there, one spread his legs, the second covered his head, the third, they tore off his arm, he was so green because the blood had obviously flowed out, the fourth was running somewhere, obviously, because he somehow froze in russia, and if these shots were shown on russian television, maybe maybe it would somehow have an effect. well, i think so, but unfortunately for these cadres, i think the russians will not see where their people do not see that they have everything clearly under control, that is, if we think that well, there are consumers of russian telegram channels, they receive some information, but it is also not so easy, in fact, in russia, unlike ukraine, there is a fairly monolithic information policy and television, and there are electronic media or print media, the ones that remain and telegram channels, they simply clog the entire information picture with the fact that it is profitable for today's moment p oleksandr here i am now hello i have addressed a little, we

will talk about it, then we will go back to modern times , but if we take the russian coups, the last ones we will not be there already in the times of fedor godunov and there paul the first, peter iii, we are closer to our history here. this is a coup. when stalin was actually removed. in fact, in 1956, the cult of the personality was hanged. well, after all, the soviet union followed a slightly different path, although again later there was the crimean crisis. there was again well, but you can also take a coup, let's say, when brezhnev came instead of khrushchev, it did not change anything in principle. to the soviet union, please tell me what is happening now. well, you can also say tsar nicholas ii, who finally signed from the throne in march. well, at the end of the year, there was already a revolution, well, it wasn't real at first , the february revolution took place, then the bolsheviks they made this coup in october, but what is happening now in the

kremlin, at least what we are saying now, those are the signs, those are the moods, what are they that remind you the most? some dismantling of the personality cult and, in principle , continuation of the work, but at the head there is already someone more like that, well, more humane, relatively speaking, more humane khrushchev, well, it could be, i don't know who they had there, i may be, yevhen bronyu will tell who was there among them. oleksandr, what does this mean to you if the historical parallels are drawn? is this completely different at all? it resembles the attempt to overthrow gorbachev, that is, he tried to rescue through the state committee of the state committee the so-called emergency created by an artificial one-time rescue russia, the soviet union, and this only led to the acceleration of the collapse of the soviet union, but the same russia, with its convulsive aggressive actions, is trying to divide the supposedly great russia

, in fact, they are killing, and there are extremely many coups in russia. th year yes to the removal of the tsar coup coup coup then the bolsheviks come to power coup coup stalin monopolizes kills the politburo and monopolizes power there starting from the 26th year of the coup the coup is then killed, most likely they kill stalin and most likely beria did it, so why yes, there is very little data, you know this movie, many people watched it about stalin, but there is a fact, a fact and it is that beria really shook out all the documents the nkvd came to stalin's bedside table and shook out all the papers, and he left one piece of paper, he left a piece of paper from yosif brosti, the yugoslav leader against whom

stalin attempted many times, and yosyp simply wrote to him that if you call me another rebel well, the hired killer has arrived, so i will send you just one and that will be enough, and beria left this one piece of paper in the bedside table for some reason, that is, with a high probability to divert suspicion from himself, but we do not know anything more, there are no analyzes and so on, that's all the only fact recorded in history then, as you rightly said, was the coup of 1956, when khrushchev fired all these henchmen of stalin and accordingly voted for the anti-strelin course. then there was the coup of 1964 , although it did not end there with a shooting khrushchev yes, yes, but the military component included the blocking of the kremlin there, it included the use of all kinds of military forces, and so on. well, in 1991, the coup attempt was also, in the end, a

coup . in the russian white house , the coup d'état was attacked again, and there is nothing unusual about coups in russia. on the contrary, it is a very typical thing, when summer comes, it is older. it happens because uh, you can say that it's more than that coups in russia are very predictable but we are not about them, we will even find out about some of them there in a few months, maybe in a week . maybe, somewhere, putin will not show videos with them and so on until everything is in a glass until they are these spiders in a jar they will not decide who is there, who has to do what, that is why i believe that there are grounds for coups well, when the lows do not want and the highs can

not they still can't organize a normal mutiny because they are so atomized and permeated by this system that they are a step to the left and a step to the right, and in fact they are suppressed to the maximum extent, that is, the system has not yet broken down to such an extent that they cannot be fully controlled, but one day the system will go to such an extent that it cannot be controlled the elite, what do they say, and so on, and so on, this will be a very good sign , because now when this simenyan starts to say that she is from the common people, that she is not from the top, that she is not the leader of the mayor, what is that ? in general, super simple people, and when nina matvii or this matvienko, i even apologize for standing with a glass, what half of a glass is valka half a glass when she says that it is possible that putin does not need to speak, this is uh, well, if the demonstration of the fact that even summer

is sold little by little, she no, it does not compare when they are against each other, when kadyrov, for example, against the generals, when now there will be a response from the generals to kadyr, for example, this will be a sign that the system is beginning to enter such a more serious resonance and dissension. and when they will start to act and not will be able to control the special services or will the special services be completely disintegrated when this top starts to act autonomously, then we will see and then by the way this coup can happen, well technologically it is extremely simple it can be and the snuffbox can just be his someone in the toilet sorry will close putin and that's it and on this coup, well , this can happen, and er, there can be a disconnection of his bunker, for example, from communication. yes, some soldiers there took and disconnected his bunker from communication, he will go to the mountain and this can happen it is quite easy and simple technologically,

but for this i emphasize once again that the top must have at least some degree of trust in each other, the russian top is so degraded, that is why the soviet union fell like that 7 million communists there or 20 million communists 7 million kgb and troops and it fell apart all due to the fact that there is no trust, if there is no trust between each other, everything simply falls apart. this is what is happening. you have now mentioned margarita semenyana, this russian propagandist, we will now listen to her, this is very i'll explain why and let's try to comment on her, here's what she said. after those solemn events in the kremlin and on red square, after the fake accession, after the fake referendums in ukraine, how people stood for the anthem in this big royal palace, and i assure you a huge number of these people about themselves, as

i sang your song from the indestructible republics of the free, paid for the new great russia. yes, now the will of the people will create a united mighty soviet union, the soviet union, when i was 11 summer, but i still sing this hymn and its words, as it is impossible from the moment of discovery, it is precisely his words. i am simply asking comrades generals not to compare this hymn to our faith and our desperate desire of these people to leave this territory with us and return to normality already even more russia what mr. oleksandr said that the attempt to save the soviet union was the creation of the cpsu, by the way , our colleague vitalik portnikov said about this that this cpsu was created in a hurry, it became one of the reasons and accelerated the collapse of the soviet union to the union, this is an attempt to grab hold of the soviet anthem, for some soviet allies, compare rud , all in a row, this is already happening, while

putin gave his speech and told him that the soviet union would not be restored. well, that is, he almost sees something, something different. of the kremlin vita, do they understand what they are grasping for, or now it doesn't matter what they understand, what matters is what to show people and to what and to what, so to speak, to call them, how do you see it? please, look badly, russians to a large extent, they live in the paradigm of a surrounded fortress , and that is why in them the theme of the great patriotic war, that is, the soviet-german war, it dominates all others, they are very actively twisting it and twisting it all this time, and the dehumanization of ukrainian not only the military, but also ukrainian citizens is part of state policy in public opinion the 100th anniversary of the formation of the soviet union is also approaching,

although in fact the so-called union treaty was signed in the summer of 1923. сейчас was it december 30, 1922, and this is also putin's modus operandi. do you remember that he says that the collapse of the soviet union is the biggest geopolitical catastrophe of the 20th century? i think it will continue. that is why we need to take this into account as effectively as possible and remind the world of what putin is going to do, we must draw clear and understandable parallels and not count on any mutiny

within putin's environment. the environment has become much worse, the average russian has already become much worse, as of now, no, they are just entering this process and we must accompany it with information. we must say that russia will disintegrate and only the disintegration of russia and its dismantling are the guarantee of european security, because russia by its actions during the last seven in a month and a half, she has actually placed herself outside european and world laws, outside the norms of international law, these are obvious absolute realities, this must be taken into account once again, we have and must talk about the fact that at the moment there is no need to be afraid to live outside the imperial ideology, but

let's not be naive and let's not think that it is possible to turn off the russian world once and for all, it's impossible, even the west does not always accept it, because in the same place, for how many years dostoevsky was admired a little bit of yesterday the story with the green mask can be interpreted in different ways, but here is this referendum. let's make concessions to russia. well, they say that elon musk had some kind of marketing goal, do you have something else here with twitter, but this you know everything is a dead poultice well, this is just a vivid example of the fact that russian peace can be everywhere, or if it can be well paid, we don't know. we haven't heard or seen it, but well, well paid for one of the richest people in the world - everyone can to have our own interests, as they say, well , we won't, i'm not saying we didn't hold a candle, yes , i still want to say something else, that we should aim for the long game. if we

have the attitude that russia is already on at the threshold of the abyss, she just needs to be pushed. it's not quite so it is reminiscent of russia during the first world war, this is also true, but the war lasted for more than one year in the russian empire, and the stratification of its society did not happen all at once, therefore, it is a long game and it needs, let's say, the formation of a baltic-black sea narrative that proves which unites other peoples together with ukraine so that we can speak and appeal also to tens of millions of people who know and realize what evil the criminal russian government can bring and these are facts that must be used and about to speak, that is, in fact, the dehumanization of ukrainians

, in fact, the sanction for war crimes on the territory of ukraine, in fact, looting, the possibility of looting, etc., but look, russia now has no allies, in fact, with the exception of belarus, only lukashenko with him as a pocket dog, but by the way, i am opposed to putting a consistent opponent of that to put the russians and belarusians on the same level because it only strengthens the russian position, we should also realize this. and all other allies of the soviet union, for example, it already turned away from russia, it simply does not exist, with the exception of belarus itself, uh, they listened to putin in samarkand, and through one ear they are not their allies . at the moment, putin is interfering because he threatens stability, if there is

an idea in russia that they can scare someone with nuclear weapons and the whole world is simply on the back foot and will force ukraine to do something, then this is a completely wrong calculation. but such a scenario is really some kind of action, you understand, some kind of action that the club will carry out in russia and which can cause the indignation of the whole world, it can just speed up our russia, we should talk about myrnyi, but keep in our calculations that only a military defeat of the russian federation can cause him, here is this russian jester who played by the way, the jester of tsar ivan the terrible in the movie tsars with yankovsky, do you remember this one great movie, uh, yankovsky is gone, and the actor who played the tsar and ivan the terrible is gone too, but in globistin, there was a clown playing there, so here he is, here he was, by the way, he was swinging on this one on red square , although i don’t even understand if it’s possible

they specifically say that the word hoyda, well, this is a ukrainian who got it from ancient russia in the form of the word haydatami, hey hayda is gone, they say in ukraine, but they don’t say that in ukraine, they have hoyda , but this cry of hoyda was used by the oprichniks when they went there to kill the boyar, uh, rape their women, cut out the entire staircase, children there, burn the houses, they shouted hoyda well, this guy basically shouted the tsar's oprichniks, yes, by the way, he said such a phrase about what you said russia over the abyss, and the guy just said what russia standing over the abyss and you just have to push it with one foot so that it already fell to the bottom and then rose up, russia really fell and rose and the revolution and uh, let's remember the year 1612, when there was also turmoil, turmoil for a while, after which it rose and the soviet union supposedly fell apart again somehow she cut out with the help of the west, of course, and western money, but now we just need to make it fall, but not rise in the military form in which it is, but before that, i have literally 10 minutes, i will ask such a question, and we will already

let's finish, president volodymyr zelenskyi said a very good phrase, he submitted an application to nato, my friend. by the way, it is important that he said that ukraine will conduct negotiations with russia, but with another president, and i understand that this is not only zelenskyi's position, the position of the western world, that's what the western world and ukraine, and with which, in principle, it will be necessary to negotiate anyway, in any case, they no longer see putin as a negotiator, and they obviously do not see whether this is not a signal to the elite that something needs to be thought about, because i think all of them want to continue to live in russia, use its resources and get rich and disappear from the face of the earth in the course of a nuclear war. i think there is no special desire there, mr. oleksandr, please. well, first of all, i would like to say very clearly that russia is not russia, there is no russia, let's go well, this is absolutely wrong, in the context, they did not move what came to us from russia, haida. and they are not russia, they are just trying to rewrite everything for themselves, this is such a

thing. well, in general, according to some data, the word is tatar in general, that is, it could autonomously come to us er or even in very ancient times and autonomous to russia and from the tatars from some tatars to us from other tatars to russia, it is also not excluded, but philologists meet there, but not in words, that is, they are really russians, really determined for a genocidal war against ukrainians, i said it for a very long time. so when many did not believe it, but in fact it is so. why is this happening? it is very simple, very simple explanation, elementary explanation in russia. stone cave age when they devoured each other one and a half thousand years ago, it is possible even earlier in some areas 300 years ago and in our country, the stone age ended six thousand years ago, and this is a big difference of 5 or 4000 years in this evolution , that is, they act exactly the same way as people acted in the

stone age, that is, their evolution doesn't go as fast as evolution, well, that is, they jumped from the stone age straight into communism, yes, or into advanced socialism, and therefore to expect some moral changes from them is not an event, an event, only when they understand that they are in trouble by saying words when will they go and understand that they are taking a risk it is real that they risk under ukrainian bullets and heimers more than they risk from their own government, when they understand that the pressure from ukraine and the west is so strong and so powerful at once, the whole structure will collapse, moreover, look at what this semenyan says, she wants a return to normality this is already called the recognition that the situation is now abnormal and she wants to turn everything back and

there will be more and more such people. she does not understand that for russia there will be no normality for their new normality will be formed later, and this normality will include pogroms there, it will include thefts, it will include robberies throughout the country, it will include a lot of deserters who will go around with weapons to take from people like the people of semen. in fact, everything they have is their new normality. do you understand ? she hasn't understood this yet, she wants to roll everything back. like the swamps when she went there to europe. something there for shopping and so on. no. they all drove by. goodbye, and when we say that they can't intimidate uh with nuclear weapons, well, look the mask was intimidated, yes, masks, well, you can say that he was not influenced by any russian culture, because, well, russian culture is especially modern, it is nothing at all, it is a pittance, a tiny part of the world's cultural achievements. if we talk about the 19th century,

well, it is 1% of the world's achievements, there was something else a now it's nothing at all, that's why they're afraid of only these iron russian soft power in russian soft power is no longer there, it just really evaporated because there is a moral such a huge demonstration of what russia can do nothing neither in the army, nor in weapons, nor in normal life, they can only torture people, but they can organize torture camps, that's the only thing russia can do is torture defenseless people. you finish the thought because i still want mr. yevhen to have time for that our politics and flights and politics thank god the pentagon is about how to win this war, well this war is won by force by force simply by the collision of our brave er soldiers with their soldiers not brave not all that

it ends as it continues in the north , it is not relevant right this minute and second, and since very recently, a couple of days ago, the entire territory of kharkiv oblast was liberated, yevgeny, i have another question for you, too, exactly what putin was asked out of context and zelensky said that it will be agreed only with another president is not in principle well, we will see how it will happen there in november, it will happen precisely from the big twenty, but in principle they understood that putin does not want it or not, or it will not push the elite to look for another one after all candidacy with how it will be able to somehow get out of this situation with losses, of course, please. i think that putin will not be invited to the g20 itself at the ball, and it will be a consolidated opposition of its members. this is what someone will say out loud, who will simply support it, because what russia is doing well, actually you cannot be ignored without an answer without without

a reaction, but i will repeat the point about which i have already said that the question is not in putin himself as the personification of the russian government. of the russian political elite to destroy ukraine has not changed, it has not changed at all, we must remember this. therefore, we must prove to our fellow citizens and our partners that russia must be dismantled. it must not exist in its current form and it must no longer threaten anyone in this world and when we solve this issue, we will be able to answer many other questions, including how ukraine will become a member of nato, how ukraine will become a member of the eu, because

we continue to need consolidation. we we continue to support the armed forces of ukraine in their fight against the aggressor, and the issue of restoring territorial integrity is only a matter of time. i think that not only the vast majority of ukrainian citizens, more than 90%, but also a significant part of the world elite already understand this, whether it will be done is simply a question of that if this is done and russia is not destroyed, a wave of revanchism is waiting for us from that side and it doesn't matter if putin stays there or someone else appears, this is not kipling after all. we ourselves talk about the fact that russian citizens do not decide anything, all that they were able to decide was to flee to a country they despised instead of going out into the streets and protesting against the mobilization

, so er, i think that russia in general has become a logical state and one of the main consequences these two 22 days of war because the whole world saw that the state filet is russia and not ukraine and the degree of this filet will only increase. thank you very much yevgeny magadan, the executive director of the institute of world politics oleksandr paliy was with us and the hundred very thank you for participating. thank you for your comments . i wish you a good day. well, dear viewers, i will say that the russians, after all, aside from the question of where you led us as the last hero, they have to ask themselves one more thing, as they say. the eternal russian question was voiced by dostoevsky's hero of his novel crimes and punishments by radion raskolnikov, the creature is tiring, or do i have rights, so far they are a creature of the state, well, i have rights, and killing an old woman is not a real name. i think it is better to kill some old grandfather who is sitting there alone this gave a much different effect. well, be with the

press, like ours, follow us on social networks, on youtube, comment, uh, also write to me on facebook, uh, suggest your topics so that you would be interested in listening. we will talk. we will activate, update all topics and contribute. so that russia in this form disappears, then we will live, be with espresso and there will be something until the evening . have a good day. take care, we are looking for 14-year-old hanna paliy. nothing is known about the fate of this girl for more than 6 months. unfortunately, there are no details. travel, disappearance, also deception, i only know that when the war began, the child was in kharkiv oblast, in the city of izyum, contact with her was cut off on march 7, that is, even before the russians entered the city, now

izyum has been deoccupied, but paliya does not have the requested information at all, that is why i am very please, especially residents of izyum, look carefully at the photo, she has beautiful blond hair and dark eyes, she looks like a girl plus or minus for her 14 years, if anyone suddenly saw her or knows where she might be now, do not delay, call us on the hotline service search for children magnolia by short number 116,000,000 calls from any mobile operator are free or write to the chat bot of the search for children service in telegram this is only one story of a missing child in total in more than seven months of war we received about two thousand requests for help in tracing luckily mostly most of the children have already been found, but the fate of many remains unknown, especially in the temporarily occupied territories, where the work of the police is virtually paralyzed, from where it is impossible to leave. however, there are problems with communication in some places, people who cannot

to find their own children, they don’t even know what to do. where to turn if suddenly you find yourself in a similar situation and have no idea how to act. call the short number 116 000 or write to the chat bot service of the search for children in telegram. here you will be given all the necessary advice. what i want to tell you is amazing imagine the story of five-year-old sofiyka holinska, the girl lived in odesa, in the city of balta, disappeared in september 2020, it is scary to even imagine what her mother feels, who has not known anything about her fate for almost two years daughter, the woman can only guess what her child looks like now, because the last time she saw sofiyka was when she was only 3 1/2 years old, the will of her child, what condition is she in?

1.20 she has pigeons, please, she was dressed for the last time, a little bit, how many, uh, new human ones are expensive, little mannequins and who has tails all in the 20th year of course, in almost two years, sofiyka has grown up and changed, but i don't think that it is so drastic that it is impossible for her so please be very careful to identify it look closely at her face, the girl has big blue eyes and light blond hair, the approximate height is 110-120 cm in these photos, she is about three years old, and this is one of the last pictures, where sofia is about 3 1/2, of course, the girl's mother also has a video of her daughter, i asked a few files let's review them as well