because you helped so much, but people who earn more, who have more funds, and at the highest level, how should this help the economy, eh, this is a reminder because it doesn’t work and they already know all this . in america, there was such a president, runet dreygan, who spent the idea of ​​the tricycle of the down economy, when everything drips, it means we fill the big bowl from above, and everything drips from it, and everything seems to get something from it. simply keeps it to himself and invests it, for example, in panama. and where can it be hidden, so to speak, and so on, that's why these systems don't work, and the people of great britain apparently understood it too. and tell me , in principle, this is a destabilization of great britain, we understand that who would not become the new prime minister of great britain the visa will continue because it's a brexit crisis, and i don't really understand it at all. this is not the appearance of a politician who, in principle, will tell

people that they made a tragic mistake, bolitva, maybe johnson, who in principle is the author of all this wild delusion, is going to return to the post of prime minister - this is to say that the crisis will accelerate with even greater force in the near future. well this is very dangerous for all our general solidarity , the united states of great britain. in our eyes, it is simply slipping into the economic abyss and the political one, because i assume that you will be knowledgeable about the opposite of this. well, you know, on the one hand , i can't share with you in detail, on the other hand, i think that's what we saw, but from great britain the last one, let's say in the last year, and how much more aggressive is its policy in relation to how did you correctly define the opposition to authoritarianism, and even in contrast to the european union, which seems to

be a wonderful system because it prevents warriors among all these european states, but from the second country, how do they have a foreign policy ? it is possible because it is not part of the european union, but on the other hand, well, this is such a democratic problem, they voted to leave, it was such a dubious decision, and it seems that since then, even everything is an illusion. well, apparently they need to operate within the laws and order and the system, they just take their heads and start chopping. and somehow, here you are, reorganizing yourself so that they can hold an election, which boards are voted on, which need to win in the system, so that the country turns in the other direction. in principle, we are stronger. when we are with allies, oh, allies, we are stronger when

it is ukraine and the united states over the european union. this is stronger than russia and the wounds of north korea, and therefore allies are of great importance who, eh, i forget that russian is needed, who can leave, too, how is it true, who can be yours , you are the winner, after all, officially, it seems that only pony mordon, eh, announced that boris johnson has already returned to london, but for now, how it would seem that he is silent on the last one, there is already 100% yes , that is already ritalii emu well, the minister of finance, too , will roar sumakov, i will not build all myself specialists from great britain. approach to ukraine a-a that's why it from the other country didn't like its approach to the consideration of the legal order, and that's why i want the british to understand

their country , after all, this is not my field. how to open examinations. i'm just watching this soedym of the nominal states. we had a figure of the united states on the air, we will now turn to the topic of energy terror, we will continue this topic, we will play zhdanov, a candidate of political sciences, the head of the information defense project, he will be on the phone now, and we i will still ask mr. vitaly, but we have already discussed the goals of the russian federation, the continuation of this terror, but it cannot be eternal. yes, it is possible that the countries of the west will do something to prevent this. they do not have the means. do you think they have the means yet? by the way, our prime minister said today that it is necessary to create some opportunities in order to support the ukrainian energy industry. this means that we need to look for some non-

standard steps. this is an absolutely obvious thing for me, you need to realize that in any case it is impossible to completely destroy the entire energy industry. and what we talked about with mr. serhiy about nuclear power plants is an important part of this energy history and what we really need is to protect these nuclear power plants that we still have. because putin did not leave by chance. chernobyl and zaporizhzhia nuclear power station, it’s not just that they were going there for a nuclear power plant, no. it was such a plan from the very beginning, and it didn’t go anywhere, and it’s logical because the situation with control over nuclear energy is, firstly, blackmail and secondly you can just turn it off little by little, well, it can reduce the power supply, or can it continue forever? no, it can continue either until the collapse of one force or the collapse of another, the only thing is that it does not create opportunities for victory at the front, there are

many examples of this in general, broom i do n’t really understand at all why are they doing this, the russian general, the main myth of the second world war is not only soviet, by the way, it is the blockade of leningrad, a beautiful story, a city that died not only from lack of heating, but also from food, without anything, simply nothing it was not and it was not possible to leave. this is not the situation when we say that putin cuts off the electricity and people can leave. it was not important to leave . the party government of the soviet union itself, you understand, wanted people to stay there and die of hunger. it was interested in propaganda. and i want to ask who did this bring victory? well, if the germans did not break through to leningrad, then they did not win it. that is, they took atrocities against the civilian population, whoever

they were carried out. it's simple, of course, against the civilian population, in order to win, you need to destroy the army, well, there is an important moment there, their citizens , she has already appeared, mr. igor . everything is happening right now. so we understand that we will have all this kind of television, television by candlelight, well, it's very romantic, if it was on television in the 19th century, then they could have interviewed a certain marshal murat or marshal her during the siege. moscow yes, that's for sure, i have a candle burning here, so everything is fine. well, do you feel like marshal, the mirat , or marshal, the widow? who do you like more? well, i don't even know. okay, so now about energy terror, let's understand in general what is happening politically, and here angelica asked a good question. is it can it go on forever what

should be done to stop it the war must be won you are absolutely right because all other solutions are polyethylene you can create an air defense system but no appo system guarantees 100% downing of the air force, although it's more to me to protect our energy facilities, it's possible, this is the first, uh. well, the second direction is simply to expel the syrians from the territory of ukraine, to change the government in russia, or simply to disintegrate russia as a state, and then we will not have threats of shutdowns and so on and the like, well, theoretically, it’s still possible, let ’s say so, if they are given these goals, but this is this, this is a theory, because 101 years ago there was such an italian general, giulio duet, who published a book

called dominion of the air, he took up the the war can be won at the expense of massive air strikes, because there were strikes by bombing cities and forcing the nation to surrender, but world war ii showed that this is an absolutely false concept." but well, he is somewhat possible, far promising well, not

tomorrow, although we really want it to happen tomorrow and for putin, putin, to be killed or for him to finally die and for the power in russia to change and so on and so on, but the main thing is that we expel the russians invaders however, if we return to your first option, what is still possible with air defense forces to close our energy critical infrastructure as much as possible from the promises made to us at the last rammstein regarding silpp as far as possible to protect our state is possible in percentage terms if you know well let's go to rammstein 6 we were generally promised to create a system after we we will win the war, well, that is, all these modern systems of the patriots, the rest, well, it was theoretically considered after the victory of ukraine, deliveries, as far as i know, in rammstein 6 agreed that the integrated air defense system like this

a system that overlaps batteries, divisions, each other’s actions from the crazy, it will be helmeted in height for small, medium and long-range high-altitude targets , such a system will be created already today, but the problem is that there are all these systems to create some, well, they are necessary, well, they are produced for quite a long time. and they will be produced close to the focus, the first one was delivered now, and the next, uh, system complexes will be delivered or, in my opinion, in six months. that is , this is still a question, since they are high-tech the question of weapons is universal in the political will, which i hope already exists in western democracies, its

understanding that without this it is impossible to win the war and ensure the normal existence of our country, but this is also a problem of purely technological production, it is quite a long story, so we hoped that one came arrest, maybe there are some system loopholes, but in my warehouses, such information is not the most up-to-date , not in the systems there, not in the latest versions, but they must be delivered to ukraine and try to. cruise missiles well, with all of them, that means 90%, er, drones, dad. but you understand, the citizens are not interested in the number of downed ones, because of the arrivals, you have how many hits on ukrainian lands, how many arrived and struck, not how many were shot down. i think

in the near future it will be within a month or two until the new year, and we will have to endure it and sit by candles to save energy. well , our new lifestyle will be romantic. we thank the russian dwarf for this romance in quotes. we only need to talk about light, mine, we need to talk about water supply, yes, it is also related to electricity, we need to talk about heating, about heating, it is also related to electricity, there are not so many autonomous systems that people can say well , i will not have light, well, i will sit at candles, but i will have heat and water. and this is somehow interconnected, this raises the question of how we will cope with all these problems, apart from sanctifying our teeth and being patient, i have no other suggestions. i remember the 93rd or 92nd year of tbilisi, everyone is there

the trees in the center of tbilisi were produced, produced, and simply lit bonfires and burned, well, in tbilisi itself. in the yards and so on, they warmed up there, they put small pots in the apartments so that it was quite dangerous . the gas boiler is in the apartment, like mine, for example, if there is no electricity, it doesn’t work now. well, i’m talking about it, and i’m talking about it. it’s cold. the batteries don’t heat me. who has central heating ? but it seems to me that where there is central heating , pumps are also needed for this, for that, they are electric. well, most likely they will be used, uh, these pumps will provide current for them. although i am

not sure, it will depend on intelligence and what is the problem the problem is not in energy-generating capacities, they are practically preserved and there is a very large reserve for the production of electricity in ukraine, but the problem is in the distribution capabilities of delivering this energy to consumers, they are waiting for transformers that are in the open a transformer hit a drone in the area, it caught fire there, they don't have access to the country's unified energy system, and that is, it produces energy, but it can't connect consumers to the network , that's the whole story, that's how i understood it. told the experts about the situation in ukraine, what do you think, the new one in the house will probably start the concert , absolutely, uh, part of our

compatriots will be justified, i think it is the majority, well, it is objectively, women, children will leave somewhere in poland, in other countries because, well, or come for example, i'm thinking of coming to the village. maybe there 's a wood-burning stove in the house, and it will definitely provide us with heat, at least there, and there's a generator that can be started if there's a problem , yeah, so i thought about the villages. now there will be a lot of people will move from the city of otaki to the village of otaki, where there are birds, where there are rough people, and where it is possible to be warm, but these are those who do not have work and can afford it . not all enterprises can live on their own

having generators, not everyone can kill business at this moment, i think that the issue of work is always me. by the way , eh, igor said that when there were all these calls to come and start the economy, i was absolutely not sure that this is exactly what should happen as a priority in this situation which is in the country, but this is already a question of such competence well, we will adapt, of course, they will change jobs well, at least it's not a paradox, i have an internet connection, gadgets work, and the power bank is correct, and there is light, why can't i contact you, because you would i didn't physically see the candle, it doesn't give off enough light so that i could be on the air normally . you saw me there, but you can communicate, that is, the internet connection was never installed, and theoretically , a person with some kind of laptop, generator and access to a mobile or internet connection can work

for himself at his place during the day there, for example, if it is not disconnected, the belizka station will work if it is yes, because when the lights were turned off in lviv, for example, my mobile communication did not work at all, yes, with different operators - this thank you that before the covid epidemic, the covid pandemic , we had no idea how we could work remotely. and now, thanks to this pandemic, we wanted to work remotely. and this helped us a lot during the war. by the way, before the war, we did not understand how we would work during military operations. of hostilities, but i will tell you that, for example , a private lyceum headed by a wife did not work for a single day without stopping in remote mode, even when the teachers were working, they taught lessons to the children from the bompa warehouse, on the contrary

the same children were sitting in a bulb storehouse, the main thing is that there should be an internet if a person adapts to this, our people are smart enough. i think they will adapt to such options, although it will not be easy , it will be difficult, but i do not think that there will be any uh, well, such an energy armageddon. that is such a viel- shutdown, they will thank you mr. igor igor zhdanov candidate of political sciences, minister of youth and sports of ukraine, we were in touch by phone because you see that there are problems with light in kyiv right now, it's too bad, it's too bad the expected problem and we will be back literally in a few minutes and continue our conversation with medications events the most important events events that are happening right now and affect our lives of course the news feed reports about them but it is not enough to know what is happening you need to understand antin

borkovskyi and invitation experts soberly evaluate the events analyze them modeling our immediate future every saturday at 1:00 p.m. with a repeat at 10 p.m. studio event with anton borkovskii nayspresso join the community with a ukrainian perspective on the world become a sponsor of the youtube channel espresso and this is access to exclusive content personal thanks fixed comments special icons there the possibility of personal communication with the espresso team click sponsor and become part of the community with a ukrainian point of view oh in ukraine and volunteers everything is possible death of the enemy of ukraine everything will find everyone feed everyone they will save their tails

they will give them a gift for the planes they will collect them they will help the doctors sing a lullaby they will sing the foresters they will equip everyone they will hug them glory to ukraine to the whole world ukraine will be glorified by the volunteer family there is no translation all of ukraine thanks you, we continue the saturday polyclopa anzhelika sezonenko at this hour vitaliy portnikov will answer questions on such topics professionally as always, let's talk about how ukraine should answer and it's early for the kamikaze drones that he supplies to the russian federation , although he won't admit it let's also talk about the hijab revolution in iran, an accessible and interesting topic, how it can affect the domestic political

situation in the country, why china helps iran and condemns the sanctions imposed by the european union and great britain against iran. well, there is also a good topic of sanctions against russian oligarchs and sanctions against artists who were citizens of ukraine but now support russia's war against ukraine. what do you think, vitaly, that ukraine can do, do we have any means of influencing iran in this sense? well , about the military part of history, we were already told about kryvonos. i think that politically we have no means there is no influence on iran, and moreover, i think that no one has any means of influencing it. iran is a great example of a state that has adapted to sanctions and demonstrated that it is possible to live under sanctions and maintain power for ten years.

that is why i am very surprised when now many says that russia will change its policy in connection with western sanctions, the president of the united states, barack obama, once spoke about the cumulative effect of sanctions. i absolutely agree with this opinion, the cumulative effect of sanctions always works. let's say, when in the 70s the united states introduced the jacksonville amendment against the soviet union, which limited the possibility of supplies to the soviet union, it used some kind of technology until the soviet union allowed free migration from its country. by the way, it was only about citizens of jewish origin. nothing special, but at 11:00 a.m. before that i did not want to do this amendment . the soviet union is really incredibly technologically backward, technological backwardness creates

the possibility of the decline of the state, the question arises in how many years 25-30 45, the more the soviet union had another big problem, it was a country with a planned economy, and the iranians, russia is a country with a market economy, so they always asked how effective there is market authoritarianism, so market authoritarianism is effective precisely because it enables people to survive by themselves even under any repressive regime, that is, the regime is not prevents them from surviving, it does not give them the opportunity to live, but please survive, when north korea allowed its citizens to trade something or something on the black market, or even when it leased state canteens to some party officials, they showed that it can also exist, that is, the problem of the economy is absolutely obvious the market will create i would say i hear absolutely incredible things

and the problem of the communists was that they were afraid of the market and now we have a rather interesting situation market authoritarianism against market democracies, and market authoritarianism is always afraid of market democrats because it has another half that did not exist in the soviet union, it can not fully control information, and it understands that somewhere there is an end and so that this end does not happen, it comes to the conclusion that it is necessary to destroy market democracies, communism he did not come to this conclusion, at least according to stalin's. did he control the information? he believed that he could absolutely peacefully coexist with the west and the west, or russia or china and the west cannot coexist that's why we got into such an existential conflict, it's not only a conflict between russia and ukraine, because the conflict between russia and ukraine is not just a conflict between a state that wants to take back its territory and don't give it back to russia, but to belarus, it's also a seemingly independent state, but it yes, but it is the authors, but it is not part of the territory of russia, the russians can be said it is our part, but it is an authoritarian state, it is

a state that agrees that we and russia will fight against the civilized worlds. as you see, russia he does not show great interest in annexing it to himself, and from ukraine there are other stories, this is not just a conflict with the former soviet republic, which should become part of russia, this is a conflict with the former soviet republic, which does not want to be a part of the empire of the imperial view of the democratic world. should be canceled, this is also a huge goal, and in this sense, in this sense, we can immediately say that iran has proven that it is possible to exist under sanctions , russia also has to mean what can be done to stop this, there is only one recipe, unfortunately, it is the overthrow of the regime in the morning, they have already experimented many times, let's have a moderate regime , there were presidents who tried to somehow make this

islamic radicalism out of the conventional islamic, because i think that it is generally just a dictatorship that covers itself with religion but with a human face well, then everything ended, this is how it ended now that now in iran there is a radical regime in the essence of this special police, their corps is worth a slam revolution and this regime understands putin with all my heart, because this is the union of the cargo corps of the guards of the soviet will of the islamic revolution with the kgb , people absolutely understand each other and they are destroying people now, just as they destroyed them in 1979, i already smoothly want to move to the hijab revolution. right now, this topic is just what it is for. big , huge direct mass protests, ap vitaly, but this is not only about the hijab directly - it is about freedom - it is about the rights and, by the way, not only women , because the phenomenon of this revolution is that men

supported women, well, you understand that so many how long has this regime existed, but it still creates a certain illusion of voters for people, by the way, a big problem is that it distinguishes iran and russia from china, china, there are no elections in the eu for the congress of the communist party, well, that is, it is like in the soviet union th union, and in iran or in russia , elections are allegedly taking place all the time, so people have an illusion, by the way, in 2020, she played a bad joke with the belarusians that people decide something, and the question always arises here, can people really prove that they are meeting with the truth or they really are they were just participants in the scenery. what is the power apparatus in fact, and in this sense we are of course with you. we must do everything possible to realize that

this is such a real struggle between people who believe in their capabilities and the power apparatus. they must prove their capabilities to the authorities, because why does it exist? huge money, then we need not only iran, but the iranian government to destroy and somehow reformat and rank a more democratic state, and china too, but we cannot do it, only the people of iran can do it russia and china have nothing to do with it. the russians think that it is possible to change something in a country through external intervention. this is not true. the russians came up with various conspiracy theories that scared putin for life about the fact that the arab spring was organized by the us state department, but the us state department sat and watched what is happening in the arab age, i would say holding my head in my hands, then it turned out that in this situation, which

developed in the islamic republic and er iran now or which then developed in egypt or in other in arab countries, of course, people can overthrow a dictator, but this absolutely does not mean that they can create democratic states in egypt, it all ended because the army returned to power after a short period to the applause of the society, which should not have gone to democratic elections, but got the wrong one at all the result they expected when they went to the revolution on the left, it ended with the fact that there is no state there, it turned out that the entire state on the left rested on the authority of the dictator and by the way, everyone says oh how did it happen, libya will catch fire, what a horror, but the question is that before the appearance in tripoli of the koro