then we had to leave ukraine, we went to puerto rico or to georgia and no one fulfilled their obligations. well, well, well, well, well, that's unfair, so i'll say this question . nevertheless, ukraine did not ask questions not only to bohdan lviv and the security service of ukraine, but also to those 18 judges who voted against the release of bohdan lviv and did not see anything wrong with that, and selective justice you say here we are we close our eyes because this is georgia and here is the son of a man. we will not close our eyes like this. it does not work. there should be a standard system . the deputy of ukraine was with us, and now it's time for news and iryna koval is already ready to tell you about them.

thank you oles. congratulations to the studio of iryna koval, another torture chamber of russians was discovered by law enforcement officers in the village of velikiy burluk , a settlement in kharkiv oblast, recently freed from the invaders, the invaders turned the police department into their fortified base and a torture chamber for local residents, outside the attackers dug trenches for defense, inside, everything was crushed everywhere, garbage and dirt is reported to the national police, now the investigators are collecting all the necessary evidence so that every war criminal is punished, now the

district police department is behind me, which has been destroyed. now there investigators and forensic scientists are working to extract trace information and evidence of the presence of occupation forces in it and the situation in various regions of ukraine, the russians attacked kharkiv again at night with s-300 missiles, fired at two districts of the city in novobavarsky, an infrastructure object of railway transport was damaged, one of its buildings was destroyed by an explosion there a fire broke out, it was extinguished in the morning, the body of a 46-year-old woman was recovered from under the rubble, the state emergency service of the region was informed in ukrzaliznytsia that the railway line was de-energized the network, so train delays are possible, they are currently minimal in the holodohorsk district, an industrial enterprise came under enemy attack during the

day, the attackers continued to attack the civilian population of kharkiv region, the head of the regional military administration noted that as a result of the shelling of a hospital in the kupyan district, an anesthesiologist was killed, two nurses were injured , and a man and a girl were hospitalized with injuries nine years old, doctors assess her condition as moderate and the occupiers attacked kramatorsk in donetsk region at night, two people were injured, he said the mayor oleksandr goncharenko, private houses and a school were damaged, the ceiling was shattered and windows were broken, shells hit the yard, the invaders also fired cluster munitions at the mining village of gagatyli and along kostyantynivka , houses and roads were damaged there, according to the regional military administration, in the past day, the russians killed one civilian of donetsk region two more people were wounded, four people were wounded

as a result of enemy shelling of nikopol, two men were hospitalized in the city, about 30 projectiles from russian hail and heavy artillery more than 7,000 families without electricity, repair works are ongoing, the city is still without water, the networks of the pumping station of the vodokanal were damaged, the head of the dnipropetrovsk regional military administration, valentin riznichenko, allegedly said there were more than 30 multi-story and private buildings, the shelling damaged a school, a pharmacy, an industrial enterprise, grain the elevator of the shop and the administrative building were destroyed by the russians, and the agricultural warehouses of the pokrovsk community caught fire people have already put out unharmed enemy attacks , the morganets and chervonogrigoriv communities of dnipropetrovsk region have been found out, the extent of the destruction is being determined, and prior to the situation in kherson region, the russians

shelled almost all settlements on the line of contact, there are injuries among the civilian population , the regional military administration noted the most destruction of civil infrastructure, private houses, commercial buildings the state bureau of investigation recorded in the villages of arkhangelsk and visokopilla tokarevo, ivanivka, olgyne, myrolyubivka and orlova fighting against their own people concluded the case against the former deputy chief of intelligence of the board of the headquarters of the naval forces ihor tatarchenko. in 2014, after the occupation of a military unit in sevastopol, the captain swore allegiance to the aggressor. he currently holds the position of commander of the 155th separate brigade of the russian marines. it was this group that took part in the fighting in buch and irpeni, after the beginning of the full-scale russian

aggression, the traitor went to fight against his own people, not even considering the fact that, according to operational data, his close relatives still live in the territory of the kyiv region, a former ukrainian military man is accused of treason, he faces up to 15 years in prison before the war, russia has difficulties with the placement and training of those mobilized in the formation of the ministry of defense of great britain, it is said that the autumn conscription to the russian army has been postponed for a month, this shows the inability of russia to train and arm a large number of new conscripts, at the same time they point out that the russian army is not recruiting those who were planned. also, soldiers are being placed in tent camps. of the russian administrative and logistical system will continue these efforts, the british scouts in the black-pack troops have added

370 more russians, and since the beginning of the full-scale invasion, 6,60,800 attackers have fought. the same number of rocket salvo systems and one means against air defense, in addition, the defenders also landed the largest enemy aircraft losses per day the enemy suffered in the kramatorsk and bakhmut directions in the general headquarters emphasize that the data is indicative, it was for russia, it became for ukraine estonia handed over to the ukrainian armed forces drones that they had previously tried to take out of the country for the russian army, the estonian embassy in ukraine said in july this year, a russian with dual citizenship, he tried to transfer

technical equipment for the needs of the russian military, the police arrested a man and seized the drones he had purchased for the benefit of our state across the country without leaving the city limits in lviv , they organized a west to visit ours, where immigrants and local residents could get to know the color of five front-line regions of ukraine, the journey starts from donetsk region, in particular from mariupol , numerous exhibits instantly remind of the sea, paper boats, smooth pebbles and painted shells nearby paintings depicting a drama theater and a house with spires, each city is represented by its inhabitants, says organizer yulia we were looking for people who are currently in lviv and are ready to tell us about their cities, er, these are the cities of the front line, we were interested in kherson oblast, kharkiv oblast, donetsk oblast, luhansk oblast, of course crimea, our cities

sound like culture, sound like cuisine, sound like philharmonic music. we want to talk about this wonderful and common thing that we have at the stand . daily life of slobozhanshchyna participants learn how to knit shawls correctly and examine the unique pattern of embroidered women our goal is home gatherings we want people to visit each other we want to lviv residents of his family and all of whom are already in lviv we live felt like a big family because we are the highlight of the event, the auction of kherson watermelons, the smallest fruit was bought for a thousand hryvnias, visitors also had the opportunity to purchase a trophy anti-tank missile complex and reproductions of art paintings all collected funds will go to the needs of the armed forces of ukraine lots were brought from skadovsk by the mayor oleksandr yakovlev today as skadovsk we represent the entire kherson region there are skadovsk watermelons stand skadovsk we represent the kherson project indomitable, that's why we decided to join to support

all the people of kherson, the people of skadov, all the ukrainians. so we prepared a pilaf here today, we will treat all visitors to this event separately. the crimea also has a location in his homeland, and honey worked for 13 years in the bakhchisarai palace, now a man from lviv, heritage and culture crimean tatars, we do master classes for little girls. the first master class is coloring. it is very valuable for me and i want to show yes that crimea is ukraine and that we will definitely return to our homes like swallows, the organizers plan to hold similar events in the future, because it is never too late to get acquainted with the culture of different cities of our country kateryna oliynyk oleg palamar tv channel espresso after the victory, everyone will definitely

return to their homes and rebuild the country and that was all the news for the time being, the updated issue, wait for the 12th war in ukraine, the main topic for ukrainians , victories and losses, analysis and forecasts, politics and geopolitics serhiy rudenko and the guests of his program will talk about all this people who have information and shape public opinion people who defend ukraine and create the future right now the main and interesting thing in the program verdict by serhiy rudenko monday to thursday at 5:10 p.m. repeat at 9:30 p.m. our method to act in anticipation our task is

to disrupt the plans of the enemy our slogan is wise rule me in the stars our battlefield advance and deep you are in the enemy our goal is victory glory military intelligence of ukraine this is my country my fields are mine friends, brothers, parents, children, neighbors, students, doctors , teachers, soldiers, we are all, all of us, regardless of age, beliefs, preferences, beliefs, we are all united now. we will win. glory to ukraine, we are returning to our telethon, the fifth final hour, together with lesya gukalyuk, andriy savchuk is holding this

marathon for you. i want to tell you, gentlemen, that elon musk , with whom we started our barathon 5 hours ago, already admits his mistake. well, let's say it's not a mistake. i would like to remind his critics that elon musk called on ukraine to start peace talks, to give way to the kremlin, to recognize crimea as russian and to agree to a neutral status for ukraine . even he himself approved of it, and he responded to it . dmitry medvedev is russian and so on and so on. mr. andreas uman , political scientist, analyst of the stogorsk research center from europe, join us, we are also waiting for viktor svynchuka, head of the board of world politics, a little about this, and we will also talk, mr. andres good afternoon, we have devoted quite a lot of time to

discussing this idea of ​​ilona's mask of a peace treaty, but i will also pay attention to a very interesting post by tomos friedman, an american journalist who is known to write about what is possible , he mentions this a game when two drivers just go head-to-head head-on and this game is about who will lose their nerve first and who will turn the steering wheel first and he says that on this theory of the games they say that the best way to convince the opponent that he will lose is before the start that how are you going to unscrew the steering wheel and throw it out the window, didn't putin unscrew the steering wheel by blowing up two branches of the northern stream, because we believe that russia is probably behind it after all, and recognizing this annexation, er, the annexation of these territories, which in fact

even the russians control, is this putin does not demonstrate that he has completely lost his mind in order to finally convince the way he expressed himself, this is not a bluff, what this actually prophesies to all of us in the near future. how can we cope with this? well, for me, this is the last month became such a strange month because there were a lot of such strange decisions on the part of russia, it just doesn't even correspond to the russian narrative because, for example, it is of course very good that russia let these people go azov people who have now returned to ukraine is of course very good, but if it is against the russian

narrative that it is about unification, it is if such a decision is also related to annexation, because this annexation is new, if it is all it violates the soft power that russia still had somewhere there because there used to be, well, yes, probably there with the crimea, there is such a person, the history is probably there, it was historically justified, and now these new annexations - it is already clear to everyone that it is simple here, it is about the usual imperial expansion there, it is not about any there is historical justice of it. here was this narrative in russia. well, there are a lot of such decisions, which for me are evidence that something in the kremlin is no longer the way it is. they can't even stand

it. well, i hope so much that this will also become more clear now for the russians themselves, that they have understood that already in the kremlin itself there is somehow no strategy, somehow there is a course that can be understood whether it is true that russia is actually moving towards the great north korea , friedman also writes about this but after all, russia is not north korea there, er, there is a completely different story there, and er, well, there is a lot to criticize there, the last 30 years there, russia, but it is these last troikas, or even 35 years, russia lived in such a relatively free regime and well

it seems to me that it is not. perhaps it is putin who wants to create such a large north korea from russia. but it seems to me. it is just not, it will not work , that is, even now all these narratives are no longer special operations, it is already a war, it is no longer, it is something special this applies to every russian and i hope that sooner or later it will welcome the change of regime in moscow. head of the department of the institute of world politics. good morning, mr. viktor. and i have a question for you. we are, in fact , elon musk, the sponsor of our today's interview. because we have something to talk about his scandalous

poll and now after that poll he made several statements there and introduced several more polls, but if we return to the very first one that stirred up ukraine so much on all e-e columns number one in all news releases we are already saying so much conversationally whose mistake is it, or is it just that they did not look at ukraine as a country whose history is worth studying, mr. viktor, i think you are right here, ms. lesya, that really now, in the video spread , a statement was made that de facto resonates with what we for ourselves, we imagine the development of further events from the other side. i don't want to reduce it to the fact that they don't know much about ukraine. i think that there is a kind of special operation that is very often carried out by the russian special services, and i do not rule out

that here they can be hidden and their ears as to what musk said, well, it is clear that the issue is the so-called neutrality of ukraine, it was raised by some of our foreign partners once, but it was also raised inside ukraine, remember as one of such pillars of this theory about neutrality , oleksandr chalyi should not be confused with valery the guy, who was sent to the united states of america, so alexander chalyi was even part of the first delegation that went to meet with the russians, and i think that at that time it was about the status of neutrality was also

mentioned. but it seems to me that no country has had such a so-called neutrality. ukraine is faced with such hollow realities . first of all, secondly, i think that it was put literally a few days ago. finally, the point is where ukraine is actually moving and the application that was signed by zelensky er regarding nato yes, it is a symbolic application but nevertheless , it is a serious reversal from the neutrality that er 7 months ago was promoted by his team and this is an important moment for which i would like to draw attention to, so i really want the question of neutrality or neutrality of ukraine to finally disappear from the informational response

and for us not even to talk about it. if we have a strategic decision and a strategic vision that we are we understand that our security is the accession of ukraine to nato, which means that we must move forward to the year actually, mr. andres, and it is confirmed by the survey of ukrainians that support for the accession to nato has never been so massive, more than 80% support it, and even in the east of ukraine, it is for this support is far from 50%. is this a strong argument? this application, on the contrary, did not scare away many skeptics in the west, who see that ukrainians are some kind of scum who are trying to make everyone guilty and take them again as an advance to some structures and so on, is this not how mr. andres perceives the statement to be different from the one made

in 2008, when we must remember that when there was not yet a majority of ukrainians in favor of nato, then it was a statement of the ukrainian political elite and on it's a pity. but it seems to me that at that time, in the eighth year, there was also one of the reasons why this statement was not successful. that is, it was actually partially successful, because there was also a declaration that georgia and ukraine would join nato, but there was no it was said how and when they would be it's all a different situation now, and of course there is a war and there is a lot of support now. this is important. but it seems to me that even the presidential administration

understands that now it is more likely that this introduction will not be successful because, well, the logic of such allies is that they, well, they are not will now enter into a war that is not being waged with a member of this alliance, it is like an insurance, that is, there is a need to enter before the incident, when the incident has already taken place, it is already too late, but nevertheless, i think it is a good, good, such a tool to press for protection and now there is a statement from eastern and central and eastern european countries that support ukraine's statement, including finland, these are all good signals. but it seems to me that even in ukraine, the government there understands that this will most likely

not happen, but it is so important the signal is the right moment. that is, it is rather a gesture, let’s say, some kind of evidence of the seriousness of the intentions and uses this political moment in history, if you remember, before the war, scholz assured putin that ukraine in the coming decades would not will join nato and thus hoped that it would avoid escalation and allow a full-scale invasion to disappear. well, we see that these reassurances did not affect putin and putin did what he did. now, if putin threatens the world with a nuclear attack again, this again distracts us from our accession to nato for ten years viktor the fact is that i agree with mr. andreas that we are not talking about a quick entry

or entry just in the phase of military operations, that is, no one is now talking about literally the day after tomorrow we will be accepted into nato, but a political statement was made here, and it seems to me very important to hear it now, because once again i emphasize that a certain part of the presidential administration was inclined to consider the possibility of this non-blocking neutral status of ukraine. i believe that it was a huge mistake and it should not have been played with from the very beginning. as for the prospects, it all depends on how the war ends, it depends on how the ukrainian armed forces will be able to restrain the enemy go to the counteroffensive to liberate our territories and

er. first, you um, do you remember that there was a request from the president that it was necessary to leave at least at the border on february 24, now society naturally puts pressure on the authorities and demands that the entire territory of ukraine be liberated, and i perfectly understand that if we conducted exactly the same sociological research, so i think that more than 90% of ukrainians are in favor of this. of course, this will put pressure on the military-political leadership . at the same time, it will also put pressure on the world community, which is not necessary to do it on its own. i think that it will and pressure on those leaders who are now playing er, well, such

a certain role that europe is not so united as it demonstrated the first places of war . i think that winter will be a very big litmus test for us to understand how strong europe is, how european leaders are able to negotiate and how ready they are for the fact that ukraine you yourself will win in the sense in which they want ukrainians, well, the situation is probably from the category of those when it is not predicted, here i mentioned , uh, from the column of thomas friedman, who says that russia will gradually turn into a variant of north korea, which means that the world will be very

dangerous and unstable, because it is a huge giant e-e from north korea with e-e thousands of nuclear warheads and this is exactly why your thesis is correct your thesis or just ironically or within russia, the processes that we talk about a lot will take place, first of all, i insist that security for ukraine depends on whether russia will disintegrate or not. if this evil empire will operate within the same borders , even with a change in leadership sooner or later it will still start to move in the direction of ukraine, so this

is absolutely not a very happy option for us , so i am in favor of the fact that right now there are many free peoples of russia who declare their self-recognition and self-determination, they are moving in the direction of this is so that there are more free peoples on the territory of the russian federation. 11 correct decisions, we will not do their work for them either, that is, if they do not start doing this. they say people who live in will not fly here instead