where you can help each other, share materials and rain, that is, and critical evaluations , including uh, what about the reputation institute? is it still there? yes, he said that we talked about that. well, there is a strange situation, for example, now with the monobank. that is, all its founders are involved in the case of theft , in fact, the withdrawal of depositors' money from ukraine, but at the same time, the monobank remains, for example, completely respectable, and his representatives, who here in ukraine are absolutely there until recently, even said that he is the most cherished bridegroom in ukraine and so on and so on, that is, we say well, how come, but he says, well, you know, well, we have a little more like that, conventionally speaking, wild the west, that is, we still have moral frameworks , only now they are groping to a certain extent, and

when they say that what is the matter with the reputation institute, will this war still launch it, because for a very long time the conversation about that is in the journalistic workshop about why we do not have effective these things already they rest on the institution of reputation and here reputations always rest on that and where did you work before that and who did you work for there, the oligarch, but you remember well and so on and what will happen to the institution of reputation it will arise it will arise now when we look well when you just won't get anywhere, good people. well, it's us, under any change of circumstances, it also disappeared, it arose, in fact, it existed from a long time ago and will exist, so someone invents that fakes arose. i apologize, i grew up in ukraine with fake news, only then they were called lies because they were propaganda. yes, someone invents that

such a genre and such people as bloggers arose. i apologize for autopolonok and especially opinions. there were always opinions. the reputation was and will be like that. for example, i also worked. this can be seen in archival records and many other things . and with regard to monobank and other things, i will remind you that there is such a rule that a person can be called a criminal. only a court and even the serving of suspicion does not prove that such a person has committed such a crime, we will see let's look soberly and report in time what is actually happening, mr. andrii, you say that the

institution of reputation will not disappear anywhere. bulletproof vests on which a map of ukraine is pasted or a cap with a red and black flag. and here is a question for him . the fact that mostly women in ukraine buy books with the money of their husbands. this all stirred up the public and as a result he paid for it with his position . i'll say it, but nevertheless, he remains some kind of advisor to the entire office of the president, it's not clear whether on a voluntary basis or on a volunteer basis or for a salary eh and how can we be

with such people that some people really lose their position because they are responsible for their words, and other people wear er bronx er with a map of ukraine or in some positions near the authorities and remain behind and they have nothing. well, it seems to me that positions are nothing, positions that he had, he messed up. and what authority did he have? well, let's see if it will be real, take him, and some tet will be restored, but i will remind you of something else, ask the same questions about terekhov or the wolf or such and such another, so the current phase of the war, listen and who today when actually after the first time i carry someone likes to constantly hear that well, another month and a half and we will win, this is very, very

reassuring, it can support you, but then the disappointment will be too deep. this is this story, since together with ukraine we received a russian memorial and also a belarusian human rights defender, who is now generally obliged to stay, and all the people who were disturbed by this did not like the context, that is, they saw there a hint that these are three fraternal nations again and somehow you have to be in the pile anyway. what is your attitude to this story, again, i do not accept now those people who are there uh there on such a level that they are criticizing for example , the nominees and winners themselves, because i, uh, that's right.

we think we should proceed from the fact that these people are absolutely worthy of this and the award, but there is a question. why should we receive it in this combination right now during the war? well, obviously we should receive it that otherwise those who award this prize do not think so the only question here is whether to refuse or receive. you yourself say that the people there are worthy of being named, so you must refuse in order to emphasize again that we do not want to have anything in common with russia now. and our stability, our perseverance, everything proves this, you know, you can say 120 more times that putin will not become smaller or different because of this, or maybe it will. thank you, mr. andriy

, for the conversation. at the book forum, andrii kulikov, journalist , editor, leading media expert and media trainer was in touch with us. well, actually, as we announced , yevgen spirin, journalist, editor-in-chief of the babel publication, who is currently engaged in the e-e memorial of those killed and tortured in buch, was in touch with us mr. yevgeny , good day, i will ask you right away, because everyone immediately thinks that the memorial is a monument, it will be a monument, or will it be some other way in the age of memory perpetuation, i will answer you more. i think that someday it will be a monument but it will be buchansk city government, i don't know what their plans are for this. we have a virtual memorial where you can look at the surnames, names, photos, and everyone who was buried, buried,

beaten, tortured, so that there could be a paragraph of text about who these are. people and so on, that is, we will have a virtual project that will be stored on the internet, and every relative who has lost someone there will be able to go and find his or her, or any person will be able to find the person who was killed. why is this important and why this do you do when you are a journalist when you are an editor. how did it happen? i don't know how it happened because i was very hurt by the kyiv region. i understand that the whole of ukraine is suffering now, but for me this story is personal plus the deputy head of the buchanan council mykhailyna skoryk this is my old friend who is my first main she sheltered me as an editor in the 14th year and

actually taught me how to write news when i moved from luhansk, but now she is there, she is doing it, she is taking care of it, she was there almost until the end and during the occupation there until on the third or fourth of september, we met with her and she was like that well, okay, let's do it, we're like, let's do it, because we didn't do it in ilovaisk at the time, but we really wanted to, so we decided that we'll do it here, when we do it what's that and how your work looked like, these are the three projects of the first one, this will be a map, it is already ready, uh, this is the grave near the church of andrew the first-called, we uh, we shared about how, uh, people lay in the grave of a mass burial , uh, we will indicate who exactly buried them, when who

dug them up, when, and where are they buried now? the second story is a big project. there will be everyone by name who was in a mass grave. and the third project - it is a little secret for now because it is more extensive, but sometime in a month we will finish everything and we will release it all, that is, everyone will see everything, you know i read it your interview and i was extremely impressed by the fact that in bucha, which was under occupation and under constant shelling, there were several such brave volunteers who collected bodies around the city so that they would not be dragged by some er, homeless or abandoned dogs, and what's more, they because it was not possible to normal to hide, but they hid in such a trench and still at the same time folded the hands of these people, yes, there were 4 people there. well, maybe there were more,

because they still had assistants there. such an orderly, they transported people with er on these carts from the novus supermarket, which are broken down in the center of the city. that's their only phrase that they said during all the interviews, and we had to interview everyone in order to understand when who bought whom. they said that we tried to be human and to hide in a human way, that's all they said, that's why i think that they were trying to fold their hands there, er, somehow not to throw them off the tractor well , and so on er, moreover, they went to the russians several times, they changed clothes and asked to give to buy again, yes, yes, so that they are not simply shot and

asked to allow people to be buried, and this is extraordinary , in fact, because it somehow shows the humanity here and , again, shows the humanity of the russians, that the body of some buryat was left there, and his wife said that why he i thought well, well, and a plus when we were there on the second of april, we went to bucha there after this was the first day after the liberation, there was not one body of buryats, let's say so, and they lay there for a very long time because no one needed them, well, if ours were needed by everyone thank you, mr. yevgeny for what you do, for what you preserve the memory, for what you did not let these people become somehow unrecognizable and without a name and without a surname yevhen spearing, journalist, editor-in-chief of the publication babyn, who is engaged in arranging the memorial in buch, actually these are several projects that will preserve the memory of those who were killed

and tortured in the city of bucha. thank you for being with us during these hours and on this day. andrii saichuk and lesya vakulyuk. see you tomorrow morning at 7:00 a.m. we will also be waiting for you at espresso. let 's start, let's continue our marathon, which has been going on for a few days now, and now the judicial control comes to your attention. watch this week's program: judicial control, circular guarantee, bribes and property of dubious origin. how did the owner of the russian passport, bohdan lviv, become famous? he was a participant right away. several criminal cases at the time of his election as a judge of the supreme court, kum groysman, why did the head of the vinnytsia district administrative court stop participating in the competition for a member of the vrp in order to explain where the money from the higher qualification commission helps judges become virtuous, congratulations on

the air, judicial control, an effective judicial system and qualitative transformations in this stage is one of the key requirements for ukraine's accession to the european union, the process has been launched and the reform is progressing very slowly if the unscrupulous judge continues to occupy positions in the updated bodies, the construction of a high-quality judicial system is doomed and at best will take years. the war of ukrainian courts was calculated by the state judicial administration , there they report that since the beginning of the full-scale armed russian aggression, 85 judicial institutions have suffered destruction and theft of property the most

damage was recorded in the territories where active hostilities are taking place in the kharkiv, donetsk , kherson, and mykolaiv regions, the review of the tapes and the wolf case is actually blocked in the higher anti-corruption court in pyate, judges are dismissed and the accused ignore the process , the court reporter reports due to the dismissal of judge tetyana gavrylenko at the end of september, a preparatory meeting only two defendants were adjourned, and the other nine, in particular, the judges of oazka , did not appear for unknown reasons in july in 2020, nabu announced the cover-up of a criminal organization led by the chairman in vasko, pavel vovk, as part of the judges of the same court, the chairman of the state judicial administration, former members of the communist party of ukraine and other persons, and it was about the adoption of custom decisions and interference in the work of state bodies , the indictment in this case

in june of this year, bohdan lviv, the head of the commercial court of cassation, who was found to be a russian citizen by the journalists of the scheme, was brought to the supreme anti-corruption court in june of this year; the relevant order was issued by the head of the instance vsevolod of princes justified his decision by the requirement of the constitution, which allows to terminate the authority of a judge in the case of acquiring the citizenship of another state. two days before, the meeting of judges of the commercial court of cassation decided to leave lviv as the head of the highest court in the field of economic law , meanwhile, the judge's russian citizenship had already been confirmed . the security service of ukraine lviv himself called his russian documents a forgery and the questions to the head of the cassation economic court bohdan lviv not only about citizenship in 2017 in 2015, the public council of integrity recognized him

as not meeting the criteria of integrity and professional ethics, in particular due to alleged interference in the court's automated document flow system, making dubious decisions and suspicions of involvement in corruption offenses, as well as violations when entering data into the declaration of family ties and lifestyle inconsistency declared income is told by the head of the de jure foundation, mykhailo zhirnakov, a very well-known character in the ukrainian judicial so-called beaumond it has been quite a long time since he became known to us from the best side when he became especially famous when he participated in the competition for the supreme court, where he received the opinion of the public council of integrity about non-compliance with the actual criteria of integrity. it was 18 pages long, with two additions . well, there were a lot of interesting

episodes. bohdan lviv has been making decisions on behalf of ukraine for more than 20 years. during this time, he managed to get into a number of high-profile scandals in 2011 as a judge of the higher economic court of ukraine, lviv allegedly participated in the falsification of the auto-distribution of cases, and four years later, as the head of the court, he directly ordered his subordinates who should be supported in the competition for the position of the head of the constitutional court of ukraine, they called me not the drawing of the grateful participant of the last congress, что эти байти не стали настоянием прес но во избежание всё - still, uh, cases on the future of the larger constitutional court is lviv. i directly managed and

directly gave instructions to my subordinate judges from the economic jurisdiction of the judge, according to the relevant records, of course should be independent, but unfortunately on this system that was built by mr. lviv and he directly says that you should vote for the judge of the constitutional court from the candidate for the constitutional court, krivenko, who was then one of the judges who destroyed the declaration then electronic declaration in 2020 in 2016, investigative journalists found out that judge lviv may be involved in a high- profile corruption scandal. then, according to the case materials, a member of the supreme council of justice allegedly promised his acquaintance to ensure the adoption of the necessary the decision in the appellate and cassational instances was valued at $200,000, a positive decision of the commercial court of ukraine headed by bohdan

lviv, he was a participant in several criminal cases at the time of his election as a judge of the supreme court, one of them is probably the most interesting, where a bribe in the amount of $500,000 appeared . and the person was heading to mr. lviv with part of the money, the then prosecutor general yuriy lutsenko said that they had caught a big fish, you can imagine that the scale of these corruption schemes in general according to by declaration, the lviv family owns two apartments in one of the most prestigious residential complexes in kyiv with an area of ​​71 and 130 square meters , a square meter in this residential complex starts at four thousand dollars, but according to mykhailo zhornakov , the family paid much less, all millions of uah 812,000 for 130 m² should have been spent accordingly and 4 million 284,000 hryvnias according to the exchange rates of that time - this is

about half as much as i paid on the market, or these prices were deliberately understated and, accordingly , apartments with morning prices were purchased. but uh, for that money which was not officially earned by mr. ljub or his wife, or someone actually sold them these apartments twice cheaper, then the question arises for what kind of goods or services the judge and his wife got apartments that are twice as cheap as they are on the market. bohdan lviv indicated in the declaration that owns a 2011 toyota land cruiser 200 and his wife drives a lexus rx350, the judge also likes expensive swiss watches, he admitted that he has two beregemarins and an embroidered konstantin petrimani watch, which on the market costs from 20 to 50

000 dollars each, which are p. lviv explained at the interview that he allegedly imported the curtain from somewhere abroad when he was asked, and actually where are the tax or any customs declarations for these watches and can you prove it? neither the possible manipulation of the declaration nor the alleged involvement in corruption schemes prevented bohdan lviv from confidently stepping up the career ladder to the position of deputy chairman of the supreme court and chairman of the commercial court of cassation of ukraine, even now in in the midst of a full-scale war with russia, the judge is at the epicenter of the scandal due to the possible citizenship of the terrorist's country. and although he denies everything, we are waiting for the conclusions of the official investigation and will definitely let you know how

this story will end. justice, the ethical council conducted the last interviews with the applicants, now all subjects of appointment must fill their quotas as part of the vrp, in particular, guided by the conclusions of the ethical councils to appoint their candidates, the president of ukraine, congresses of judges, scientists and lawyers, as well as the all-ukrainian conference of prosecutors, the verkhovna rada has already appointed two candidates according to its quota, roman maselka and mykola moroz, according to experts, they are the two most worthy members of the ukrainian people's party to date and to make their way to the highest even unworthy candidates tried to the body of judicial power, despite their extremely dubious reputation and common sense, which should have suggested the doom

of this idea, this is the head of the vinnytsia district of the administrative court oleksandr vilchynskyi he has insane fortunes that are difficult to explain and even comprehend. vilchynskyi lives in his mother's luxurious estate with an area of ​​more than 630 m² in the suburbs of vinnytsia. of the minister of ukraine volodymyr groysman by the way, local changes call the ex-prime minister oleksandr vilchynskyi's godfather and it is he who allegedly contributed to the career growth of the judge. in general, the chairman's family vinnytsia district administrative court oleksandra vilchynskyi has a lot of real estate , although he still lives with his mother. in 2017, the judge's wife bought an apartment in the center of kyiv in the

elite pechersk district, housing in this building costs from uah 5 million . it is possible , explains halyna chyzhik, an expert at the anti-corruption center, then they also do it in order to explain where the money comes from, although to vinchynsk it is it didn't help because even there the one and a half million that were paid for the apartment was also not enough for him, because at the same time his wife bought a toyota rav4 car and the car also cost a lot. we do not know this belt because the interview was not broadcast in 2018. vilchynskyi's wife received a land plot in the village of lityn as a gift

. and in 2021 she declared an entire hotel and restaurant complex dvor litynskyi with an area of ​​almost 2000 square meters on booking it was possible to book this hotel as early as 2019, but in the declarations for both the 19th and 20th years, oleksandr vilchynskyi forgot to indicate it in 2019. uah 590,000, which is at least significantly lower than the market value of land in this area. in addition to the huge estate where the judge himself lives, the retired mother of oleksandr vilchynsky has another smaller one of 245 m², a roadside

service complex of more than 530 square meters and two inherited land plots, as well as according to our colleagues from the court publication, as of 2019, a real fleet of five cars gave one mercedes-benz s-class to the granddaughter of hanna vilchynska, this is all done in order to avoid the obligation to prove the legality of the origin of the money to whom all this property was bought, but this does not help because such questions still arise, but the head of the vinnytsia district administrative court oleksandr vilchynsky himself, according to declarations for previous years, has nothing but cars and motorcycle although he does not have some good friends. for example, a friend of the judge, the scandalous deputy head of the kyiv district administrative court, yevhen abv

, together with the head pavel vovko, he is suspected in a criminal case of usurpation of power. celebrated his birthday in the company of a member of the higher qualification commission of judges , volodymyr butenko, a little later during the qualification evaluation of oleksandr vilchynskyi, butenko will be the head of the commission which of course, he recognizes the head of the vinnytsia district administrative court as virtuous and appropriate for the position he holds, despite the many facts of vilchynskyi’s biography that contradict this, despite the assessments of experts and the conclusions of the public integrity council, at this birthday celebration party there were many judges and, most importantly, there

were also members of the higher qualification commission judges who were supposed to assess the integrity of vilchynsky and at the same time this did not prevent them from going to joint parties with him, which is an obvious conflict of interest and they would not have in the future in general, and you have nothing to do with his assessment , in particular, i am talking about the members of the commission volodymyr butenko , who in a few months already conducted an interview with ilchyna and voted for the decision to recognize vilchyna as virtuous, judicial circular bail has become a phenomenon, however, the judicial reform is designed to eradicate it forever and it seems that oleksandr vilchynskyi already understood this himself, his interview with the ethics council as a candidate for the vrp was apparently so unsuccessful that within a few days vilchynskyi decided to stop participating in we hope that

the updated composition of the supreme council of justice will work. soon, and later, the higher qualification commission of judges will also be updated. cleansing these bodies from unscrupulous representatives is the main task for today . facts of corruption in the judicial system, report to me on facebook or to the e-mail whose address you now see on the screen. good luck and see you next time thursday in