did they leave the region, or did all those enterprises that we were all well used to, which fed us and supplied us with the most necessary things , did they fully work? let's be honest, many entrepreneurs have already transferred or are currently transferring their enterprises to western ukraine , so they are absolutely familiar, some of them have transferred to the assembly that was occupied there, transferred to ternopil, or something else, unfortunately, unfortunately, it is so and these communities that are shelling them with our budgets, you know, said very well. we have a girl from finland who manages our budgets in the

sumy region, half the garden blooms, half the garden withers where there are military units and they are more or less the rear is not even going there, you won't believe the over-execution of the budget when the budget is being executed, but the community is like krasnopil, myropil, there is a polish community, it's there, of course, it's not up to the implementation of the budget, it's terrible in all positions and precisely because there is no local business even there in in some communities, the analysts will not hear bread, but the frunze mnpo sumske, which you mentioned, also belonged to kostyantyn grigoryshyn before, which has now been taken away, and the npu of the frunze mnpu has not yet been taken away by the securities commission. no, this is a military facility, also a military destination i know, they turned off my light, but i joined myself, well, on the phone, what can i tell

you ? i have some questions but now i can’t say who owns it, who controls it now, but it’s working there, well, maybe not at full capacity, but something is working, so it’s, well , enterprises are working, including the machines of machine-building enterprises are working, so business in sumy is more - it is even 80% less than the pre-war capacity, and works at about 80%. well, not everything is so good, but you see, well, we have what we have , but it’s the same thing over there. in konotop, they are shostka, something has been restored, but the fact that under shelling, well, understand correctly, they don’t even bake bread in some communities thank you, mr. viktor viktor bondarenko , the head of the expert group of the bureau of analysis and policy

from sumy, joined us and talked about the situation in sumy oblast, which continues to border the aggressive russian federation, and let us remind you that sumy oblast was one of the first to meet the occupier, and i think the russians will not forget this meeting until at the end of his life, because the arrangement of children in sumy, the teroboron of the sumy oblast, on the very first morning, gave battle with russian soldiers on the first night since february 24. well, i personally will never forget such a first armed resistance in fact, the civilian population to the russian occupiers , even when all the law enforcement and military forces had already left the city, the defense kept the sums to the last and held on to the city too, and what is interesting is that even mr. ukraine will be able to resist russian aggression in the epicenter for so long and it will be so effective,

but the sumy teroborona decided in a completely different way , they changed the course of history, well, with this, it seems difficult to me, it’s hard to somehow disagree a-a we let's move on and we have several messages for you that are worth your attention, uh, in the pentagon, they talked about a window, possibly with regard to negotiations between ukraine and the russian federation, the chairman of the joint chiefs of staff, general mark milley, during a speech at the economic club of new york york of speeches for the window of opportunity for the start of the negotiation process between ukraine and the aggressor country is reported by issinn colleagues when there is an opportunity to hold negotiations when peace can be achieved use it seize the moment for it in words, a window of opportunity may appear if the front line stabilizes during the winter, he reminded about the huge losses of the russians, about which i already noted more than 100,000 military wounded and

killed, but he says that in ukraine no less, where he has the data, he did not specify, well, in any in any case, the summit of the g20 is the same. it will be interesting to point a-a to which the representative of the russian federation, vladimir putin, is not going. bloomberg is not going. putin will not go, but sergey lavrov will. if there is no putin, then he will not go to the ball, for which he was severely criticized by ukrainian political scientists, saying that it is still necessary to go and represent ukraine and tell and explain our position well, if putin is no longer there, then the way for the ukrainian president to be at the ball is for sure open, obviously, if bloomberg is not mistaken, then zelensky will definitely be there. well, this is an obvious plus for ukraine and for promoting our agenda and our position and explaining our

priorities in this war. foreign economic and generally humanistic development of our country, society for the world for all countries, not only for western countries, but also for the countries of latin america, for the countries of africa, for the countries of asia there will be many representatives of various major economic countries of the world, we are now handing over the floor to our colleague andriy yanitsky e news of the economy under the time of war is expected of you andriy, congratulations and we ask you to say thank you, colleagues, today we will talk about turkey, about what place it occupies in the world and what influence it will have on ukraine in the future andrii yanivskyi with the economic program on espresso tv as usual on weekdays at 8 a.m. today it turned on a little later at 8:05 a.m. and usually at 8:00 a.m. live and at 11:00 p.m. in a

repeat and when it’s convenient for you on youtube at any time what time today will we talk with our permanent expert who is on on thursdays and he is the head of the burakovo institute of economic research and political consultation igor was at a major economic conference in turkey and is ready to tell what mr. igor was talking about congratulations, congratulations, when we spoke with you last week, you were just in istanbul and were waiting for the speech of mr. erdoğan, uh, they said that it should be a landmark speech, what did he say there that impressed you, what was discussed at that conference , i immediately want to say that in 2023, turkey will have several anniversaries. the first anniversary is 20 years under erdogan's rule, and of course i don't want to show my importance, i won't say it, but my

leadership, leadership, and not only in turkey, but in the region. perhaps in the world, the second anniversary is the centenary of the turkish republic and this is a really great holiday and a holiday of state formation, and i think we, as ukrainians, understand very well what an independent state is, especially a dynamically developing state. well, the banal things of every politician are waiting for elections in 2023. turkey is also waiting for presidential and parliamentary elections, that's all. together creates such a certain background when turkey is trying and in this case different political elites to define their place in the world to define their vision turkey and the world the world and turkey from the other side party and this particular conference. it is very interesting. it was dedicated to and was called very very good . it is provocative. this is politics and the new paradigms of the 21st century, and this event was held precisely by the party of justice and development, that is, it was such a party scientific conference where they really

tried to put very difficult questions, and many of them, from our point of view, need to be discussed not only in turkey, not only in the world, but also in ukraine. if we talk about turkey, we also mentioned the past week that all is not well there with the economy that is growing, prices are rising as recently as yesterday when we were preparing for the program, we said that everything is not very good there with unemployment either, that is, despite such loud statements about some kind of regional or maybe even such a thing. well, not global, but still leadership there are economic difficulties, how turkey is trying to fight them or what way does it propose to get out of these difficulties because we also have problems with unemployment and rising prices, but for other reasons it is clear that because of the war and there is no war and prices are growing, this is a very complex and complex question , so i would just like to answer with three

theses. well, starting from about 2002 to 2021 , turkey demonstrated quite strong rates of economic growth, they amounted to approximately 5.8% annually. this is a very high stable rate of economic growth so that we do not compensate for what we have lost in the future, such rates must be maintained for a fairly long period. the second point is that in order to ensure this economic growth. by the way in many respects, it went to the regulation of the same interest rates, that is, in fact, local cheap money flooded into the country, but at the same time , what is called structural changes did not take place, that is , in this case, there was growth, but on the other hand, the stability of its growth was not what it should be well, according to all economic canons . well, a very interesting situation arose when, on the one hand, turkey was growing very dynamically, it is the 22nd economy in the world, but ah, on the other hand, economic growth was according to, well, in this

in the case of the population, the great inflation, very high inflation, obviously one of the biggest inflations in the world, on the one hand, and on the other hand , there was a slowdown in economic growth, a slowdown, plus inflation, an outflow of investments and an outflow of investments, these are all negative problems have led to quite high unemployment, and this is the situation. therefore, now it is fundamentally important for erdogan to return to the same trajectory on this track of economic growth. the tool that is used today in turkey is large investment projects. well, when he arrived, for example, in the same turkey, in istanbul, he just means that he arrived in a large new airport. this is the largest airport in the world today, that is, the idea of ​​large constitutional infrastructure projects of the dergan is very attractive, he tries to implement it well

, didn't we go through this in our history, uh, back in the soviet union, when we were in ukraine, uh, we're not going to talk about it today whether the status was colonial or not, but still, we saw our parents saw how these big infrastructure five-year plans were made and it did not help the soviet union. politics. another question is how it all develops directly. and what is being done in terms of economic policy. therefore, on the one hand, it is true that the projects themselves can pull out, they can not pull out the economy, in the end, they can be such situations when we built the facility but nevertheless , nothing is happening so to speak, and in this case, let's say the same big airport, it's not just, you know, this kind of provincial

gigantmania . a regional, possibly large, transport event, if it is implemented, then i think everything will work out in turkey, but on the other hand, questions immediately arise regarding the economic policy itself, and what should be paid attention to in order to ensure a low interest rates, erdogan actually established control over the national bank, and once a problem arose, we already went through it, and this is just a negative lesson, a negative experience that does not need to be oriented in order to make the economy work . ministerial or horde, but it certainly did not contribute to economic development, so it is about the fact that we should look at what is happening in turkey and take relevant experience but including you learn from mistakes and many things that we are talking about today, let's give cheap money, let's give low interest rates, let's give something else with the example of turkey, show that it can work

sometimes even it can work very well, but in the medium and long term there are economic laws that cannot be changed and which you can't adjust to your wishes, we still have time to talk about turkey and ukraine if previously ukrainians knew about turkey mainly because of relatively affordable and cheap democratic rest through this system of all inclusive hotels well, maybe because of the vegetables and fruits that appeared on our markets, and also clothes and light industry, turkey is also developed there, jeans from turkey were bought, and now we know turkey mainly through the grain corridor, that is, turkey already and through bayraktars, of course yes, the military industry and assistance in the export of ukrainian grain, what is turkey currently doing together with ukraine or to help ukraine in the economic sphere, and where does it see its leadership if we are talking about the grain agreement?

a typical example of the so-called third way, which was very actively discussed during the conference, what is the third way, it means to be a mediator and to be a mediator of letters, if we recall the structure of the same grain agreement, turkey and the united nations, on the one hand, agreed with ukraine as everything will happen on the other side in parallel agreed with russia thus we did not meet with russia but through turkey this agreement is actually implemented in these two components and as for the economic of development, turkey is indeed mechanical engineering, turkey today is also the production of electric cars, there are bodies, so to speak, the national program, it may not be going very well, but nevertheless, so to speak, there are already certain developments, they present their new electric cars, and we will see how will it all happen next well, of course , the main e-e part of the main sectors of the turkish economy is more than 50% - these are various kinds of services, this is

first of all the tourism that you talked about well, and some eh some other services and the last thing i would like to say in this motorcyclist is that turkey today eh is trying to attract foreign investors . tell me, i also already have problems related to the fact that turkey needs economic reforms when we talk about the normal fundamental policy of the turkish state, this is just an example of the fact that these things cannot be neglected and uh, while there were uh in turkey significant economic events took place here in ukraine. i would like to know your opinion about them. perhaps you have heard, well, 100% have heard and read about the fact that five ukrainian enterprises were transferred to the state department and were nationalized, in fact, but there is no such word in the legislation. how the nationalized alienated shares of these enterprises

were in favor of the ministry of defense, on the one hand, there are economists who say that this is war communism, we cannot do this, that it scares away investors, there are other economists who understand that stand and say that uh, this is during wartime . maybe in peacetime, of course, such a decision looked wild, but we understand the times we live in and that we need these enterprises. what do you think about this, well, in fact, requisition uh, will they ever be returned these factories to the owners and hmm or compensation of the shareholder, i would talk today about uh two dimensions of this process and i will say very briefly the first dimension is the crisis dimension if we remember all the past financial crises then this was precisely the key issue for the governments of many countries that to make system companies with large companies in one or another sphere when they were experiencing the corresponding difficulties as a result of the economic crisis, and in the west there were two approaches, the first approach they

should save, because if they die, the relevant sectors will die, well, in this case, let's say the defense sector in ukraine and on the other hand , it was said that their support is a lot of money and it is possible that it is better, relatively speaking, to close it and quickly go bankrupt than to spend money on something that is possible and will never come to life, this is also the case the problem is the part that we should pay attention to, this is what we need to talk about in ukraine, on the other hand, there is, so to speak, a political moment, but er, i think that really rescuing enterprises, especially enterprises of the military-industrial complex, is not a step, but at the same time, we should not forget about the fact that the state is not always a good government and if we tell them today these enterprises have taken under their wing, then the question arises how we will work with them what will be the politics there and in general for today if we let's talk about the public sector. well, it is growing very strongly in ukraine, a large part of the banking sector is state banks, which

in fact the state nationalized in order to save them, we have an increasing number of enterprises that are also under state management today, and from my point of view, this is to some extent can become a very dangerous trend, we must end it. thank you for your opinion. ihor burakovsky, the head of the institute of economic research and political consultations, was on the espresso broadcast, talking about the great economic a conference in turkey and an appointment in turkey on the economic map of the world and for ukraine as well and i'm andriy yanitskyi with economic news on the espresso tv channel together we will win see this week's program judicial control with tatyana shustrava supporters of russian peace how judges defend raiding in favor of the russian oligarch's company and danger on otaki, the company had to pay attention a long, long time ago to whether the dbr checked the

dubious connections of a colleague of the northern commercial court of appeal with the russian federation and how prof. unfit servants contribute to the withdrawal of capital from ukraine, watch the program judicial control with tetyana shustrova on the espresso tv channel on thursday, november 10 at 4:40 p.m., whatever the ukrainians think about so that they don’t talk about the first place, war, war, and our victory are seven days . for a week from monday to sunday, seven different spheres of human activity, sports, culture , politics, eight presenters of express, journalists , experts, opinion leaders in real time about the most relevant events through the prism of war every day author's projects on espresso war in ukraine

is the main topic for ukrainians victory and loss analysis and forecasts politics and geopolitics serhii rudenko and the guests of his program will talk about all this people who have information and shape public opinion people who defend ukraine and create the future right now is important and interesting in the program verdict serhiy rudenko monday through thursday at 5:10 p.m. repeat at 9:30 p.m. let's get a defender well, listen, the defender of ukraine can see in the dark as if it were daytime, what can i do, my brothers, for kilometers around to move quickly over any terrain, the body is reliably protected, which makes it less sensitive and more confident about cockroaches from a bird's eye

view - for eight years in a row, you and i have been providing our defenders with what keeps their lives on the front lines, our priorities are day- night and thermal imaging optics communication off-road vehicles personal protection and technical means of intelligence join the fundraiser and let the next night be peaceful for all but the occupiers good morning again 8:21 on the clock and november 10 thursday khrystyna yaskiv yehor checherina is with you and we remind you that espresso, together with the public association of dreams of action junio, is collecting funds for the purchase of silencers for our guards and defenders, the polish campaign workers also joined the collection, who will add their own for every hryvnia we collect. we have a chance to double what we will collect, who can join, please join, invest in your own security, the defense capability of our country, we help the defenders on all platforms as soon as we can see the qr-code on our screens now

it can be scanned to get all the necessary details, if colleagues showed it again, it would be great. well, we will continue to collect information quickly, in particular, we will talk about the situation in luhansk region, which settlement after settlement is being de-occupied in the same way serhii gaidai, head of the luhansk regional military administration we are in touch with mr. sergey, we congratulate slava to ukraine. good morning. glory to the heroes. we will probably start with the military situation. we understand the tension of the situation in the area of ​​savatovo and crime there continues intense fighting, i would like to understand the situation in which the occupiers are now in the area of ​​these settlements and how the situation is developing there, well, there is enough. the situation is difficult in terms of military because, after all, the russian occupying forces were accumulating forces and means, but eh well, first of all, they are mobilized,

and they are, well, so-so. they are not very good soldiers, the only thing is that there are simply very, very many of them, and they still carry a certain degree of lethality, plus they managed to replace everything there, we have to build protective buildings, but er, the armed forces of ukraine are moving forward, er, not like that, of course, like in kharkiv oblast, but it is still moving forward, and i can say that i hope that in the near future i will be able to make material from the new de-occupied settlements of luhansk region, for sure stands literally yesterday they announced that the luhansk region is gradually turning into a large russian burial ground, the ecology is disturbed, a large number of dead russians are spontaneously buried or unburied remains. well, you wrote what appears the problem with contaminated water in the

ukrainian luhansk region, this problem can be solved and what is the ukrainian government applying now? a certain demining of specific areas and only then build water aqueducts, and there is strategic infrastructure related to water, but we worked for several months with our international partners and we have a certain supply of a tablets for water purification so that it is easy to add them to the tank, we have such small manual mobile water filters and we have them from french companies, and they are large enough for the public, they are like a trailer, but they are already powerful and they already work for more than one d - there are two or 10

people, and already thousands of people will be able to drink normally already purified water. that is, we have already prepared for this, and in principle, for people who live in small villages, we will deliver them for the time being tablets for water purification and manual filters and already such cities as matchmaking-criminal investigation, we will already bring powerful equipment there. well, regarding the bodies of the russians, you said that for the time being they will be collected in refrigerators , and then the ukrainian authorities will decide what to do if these refrigerators are available, so we will find that it is not the biggest problem, in fact, for something like this -that thing is a sin. i can’t find it. if you contact me, we can announce the meeting on the air of our channel. well, i’m joking, of course. sergey, eh, still returning to the topic of the matchmaker and the flint. and what about the

supply of silent groups by the enemy? they still have the opportunity to get everything they need there and to communicate with each other in these settlements, they have the opportunity, not as much as they would like. moreover , certain routes are already under fire control of the armed forces of ukraine, that is, in principle, you know this the comfortable movement of ammunition or heavy equipment or personnel, of course, it is broken, moreover, there is quite a strong demoralization going on in them because they are simply thrown in platoons at those freshly mobilized at will. so they were thrown in some direction and simply forgotten about them that is, it is occupied by what is happening there, the offensive of the armed forces of ukraine, how to do it, with whom to do it , very often the commanders abandon them, simply leave them on the battlefield, they themselves run away, and then these newly mobilized people are captured or

killed because they are the same the soldiers are not very educated . but still, for now we are talking about the fact that they still have the opportunity to deliver ammunition and personnel. there is a lot of disinformation around the settlement of belohorivka. let me remind you that this settlement has drunk there was a lot of blood at the time of the russian occupiers, what is the situation, what is the status of belogorivka now, because they claim that they are already repelling it or something like that? of the russian occupation forces, our military is located there. the fact is that now, all such military actions are taking place around belogorivka . unfortunately, these are more military operations for

the territory, because the village as such no longer exists. everything is there completely erased, all the houses were completely destroyed, ugh, and those population points that are now in the luhansk region under the control of the ukrainian state, how is life being restored there, or can we say that it is being restored, considering the fact that the front line is very close to them? no, we are not yet all the same, our first priority is to evacuate people, because despite the fact that the russian troops have withdrawn under the pressure of the armed forces of ukraine, they are still shelling these populated areas, they are constantly flying there i personally drove through several populated areas and, well, i was simply a witness to the fact that the military operations continue, the arrivals continue , so it is still dangerous there, unfortunately, not all people want to leave anyway, even despite the fact

that they saw what they experienced in which under the conditions they live in, not all of them want to leave . well, we are still trying, at least for a certain time , but the front line needs to move back somewhere approximately 40 km, so that at least they don't finish you off with hailstorms. very briefly, finally, what do we know about life in the occupied territories in the luhansk region as it looks now, is it possible to share the last successful work on the enemy rear e-e by the defense forces of ukraine, i can say that regarding the successful work of our e-e artillerymen, it happens regularly, these are not isolated cases , that is, the warehouses and e-e ammunition warehouses shells a-a and plus e-e fuel and lubricants e-e stocks plus barracks command center