what foreign countries teach. and you know how often people say that there abroad, and how do i understand that something seems wrong? i don’t have clear information, so step by step, you are not planning to return. the majority should return, although some will remain . yes, and after every war, he draws conclusions and, you know, we actually have a very welfare state that provides food in schools and kindergartens and kindergartens, even with difficulties, but to a large extent they are free because they have very little in such countries of the world. well, in fact, there, for example great britain, about which we are talking about the usa, germany - these are not free kindergartens in most of them. well, let's hope that they will really take the best from those countries where they are now forced to stay and then they will implement it in the end, even about nutrition, a lot of moms write their impressions from different countries or the netherlands or britain about the fact that

children can give children to school there some nuts, fruits, but definitely not sweets, no chips , you will not see any sweet water, and even more so, you will not be able to buy it for school, it is the opposite there is too much and it is changing, so there is no way to reduce this mythical foreign country, well, and it is going to ukraine. well, i say that maybe we will take that is better, and we will reject the grains from the maternity ward and still better implement well, let ’s teach something better let's teach them those people to whom we are there, to whom we were forced to visit mrs. natalya, but you said that some part will return, some part will stay, as if there is already some cut, who are the people who will remain, who are those who still want to return despite everything here with the children to return to their homes or to their cities, even if there are no homes and rebuild them there. well, the first key thing, as if i wanted to say, when

our people come abroad, the key thing is that we have high knowledge, but we have a low level of skills, competences, what changes the new ukrainian school conditionally, we know how to read quickly, but we cannot answer well , many children answer what the text was about and retell it like this, or solve a mathematical problem and know the area formula, but not be able to calculate conditionally how much parquet is needed for the house. well, these are the moments about the fact that we have a high level of knowledge and especially mathematics of technical sciences compared to the background of many countries there, in particular france, for example, and to compare, and secondly, when we come back to that question, ah, what did you say, uh, clarify, please, remind me who are these people who are going to return here 100%, about 30% are considered not to return, it was like that after the war in the balkans and others, about the height, then they do not return, first of

all, those who have nowhere to return or who have lost ah, dad especially or mom as the main breadwinners when they have nothing to fall back on, this is the first thing. that is, it is first of all, after all, more. this is the first. well, these are the two key categories, and in principle, in fact, in the majority, and if something forces you to leave, unfortunately, it is economically , well, after those two factors, it is economic migration, yes, especially those who had a highly qualified job here. he is also abroad and in ukraine it is easier to find and those, respectively, who are accordingly, here he had a specialty as a worker or a cleaner, then according to him and abroad, it is more difficult, that is, these are the categories that

can probably remain, but in the majority of people expect victory, the reconstruction of the economy and the return, we are talking about knowledge and skills and about application of that too by the way, it is interesting that what seems to be good knowledge is not good for practice later . and maybe this will also be implemented later in our general education. but if we talk about the psychological state of children who found themselves abroad, or are they already thinking about how to protect these children, relatively speaking, or even if someone already has ptsd, somehow prevent him from developing further, well , it is very different from country to country educational systems were offered to ukraine. in our country, most people in poland still went there . i know the most about this system. well,

for example, it is not very long from city to city . lublin-krakow wroclaw are also different. if in wroclaw, for example, from the first to the fifth grade ukrainians are in one class to which polish-speaking teachers come - it's actually not the best practice not to teach and uh, on the one hand, they continue to be well, i don't know, well uh, such that softer words are justified, isolation or some more sharper ones in such a separate vacuum they actually don't communicate with poles much, they don't socialize much with poles, on the one hand, it's very good, because then there are more chances that he won't return to ukraine, but on the other hand, they stay in their cultural tradition without going outside, and there is a negative here lublin, for example, from kraków, they went by other paths, they send ukrainian children to polish classes, etc. well, this practice is also related to injuries, in particular, in the lviv region, now in warsaw, for example, there is such a

doctor, karen . and it’s exactly the grandlers, they’re already coming for the third time, they offer such a large-scale program that will be online training, and that’s why i invite everyone, and we will. well, i’ll write about it and they separately. they have an aid fund for ukraine and extensive experience working with injuries, respectively . for particularly for teachers a way recognition of trauma because in every child it happens differently, some shut down, some, on the contrary, become hyperactive, and the manifestations are different , accordingly, work with them, well, the task of teachers is not actually to be psychologists, but to recognize and understand well, how big is this trauma and, accordingly, where to direct or to in the initial stages, what to do, and within the framework of this project , i say that well, it will be quite large-scale, because most of the training will be online, but also partially and in person, well, he will be able to use it accordingly anyone and i am also very insistent and there is an understanding

that if the first course of study will take place for several months now, then in 3-6 months there will be a second stage of analysis that was well done, it is still not good that the teacher is ukrainian or polish or german he was left alone with these questions that were put to him or in the next stage, and accordingly , now, in fact, the state does not yet have such a program to fully, well, if it were to teach teachers how to do things, but actually there are various foundations and facebooks that do this. and accordingly it is the one what kind of experience is worth adopting, the state has not yet had time to react. well, for example, it is clear that ukraine is now thinking about how to win the war, so according to the child's trauma, it will also get there, but foundations and experts are already dealing with this issue, well, actually, because if the child in may and knowledge and skills may not help her in any way in her life

, that is, honestly, if the important moment of working with so many herbs, in principle, does not exist in the history of the modern world, and after the 45th year, because of such a large-scale war, well on in these in this case in part of the hemisphere was actually not there literally very briefly i will ask a question there is very little time left the center for civil liberties ukrainian orthodox organization received the nobel prize this is the first nobel prize in the history of ukraine eh, no matter what, there are a lot of congratulations e there biden congratulated macron there everyone they congratulated the world, in fact, even some belarusian foreign ministers somehow did not congratulate them, because theirs, too, oles blyadskyi and so on. well, at least everyone comments on the website of the president of ukraine and on the website the ministry of foreign affairs did not find any mention of the fact that we received the nobel peace prize. how to explain it, if

you can. i don't care either, because it's actually a great achievement for us as a country. such a nominal award is no longer a nomination, but receiving such a prize is why i also like it. e their position and appeal understand what's wrong what's wrong thank you ms. natalya nataliya pipa people's deputy of ukraine secretary of the verkhovna rada committee on education, science and innovation was with us and is with us now volodymyr omelchenko director of energy programs of the razumkov center with whom we will talk about the heating season, which has not yet started, but it is not very good, mr. volodymyr. good

day. at this low start well, you know what, taras, different information, uh, the government, regional organizations, some want now if you take it for schools, for ikarens , for the population. in general, well, this period, when we had shortages of fruits and a lot of destructive power of kangaroos, it was productive to move the incinerator two or three times ahead to the first tenth

of november, that is, i understood. we can talk about it in this matter of preparation for the heating season, except well, including the zaporizhzhia nuclear power plant, which is actually not working now . capture by the russian occupiers of 20% of this electrical energy. well, even more so, your loss , that is, will seriously affect and provide energy, and export therapeutic energy, in addition, there are issues with the repair of e-e blocks of thermal operations from the 13th state of the 12 state constancy blocks, this

is primarily this to the coach, that is, only three of them are working, so the others will be done very quickly. it’s enough to finish three jobs like that. in addition, there are enough problems in the state states. there are problems that need to be solved . infrastructure is already known by everyone and it has been destroyed more than 40 + of the entire agitation has been destroyed. are there 500 combat operations going on in the mining zone? there is a big problem , and besides, we have spares. in principle, it is normal to have billiards, but only to burn a lot of coal, because we need to replace the deficit with something. of nuclear power generation, we have 16 out of 15

units working capacity, eight six can work, you know, there are already pigs working and one khmelnytskyi, i stand there, it also works there, it is incomplete, but you know, you say what will happen there will be problems. and in the meantime, we read, well, that is, notifications from the authorities that everything is ready , everything is okay. well, it is very simply explained. well, the authorities do not need to implement such work. they do not need to think , analyze, these are issues not for the authorities. they have never dealt with them. they need an official. who have to report that everything is fine. everything is fine. this is how it has always been with the candidates for the presidency of the soviet government, that is, typical, this is not typical

. this sliming should be a situation that it will be a warm winter , well, we are always lucky, what should we say, what is lucky for us, zelensky, who is lucky. positively , people don't ask for panic, well, this method too, but still, here's the question of coal. so where will we get it this year, coal will be ex-imported, because you know that mainly the leader was imported by transport for today. it is almost impossible due to ports in the russian sea by the occupiers and railway tracks, too. there are also problems

because there is a large loading, e. million 1 lord for the fact that this will be enough for us. well, a lot will really depend on how cold the earth will be. i also uh, what i am asking about uh, about the fuel here, everything is with us now. calm down, we can see how did the russians arrange again? when the russians arranged in crimea in 1 hour due to the panic in crimea, for example, queues in front of the gas station, there will be no return to this, the situation here has already adjusted. well, i think that here we have had a serious

decentralization of supplies and storage of one u it is no longer stored in any warehouses, reserve parks, and at oil depots, mostly all wheels work, the delivery mechanism is arranged through a country house, where there is a lot of income, so if even one gas station is requested station e, it will be critical for the next diversification of supplies, now there is a huge decentralization, a huge number of suppliers of imported petroleum products, it too all factors have significantly disappeared, the risk that we will be left without petroleum products, well, besides, the demand

for the next one has fallen, so i think that today i don't see a big problem with the provision of auto products. thank you, mr. volodymyr marchenko , the director of the center's analytical program, rozumkova said that it might make sense to postpone the start of the heating season by 2-3 weeks, which is not the case it's simple, but er, somewhere, but we still hear from the authorities that everything is not bad the old man punched through the wall and raised this comment to the ninth floor. there, he raised it up the wall. i have no idea what the neighbors think of that person, but uh, by appearance, that is, it's as if i figured out how

to solve the problem. and you all don't like me in principle i'm interested, or would it be possible to make a small house for everyone, well, you know, it would also look very strange. well , it's even dangerous, that's also a question, so how can one person take it ? maybe it's some kind of photo from some kupinsky, i don't know, he made one for himself. because he says i was the only one left there in the ninth hour, considering how our foreign colleagues are now saying that ukrainians don't want to be vaccinated. they follow some rules, which are the rules of requirements when reception children to school or kindergarten, ukrainians are always used to relying on themselves, they are not good at negotiating because of this. so when there is insulation of buildings . the balcony and the house must have a certain look and everything, and you won’t

die against it in our house, that one glazed it brown, that one like that, that one keeps flower pots on the balcony, and that one keeps all the junk that didn’t fit in the house, and why isn’t that junk well, we will talk a little more about the hostess, but not about the hostess of each of us, although she is also the hostess of each of us, the hostess of the whole country, but before that, i also wanted to, you know, what to quote one people's deputy who just impressed me a little. so i just have to read this liza bogutska, that's how she at least calls herself on facebook lisa bogutska, i wrote a post on facebook in the original language two hours ago crazy war ta-ta-ta-ta-there it is eh why do they kill those who you call one people the russian-speaking population of our russians is beyond common sense, and it is very interesting

, terrible thoughts, of course, but it would be understandable if they wiped out the lands of western ukraine, like fighting without the bander region, well, they are killing the masses, they will destroy precisely the south east of little russia, it is forbidden not from bander, but from bander, or are they somewhere in odesa, we have to fight. yes, she is. well, it is clear to you, and it turns out that there is a division in us. we still have ukrainians of the first class and of the second class . well, i don’t understand. a shot just sounds and it is among those people who , well, did not expect such an act from russia because they considered russia to be a truly brotherly nation and the russians to be brothers, and here they received such a blow from the brothers, well, that is, yaroslav zheleznyak by the way, he joins us people's deputy of ukraine,

yaroslav, have you already read this post by liza bogutska , about what she would still understand if lvivians were being killed, but already when kharkivians are being killed, she resolutely refuses to understand, i will tell you honestly, i will somehow since the very beginning of our tenure, the creeper has not i read it and i haven’t regretted it for a single day , including now, there are very few people who can be read in the service of the people, and lisa, unfortunately, does not belong to this list, starting with her position on vaccination and ending with exactly what you just said . in the same way, who in the bazaar is selling uh, semochki? one thing is that she can talk to herself, she still differs from the majority , respectively. well, besides, the person who is in the government. well, they were only there to influence that, in

principle, the equation that you they said it very much about, well, less, but i also read more in some dmytro gurin from among the servants of the people, there is a normal metro, it is quite adequate, yes, there are many unconscious people, just lisa lisa, after vaccination, i have this story in my understanding. it seems to me that they are a very strange position, as they say . by the way, it is very interesting. what, for example, is the same dmytro gurin? that's for sure. it's not a person who came from business, not a developer. well, and so on, but now a criminal case has been opened against him . well, maybe someday, we will tell more about this, maybe we will include dmitry himself. well, less, but he is one of those few servants of the people who has his own opinion and votes as he sees fit, and therefore very often the sun will not be with the faction, but let's talk a little about voting unison factions are also important - this is about the issue of the budget, after all, which

we can now draw conclusions about, what are the features of this financial document, in particular, the expenditure part could be noted, mr. yaroslav, the budget is actually nothing new to us he brought a law that simply stabilizes the existing situation , and the situation is very simple, and all the money we earn, we spend on the war, plus we print 30 billion a month, and again we spend on the war, and all our other expenses are compensated by our international partners, well, the budget, in principle, if if you look, he is talking about exactly this: 2 uh 48 hundredths of a trillion hryvnias, these are our expenses, our revenues cover only half and one trillion 114 billion, these are military expenses, and accordingly well, almost everything we do not do, we spend on war everything else is again being closed by our international partners, this is normal, i have no doubts that

we should not have problems with this, so i think that everything will be financed within the parameters that exist and now there are some of my uh, again there is trying something there to change some of your wishes, we will disappoint them during the war. the ministry of finance can change the budget in one minute on its own without the parliament, therefore, frankly speaking, it does not matter what will be there, in other lines it is written what can be said about the resignation of kirill shevchenko, in your opinion or after all, there is some political subtext in it, and was it necessary to take the chairman of the national bank from the very beginning, on whom there was already a criminal case, and they could not have known about it, in particular, in the office of the president, they knew for sure when the head of the sap was not appointed, and we dragged it ourselves have seen why the government does not want to have an independent anti-corruption body, because

then such situations arise that any official, regardless of his political position or bureaucratic position, can be given a division, i will tell you honestly, i would very much like to postpone this part of the suspicion, let him sort it out here, and really, this is a suspicion not because of his activities as the chairman of the national bank, but because of his previous work, but i very frankly say that as an economist, he is simply satisfied with how the national bank worked , it worked during the war, well, thanks to them the banking system withheld our payments, we all had cashless cash settlements, we did not have 100 per dollar, and unfortunately, only 41 days ago, in this case, the national bank worked as

the constitution and best wishes to the new chairman to andrii national bank, we will start this so that the change of the leadership of the national bank was simply not noticed and everything remained as it is, but there is such a hope. i really liked how andrii answered our questions from the deputies. are 110% satisfied, well, you can't come up with better answers, he came out and said i support all the decisions that were made before this, i will use the information prepared by the team, i will use the data that was prepared the council of financial stability is such a body, it unites not only the officials of the national bank and could also deal with securities, and he and the office of the president and the cabinet of ministers, look at the bad institute, we will

comply with all the requirements in order to receive inflation, and the mission should not be large. in principle, and once again, if these answers are translated and sent to the imf, i think they will be satisfied there, and that's why i have hopes that, well, he frankly says that the national bank is the strongest institution among those that we have in ukraine, well, in principle, there are few others in us through the fact that they are all political independents, who is there, what kind of person i want and national banks are just very difficult to break, so i hope that it will continue to be so that you hold firmly to your positions and dialogic and well , functional, you have less than three minutes left by the way, you paid attention paid attention to what is increasing are some items of expenditure, in particular, we have 100 million increases in expenditure on e-e coverage, well, in fact, on a telethon, what is a telethon called, it is called the only

news? the bigus team of the well-known investigative journalist, who is now, by the way, the armed forces of ukraine, and about the fact that these expenses are also distributed through one structure, which is well, to which kyrylo tymoshenko is one way or another involved, so they claim in their investigation that the people there are not 100 million or so two chemistry edits, one for 100 million and the other for 1 trillion 300 million and we get one billion see 300 million and therefore we get 1 billion 400 e-e million increase in the marathon but if it was correctly noted i she was noticed in time, warned by colleagues, and one of them, dmytro razumkov, raised these two amendments in the verkhovna rada hall. we successfully knocked them down, so they sent the final version to the budget regardless of whether the authorities wanted it or not. after that, i was

satisfied with what was left. in an almost unchanged version, and this money that was saved in this way is 200 million. where will it go? we will print less, borrow less. that is, we should consider less inflation and less debt, less inflation, no less for us later and for our children. to pay off this debt, money is not taken out of thin air anyway, construction is a good thing to remember, really, thank you very much yaroslav already zaliznyak, people's deputy of ukraine, he was with us in our etar, we talked a little about the budget, i learned the good news that 200 million have been saved on propaganda i don't know why we don't have a lot of uh, twitter, you bastard, or why we don't have a lot of twitter , genton gerashchenko, and my god, how do i read, well, i confess well, in principle, it seems to me that uh, you have to, well , sometimes there are very often well, first of all, look here

for example, no one is commenting on this situation regarding the nobel prize. podolyak commented that this is the only more or less official reaction to the fact that ukraine received the nobel prize, and it sounds like this is a very strange understanding of the world of these these uh and that well, criticism is criticism, that is, we know that there is a critical view, at least yes, yes, on this award, well , zelensky was nominated, well, but it’s not nice not to congratulate the ukrainian public organization that won, we’ll be back, let’s continue good evening we are from ukraine vasyl zimi’s big broadcast me my name is zima, two hours of airtime and my colleagues are with you until 21:00. two hours of your time will talk about the most important things. two hours to learn about the war .