of ministers that will determine these criteria, this order, we will try to uh, uh, lay down transparent criteria, more or less, that corresponded to the hm characteristics of the state fund for regional development, here the most important point is that you correctly said that transparency should be ensured and justice should be ensured as the minimum participation of the subjective invoice , i.e. the commission should consider only e-e-e-e-e we will say so for formal reasons if the object meets the readiness documentation is necessary, and then the terms of the schedule for its financing are simply determined. if a subjective factor is included, for example, this municipality or these regions will be given because the committee of m-m includes

representatives of hmm from that region or at the level of the cabinet of ministers or at the level of the verkhovna rada, of course we get not very good coloring pages, but in literally 15-20 seconds there is an answer with educational subsidies. how is the matter resolved, will there be anything to pay the teachers global subventions, we predict a huge deficit, er, centralization has taken place at the er government level, and we believe that we will face problems in all areas from december, er, december, january, february, we strongly opposed these changes. well, let's see uh, how will they work, but we are evaluating it, these changes are negative, accepted the answer thank you very much, uh, well, oleksandr slobozhan, the executive director of the association of cities of ukraine, was with

us, but now with us is mykhailo nepran, the first vice-president of the chamber of commerce and industry of ukraine a member of the ukrainian business council, let's start talking with him about the prices of eggs, 169 hryvnias for a dozen , mr. mykhailo, good morning, well, that's just a sky-high price, and eggs are now some kind of delicacy, almost red caviar. good morning, well, it's not a sky-high price i was in kosmos yesterday in the evening, i think i'll stop by before our meeting with you and see how much they sell in the store. how much do experts write on the internet? and i say live, but there is uah 87 a dozen, but remember, you and i analyzed the salt situation in my opinion four months ago there was a time when the price rose from uah 20 a pack to almost 100 five times, and yesterday i spoke with

egg producers from kyiv oblast, zhytomyr oblast. a gap in growing a actually speaking, what is going on, we talked and i am looking at this situation. i have the impression that this is such a big adventure, a big divorce, what is it called? and here i am for the purpose, i remembered how we talked with you. look what they say to me in the month of january the cost of a dozen eggs was uah 12, i.e. 12 kopecks , an egg was overproduced, there was a surplus, nobody needed these eggs, now, roughly speaking, uah 80 , the price has risen almost 7.5 times, well, someone needed it, and what if we talk from the point of view of what all the eggs will not be lost, well, there are experts who will give negative forecasts, because negative forecasts are always shown and always appear in the first lines of the news, but

they say that poultry farms are working and producing grain and there will be no shortage of grain after in the new year, there will be even more chickens because this technological chain, which was broken, will refuse to refuse, and now it's the middle of december, the beginning of january, and the new chickens, the ones that were supposed to lay, the ones that were planted in may, will lay, that's why you know me to be honest well, well, yes, someone is playing for an increase, like on the stock exchange, someone earns from a decrease, and here someone earns from an increase. well, plus there is also such an element of panic, plus there is also the fact that people are so hyped up, everything is gone, gone, ran, ran, ran, ran they bought bought, well, in the bazaar they generally sell more than 100 uah, you see the market is like this. well, we have a homemade one, it’s better than in a store, buy it for 100 uah. well, the aunt from the village can at least this time earn something, so that our colleagues will not give in i panic, doctors say that

you can't often eat dishes made from eggs because it has a bad effect on the heart . we only export all eggs and that's it the country also belongs to us, no, absolutely, absolutely , there is no problem, i have such unofficial information, we communicate very intensively with business. well, we have a large agrarian neighbor - this is poland. yes, the truth is that we have an interesting situation with them, so we we import, then they import to us. this year, for example, there was an interesting situation with potatoes, because there was a drought in europe. roughly speaking 12 hryvnias per kg of potatoes despite the fact that traditionally poland has always exported. we imported potatoes from poland, so the polish egg producers are already

looking at our retail chains and even, as lviv residents will tell me, they are selecting possible warehouse premises, so the first thing i want to say to all the talk that there will be no eggs, well, this is all artificially inflating the situation, the eggs are there and there will be no need to worry about it, who is already holding on to his heart like this, buy yourself two dozen eus, put them in the refrigerator, their shelf life, i told me a familiar veterinarian, 90 days, cheer yourself up and sit quietly, there is a lack of such a speech, maybe the president, do you remember how viktor fedorovych said that there is something i have no hands for, i will tell you, but now i would go out, and the president said, where are the eggs now, but everyone is on the eggs, yes , yes, yes, yes, yes, yes from eggs to other food products, they say that on the eve of winter, another price jump awaits us, e.e. more than 20 by 27 percent, food products,

household chemicals and appliances are more expensive by almost 24 e.e., alcohol, cigarettes by 19.5%. well, let people become more expensive they will be healthier, let's switch to alcohol, circuses. i understand that it is the cheapest. i don't understand any experts with such accuracy. 24% gives a rise in price. you know that. well, as raznikovich said when he was asked about going to the surgery , he says, i have tarot cards with me today i didn't take it . well, yes, and here, of course, as they say, i take my hat off to the expert who calculated directly by 24%, but this is all guesswork on coffee grounds, in reality the situation is different, it will be such a diverse situation, people will depend on that how big is the share of fuel and lubricants in the production of this or that product? i spoke this week with one of the large producers of one of the leaders in

poultry production, which produces chicken, and i asked him a question of course, i say that i speak regularly on television and journalists ask me and what forecast does he say? you can calmly and firmly say that chicken will become more expensive . a large producer has its own small compound feed plant, they bought it at the price when wheat was shown - when grain was uah 2,500, not uah 9,000, as it was last year in such a period, that is, they said that the price of chicken will not increase, it will be at this level, and thank god for eggs we will always have chicken soup with you and there will be delicious fried chicken. regarding the milk, the milkmen also give forecasts that if there is, it will be related to about 50%, no more, as with the younger milk production. thank god. it's also good, even they say a surplus

production, since the consumption of opal in our country, which has gone out by several million, consumption has decreased because of this, in principle, and there is no possibility to raise prices, and here are the main social products, you know, they are regulated by the same bread and pity , that is, there are no reasons for such a large growth, it can grow with e there may be non-social packages, especially where there is a large consumption of fuel , because the increase in the price of gasoline due to the increase in the price of diesel fuel will, of course, affect all of this, and on the other hand, we had a good grain harvest there will be pasta, there will be bread, so there will be no famine, we will not push the situation on the contrary, and now there is still an opportunity to buy vegetables, fruits, which are still fairs, they are still held, although not as intensively as before the war, stock up a little in order to survive the winter normally, especially for autumn vegetables, for example , even fell by themselves. the same potatoes were sold at

retail, but you know what is interesting. chernihiv oblast, which traditionally produces there itself, has a cheap price of 2.50 m . they sold it to me. i also sold it on the internet platform. notice how the people have progressed. the most expensive potatoes. it was in odesa, in privoza, 30 uah per kg. well, in the south, potatoes are always more expensive, or because of the climatic conditions there, potatoes do not grow. grapes grow there. tomatoes grow there, so there is such a gap, but there are many potatoes. potatoes are good and the average price is somewhere around 10- 15 hryvnias depending on the region, that is, i would not have made such panicky statements, such panicky moods and would not have escalated the situation , well, in fact, i understood that the borscht will be cheaper in price due to what is said by the favorite occupation of all experts who tell carrots but fortunately carrots are not exactly the main element of borscht, because when you cook, you know what's there.

the main thing is to have a piece of good meat and to have rich borscht, but potatoes are inexpensive , cabbage is not expensive, there are red beets, so borscht will be with borscht and let's go with the chicken and the egg. that 's right, it's great. regarding the budget, again, i 'm asking about the indicators. what would you pay attention to, like the vice president of the chamber of industry ? is everything okay for business there? i'm looking at things like grants to create business development 1 billion 370 million. it's just some pennies. what else can you say about this budget? you know, let's call things our own. to be a military economy well, we have come to this, we have a military budget, 60% of the budget goes to

defense , goes to security. an understanding of what if it doesn't happen defends independence, then talking about any business, any development, in general, about our existence as us and as physically people is just about nothing. therefore, let's be realistic, we are a fighting country and we have a military budget and business, this is an understanding of what we want or we don't want to hope that someone will support something, someone will pay something. well, just nothing. i would speak from a different point of view now, and we had several meetings with the hetmanship with other heads of the economy on the block from the first vice-premier of the minister of economy sviridenko and with my point of view and we are in favor of the fact that now, taking into account the state of war, it was possible to carry out the maximum amount of regulation, simplify the rules of the game

as much as possible, ensure the conditions for business as much as possible, you know as they say, if you can't help, then at least don't interfere, especially since these deregulatory processes are a simplification, a ban on inspections a er, they do not require any additional funds, you know, figuratively speaking, give maximum freedom, although the project is very good, we will see how it goes, i even wrote a post on this topic, we can do it separately let's talk now, we'll try. one of the three stops of corruption is firemen. you know, the fireman's favorite pastime is to come with a business inspection and be sure to come to the regulatory acts that exist in ukraine. find a flaw in any company, in any store, in any sports club. well, it wouldn't be a problem, there would be a desire so, now, uh, adopt changes to the legislation, which transfers, cancels inspections, but transfers it to insurance, to the insurance liability of the business owner. that is, you uh,

buy insurance before you pass an independent e-e fire audit, an insurance company insures and you pay the insurance, and if god forbid something happens, then you will already pay with your money e-e in the event that, as a result of your violation, god forbid, an accident, fire or something else happens and at the same time, the firemen will not have the right to check, you know. if it is possible to overcome at least one of the types of corruption that exist in ukraine in relation to the business of the government, well, it would be a very good signal for the insurance company, it will be from the firemen is there a specially created insurance company, or will it be possible to choose that insurance company? you know, of course, i would like firefighters to make their own insurance company. well, we cooperate with insurance companies, because when they are taken out on the road network, when you want to take out some equipment for example, for an exhibition abroad,

you can pay 30% of the cost, and you can insure the trip with insurance or arrange temporary customs clearance, that is, there are three options that a business can choose, so we do not have an insurance company i don't have my own insurance company, for an insurance company to add such a service there are very high requirements, because it is for example , one of the galleries has contacted us now and it is taking two sculptures to the exhibition and their cost is 6 million euros, so not every insurance company is ready to take responsibility and insure such a cost. so it is not as primitive and simple as it seems, therefore, in any case, there are still national banks that determine whether to insure, because we talked to them about this topic, they have their own questions problems, but in any case, you already know that this is an option to bypass the abyss and overcome it is practically impossible. well, in principle, this is the right

idea, in any case, because it is so . first of all, there is an insurance company abroad everywhere, it is really interested in it so that it does not happen there fire in order not to pay your money later. you understand what you are saying to the fireman, but he, they can resettle. i think there are people there who are not poor. i can resettle and make an insurance company to get licenses, but you are absolutely correct in saying that they are not interested. without an insurance company, the ideal option is that you paid the insurance, nothing happened, yes. and she later made money from it, and when the insurance payment is made, the insurance company loses, so it is ideal for them that everything should be fine, that the year ends and there is money left. and secondly, if there was a fire, then we know where the money comes from, there is no need to dry the heads of the municipal authorities there, uh, everyone went begging because we are drunkards, accept us, we ourselves are out of place at last it was a strong step in

the direction of some civilizational solutions or the world invented everything a long, long time ago. thank you very much, mr. mykhailo nepravin. he was with us. he talked a little bit about the evaluation. he says that everything will be fine with our eggs, that the prices will not rise much. well, who can stock up and make some stocks? although i think that ukrainians are trained in all kinds of different er, the 90s, and before the 90s and the 1000s, they always have stocks, yes, stocks of all kinds of good things, which well, even more so with the current power cuts, all kinds of twists and turns, they really help and save, because something that can be stored longer is not the fact that regardless of the refrigerator, it comes in handy. by the way, we can show you an interesting video. i think it's real. i saw svyatoslav pavlyuk's video of an energy saving expert. it's actually about the necessity of

why it's important to save electricity. oh my god, even look there, change the light bulb if it's old . she is not yet frugal, she literally consumes more time and time again. well, just to understand what such a small word like a regular toaster means, god, where is it? i wanted to show people, but here they show and this is how they show it is simply the world champion in track e-e of track e-e bicycle races, here he is, his task now is to prepare toast for himself with an ordinary toaster, but with the help of electric-e-e energy that he himself produces now on an exercise bike and this is the world champion in him so that you understand he has a hip girth of 71 cm 74 it is possible i just remember see if you match this parameter under this parameter and here he is just trying to catch up

with 700 w this is the usual standard that's just just a beautiful crust on the bread and what do you know how to end up i'm like this honestly it will end up uh this let's say it's very difficult if so yes if you're not an olympic champion frankly speaking you're unlikely to make yourself a toast with only your energy here eh robert first man is the name of this olympic athlete 74 cm and he has a leg girth, and to be honest, he was able to toast himself, but then he said after this test he said that my legs have never hurt so much, for sure, yes, not so much extremely it is difficult and this shows how important it is to protect this energy, it is not uh. this is if you do not have horse health and you can produce a lot

of electricity electricity. uh, the russian army from our territory. well, in the meantime, let 's actually ask ourselves what is there in russia and how is it with their economy ? mr. ivan uz , the chief consultant of the institute of strategic studies, candidate of economic sciences. the studio is all of us we all sit and wait, when will the russians get so bad over there that they will say, listen, cancel that special military operation, take away those soldiers of ours, we don't have anything to eat here, and they don't get sick, and somehow these sanctions work in the end or they don't work against them, you know i immediately remembered one wonderful soviet film with our actor leonid bykov, when he was asked how he was doing, his answer was everything is falling normally, but actually this phrase fully corresponds to the state of russia

, that is, unfortunately, for us, it is falling as fast as we would like that, but you know, before the start of the broadcast, you talked about how it is necessary to have light here in moscow, it is also clear how important it is, let me remind you that yesterday the central part of moscow would be light for a certain time and this led to a rather interesting situation when their president was on the radio it seems to putin that two or three ministers sat without light at all because there was no light in their ministries. that is, it is to the point that karma exists in general and that is why they also flew away, but this also demonstrates the fact that these sanctions which were introduced against russia back in the - well, they were partly there before the beginning, but more significantly since february 24, they appeared, they lead, in addition to the smaller one, to the fact that russia adheres to very important components, which now, as they fail, russia cannot to replace and that's why

there will be more problems with the mobile connection. they didn't have electricity in moscow for several hours, and maybe it won't be until the end of the year. it's not the last time when this happened, and the most important thing is that there are a lot of factories in russia that resented the fact that they they bought some components of this production abroad. they simply do not exist. therefore, the production stops, first of all, it is the bearings, because recently an interesting study appeared that russia cannot produce complex wagons because for the railway, because they need bearings, which i bought in sweden and sweden does not supply them now due to sanctions. therefore, the branches of the industry are bent on the question that, well, it is somehow a very long time. counts on the 24th-25th year, it is strange for me because i am not sure that there will be anything from that economy in the

24th year, by the way, we will now show you the photo where the russian ministers are sitting without light, like this, it is dark - it was very dark, exactly when yesterday, my god, bots, these kremlin rafts wrote in the chat that please turn off the light with these vile drivers on the express, it is impossible to have them for strengthening, andrii wrote, yes, this is what we made your minister, she just took revenge. ivan do things are interesting, what is the most as far as i understand , the russian auto industry is suffering so far, including the fact that somehow the russians are concerned with them, for example, the fate of chinese cars has increased three times, nevertheless, the chinese have come to help, they put in a powerful leg or shoulder e- to the russians , that is, in principle. following the example of china, that is, china can replace all the imports that russia is currently

losing. you know, first of all, the question is not only in the quality of goods, that is, an unconditionally chinese car can replace a mercedes. by the way, any even the soviet muscovite can replace the mercedes without any problems, this is a car, but as it is prepared in many countries, the difference between them is that, after all , a mercedes is a car, and a muscovite - no, although this car is formal, but still, it does not provide the comfort that we are used to in russia, like any person in the world, gets used to the full level of comfort, and now what is happening in russia is the return of not even a decade. and for a few, i will remind you of a humorous song that appeared in russia about 3-4 months ago about that russians need to remember the times when they went around their garage on the weekends and spent all the time

under their car. because the cars that are now returning to their market and on which they will drive. from the owners that they are constantly doing something. no, but since those days , the russians have already gotten used to how to spend all these weekends in cars, because if something was not very strong, the cars would break down, but now it will all happen. let's say that it will become the norm when there the car they have, uh, you already bought it there, in 2-3 weeks you need to iron out something in it, because something went wrong, that's why uh, they are replacing an important one. these goods are imported, but the quality is much lower, and this is very important until april month in russia there was no such thing as the so-called parallel import, so what is this the same thing, but i see that according to the

latest figures, they now have parallel imports of a wide variety of goods, from sneakers, relatively speaking , to adidas tesla cars worth 12.5 billion dollars have already been imported this is how this parallel import works so that we allow it in russia at all. see what parallel import is when it is forbidden to supply certain goods to the country, and that is why these goods do not come from the manufacturer. you turn it on and it didn't turn on at you why because the quality is a little bit wrong and what do you do in a normal situation you go to the company that tells you about a 20 tv and say compensate and when it's a parallel import i'm sorry you won't be able to approach anyone, because officially , you shouldn't have a tv at all, this is just an example of parallel imports - it's when the supplier is not responsible for the quality of this

product. and plus the price, and the price will probably be increased because it's still going on through resellers who do not know how it is transported across the border, of course because each link in this supply line will take some percentage. the same, even kazakhstan or armenia or georgia or another country through which goods enter russia and even turkey and they everyone will take their percentage for the fact that this product goes to them, that is, what can be bought there in other countries of the world at a much lower price in russia, she will pay extra for the fact that they do not have direct supply, that is, you can live for a certain time, but the residents as much as they have, let's say, adequate reserves. but recently there was a statement that the russian government, at least prime minister myshustin, took one trillion

rubles from the russian national welfare fund because they do not have enough money for normal the functioning of the state, i don't know what their statistics are, and this fund had before they took one, there were 11 districts, that is, there are 10 left if they will take trillions a month, well, count whether there are 10 months left, and this is on the condition that they lied about these numbers, and the experience of cooperation with russia shows that they really like to lie and add some things, so i think that there are 10 , and somewhere at most six or seven trillion, mr. ivan, but 10 months of war are still very huge losses, and we see that even despite the fact that the russian the military is poorly equipped, despite the fact that russia is running out of missiles, they can get ballistic missiles from iran, again, iranian drones are flying over ukraine, which russia received, and one way or another, these are also losses among the

civilian population, and russia continues to fight as hard as it can - does the world see that these sanctions, which are there, are acting but very slowly, or maybe there could be some sanctions that would speed up and shorten the eye by 10 months, a shorter period, the world definitely sees. another question is to find ways. how to press because i let me remind you that iran was also a vassal for many years, which did not prevent iran from actually creating these thrones and these missiles, that is, despite this constant pressure, the country still had the opportunity to produce such good weapons that russia fully recognized that iran, from the point of view of construction in the of weapons is much higher than that of russia, in fact, the fact that they bought rana, they admitted that they are lagging behind rana, but here is another point that as soon as rana began to help russia and countries that have problems with the frame, they became more than before

to treat ukraine if they used to stick to neutrality, now they are changing a bit. look at saudi arabia, which recently allocated 400 million dollars in aid to ukraine, and before that it did not allocate anything at all , because saudi arabia understands that for iran, ukraine has become a testing ground for its weapons and in the next series, all these weapons, these drones, they will fly precisely against saudi arabia, about which recently, by the way, it was noted in a memo to the united states of america that they have intelligence intelligence that iran is planning an attack on saudi arabia, as well as nuclear weapons, where the base of the united states of america is located, and the second country, which also cannot silently watch this, is israel, because israel will also understand that they are hypothetical next victims, i will remind you that when the supply of drones took place vranskyi to russia, journalists began to realize the idea that with a certain joy