well, russia will simply stop supplying them too generally to its empire with competition from which everything depends on it, i think to some extent i really believe it myself, but today the market is able to live without russian oil, this is very important and of course oil in such a case if the russian resource its market nozzles if putin completely takes away his oil, then oil will cost more , of course, because the countries of the middle east will have to invest resources in order to increase production, but the world can do without it maybe, that is, we all reached this limit and then this is perfectly understandable, and therefore out russia without money from the sale of oil is unlikely to do, that is, without money from the sale of gas so this is one story because gas was mostly used by russia as a weapon, a tool is blackmailed as a commodity and exactly without

money, it is unlikely that is why i think that russia will sell this resource, it will not go anywhere, and even if it happens that they will not sell, then this winter the world will survive without russian oil. well, i have already read that in sakhalin is such a reliable source komsomolskaya pravda well, in sakhalin, mobilized families are given 5 kg of fish, so they mobilized, but there is also compensation for 5 kg of fish, and they still have surplus profits from oil. i think what will happen next when they are from this oil-eater this is how much up to 60% of the gdp does this export of gas and oil seem to me to be a bright reflection today. this is the very near future that awaits putin and the youth who have absolutely no opportunity to get a

job and no future in the country ah, people who can't go to the city center in this geranium with a more or less expensive phone, that is , you can't go out there with an iphone because you can be robbed by tanks one day, the only one remark , iran is still an ancient civilization, an ancient country, a cultural country, as it were it was not like that but on the one hand yes on the other hand everything will be worse in russia in russia well listen if there are fish in the evening if fish will be given not only in sakhalin but in other regions of russia and fish it affects the work of the brain can really russians are getting wiser there will not be enough fish for everyone, then it is not caught there at all. and what will they give in kaluga, what will they give in karaganda? well, you should have asked where it is good to have less of that. okay, ma'am. thank you very much. we are trying to continue our

morning test on such a cheerful note, and there is zagreb with us is the legal representative of the antimonopoly committee of ukraine in 15-19 years. thank you very much for this conversation. we talked a little about sanctions. we talked a little about the resignation of kirill shevchenko . the 95th quarter was generally terrible and made fun of the moment when her car crashed there in london hahaha they burned her house it was very funny the person who saved the ukrainian banking system it was very funny that she was being mocked then there was this mr. yakiv smolii who was very bad to whom they gave and for well, i don't know for whom, for the authorities, probably later and to whom they gave awards there, the best bankers of europe and the central east, etc. it turned out that he was also bad in the end, he had something wrong with his health aa but again, the man showed himself well and received a lot

of compliments from his colleagues in the west for having managed to hold the hryvnia exchange rate in extremely difficult conditions, stabilize it and the russian ruble in our country is now worth 30 kopecks, well, the real exchange rate. this is it . this is our country. it is all destroyed and destroyed, but we are holding the course and it is great. in fact, the steps taken were professional and good. we don’t know what will happen next. the vice-president of the chamber of commerce and industry of ukraine and members of the ukrainian business council ah, mr. mykhayler, we are glad to see you. good morning. everything will be fine. and only good. it simply cannot be in any other way, because thoughts are material, what we think about and what happens. how are you ? in general, do you think for the chamber of commerce and industry for its members how important is the stability of the hryvnia exchange rate? what are your considerations

and do you understand the macro-financial policy of the national bank? this is such a traditional dispute. i call it fetishization of the dollar exchange rate. among the population is considered to be one of the indicators that everything is good when the dollar exchange rate is stable, and every government since the first years of independence, especially when more or less late in the bush, remember, there was such a more or less stabilization said and what are you going through, the dollar is already standing the dollar is not growing, although this is not entirely correct . and the assessment is because if we are export-oriented, then one of my colleagues at the ministry of economy says that mild inflation is an intelligence locomotive for an export-oriented economy, on the contrary, what the weaker the national currency is, the more you don't receive and the more interested in exports, so i wouldn't make such a fetish that if the dollar stands, it's all good, really, everything should reflect the processes that take place in the economy, but i wanted to go back a little, my colleague agia, with whom

we will have very difficult relations, we were on one side of the barricade, then on different sides of the bdk, where when she was at the antimonopoly committee, she spoke for iran, you know, in my opinion, it was the end of the 17th or the beginning of the 18th year, we are when the americans loosened up sanctions, we took a business delegation there, it was quite an interesting trip. and we compared the situation with russia, of course, you are absolutely right. you said, i support you. you ca n’t compare iran and russia. it’s absolutely different. different countries, er, and ideologically. different countries, one way or the other. was in iran, i completely understand the position, it is not acceptable for us, we do not support radical islamism , which exists there, but it exists and it is supported by the main mass of the population, so that there are problems in the youth, they were there then and there are now, but another point is that regarding our conversation today, we were taken 70 km from tehran. they have e partas, that's what i think it's

called an industrial park where they offered scientists from all over the world to come and work and created ideal conditions for this. and then they told us, they say, you know, we are on in contrast to the russians since 1979, when the velesantsi did not talk about import substitution against them. and we were engaged in this. and here they showed their developments, from scientific and technological, ending with medical ones, starting with the level of drugs that they had, say treatment for diabetes is of such a level. that is, it is a completely different country that works and develops. it is not in the direction that we would like it to be a secular state, but you correctly said that these are different countries. they cannot even be compared with the russians. well, but also by the way, iran and iranian iraq, er, did not support er, did not support er, annexation, or some ukrainians and

er, but they wrote it as the capital of bohdan, but bohdan, and it turned out to be such a confusion, because it seems that this is an anecdote about a blonde, he is here if i was right somewhere somewhere, sometimes, different countries. by the way, at one time, there was a war between iran and russia for 7 years. there were two dictators, on one side there were khamenei, because khomy is khamenei, it is one letter but different views, the supreme leader and the ayatollah, the supreme leader, and you remember there sadat hussein by the way between them they are different branches of islam doubt and shiite this is also one of the reasons for the war that went on between them here such a long history by the way this war between them ended in nothing by the way before talking about the very stability of the dollar exchange rate here i am zatsi such a practical strange moment i noticed that today we were talking about how much tajik workers are paid who are taken to mariupol

to rebuild destroyed houses and so on there infrastructure they are paid 100,000 rubles each. that is, it is huge by russian standards. well, probably even more by tajik standards salaries and here we said that according to the official exchange rate it is approximately 60,000 hryvnias, but interestingly, the real live exchange rate is twice less than 30 kopecks, they give a copy there, well , something like 30 or so kopecks per ruble what is it with it is related to ukraine. you know the sanctions are working. we talk. and i have a couple of acquaintances, so to speak, who at one time went to work even before the war, and i still call from time to time and don't say, guys. well, unofficially, tell me what and you know, if they tell me, well , from the outside, they say that at first it was not visible, let's say well, we are talking about moscow because russia is not moscow, and moscow is not russia. so, one hundred thousand. this was the

average salary in moscow, and let's say already in ryazan 70 or 80 km - 100,000 it was a fantastic a when you say kolomiyka, there are 8-10-15-20 thousand, 30 thousand, it was considered a good salary, now you can find a salary for 100,000, moreover, for 100,000 muscovites and russians did not really want to go to work , guest workers went now, as they say, it is impossible to find such a salary of 100,000 what is the situation in russia, and by the way, there is such a beautiful woman economist , msu professor of economic geography natalya zubarevich , in my opinion, i listen to her, she makes an interesting analysis from the inside, you know, in order to understand the processes, you sometimes have to listen to their economists, how they analyze it is interesting that she keeps statistics on the number of employees, yes, the balance sheet does not show that i am unemployed, how is it done, and my acquaintances confirm this to me: they are forbidden to fire people, that is, if you fired people tomorrow, the prosecutor’s office will come and

open a criminal case, but there is no more money, and earnings the volumes are falling, how is it done, then what you have earned, you know, they begin to spread a thin layer of butter on the e on the bread, so that is, the salary falls. was to book now you come to you happy waiters rush pass sit down order so shopping center people became much less the level of uh or what in the store fell by 30-40%. that is, sanctions work in reality and it can. i remember one such beautiful saying that was during the crisis of 1998. do you remember the first crisis that we experienced, a crowd of well- dressed but already hungry people was walking down the street, yes, now, yes , so good it's really a good comparison. there are still a lot of well-dressed people, and they still say that

dolce gabbana and versace people report, but already about this when they buy and choke on simple champagne, and there are well-dressed people, but there is no longer jamon in the refrigerator, but frozen pizza, here it is. so gradually, gradually, gradually, it gives its effect, well , that is, what herman the russian said uh, a banker, uh, a former liberal, how he positioned himself so decently behave with me. a professional can, because the german approvals are good enough for that, uh, rather, yes, the baltic will not immerse itself in everyday racism. i will stop. but he said that the ruble has ceased to be a convertible currency. and this is this. this does not prove, in particular, that the ruble is its nominal, er, nominal exchange rate value, and in reality they are already different , in particular, that is, even in a different way, my colleagues said, but in

reality it is a large, speaking youth slang is an embarrassment for russians, and from the fact that they proposed to make the ruble a reserve international world currency until the 14th year, there was talk about it, now they have reached the point that the ruble has become toxic, no one wants to take it, and before that there were such ambitious intentions that next to the euro, next to the dollar, the yuan, which came out, the russians suggested that let's consider the ruble as a reserve international currency, that is , the fall has simply passed. well, their success is in the fact that the amount of some good sausage in their refrigerators is decreasing. comforting, of course, because it means that the sanctions are working from the other side, we are not starting to live better either. although there is news that onion prices have decreased and this is good news. yes, but there is another

news. the world bank has made a forecast and said that in ukraine there is a threat of mass poverty from 5 to 25%, according to estimates, it is from that bank that the number of poor people among ukrainians can increase, and here, by the way, another 25% is interesting, it is 25% only sown winter crops, so far, according to the results, get ready , get ready for what it is necessary to preserve cucumbers and tomatoes, as last time we talked about stewing, not jello and then i will tell you why this forecast did not come true, although in reality there is a problem, and the war does not improve the standard of living of the population, it does not improve the standard of living of the people, and this is first of all

expenses expenses, once again, expenses, war is money, there will be no money, nothing will happen don't buy weapons, don't pay soldiers with them, give them away, don't feed them. and i fully understand that there will be a drop in people's living standards, and here right now one of the main reasons is how to minimally allow a drop in this level and how it could be amortized so that it would not be like that of course, the salvation of the drowning people is the work of the drowning people themselves, first of all, of course, you need to understand what to rely on the state for some kind of state subsidies , but you have to be realistic. completely different questions, other problems, so, uh, we have a difficult winter ahead of us. i wouldn't do tragedies, that there will be a famine, that there will be a lack of something, just like you said about onions, a good harvest of potatoes,

unfortunately, natural conditions did not give us the opportunity to grow cucumbers for a very good crop of tomatoes, i talked to my friends , producers in odesa, they have already started exporting tomato paste, it makes me very happy when we are not tomatoes, when we are not vegetables, but a processed product that the added value remained here in ukraine, mainly through moldova, they go to the balkans , turkey, are a little ahead of europe in europe, by the way, this year there was a big drought, you know, there was no harvest for many products. i read today innocently that hungary wants to buy ukrainian corn, and fortunately for corn, the weather is not so terrible. what are the rains like now? today they finally stopped, well, that is, corn can be harvested after the frost, so there is a new country that will buy our ukraine, and by the way, this may affect the political position, because politics remember the concentrated shot of the economy hungary, this may force them to change the situation so

that the situation with oil may be more difficult , because if the rains continue, it will be more difficult to harvest sunflowers there. certain processes begin in the seeds that can affect the quality and yes, the potatoes gave birth well, the potatoes are our second bread, and here the price is the most diverse, i specially made such a survey on facebook, when i do not trust the status, i go to the bazaar store myself and asked in different regions, well, from 4-6 uah a kilogram, the most expensive is my colleague in the ward to me she told me that she lives in pechersk for viewers from ukraine. pechersk, so that you know, it is our very district, the most fashionable, the most expensive district in kyiv and in ukraine, well, there are potatoes. the same ones that are served in the troesky region are served at 8-9 hryvnias for 10 hryvnias in the troesky region. the wholesale bazaar in pechersk is sold at 15-20 , i.e. such a price increase in rivne, a colleague

wrote to me there 8-10 uah per kg, i.e. there are tomatoes, there are potatoes, there is milk, thank god they produce with meat, there is a little tension because they were military actions on many points where there were large productions, well, now some of them have already relaxed, there is a question about eggs, we discussed it with you last time. this morning, i already gave a comment on facebook because the people there continue to worry about what they are doing. well, what to do? no don't run, don't panic, and those who are nervous, go buy two a dozen eggs, their shelf life can be up to 60 days. and in 60 days, new chicks will grow, there will be new hens, laying hens, and the price will then drop so that we don't panic, everything will be fine. everything will be fine , and super generation, then they can take the chicken home to the balcony and that's all already yes yes and maybe we do

n't hear something that mr. mykhailo answers the discussion among philologists how is it correct that a jacket is a laying hen or a hen is not drying well, dry and dry yes, but the hen lays eggs, it's true mr. mykhailo, as always, a dose of good mood even if even if not everything it's so simple in our country, mykhailo, the first vice-president of the chamber of commerce and industry of ukraine and members of the ukrainian business council, was with us, we are moving on, so there was a chicken, she would have come to our table and, unfortunately, the national marathon, and carried out the act of laying an egg and not simple, but golden, that would be four understandings, so that it would be like that, well, let's continue. i promised you that we would

. what we will show you is the last wife of ilona the mask, who reads marx and fights terribly that they can't. this is the last wife of ilona the mask, almost to the point that's his extreme wife. she's some kind of singer. she looks quite futuristic. her nails are terribly long. they're so long. it's hardly possible to gouge out this eye, but i think that those nails were manicured. she flew to russia specifically to do it, because it's only there. there is such a manicurist who knows how to produce such a thing, she was fighting that there is a war here and she can't get any master manicurist to do her nails there. and with that, she can't even notice the dishes in the house, so she decided to go read she may have the dishes of my elon musk. she may be. she may be the wife of such a rich man,

being dressed. well, not for 3 kopecks, and those nails are also probably not 3 kopecks. and in the end, to fly to russia to get a manicure. well, you can imagine how much that manicure would cost. she talks about what communism fascinates her and that she wants to live equally so that everyone is equal. and here we will ask andrii karakuts about this trend - he is the head of the ngo , the center for applied research of the ngo, the center for international security andriy, candidate of historical sciences, good morning to you, in fact, to you as well as to a person who, even internationally, understands both economics and history, because here it all somehow got mixed up, where is this ilona maska’s wife, she is not the only representative of that western capital-capitalist of the world that admires the ideas of marxism, leninism,

communism, and lives as if it were good and warm, where did it come from, this is in those people who live so well there, really, in america, there are very powerful trends, just the support of various socialist people, yes they don't think that there must be some kind of communism there, as in general, if you look at the right-wing democratic party, and there is a very powerful left wing , okazia cortes is one of the representatives of this curve, and in general, these are the ideas of justice that allegedly rich people seized a lot of different resources control the economy yes and accordingly the poor cannot er get any er opportunities yes they are also very popular in the west and here we can only say that ah really we experienced such an experiment yes called of the soviet union well, after that it became clear that there

are no such ideas. they don't work. that is, you can believe in some fairy tales, you can believe in communism, socialism, but in fact only capitalism, democracy, yes, they work. that is, this is already a proven page. well, but having such attitudes among i understand that these are young people, and not only in america, in italy, there are also a lot of such people who are fascinated by the ideas of communism, in germany, in the same way. well, in europe, too, and now having a continuation of that, because it is also a part of some russian world . now continuation of the russian world is waging a war and we understand that these people grow up and then become voters there in the west, then we will not have any support because they believe that ideal communism stands. it is a very interesting thing when they do

these polls. first of all, young people, but when they grow up, they begin to understand a little how light works, they begin to face certain problems, yes, and after that, it is already very much e there, roughly speaking, after for 60 years, on the contrary, conservative views have been growing , that is, that’s what they say, it always has a spirit of rebellion, it always wants to make the world fairer, it’s just a question, yes, what models should be used for this, so i will be optimistic, yes. well, of course, socialism will not go anywhere, communism will not go anywhere not shared, but here are these examples. yes, there is the ussr, cambodia, yes, that is, communist china during the time of the youth, they all proved that these models are, first of all , totalitarian, they cause the suffering of the population and it will be very, very difficult to build a fair society there. well, let's

also talk a little bit about the situation that was somehow provoked by the successful offensive of ukraine, in particular , in the kherson direction, faneshino times with reference to interviewed military officials and analysts, and to the unnamed and says that the us defense minister expects that ukraine will be able to recapture kherson by mid-november, perhaps again, and, accordingly, go completely to the border along the dnieper to the left bank. that is, after that, we understand that ukraine will rebel first, winter is beginning, which complicates military operations

. for possible future negotiations, in your opinion, can such negotiations really begin because, judging by the rhetoric emitted by putin and his entourage on the one hand, on the other hand, the same thing that volodymyr zelensky said that we are not we will hold negotiations with this president. do you still think that these negotiations cannot, that the situation at the front will force the parties to start some negotiations? perhaps at a less official, lower level, as was the case in the spring of the russian federation. yes , she may want negotiations, she may try to pressure me through the energy weapons and increase mobilization, but in fact ukraine will decide when these negotiations should begin, and not even the political leadership; in fact, the armed forces, which have united, the people, that is, the entire ukrainian

the people will have to decide at what stage it is necessary to start a-and if you look at this mobilization. this is my point of view that it a-a was created in the russian federation. well, it was started primarily with the aim of at least stopping the ukrainian offensive so that those troops who are in the kherson region offensive forces near kherson so that they did not disperse , i.e. they waited for some reinforcements and tried to hold their positions there. to expect more pleasant surprises, accordingly, and any negotiations, i think , will begin only after ukraine will leave at least the borders by february 24. actually, no one will stop at donbas first and i think that crimea is also a very high priority. well, finally, let's say that

today putin signed his own, as zelenskyi said, that's right, worthless decrees about the annexation of these annexed territories. there is an interesting point that i understand in these documents, for example liman, which the russians call for some reason the red liman , like that he is probably very beautiful. it seems that he is there, but he is already there, and he is no good. this pushylin is the named head of the republic himself. he said that we will soon take him back. well, i don't know why i'm even mentioning it today well, it's probably worth mentioning about it in your opinion, how about us well, how will the situation develop further, does it even have any effect if you take into account that even iran refused to recognize it, so in general, all these referenda are like this one attempt

annexation uh, it helps ukraine a lot why, because the international community, so it is united itself, lead the world, uh, there will soon be a vote this week in the general assembly, i myself will fight yes, who will condemn again, uh, have they tried annexation and it is very interesting that russia itself got into such a trap. yes, if they used to talk about some legality of the referendum and in crimea in 2014, now all of them are all of their rhetoric. she understood that it will not work. often talked about that that russia doesn't end anywhere, so let's see. maybe it just ends very quickly and ends accordingly. all other countries that have territorial claims to the russian federation can start these claims , that is, try to take advantage of the weakening of the

russian federation. that is, everyone, thank you for the conversation, we must finish we have a strict schedule and chronology here, because the news should be next. our viewers correct me. they say that this is not the last wife of this one, what is the last one ? because he broke up with her and he is already, well, the extreme, well , that is, there will only be wives. well, why don't you look to read a blogger like gorgona bobrovytska, she will tell you about the charms of life during the communist holidays, when you had to crumple the newspaper, it's true, to use it not like toilet paper well, or instead of spacers, then there were just some pieces for me. this is the end of our next hour of the marathon, there will be another one, but now anna diva melnyk and the news. congratulations, colleagues. well, iran renounced its drones, what are the russian ones nazis use in war