the americans are capable of hitting any target. russia today seems to me unable to do this because there is currently no access to the a-a of the west, what space microelectronics and more. please tell me the highest altitude of finding a stay from a satellite above the ground, which i just listened to. i apologize for 36,000 e -th kilometers above the surface of the earth , there are stationary satellites that are constantly at a specific point near the equator , saturated with space debris, so what will happen next if such dynamics are maintained will there be an oversaturation and what is the threat of it in general ? now there is a need to create a space traffic management system, and such a system in principle exists in some countries, including in the united states of america and european countries , including in russia, and they are separated

from each other, but for now they make it possible to avoid collisions of both satellites between each other and with these fragments but really, what today is only getting worse around the earth, first of all, it is low at an altitude of 3800 km international management of this space traffic is already needed and the cost is working groups within the framework of the un committee on space, which are currently working but are trying to create such a system, but so far it mostly exists at the level of declarations and recommendations, which is very unfortunate because, after all, it really every week, i.e., the mask level launches another batch of its satellites of 50 pieces into earth orbit. china has also already demonstrated that it can simultaneously launch its satellites from two space probes, i.e., the possibility of advanced space e-e world

to saturate this orbit today is extremely high and thus there is still a real threat that one day we will need our imaginary er traffic lights already in space orbit around the earth, moreover, when er research and er practical research will begin month , and then it will be necessary to also establish the appropriate rules on this particular path from the earth to the moon in order to ensure that there are already n- oversaturated with space vehicles and there are no exemptions. expert analyst on issues of space activity is an extremely interesting topic and e-e. thank you very much to andriy kolesnik for finding time for us and you, we will continue. serhiy stukanov, the head of the analytical department of the content analysis center is already joining. we welcome you serhiy. good afternoon. greetings. good morning.

well, everyone e- they are writing something, they are discussing putin's speech, putin's speech yesterday at the so -called valdai discussion club, tell them what conclusions you made for yourself or did you hear or see something new. good afternoon, colleagues. indeed, i listened to putin yesterday i endured let's just say that i made an effort on myself, well, it should be noted that i did not offer anything new after that. that is, his speech was largely dedicated to the fact that he described the usual picture of the world for russia, according to which russia opposes the west. that is, it is purely anti-western position, we see that in his position, putin has evolved to understand world history as a certain set of civilizations, he

quoted danilevsky, this is a russian historiographer of the 2019 century, who proposed a civilizational approach before the spenghor and before the sky that is, the understanding of world history as the coexistence of certain native civilizations, so putin imagines that russia itself constitutes a civilization, of course, he includes ukraine as a part of this civilization and believes that it is called today precisely to stop the hegemony of the west. it is very interesting that putin, at the same time, appeals to the interests of africa, appeals to the interests asia, which is supposedly also not taken into account by the west and, accordingly, russia is on their side, is a hinged thing, this is an attempt by the russians to find allies, at least where today russia can still look allies because in the west, well, except for hungary, putin has no allies, and the rhetoric

is clear. the west is being primitive. the west is essentially reduced to certain ideas of hegemony , and putin constantly repeats the issue of gender, which hurts him, and says that the russian - this is absolutely not inherent, that is, purely traditionalist rhetoric. well, when putin sat down to answer questions, it was already largely about ukraine. that is, we began to see very well that the key for putin is confrontation the west, and he sees the confrontation in ukraine as one of the elements, seeing that the west is inciting ukraine to a conflict with russia. in fact, putin directly said that russia was not up to anything when it came to the reasons for this alleged special operation, from his point of view, it is allegedly the west incited and incited ukraine to the point that it would actually oppose the west. i am here. i want

to emphasize to my colleagues an interesting point that despite the fact that the presenter clearly did not ask putin tough questions, they even made these questions public the situation in which the russians no longer really trust the narrative that putin is trying to create. well, look, the presenter asked putin. and everyone tells the military and political leadership of russia that the operation is going according to plan, but society says that the presenter is not very clear about what plan, please explain please, one more question: 8 months of the war have passed. do you actually stand on the basis of the fact that we and the ukrainians are one people? well , the host of the day is aware that the ukrainians are actively resisting russia, and it is obvious that reveal the existence of a separate nation. do you still believe in your own thesis about one people? well, there is one more

question that the presenter asked putin himself. it related to this whole war and whether ukrainians were underestimated, that is, there is also an understanding that ukraine was underestimated, that ukraine is a financier well, of course, putin's answers were predictable in the question, uh, let's say one nation or not one nation. putin again resorted to a history lecture, plunging into the history of russia, where there was supposedly a single nation that spoke a single language language, then in the 14th and 15th centuries, allegedly under the influence of poland, ukrainians began to speak differently in his faith. finally, in the 19th century, ukrainians began to be separated from russia in countries that were foreign and

hostile to russia. emphasizes putin, ukrainians were killed oh, i apologize to the russians, poles, belarusians, and jews. and regarding the fact that, uh, is the operation going according to plan, and again here, even on putin's face, you could see that he uh, with a certain certain, let's say, waves of concern well, but later he began to talk about the fact that we are protecting donbas, about the fact that today we are protecting ukraine with weapons. well , accordingly, we are moving forward. those goals have set a real form, that is, in fact, a fairly standard speech, which does not seem to me to be anything new, neither to the world, nor to the russians, nor to the ukrainians. he offered me a very i liked these uh, well , the interruption plans of tv people are called when they film the audience and everyone nods so-so-so, and what kind of people are these, because this is this discussion club, which is, in principle, nonsense for

in russia, the international discussion club 2a is called uh putin speaks and everyone else it is called this discussion who are these people what nationality why is the internationality of the club, you know who was there every country is held annually for 19 years it was started obviously in the early 2000s when putin only came and was perceived by many in the west as a liberal politician compared to his predecessor yeltsin, there were a lot of hopes for putin, it is obvious that the russians started this international platform at that time precisely in order to to involve the international community, to promote their narratives, to make certain connections and contacts there, today it is clear that no self-respecting person, no self-respecting analyst, politician or representative of the class of political scientists will come to russia in order

not to - to legitimize the regime that today is increasingly recognized as terrorist, not only at the level of the parliamentary assembly of the council of europe, but also at the level of the parliaments of individual states, such as lithuania, latvia , and poland. we hope that the usa will soon join and other countries, so it is clear that in russia for ten years, during the soviet era, and later during the time of russia, they fed a number of experts in western countries, politicians, mainly provocateurs , so it is clear that even today they can find people who will come to this forum, and mostly it is from countries, maybe in asia and africa, but also in europe, even they can find people who can come to crimea and in order to rationalize the occupation, but these are mostly, i say, people who are engaged in provocations in their countries and the promotion of the russian people in response to the questions that were asked by foreigners. yesterday, i will honestly

say that i did not listen to the whole discussion, but i also saw what you are talking about, that they are approving and subverting putin, smiling and looking at him as if he were a prophet of some kind, mr. serhiu well , in my opinion, the motive can be written into the old joke about the fact that the russian elephant is the founder of all elephants on the planet earth, the belarusian elephant is the best friend of the russian elephant . all the geopolitical nonsense there about the mission there about the role of russia, is the sound perceived anywhere from them at all, but i hope now we will resume the video with sergey . is it exclusively for these handmaidens who sit

and nod their heads to sergey, can you hear us, it was communication problems, the question did not hear the next question - the next one, were all these geopolitical myths told for the world or only for their own of the russian cold weather sergey stukanov was with us, we hope that now the communication will be translated in a new way, and probably the text, but i do not think that the president of the united states joe biden and his analysts will sit and reread what putin said there about suburban russia and its role there in the 17th century or there from the time of kievan rus' about the fact that kyiv was the mother of russian cities well, it's hard for me to imagine everything, or there is the british king charles sitting and reading

these britneys or the prime minister of australia there or even these zinpil with the chinese are sitting and they think well, where were these mokshes when we already had gunpowder? sergiu looks at it all strangely because he knows he was sophia for a reason. sergiu is interested in anyone in the world besides the citizens of russia who is talking about this on tv. thing is vladimir putin or not unfortunately, we now have power outages and then the vopli display without 30% of capacities ah, in connection with the terrorist attacks of the russians, you see so, soon more time will also suffer well, do you remember that moment when the boresh johnson about the former prime minister of britain used to come to kyiv, he went to sofia of kyiv for nothing. this was also a kind of sign

, because he is one of the few world leaders who knows the history of kievan rus with absolute precision, and if putin said about him that russia was invented more precisely ukraine was invented by russia and that russia was in relation to how ukraine was, then he would laugh at you, well, then i will calculate some information , here is interesting information from estonia, they will deprive russians and belarusians of permission, but the fly does not get me weapons permits according to the head of the ministry of internal affairs estonia's laurel tree is not our name, the government decided on thursday, the day before yesterday, that more than 13 foreigners with 1,300 weapons permits, because there are three battalions of them in estonia , will soon lose it, reports the local edition of the city's pontoons, according to of the minister, all persons without estonian citizenship, citizenship of another eu country or even a nato country will lose their right to weapons in estonia, the decision will affect 683

foreign citizens and 595 holders of gray passports , that is, non-estonian citizens who have the right to live on the territory of estonia, according to the decree, it will be in force on december 1. good afternoon , once again, mr. sergiu. good afternoon. did you hear my question when i asked it at 2 o'clock ? putin's nonsense is interesting, is anyone familiar with it outside the borders of the russian federation, the republic of belarus and satellite states, for example , tajikistan, kyrgyzstan, uzbekistan, tajikistan , turkmenistan, please and definitely i think it is about about the leader of a great power that today unleashed an aggressive war, and accordingly

what he announces and the messages he tries to send are being actively studied . putin did not say anything new, on the other hand, there was an interesting reaction from lithuania, where it was assumed that this speech by putin could be the opening speech during the meeting of the international criminal court, which will accuse russia of aggression, and putin could in this way try to to justify himself by declaring that it was not he who started the war, but the countries of the west, so it is clear that they are still studying and trying to feel and feel putin's mood. well, i would say so, colleagues. what was putin's key message in yesterday's speech? and it was a call to the countries of the west to sit down at the table of negotiations, to agree on certain coexistence, on certain certain principles of the world structure, that is, it is obvious that the crisis that russia is currently in because of the war in ukraine is a certain impasse today

for russia and there is only one way out. it is either to agree on top of the head of ukraine and the west, respectively, to force to incite the west to betray ukraine to surrender the interests of ukraine, well, or press ukraine and accordingly force zelensky to drop to his knees and sign some self-dealing agreements for this by the way, they are destroying our electricity infrastructure in order to incite to this, but we see how unsuccessful it is today this is ukraine's strategy, they can't force them to negotiate. and the narratives they spread to western countries also absolutely do not work today, the leading trend is consider russia and putin an international criminal and terrorist. i think that this trend will spread, that is why theses are being studied, but it is unlikely that they are already forming a certain worldview for the countries of the

west, mr. serhiy, thank you for this analysis on our broadcast, serhiy stukanov, head of the analytical department of the content analysis center they talked about yesterday's speech by putin. well, me too. to be honest, i did n't listen to the end, i didn't watch it, but many people later. by the hand of the late queen, the kingdom of heaven, that there are very similar signs, there is some kind of spotting . well, let's hope. well, but even physically, since he was prophesying there for two hours, physically, if he was in a bad condition, it is difficult for a sick person to be healthy, so i think with a healthy person, there is still everything okay, petro andryushchenko is with us, adviser to the mayor of mariupol, mr. peter, we welcome you, congratulations , glory to ukraine, by the way, today in the dressing room, we

were reminiscing about this series, do you remember the beautiful nanny, which was so we all watched it then understood that this is part of the weapons of russia's war against ukraine, it is said that the ukrainian woman was portrayed as picky and not far from mariupol, yes , let's react then, and you have given birth to something new for putin's people, we saw that he does not see us and they want to prove to everyone that it was russia that invented ukraine, well, actually, nothing. that is, well, you know, we have been commenting for two hours on this brand. it is clear that it is interesting, probably for psychiatrists, ah , nothing new. works from europe, of course, there is really something very deep in the head of this dictator, that's why, well, do a deep analysis, you know, these made

-up stories about ukraine that never existed, well , i don't even know, i'm talking to someone, yes, sahaidachnyi almost didn't burn the date of the brain of its time, it was probably necessary to burn it there, it was much easier for us today, but how did his speech become the result of his speech, that everything is better now , unfortunately, we see in mariupol that the history of mariupol is being rewritten, in fact, regarding the foundation mariupol, which did not exist before there was kateryna. she did not deport the greeks from our ukrainian crimea because of their history, and ours went there themselves, so we see it as it progresses, global changes regarding, in principle, the truth regarding narratives and all that he says, well the people of mariupol hear every day in the occupation from all available sources , so it is not surprising that people there really believe in

russia and in the occupied territories, who have been there for a long time and repeat like parrots what is called mr. peter, what is happening in mariupol , according to your information. now we read about the fact that people are offered a new service from the so-called administration, you can buy your house from demolition, so pay the right person and your house will not be demolished and it will remain, do you know something about this, a warned list of it from a solid so -called dpr instroy, there are 136 high-rise buildings subject to demolition , considering that everyone understands that they will not demolish everything at once, and among those houses there are a lot of those people, well, people continue to live, for example, one of them won, and the others drove up.

ivashchenko is there, there is a special person who takes the money , the issue is resolved with the minister, the house itself does not disappear from this list, it’s just that the russian contractors who are engaged in the demolition of houses do not approach that house, they go further, that is, such a kind of income, in principle, first, the occupation, well, this russian corruption, which seems to not exist yes, we can see in all its glory the ministry of emergency situations, which sold diesel fuel as a farmer at one time. and here is the demolition of houses, and probably the saddest income was through exhumation, through funerals, everything there is arranged for money, that is if in mariupol people began to earn money for construction working for contractors, then this means that this is such a signal for the occupation authorities, first of all for our collaborators, which means that the people of mariupol can share a little of this money with the authorities under the condition that one scheme is invented there for others, that is,

the whole business under control also lives on bribes, in fact, it has now come to that, today even restrictions on seat belts are starting to apply there , and in the city where we do not work, because there are no traffic lights and such chaotic traffic, what are the rules about it is not mentioned at all and the new police officers are already on the streets already insuring people, well, again, yes, how are they fined, how do we remember how it used to be , i guess we had it before the reform, that is, all this has returned in all its glory and in fact it is still destruction if you recall one myth like this, yes, the pro-russian stratum was invited and constantly told about us that there was corruption in ukraine, and corruption in russia was because everything is in the hands of putin there. now we see it. well, i will tell you that our corruption is childish kindergarten in comparison with in russian and in contrast to russia, our corruption, which may still exist there, we will

say a lot about it there, it mostly does not apply to a citizen. well, of course, in mariupol today, if you do not have a thousand rubles in your documents, in principle, you can not enter to any conditional state institution , i.e. a banal reference, a banal question until you provide money well, in principle, no one talks to you, they say go wait your turn queues of thousands are written there, that is, everything is set exactly to this is mr. petar. well, we have a legend that ukrainian corruption is the cement of the creation of the ukrainian state. let's be honest. we have tsnaps and people don't go around with them. they gilded the handle . well, they read ads on our espresso tv website, he says from a message with a link to your mariupol city council , a message in telegram that the residents of mariupol still live in tents and cook food on fires, the tents are located near the cinemas in the salon. i

really don't know, i've never been to mariupol, by the way well, i've traveled all over mariupol, i'm afraid, i've never been. where the residents of the city did not hide during the shelling of the russians, and to this day they continue to cook food on fires there and sleep in the basements of cinemas. e reports your telegram. well, our channel also spreads it through our online tv store. please comment. these are actually the people, the comitator of savona. the question here is not in the cinema, but in the fact that it was one of the storages. it is big enough and goes on for a very long time. there were many people who live in the 17 residential microdistrict, and now we are returning back because they understand that together it is easier to get warm, get food, get water, that is, everything is back to how it was in the spring for many people, only the russians don’t fly with the shabo from above, but even without that, it’s

sweet it's actually winter, that's why the situation doesn't look the best, really, but the only thing we can write down for ourselves and together with you, including in the victory asset, we talked so much about the fact that they give out keys to apartments only to their own, what happened before the inspections, there were scandals there, including with the occupation authorities and their collaborators, and they began to give out the first apartments in a somehow, again, incomprehensible queue, but the queues, that is, ordinary people would begin to be resettled, but, again, the tentatively announced 500 apartments are ready, that's about 500 families, it is estimated that there are 1,500 people, and the need for resettlement in the city reaches 30-40,000. that is, we understand that there is a catastrophic lack of this. they still live in some apartments there, the only survivors in the whole house well, these are

actually shoes, and if there are these pictures, they were a little beautified , let's say, well, spring, summer. even some of the russian propagandists are already getting worse. by the way, i started turning to the leadership of russia and saying what is this, and the city of mariupol is again on the verge of a humanitarian disaster, we told how we are restoring it nicely, that is awl between rooms and others. as they say, yes, this is the situation in mariupol, and it is true that mariupol is not ready for winter, but these topics of construction and restoration are far from the reality that the city needs. in fact, the lack of any plan, and this all chaotically leads to the fact that a lot of people really stay to actually live on the streets today well, one more question, the day before yesterday, the ministry of foreign affairs literally asked law enforcement agencies to open ukrainian cases

against a russian citizen of lviv and lviv and belova. i apologize, she is commissioner for children's rights and the president of russia, who declared that she personally adopted a child taken from mariupol. well, the statement of the ministry of foreign affairs of the removal of ukrainian children from the temporarily occupied territories of ukraine to russia and their subsequent so- called adoption by russian citizens grossly violates the legislation of ukraine, the geneva convention on the protection of civil population from the 49th year during the war, which provides for the obligation of the occupying power not to change the citizenship status of children, the convention on the rights of the child in the 89th year what do you know about this history, do you even know what kind of boys these are? i understand that from whom the authorized representative of the president of russia on matters of truth adopted a child to the authorized representative. apparently, every ukrainian has a personal enemy. yes, there is such a big one in russia, and i will tell you honestly. this is my personal enemy, this person took away more than 1,300 children from mariupol. these

are just people. in fact, she installed not one but two children from mariupol. the first is that they are boys. they are about 16 years old and he already received a russian passport from her. and he also has sister ah somewhere around 5-6 years and about a month ago she also brought her to russia and also well, if she hasn’t established it yet, she started the procedure for establishing and changing citizenship, that is, this person is personally guilty of a large number of ukrainian children, in particular , mariupol children, and there is a story recently, finally, 6 airplanes, due to a long history, were returned to their mother, who also installed them before the russians took them away. they said that they were orphans. well , therefore, if you take mariupol there, it is, in principle, a complete war crime of russia. this is probably what after the drama theater or not at the level of the drama theater, let's compare the inhumanity and consequences of lviv bilov, this is the

same war criminal who will be punished in the same way as putin, because it really started in fact from the end of march, at first he was deported for 100 children who were the hospital in mariupol, where the parents took them, then they collected the children who were lost. then there were the facts of the divorce of the families of the incubation authorities, and all these children ended up in russia under the influence of a guide and they take care of them, that is, 50 children, it is already on its own stated that it was established, she personally negotiated with the state duma a simplified process of establishing children, as they say, from donbas, but it only applies to children who were taken out of russia during this phase of the war since february 24, so, so, well, this is a separate sad story that well, it’s just getting furious. i think most mariupol people have it because there are indeed rare cases when the parents are in ukraine when they give birth