an equation with what was, for example, in the summer will give yes, not higher, everything the price was justified, but i'm sorry, it's not uah 90, clearly not uah 100, it's possible for a home, there's its own price. and i usually have domestics. by the way, this is how you can only quarrel at work, an angel works in the field, and because, frankly, there are certain reasons to believe that there is a monopolistic conspiracy. well, i didn't tell. i don't like being taken advantage of the situation and raising the price of the panel is not justified, and with regard to sour milk products, they mentioned sour cream, which costs 200 g almost almost 40 uah, but raw dutch raw i like it, but they have become more expensive lately, both before the war and after the war, which is 350-400 uah per kilo. well not every ukrainian has my pension and a salary. maybe

it's good even for me. when i approach, i see 400 uah. i see that you have to pay 100 uah for that much with cheese. well, i think it's better to eat some kind of vegetable. well, there were in the summer . there were cucumbers in the summer, now i will eat them pineapples with crucian carp will no longer be available in our country. prices for fermented milk products. well, we are a fermented milk country, but the prices in our country do not correspond to our salaries and pensions. that is, we have absolutely a woman who, in principle, talked about the situation in the country where we had a lot cows, and this is actually our center , people were afraid of them, i'm sorry, they sent them for meat well , they cut them because there were a lot of interesting things on the territory and so on, there are a lot of imbalances kharkiv sumy region, you understand and we are wearing these corrections anyway, hmm, we have to to be objective and that there are things that i just don't know. i understand that we have european prices. we live

in a global world, and therefore our prices cannot differ many times from european world prices. but then why are our salaries and pensions many times different from world prices and global, this is a key question, if all these goods and purchases are taxed in the budget, well, look, i always talked about the salary , the employer sets the stop on the salary, if there is a significant offer, there is a small offer, and accordingly, people are looking for work then he will use the situation to actually dictate his conditions despite the fact that demand has fallen for many and the economy has shrunk by 30%. a lot of people left, they left accordingly, and the help that is currently being offered by the government is limited help, it's good that i will emphasize once again that those who left abroad with children are women, they are just now saving our budget due to the fact that they relieve social tension you have a child prepared, you have funds allocated by the governments of other countries, this is great, please consider

i understand the circumstances, well, come there to kyiv . you can meet your husband there, but the best thing is when you are there now and, accordingly, in fact, another government undertakes to support you. that is, you are calm about the fact that our government does not pay a lot of protection, probably to the children who went abroad. i see how funds are distributed in the budget when, i'm sorry, funds are allocated again for the same expensive ones in such billions of sums, the question arises. where did you get this bitumen, where did you get those materials, respectively, these were premium materials, that is, in fact, you again, who will you finance, what will you restore, sorry, first of all, people, yes, people need to be given jobs, this is search for support, now they are launching these startups, i have already done it a thousand times said in which startup startup it will emerge or not affect there, well, the probability of interest

is 30, that is, one - this is in the best case, most of them will not give anything, or the economy predicts 30% unemployment for us at the end of the year, the end of the year already autumn 30 program, that's what i would say instead of supporting enterprises that just need to be supported now, they will leave their jobs 150 uah startups 250,000 uah from the state for development why are you in i don't understand , firstly, they don't come back, secondly, it's me i think , well, in fact, to a certain extent, the theft of the news of taxes, there are already taxes, look, you know the number of people. they want to employ hundreds of millions of people there, which they 146, in my opinion, said 500 people, well, accordingly, what is the program for 500 people, you allocate such huge funds, then you better give these funds to people, it will no longer be 500, or it will already be at least 5 hryvnias, which we globally expect consequences based on the results of this year in the global economy, unemployment, inflation. well, gdp

growth, falling, falling, of course, actually very much we have such a magical number now 3030% drop in gdp 30% predict unemployment 30% predict inflation is it a disaster or not, given the circumstances we are in now, the government could easily get better results and we are constantly asking the question is what is the military economy, you transferred it to the military economy, the military economy is an order, guys, orders are made internally, give work to all enterprises that somehow have the opportunity to produce products for the front, make orders for them and it does not matter there, simplify the procedures, let them pay more there, but so that the people there was work. and you, your programs, they are sorry. they do not order about anything. only a very limited circle of enterprises understand that business. check with the military, you have to place

orders for products. if you would now, for example, give the same orders, for example, for milk , in order to provide people who are not well - off. she lives in the city, she has no garden to survive, well, it seems to me that the government simply forgot that our pensioners receive such sums . i know what you have to eat if you pay the utility bill and medicines are also a big question how much they cost us now and people of retirement age many of them are a large percentage in general without medicines they will simply die anywhere well here is a situation i am still grateful to our partners, we often talk about military aid, there are many humanitarian missions, please. if you are in a difficult situation, you are looking for in

your place, there are always various representatives of international organizations or individual countries who they provide direct help, search, apply , you will receive products, you will receive clothes, you will receive support in general, i think it is a great initiative, thank you, the ministry of economy, if, uh, hetki affairs, you can go to the reconstruction army for the minimum amount, how do you like it and is there enough space for everyone, what people will do. people are sorting out the rubble or something. we now have volunteer battalions working on sorting it out. look here, there are a lot of questions about this program. first of all, what did the government do at the time? he said that due to unemployment, i will pay only one month, and the rest of the rest you already have or work accordingly, i will give you a job there to resume the analysis of the zavaliv, because if i am not mistaken, there was a corresponding resolution in june and then i will pay the funds, the amount there.

sorry , 4,000 uah . we will pay the minimum wage, as if we had raised it. well, you already robbed these people who were unemployed, taking away from them the unemployment benefits provided for by ukrainian legislation, you stole from them, and now you say you have to work how much do you offer, and we do a huge amount, but the average assistance is 4,700. yes, some have 4,700, some have less and some have more. colleague's day, let's talk a little about the economy, yes, about our prices, about our salaries and about pensions, and about where public funds are spent. how do you assess the government's activities in under the conditions of the war at the end of the year, we generally talked about the fact that -30 us will be gdp minus 30 plus 30 unemployment and also plus 30 we will have inflation that the government is in the meantime against the background

of this we are allocating funds for the construction of roads it is important, of course, but why is it a priority task in the conditions of war, i ask oleksandr, i want to say that i am a specialist, hear me like this. unfortunately, there is no light in the house where i am, where i live, now i can have such interruptions, that is, please pay attention to this , but i want to note right away that i'm pretty high assesses the activities of our government during the war and ah, you know, they are doing everything possible and impossible under very difficult conditions, we must realize that we have extremely difficult times ahead of us, we have to survive the winter, which can be the most difficult eh with eh such a time in our history maybe, but i am sure that we will succeed with the support of our partners, well, regarding the construction of roads and

infrastructure. well, you see that russia is trying to destroy our infrastructure and roads . i understand that roads are important, at least in order to supply the necessary goods and the necessary weapons. that is , it is a very important element of the infrastructure for the development of the economy, including during the war during the war ilya please question yes, roads are important, but when we had a fight against the coronavirus and roads, we directly prioritized roads again. when we were preparing for war and roads, instead of preparing for war, we once again allocated roads, now when we need to support the economy, we again prioritize roads, it's wrong priorities, it's always the wrong priority every time , and i'm asking you very much, you say a lot of things it does, name three things

that you think the government was able to achieve in these difficult conditions, that is this is really its result, which can be recorded in a positive way. the main thing is that the government is trying to do everything possible so that we survive , including more economically, that is, and the support of the support - the support of the economy - you already know that. i consider this a feat on the part of the government, and they are making it possible in the field of energy, well, in the field of energy, for example, they are updating the fact that what will destroy russia are private and not state-owned companies, and they are doing it effectively right away, that is, you know. i trust the government and i see that now there are specialists who are working there who are trying to do their best. look at the teacher. yes, children, and ukrenergo is a state-owned private company. it’s not quite close. i think that oksankos is really not an expert of this tsar. no, he is no longer in international politics. marshall's plan, well, who is it? navsky is also engaged in

restoration, and on the one hand, uh, yes, the plan, well, look at what we know, we know that everyone has begun to register objects damaged by their private ones, this information is transferred to the places. and what's next, no information and the reaction we don't know what we have now with the recovery locally and globally, oleksandr, who will restore only the country because we will be ourselves, i.e. the citizens of ukraine, this is quite understandable, but we need appropriate financial assistance first of all, in order to solve the problems that we have, for example, with the budget deficit, this is an important issue, now a special plan for such a quick reconstruction has been proposed in order to restore the destroyed infrastructure of schools, hospitals, etc. and for this we need 17 billion dollars this was announced by the president of the european

union. they slandered the derlilyan fund with their mouths. they said that next year they will provide us with 18 billion dollars. the united states, if i am not mistaken, provides 1 billion 800 thousand dollars every month, that is, aid is coming. on the part of the united states and on the part of international financial organizations and on the part of the european union, and this is necessary - they understand the gravity of the situation in which we found ourselves, but we need to create a platform accordingly, what was called the financial rammstein, that is, such help, since it is about the war to exhaust the cracks of word, we understand that our economy needs stable permanent financial economic assistance and this is precisely what the creation of such a platform in such a platform as the financial rammstein of mr. ilya is aimed at how do you see the plan for the recovery of ukraine,

are we arguing only on our own and how can it be on our own, that is, we have a lot of challenges. there is a specific in this and the governments of western countries have funds that they have actually frozen and, accordingly, either the funds of the oligarchs or the funds of the russian government could be directed right now to restore instead of spending their own however, we see that the governments of these countries they are ready to better spend their taxpayers' funds than, let's say, confiscate these assets of the panel, but here is the question and to our government regarding these assets, did you mention the oligarchs, did you mention the pro-russian ones, but these funds are not only arrested, that babakov, the same fried us what about alpha bank, tell me whether it will be

nationalized or not, no, it is now in an improved condition, it is the same rottenberg, the same ocean plaza in kyiv, the same generators with these oblenergo, nothing is confiscated, it is only arrested but but there medvedchuk, medvedchuk's house , this palace, which until yesterday was guarded by the security police, it was also not confiscated in whose state, after all, what claims can there be to western governments if we and our russian oligarchs cannot figure it out in ourselves, i agree, especially the sanctions were in the principles were applied just last week, that is, something real has already begun to move. 8 months of war. we finally woke up. russian business worked calmly. i counted how many conversations there were about what should be more to tax, confiscate, limit, there was nothing, that is, for 8 months they withdrew capital. they sometimes returned it to finance the war . i am absolutely with you. this is again a question for the

government . the fact that russian oligarchs work for us. are you friends with them or do they have any interests there, for me it was simply that we compared the number of persons against whom sanctions were applied in europe, the united states and ukraine well, until last week, it was a horror, we had such odious persons who are friends of putin, who financed the military complex, well, excuse me, even ukrainians are included, well, excuse me, when in the 19th year they listened to boguslav and only now were arrested, well, this just horror and he says that the authorities knew all our supplies on the hill, the lawyer stated this today, oleksandr said about the russian business well, as for his arrest, not only the rest, but the transfer to

the state, when will this procedure work the 9th month of the war has already passed, please, this is an extremely important question. zinsky said that in the west, if i am not mistaken, there is one trillion russian e-e funds, and this is a huge amount, but the question is that in western countries there is a state of law, the rule of law and in order to confiscate property, it is necessary to go through the appropriate legal procedures, and this happens. well, such a long and rather complicated process is currently the western countries, they have already begun to freeze russian assets, russian funds, property, but still it is necessary to go through the appropriate procedures, because this is private property and the idea of ​​the western world is based on this, but there are very positive examples

. this can become an important precedent. i want to note that we expect the european parliament to adopt a resolution aimed at encouraging the member states of the european union and not only freeze but also confiscate russian property and hand over victims of aggression, that is, this process is taking place, but it takes some time, but i asked about ukraine, when and how long this process will take in ukraine and the confiscation of russian business, the right is clear in europe, its right, but we have the verkhovna rada the president got together, pressed 226, and bye-bye, they confiscated tomorrow there and alpha bank and offshoushin plaza and babakovsky oblenergo with giner, but this is not happening. for some reason, i don't know, the ninth month of the war, someone, for sure, somehow little luck is gained from this, well, this only explanation can be related to the activity of the

legislative power only, because there are all the necessary laws on the basis of which this can be done, this is also a question for law enforcement agencies and the e-e judicial system because we have separation of powers, we have legislative, executive and judicial power, and it is necessary for the judicial power to work here, because this is a very important issue, and it is necessary to support this separation of power, but from the point of view of the legislative, from the point of view of the verkhovna rada, we have done everything what it was necessary and there are all the necessary legislative levers for this panel of questions, we will not lie that we really have a division into executive and legislative, we know that the government was formed in a new main political force , yes, the people must also understand the responsibility for that. who is responsible for that? answer specifically now two packages if i remembered i remembered this

answer gentlemen i remembered do you remember he has a miniature there he says who sews this suit he says i sewed buttons to the buttons there is a question no there is no tight they sit like this and in our country they say it’s not up to me it’s up to the court yes here they say it’s not up to us it’s up to the legislator to legislate and it’s up to the government and the government says and we don’t understand there at all everything goes to the president and everything and in a circle gone, i will simply remind you of the decision regarding, firstly, for example, the deprivation of citizenship of certain individuals, we have a specific judge who is not deprived of citizenship, the question and now we had 25,000 the day before yesterday, the time for answering them has passed. and when there was a question about smugglers, excuse the decision, which courts they just accepted it there, and when you want, you do it. and when you don't want, you look for reasons, you are not judges, the executive power, who has not yet completed the work, has not completed everything that is necessary, this is a

matter for the government, i emphasize that the government is responsible for what the russian oligarchs have done so far work in ukraine and still have property here. and this property could have been working for our direct interests for a long time, well, it is interesting that the russian oligarchs and russian businessmen, collaborators, and this list also gathered supposedly formed, only one, no one made it public and no one knows what is on that list , and maybe now the list is being adjusted, why not the nsdc, for example, we already have this tool and it was working, you know, a french lawyer - this is when the constitution was created. they said that a state in which there is no division there is no power in the constitution, this is also enshrined in our constitution. and if we destroy this division of power, then this is the way to a dictatorship . this cannot be done under any circumstances. i consider this right to be negligent when, for example, from the executive

the authorities demand that it perform the functions of the judiciary, this is wrong because we live in a democratic state governed by the rule of law. we need to support this, that is, everyone must act within the limits of their competence, but act in such a way that, well, it would have concrete results , alexander, but you know i i understand, but they didn't want gennady korban and simply didn't let him into ukraine. without any courts, with a non-ukrainian passport, while bohdan lviv, a judge of the supreme court with a russian passport, walks around kyiv calmly, there are no there are no complaints against him, the citizens immediately have a question . why is the selective approach to foreign citizenship of different citizens who were once citizens of ukraine possible and in parallel, someone is not allowed in and is exposed, but there is no complaint, you understand, well, where is the justice? where is the equality before the law? again, this is a question for law enforcement agencies. and pre-trial bodies, that is, it is necessary to solve this issue, but if there are doubts about their

competence, then you can apply, for example, and ask what is happening, why don't they have the place is like this, let's tell the facts. thank you, let's talk about attacks on infrastructure. let's talk about ukrainian. it's important that ukrenergo decided to extend the blackout throughout the country. forced restrictions will apply to household consumers in the central northern regions of ukraine. whose networks were most affected this week? and we have a plot . on this occasion, let's look at the material about disconnection, what awaits us, what is happening now and what can not be turned on when you need to save power banks, candles and warm blankets this year, ukrainians are urged to be ready for anything , especially this applies to power and water outages throughout the country due to russian missile attacks on the energy infrastructure in the

president's office, they emphasize not to overload the network, everyone needs to save money anastasia lives in a one-room apartment with her husband , she says she began to comply instructions on energy saving right away, now we are more, for example , there are those hours that you can try to use more to re-wash and recharge a if at all during the day we try to save as much as possible and when we leave the house we turn off all the electrical appliances that we only have, what can we do now, we heat food on gas and it tastes even better. but already when we are in a hurry somewhere or somewhere we then we already use microwave light during the day, in particular, the recommended time for their use is from 11:00 p.m. to 6:00 a.m.

it is considered that this is the optimal period for not overloading the network. heaters, irons, boilers, air conditioners , dishwashers, or washing machines, it is prohibited from six to nine, and from 17 to 23, energy workers are called on to refuse to plug in several powerful appliances at the same time, and they ask to turn off the lights where there is no urgent need. but in specialized stores they tell in order to save light, you need to start with energy- saving light bulbs without disassembling them. they used to be led. they were also spiral. well, they are banned because they contain mercury. all led ones save 10 times as much as before. were insatny, they saved five times. that is, it is 10 times more economical than an incandescent light bulb, it is better to

choose a more expensive one because it lasts for a longer time, ok, a similar situation with lamps and switches, which can also save enough light with the right choice, according to the store consultant ivan if you choose an ordinary lamp under an incandescent lamp, it will consume 100 w, but an led lamp will consume only 10. during power surges, specialists advise to always turn off all electrical appliances in the apartment and leave only the most necessary and use them minimally. but popular heaters or convectors consume the most electricity in the house. it draws a lot, it draws 2,000 w at maximum power at minimum initial thousands. you can use an electric device, but with reason. this applies to mixers, blenders

, electric kettles or microwaves. another issue with boilers most of them have timers that can be programmed not to overheat and when the appropriate temperature is reached, the main boiler automatically turns off, in principle, it heated the water and it turned off, that is, when but when you constantly have to wash the dishes there, it turns on again and while the enemy continues to destroy the objects of the energy infrastructure of ukraine, it is important for us to unite and with joint efforts to help save the country's energy system and if earlier ukrainians saved resources to preserve the environment or reducing the amounts in payments, today they are doing it for the sake of a common victory, love, gerashchenko, oleksandr, kuga, espresso, bila tserkva. well, these studios have already said that the main challenge is not even citizens and household consumption, industrial consumption and business, i don't know that oleksandr mereshko stayed with us. please tell us. if not, oleksandr, what are

the main challenges for business and industry in this story, what should be done, please be brief well, if we are talking about business, you know the main thing is to preserve the existing business and the main thing is to preserve people and human capital, this is the most important thing because millions of people have lost their jobs, millions of people have moved abroad and we need to preserve what we have, and i believe that need implement an appropriate tax policy that would contribute to the preservation of business and even stimulate the development of small and medium-sized businesses, primarily businesses, because now the most important thing is to survive the panel well, in fact, it is possible that the taxation system is also needed. now we change when the business does not know whether it will work tomorrow or the day after tomorrow will there be light or will there be production, you know, in the beginning, they made basically the wrong steps, e.e., regarding taxation, and as a result , you have to balance between business support and funds

in the budget and when you do, let's say yes, an imbalance , this of course is wrong, that is, competition, the guard, internal competition and direct budget funds are still necessary, these were the primary funds that we used for the fact that we entered the war, and the business itself, so it is necessary to help them now you have raised more questions about the unjustified blocking of tax invoices . the practice has spread a lot. this practice actually collects funds from the business. but i support by the way, in general, regarding that the business should work again, we specifically emphasize the thesis that it is necessary to maintain the business that currently exists, and not give startups, i would like these funds now, but you have a specific problem, quickly change the order and those funds that you allocate, you allocate for business generators, interest-free loans for a year for two for five years for as much as possible give money so that they have the opportunity to ensure their internal consumption of

electricity at the expense of various generators give loans to install solar power plants, well, wind, of course, everything is difficult, but solar is still fast within one week, in principle, installation, do it, it costs me a lot when i installed it somewhere thousands of dollars, all together, it is a private house, a loan to the parliament for three years, the head of the analytical direction of the network ange and oleksandr merezhka svetta was also with us. and you are in kyiv, and he is not now, as you understand correctly, yesterday he was not there, this morning from 8:00 a.m. he is not there, but hey , well, we will survive it and the main thing is that we know how to win thank you, oleksandr mareshko, people's deputy of ukraine, because you are with us, and yehor, chirynda valevska, were with you for the last five hours. thank you for being with us, don't stay with us