we want to be not this one, you are not worse, our startup, wait, it is you, it is an invention, i forgot the name, look, these are the tsarist philosophers who wrote all the strategies of russian statehood, and here they are written out, and putin believes that, plus these western messages, that russia without ukraine is not from a european state, putin is afraid to go to asia. putin is afraid because he does not understand that he will be torn to pieces there, just as determined dictator as he wants to be a dictator in the european or western space where the law is respected and he wants to be the only one by a brutal speaker's doormat, all because he understands that between tajikistan, china and pakistan , he will sweep the yard and he understands that, and that's why where there are no laws and rules, he wants to allow this manifesto literally. it was a phrase manifesto. it's been a long time, just at the beginning of the zeros, what do you remember brother 2 movie so it was the next one, it wasn't a movie no

, it's simple and that's about it, do you remember it when there is this certain character, this bald brother of his, they ask for what purpose you came to mean is the conference of the united states is something over there with computers, it’s the same, and then he says he’s being passed over. what stage is he now at, what stage is putin's tyranny at now it has cracked 100% the fact that dagestan has already started going to rallies the most conservative the most closed the most closed started going to rallies women turned out the biggest leaders and this and this is a demonstration of the fact that cracks began to occur in russia georgia which, as it were, they thought that at the expense of ivanashvili they control georgia in and played along with putin's bloc -

blocked all our initiatives people began to protest we are now and we are today we are just about this society turned upside down just the russians who came said you occupied the territory, sign glory to ukraine say that you are against the war and the russians are hiding, it’s more like a dog running in pairs, doesn’t know which side to shoot the video from do you understand it a demonstration of the fact that the processes have already gone against him, here is this sindbol, which is sitting, half fell asleep because they are a little over 80 and 90 there, and the other half, i am thinking of stabbing him in the back kadyrov , for example. this is the elite's struggle for putin's legacy and this is a demonstration of the fact that ukraine has become afghanistan for the soviet afghanistan has become a split of the soviet union . it seems to me that right now some elites have fled, others are hiding, and the third are the russian elites. you don’t know what to do, but this is a demonstration of power and

one point of decision-making. there is no bunker . the dictator has hidden so deep underground that his own people have stopped respecting him, even today, for example , china who feels russia's super debt to itself for the past wars when the russians played the so -called objective leader and they then from a million square kilometers china did not forgive this india who he thinks is his so they they record who thinks that these are his partners. they are also making money from russia for india. now is a super golden time to make money from the russians and a similar story that the opinion of the finns forgot the elections, but the prices entered nato . this will be the last nail just in putin's groups , we need to join nato so that everyone can see that everything that putin does not take up, that he is the king, will not give, on the contrary, it will not turn into gold , far from gold, but with respect to our viewers i will not say these words, but in ukraine we must

join nato, join the virus to demonstrate that this strategy is not strong, this is the colonization of strength, it is wrong . the european union that we have demonstrated that we are the strongest nation, this is our demonstration and we must move along this path and the fact that putin, mykola, valentin, too, and the world is against them, but we see phenomena in the world that , to put it mildly, make us wonder about the last - that about what did we say before the start of this program about the nobel peace prize, what is happening in the world, what are the figures of figures who do not understand something, what is happening, are these indicators of secret processes, is this political corruption, including let's talk about the pope yes, including his entourage i will not throw it at the holy one, but there are some cardinals around me who are known to go around and

tell false things and the statements of the pope of rome, confirmation of a little demonstration, correct 100% of gazprom, that is, there are cardinals who work, well that is, i'm sorry when he says that ukraine should go to negotiations, the whole world knows that these negotiations are a hidden capitulation, but he says this. and this is not the first time he says that he should be brought here and let the nobel committee look at the similar two years and three years ago there was an investigation that they fell under yes, they were bought as apartments offshore, yes , a similar story is the network of soviet and post-soviet security guards, it persists. is it the political corruption of france? well, what did it reveal itself after the fall of seryoga? well, let’s say the fall of putin will this network be preserved partly yes partly yes what shall we do look i think that ukraine needs to tell the truth their propaganda against the ukrainian truth is losing ukraine in the 14th year spoke the truth so eight years have passed and we have overtaken them and we are now our truth sounds louder yes they billions of billions

of dollars are invested in this every year, we don't have such budgets, that's why we have to tell the truth about valentine, what do you think of this resounding failure and defeat? i think it 's a defeat, the russian army in ukraine. what is this? they did not evaluate ukraine or did they evaluate themselves, how do you think this is not the first time it has happened to them. this reminds me quite a bit of another story with the crimean war, i would draw parallels not even with nicholas ii, she with nicholas and pasha, probably well, now we see the same well, they started in crimea in crimea. we can finish it. it will be a completely logical conclusion to this story. japan, russian, japanese war, that is, simply, well, an inadequate perception of reality, well, it is completely false . led astray well, they fooled themselves because they have such a built-up system of approving

political decisions. well, there is a big scientific problem, which is called the role of these scientific experts in the process of making political decisions, how much people are prone to various prejudices cognitive distortions to everything else, that is, the russian case will be described, well, it will definitely be described . what you want to hear well, it is so clear that you will approve absolutely wrong decisions, well, this system from the highest offices to the battlefield . as far as i understand, well, well, this is just an internal property of the current management system of the russian federation. well, when there is some signal from above. well, that's it. mathematics, you understand, we, as

political scientists, try to explain to people in simple language, but if we come to practice, in fact, it is, well, it is cyber, as in the science of management, roughly speaking, it is all described there as the signal goes through, yes, how does the signal go through the feedback? it's a shame that putin said yes, there is a signal somewhere, where is the noise? where yes, that is, then he said that mobilization should be carried out. do you all think that the local leaders told him that they had problems with mobilization, no, they told him that mobilization takes place for one's own party, let's say it is necessary and so on, yes, and why are you surprised that later the signal reached the reverse, yes, even your behavior if you do not have feedback and for example, yes well , that is, how can you no, how can you learn to play golf, if you roughly say hit the stick but you don't know if your ball hit the ball or not, well , report that you hit it, that is, you hit it, and about any schedule, you hit

it. - about a bunch of other moments, corruption, well , corruption that hid everything from ufos. that is, it can come to tell him about corruption. intervention in his personal financial space is 100%. i am more than sure that he brought him back for personal revenge, this is definitely because he dragged him into a game in which he definitely lost, and here are all these sociologists who wore a rating of 70% for putin and the fact that the perception of putin here is more than 80 will be met with tarts and loaves i think that this is what he will definitely want to take revenge for. because putin realized a long time ago that ukraine was his biggest loss, which was the beginning of his end, and what are his options now? ukrainian media space, er, all users

mean they are waiting for a nuclear attack, not a nuclear attack. about what babka says, dido says that our hen is so sad, let's kill her, and he says, well, if it cheered her up, then let 's solve it completely, that is, if putin thinks that he can solve some problems with a nuclear strike, well, then he repeats the same mistake that he made 24 well, the riot on february 24. well, for example, i was one of those people who considered the scenario created to be unlikely. why because i perfectly understood what the consequences of this would be. well, when i analyzed the situation, i was not mistaken about the consequences, well , that is, i predicted the consequences just clearly enough and but simply realizing what the consequences would be. well, i was inclined to think that a person would not take steps that would lead to such consequences, but nevertheless he took such a step, and here is the

answer, you understand that he does not care about you, he does not he is logical in this and he well, it seems to me that we should prepare for the worst development, he is illogical because he is stupid or is this a special game he is possible for him, they never can the last time his rocket did not hit uh, it was on tv there, i don't know there in some there in 2001-2002, when they were there after that, when they privatized all the tvs, all the officials were selected by him, how does keta not shoot, she hits? the production of ukrainian missiles has been destroyed, and this is the answer, and i think that this is precisely what is hiding in this, that he is irrationally searching now, he thinks that nuclear weapons are such a threat that the whole world will surrender - the first ones who do not surrender are the ukrainians , the world may have surrendered, but this the ukrainian puzzle stands among the elites of the world and those who make decisions, but he does not give up, do they want to surrender us, yes

, do they want us, no, we will fight, we will defend ourselves, we will go on the attack , and what putin thinks that he is us doesn't scare us is intimidating. but could this strike be tactical? it could be. they need to buy protection and medicine now , everything must be prepared for it, but he alone is the biggest one for putin. it is just a guarantee that two nations in the world experienced a nuclear disaster, we and the japanese, but the japanese were hit for raising the topic of fascism, for the fact that we killed tens of millions of people, the ukrainians did not do this to the ukrainians there is no reason to shoot poison weapons raise the question of how the poles raised let's share sharing with the americans with the british why not? sorry, we gave our missiles to the russians to the americans, why don't we now have the right to defend ourselves with our missiles. to speak we should not be silent now threats and threats are more than real then we don't need to

spread our hands and say let's post here then so that you don't know that these things that are signed that they are important because they are now matvienko says let's negotiate, let's see each other, will we sign some bills, yes, let's pick up the old bills that were signed and then we will start working on them. i think that we need to strengthen ourselves with civilized methods, we are not pakistan, we are not iran , we will not do black dirty bombs, but also to give our nuclear power plants. should we receive these threats? we also should not have political and diplomatic tools to strengthen ourselves and nato, one of such things. and we remain literally 5 minutes, and i wanted to discuss one more thing, where putin will be tried in the gas, whether it is necessary to create a special court, and which zelensky has already proposed to create, and whether there will be a whole queue of those who want to condemn putin. ukrainians

, of course, what do you think, who will judge and where will it be? will it be a special tribunal like this? it stands for special, well, all the international tribunals that were created. they were created specifically, just their location is in the hague, according to your opinion. that is it is necessary and legal, it is necessary to make some kind of tribunal in ukraine. well, there were such proposals , if you remember. why? why? the result of this war well, because what the russian federation committed is a crime well, because they encroached not only on the territorial integrity of the state sovereignty of ukraine well, they again encroached on the norms of international law on e the rules of civilized coexistence, well, that is, they opened this pandora's box, if this continues, the world will become a very

dangerous place, but it is necessary to repress accordingly, so that everyone understands that such patterns of behavior are unacceptable, and never again . well, the russians must, this is a gap in consciousness between never again and we can repeat well, well, that is, that is the logic, that is, and on the other hand, and people determine what they want, people want to get a number, it was again because never again, the first time, it happened twice already more angela merkel, who started with never again, makes a statement and about the fact that peace is impossible without putin must be heard. yes, she now runs and pops up almost every day to announce something . putin needs to vote out the pension fund of putin's merkel, and the pension fund is called gazprom, because yes to openly lobby putin without being shy and destroying his actually enormous political legacy, so after konrad-dinaur, the first prime minister who was in office for so long and today 's brezhnev, because he was there, does not make him

i started as a great political figure, that expert in merkel was a legacy, but today with these statements she erases this legacy, moreover, she shows whose side she sat on in these so-called peace talks in minsk and on whom she put pressure in order for putin to get his victory and look at the last one literally. i think that now what kind of court it is is not important, the details are the main thing that it should be so that the ukrainians will be pressed in exactly the same way as hitler's generals were responsible in exactly the same way as they were responsible for the balkans - for balkan crimes generals, this is ours - it will be a year, two, five, ten, it doesn't matter, but we have to make them answer so that it doesn't happen again in the future. well, i think that even if someone doesn't live to be tried together with his children, how do we die with his family? will also suit and please tell me the last questions, putin will disappear, the issue has already been resolved in some way and what will happen to that territory, how will it be reconciled with it, the territory will definitely

not go anywhere, it’s just like a square will there be or will russia survive after putin or is it possible in general, putin's russia now and what should we do with it, how to build or not to build or build a wall as possible, the germans and israel, uh, relations were built well, somehow the americans and japanese built relations, i do not want to dissonance with the general opinion, yes, what is our plan in the exaltation of wartime but it must be understood that our interest lies in the formation of states and a political regime in that territory that will not pose a threat to us. the way that the post russian space is once again formalized by some political regimes which again will not pose a threat to the civilized world and for today the answers to such questions should be squeezed out and how successful and unsuccessful are because we must understand that

when a political regime falls sometimes it happens like the soviet union, yes, that is, in principle, a sufficiently civilized way, despite the fact that it was a really gigantic state with huge potential threats and conflicts. how do you react, or can it be as in syria. well, if anyone thinks that the americans or the germans are sitting now. yes, and they are ready at any price to break up russia and have iraq there. therefore, they are very inadequate people, that is, it is necessary to understand that the collapse of russia. well, the fall of putin's regime also contains certain threats, that is, it is necessary to understand that the existence of putin's regime is already a clear threat with which no one will put up, because the current russia is an alkaida with nuclear weapons, and no one will put up with nuclear weapons, but at the same time, people understand that the fall of this regime also contains huge threats to itself, and we must also understand that the wave may not reach us

when it all collapses. therefore, i tend to think that russia in the form in which it exists today will not exist. yes, that is, and at least where nazification is fully resolved by a person, the situation of the territory is some kind of spending is a probable fundamental issue on the territory of the region now that we are talking about the territory and we will resemble the russians of the 21st century. that is, there is no you understand feudalism more, and they divide enough territories. well, when europe was created, by the way, few people know that europe is a union of regions, they are states. ethnic inter-ethnic conflicts, because there is not enough territory in europe, and not where the french are, strasbourg, yes . why did they take the capital there because it was precisely the conflict territory between germany and france , they fought there for 500 years, to put it bluntly, today, anyone cares about the situation in

austria, switzerland, italy, yes, there are a lot of territories that speak different languages. this is a problem for them at the moment. there are no problems, that is, it turns out that it is possible to speak such a language and live within the borders of another state. it is absolutely true not to worry . then to and then they should think there although i do not exclude and am practically sure that sooner or later the peoples who currently inhabit the russian federation are at different stages of their development, this must also be realized that is, the vintsy and the tatars are at different levels of national self-awareness, or what are you there, the buryats, or the kalmys, who, roughly speaking, but sooner or later some have already matured, i don’t think they will refuse the opportunity, if it turns out like that , to determine the right to territorial state self-determination, some peoples have not yet matured to this, their elites simply have not even matured to this, but they can also

mature. therefore, this is a somewhat similar situation as from the ottoman empire, an old sick person on the shores bosphorus and when they fell apart, in principle, turkey did not get worse, just as the people who left the soviet union did not get worse. by the way, what they are experiencing is a tragedy, well, for normal people, on the contrary, it is wonderful that we have achieved their independence, the baltic countries here are a camp. well , they built a normal life for political russians, and this is the last thesis that they must understand for them, for a tourist russian, the end of the existence of putin's tyrannical terrorist regime, even in relation to their own own subjects and to those peoples who inhabit the russian federation, this is an opportunity, well, this is a chance with the rest to build a life that is worthy of life in the xxi century, and not to exist in some archaic society in poverty everything should be equal

in russia, we should be strong, protected and rich, let it be better not to think about how to attack us, let him be jealous, you understand, this is our task, therefore, it does not make sense to invest everything equally, invest in our country. are engaged in. we just have to be strong defensively, if we drive, we have, for example, the joint use of nuclear, everything is the same as what happens in them, if we have, for example, super incomes, we are the same with what kind of salary they have, and the second thing is about the collapse of russia or not the collapse of russia you understand , at some point there are states that rise to the level of fascism when certain measures need to be used against them why germany was divided germany needed to be punished russia also demands to be punished today so in germany it is it happened in a civilized manner, the soviet union took the west, divided it, punished it, that now it has been 80 years and the germans do not want to do anything, a similar story can be between china and the united states, and again

, is nuclear division of a civilized state possible ? therefore, there is no need to be afraid that there will be no russia without putin, there will be russia, it was without putin and it will be in such borders . at the beginning of this parade of sovereignty, he actually did the most for the liberation of the peoples of the russian federation, the prisons of the peoples, ukraine , which was no longer a part of the soviet union or the russian empire, that is exactly how we can end our conversation today. thank you , gentlemen, this is interesting and i hope useful. i would like to remind you that the guests were valentin glynykh, political experts mykola davydiuk, political scientist. putin about him today we talked donetsk

luhansk kherson zaporizhzhia were and will be ukraine we will forget we will see we will not retreat we will not surrender children of war wounded and dead missing persons deported and displaced if you know any information about a missing or deported

child, report it on the state portal children of war at the address children of war.gov.ua or at the number 0 850 17:20 help bring the child home for more than six months, russia has been waging a bloody war against ukraine and the ukrainian people en masse they kill ukrainian men, women and children, more than a thousand athletes went to war defending their country, more than 100 of them died, the russians have already destroyed 111 sports facilities, including one of the largest festival centers, the unifect club in kharkiv. and it's even scarier when a russian or belarusian athlete lives nearby at the speeches against russian aggression, ukraine calls

on the whole universe to prevent russian and belarusian athletes from receiving official knowledge of fencing. we insist that they can take part in international tournaments only the end of this bloody war and the victory of ukraine the rules of a warm country this winter no house will stay warm the state and cities are doing everything possible to give cheerful warmth it is our job to preserve it unite with neighbors insulate your house and your apartment check the electrical wiring take care of alternative means of heating warehouses

in an extreme situation, help each other , we will

overcome the winter together.