replied to the minister that his about the proposed planned withdrawal to the left bank of the dnieper that was agreed upon, probably general surovy kin e and e-e believed that he was e-e a coward when he surrendered to moscow , but apparently still in and probably not in the consciousness of the world community, they escaped not far from the best representatives of the third reich, and it is obvious that they will be judged for this and for these toppled towers and for the fact that people are freezing and for the destroyed civilians , this is all waiting, of course, the international tribunal is ahead of all the generals, including this general, who today commands this continent of russian troops on the territory of the kherson region, and another event that coincided on the same day is the election to the congress of the united states of america , which coincided, even president biden said that everyone already knew that they had to withdraw the troops and what they were waiting for ahead of the elections, this is a mystery.

obviously, they probably hoped for a different result of the congressional elections. for me, the fact that they are withdrawing troops became clear when the russian command began to take away the remains of prince tavriysk. prince potemkin appeared to them, well, it is obvious that this is such an interesting and extravagant figure in the russian history of autocracy, that it is obvious that if they leak, then it is necessary to take away what symbolizes the same statehood in that territory. a capital failure of information, not only informational, but also military, of president putin, at least it was clear that this is a planned, good , methodical special operation and a military operation prepared by our services, our the main command headed by fan za luzhnyi and in the tomos of the main intelligence department headed by

mr. budanov, in fact, the russians were there in the apiary on the right bank of the dnieper in kherson region in kherson and they had nowhere to go but to withdraw to other bridgeheads and this way stop the advance of our forces further more this is more crimea, obviously we can no longer talk and they can no longer talk about the fact that they will have some land corridor further along the line of the right bank of the dnieper to odesa odesa has become safer and therefore safer ukraine has become even safer for the villages, but the fact that they are destroying the cities, the fact that they want to undermine and the fact that mr. mykhaylov said to leave behind the principle of scorched earth well, i don't know what they are cooking in kherson, we still don't know to the end, so it's probably just them the beginning of the mass mining, it is not only energy facilities, it is also boiler houses. it is probably also other facilities that are mined. well, what do they want to blow up kherson, like it blew up warsaw, well, these are extraordinary crimes that they are preparing against humanity, and there is no doubt that putin is preparing i think that what is happening now is an

irreversible thing that awaits the russian federation. already next year, it will still be connected with the fact that we will liberate all our territories as an irreversible thing. and what we are convinced of and our international partners who help us with weapons are convinced. and this is inevitable, because it will be accompanied by the disintegration of not only the russian federation, but at the same time, obviously, there will also be a change in the top leadership of russia, which i believe that it will begin soon and soon, and even the ultra-nationalist public in russia will not forgive such failures of the military and political failures of president putin, such as the surrender of christophon, as well as the surrender of other territories, as a rule, military operations in the kharkiv region and obviously other failures await the russian federation, but we must definitely remember here that it comes at an extremely high cost, at the cost of our people, because somehow i will repeat once again that it is possible to restore an architectural monument that has been destroyed, well, labor in the kharkiv region and obviously other failures that await

the russian federation, but of course it must be remembered that it comes at an extremely high price, the price of our people, because somehow i will repeat once again that you know, you can restore an architectural monument that has been destroyed, well, at least in most cases, you can restore it, but you will never get an interesting life back and - there is nothing more valuable than human life. and you know when the nobel prize laureate said that it is possible that when a person dies, he must understand that he does not die completely only then when she fights for freedom, all those people who died in ukraine and first of all soldiers are people who fought for freedom, that's why none of them died completely and we should remember them, mr. kovalchuk, i promise you, i will respond to some of the things we discussed it is clear that we should be grateful to the military every day, including for this advance in kherson oblast, but let's not forget luhansk oblast and donetsk oblast, where the positions are held, and the zaporizhia oblast, and those positions that are, so to speak, out of earshot.

but we are fortified there and ready. this is the north of ukraine. volyn is rivne region, where if it wasn't there, we wouldn't be told by the intelligence services that they aren't ready there, they won't be there, and so on, we still have to be on guard there, that's definitely why everyone has special respect, and it's good that there are opportunities and studying abroad is another one a special thing now is that there are a lot of young guys who have their first and second year of military training somewhere abroad in great britain, in particular, they study together with their commanders and come back even more experienced , a plus for our army, unlike the russian one the only thing i learned is that it is possible to retreat more correctly , and the only thing where you can give them a small credit, and this is actually. to be honest, according to conversations with the

military who liberated kharkiv, raisin, operative irpin bucha, and observing the liberation, so to speak, of the kherson region, more precisely, the retreat of the russian army, i mean them have been watching there for a long time and here maybe i will say something that should be said carefully but not everyone may like it we would have gone there sooner if, again, what we repeat as a mantra all this time of a full-scale invasion, we would have had more long-range weapons and more ammunition, and it would have been faster. i am sure that it would probably have happened before the beginning of november, if there had been more, we would have released it, because it would have interrupted all the transport and logistical moments of the russians, etc. maybe they wouldn't even have time to mine where they will now mine everything that can be mined there, we will restore the energy infrastructure, that's not the question

- these are big problems of course, for the local population there, in particular, i don't quite agree with because europe is not ready to accept ukrainians. well, there are factors somewhere that some people are fed up and others are the opposite . recently, they talked to the french, they treated ukrainians strangely at first, then they realized that they are cultured, that they want to work, that they behave well on the streets, that they are not rude there they do not make noise, there are isolated cases well, as they say, and in ukraine, there were always enough of them, these are the nuances, but moreover, another effect should be mentioned, in particular, poland declared that ukrainians in poland paid taxes for approximately 2 billion euros so that you understood for comparison - this is even twice less than poland directly paid to refugees e from ukraine, more precisely to migrants from ukraine to

poland. that is, it is a very advantageous position if a ukrainian goes to work abroad, this is a big plus, so ukrainians will definitely give themselves advice even if kherson oblast wants to go somewhere and suddenly there will be no place on the territory of ukraine's western regions or other regions, they will be able to go abroad. well, i'm not talking about men, it's clear that they should be here to help protect to restore and so on, this is our role and about the g20 i wanted to add a few things, an important point is that president zelensky was there, but let's analyze the 20 states that were there with 12 actually leaders directly or very close contact or there were meetings further we have australia argentina-brazil argentina brazil there we have a diplomatic finalization it would be good of course possible not the most comprehensive factor but from the economic point of view of cooperation with ukraine the positive of the pair is actually pro-russian

south korea is still in contact, i don't even remember who it is. and indonesia is possible, except for something else. and india, china, india is there. let's go to china now. well , with china, what are we going to talk about, so to speak? we need a certain question. but i i am not sure that there will be any changes at the g20 site. although , on the other hand, i will add a second point for thinking about the discussion. i am sure that precisely because there have been certain changes in china's vision of geopolitics in the world, we are now seeing such a hmm how to say humiliating retreat of the russians in including in the kherson region because they didn't see, let's say, shadowy or direct support, rumors or not rumors through iran with those kamikaze drones and so on

. that's why they go and add the last factor and pass the word on to why this can happen because putin's influence is weakening and he has to rely on his closest military entourage, it's about who can decide who can influence kadyrov and what can be decided by the head of wagner and this is like his beauty so right, that's why we see the prestigious statements of these generals now, or who is he, what is he there, i don't remember his rank, we see that the tactical storage of forces, which will allegedly be useful later, mr. golovko and hermenyuk will now have the floor, we are adding valery chaloga

, ambassador extraordinary and plenipotentiary of ukraine to the united states in 15-19 years, chairman of the board of the ukrainian crisis media center good evening mr. valery, glory to ukraine glory to the heroes i welcome you and guests to studios yes, we have just. several guests touched on the topic of the g20 and the meeting that the summit should take place next week. troops and are recapturing our territories , we have heard statements from the russian federation that they are allegedly withdrawing from the to sound and what can be discussed next week in indonesia or somehow it affects the schedules of what we have obviously and we

talked about it in your studio as well that the success of the armed forces of ukraine will seriously affect the positions of our partners and allies if you look as for what was supplied to us, it was actually and it was said in the studio that the necessary means for the liberation of kherson oblast arrived . including heimers, howitzers, to create unique conditions when the ukrainian armed forces, our soldiers demonstrate that it is possible to liberate territories and cities without hitting, how harsh is it, what is putin doing to civilians, simply destroying citizens, and obviously , our partners outside are talking about this. joseph biden said that it was expected, well, you know. we also

expected all this, but it is one thing to expect, and another thing to save life so that offensive operations are successful, as in kharkiv oblast. i hope it will be here, but then the offensive will be a special moment already phrases were sounded to the question, uh , some diplomatic directions will be discussed, even the president of the usa said that this issue can be raised in indonesia, this is a very strange statement in my opinion, because if it will be raised there in this format, it will not be rammstein on weapons, but rather in in the political format where china, india , indonesia, brazil-argentina will participate, you understand this, well, if the level of their support for these countries is lower than the united states and the country of rammstein, therefore, i think it is good that there will be talks and it is good that at least putin is not allowed to

come there, that's good, but it would be right to boycott the participation of russians in general in 20, that would be the right decision. well, if you are not ready for that, then don't accept the declaration that is currently being prepared in the draft, which does not have such clear assessments that would we would like it if our partners and allies would allow indonesia to accept this declaration, then i believe that it will not be the best scenario for ukraine in any case. how much will the ukrainian people endure in this situation? i am sure they will endure, because the further decision of our allies depends on the further development of events in the coming months after the liberation of the right bank and valery. -th initiative at one time

was seven countries that united the most economies plus democracies. they then expanded and offered to expand to countries that are now democracies but economic power and such in a way, russia also gets here, so if they discuss and put threats to the world in the first place, now the most pressing economic problems, which are inflation, are big, if this is the key, and security is relegated to some third plan, then it will be a problem, moreover, while the project is at least as far as i know, there are no clear indications of russian aggression in the russian war against ukraine. moreover, there is no mention of joint efforts against russia's nuclear blackmail. that is, you know that, taking into account the participant and russia should be thrown out of there by the very first decision of the twenty-somethings. well, this is not planned now, so i

think that this is not the format that will help us much. the only thing that can be expected from the meeting, which has not been confirmed yet, but i think it will take place in china, the united states, er, maybe that's all there - they will still come to the understanding that it is necessary to stop attempts at nuclear blackmail, because it is also unprofitable for china, absolutely unprofitable and, well, we will see the results, but once again i confirm what i already said, expect that there will be a more pro-ukrainian position than it was, for example, in nato statements of the eu or there, rammstein is not worth it to us, so i honestly think that after this, we would like to see another rammstein. another decision of the european union and nato, so that we don't delay this today , because the window of opportunity may close in the next six months, well, these are objective circumstances in the world, thank you for your comments

valery chaliy, the extraordinary plenipotentiary ambassador of ukraine to the usa in 15-19 years, was with us via skype and explained what could happen next week, and in the end, we will monitor all of this, mr. golovko , we promised you a word, then romanyuk, we will just summarize this political component. good evening, indeed, the summit of the g20 is of great global importance , including for us, is it necessary for president zelensky to attend those meetings, does he think so, after all, we understand to what extent is the global game being played and to what extent is the name-calling game going on and therefore literally even the very presence of the president and a direct statement and demand will be able to make someone immortal and yet it will create such moral pressure position even the last meeting of schulz in china with cimping is changing. so it will significantly change the position of china , that is, china even announced that it is the guarantor

of the security of ukraine. when ukraine surrendered its nuclear weapons , because china and france later joined the budapest memorandum, that is, if the ice had already moved, so now it is necessary to press it, pressing it, understanding that there are countries such as park, who said there, argentina, brazil, which neutrality they maintain, but they must be put under pressure, and therefore it is still safe to create a common position the question should be number one, because today china and india really want to raise the number one question, another economic, er, economic situation that is currently heating up in the world, and that is, the future crisis , and so on, so there is no need to complex, there is no need to worry about the fact that the european partners there, america gives us financial assistance today ukraine is the shield of the civilized world today ukraine with the sieve of europe that is at war is dying, the best of the best sons and daughters of ukraine are dying for the fact that practically doing the work on so that they amount to billions every year in membership

fees to obtain the structure of nato, which includes 30 countries, and we practically and the purpose of creating nato was a counterweight against the soviet union and further away against russia, today we are doing this work instead of them, so you do not have to fight and do not we need to die, we just need to help them, give us these weapons. and we understand that there is a problem because we are the help that we receive, well, pennies, but for their scale, these are real pennies, i will not say how much the united states of america is there they allocated 140 billion in aid to the democracy of afghanistan, 85 billion were left only by the technicians. in general, this company cost one and a half trillion for america. we will give them, we are ready, but there is a completely different question when it comes to ukraine , you understand, then they start counting every penny there again, we understand that we counted on a different

amount of weapons in small spoonfuls, as they give us, but really, as it is necessary and we understand how it is weapon the artillery is there and go to the missile troops, how are they changing the situation on the battlefield, and here are the successes of our armed forces, this is precisely the fact that the weapons have started to come in handy today, the europeans are already taking over the palm of championship. look how the situation has changed in germany, spain, france, that is, america is starting to fall behind. that is, let's assume that this is the brake of the white house, because today there is really a lot of criticism , that there is a problem, that the white house creates such obstacles, and that it delays, and there are accusations in the press that it is necessary to sit down and negotiate, washington ponz wrote under this information and so on and we understand that, you know, we must draw conclusions for ourselves and use such a quote from the minister of defense of israel in the six-day war when he called with egypt when he said that america our friends offer us weapons, this money and we will take the advice of weapons and the advice of these weapons and money, but we

will refuse to send them, so these tips sometimes connect that we need to sit down and negotiate with someone , we will already remember how biden advised the turks to surrender crimea without a fight and that it would end for us therefore, we must always take into account our own national interests, because they have their own game , their own story, in each party, in a democracy , in a republican party, but today, every part of the group of originals is there for the elections , the democrats are shouting, 30 congressmen have collected signatures, let's let's stop the aid to ukraine there among the republicans, what statements that said that ukraine should not be helped, by the way, today they lost the biggest because with 80% today american society is never united and we are not we have to make mistakes and not stand on the rake. we ca n't say what we like more or less, we need the help and support of both parties. because when we made such a mistake in the previous term, when poroshenko was president and did hillary clinton openly campaign - it was this music that worsened relations as a result of ukraine and america,

when trump came and became the president, that's why today we say that we are friends with everyone, including the democrats of the republics, and we need all of their support. let's give real help to this and not do not mince words and in the end we bear great losses losses the most valuable thing we have is this life our boys and girls so for today we have to be of course i think it was worth it for the president to go and make demands and after all they were guarantees of our safety when we gave up nuclear weapons and today you know we are doing work for the whole civilized world for the whole of europe too. they were given in the teeth, this shows that the ukrainian nation is strong, unbreakable, powerful and has given faith to the whole world, and this must be used. today, it is necessary to occupy the burning primacy, and it is clear that many are opponents of our bright victory, they would not want it, they wanted to get out of these rotten

agreements that neither yours nor ours we lost but neither did we win because if ukraine wins, you understand, a new state is born, a leader in europe - a military immoral authority, which in the end will be drawn to that leader and funds then this weight and influence and pressure and everything else, no one wants a powerful player to appear on the world map, so we must understand not to let this moment go but press on because we must demand as much as possible for ourselves and understanding that never we must still know as this development said and we must always set three measures for ourselves, that is, measure what we did in the past, what we will do in the future, and the main thing is to analyze our mistakes so that we never repeat the mistakes, namely thanks to error analysis made our state better and great, that's why we are today those mistakes that destroyed the nuclear weapons destroyed the national economy, when they destroyed the state,

when they destroyed the warehouses, blew up ammunition, sometimes no one punished anyone, practically 30 years of such a company of disarmament and destruction of our state, the national economy, should be taken into account so that this never it did not happen again to have your own strong anti-aircraft missile defense system so that you never stood there with outstretched hand asking to give us a plane, give us a tank, and so on. until today, we have not received from america a no not a single tank, not a single drone, not a single plane. and we really need this, and it would change the situation very dramatically at the front, so we should never fall into dependence, but build a strong, powerful ukrainian state, relying on our own forces, on our own air defense and on our own army, thank you. i have to to react because the statement that president poroshenko supported this or that candidate during the elections was very dangerous. i categorically want to state once again that during poroshenko's presidency, we achieved bipartisan support and this is mega-important; secondly

, poroshenko never once. none of the leaders of the ukrainian state interfered in the internal affairs of the united states of america because the presidential election is an election and it is the business of the american people, and poroshenko never supported one or another candidate for the position of the president of the united states of america this is extremely fundamental and very important another inaccuracy was voiced in my opinion it is also unfair at least the last funding which allocation of funds from the united states of america is allocation of funds directly for the supply of t-72 tanks to ukraine, co-financing from the netherlands, an american tank i am talking about i am talking about tanks supplied to ukraine at the expense of the budget of the united states of america, also

at the expense of the budget of the united states of america , attack helicopters were supplied to ukraine and what about my opinion is most important, we never in any way have the right to question the help of our allies, and i want to say once again that the total help of the united states of america is greater than the help of all other countries and this should always be given credit because it is important, but today we should not talk about whether the united states of america gives more help or any of the baltic countries . the only pro-ukrainian global western coalition and ramstein would never have happened if it were not for the position of the united states of america, if it were not for the position of our western allies, friends. we must

be very careful to hide our western partners we should first of all thank them and secondly ask and demand even more weapons, and i was actually comforted by the statement that came from the mouth of the president of the united states of america, because he said in diplomatic language, we can give ukraine more attack aircraft, which they did not give, we can give ukraine also has attack helicopters with drones with a huge radius of action, we can give ukraine missiles with a range that exceeds the hymers, this was stated by the president of the united states of america when he listed what he had not yet given or helped for ukraine, the meeting that will take place right before the g20, which has already been de facto made public between the president of the united states of america and the leader of china, will actually be very, very important, and i

want to remind you once again that when someone here wants to criticize poroshenko, do you remember the story when poroshenko was castigated and his greetings from izenpinu when the story with criticism ended congratulations after that when zimpinu made a reverend towards the united states of america friends you don’t need to be holier than the pope this is very, very it is important that mr. oleg and i said everything correctly for the pope, it will not be possible to become a saint, although today i do not know how he can be treated and behaved, but i sent you this article from yours: german waves when president poroshenko met according to the article, send it to you again i have never claimed that poroshenko day is dedicated to the fact that today the united states will hand over systems to ukraine. the white house announced a new aid package. the last time they announced an aid package was at the

end of october, and it applied to khymars and now these are air defense means and it is actually very good because all the experts are inclined to the fact that what russia will resort to next is definitely an attack on our infrastructure and it will happen during the winter , we are recommended to prepare for the worst and we have to think about it, mr. romanyuk, you have my word i will just say that the president of ukraine, volodymyr zelensky, plans to participate in the g20, and the spokesperson of the president, sergiynyki fruk, said that the most incredible thing will be the online format, and whether the 20th will be held on november 15 and 16 on the island of bali indonesia, well, with regard to participation, i think it is quite logical and justified that the representatives of the ukrainian authorities are talking about the fact that it will be an online format. i think that announcing that he will go is due to many issues. well, it is probably not appropriate yet. it is necessary

to prepare. yesterday's event is related to the fact that the heads of the russian armed forces announced planned planned maneuvers, as they announced the movement of russian troops from the right bank to the left bank - this is the main news, the main news because it is not would have happened if the armed forces of ukraine did not act during the last few months, that is, russia was forced to make assessments that are being made, why this was done. well, probably from the point of view that they calculated that they would lose anyway . it is in such a way as they did and use it for but here is a question for me the question is probably what