, in a certain situation, you can still press the button that we call red, they say that it is not red, well, you know, until february 24, everyone hoped that putin has, er, some remnants of the voice of reason that что мы видели после бучи, после изюма, после мариупол, well, what can we talk about, a-a, absolutely immoral, absolutely inhumane, e-e , the image of a person who is e-e, to achieve his own

personal mercantile a-a, the whole a-a will go to all lengths thing, in your opinion, how can this be prevented, how can the west prevent it, or does the west have these means of putting pressure on putin so that putin, as an immoral person, did not press this button ? intelligence, including the united states, works very well, we know this from the actions they took before the invasion and from the information they provided, it seems that their agents are in the russian leadership somewhere, so i think that if in principle, the kremlin will decide to arrange an apocalypse for this purpose. it can prevent a-a in an asymmetrical way , that is, the west is not interested in a global nuclear war, and the west has every

possibility to avoid it. became how i now put it, i put several programs in it, it seems because of one program, so i'm just interested to hear your answer to it now, taking into account the situation that has developed now , taking into account the defeats of russia in ukraine, taking into account the mobilization from which the russians are are fleeing en masse. please tell me what is happening in russia right now, at the moment, it must happen that the russians say enough is enough and overthrow putin. as a few weeks ago, because putin is relying, among other things, on the repressive apparatus, this is the special services, this is the fsb, this is the police, this is the guard, he is increasing the financing, and this has already been discussed by the state government for the

upcoming time alarms of discontent within russia in some regions, including dagestan, as we saw, they were quickly quelled, and in this sense, the resources for suppressing any protest within the country in the russian regions are more than enough, so we hope that that from the inside the russians will be able to do this situation on their own, including through the uprising, for example, it will fix it. there are two possible options. opinion because i still thought that this situation that is now made up of changes that have taken place now that it is possible that they somehow and uh influenced it on the course of events in russia, unfortunately no p mykola and the last question for you today

provocative, i understand the question as a citizen of russia. please tell me that russia after putin is territorially the same russia as it is now or not. of course not. the empire is falling apart. this process has been going on for more than 100 years. dezontagration and erazlichnye processes within russia are not going anywhere and the crisis will be only and the russia that we know now and the russia that was before putin's invasion of krym before the beginning of the ukrainian war will not exist in the future thank you for your answer, i will remind our viewers from mykola polozov, a lawyer, was on the air. they obviously talked about russia and, unfortunately, about putin , but i have to talk about it. well, they tell me that she is ready to join me. my second interlocutor today is maria zolkina

, an analyst at the democratic initiatives foundation named after ilka kucheriv. congratulations, ladies. maria, congratulations . thank you very much for joining today's program. i am waiting for your professional answers that will allow me to understand the questions that for me personally and for my viewers sometimes seem difficult to understand. i already have some with mr. mykola spoke about the referendums that took place, the so-called referendums that took place in the territories that russia now considers its so-called own . ms. maria please tell me what we need to prepare for, what we need to wait for. in the coming weeks, maybe months, it is obvious that this will be a

victorious advance of the armed forces of ukraine, but what else we need to wait after that. well, we have to understand that russia has actually used all its diplomatic, economic, military, and blackmail methods not only of ukraine in order to force ukraine to cooperate with russia, but also the tools with which it could pressure the west, and therefore, in fact, russia only had the only argument on which they now emphasize it is some kind of use or threat of use of nuclear weapons, therefore, first of all, i would not be frivolous uh, since the situation in russia from my point of view they have a critical prospect of gaining military success on the territory of ukraine, which was illusory before that, absolutely negative, as

they like to say now in their information space, and that's why russia actually has a small arsenal measures and means by which they can try to stop uh, this is a losing scenario for themselves uh, therefore, on the military front, we need to prepare for what it is in principle, maybe on the diplomatic front, uh, can you hear me on the diplomatic front, the russians are making last efforts in some way to split the unity of the european union does not and will not succeed in them. well, the third argument they are counting on is actually the spread of such conditionally appeasing attitudes in some countries of the european union. i am not talking about the diplomatic front, i am not talking about politicians uh, and not about

those communicative decisions directly about society and russians, counting on the cold winter , the energy crisis, uh, unexpectedly high utility bills due to crazy gas prices, gas identity in the countries of the european union will raise discussions from below in the european union about the fact that in ukraine, russia should already agree or everything is as they calculate, the russians will not be ready to pay these bills in the literal sense of the word bills well, but these are certain efforts because russia said so and the calculations are from of such political desperation, if you can put it that way, because strategically, the situation is now turning in a favorable direction for ukraine, and the situation will not change for the next 6 months, the only possibility to

radically change something for russia remains on it's a pity for us to use some kind of terrible weapon, and i'm not only talking about tactical nuclear weapons, which the russians constantly emphasize, but also other types of weapons, biological weapons, chemical weapons, and the sikh dictator will decide on this eh, in order to eh actually stop his loss, well, it is unknown, maybe now the struggle will begin in the kremlin itself, because, eh , after all, i believe that a split in the russian eh summers for various reasons, not because someone there is about the west or uh, against war, but from rational ones reasoning, this split is brewing and it is very logical in this situation, please. and here i was reading information on

the national security adviser of the president of the united states of america, jake sullivan. he said that the united states of america is constantly in constant communication with russia regarding the possible use by russia of nuclear weapons, or some other terrible weapon that you mentioned. damn, for this it is actually enough to simply send such a message, very straightforwardly, not that the consequences will be catastrophic. well, what is being said now is generally because, of course , publicly, the united states will never allow it, and no other nuclear country in the world that currently supports ukraine will allow it. to say to yourself that in the event of a nuclear attack on ukraine by russia,

these countries or this country, such as the united states, will destroy the russian federation itself by nuclear means, that is, we should not expect such a public message, but precisely in this in the form of this signal, this message must be delivered to the kremlin, to what extent is it formulated in this way by washington, its communication with moscow is unknown, but it is certain, but there are reasons to believe that the consequences are reported directly, and we hope that even this irrational what is putin's logic for us? it is actually rationalized under the threat of the physical destruction of the leadership of the russian federation and russia itself. you even talk about the physical destruction of the leadership of the russian federation. you are even considering such an option. if you are any of

western countries were in charge of russia, then he would probably not be in the siberian fields, but somewhere where decisions are made. it is clear, yes, mrs. maria , please tell me, returning to what happened in russia last week, in particular, this sabbath on red square, why such sabbaths are still possible in russia what does it depend on the people, what is it like, what is it like, or after all, on the fact that the leadership of this country puts a lot of pressure on this people, does not allow them to raise their heads, as some people say, what does it depend on? why don't the russians can stand up against this tyrant, and as my previous interlocutor, mr. mykola, said that the russian people are not capable of changing anything now, the

question for you is, why do i remember? categorically do not perceive these values, and therefore, passively or actively, this society supports that ideology, on which the domestic and foreign policy in the russian federation is based, therefore, and the sabbath, and this the so-called changes and they became possible because there is a willingness of society to either look at it and treat it neutrally loyally or to support it to its majority this is exactly what happens and more accordingly what is the role of public opinion actually anti-war rallies , for example. and the fact is that the russians are now very active on the international arena and

are actually trying to divide into two different camps of those who rule the russian state, who live directly in the state, is the task of the russian position and russian such a liberal mind. let's put it this way, the groups are to remove responsibility from russian society, in principle, to say that they live in some kind of big prison, so that they have illegal regimes and therefore there is no to spread a-a neither political nor moral e nor economic responsibility and from this even then the bottles about that look at the sanctions affect them there some kind of economic pit even more here look at

a discussion on the introduction of an entry ban for russian e-e councils of ukraine of the member union e look at what they are now demanding, fleeing from mobilization in the russian federation, how they are demanding to be treated almost like political refugees and do not understand they sincerely do not understand why they are not perceived in the same way, but they advance all these narratives, and that is why in the russian federation there is a demand for a strong in the war. that is exactly such an offensive uh-uh in terms of politics uh-uh-uh external line of behavior it is accepted and i am convinced in relation to those, our partner union , especially in western europe, will not understand that

simply by replacing putin with a conditionally different head of the russian federation, who will play the role of someone who corrects putin's mistakes, will try to restart the dialogue of the west, will take russian troops into the territory of ukraine, and so furthermore, this change itself will not strategically change anything fundamentally in the policy of russia in relation to the outside world, because everything will be the same as the laws of history and the laws of public opinion. i have been working for many years researches of public sentiments and if this request remains eh then the loss of russia and eh ignoring the fact that all this was partially caused and supported by society will simply lead to an explosion in 10-15 years maybe even earlier there will be a revanchist there will be a certain feeling of humiliation well, i will not appeal to the

country, which i think we understand, where all this happened after one defeat . us for ukrainian analysts, by the way, it's a serious problem now that the west, especially in western europe, has uh, that's not rest a mrs. maria we really have us mrs. maria excuse me please message maria i'm sorry we have a lot of problems with communication right now the last thing you said was difficult to hear. we will now redial you and try to restore normal communication, because it is very interesting to listen to what ms. maria says, and it is interesting how she says what will happen next in russia, will there be these revanchist sentiments or there won't be, mr. mykola - my previous interlocutor, mykola polozov, said that there won't

be any revenge movements, that you can only try to destroy russia from the outside, but what's most interesting is what he said that you can destroy such things, mrs. maria, you're with us again yes yes congratulations yes yes keep talking because because we are you the sound broke a little and after hearing what you said you can continue we understand that there is a really significant part we i mean not only ukrainians for us sushi is visible but collectively such an anti-putin anti-russian coalition if we do not collectively understand that there is a serious request for such an aggressive policy or a willingness to passively watch the implementation of this aggressive policy on the part of russian society. ukraine we will all the same return to another war in 10 or

15 years. because these sentiments of revanchism are the feeling of the premises of dissatisfaction with this loss. they will be conserved as a result. i will explode again. and instead of a transitional, new , sputin-like president, a new figure will appear in russia anyway, and it will very soon be a figure that is no better. well, this is very bad. maria , please tell me your opinion, going back to last week, and a few a few days ago, everyone was waiting for the speech of the secretary general of nato and jens stoltenberg, even in the ukrainian public, in particular on facebook, which i like to read, they talked about the fact that we should wait for this evening because janstoutenberg has to say something very important, i confess, i behaved because i thought that he would say something about ukraine joining nato, and just before that, the office of the president of ukraine said that we were somehow submitting a new

application for joining nato, and i thought to myself that maybe they will accept us without a passport. perhaps accelerated in some way, as sweden and finland, for example, i was waiting for jens stoltenberg's speech, i waited and listened, and nothing about ukraine came up, even when he was directly asked if there was a chance, he said that every country obviously has a chance because nato's doors are open for everyone, what do you think it is? our chance to become a member of nato in the short and medium term. i think that ukraine will become a member of nato earlier than a member of the european union, and the fact that the ukrainian side without 100% coordination with our western partners made this decision is of undoubted strategic importance despite the fact that there will not be such an instant reaction to the ukrainian application as there was no re

-enco of the political finland of sweden , that is, we will now have more discussion now, uh, some members will feel very uncomfortable nato, including one of our best and strategic partners in fact, but the situation requires non-standard solutions . itself creates a certain political umbrella for us and nato, but also requires non-standard policy decisions regarding russia, because the problem of repelling russian aggression with the help of ukraine is understood in the western world, we are supplied with

every month we have more and more weapons, we have the necessary dynamics, sanctions unprecedented in world history have been imposed on russia, and from december 5, when the supply of oil from russia to the countries of the european union will be cut off for good, this effect will only take on greater forms for the russian federation, but among our western partners there is one question to which they cannot formulate an answer, and ukraine should push with the help of our central european and eastern european partners to push other members of the european union and nato before finding an answer to this question, this question sounds like this and if ukraine remains outside the european union , in what way will we be certain that similar aggression from russia will not be repeated in a year, two or three years, that is, what there must be a

security architecture on the european continent after the victory of ukraine over the russian federation in this war, and it is necessary to prepare for it now, but unfortunately in the western years, even the united states does not have an answer to this question, they do not know what to do with russia if it starts to crack at the seams and fall apart, this question was put last to the previous speaker, this is a question about the possible disintegration of russia . russia , er, how to restrain its aggressive er, um, aggressive policy in the future, there is practically no discussion about this right now, and that is why ukraine's application

is a political application, we understand that it was not legally required, there is no such concept at all how to submit an application for joining nato is a political step to declare one's intentions and provoke a corresponding discussion in the member states of the european union, it was strategically important and now we see that it has already pushed nine countries of the center to europe, we should directly support ukraine and if we have e 30 from the start of the allies e among nato members will mark the discussion will move quickly god grant that it moves so quickly and that we become a member of this military-political union in order to be able to defend ourselves in in the future, i will oppose such aggression that may return. thank you, maria. i will remind you that maria zolkina , an analyst at the democratic initiatives foundation named after

ilko kucherev, was in direct contact with me. the most important thing that happened in the world is obviously related to ukraine next week, next monday will be of course more at the very end, i just want to remind you of what i always say to those who watched we are on youtube. if you liked it, please like it. if you didn't like it, please dislike it and write something. it is important for us and it is important for the promotion of our network on youtube. well , for today, my full name is yuri fizer. see you soon, we are looking for 16- year-old natalya butyk, who disappeared in the middle of august in the city of boryslav, lviv oblast. that's exactly how it is.

by the short number 116,000, since then it has been about two weeks and now i am returning to this story because i have very good news, let's listen to the message that we received from the mother of the missing girl. i say thank you to your service for tracing children who have a daughter found docsik natalia yuriivna thank you to all ukraine natalya the boutique was found in the city of drohobych, everything is fine with her now she is definitely safe this is very comforting news and of course we want similar messages we received from the parents of all the missing children so i am asking you very much look carefully at the photo, this is also a 16-year-old girl, her name is kateryna dyadiova, and nothing has been known about her fate for a month and a half. katya lived with her parents in novaya kakhovka in the kherson region, but due to the worsening of the situation in the region in july , the family decided to evacuate in 5 months,

we are working or me and my husband, there were 12 of us from 11 to 12 in the crowd, the balconies hit the windows, they flew out , then our house flew by, too, the whole life passed before our eyes, the family managed to leave for poland on july 17, everyone was already in wroclaw and settled there we lived for a couple of weeks, everything seemed to be ok, until suddenly on august 2, kateryna dyadiova mysteriously disappears, it turns out that it was the second day. мы её больше не ведие so, katya disappeared in poland in the city of wroclaw on august 2. of course, her family immediately turned to the local police, the search is ongoing, but there is an assumption that the girl may be in

ukraine . after the disappearance, the daughter started talking to some young man, and he seems to be from ukraine, so it is possible that kateryna crossed the border and went to see him, but he was such a fool. well, it ’s not her at all. well, she’s usually domestic. she doesn’t go out. well, naturally, i don’t know who what could i do? i don’t know. i don’t know. the most important thing is to find 16-year-old katya, if she is really in ukraine. everyone can help to find her. look carefully at the girl’s photo. she is quite tall, her height is about 175 cm, her hair is dark, her eyes are dark. blue-green, kateryna looks a little older than her age, the girl wears orthodontic braces on her teeth and she also has a small scar under her left eye