i am of the opinion that it is possible for your tv channel and it is good that they are in telethons, you are not limited by the framework of information state policy, respectively you have the opportunity to be more creative and more advanced, accordingly you have the opportunity you have a greater probability of increasing your audience than conventional 1+1 ictv this is your chance and opportunity, use it and wise wise solomon's answer thank you, mr. oleg, i would like ms. yulia to react to what i heard from the representative of the monomajority, look, i want to say with all due respect to oleg, i definitely understand that we need to finance basic expenses, but i don’t understand why it is financed in such amounts, for example, the state apparatus there is the secretariat of the cabinet of ministers, 8 billion, many ministries have budgets of more than 2-3 billion,

i wanted would understand that if everyone bears the burden of the war, then the state bodies also bear the burden of the war, which is all of us citizens, this is my reaction to the budget offered to us there, i do not understand why it was not possible to reduce the state apparatus and transfer this money to education because you are oleg you are a smart person and you understand that without education, investing money in education and medicine. now we will not restore the country, then education is generally the basis for the restoration and proper development of ukraine. regarding tv channels, we have had a debate for a long time in the verkhovna rada . although in principle it was conceived as a tv channel that works in the parliament, people should watch what the deputies are talking about, including maybe something useful will come from this, but it works exclusively for the marathon that broadcasts what he broadcasts yes. and i want to say that

mr. oleg correctly said that for the time being, people simply do not watch the telethon anymore, that it has simply turned into an absolutely uninteresting product, and that's why i think that we must gradually despite the martial law, we need to think about the future and gradually return to normal, optimal functions of the state, definitely reducing those that are bloated and that are not needed, and we need to think about the future now, not later . so, when the war is over and we will think about education, medicine, information policy, this is not the case works. these are the areas where you need to invest today to

get it in 10 years. eat something, drink something, take care of yourself, not at the same level as they might have dreamed two years ago, but nevertheless, unfortunately, it is necessary. social policy, we need to understand another factor that no one talks about. we are forming and, most likely, from january 1, the country will have two budgets, one state budget, which is directed primarily to the achievement of our victory and the financing of social policy, including the guaranteed minimum minimum, but the second budget, let’s say so, is unofficial, this is the budget that should be dealt with. for example, mrs. yulia and i, what am i talking about? funding and now it is being developed, let’s say for rehabilitation or community support, and

they are looking for partners, how to do it in ukraine, who to contact directly, without the government, without kyiv, there are such proposals, and most likely from january 1. this program will work and those deputies who are conscious , who work and do not think about their wages, others have such an opportunity to bring to their communities that they take care of or their regions, this is funding for those programs that were stopped during the war, and we are now talking about it, and i advised them would look in the other direction towards such an unofficial budget. do you think that unofficial budgets will help us support these areas of our ukrainian existence that are currently deprived of usual funding, at least you know they will help only in two of my practical experience, first and n- we will promote this to our

international partners. for example, we should say that we as a state want to have five top universities, representatives of top universities in the world, the 10 best schools there, and so on, you understand when the state doesn't stand up, no, at the local level, not at the national level, say what exactly is needed tomorrow, what is its 10 -year plan, ah, because the plan that was presented in lugano, pavlan-restoration, he's like that, you know a little cosmic e well, then no one will come here and give money, because money is given to those who know what and how to do it, and what will be the result and impact of this money, that's why donors and many countries are interested in the restoration of ukraine, well, for this, ukraine needs to do such work. offer what exactly does she want? and what will be the result of this? thank you, ladies and gentlemen, dear people 's deputies. as for you, we are carefully monitoring your work. no matter how

you want it, it is possible to hide it somewhere. it is a shame that there is no access to live broadcasts, but we hope that they will return soon yuliya klymenko but miracles do. very good. what are you watching today? mrs. yulia will confirm that such a historic day took place today. today there was a vote on the resolution on appeals to the international community regarding the support of peoples' aspirations . it is true of russia before its independence. and by the way, your idea of ​​creating an administration is about the ukrainian administration. as i understand it, somewhere in the kuban or, according to it, mining, the weather is beautiful, so to speak, the ukrainian administration on the company, not only kebani, puliy syome agreed to head the administration buryatia if klymenko , people's deputy of ukraine, first deputy chairman of the committee of the verkhovna rada of ukraine on transport and infrastructure and oleg hunda, people's

deputy of ukraine, servant of the people, committee member of the verkhovna rada on the organization of state power, local self-government, regional development and urban planning, the chairman of the committee on construction and design worked live on the espresso tv channel, such regalia as that of franz joseph, the emperor of austria -hungary, are the names of the ukrainian committees of the verkhovna rada with him now let's continue the topic of the national bank of ukraine and today's resignation of kyril shevchenko, you know one of the first people who noticed that there after all, there is a black cat in this dark room. it was mark savchuk, who is now in touch with us. mark savchuk is the head of the public control board. quite unambiguously hinted that the activity of the specialized anti-corruption prosecutor's office and its

new head was behind the disease and resignation of shevchenko, and how the water was actually viewed today we have a vote in the verkhovna rada, he is no longer the head of the national bank, tell me a little more details about this story and in particular about the bank in question, the work of which he was involved and where there is a case of embezzlement, please look. there is no er-e means of my foresight, some kind of a-a there is no surprise that the president was known at the time of the appointment who is shevchenko as the head of the national bank because all the top officials pass a standard check by law enforcement agencies and already at the moment of discussing the candidacy of kyril shevchenko as president they reported to him that you know there is a very high probability that kyryll shevchenko will receive suspicion in the case of ukrgasbank, this was known to the president even before the appointment, so of course i say so because i damn well know, i know, i knew about it back in

november 2021, when the president, at his press marathon, you, er, journalist from bumberg asked ah, there are no problems with the reputation of kyril shevchenko, everyone already knew about this back in november 2021, and the president then said that i believe that he is now the head of the national bank, this is correct. прохое настроение now i'm watching how our powerful authorities are laughing, and those who gather in the verkhovna rada to vote for some kind of crap that does not guide europe. instead of dealing with internal affairs, i repeat once again that the head of the national bank has suspicions in the fact that he a-a squandered money when a-a was in ukrgazbank, the president knew about it, and the authorities knew about it, and the powerful authorities, our journalists , directly asked our government of parliamentarians about it, and they did everything forever, nothing happens. and now

that is, if the specialized anti-corruption prosecutor's office was headless and in general it was possible to get lost in its activities, and how can you say that such bodies that give courage mean to sign suspicion to these people, how good is it that we finally have a new chapter of sap that has prospects for the development of this do you think it will be blocked or will it develop at its full potential, taking into account the unprecedented nature of history in general, ah, look there, ah, let me tell you a little bit about this case, what happened in ukrgazbank, ah, what the hell they know when the war started, and our cabinet of ministers made a decision so that the state banks would at least somehow survive, so there was a huge financial crisis, and state enterprises were obliged to open accounts in guest banks. well, then in the 14th year there was an incredibly difficult situation well, from some country it was possible to

understand such a decision, although it is not a market a-a and that is why in ukrgazbank some state enterprises opened accounts a-a what did ukrgasbank ukrgasbank e-e paid a commission type to fopam which types they brought these big, uh, loads of companies, uh, or deposits in ukrgazbank, they were paid commissions, as if these fops brought these big clients , so the journalists did an investigation, they came to the people who, uh, well, who are headed by these fops. yes, that is an individual of the enterprise and these were students pensioners well, it is quite obvious that these are not employees of the financial sphere, they are some cool bankers who had cool connections no, this was the most common scheme to launder money somewhere around uah 200 million was paid out, or something says so. in fact, in these schemes, the management that not only

knew about it, but also directed this scheme is blamed, and they simply poured in the money in this way and that 's it. это от та история вы спражаете какое будет развитие well, let's see, er, in this case, the case is absolutely black and white, so what can i say? thank you, dear marko, for your activity, in particular the public one, and of course for participating in the live broadcast of the tv channel espresso marks savchuk an activist, a representative of dems sokyri, who is a member of the supervisory board, worked live on the espresso tv channel together with khrystyna yatskiv and antin berkovskii on this, our information and analytical watch is coming to an end, we will see the viewers tomorrow a-a well, literally in a few moments on you are waiting for judicial control with tetyana shustrova, where i suspect they will definitely talk about other interesting cases related to the ukrainian judicial system, be from the press and watch this week in the program

judicial control circular surety bribery and property of dubious origin how famous was the owner of the russian passport bohdan lviv he was a participant in several criminal cases at the time of his election as a judge of the supreme court kum groysman why the head of the vinnytsia district administrative court stopped participating in the competition for a member of the vrp in order to explain from where money from the higher qualification commission helps judges to become virtuous, i congratulate on the air judicial control, an effective judicial system and qualitative transformations in at this stage is one of the key requirements for ukraine's accession to the european union, the process has been launched and the reform is progressing very weakly if unscrupulous judges continue to occupy positions in the updated bodies , the construction of a quality system to the office of the doomed and at

best will take years about the related challenges of the threat and specific personalities who are hindering ukraine's path to the eu. the judicial administration there reports that since the beginning of the full-scale armed russian aggression, 85 judicial institutions have suffered destruction and theft of property, the most damage has been recorded in the territories where active hostilities are taking place in the kharkiv, donetsk, kherson and mykolaiv regions . they are dismissed and the accused ignore the process, reports the court reporter due to the dismissal of judge tetyana gavrylenko at the end of september, preparatory

the session was postponed again, there were only two defendants, and the other nine, in particular, the judges of oazuk , did not appear for unknown reasons in july 2020. in july 2020, nabu announced the denunciation of a criminal organization led by the head of vasko, pavel vovkom, among the judges of the same the court of the head of the state judicial administration of former members of the communist party of ukraine and other persons and it was about the adoption of custom decisions and interference in the work of state bodies , the indictment in this case was sent to the higher anti-corruption court in june of this year the head of the cassation economic court, bohdan lviv, whose russian citizenship was found by the journalists of the scheme, was deducted from the staff of the supreme court, the head of the instance vsevolod knyazov issued a corresponding order, he justified his decision by the requirement of the constitution, which allows the termination

of the powers of a judge in the case of acquiring the citizenship of another state, two days before the meeting of the judges of the cassation the commercial court decided to leave lviv as the head of the highest court in the field of commercial law , meanwhile, the russian citizenship of the judge already the security service of ukraine confirmed that lviv himself called his russian documents fake. and the questions to the head of the commercial court of cassation, bohdan lviv, are not only about citizenship. in 2017 , the public integrity council recognized him as not meeting the criteria of integrity and professional ethics, in particular, due to alleged interference in the court's automated document processing system making questionable decisions and suspicions of involvement in corruption offenses, as well as violations when entering data into the declaration family ties and the inconsistency of the lifestyle with the

declared income is told by the head of the de jure foundation, mykhailo zhirnakov, a very well-known character in the ukrainian judicial so-called beaumond , eh, quite a long time ago, from the best side, he became known to us when he was especially famous when i participated in the competition for the supreme the court that received the opinion of the public integrity council about the inconsistency of the actual covered celebration was 18 pages, the opinion with two additions and information because there were a lot of interesting episodes bohdan lviv has been making decisions on behalf of ukraine for more than 20 years, during this time he managed to get into a number of high-profile scandals in 2011 as a judge of the higher commercial court of ukraine in lviv, he probably participated in the falsification of the auto-allocation of cases, and four years later, as the head of the court, he directly

ordered subordinates who should be supported in the competition for the position of the head of the constitutional court, that these papers did not make the press faster for me, but there are still some cases for the future, a big person for the constitutional court, this is krym, this is uah, lviv, i am for the relevant records a-a directly directed and directly to you the instructions to his so-called subordinate judges from the economic jurisdiction, of course, judges should be independent, but unfortunately, on this system, which was built by the lviv plan, and he directly says that you should vote for the judge of the constitutional court from the candidate for judge of the constitutional court krivenko, who was then one of the judges who destroyed the electronic declaration in 2020

, in the 16th year, journalists from sledstvo.info found out that judge lviv may be involved in of a high-profile corruption scandal. then, according to the case materials, a member of the supreme council of justice allegedly promised his acquaintance to ensure the adoption of the necessary decision in the appellate and cassational instances . the positive decision of the higher economic court of ukraine, headed by bohdan lviv, was valued at $200,000. he was a participant in several criminal cases at once. at the time of his election as a judge of the supreme court, one of them is probably the most interesting, where a bribe in the amount of 500,000 dollars appeared, a person headed to the city of lviv with part of the money the then prosecutor general yuriy lutsenko said that they had caught a big fish, you can imagine what the

scale of these corruption schemes is, according to the declaration, the lviv family owns two apartments in one of the most prestigious residential complexes in kyiv with an area of ​​71 and 130 square meters , a square meter in this residential complex starts at four thousand dollars, but according to mykhailo zhornakov , the family paid much less, the cost was 7 million 812,000 uah for 130 m², respectively, and 4 million 284,000 uah at the exchange rates of that time - this is approximately half as much than are available on the market, or these prices are deliberately understated and, accordingly, apartments were purchased with morning prices , but for the money that mr. love or his wife did not officially earn, or someone sold them these apartments for half the price, then

the question arises for what kind of goods or services and his wife got apartments that are twice as cheap as they are on the market. bohdan lviv indicated in the declaration that he owns a toyota land cruiser 200 201 and his wife drives a lexus rx350. the judge also likes expensive swiss watches. he admitted that he has two beregemarin and vyshyvan konstantin petrimani, these watches cost from $20 to $50,000 on the market. every one of lviv explained at the interview that he allegedly imported the curtain from somewhere abroad when he was asked, where exactly are the tax or any customs declarations for these watches and

can you prove it? declarations or alleged involvement in corruption schemes did not prevent bohdan lviv from walking confidently through his career up the ladder to the position of deputy chairman of the supreme court and chairman of the commercial court of cassation of ukraine, and now in a full-scale war with russia, the judge is at the epicenter of the scandal due to the possible presence of citizenship of the country of the terrorist. and although he denies everything, we are waiting for the conclusions of the official investigation and will definitely let you know what this story will end before the end of the stage of evaluation by the ethical council of candidates for the position of a member of the supreme council of justice, the ethical council has conducted the last interviews with applicants now all appointing subjects must fill their quotas as part of the vrp, in particular, guided by the conclusions of the ethics

council, appoint their candidates; the president of ukraine, congresses of judges, scientists and lawyers, as well as the all-ukrainian conference of prosecutors, the verkhovna rada has already appointed two candidates according to its quota, roman maselka and mykola moroz, according to estimates experts - these are the two most worthy members of the people's party of ukraine today, and to make their way to the top , vilchynsky also lives in his mother's luxurious estate with an area of ​​more than 630 m² in the suburbs of vinnytsia locals call this area the tsar's village, tax officials and fiscals live here, the management of the vinnytsia national agrarian university and the family of the former prime minister of ukraine, volodymyr groysman . the family of the chairman of the vinnytsia district

administrative court oleksandr vilchynskyi has a lot of real estate, although he still lives with his mother. in 2017, the judge's wife bought an apartment in the center of kyiv, in the elite pechersk district , accommodation in this building costs from uah 5 million. vilchynskyi claims that his wife bought the property at least three times cheaper, as soon as judges manage to do this, explains the expert of the anti -corruption center halyna chyzhik, then they do the same thing and in order to explain where the money came from, even though vinchenskyi uh, it didn't help, because even there, the one and a half million paid for the apartment was also not enough for him, because at the same time, his wife bought another uh, toyota rav4 car and the car also cost a lot. and they

didn’t have the money for it, and we don’t know how he got it, because the interview was not broadcast in 2018 . an entire hotel and restaurant complex dvor lytynskyi with an area of ​​almost 2,000 square meters. on booking, this hotel could be booked as early as 2019, but in the declarations for both the 19th and 20th years, oleksandr vilchynskyi forgot to indicate it in 2019. vilchynskyi's wife also purchased land plots in to the elite village of kozyn near kyiv with an area of ​​2,000 m² for only uah 590,000, which is at least significantly lower than the market value of land in this area

. in addition to the huge estate where the judge himself lives, the retired mother of oleksandr vilchynskyi has another smaller one of 245 m², a roadside service complex for over 530 squares and two inherited plots of land, as well as according to our colleagues from the court publication, as of 2019, a real fleet of five cars, one mercedes-benz s-class was presented to her granddaughter hanna vilchynskyi, this is all done in order to avoid the obligation to prove the legality of the origin of the money with which all this property was bought, but this does not help , because such questions still arise, and the head of the vinnytsia district administrative court oleksandr vilchynsky himself, according to declarations for previous years, has nothing but a car and

a motorcycle. although he does not have something good friends. for example, a friend of the judge, the scandalous deputy head of the kyiv district administrative court yevgeny abv , together with the head pavel vovko, he is suspected in a criminal case of usurping power colleagues from investigative info filmed how a few years ago oleksandr vilchynskyi came to congratulate him on his birthday. he celebrated in the company of volodymyr butenko, a member of the supreme qualification commission of judges. a little later, during the qualification evaluation of oleksandr vilchynskyi. corresponding to the position held, despite the many facts of vilchynskyi’s biography, which contradict this, despite the assessments

of experts and the conclusions of the public council of integrity at this party, er, birthday celebration, there were many judges and most importantly there were also members of the highest qualification commission of judges who were supposed to evaluate the integrity of wilchynsky and at the same time it did not prevent them from going to joint parties with him, which is an obvious conflict of interest and they did not have b in the future in general, and you have nothing to do with his evaluation , in particular, i am talking about the members of the volodymyr butenko commission, who already conducted an interview with ziychynsky a few months ago and voted for the decision to recognize vilchynskyi as a virtuous judge circular bail has become a phenomenon, however, the judicial reform is designed to eradicate it forever and it seems that oleksandr vilchynskyi already understood this himself, his interview with the ethics council as a candidate for the vrp was

obviously so unsuccessful that vilchynskyi decided to stop participating in the competition of his own free will the composition of the supreme council of justice will work soon , and later the higher qualification commission of judges will be updated, the main task of cleaning these bodies from unscrupulous representatives today it was the judicial control program and i am tatyana shustrova, if you have information about unscrupulous judges and facts of corruption in the judicial system, let me know on facebook or to the e-mail whose address you now see on the screen. good luck and see you next thursday at the new time at 4:40 p.m. the war in ukraine is the main

topic for ukrainians, victories and losses, analysis and forecasts, politics and geopolitics, serhiy rudenko and the guests of his program will talk about all this, people who have information and shape public opinion, people who defend ukraine and are creating the future right now the main and interesting thing in the program is the verdict of rudenko from monday to thursday at 1:00 p.m. repeat at 9:30 p.m. in ukraine at 5:00 p.m.