it seems to me an important question. and then who will investigate the whole whole whole series of problems, because you say that then it is necessary to turn to the sbu, where were the eyes of the sbu, where were the ears of the sbu? and who will investigate the crimes of the sbu, if not the sbu itself? i don't know the intelligence service, scotland yard, i don't know the polish defense intelligence in some way and then somehow with them well, it's difficult for me to imagine that even the prosecutor's office will start an investigation, but that's only yesterday , classmates. they were sitting next to each other somewhere in the law academy, and now vasya you have to research petya and petya say, vasya, you're better. let's drink some vodka, i'll give you a million more so that you forget my name, what should i do? i'll answer you, i'll answer you, and that's why, since 2015, an

alternative vertical has been created about the sbu, there is the elements of corruption did not happen just like that, that is, they received funds, they received a certain incentive, and this can be investigated, this can be established, and accordingly, the vertical that was anti-corruption was created, this is nabu, this is er-e sap, and this is, accordingly, the anti-corruption court, it is now completed therefore and directly the main condition of our entry into the european union is the provision of the work of this vertical therefore when you say who will clean up, it will be this very structure that is very important now we already have a new head of the specialized anti-corruption prosecutor's office and we can see the results of his work now it remained, accordingly, that the same independent competition and the answer was assigned to the head of the nabu and thus completely ending this vertical and ensuring its independence

and full-fledged work, right at this moment we can talk about the fact that a full-fledged cleaning of all the affairs of the government will begin, both the executive, legislative, local authorities and directly state enterprises. i hope that this mechanism and the political will, i have heard such a phrase since 1991 if there was political will, it would be done if there was and it would be done today, in your opinion, during the war, during the most severe test, we can hope that there is political will on the mountain, the prime minister , the president, the speaker of the entire supreme cabinet the ministers together in the ministry i do not know the industry is there such a thing or not shorter where it is actually needed the will to finally clean all of ukraine from the top to the bottom of

russian influence or russian influences please this is a question of political will ah at the moment it is already pressure from on the part of the european union, there is dependence on our international donors, and this condition is mandatory, therefore, do you have political will there, there is no political will, if you do not do this, then the european union will not shine on you you don't have the money to restore the country, you don't have the money to ensure the work of everything, no matter how much you want it, i'm talking about the current government, but you will actually be forced to ensure the appointment of an independent manager and an independent competition, and then it will be closed and closed again for everything, the vertical is completely necessary, the one who investigates, who directly sues, the prosecutor's office and

directly the court itself, this will be completed vertically . the president and the president in a certain way or others there , the prime minister of other leaders did not want to change anything, now it is actually under different requirements, namely, let's appoint differently, then your country can simply be a-a and not develop because you now have a collapsed country where 30% of the economy has been destroyed thank you thank you ilya ne schadovskaya director of the institute of socio-economic transformation and i forgot the second part from the management to practically research strategic research thank you and let's answer the questions. i think so, let's start with the longest one. let's find it so that later. in short, such an idea. well, let's go. well, you just know from your kyiv questions to easy ones, but for me

it is the longest. this is probably the most difficult. i don't know. amonito amonito wrote or wrote your opinion. about the fact that putin will end up like lenin or like stalin, the model idol of the russian dictator, nor the deer of stalin, there were no heirs. therefore, they did not prepare them to hold on to the family with guarantees for it to putin, as was the case with sobchak or eltsem, which brought to power under the conditions of preservation of all their family privileges, there is no meaning for him, that is why he will sit on his throne until the czech urkagan gang does not feed him. it is known that among the fraudulent criminality, according to the concepts of which , uh, the entire system of modern russia is built, it is forbidden to have a family. thank you and thank you, and no, i think that the circumstances always turn out like this. they can

turn out like this. only military, and this energy, what does he hope for, and military in ukraine, some diplomatic and so on, there is ibush and he still has something to lose, not only kherson, but everything will not end, so i think that this guy, as you say, will come to him and say, listen, or we keep the system, and we get rid of you, or you go to the bottom, and the system you built thanks to us, our efforts there, too, and it, and we are against the system dying, you can die, and we don’t want to, and that’s why come on, we’ll come up with an option here somehow as option i say i don't say it will be like that it will be like that necessarily but always in such cases such moments come well, i wouldn't say always but very

often such moments come to say that this will necessarily lead to the destruction of the victory of ukraine eh dear nations we can find many cases when external and internal pressures were well in venezuela to take shaleni more than today in russia, but there this dictatorship sits and no no no it does not change and cancer in the middle of the programs two wars in a row sat until the american troops came to yes we literally take milosevic's words away, that is, there are many such moments that it seems that way from the outside because it seems that way in a democratic country well, how is it in america, everyone voted against the election, it did not take place, someone was thrown out, competitors were not allowed on television, another won, and well, it doesn't just happen that they themselves it is not possible to imagine authoritarian countries in such a way that it is impossible to do so here there

is a similar question mykola, if in russia it has historically turned out that after military defeats they refused to change the constitutional system why do you not believe that and now the regime will fall, it's you, it's a good question, a good question, i absolutely believe it, but i don't guarantee it. i'm not saying that it's necessarily doomed. there were changes in the constitutional system. by the way, once after a military defeat after the first world war in russia, it was the fifth year, after all, and then there were changes in the back, everything happened in power, he simply gave some kind of manifesto, then he can also any, but the problem is that people knew for sure that they were waging a war, a war was declared, russia lost at first, won, and by the way, the revolution did not even take place when russia

lost the war, because simply people were already tired of the social consequences of the war in russia just a four-year-old in the 17th year had all the chances and well, you actually win and not lose. sorry vitaliy, it’s such a coincidence to some extent, and there was bread and that was all, and here was patience, and when you needed bread for two days, you just had to not eat bread for one day petrograd and then you have to understand, and here it stopped for one day, maybe the train got stuck, maybe there are people with weapons in the city, then you have to understand why there is no bread. oh, that 's enough. come on. and you have a machine gun, and so did i. this was russia after the fifth year there there were different political parties, different authorities , the state duma was dissolved from oppositionists, there is nothing of the sort in today 's russia at all, and the most important thing is that there is no war, there are no heads of the russians, there is a special operation, and no one is telling anyone, and how should it end, this is what we say all the time the victory of ukraine is that we must restore

our theater integrity and provide ourselves with security guarantees for the future discussion the goal yes, it can be achieved, it's not like that . it was not, well, no one is saying yes, no, no one is saying that, no one is saying that, we are not talking anymore, we are conducting an operation to communicate, so that ukraine does not exist, and now we are also fighting against the west, which wants to take us over and uses ukraine, which is actually russia, as a tool for this, well, very it's difficult, it's difficult, one sentence. you won't put yourself in, but for the russian people, you need one sentence, an explanation , two, he won't understand - that's the difficult part. the question is that anything can be achieved with victory, i've been saying this all the time, so you think that for the russians, kherson is the tsar of aparatsk, and the russians can to believe that this is a victory because there are no troops in belgorod, yes, and then the troops appear in the whites, and there is no enemy in moscow, and from

mikhail leontiechku tuzov already spoke correctly . i want to remind you we don't love russian culture but i think that it should not be studied there is a wonderful phrase by mikhail yuriyovich lermonto vas poems borodino yes there were people in our time not that the current tribe is rich and not vydaevy the wicked got the will now they are the most important when god’s will is not given to me. god’s will was not given to moscow. well, god decided so, but they took it and gave it to me. well, when there is no one, god’s sake, they did not give it to kherson, nor did they separate donetsk. luhansk is not otlyt, but they did not like belgorod-bokkurskom. look, i’m sorry. that’s it. the evening is rational but here we are now watching, remember the 14-15-16 years in the

crimea class we have it here quietly we don’t have it, but in donetsk, you can see these horrors, we would have them if yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes now they are talking in some i don’t know kulyanskyi imagines that in belgorod there is a ruler who would have started this , that he found it there, they shoot goblins, goblins. well, where are you overestimating, i would say the ability of the russian people to establish a causal connection to the holidays, yes, yes, yes, yes. we have a lot of singing in a few weeks they can say it on war but the most important thing is that this is a trick of the chekists , they can't tell people what they want in principle. yesterday we still took kyiv, but today we don't. today we yes. yesterday we said general lapin, who left liman, a bastard, a bastard

, a hero, stayed, left kherson, the one who left liman, but that's how it was. i'm sorry, even during the second world war, general pavlov was retreating, and the marshals of olga chi zhukov somehow bought the marshal of victory. shot and shot well, who shot, no one was shot, and no one wanted to ask at the time, and of course, what is the logic? this is serious. the stadium is recognized better yes i know better yes, i really wouldn't want to ask such a question there there better no there better i know uh that's why they definitely know

something that we don't it's not by chance that they are sitting there as tax collectors well, how is everything it's you and if you take a map of the soviet union and take it and look here is brest and here is stalingrad and here are all the marshals of victory ran from brest to stalingrad, then according to this logic they should all be shot, but only pavlo, but only pavlov was shot and all the rest normally became marshals of victory, a very funny story if i wasn't so sad because people died and are dying now. well, behind people's bodies, everything is like that, you know, they told me this is interesting, come on, in an interview with one, the beetroot fund is taken freely and they tell me. well, that's what we see, yaka now it will be a mobilization. and you know that the bolyats are just like they were sent to the battle for moscow. yes, just like now, a huge number

were mobilized, and then the war ended. why are the buryats going and they somehow explain that it is the rural population that is easier to mobilize because they wrote now, i think it matters because putin is simply uprooting the people of the soviet union well, by the way, the russian federation by the way, stalin could too to think that katya is going to the national people's congress so that the russian people are not offended, that's important, yes, and why. by the way, there are so many heroes of the soviet union among the ukrainians, among the jews, that's not proportionally more than the russians, not because the russians are not so brave, but because they were mobilized more carefully, well logically and of course there were more of them in the army, of course because they are simply absolutely absolutely, but in any case, these unfortunate buryats from these national fences, in fact, they only recovered after this decade, they were cleaned out again, it’s like this

hedocide yes kateryna oliynyk good day. what do you think? how will the liberation of kherson affect the situation at the front? can the russians advance in the bahamian direction? why not? war is war. alleger komarlier. you can't say anything here. it can be both very optimistic and, to put it mildly, not very optimistic . it seems to me that the russians are now trying more to defend than to advance, and the initiative is obvious. ukraine can even say why. they can attack, they can defend themselves in order for a person to attack, it is necessary to understand that the military is a serious profession and this applies to generals and officers and soldiers, people must be trained for us , that is, so that they survive the offensive. and when you defend yourself, you create some defense certifications, you sit in a trench it also does not mean that it is so. everything is fine. no, but often survival is greater in defense than we have here. you are only based on this

when i say that of course there will be attempts to attack bakhmut. but in order to do all this , the russians must have prepared forces now of course, a certain part of the mobilized will be taught because, again, nothing is over for putin, for him everything continues. so, it does not depend on putin, and if it happens, i have some internal suspicions that the industrious man is very protective of the troops, not for very simple reasons, and in me. that's how he behaves. i'm not an expert. i have the impression that he wants the russian front to collapse and they run away so that they don't fight. well, so as not to lose our own because we are going on the attack. we will still lose even if all the battles are now said by the americans hundred thousand or more russians have been disabled and the ukrainians say that there are 10 times less of us ukrainian president here anyway we lost 10,000 people and

that is a lot and therefore the ideal option is for the russian front to be empty and they simply fled and i have the impression that a lot is being done for this with these long-range artillery, the destruction of some headquarters, the destruction of ammunition, the destruction of roads, junctions, so that they simply run away with blood and so that the ukrainians do not run forward to attack, as in the second world war, they do not run anyway. tell me please, when you fight during the broadcast , kick each other under the table without a doubt, and in italy he pushes me with new legs, longer, bigger, longer at this table and sida . because he has a weapon, it is like a ukrainian, more precisely, a nato weapon of ukrainians. in this case, i am acting as a

russian invader, and vitaly as a ukrainian warrior, he is not the same as he will give here . you see, i suffer, but i have, i would say, marina’s version we will consider them to be the main topic of the day of the liberation of kherson. what do you think russia will do in the future to destroy the city of kherson with rockets? i don't know . such a moment that they are faced with a choice whether to kill the civilian structure or to use it at the front when they started they had an unlimited amount of everything as

they thought and they can shoot and shoot and shoot with their hands, they definitely have a lot of all this, but not so much anymore, and my hope is that they, well, what are they, what will they achieve if they start continuing to shoot at kherson, which has already been liberated, they have already blown up everything they wanted there, i don't know, it's hard for me to climb in putin's head, it seems to me that, after all, now the issue of the civil infrastructure option is a priority for putin, rather than the military one. can be overcome with these ordinary soviet missiles, which they really don't have, yes, yes, yes, these are projectiles. this is a completely different story regarding these long-range missiles and so on. these are exactly the missiles that will be fired at this territory

because they need them for that to destroy the ukrainian critical structure, and as you know, they were engaged in this exactly this night, there they destroyed strategic objects in vinnytsia, they will do it because this is now the main direction of the war for them, what is the idea now, they cannot fulfill these goals by military means and they act as they acted . whenever they cannot achieve something by military means, they start burning villages , cities, terrorizing the local population - this is generally the tactic of any terrorist army and see what happens next, because this is really your army. we can advance but while it advances towards us, you will have nothing left in the rear, the main idea is the destruction of the rear, and now success in the war will depend primarily on how well you manage to defend the rear . the direction of the war, because if this tactic of theirs is abandoned, it will mean several things, firstly, that a really huge part of the territory will be destroyed, secondly, that a large number of people will

leave again, this will again be a migration press to europe 2, this is what they want why do they want exactly in the winter period when electricity is expensive when gas is expensive when everything is expensive this is the second point what it wants the third they will always say from the west well well well well well and what will you do with all this we will buy these you will buy oil and gas from us or china and we will use this money to buy drones early and everything will be beautiful and so we will be a country in the desert what will be a lesson for all other former soviet republics what when we turn here to others with a question i didn't want to play, it's not a question. yes, we're not a mountain. he says that it won't happen. we shouldn't pour anything. well, you want to live like this. live and be friends with your

americans. it's not a secret, and you understand very well that how many of our viewers don't watch us precisely because they have a blackout. that's all. here's an interesting option. do you know or do you think that changes should be introduced in the legislation regarding stricter punishment of collaborators? what kind of changes should these be ? judging by the question, the answer for the questioner would be immediate execution, so i want to say that i am very afraid of this harsher punishment. why, because i have no guarantee in a fair ukrainian court, and when we introduce a harsher punishment, we are writing we are writing in the criminal code, there is somewhere not up to 10 years, but up to 15 or shooting, well conditionally. we don't have the death penalty, and at the same time, a judge who does not have

confidence to give a guarantee that this is really a collaborator and he really deserves 20 years, but i have no convictions . such individual work and how much envy there is in ukraine for various reasons, and well, they tell me some stories, for example, from chernihiv oblast, and some huge fields, some uncle in these fields, some farmer came, so there are many people working on the farm the russians came, he left, gave them vodka in lard, they drank vodka, asked let's go, just don't destroy it here, they didn't destroy it, the harvesters sifted, then they harvested the crop there, they milked something from the cow well, in short, people worked, someone made money

, and so on. we will count here as if he had contacts as if he did it as if he came collaboration - this is not a contact collaboration - this is a conscious work of a connection connected with a neighbor he does not love him he is jealous of him so i am very careful if it was in saxon the legal and law enforcement legal system or the european one, maybe somehow i would be more sympathetic , i will open up with you and perform the atlas kherson 's legal system did not work during the second world war and people interview intervals where the court, but by national origin yes japanese people seem to be people e they were arrested without any precedent , the war is such cruelty, and the other problem is the harsher punishment of collaborators, this moment three three words are important. we define collaborators now

or after the war, during the war. i agree with italy which means the war is being assessed and we need to find out who is who rabinovych what is there what is there what did you do in kherson what did you do in kharkiv oblast, chernihiv oblast, kyiv oblast and so on no, this is a stalinist approach what did you do when yes yes yes yes yes people are not responsible for the fact that they live in the occupied territories. and for the fact that they work in the occupation administrations of the special services, the university, that my father was in the occupied territory, i had no options, i wrote the truth, and my father really was in the occupied territory , obviously the occupying territory and millions of people lived in the occupied territories, and then they were to blame for this. and this definitely cannot be the case with us. because all the time the population living in the free territory tries to blame us for something, and the population suddenly finds itself in the occupied territory, we need to rebuild a state in which there will be no inhabited space in the occupied territory because there will be no occupied territories for literally 1 minute left before

the end of our conversation today, i think that this should be the end of this dialogue, here we are now we see how the people of kherson who lived in the occupied territory welcome the ukrainian troops and, of course, the effective state that we want to build, this is exactly the state that will never again allow the occupation forces to come anywhere because the collaborators are largely due to the defeat of the army if the army stands on they are not allowed at the border, there are no collaborators. of course, this is an important point, and people with some other political views express these by voting for certain forces that do not find support in the majority of the population, and this conflict is resolved, so let's hope that we will never be collaborators and there will never be traitors, because there will never be foreigners on our land. thank you. glory to kherson . glory to the ukrainian army. good luck to her. the lord of all the best

. let's see how people who suffer from rheumatism live. and arthrosis is changing, so i smeared dolgit in the morning. now let the dolgit cream relieve pain, reduce swelling and improve the mobility of the joints, because the joints are already broken, the only yellow cream for pain in the joints and back, order on the website pharmacy 911.ua dolgit cream 100 grams with a 20% discount events, the most important events, events that are happening right now and affect our lives, of course, the news feed reports about them, but it is not enough to know what is happening, you need to understand antin

borkovsky and invitation experts soberly assess the events, analyze them, modeling our the near future that saturdays at 1:00 p.m. with a repeat at 10:00 p.m. studio event with anton borkovskii nayspresso no matter what the ukrainians think about so that they don't talk in the first place, the war still comes out, the war is ours victory seven days a week from monday to sunday seven different spheres of human activity sports culture politics eight presenters of express journalists experts opinion leaders in real time about the most current events through the prism of war every day author's projects on espresso i'm iryna koval mother wife host of the espresso tv channel and also me volunteer,

our soldiers at the front need a lot of things every day, and that is why part of my life today is helping the armed forces of ukraine, and i am very grateful to my colleagues for supporting me in this, now i i walk through unfamiliar lviv, not kyiv. i go to an unfamiliar coffee shop and drink delicious lviv coffee. everything is alive and everyone alive in ukraine owes the army to the army . life and the army are now a miracle. these words are synonymous in ukraine, because without the army there is no life. to help the army is to help life. help the ukrainian army and life will win over death, everyone of you can even a small contribution to support the army saves the lives of our soldiers