the procedure to expel russia from there, because in some organizations such as paops, we are once again talking about er organizations that did not cope a-a or are not coping, maybe they will correct themselves er-e there is not even an exclusion procedure ms. thank you for creating it, i hope everything will work out for you yevgenia kravchuk, people's deputy of ukraine, represents our country in particular in the parliamentary assembly of the council of europe, is also a permanent member of the european parliament of strasbourg, volodymyr aryev, people's deputy of ukraine, is already joining us, mr. volodymyr we congratulate you, have a good day, and we want to talk to you about the budget. you wrote posts and were indignant about the not very logical direction of money . not quite so, well, first of all, happy holiday of the day with the veil, happy defender of all day and may god

protect our defenders and help us clean the earth from the russian uncleanliness, and secondly, i uh ordered that it is not released uh i'm nothing at all i didn’t write that, i just think that now, at a time when we have such serious challenges, we ca n’t invest in anything else except the security of ukraine. i’ll explain why it’s two years before the elections in america. what will happen there, the governments of european countries are changing in the same way, and now russia is actively working to ensure that the political picture changes in the countries that support us the most in the current elections, unfortunately , ukraine does not oppose this because the informational component of the struggle is all aimed at tv channels freedom is conditional a-a english-speaking e-e quality

products e-e spanish-speaking and there are no french-speaking e german-speaking and that is why i am talking about the fact that our situation is such that we may end up in e-e then the aid e will be less than e it is as of today, so today it is , and what it will be in a year or two, no one can say for sure, so the only way out is to have your own weapons , your own air defense systems, your own missiles, and what i know is that even this year even under the guarantee of the government, which allocated 20 bln hryvnias, the government has not even approved any certification of programs and in order to produce its own products in the military-industrial complex, we will

deal with this separately, but 90 billion is taken into account for inflation, so it turns out that it is 68.2 billion is now recorded plus 30% in inflation, what is the coefficient that is written in the budget. i think that it is too much , and not only me, and there was even a statement from a colleague from the estonian parliament, who heads the committee on international affairs. he also thinks that now need to invest in security and not in defense, that's why it's so for everyone. where to get it and then transfer it to the production of weapons , where do you see that reserve? are not mandatory, and all the amendments were rejected, but among them there is even an increase in the cost of liter flights for government officials. well, can you imagine letter flights for

government officials? what they serve the members of the government, the president, the chairman of the verkhovna rada, and where will they fly from? i have one question against the increase in the cost of this, and when we even ... they also refused to adjust this line in the budget, well, that is, you understand. if that’s the case, to save money , the question here is not in specific numbers, but in the approach, that is, if it’s really possible to manage every penny now, especially since our production must also be convert thus and e hm to make it unreachable - unattainable for russian missiles, this requires funds, plus launching

a program about a year ago, for example, kb лучше конструция тиберо лучше, they said that in order to make the property a high-quality air defense system , 40 million dollars is needed, well, as of today this is an exchange rate of 140, calculate it is 1 billion 1 billion 600 million e-e hryvnias and 2 years, but right now we have two years in order to start it further, no one can say for sure how the e-e political map in europe and the world so that the aid we will receive today remains as large and stable. therefore, we must think first of all about our own resources, volodymyr. last year, for example, the development of the network of obtaining public roads instead of 42.2.2 23.2 and on subsidization by the

local budget for the construction and repair of highways 30 13.6 instead of 24.6 reduction well, almost 50 argument well, the situation this year is also different from last year of course the company that lobbies this line regarding the big construction and roads, well, it's some kind of purely financial story, yes. some kind of personal interest, and then you can't beat it with any arguments. is it still possible to somehow prove that people need to be restored, so that the first priority, well, it's not the restoration of roads there and the situation at the front well, it is clear that there is a financial interest because there is a consortium of several companies the reconstruction of roads must be

understood very well right away that there are two types of budgets: the first budget is the state budget and the second budget is the local budgets of cities and united communities, for example in dnipro and kyiv, roads were quickly repaired after the missile attack, but it is not from the state budget and from the local budget, the budget of the city of kyiv and the budget of the city of dnipro, funds were taken from them, and from those budgets it is not possible to finance with the law, simply not having the opportunity to finance defense and its needs , but from the state, it is possible, that is, from the state , subventions are allocated for the construction of roads in within the framework of certain united communities or within cities of national importance , nevertheless, the quality of the current roads is sufficient to deliver heavy equipment to the front, including well, when i i hear

that planes land on repaired roads, this is necessary so that our fighters can land there . you know, it’s just strange here that no one has explained for sure that a fighter jet for er lands on the road only in er case in one case, an emergency landing because where is he well if he is well will sit on the road next, what, where can it be hidden? nowhere in a clean field, eh, on wog or on okko, yes, or where will it be purchased, eh, what will it be, where will he hang himself, ammunition in the atb, go well, seriously, that 's why we're talking about what is written qualitatively approach one question a little, well, it is not very on topic, but on the topic of how for us, for journalists, you are also a journalist in the past. how do you feel about

it ? words reduced to three people is the head of the committee, nestor ivanovich shufrych, this is his first secretary, serhiy shvets, our colleague. yes, together with him, we once worked with you too, and yevhen grabar, who is a deputy, what kind of dog did we want to settle for ? not only do we have a committee here, headed by palkin, a supporter for the better fate of the ukrainian people, nestor shufrych, and three more people, all this actually remained in it, and they started with three people, then five, yes. maybe what i saw in the first case is because our faction proposed me to be the head of this committee. i was ready to join this committee, but when i saw that shufrych, who was in his time, would become its head i did everything to get kicked out of my job in 2000.

well, i understood that instead of freedom, the protection of freedom of speech, it would be about clean water, profanation , profanation, that's why tkachenko took a lot of the powers of this committee. e-e to the committee to the humanitarian committee and in fact, as of today, tkachenko has already become a minister, but the powers have remained the same, and to date, the committee on freedom of speech of the verkhovna rada has only one authority to make statements, more and more to me, what we organized in this way provided, and so on i have my own car, my own office, a secretary, everything is paid for by the state, drivers, do you understand salary supplements? well, for what, for what? and this question is already for the leadership of the verkhovna rada and the monomajority, because i understand with them from the

wreckage oops, they are now paying for their uh loyalty because the votes of the psj all the time save the monomajority or the monomajority is not enough for us, they count on us for this well, such that no one touches them, that they will continue to be in their positions, then they are very similar. unfortunately, every ukrainian government suffers from this, distributes the positions of its vladimir the people's deputy of ukraine was in touch with us and oleksandr hara is already with us , a diplomat and an expert of the center of defense strategies . oleksandr. good health, happy holiday. good day to all, happy holiday. comment any laska, the latest nuclear statements and threats are again in response western nuclear blackmail of putin , borel said about this the day before, in the event of a nuclear attack by russia on ukraine, there will be a powerful military response well, macron said that nothing will happen if ukraine is struck, france will not in any way

to react, he said that there will be no nuclear response, and nuclear exercises are also planned there, this is already a response of a collective event to the threats of russia. i would say that this is not a collective event, some crowd of western politicians who for various reasons with different motivations, they say things that do not add positivity. i would say so. well, let's start with the fact that mr. piskov, well, it's clear who accused the west of using too much nuclear rhetoric, and he says that it threatens, it means somehow and rocks and, of course, he simply kept silent about the fact that his boss putin started this whole catastrophe. by the way, let's remember the year 2014 and when he told how the crimea was captured, he said that he gave the order to bring the strategic nuclear warhead into combat

let's say it's a turn, of course, that this is also your speech, especially the last one, when he illegally annexed ukrainian territory and he said that he would defend the entire territory of russia. having in mind, of course, first of all, the ukrainian autonomous republic of crimea and the donetsk part of the kherson region of the kherson zaporizhia region, and without that's exactly why this vip went, let's say, she is ready to use nuclear weapons even if it will actually be the apocalypse and there will be no human civilization because they understand very well that it is impossible to submit to nuclear blackmail, mr. borey, he said, in principle, he is correct, but he is an official of the european union who does not possess nuclear weapons . i really liked his position and i hoped that this is actually the agreed position of the european states, and that means, english - they are preparing and that

is precisely why they are going to conduct these nuclear exercises and he said that it is correct not to show weakness and not to postpone these exercises. in this case, they carried out the planned because they did not want to annoy and somehow provoke russia, but in the end they did it here, those who own weapons, denmark and those who, let's say, somehow collective , broadcast and give signals to the russian federation about which no one wants the third world war there, nobody wants a nuclear one. well, only crazy people want to do such things, but it will not

come further. it will not be a reason to use nuclear weapons in some way to correspond to france. they say the answer will be catastrophic. biden said it more than once. jackson, the national security adviser of the united states, said it. tony blinken, the united states secretary of state, said it, because the russians will be scratching their heads. we need this and understand that something will be possible, nuclear is possible, but it strengthens the similar and that's why i'm so, and god forbid, i'm a little emotional towards the french, who show traditions for such security, which only wants to continue blackmail and, god forbid, nuclear weapons, that's why it will be

some kind of answer from our other western partners, there is already an answer even from one of these, well, we are holders of french passports, they are domestic, compatriots of the french, yes. so what did the former president of francois lande say, he said that the reliability of nuclear deterrence is not to say what exactly we should have done commented on macron's words, ex-president françois-hulan noted that it is better to say as little as possible and be ready to do as much as possible instead deputy vice-president of the defense committee of the lower house of the national assembly jeanlou and thirio of france said that he almost fell off his chair after hearing macron's statement - this is a political mistake, one of the principles of nuclear deterrence is to keep vague about that well, actually, what did you say that the state considers to be vital interests, he said, well, bruno tetre, the deputy

head of the analytical center the strategic research fund, the analyst believes that the correct answer for macron would be that he would not play this game in any case putin must know that he will lose, the expert believes here are the comments that is, makran is ambiguously evaluated by france itself, there should have been a pocketman such that nuclear weapons are such a weapon that cannot be used. i.e. nuclear weapons, but let's remember that in 1945, the united states used nuclear weapons against the japanese from the last war with which they were already good, but in 1955, everything seems to have been on september 14

the soviet union and mr. zhukov, marshal of the victory for 45,000 soviet troops, because he wanted to see if the red army would be able to iron out after the use of nuclear weapons, so the event is in bad shape. against their own fellow citizens and actually, that is why they now believe that they can threaten with these nuclear weapons and for some scenario they leave it in use against ukraine, and this means a red line, as well, how can russia not be allowed to invade ukraine - this is not just an armed aggression, because it is in other parts of the world, and that is exactly why macron's statements are dangerous, let's go ahead and

note that the americans struck japan in 1945 after japan in 1941 declared war and struck the united states. that is, the very first was the aggressor country. let's start with this. let's start training, which we can say now. it's already been a long time. in october 1962 , there were those 13 days when the world was on the verge of a holocaust. after that, we signed ya i have in mind, and here i equate us and ukraine, including under the soviet union, we signed a number of agreements at the time. with the tactical use of nuclear weapons, he leads the prize, i see in them the excesses of civilization, so there is no difference what was in the past. we talk about modernity, and we talk about

international law, and we talk about moral things . now, in your opinion, how close has the world come to a possible repetition of what cannot be done? nato can now hold these nuclear exercises, accordingly , russia will also react in some way, and this is an increase in degree. what will these exercises mean, how will they go if compared to the caribbean crisis, i believe that when he addressed his supporters at fine rising, he said such a thing simply as a hypothetical, because in fact , in 1962, let's remember that then the united states was located on the territory of europe of its european allies, the so-called euromissiles, which threatened the soviet union, and this is a completely normal thing, since they were in such a permanent cold war, er, mr. khrushchev decided to

make a show of it, and that means placing missiles near the er borders of the united states, and of course that they lied like modern russians about this and in the end. that is, it was the opposition of the two superpowers and those in this issue , which was extremely painful for the two countries, now the united states supports us, but they are not part of this war. they are not going to place on the territory of the european continent any of the missiles of the russian federation. they are american bombs and they have been with the cold since the cold war and in principle. well, the soviet union was not very happy but put up with it and they did not is a ready-made weapon that will be used only in the event of a conflict, i.e. without a collision

, especially when their vital interests were under threat and now with ukraine, what a harrow and the whole free world to protect all our partners from this that is, these are different things and simply cannot be compared. thank you, oleksandr khara, diplomat , expert from the center of defense strategy. look how once i was at a divine service specifically for the intercession and heard from the priest that in fact it is the same feast of the intercession, then the intercession of the most holy theotokos saved constantinople, it seems if i'm not mistaken, from the attack of the barbarians who came from our territory, that is, our ancestors wanted

to buy constantinople, and the holy mother of god saved the holy city. metamorphosis is interesting and it is really so because our forefathers er-er when wars and to constantinople also because of how he behaves well this is a historical historical fact and er-er there is nothing like that but we were not baptized then we didn't know what it was well, we didn't know what salvation in christ was. well, let's say, what is christianity? good

civilization , etc. the people who prayed to her were promised that the troops that came to you would leave, and even historians and chroniclers write that it really happened, even those who watched from the side, the greek historian, and say that there was an army, it left, and then the protection of the most holy theotokos became a symbol of the cossacks well, not a symbol, but a defender of the cossacks, too, if the ukrainian troops and already later as it happened, and this is the phenomenon that the greeks do not celebrate the holiday, we celebrate it, and we follow because we understand that we, being uh, people uh not quite intelligent, they went to war against our brothers, against our partners, and now,

being their descendants. mother of god save us, help us, already being baptized from constantinople, christianity and vladimir did not baptize russia, now we are better chaplains, and what role do we have ? well, not even religion, but faith, it is probably more correct to say this, you communicate with soldiers who defend our country, what is the role of faith and christ here you know the inner strength of a warrior, they are based precisely on the invisible bayonets that are inside a person, you know what there is, you can count

what is in the enemy's state, or can the enemy count what is in our state, how many tanks are there how much artillery is there, how many personnel, since the rooms can be counted, anything can be counted and these spies can be transferred, it is impossible, this is a secret weapon that the enemy does not see, and this is exactly what our enemy failed today, he did not calculate the internal energy of our soldiers, he did not calculate the internal weapons because a warrior fights until he gives up in his heart, this inner faith is based on this, now our soldiers have a basis, this is faith, this is a religion, this is what forms the inner strength of indomitability, you understand these spiritual forces are difficult to explain. as a

christian, as a priest, they are called the power of god, and most religious people call it that, for example , an atheist can say that it is not the power of god, but it is my inner energy, which is determined by what factors we are here, and so on we we will not argue at this stage we will say yes so be it but we will unite these forces and energies and we will direct this force energy against our enemy to protect our country to protect our land they konstantin let's have another video let's see how we have enemies, how is their communication with their church, let's see, come on, the moscow theological academy seminar is fighting with nato, christ, what do you see, kovalenko

, everything is a disaster, look, the moscow theological seminary, the academy is suffering from nato, says this person, and the graduates of this academy are now sitting in kyiv, onufriy berezovsky also graduated from the moscow theological academy in the seminary father pavlo lebid, abbot of the kyiv-pechersk lavra, is also a graduate of the moscow seminary and theological academy they are also now fighting with nato on territory of ukraine what do you think? and i want to comment on this video, first of all, this is what he is doing and the noise. he is wearing robes, red robes that symbolize the purple robe of jesus christ, who led him to the crucifixion, which she put on him, the bloody ram, which we priests wear on easter, as

a symbol of the torments of the crusaders, he takes an rpg-7 grenade launcher without removing the cap and he shoots at nato, you understand this costume at least less, and in general, i see this general rampage of the moscow patriarchate because what with about onufry berezovsky pavlo lebedya and the rest of these people i don't know how to call them, the question is who make a living as priests , metropolitans, etc., who are still in ukraine , i don't have any of them... well, i don't have any of them i ask you honestly, what are the possible problems? kostiantyn kholodenko, who goes to this church , knows the most about me is that the chaplains are shooting at him

. we thank you very much. we congratulate you on the holiday. unfortunately , there is no time. we congratulate you on the news iro a word of thanks colleagues literally in a moment about the most important events at this time, wait