and this is very strong, it even shocks a little. and among those people who remain there because they live in such and such silence, yes, but this silence is not pleasant, but simply silence as a result of what has been done to their cities, it is possible to leave somewhere somewhere such a true life will return to their cities. well, in principle, that's exactly all those 20-30% of people there, that's the average, as far as i'm concerned, as i see statistics across the country, these are those who stay, those who don't they can go somewhere or they have some relatives who are lying down or they simply have nowhere to go or they don't have money to go or they are very attached to their place of residence for some other reason and it is precisely their people who stay and those people of these people we see them later when they buy our territories that's why hmm here such a question, well, this is the percentage of

some, you will convince me. well, because they have their own reasons for not going anywhere, they are there. why are there such people? it’s just a funny moment, it’s what i actually saw in a post in andriy, that among the humanitarian aid, in particular, products which the americans transmit are also of russian production, for example, products, for example, family-made macaroni, with such russian, i’m chubby, or what’s the name of that painting? by the way, i didn’t take a picture, there is a sticker with the importer’s data, it’s some company in new york, brooklyn she is this russian shit in america and then this shit gets to us as a humanitarian. by the way, you poured these macaroni into ordinary packages so that people would not be

horrified that something russian is again in my the group got into it after the occupation, they added a little work to you. well, yes, but you didn’t try, didn’t you do any testing of that pasta, what does it taste like or whether it can be consumed, everything is fine, it’s just that they are produced by the accepted aggressor, and mostly from america they got to us, and i think that everything is fine with them, i don’t think that american importers import shitty things to their consumers, if they didn’t get into this wrapper, this package, uh, that’s exactly russian. it was shocking, that is, they would have rejected these macarons. what do you think? well, i think not, well, i don’t know. it’s so hypothetical and simple. personally, as a volunteer, it would be unpleasant for me to hand a person

macaroni with the russian e-e inscription on it from these advertisements and so on. and i think that the state that we were able to perceive and get acquainted with the psychological state of people, i do not think that the state that would allow them to throw them away or not because people who are able to survive, that is, to close their very first basic needs they about these they don't think about philosophical things there, and that's why it 's difficult to talk to them about ukraine or the occupation, because they're confused, i understand them in this regard, too, because they don't know what will happen tomorrow, we hope that in the armory the forces of ukraine will hold our territories and no longer lead a single centimeter, but they lived there for about seven months and now it is very difficult to talk about anything, i try to constantly

joke with them there, somehow to cheer them up, it's useless for them. you understand that people only think about that that's how to survive, that's why they then prepare questions for you, what do we have, what do they need, what can we give more, they are not really interested in anything now. well, this is natural , it's normal. well, of course. hygiene products, yes, these are first of all hygiene products, medicines because there are no pharmacies, when they heard that we brought some medicines, they became very happy. well, we only brought the basic ones. bread they refused, for example, from them. that is , someone sang there that it should be such a simple question , but people. in general, do they feel gratitude? well, they are glad that the volunteers came, that there is attention,

she said that you brought me here, i do not need this bread and that i don't need it, i give it to the dogs do you have such stories no no i would say well i did n't say that i could say that i directly felt there, i say some emotions from them because it was very difficult to bring them out on them for some conversation there and so on, but to say that they are there ungrateful or what? no, they felt me ​​like that, they tell me something about, well, actually you say that they compare and about the occupation, about their lives, the occupation, about their experiences during that occupation, if you compare it with the kyiv region, and kharkiv today, well, we felt the difference in the kyiv region, it was already there, yes , some time passed and the occupation was not so long there, it was a month, people were more open, they

joked, they stopped us for half an hour to an hour so that we could talk with them, and there are a lot of people stories were told in kupyansk. well, the situation is completely different, on the contrary, they are very few words and answer in monosyllables, somehow, so and so, even the volunteer who was a local helped us, he already helped us all during the time when there was already some kind of her contact more- less long, he began to tell something, they say that they were not insulted especially there, i think he asked them if they considered him, they say no, so that directly no well, that is, it does not open, because after all, time from time to time matters, after all, the kyiv region is obvious they can really think i will hug the volunteers here now and then russia will come here again and they will say here he took those volunteers and shouted that he is

for ukraine i think that people like this situation that it is some sort of filtering from that side then checks on our side, of course and me people are necessary well, people just don't want anymore no , they come only with help, they go home yes back and don't go out anymore, finally, i'll ask myself, we just met andriy in his native mykolaiv but how am i doing there mykolaiv is it possible to visit there, what's the mood like in mykolaiv next week? mykolaiv stands mykolaiv, the english live there, the situation is not the same as there in the kupyan occupation, he didn't have a son. thank god, but the daily shelling is slowly turning mykolaiv into a city where almost nothing remains i mean the infrastructure there, first of all, some educational institutions, three universities out of four are broken, uh, national, i

mean, uh, as far as i remember, 80 schools were affected . well, and so on. and it continues. and of course mykolaiv is not in a very good mood, but the city is standing and it seems to me that these are some of the most hardened civilians in ukraine today, because only 40 days, and somewhere close to these two hundred marks, were more severe, and all other constant shelling, and my mother personally already understands all types of weapons by sound and she can say in a second that this is s300 and this is the caliber and this is her and she does it somehow like this eh let's say this means it has always been in her life this is of course not good in my opinion this is of course high constant high psychological stress on people and this chair it will be possible in the future, but what is it?

look, thank you. of course, this is not good. you understand it. maybe even your mother. they distinguish the s-300. something else flew from there . it flew from there. it was ours. well done, sometimes my friend who is in kharkiv is there, she says, i can tell where theirs are and where ours are hanging out somewhere there. actually, these people will need some kind of therapy. such people get there specialists or some single names of theirs will do something. by the way, it seems to me that one of the biggest problems will be, as far as i remember, according to the estimates of the world health

organization . there is a lot of time left, i don't know if we will be able to restore contact with, we are still trying to contact andrii because i would still like to hear that answer because this is the kind of mistrust that exists in kupyansk, so this is a big problem, it does not affect either and for life in ukraine later when we let's win this war p andriy yes yes, i'm sorry that it broke a-a i wanted to say that there was a large-scale invasion uh-uh and as far as i remember there were such data that 8 million ukrainians have uh-uh some kind of mental disorders or some mental health problems a it seems that recently the number was somewhere around 16 million and these are actually very scary numbers and they are preparing for themselves how many specialists are needed, how many people are needed

who would constantly carry out work and one, how do you say departure, well, that’s well, that’s not what it’s about, it’s constant work should be uh because if it's ptsr yes uh, post-traumatic syndrome there, it's not one day in two. it's a long work with a person to bring her to a certain state more or less uh, and respect that she was to continue and work yes and live a full life, also understand that she needs to consult a specialist because there is something wrong with her, and this is also difficult. thank you, andriy, for what you are doing . thank you for sharing with us the features of your volunteering. you you were with us, thank you for staying with espresso , eh, the marathon continues, andriy sychuk and i will be back tomorrow at 7:00 a.m., we will be waiting for you. well, stay and watch further. watch

this week's program judicial control with tatyana shustrova, judge bereginya pyanits why did the candidate for the supreme council of justice overturn the verdict and prosecute dozens of drunken drivers drivers who get behind the wheel drunk and glue their own traffic accident contestant of the year as an unscrupulous candidate for the vrp got into the contest to the highest qualification commission of judges with one of the members of this colleague and an incredible judicial intuition how to be abroad on the first day of a full-scale war i congratulate judicial control the judicial system of ukraine needs a thorough reboot this is one of the requirements of our accession to the european union a new composition of the supreme council of justice is currently being formed and the higher qualification commission of judges of ukraine, who will later

clean the system of unscrupulous representatives, and we will talk about it today, but first, to the news, the specialized anti-corruption the prosecutor's office reported suspicions of deliberate non-declaration of assets of kyiv district administrative court judge oleksandra braginia in 2020 and 21. with the same digital signature, the national agency for the prevention of corruption refused to accept the declaration of the fraudster in paper form, later the investigation came to the conclusion that according to the law it is not religious beliefs that prevent the judge from reporting his wealth to the judge, but the banal desire to hide

the property of the public judge of the district administrative court of kyiv, kyryll gardnyk, will be tried for an administrative offense , the case against him has already been referred to the court, it is not known for sure what exactly gardnyk did, however, according to the information of the de jure foundation, it is about steering on tipple kyrylo garnih is a former member of the russian star factory and, in addition to his creativity and creative streak, he is known in particular for making questionable decisions regarding the protest action. repeatedly and unjustifiably prohibited peaceful gatherings from 2011 to 2019. his family's expenses amounted to almost 13 million uah, which is 9 million more than the

official income. the corpus has not yet reached the judges with far from perfect biographies continue to make decisions on behalf of ukraine today we will tell you about olena kruzyliny in the kharkiv court of appeal, although becoming a member of the supreme council of justice and very sympathizes with the drunkard during her career as a judge, kruzhilina helped avoid punishment for at least 19 drivers who were driving under the influence of alcohol, mostly the judge just bails drivers and closes the case, she made a lot of decisions that we overturned court decisions in of the first instance on prosecuting drivers who sit down while drunk. they are

driving the road accident itself. if the first instance, for example, revoked the driver's license, the court very often overturned such a decision. and used such punishments in which , for example, being sent to the bail of the labor collective olena kruhilina is so used to this practice that she did not even invent anything special in one of the cases, she handed over a drunk driver to the bail of the collective, which he himself leads in the other deprived the driver of his license because apparently the violator needs a car to perform his work . elena kruzelinia also needs a car and it's not easy. in 2020 , she bought a mazda - it's an x5 of 2019. and for almost a million hryvnias, in the end, according to according to the declaration of the judge and members of her family,

they also do not deny themselves expensive purchases. in september , she bought three plots of land in the balakliya district of the kharkiv region with a total area of ​​almost 3,000 m², for more than uah 60,000. among her savings, kruzelina indicated uah 280,000, €25,000, and $32,000 in cash. has two apartments in kharkiv , bought in 1995 and 2018, however, the judge did not specify their value earlier. they were almost fired for violating the oath because they changed the decision of the court of first instance in

the case of a traffic accident. there it was about compensation for the damage caused by the traffic accident and they significantly reduced the amount of compensation . were admitted by the judges of the appellate court. and precisely on the basis of this, the highest qualification of the commission of judges recommended the release of this circle, but the supreme council of justice refused to do so. this story took place in 2012 at that time the entire judicial system was controlled by the administration at that time. in order for president yanukovych to be the so-called gray cardinal, andriy portnov was the deputy head, he actually managed the supreme council of justice, so by not giving consent to the release of the court, he could take it under his control by providing the necessary decisions at the right time , experts note release someone who is not released . some people owe it to him. for example,

he finds himself on the hook for a porter or his assistants, and then he has to follow instructions because he understands, if not, then he can be released at any moment, this is a very common story, we are precisely to make such stories impossible in the future, ukraine is reforming and in some places completely restarting the judicial system, the composition of the high council of justice, which is responsible for the honesty and transparency of the entire judicial corps, the independence and professionalism of judges and prosecutors, is being renewed after a three-year pause, the higher qualification commission of judges is created from scratch, this body forms the judicial corps, transfers judges from one court to another, and also conducts qualification evaluations and makes recommendations to the high council of justice on the appointment of judges, members of these judicial bodies must

be independent, impartial, incorruptible and adhere to ethical standards and demonstrate impeccable behavior in professional activity and personal life, the legality of the sources of origin of property must not cause doubts, and the lifestyle must correspond the status of the competition for the vrp recently ended the competition for the higher qualification commission is still ongoing, however, they managed to see daleko not all applicants can objectively assess themselves for compliance with the criteria of integrity and professional ethics and stop in time. career and what was our surprise when we saw him in

the competition for the higher qualification commission of judges , one can only envy this self-confidence. so let's find out why oleksandr vilchynsky has no place in the higher judicial authorities . oleksandr vilchynskyi has been the head of the vinnytsia district administrative court since 2015 for three terms in a row. this violates the legislation on the term of holding an administrative position, which stipulates that the seat of the head of the court can be held for no more than two terms, however, oleksandr vilchynskyi is good at de jure foundation expert stepan berko explains how to circumvent the law, many judges use tricks of maneuvering various tools in order to somehow justify their stay in these positions, in particular, for example

, they leave this position early and then claim that they did not meet the deadline, because that is why, because of espano vilchynsky, the situation is the same on the eve of the coming of age on february 2, the emergence of the powers of the head of the court and leaves on vacation for a whole month or more, he has time to go abroad , such facts definitely raise questions for an outside observer like this. the head of the court gives himself a vacation for more than a month and in a strange way it happened coincides this is the beginning of the vacation coincides with the date of the large-scale invasion and this judge above the border, we do not know if oleksandr vilchynskyi has plans to sit in the chair of the chairman of the vinnytsia district administrative court again, but there are

already many questions for him, oleksandr vilchynskyi lives in the mother's luxurious estate with an area of ​​more than 630 m² in the suburbs of vinnytsia. locals call this area the royal village. many representatives of the vinnytsia elite settled here, in general, in the family of oleksandr vilchynskyi has a lot of real estate, but he still lives with his mother. in 2017, the judge’s wife bought an apartment in the center of kyiv in the elite pechersk district, housing in this building costs from uah 5 million. uah , the declared value of this apartment, it sleeps four times less than the market price, that is, it is not

clear how they always manage to buy real estate at very low prices, even this one its value is still more than half a million hryvnias higher than the combined declared income of pilchenskyi and his wife for this year, not to mention the money that needs to be invested for repairs or any type of decoration of this apartment, that is, not even taking into account these things in 2018, the wife and elite a in 2021 declared there an entire hotel and restaurant complex dvor litynskyi with an area of ​​almost 2000 m², on booking it was possible to book this hotel as early as 2019, but in the declarations for the 19th and 20th years oleksandr vilchynskyi forgot to mention it in

2019. vilchynskyi's wife also purchased a plot of land in her native village of kozyn near kyiv with an area of ​​2,000 square meters for just uah 590,000, which is at least all times lower than the market value of land in this area . their 23-year-old daughter bought a neighboring plot the daughter has no information about any of her er official incomes that could explain the purchase of a rather valuable er plot of land in such and such a national point, meanwhile, she is not a retired mother oleksandr vilchynsky, in addition to the huge estate where the judge himself lives, has another smaller one of 245 m².

they arise, but the former head of the vinnytsia district administrative court oleksandr vilchynsky himself, according to declarations for previous years, has nothing but a car and a motorcycle. the seizure of power

was filmed by several of our colleagues from investigative information years ago oleksandr vilchynsky came to congratulate ablov on his birthday celebrated in the company of volodymyr butenko, a member of the supreme qualification commission of judges, a little later during the qualification evaluation of oleksandr vilchynskyi butenko will be the head of the commission which will of course recognize the head of the vinnytsia district administrative court as virtuous and appropriate for the position he holds, given the many facts of his biography vilchynskyi, which contradicts this, despite the evaluations of experts and the conclusions of the public integrity council, it should not have been confirmed as one that can administer justice, but unfortunately, the higher qualification commission of judges is the conclusion. it did not take into account the composition of the chamber that considered this decision, where did such a mr. butenko belong, whom

vilchynskyi obviously knows because they also attended the birthday of one odious judge, judge ablov, during the interview itself mr. vilchevsky in no way declared that he had any conflict of interest with one of the members of this colleague . this is how this panel actually recognized the jury as meeting the requirements of integrity now judge oleksandr vilchynskyi wants to be a member of the supreme council of justice and the higher qualification commission of judges of ukraine. by the way, in order to participate in the competition, the last candidate must provide recommendations. on vovka's tapes

, where, if you believe the tsymkivkas and the investigation, in fact , mr. holodnyuk appointed persons loyal to judge vovka to the higher qualification commission in in exchange for the fact that wog judge pavlo vovk in his district administrative court of the city of kyiv will block decisions concerning mr. holodniuk. we hope that the competitive selection of members of the higher qualification commission of judges of ukraine will take into account all the facts of the biography of oleksandr vilchynskyi that we have mentioned and make a decision regarding it was a fair decision, it was all judicial control, and i am tetyana shustrova, well, the facts of corruption in the judicial

system, or do you want to report about the judge’s exceeding of his powers or his ruling of illegal decisions, write to me on facebook or to the email address whose address you see on your screens. all is well and we will meet exactly in a week, almost seven o'clock in ukraine. news time on the espresso tv channel. greetings to all viewers and in the studio of iryna koval, i will just now tell you about the most important events open genocide in the kherson region, the rashists deport children from the local boarding school to the crimean mental hospital, reported the obmudsman dmytro lubinets, the occupiers took out 12 pupils in the next round