well, i think that all of them understand this, and the soldiers on the front understand it, and the general staff, i am sure , understands this very well and i am sure that all the necessary steps will be taken. well, in the end, look here is an important factor. the fact is that they suffer defeat after defeat and in this situation to get some kind of psychological moral resource for some kind of great offensive, well, it is very difficult and their losses are huge and not only lost personnel, which they somehow can replenish, there are mobs the ball by mobs this is not important, but somehow they have huge losses in technology to be replenished, well, in particular, there are already americans there, the pentagon declares that up to half of all tanks of all tanks that were in service in russia, not only those that they concentrated against ukraine from the very beginning, but in general, of all the moves that were in russia as of february 24,

they have already lost half, this is a gigantic incredible number, this is what was accumulated by the soviet union for decades, the most militarized country in the world. that is, it means that they have big problems in all these aspects, and that's why i understand that there will obviously be more exhausting battles, difficult battles ahead, but no one has any illusions about this, on the one hand, on the other hand, no one is afraid of them anymore and, actually, everyone they understand very well that we now have an advantage, it is now an initiative and uh, if everything is in principle globally in our favor yes, but this does not mean that the war has already ended and this does not mean that the enemy must be underestimated, the enemy must always be calculated and no, he must not be despise you should hate him, but you shouldn't underestimate him. thank you andriyuenko, officer of the freedom battalion of the national guard, he will be able to do it in donetsk region. i really

liked the words nobody is afraid of them. these are very important words, it seems to me, because until february 24 of this year, the whole planet earth was afraid of russians. and now ukrainians say we are not afraid of them. well , if the ukrainians are not afraid, then the rest will start to think in more detail about the situation, especially in the south, we will talk with vladyslav seleznyov, a military expert, a colonel of the armed forces to ukraine and grigoriy tamaram, reserve captain of the israel defense forces, military historian, i will speak russian because it seems to me that grigoriy can speak russian more easily, and vladyslav will be worse at speaking russian. we don't remember the russian language instantly on february 25 so i, er, and so i

greet grigory kamera, captain of the reserve of the israel defense forces, a military historian, and vladyslav seleznyov, a military expert, a colonel of armed forces forces of ukraine hello , i'm glad to see you, and we'll start with mrs. grigory, and hello, first of all, secondly, a very important question for you. well, i am asking for forgiveness, and so look. well, this is how you assess, looking from the middle east, what happened yesterday, the day before yesterday, and maybe even part of today happened around kherson and in kherson itself. well, here are three factors for me. with one

the skill of your armed forces is constantly increasing, which is explained by the fact that there is an increasing factor of the experience of your servicemen, first of all, the command staff and also the rank-and-file, of course, plus, of course, you are trained by your western allies, too, a factor that must be taken into consideration, that is, your troops fight all the best , and the russian ones troika how is this not paradoxical, they are getting worse and worse because, well, if you understand more, so say a deep-seated question, well, they lost a significant part of their of the cadre of officers and here are many mobilized er those who fall into the ranks of the armed forces apparently there is simply no one to train and actually not enough time is devoted to this, we have already been told a lot about this, the difference is 32 factors agreed, so to speak, in one segment of er locality in one for three times the time well, plus there is another factor that also cannot be

reset a-and one of mars' rockets on the antonovsky bridge, which in particular led to the fact that part of that bridge collapsed, and apparently it played a certain role as a catalyst here, i understand that when information about this began to reach the troops who were supposed to according to the idea of ​​holding a perimeter in the city and forcing you to fight in the city, it seems that this is panic information and the realization that if they don't drop everything now, it's not a fever, it's not actually an impulse, and it seems to me that it also played a role here because all the experts agreed that

the russian side would try to impose gut-wrenching street fights on you, and well, i was talking about the fact that this is a progrytsa for about a week, actually part of your uh , their alcohol, and the politicians also talked about the fact that the city will be liberated for a week, and it turned out so that this is generally a frozen number, mr. vladyslav seleznyov, that is how i am addressing you. excuse me , that it is in russian, uh, two questions for you, continuation of my grigory, uh, that is, from one country. i want to ask you, that is, we we can tell you that the russians did not have an organized withdrawal. this is the first and second question. how do you assess the situation that has developed in the kherson region over the last

week , let's say, the first and second question? plan for the promotion of the ukrainian defense forces, but here i think it is necessary to supplement it because of the reason that the ukrainian defense forces systematically worked on logistics routes, the same bridges along which the rescue technical e-e military assistant for 10 russian troops on the right bank of the dnieper was cleared, there is no logistics due to russian tanks, there is no fuel, there is no ammunition, there is no food for the personnel and water, there are no repair parts, in fact, he clearly understands the fact that tomorrow they will be worse than today, that is why , from a rational military point of view, the decision of russian or not russian grouping is a matter for the left bank of one perfect thing касая процесся как всё ето изиходы i have not seen any reductions in our general staff, and how many russians are left on the right bank of the dnieper, although it is obvious that now search and raid operations are being conducted in order

to catch all russian military personnel, be it sabotage-developed groups, whether they were lost, plus, again, we have not yet seen information about how much russian equipment was abandoned on the right bank of the dnieper, because russian general konashenko is the main spokesman the ministry of defense of russia reports that the last soldier of russia was not taken from the right of the coast and to match all the equipment was taken. it's worse and worse , ukrainians are better and better. how do you explain it? gospodenisilizyov, that's how it's possible to understand when there's a war and, uh, experience should be gathered according to ideas, and one and the other side are not alone and the second side is fighting, but one gets some positive experience and improve, and the other

one receives negative experience and vice versa deteriorates their knowledge, their skills, their skills . in this context, the russians have shrapnel from ukrainian shells, and russia is lucky because the combat work of ukrainian activists is exceptional, first of all, the school of artillery in the spaces of the former ussr is ukrainian the school is the best. plus, ukraine has a sufficient amount of weapons from our western partners and, accordingly, ammunition with the same artillery systems. we all know that these were the procedures of russian loops. this is a loss as a result of the effective work of ukrainian partners. they are responsible even on the right bank of the dnieper, where the russians were sharpened among the elite. some things about landings of the public campaign and about the

guards tank and the guards motorized rifle unit, but nevertheless a natural decrease personal composition, the result of the combat work of the ukrainian translation and it was noticeable that russia pulled on the right bank and even an additional member of the chemobykov of those most civil-russian federation called as part of the partial killing of naruto. it's not enough. here, please , please, please answer. all of us had the same land. spring, summer, autumn, uh, all of us have approximately the same amount of weapons. ukraine is currently superior because of western weapons, while russia is superior because it has accumulated more soviet reforms. what is going on in the minds of russians, lord

grigory ? i understand this situation. 4 you train ukrainian military medics as an israeli specialist, and i then noticed that the level of the ukrainian army was extremely low in the 15th year. it was, however, and for these codes, it was committed an incredible leap in quality, i did not recall the military history that in 7-8 years the army has improved so much in terms of personnel qualifications. i think that this is an unprecedented coincidence. it was apparently caused by many factors. of other countries , the big role in the preparation of your military er unconditionalities belongs to your head committee, who is a man of a completely new generation of conceptual vision.

this is the fact that you did not follow the soviet paradigm. until now, the russian generals of officers are still there. por is in the paradigm of the second world war, and here it is, here it is, the collision is a completely different concept, one of which is several stages of the evolution of the war higher than that which gave the result. well, of course, the factor that your servicemen protect their home are in complete a-a such internal conviction that their business is right and they cannot lose this excision war for them it is of course also very important and a factor i think that not in this respect their position is much more enviable than many from which i understand what they are doing on ukrainian land, why they ended up there and in fact strive

only to save life there a -a well and so on первые месяце войны, the russian officer corps suffered very large losses simply. well, a large number of officers were destroyed by the generals, by the way, too, and accordingly, someone in the system must lead it. it’s not just now that the command staff has been promoted. skazaetsya here is another question for you, mr. tomar, and tell me, would you advise ukraine to be like israel, because a very large discussion is about what kind of military future ukraine will have? with such a neighbor as russia and many experts , let's make it like switzerland, like in israel, that

practically the entire population capable of living is distributed according to some kind of platoon, the whole population knows where to go, what to go with, when to go, with what weapons to go, what they can know, what they can't know where is the food, where is the water, where is the medicine, all the population knows everything, and only a wave of the hand and everyone ran, fired, went, stood in position and waited for the enemy and defeated the enemy, because this is the total uh-uh, how is the readiness of the nation for war how in israel for you to tell such a ukrainian expert? well, you know, i will tell you about this topic. when the war started and it became clear to everyone in the world that you are not going to surrender, that the gala dinner of the russian officers for the baptism will have to be canceled, apparently, that the war will take place protracted character, one of our israeli generals retired, this is about three weeks, how the show conflict, he did, uh, this is a

detailed analysis, uh, well, that's why ukraine survived стредительную победу почему близкриг провалисься how is this in the middle of march? i just heard his report on the israeli council, and one of the things he noticed was that he gave a very high emphasis on your forces of territorial defense, and to some extent, you can't say that eh- well, it says that, well, maybe somewhere, the israeli experience was consciously or consciously perceived here, but i don’t think that it’s a good idea for a copy. here is to accept er with accuracy so to say absolutely i i think that each party has its own specifics, it is determined by israel, i will tell you more about that , teo, i live in israel here , eh, there are also big changes in the system of the reserve

service, and there are also many things that change here, too. according to the dictates of time, it is up to them to say, uh, do a uh review, as they say, but there are some possible elements, they may be relevant for you , moreover, israel is a country that willingly shares its positive experience. i think that if it is accepted the solution at the highest level is to contact our specialists, they will be happy to tell you how to do it, however, i am not sure that it is 100% accurate. it is worth copying, especially since you already have your own experience in this regard already said the experience of territorial defense, he was in the first weeks of the war, it was incredibly important for you , vladislav, and would you advise, thank you, grigory, would you advise to take a closer look and adopt this experience, or, after all, regular

armed professional forces are needed in ukraine or all the same, these are the elements of the israeli, let’s say, the swiss israeli or israeli swiss defense system, please be sure to open gosudarstude israel, the opposition is automatic, and it is de facto hostile to the world. to the full extent of the ukrainian defense forces, the question is enough to discuss, we see that the ukrainian wars are using the experience of the american, british , and baltic countries in the confrontation with the russian er, the aggressor, er, our specialists in the scandinavian countries have learned a lot of good and useful things, in fact, they say that under which nothing is owned by the ukrainian defense forces, he is unique, this is such a thing, it’s a hodgepodge of the best from what is currently present in modern military science but i

would still focus more on the statement of general bohdanov, the head of ukrainian intelligence, who says literally the following until the end of the year if the future year of the ukrainian defense force will be on the state border of ukraine in at the borders of the 91st year and then the most interesting thing will begin for the russian federation. unfortunately, there is no detail. what exactly will be interesting is happening on the territory of the russian federation, but i sincerely hope for the following. федерации его есточноуперезация - this is a very important factor today, thanks vladyslav seleznyov and military expert colonel of the armed forces of ukraine hryhoriy tamar, captain of the army reserve defense of israel, a military historian was with us. thank you, grigory

. of international energy and security relations. i will talk about this during the answer to the question because there is by the way such and such a question appears some very unverified very speculative data about the negotiation possible negotiating positions of the parties, what are the parties, the russian side has some negotiating position , i repeat once again, this is speculation, we have not held a candle, and we do not have such documents in our hands, but rumors are circulating and this is the negotiating position from the other side, this is the ukrainian negotiating position in union with europe, the atlantic negotiating position, that is, there is such a western

world here, and the west for russia is both ukraine and russian, and it is very interesting, this negotiating position, which seems to be trying to push through the kremlin in the kremlin all agree except for putin, and we will talk in more detail when we have such an opportunity, and the opportunity will appear during the answer to the question, and now they ask if mr. mykhailo is in contact with us, and they tell me that he is not. well, then, as always , i start with me one question, but i never have time to answer at least one, yes, yes, otaka, do you know what it means, the live broadcast is not adjusted, but a little something was sold, which was supposed to start in october, but while they are squeezing crumbs out of it, the steps are surviving because they are a forest. loot who is anastasia? and now they are giving us so that you can choose when they give high-quality weapons or if

you have to pay for high-quality weapons, maybe not today, but definitely tomorrow, but definitely the day after tomorrow, or return them back, so this is a very complicated story with the supply of weapons, it is not given that way they are not given , sold or donated or leased or given with deferred payment or a billion weapons supply mechanisms, and this is the mechanism you say gave a lease, but it is a lend-lease, look at the translation of this whole phrase already mykhailo gonchar, expert on international energy and security relations, president of the center for global studies, strategy 21, we are in touch on the phone , now i see that these are the phones of mr. mykhailo, i would like to hear from you. it is a pity that i did not see you. greetings, mykhailo , good evening at least now

the question so, as far as we can judge, let's start with european affairs that the hopes of the russians to freeze europe are in vain, as far as we can talk about the fact that behind the excitement and europe will experience a winter that may not be ideal, but such a one within the limits, well satisfaction, you know, once upon a time in the soviet winter , the five-point system was satisfactory, it was three out of three with a plus. europe will survive this winter, it looks like that, well, at least those panicky army publications that were in the european press a couple of months ago, and even a month ago, now there are no more, i.e. numbers and europeans are used to believing in numbers , well, they say that this one will pass, but in

addition, the warm weather contributes to this, of course, no one knows what the weather will be like next, what temperature extremes will be there, so to speak, but here, but in in principle, the situation looks quite optimistic, if you give an example, it will pass. but the main thing is not how much there is left in gas storages, in principle, 95% of gas is filled, that there is a normal flow of liquefied gas, and so on , the question well, in principle, psychologically, the european politician what if there was always configured uh well yes no yes no yes why won't it be possible to quickly adjust to alternative supplies of gas not from russia and where to get it and so on that is now if we see such a phenomenon of such a positive

obstinacy so it's not a desire anymore, but to deal with russia and not only in the gas sector, everyone has become enlightened , mr. mykhailo, one more question, short and long. well, short, everything makes sense. i expect a short answer, and 23-24 winter because many experts say yes. continued to arrive even from russia in the summer, in the spring, maybe even partially at the beginning of autumn, that is, there are some options, they were in europe, and they say 23:24 winter, when there will definitely be nothing. how did you react to this, and then i will ask the next question, but now please tell me what i don't think what will be waiting for us in a year. but it is more likely for now if such a hypothetical scenario that there could

be problems, but look ah, a lot will depend on how things will go in east asia, especially in china, just in time for this season 22-23 of the year helped to a great extent. presented themselves on the european market and eliminated the potential deficit there, the deficit has not been presented in full, it will be, but it is not of a fatal nature, i think that the next year will be the same because the chinese economy is too massive, too inertial, and the question is no, of course, because if you can now draw various scenarios, including some such army or even

fatalistic ones, but i think that this will not be the case here, there is another problem that, uh, is currently being considered well, it is already being considered, if so, but also more hypothetically, what will happen in the event that suddenly ah again, suddenly, i'm taking quotes , the gas supply lines from the north sea to europe will be damaged, norwegian gas and through the mediterranean sea, algerian gas, why did they think about this, because no one knows what putin will do next regime so and if the corresponding scenarios i think in the kremlin were prepared in advance for chas ch ot although now nothing indicates that russia will dare to take any real actions in relation to europe, but it is difficult to

say what will happen in a year and in what direction war will develop in europe, what is it called , another important question is this formulaic, i have a formulaic question for you so we see europe and we understand that the energy balance of europe is minus russia , and the question arises. can you add something? i mean everything, i didn't do it with gas, oil, well, coal, i think nuclear energy will be enough in europe, which has now been unblocked, and even the germans will have enough. finally forget this dependence on russia like a bad dream. god give them health and sanity, and then it

will be compensated. i see that there are very intensive negotiations, for example, with azerbaijan, but azerbaijan does not have many opportunities for that azerbaijan, i don't know what i will do there gas is full but i understand here the middle east is also there, there are also some negotiations there, the judges, arabia, the emirates, and so on and so on. and where else to get it and are they being conducted? what do you think of the negotiations with those rogue states and rogues, that is, iran and venezuela for example, let's look, let's first look at the situation in terms of gas, so who said that europe has seen the light of day and now they rushed to look. and where is there, although it was a long time ago and it is well known that something is located, what is in azerbaijan, what is in turkmenistan, what is it number four after iran russia and qatar in terms of gas reserves and corresponding projects were there starting from the end of the 90s and so on. now they are looking at all this. how

to do it, but it is impossible to do it quickly, but build a transport system there on the eastern shore of the caspian sea and in the turkmen one, for example, in the center europe is also a few thousand kilometers, there will be a couple of tens of billions of euro investments somewhere. well, to be somewhere there at the level of the northern stream, let's say there are 50 or 60 billion heaps a year. of course , no one does this. that is why the european union is betting on liquefied gas in order not to create the effect of a new tro-county dependence, especially on the erdogan regime in turkey, which is quite problematic for europe, because everything will still go through turkey, so the bet it is done for liquefied gas on the one hand, and here, if the partnership between the united states and qatar was correctly marked, they are going to the middle east, of course, azerbaijan can help with timely

deliveries, i think, but it will be plus 10 plus 20 billion , somewhere in the future, they do not know the weather, the main thing is what is the bet on the european union is, as it were , an acceleration of this green transition, i.e. , one way or another, a reduction in gas consumption, primarily due to the de-russification of gas imports, which is called, but in principle, not only there, er, gas in in general, in order to reduce gas consumption, replace with water as soon as possible those plans that they planned for somewhere in the 30th year there or the 35th fortieth. addictions thank you mr. mykhailo gonchar i apologize terribly but simply