er, the writer of the journalist oleksiyovich oleksiyovich she who seems to be quite so adequate , but from time to time she is shot, this soviet man climbs out of her and you won't do anything because of her voice for some reason now, uh, i don't hear about the war is it because or there were some statements by aleksievich, although she has beautiful works dedicated to the chernobyl tragedy, she called for a distinction between russian culture and putin, that it is not the same thing that a good russian is a good russian , and putin is generally bad, and so on and so forth well, in a word, she expressed herself more in this way. that is, she expressed herself in a big way. forgive me belarusians as a russian writer, well, after all, we read that in the artery of the belarusian editorial office of svoboda radio. she called russia's war against ukraine a worse evil than the second world war, actually. calls the heroes of ukrainians in belarus, who are fighting in the war for freedom , she says that lukashenko will no longer rule in

belarus. putin will not touch him, we hope not, and we hope that the belarusians will eventually express their protest against their country's participation in this war more loudly. oresta breed, a volunteer and the head of a charitable foundation, we will talk to you on the phone. what we need the most right now is autumn. and there is winter ahead, and in this connection, the weather also affects it. and you have a lot of experience in volunteering. what are the needs of our boys and girls who are there on the front line? it is worth noting that the boys they don’t abuse requests and try to ask only

for what they can’t do on their own. the most requests . now i have boots and winter tires, but our main function of volunteering now is to establish communication between people who want to support our military and those who really need it on the front lines, and thanks to we were able to deliver 36 pieces of winter tires to our donor partners literally yesterday, and i think that this is a significant contribution to helping the boys and we are still collecting for the purchase of winter tires and tires for in order to make the boys abundant and so that they do not get sick at the positions, these are the main two

points that are really necessary for them in winter conditions . and so stable optics, warm clothes, eh, now i am waiting for a large supply of warm military winter jackets from our lithuanian friends and i hope that in this way, we support the guys on the front line and do not allow them to get sick, in your opinion, why is it that the russians do not have such a powerful volunteer movement here, there may be a sense of empathy, it is not inherent in them, well, a short answer, an excellent diagnosis . kindness, a sense of empathy, of course, ukrainians have a lot of it and there we perceive everyone as our own family, we sympathize and help. but nevertheless , they are also running out of strength, and so are finances

, and every day of the war, it is more and more difficult for everyone to tell people whether or not they are somehow dependent on nato from what russia is doing against the ukrainians . so yesterday we had wonderful news with the crimean bridge , and today we have very sad news from zaporizhzhia and with these massive rocket attacks, uh, the financial reserves of ukrainians who want to support the productivity of volunteers does not depend on donations, the productivity of volunteers depends on communication skills, and well , without an alternative, without an alternative, the thirst to achieve the main common goal is victories, not everything can be bought with money, this was shown to us by the first two weeks of the active phase of the war when, in principle

, donations were pouring in from all over the world and there was nowhere to buy, that's why i no longer focus on collecting donations . still, on the involved help that is directly needed and all eight years, i asked everyone who helped me buy the necessary things and with my support to pass them on to the guys, that's why i'm trying to move away from the financial, uh, financial support, and find people who can capture everything you need to bring them to the front line . it's really news about the bridge. she inspires our command, knows how to encourage the ukrainian people and it is precisely thanks to such operations that we do not lose our spirit or strength and will definitely win as soon as possible, but unfortunately this war is cruel and the russians should not be underestimated. they are terrible and

they will destroy you, you will allow them. this is the world. it seems to me that this is a story with empathy, which russians are bad. we showed us at the marathon this morning about how somewhere there, some parts. i don’t know where in russia the location was not indicated. some local, well, some small nations russian they dance such a round dance, but they just to some such music. well, some asian music, obviously, and they somehow jump like this cheerfully, holding hands, it is such a rather fiery and authentic thing. that is, she. i know sometimes you look at how there are african peoples or let's tell you somewhere in the amazon, well, it doesn't matter where it just is. and this is original, it is an interesting material for anthropologists, and so on and so on, but the question is that you are a conditional buryat. and i, for example, am a conditional udmurt and a

buryat . it's cold and i want to eat and i tell him i'm here and you're a buryat well and so on , that is, i think russia may still have a very serious problem with identity because they well, who are these russians, after all, that's how you look at this topic, we're improving the combat hopak, another good one the answer is to compare us with no one, it is not necessary to change us. we are ukrainians and we have it. well, unity actually works, if we speak, ukrainians also very often in those calmer times gnawed among themselves. will we be able to preserve this unity after our enemy intervenes ? who does not allow us to live in our country today liza bogutska, i am bogutska, i am a people's deputy, said an interesting phrase about the fact that

it would be understandable if the lands of western ukraine were erased , but the south-east is being killed en masse - this is beyond the scope and here is an interesting post like this you think oh oh this is the feeling of ukrainians it plays that joke with them until it flies into the house they will not realize who they are well we deal with such people what to do well there will be internal conflicts but they are minors something will be decisive everything will be ukraine we will defeat everyone but the main thing in myself, but this is also a very important moment for us, the lady here just watched it, this is an interesting moment of this at the moment when the ukrainian army was retreating, and it was such a time , under pressure for more than one month, yes. and we did not have any history when we said what they are retreated but you weaklings, go fight, what did

the operation in liman show, for example, what did the operation with the release of raisin and kupyansk show. russia is reacting to the failures of its army, this is a very interesting moment, and this is about the fact that the ukrainians , after all, well, it seems that they drew a little conclusions from their own history and decided that a little earlier than before the shooting, they could still unite, and there let's figure it out, every ukrainian is worth hundreds of russians, they save lives and the gene pool , and i believe in our army, they are virtuosos, they are masters , we are the best army in the world

. to rate this, i am proud of them, i will support them until victory and after, too, because this support for the socialization of the military will be absolutely necessary, we also have separate projects for this, already in the fund, we are preparing the case of victory already has a plan well, it should be like that in fact. thank you, mrs. oresta, for what you do , for how skillfully you clearly and succinctly define the diagnoses for those of our enemy neighbors who are some kind of phenomenon. what else we will have to study oresta brit volunteer and head of the charitable foundation was with us. well, we wanted to talk about the nobel prize and we will talk about it because nothing, er, nothing will stop us, our editors worked hard

while we were talking, and we are in touch with mykhailo sava, a member of the expert council of the center for civic the same freedoms that he received in a row with russia and belarus by their representatives the nobel peace prize mykhailo good day to you good day i'm from the phone but i'm trying so that it can be seen and heard perfectly please tell me if it's already wait wait we we will not follow the same option as the ministry of foreign affairs of ukraine, we will still congratulate the center for civil liberties of ukraine and all ukrainians on the fact that we received this very cool prize, the peace prize, the nobel prize, this is the first ukrainian nobel congratulations and we want to ask for one thing if

president zelensky has already congratulated you. i don’t know about it later, but very little time has actually passed, so let’s wait for monday. well, in principle, biden has already congratulated macron . there is a long queue and you are constantly busy on the phone, this happens, but i hope that after all, some official, well, some official person, will pay attention to the fact that we have received the nobel peace prize, thanks in particular to the activities of the center civil freedom, i wish you knew what i asked, i will still ask in this story, there is a comment from mykhailo podolyak, i basically understand what he is talking about, and we too we all have this little taste that we were

put next to the russians next to the belarusians and that in the context of the war, it raises certain questions, whether we are further interpreted as some kind of brotherly , brotherly people, that we are like that, a trinity of some kind, well , it’s just half a step from three brotherly peoples to one people. i understand what it is about speech, but i want to emphasize that ms. nobel nobel committee no center for civil liberties does not think about the three brotherly peoples, we clearly know that this award was received by neither country, i have not heard anything about putin or lukashenko receiving this award, these are specific people and in the case with belarus. and this is a well-known human rights activist, but also a spy, and in the case of

russia, this memorial is already banned in russia. these are organizations that are oppositional and that are frankly enemies of the e-e regimes in belarus and in russia, so this award is about something completely different. was given as a symbol of the fact that there is civil society in three countries and this civil society in ukraine already plays a huge role in russia and belarus will play a huge role in the future and as conditions rather mr. mykhailo but if civil society in both russia and belarus maybe more active worked to a greater extent, or could it be possible to avoid this war or make it not so bloody and not so terrible, if there

were a democracy from belarus, there would be no war, as if in principle there was no and of course, because russia and belarus are now neo-totalitarian regimes and the civil society of these countries is a huge problem, but i cannot say that they are to blame for the fact that they did not do anything , i can only say that they could not, unfortunately, and here the question is can we we should talk about the true existence of civil society in russia and even in belarus, since it is not about something less than society, about something more like some kind of community and than about

society. are these not people who are very they are isolated and have little effect on anything. so now in belarus and in russia, civil society as a system of organizations that worked to protect people's rights does not exist, the whole system has been destroyed, and the state, that is, the state power in belarus and russia, has done everything possible to ensure that there is no civil society there because developed civil society is a huge threat to authoritarian and totalitarian power, this is the kind of society that destroys authoritarianism, well, accordingly . i don’t even want the question of lukashenko among ukrainians as soon as it became it is known about the awarding of the peace prize , the following questions began. and who is this center

for civil liberties, what do they do? tell us a little for those people who are really not immersed, do not closely follow the work of the center, why exactly did the center for civil liberties receive the peace prize? and why exactly is the center necessary? to ask nobels because the goals are definitely but i can say what the organization a-a to which i belong is doing, it is a human rights organization that was created in 2007 , and this organization has been protecting people's rights all these years, well now. here's what it's documenting now of war crimes committed on the territory of ukraine. we started doing this in the first days of the aggression. well, to make it more clear for me, this story with documentation began on march 3, when on the

zhytomyr highway near kyiv, in front of me, a russian anti-aircraft gun shot two civilians, we documented it, and we found six dead of people , my personal history of documenting began for a month, i was in the entire zone and every day we documented shelling by soldiers. well, and everything else, then a very important story also began - this is the story of our work aimed at liberating ukrainian civilians who were actually abducted by the occupying power and who are now in the occupied territories of russia in the crimea, but they are imprisoned, such people are being detained. now we know for 26 months only in the territory of russia where they are being held

. we already know what violations there are on the part of the russian authorities, and we are the main ones actively conveying this message to the world community, these people are not their own prisoners, although the russian federation considers them prisoners of war, but it is very important that the country can keep prisoners of war the end of the war, but russia must release all people without conditions and without exchange, and we are busy ironing this idea. thank you for your work. once again , we congratulate you on the victory and we hope that after all, the official ukrainian officials of the institution will join these accessions, because this is a little pause before these congratulations it already looks obscene, but finally, if we allow a little bit of such a-ah question. this is quite a lot of money, also this award. i understand that it will be somewhere around 300-400 thousand dollars. do you have an

idea how the center will spend it? what is it for? to be honest, this decision came as a surprise to us. we did n't know anything about it even on the morning of october 7th, so we haven't discussed how we will spend this money, but i can say with confidence that they will go to the right of the virgin, we have no doubt, thank you very much mykhailo sava he joined us from the center for civil liberties, and the center for civil liberties is a ukrainian human rights organization that became the first nobel laureate in the history of ukraine to receive this award. state representative of the antimonopoly committee of ukraine in 2015-2019 and i suggest that you watch our next story together about the fact that the northern

economic court of appeal decided to take 40% of both the poltava mining and processing plant from the international mining and ore company forex, the shares of which are traded on the main platform of the london stock exchange, offshore companies received shares under a lawsuit may be related to russian oligarchs, says a message on censor.net, and the case may be involved ukrainian oligarch ihor kolomoiskyi on september 20, 2022, the forex company reported on the website of the london stock exchange that the ukrainian court of appeal declared invalid the purchase and sale agreement concluded 20 years ago for 40% of the shares of the poltava mining and processing plant, the sellers of the shares at that time were offshore companies, except croft- service limited msword sx limited wilson investmens limited and califort developments limited

then these companies were controlled by the owners of the group vs energy russian businessmen and politicians oleksandr babakov yevgeny giner and mykhailo voivodin, by its decision, the appellate instance requires the return of not previous but new shares of poltava gzk, that is, the judges decided to return offshore the shares that they did not pay for and which they never owned, instead , the current owner bought them by paying more than 250 million dollars, who will compensate the legitimate shareholders for shares is not clear, because the court decision explains this, moreover, with its decision. the court of appeal actually ignores the decisions of the regulators of the national bank and the national securities commission and the fund market contracts that at one time confirmed the legality of the concluded contracts, this is a very strange decision that will have an extremely negative impact on the investment rights of ukraine, because a public company whose shares are traded

on the london stock exchange, which means that its shareholders have many foreign funds, including one of of the largest funds in the world, blackrock , the chairman of which only recently communicated with volodymyr zelenskyi, and now these oksana shareholders have learned that the company that actually issued the shares does not own its property due to very strange legal circumstances that have been declared, a theoretical connection may be but again, this is at the level of rumors, because it is a long experience kolomoisky looked closely at one way or another, even during the placement of shares in london, there were rumors that he wants to buy the company. is there any reason for this now kolomoisky already owns offshore companies, whether he bought these offshore companies from the russians is unknown, but theoretically it is possible. moreover , kolomoisky is much better able to work with the judicial system of ukraine than any russians. such a court decision is very negative for of the investment climate of ukraine and of course undermines

trust to the extent that it undermines the basis for any investment - this is the sanctity of property rights well, actually, let's go back to now ms. aggie as far as i remember as far as i remember b in the expo is one of the first large companies of ukrainian companies that went to the ipo on the stock market after opening their shares in london, and in particular i remember that many people wanted akhmetov to exit then, but the problem is that you have to prove that you got your money honestly that they are not stolen raidernuts and so on and the like and so many, many years have passed and suddenly we see what is going on, how will it be interpreted what is happening ms. olga, of course even

the law enforcement agencies should answer the question of what is happening, it seems to me that there is a job for them here so that they studied in detail what is happening and gave an answer, including from the angle of the criminal code a, but in general, first of all, i have a huge question about a, what rights do russians have in ukraine , i.e. do we agree with the fact that as of today they have the right to protect their rights in ukrainian courts because if we take this fact for granted, if we impose sanctions on them in terms of the fact that they can use the services of legal companies in ukraine, that they will be able to pay court fees state meetings and everything else. and in a similar way, here and then, sorry. such cases can happen very often in our country, that is, they clearly have an interest in spoiling the investment climate in ukraine as much as possible. the second for today

ah, the important war that is going on between us and russia on the economic front, this is the war for investments, for today, the survival of ukraine from an economic point of view depends on how much the markets will trust ukraine, and trust precisely the consistency of state policy, precisely the level of rules, precisely not the interference of the oligarchy business, e.e., in the work of other businessmen, precisely in fair courts, in the rule of law, and everything else, because if we do not inspire confidence in the investor, first of all, in the western investor, then of course we will have no money we won't see a war anyway, it's already difficult and it will also be difficult for post-war ukraine, but if we don't give this confidence, it 's a hopeless situation simply from the point of view of investment, instead, similar cases here, i absolutely agree with my colleague who said that this ah, a very powerful blow to our investment climate, and the

worst thing is that we actually inflicted it on ourselves because the decision was made in the name of ukraine by judges who have ukrainian passports, and various ukrainian authorities did not prevent all this either and some are even particularly affected by individuals. as far as i understand why they contributed to that. that's why this is such a shameful case. i'm convinced that on the one hand this mistake should be corrected, first of all in the cassation instance in the supreme court. lessons should be learned from this story and the implementation of such policies have been implemented that will not allow such a thing in the future, well, let's hope there is also this trail that mr. kolomoisky is pointing to, at least he was in partnership projects with those russian businessmen, this is also so strange, quite strange the story itself. i also wanted to ask about what

you think about the crimean bridge. you must have witnessed all of this. in your opinion, will this story or this story have any effect on, in particular, what does it have to do with it? to influence, that is, if the cat is today. we received a signal with this crimean bridge. what did you think about when you saw this footage yesterday? this is another big step of ours in the direction of victory. this will of course significantly affect the morale of the russians on the one hand. for a while they talked about how the crimean bridge is magical is protected from any attacks from ukraine, and if such a protected object is affected, then what can we say about all the other objects? second, of course, this has a significant impact on the reputation and authority of putin himself. i think that we know that

this bridge, this bridge was his subject of pride, and it was a symbol for him of his power, and the defeat of this symbol is, of course, the defeat of the influence and power of vladimir putin himself, of course, it is very important . final that after a-a sabotage or whatever you can call it on this bridge, we can forget that someone had any doubts about whose wings because if we analyze the western press, especially in the first hours after the incident, they wrote almost everyone is in one voice that crimea is ukraine and they did not even raise questions within their articles of analytical materials about whether ukraine has the right to carry out attacks on the territory of the crimean peninsula, although you and i know that a few weeks ago they raised these questions aloud therefore this

it is also important and of course ah and here if you look at what happened and how it was described by the western press, this once again tells us that it is not so much that western countries and european countries and european voters are afraid of this rattling putin's use of nuclear weapons in the first hours after the incident. i didn't hear from any journalist, i didn't see any statements that oh, what a horror. and what will happen next, and maybe putin will now hit the bears with nuclear weapons. he already promised that there was no such thing as judgment day, that is, they refer to it confident, calm, they are already used to it. that's why it's very good. thank you, mrs. agi. and i'm a lawyer from hrebel, state representative of the antimonopoly committee of ukraine for 2015-2019. we also thank you for being with the marathon.