two main components, the first is the support of one's own producer, it is an opportunity for entrepreneurship to increase production, pay wages and thus receive the state, the second is the support of territorial communities of local self-government , today decentralization is being killed and today local producers are being killed by such decisions, this is unacceptable, and if you listen to the statements of the vice-prem' of prime minister mrs. vereshchuk to the ukrainians , do not return home, forgive me. it seems to me that this is a sufficiently dangerous public call to citizens of ukraine, because ukrainians have no other state than the one that exists today from the western to the eastern borders of ukraine, vitrenko was fired from the position of the head of naftogaz and, in general, i want to understand how many deputies support

this decision in general in the discussions, and what to do next what other personnel changes are waiting for them, yes, you understand the rates of the weather vane, that is, there was a sudden resignation, we did not support the appointment of mr. vitrenko to this position, we believed that his predecessor kobelev before all the discussions moments that were before this person actually played a very serious role in the ukrainian-russian legal and gas confrontation, do you remember that kobolev won in the courts under kobolev, the decisions that were still made under president poroshenko , several billion dollars of money was returned and kobolev refused these funds then put at the disposal of the cabinet of ministers why because he understood that it would be necessary to buy gas, it would be necessary to fill the storage, and then the disagreeable kobolev

was taken away and put in this position, forgive me for such a phrase of the manual vitrenko, because any wishes that came from the authorities gave the impression that vitrenko carried out absolutely without any disputes, and billions of dollars of money were transferred to the budget, and gas was not purchased today, and therefore the manual vitrenko will certainly become such a good person of all the problems that will now be in the gas energy sector because naftogaz , which in the 18th year was a profitable structure that paid huge sums from its financial and economic activities, in the 21st year turned into a loss-making enterprise and all this happened under mr. vitrenka, so when we appointed mr. vitrenka, we did not support this story, because we believed that this is a very dangerous story in the ukrainian-russian gas confrontation, his

release is sufficient for this by the decision of the cabinet of ministers, this is such an internal powerful kitchen, which will certainly not involve deputies of the supreme councilors i know that the name of the minister of regional development, mr. chernyshov, is being heard now as a certain candidate for the position of the head of naftogaz, is it good or bad, well, what is happening now is it is bad, we definitely need to change this situation, we will see what proposals and what candidature will be the next head of naftogaz, a strategic ukrainian enterprise in the gas and energy confrontation between ukraine and russia. perhaps there are already several ministers who are due to be expelled for some reason or another, just the dismissal of positions is not

happening. well, you know that we have a lot remarks to this government, because in economic terms, with all the problematic issues that exist today , well, i am convinced that more can be done and professional people are enough in ukraine and they must be returned to power. nature, this is unacceptable, it is not the time for politics, it is not the time to settle accounts, it is the time to unite and confront the enemy, that is why there will be proposals, we will all carefully consider them. as they say, the constitutional court of ukraine recognized the law on the abolition of inviolability in a way that corresponds to the constitution of ukraine, 50 people's deputies tried to challenge it, mainly from the opposition party. meanwhile, the verkhovna rada is calling for the adoption of a law on the deprivation of the right of representatives of the opposition party to participate in the work of the

parliament. moreover, some of them are actually no longer citizens of our country. read more in the story from things and on exit the regulatory committee of the verkhovna rada proposes to deprive the mandate of two deputies vadym rabinovych from the banned police union and the servant of the people ihor vasylkovsky basis decree volodymyr zelenskyi about the termination of their citizenship due to the presence of passports of other countries, as reported by the media, rabinovych apparently has israeli and vasylkivskyi israeli and bulgarian passports, an associate of medvedchuk rabinovych escaped from ukraine until february 24, but the servant ihor vasilkovskii continues to go to parliament meetings and vote although as you can see from the transcript of the meeting of the regulatory committee, the president signed the decree on july 18, that is, more than three months ago, according to vasylkovsky, he was not familiarized with the original document

the decree was also published on the presidential website, since it contains personal data. zelensky himself, without any surnames, only confirmed the fact of its signing on a regular basis . it is still unknown that in the summer people's deputy serhiy vlasenko published the text of what seems to be the same decree of zelensky in it except for rabinovych and vasilkovskyi and eight other people, including ihor kolomoisky, in early october investigative journalists met the oligarch near the office of the anti-corruption bureau in kyiv, where kolomoisky was leaving after the interrogation, he essentially refrained from commenting. why do you think the president stripped you of your citizenship, i don't comment on such nonsense, another famous name businessman hennadiy korban

was once close to kolomoi, now an ally of the mayor of dnipro boris filatov. on july 22, four days after the signing of the decree, he tried to enter the ukraine from poland, however, the border guards did not let him in, taking away his ukrainian passport, out of sheer malice . volya decided that i should not be allowed to enter ukraine . so far not introduced and at the request of lawyers not provided in ukrainian legislation among the grounds for loss of a ukrainian passport, the acquisition of citizenship of other countries is mentioned in particular. however, the procedure itself was not prescribed in detail, and therefore some lawyers have doubts about the legality of such decrees. well, we are returning to our live broadcast in the studio

. it's as if we were banned, but the former members of the upsj-deputies from the upsj currently feel comfortable in the parliament hall, i didn't say that it was completely comfortable, but not bad, as with this case, i immediately apologize for the quality of the picture, we don't have electricity, that's why i'm on such an autonomous power supply, that's why i apologize, well, well, during halloween, which lasts from february 24. so we're not used to it. the picture is quite good and the sound is normal. continue, oleksandr

. the picture looks a bit absurd due to the fact that there are some deputies who still formally have deputy mandates, although they are open collaborators against whom criminal cases have been initiated with accusations of treason moreover, even viktor medvedchuk, whom ukraine recently exchanged for the ukrainian heroes of the defenders of australia, still has a deputy mandate, and the deputy also has someone to close kuzmin and in relation to whom criminal cases have been committed, in addition, he has a deputy mandate and is formally considered a deputy. it seems that oleksiy kovalev of the majority from kherson oblast was killed, and it is obvious that here ukrainian legislation does not have time to follow the

events that are taking place because, according to the law on the status of a people's deputy, there are six of legal grounds for the early termination of e-e parliamentary powers a-e of course among those from this list there is also death, but e-e let's say if we consider the e-e case of kovalev, then the reports that were in the mass media e posts in social networks and even photos of the publication seem to be his the burial and also the awarding of his parents by the occupation authorities, this is not enough for the state authorities to officially and formally take away the deputy , the same also applies to the deputies against whom the criminal proceedings are still ongoing the judicial investigation, the judicial examination of the mandate remains with these deputies, but there is another procedure and another point

- this is actually the loss of the mandate in connection with the loss of citizenship, which we actually see in the case of vasylkivskyi and volodymyr rabinovych, which should be considered by the parliament in the near future because we know that there are already registered draft resolutions from the regulatory committee regarding this issue , but in connection with this, the question regarding viktor medvedchuk also logically arises, because we know that , again, according to the legislation of the state of ukraine cannot give its citizens to another country, and if this happened, then we can assume that viktor medvedchuk was exchanged by ukraine due to the fact that he has the citizenship of most likely the country of the aggressor, and uh, this exchange took place thanks to this and that the council and the regulatory committee

should also consider the issue of the loss of parliamentary powers regarding the determination of mr. oleksandr, this is actually a very delicate point. the fact is that the state of ukraine recognizes the person as its citizen in the first place, even if this the person has other citizenships, that is, i understand that medvedchuk was exchanged in connection with the fact that his ukrainian citizenship was taken away, not only because he is a citizen of the russian federation, but of course we can assume here because there are no official comments and i am not known in under what status did this exchange take place, but at the same time we see in the case of rabinovych and vasilkivskyi that this draft of the presidential decree was issued back in july and still communications between several state institutions are not automatically it happened, that is, if a decree is issued, it is not

published, but the president's office should contact it, or vice versa, the staff of the verkhovna rada or the regulatory committee should contact the president's office to initiate this issue and find out if there is a decree, there is no decree, if there is one, whether there are people's deputies in this list, if there is one, who should start the procedure for the premature termination of the deputies' powers, but for some reason this still does not exist. and it is necessary to find out everything so that, thanks to individual people's deputies or thanks to to journalists and the public, now let's try to ask the people's deputy present in the studio, oleg synyutka. so, what do you think is happening in this difficult case, as if the obvious things are the same medvedchuk, they returned him to russia, there the force of certain procedures changed him, so everyone knows who he is and what does he have to the people's deputy of ukraine, especially in the current

situation ? in relation to the collaborators, there are those collaborators who demonstrate the patriotism of the representatives of the government. and there are those collaborators who are beneficial to the government and are used in other things, in particular, in voting . and there are collaborators with whom, as i understand it, a decision has not yet been made what to do with them. patriotism is vasylkivskyi and rabinovych, because indeed the committee's regulations considered the issue of depriving them of the status of people's deputies on the basis of the decree on the termination of the ukrainian citizenship, the deputies who are profitable today are all the former deputies from the polish people's party who are in

the session hall and who vote absolutely in unison because the representatives of the government are voting today, more than that, sometimes in the session hall we observe such strange pictures when the deputy head of the servant of the people faction runs in that place in that part of the parliamentary hall where the former members of the opposition party sit and commands them or asks them questions why do n't you vote or do you vote and the third part of which i understand that a decision has not yet been made because whether there is medvedchuk is a collaborator, and it is obvious whether derkach is a collaborator, more than that, he is not even our allies in the united states anymore, he is already recognized by the ukrainian authorities as a russian agent, is he a collaborator or was a collaborator, the famously infamous kovalev, it is not known whether he is alive today or he is already in hell, but for sure he is a person who de facto

publicly declared his collaboration bias and work for the aggressor countries, we asked questions on the regulations of the committee please show for official use with all vultures decree the president of ukraine, in which either these people are deprived of citizenship or they do not exist. well, at the moment, everything ended with an appeal to the committee, to the head of the regulatory committee , to send a request to the president's office to provide a full text of the case, because we received an excerpt about robinovych, we received an excerpt about vasylkivskyi, and today there is no understanding whether there is a presidential decree on other collaborators or not. if there is none, then i am convinced that i should raise public questions to the office of the president, why there is none. if these names are in the presidential decree then they should be submitted to the regulatory committee

in order to deprive these people of the status of a people's deputy. it's very simple. you just have to give clear answers to questions and not use double standards in relation to collaborators, mr. oleksandr. well, we just heard such an answer from a parliamentarian, in particular, we understand that sabotage on a certain level is also happening within the walls of the ukrainian parliament, what to change, how to influence, yes. well, i absolutely agree with what was said, there must be, first of all, there must be communication between two state institutions, well, it looks very strange when one state body does not know what the other is doing, and in relation to such citizens with such a status, and i also want to confirm the words that we are now seeing the work of voting those deputies who

were previously part of the psg faction in that they vote for neeson with the proposed solutions, we did a separate analysis on this and well, if there was no such situation before , then there was the lowest percentage of participation in the vote, and now we will vote mostly in favor, they almost never vote against, and what’s more, if you look at their speeches, we also made a separate manual analysis of the changes in the dynamics of the speeches, and the representatives of the opposition party. there were uh and uh, moreover, yes, they are now separate representatives of this former faction from the group for the restoration of ukraine, they are now even speaking as speakers at the national marathon on the tv channel

rada uh, and they are not exactly commenting on their own profile issues - not from those committees, there are deputies working somewhere, but they act as speakers, and this also causes such dissociation and wonder because until recently they were not in the media sphere . and now they are speakers on the official parliamentary tv channel, so the situation is actually uh raises more questions than answers. thank you, oleksandr, for your work. oleksandr salizhenko, a parliamentary analyst of the movement, was honestly in touch with us , albeit from the dark, but still sheds light on the complex uh, intricacies of our ukrainian politics people's deputy of ukraine thank you, dear tv viewers, for watching and analyzing with us the difficult vicissitudes unfolding in our country. well, of

course. thank you khrystyna yatskiv for the brilliant moderation of the broadcast . all those who follow us on other sites are waiting for the project of collaborators list of miklushki you will be with espresso in the future, see this week in the program collaborators list of miklushki ukrainian kulibins in the service of the occupier as an enemy the army received sichi engines from russia plus for russia they give a traitor from ukroboronprom why the leading design engineer asked for citizenship from putin law enforcement officers discovered electronic media with pro-kremlin propaganda as well as design documentation on aircraft construction and retribution for opportunities how to get a scientific degree in ukraine and then become a gauleiter for

invaders, every war gives birth to heroes. unfortunately , there are also helpless people, and traitors are not only those who sided with the enemy with weapons, helping them informantly submits the positions of the armed forces adjusts the fire or holds positions in the occupation administrations, the governments of the collaborators can safely be counted and those who help the killers technologically, it is somehow unfair to ignore them, on october 30, our mechanical engineers celebrated their professional holiday and, unfortunately, i am forced to state that not all of them are united by intellectual the work and experience of designing, building or operating equipment for some people was united by collaborationism, and i will tell you about such kulibins in the service of the occupier today let's start with the loudest arrest in recent months. the security service of ukraine, in cooperation with russia, kidnapped

vyacheslav boguslaev, the president of the motor sich corporation, and oleg dzyuba, the head of external economic activity. in the country , a terrorist and wanted to be banned a long time ago, a pro-russian politician, a deputy of four convocations of the verkhovna rada from pro-russian political forces of the city committee on security and defense, professor vyacheslav boguslaev, the hero of ukraine, came up with a way to circumvent sanctions and even after a full-scale invasion continued to supply ukrainian engines to russia, the occupiers installed them on their military attack helicopters, the alligator peregrine and night hunter, equipping ork helicopters with their engines is also exactly what to give the enemy a bullet before one's own execution, so that no one has doubts about boguslaev's collaborative activities, the sbu released fragments

recordings of telephone conversations of this hero with his russian partners, or rather curators, i know you know, i smoke dozens of valves, and everything is fine with us, in general, we are ready to send only to think through croatia , somewhere you have been to montenegro, where have you- то былы хороший конфеты, so i want you, i thought quickly, and how can we have a contract with you? a great deal of special cynicism is added to this story by how boguslaev reacts to the shelling of his native enterprise in zaporizhzhia. now boguslaev and his assistant in trade with russia dzyuba is in a pre-trial detention center. they both have 15

years behind bars, i was convinced that until the end of their miserable days they will look at the ukrainian sky through the bars, but in the office of the president they believe that the traitor can still be useful, maybe they will exchange him for ukrainian defenders who are in russian captivity there, in the moscow swamps, the old collaborator will be able to hang all the walls with the russian coats of arms that were found in his possession during the detention in ukraine and make the passport of the terrorist's country. you will not have to go to boguslaev he is there if it helps to bring our defenders home, i think no one will be against it while the leading engineer and designer of the enterprise antonov, a resident of irpen , having pro-russian sentiments, publicly supported the atrocities of the army of the occupying state, in particular , the suspect distributed a map of ukraine on which part of the territory of our state allegedly became the property of neighboring countries there is no such country as

ukraine, it is the outskirts of russia under our power, in truth , such messengers were promoted and supported by the suspected official repeatedly appealed to of the president of the russian federation with a request to grant him russian citizenship. during the searches of the agitator's residence, law enforcement officers found electronic media with pro-kremlin propaganda, as well as design documentation for aircraft construction. now the engineer-collaborator will spend five years behind bars, and instead of real aircraft, he will only design airplanes from miniatures. in the zone and another traitorous engineer was exposed in zhytomyr , a correctional colony employee convinced his colleagues that the russian troops were not shelling or bombing civilians, but they only target military facilities, claimed that ukraine should immediately stop hostilities and accept the demands put forward by russia to surrender the occupied territories. thus

, the collaborator has every chance to change his place of work to his place of residence. there is a town of nova kakhovka in the kherson region where he works above vocational school due to the occupation, the institution was forced to switch to an online form of education, but for many teachers it seemed acceptable to continue the educational process according to russian standards. the real directorate of the school published a list of traitors, this is the deputy director, two senior masters, 12 master teachers and a librarian, 18 other employees, among whom are cleaners, secretaries, a driver, a plumber, an engineer, and a watchman. i wonder what they were all guided by, because the diploma, let's say a technician or a mechanic, that they were going to issue there will not have any power whatsoever i wonder if the so-called teachers told their students about this, a separate caste of engineer-traitors are those who became officials well, as officials servants

of the russian regime in the occupation administrations, i have already talked about andriy shevchyk, the chief engineer of the zaporozhye nuclear plant, an outright ukrainophobe who was just waiting for the arrival of the russian peace, the russo-fascists had appointed him as the gauleiter of the energy donation and headed the city of shevchyk , for a short time the explosive planted in the traitor's entrance did its job in public, a collaborator did not appear again, do you recognize this buffoon yevhen balytsky, a former deputy of the verkhovna rada, and now appointed by the occupiers to look after the occupied part of zaporizhzhia, the mediologist should break and hammer the hay bales, bad pasta, so that the word fascist never again sounded on our land, among the main achievements of this traitor, it is possible to note the organization of a pseudo-referendum, the issuance of russian passports, total propaganda of the export

of ukrainian grain to russia, why do i mention him in this program balytsky, a pilot-engineer by education, graduated from the higher military aviation school in tambov, russia, where he received the rank of lieutenant and served until 1995 in the ranks of the armed forces of ukraine, he went to the reserve with the rank of captain, as an engineer, he could now be in the armed forces of ukraine to help torture a hand from the sky, but he chose the worthless path of a collaborator, the story of the pseudo -mayor of occupied berdyansk, oleksandr saulenko, who came out of nowhere and proclaimed himself the head of the city, but at first it will not be easy and i am confident that we will be able to establish a peaceful life with the brotherly russian people. we know the peaceful life brought by the russian army and its brotherly people, because we see every day with our own eyes what to fix this loser in the city, who two days before the full-scale invasion of russia was looking for a job

as a labor protection engineer, is a big mystery, but i am sure that our military will soon work with him, so that no security will help. well, how can we not mention in this block oleksiy chaloy, a ukrainian collaborator who after of the annexation of crimea in 2014, he declared himself the mayor of sevastopol and was appointed its governor. here he is in the photo with putin. chaly was born in moscow in the family of a ukrainian scientific designer of electrical devices and a candidate associate professor of technical sciences at the sevastopol instrument-building institute studied there and defended his doctoral thesis and was a future collaborator himself, after which he founded the scientific research enterprise taurida-electrician, which brought him millions of dollars and that there are millions and hundreds of millions, a vivid example of how ukraine gave education, work, the opportunity to develop and earn a instead, she received a knife in the back. this

was another batch of collaborators from the miklushka list. we are waiting for the success of our armed forces in all directions, so that for treason every chaly despair in the zone if you want to tell us about collaborators in your region, write to me at this email address or just on facebook . see you in a week on the espresso broadcast, death to enemies , it's 5 p.m. in ukraine, this means that news time on the espresso tv channel in the studio of iryna koval, too. congratulations to all the spectators and to the most important events, another loss of the invaders in the south. the armed forces of ukraine struck a good blow against the invaders in kherson at the spartak stadium. our defenders targeted the anti-aircraft defense systems