and there will be a pause, the ukrainian defense force will continue the counteroffensive, yes, of course, a certain general moroz will make certain adjustments in the plans of hostilities, but let's pay attention to the following. the fact is that the current war is primarily an artillery war, will the frosty weather interfere with ukrainian citizens conditions , they actively used artillery not too much, because it is obvious that the logistics of ammunition and the movement of our artillery batteries are certain, and the algorithm has been worked out. but the targets in the enemy's territories in new positions are more than enough, and here there is a key factor - this is the constant supply of e and artillery systems and ammunition to the same activists , according to the rcz class of himers and their channels from our western partners, and combat work for our community will be found listen well, there is one version or one of the theories that while those who drive these

heavy armored vehicles are waiting for the mers soil so that they don't get stuck in the swamps for which direction is this most relevant about what about which about which part of the front, of course, this is the language of our sawing fields, after there will be abundant autumn rains , the cover of this territory will be used precisely for the movement of the defense of equipment in the first place yes, but there are roads with a hard surface, they can be used in any period of time, including after the autumn rains, it is obvious that the hostilities will continue, it is obvious that other levers of influence of the ukrainian defense forces will be used on the opposition of the enemy. we remember that despite the statement of general konashevkov such a spokesman for the ministry of defense of the russian federation of ukraine, there is an air force of ukraine, there is an

army of ukraine, there are special forces that are able to operate in any weather conditions, well, once again i felt the blows on enemy positions by vladyslav, another aspect, from the weather to the water and to what is happening on water i am now talking about the black sea fleet of the russian federation, which continues to be in the combat space, yes, in the sevastopol bay, they say one carrier, only according to the latest data, it was withdrawn with seven with e-e type missiles of the e-e caliber, but around 10 ships are located in the mediterranean sea with several tens of dozens of total in a salvo. is it possible to explain today such will from the black sea fleet in the water area directly in the black sea? cool wording

combat simple it now reminds me of a working vacation p yanukovych is a real cool version and in fact let's start from the next the name of the black sea fleet of the russian federation is a guy or a flotilla, because in fact now only one of these caliber missile weapons is located in the water area of ​​montenegro, it is more like it is hiding behind the main ridge of the crimean mountains, we all remember well that the kharoz region is it is reliably covered by the same ridge that protects, including the russian-occupation ships from our ukrainian missiles, name it of course he can target our positions, but further on, we are farrowing your will not dare stick your nose out, because you have a great experience when the frigate admiral makaro dared to leave in order to

replenish supplies in the waters of the sevastopozhka bay , so that later what happened to him, the whole world knows. well, admiral makarov is undergoing long-term repairs on sunday after the attack of sea thrones . so, it is most likely the previous ones putin's plans, the alarms of the officials regarding the active use of the black sea against the russian federation to carry out a naval landing in the odesa region and the odesa region will remain dreams , the russian federation does not have the same resources to have the right of the city to name what is left of the black sea fleet, we need to wait for some demonstrative changes in the personnel of the military unit in the ministries of murder in russia, we need to wait for surovikin to put a bullet in his forehead for the shame he caused, or nothing will happen and no one will be punished and they will accuse again

partially mobilized who covered the ukrainian land with an insufficiently thick layer regarding the covering of the ukrainian land with a thick thick thick layer uh, the russian army is working on this, this process came to life, they are helping, including the ukrainian army and other defense forces. i think that in this world, time, because the martyrologist of 80,000 russian casualties is not the final uh, of this process, as for personnel decisions, i don’t i think that they will happen in the near future. of course, the destructive process that is taking place among your kremlin will continue, but in the near future i do not think that it will happen to them that they are already behind the broken of the russian-ukrainian confrontation and their chances are falling. somehow there has been a re-measurement and

the possibility of preserving some remnants of honor and the same thing. they have lost all this and i am finished. the victory of the ukrainian people of the ukrainian army is the only question here, now, what price to pay? the ukrainian people for this victory. by the way, mr. vladyslav. in your opinion, what margin of safety does general zorovitin have left in the retreat? one indent well, he will withstand the type well, two already most likely no, he will be replaced by someone, if they are, then by whom, because that's why i'm quite cautious about what was stated in my colleagues because, well, putin is ready to resort to very radical personnel changes who should replace general syrovyki for that loudmouth, not

a beauty, nor his military environment? i am convinced that the er former zk will never find support and understanding among russian generals, not even taking into account the fact that the concept of a russian general and an honorable officer are no longer quite the same. where will the russians transfer those er troops and units? i have a word to say, thank you for stopping me, er, those troops and units that have now been withdrawn from kherson region, it will be donetsk region, it will be donetsk. i always don’t ask myself the question . units as far as possible or to other parts of the front, because it is obvious that after the retreat of the same group of troops from the right to the left bank, what is this about er

russian customers they should build the same defensive positions to cover the ukrainian contour offensive at the entrance to crimea er in area of ​​the perekupsky isthmus therefore, it is obvious that putin's general is so stupid as not to understand that the ukrainian defense forces will not begin to literally force the dnipro into a wolf in order not to be exposed to mortal danger, and our force and means will be used and other alternative asymmetric actions aimed at the decoupation of their zaporozhye, respectively, the south of kherson region , therefore, in order to try to stop the same ukrainian club odesa in the countryside, the generals were forced to leave everything that was left of that grouping of russian troops in relation to recently acting on on the right bank of the dnieper. at the same time on the left bank of the dnieper, the overturning of individual units is quite possible.

try to push our units to the luhansk region. perhaps if in these two sections of the front there are remnants of russian troops on more elite troops, i will remind you in our audience that at one time on the right bank of the dnieper there were elite russian units of landing forces, marines and guardsmen, tanks, guardsmen, riflemen i don't think there are many of them left. but nevertheless , in the russian steering wheel in certain areas of the front, i think they will be glad to have such a replenishment. well, again, let's not forget that she has slowly but nevertheless, this grouping of russian troops is now forming shock units and units on the territory of the republic of belarus, so far there is no threat, but the trend is more difficult. forces in the south of the country, you mean the filigree and

surgical work of precision projectiles there with ammunition or places to the word deployment of the rashists or something else in and if it was so more careful to say uh we were tearing down today we know that is happening on the kinburg axis, uh, there are also certain strange things happening there, the game is officially summarized from the ukrainian general staff, there is no but we suggest waiting for official summaries or from the greek ones, or maybe from nataliya humenyuk to kinbursk krasii and these are actual crimes of the left bank of the mykolayiv region, and i think that the same symmetrical actions will be the result of the successful in certain actions of the defense of ukrainian villages directed

on the bottom of the enemies that have struck our lands in years, because the absolute substance that the larger the organism is, we move it, the easier and more effective will be the further counterattack of the ukrainian defense forces. thank you very much. in the donetsk region, please go to the shelter of civil protection, do not neglect this information, it is extremely important to keep yourself physically and mentally healthy in order to rebuild the country quickly and simply it is not will be and so it will be expensive for each of us and you, despite the fact that foreign partners are helping us significantly to rebuild the country and at our expense, of course. by the way, the result of the work of the imf mission should be a monitoring program for ukraine, it will become the basis for a full-fledged program with the imf already next year this was reported by the chairman of the national bank of ukraine, andriy pishnyi, who says that

the imf understands how critical this aid is for ukraine today. program for students of the imf council, which advises on the macro-financial policy of the ukrainian government and will become the basis for receiving financial assistance from international partners in 2023, so already based on the results of this place, we expect to reach an agreement at the staff level on the basis of a memorandum on economic and financial policy, which will facilitate the discussion the imf board of the monitoring program in december andriy pyshnyi chairman of the national bank of ukraine i would like to understand how important it is for the functioning of our economy today full cooperation with the international monetary fund and what can we get from the imf, in what terms will we now deal with grigoriy kuzlova, this is the economist of ukraine, mr. grigoriy,

as if i congratulate you, speakers. to present voiced, well, regarding what cooperation with the imf gives us, what we can get from the imf, in what terms is this our coordinator for attracting external financing until the end of 2022, well, the key is in 2023. and if there is a war and the current the mechanism for financing the budget deficit is to be preserved, then well, about that in 2024 and there plus plus plus plus if before that we cooperated mainly with the imf, in fact, in the role of the main creditor so, at the moment, even these euro-plate hams do not work with the domestic market threshold funding and sufficient excuse me please here the air alarm is currently sounding in the poltava region and also in svitlovodsk and this is the district so

directly this is the kirovohrad region please go to the shelter of civil protection ignore this of information continue mr. hryhoriv and this is the coordinator, now there will be external funding with a larger source than himself, that is, we see that its 18 billion yes, and the preliminary approval of the european commission for ukraine for 2020 is a certain grant funding from the united states, there is a european investment bank, and the world bank other sources are the governments of various countries, canada, the netherlands, germany , here, the imf is actually such a key coordinator who will help the head of the national bank, the minister of finance, the diplomatic corps of ukraine to provide regular receipts would be the regularity of these receipts so that there are no sharp fluctuations that in one month there are 6 billion - in one month there is one and a half, that is, stability, rhythm and external financing in order for the ministry

to finance social expenditures and the military for 2023 as smoothly as possible in fact, this is the main a-a function of the ministry of foreign affairs in this case, well, consulting and coordination. thus, it is grigory, we clearly understand that foreign partners significantly help us, above all, to cover those the social and guaranteed payments themselves, yes, that is, it is the payment of the state's social obligations to the citizens. and what will happen after the victory? the next day after that, they will say everything themselves. do you see the important point that the foreign debt grew there during the war, and now we are significantly on external financing , and we have an asset that we are investing in, in fact, on the other side, there are potential reparations of the russian federation. and i, well, one of the optimistic options that will still be formed will definitely be formed

it is a legally correct mechanism for the transfer of confiscated russian assets. and this is only through the central bank of the russian federation, up to 300, well , 350 million dollars, plus other confiscated countries there , and great britain without restrictions. 30 billion is all in the european union, more than 20, and canada is also there, which is already there is trying to transfer the confiscated assets in 2010. all these sums are for someone. yes, with a high probability, they will be transferred to ukraine. yes, it will be in 2023. well, this mechanism needs to be developed and these funds will be sent to reconstruction. ah, most likely we will not be the only donor, well, not, not the only recipient of these funds, no, not, not the only ones receiving. that is, these are also the companies that left russia during the war there and in the spring and summer and lost certain funds. these are aa governments of other countries that are also there

they help us significantly now during the wine, that is, there is such a conditional general anti-russian coalition and all of us, well, of course, we are where we primarily receive funds from the russian federation, and after the end of the war and the possibility of reparations , this is one scenario, another. well, it is quite possible that no operations will be completed in time except for those that are still confiscated by russian assets, russia will close like the ira and will not cooperate with anyone. no, it will simply not cooperate on any programs. well, it will be isolated. and then the option is to build an economic one, in fact, it is still here in the form of ukraine with a strong economy well, these are quiet investments in infrastructure in other industries that are less prone to military features and so on

. by some structural funds of the european union, as it was there, on the example of the construction of the construction of romania, poland, hryhoriv , ​​two points, the first point. the second moment of information. now you can see the interactive map on your screens, those regions where the air alert is sounding and those where there are no threats . our economy, how strong is it? well, if it does not breathe incense, then it shows unacceptable indicators, we understand that there are factors, factors are real today that affect the state of our economy, simply the increase in prices, the decrease in the purchasing power of citizens, as soon as

possible uh, to overcome it in the future. well, we mean to return at least to the level of january. yes, this year, and what to do now with these structural economic problems that we have, see , part of it can be restored quickly enough in the winter there there is 35% of the recession, and of them, 25% of the recession is already, well, in fact , certain basic facilities were lost there and people who left and simply the capital equipment of enterprises that were destroyed and 10% - this is actually what can still be combined among themselves, the remaining capital that is just now not in the working well, not involved, not involved, and unemployed people have understood that unemployment is estimated at 30-35%, but if these labor chains

actually take unemployed people, establish some kind of entrepreneurship, make some products, at least what in in principle, after the end of the war, it is quite realistic. and this is, well, a quick boom there from 10 to 15% of economic growth at once, and everything else. objectively , objectively, it is definitely worth approaching the end of the war, and no investments in capital funds are expected, that is, the maximum that can be is simply the involvement of these unemployed people, some new production chains, we see certain programs with government parties there, yes, the army, the army, the restoration of a minimum of six and a half to some social work - it is difficult, it sounds uh, no, it is unpleasant, so far. so far, there

are no particularly better prospects, that is, the restoration that is forecasted for this next year, there is a budget the minimum budget there is a difficult moment there 3.2% even if it will be 5% even if it will be 6%, after this year's recession by 35% - it is no no no no no no years of tricovers expected in may that is , well, surely, well it is necessary to proceed from that the war there can continue for quite a long time, and business there is oriented either exclusively on exports or on some government orders , and this is due to which a certain stability is formed, because let's wait, many businesses made this mistake in the clicks of may, what now june, july, the series will suddenly decline. you just need to wait a little. well, this mistake is possible . for whom it was fatal? grigory was once calculated where he owed billions of hryvnias and gdp losses, and one day of air alarms spills out in

in ukraine, you can calculate how much we lost due to the destroyed energy infrastructure and because of how much business lost as a final yes, for example, the consumer a-a in this sense lost e-e profits and how much the state budget lost denisenko, when i see the ministry of economy, they show that the recession deepened from -35 to -39% in october due to the deterioration of the electricity supply situation, this is the only public estimate that is available at the moment. system in ukraine, they say that right now is the perfect time to show investors that we understand that something is wrong with our tax system. something is wrong and we are ready to change, they say that it will attract more investors

. the task is quite simple and probably classic for everyone. there are 30 years of ukrainian economic history , there are rates at which we, the business, make payments, pay taxes, make it look like they are collecting them, although in fact there is the same vat, formal the rate there is up to 20%. the effective rate there often falls below 11 well, there where there were good real managers there, somewhere effectively the rate about him is 12 13 that is, the history of vat , the history of wages there yes, there is a formal burden there 18 22 yes, there is a military levy that is, well, 40% is like an eu country, that is, in practice, there is 30%, half of this wage fund in ukraine is in the price, employees are divided into fops .

cryptocurrencies usd and so on and so on, and with the same well , income tax is also more of an exception to the rules, so that you pay most of all there state corporations and so on, and yes, well, with the tax system, what really, because it was offered, i can honestly say to myself on these assets, the business does not pay taxes, and the thesis that we are now christening the administration, it will all work, it is actually just a thesis in order to promise time and not to reform, including rates, that is, yes, somehow it is due to a problem with communication then everyone will pay the same yes yes yes yes we came back we understand that we all live in ukraine that's why there may be problems with light and communication but you are ready for that yes mr. grigoriyu one more moment it concerns our national debt

the day before i read the analysis i want to understand if this is so whether or not they say that crossing the $300 billion debt limit for any of the countries means, uh, it turns into bondage. well, it’s not such a hole from which to get out, in fact, it ’s unrealistic. now, we talked the day before with with oleg penzeny, he said that we have a public debt of 100 billion dollars. is it true that it is 300 billion? this is the maximum limit, which it is better not to cross. it is simply calculated in billions, it is calculated only as a percentage of your annual income to gdp . let's go for 100%. well, we are actually very strong, very well prepared, entered the economic war, and with good debt indicators there, it seems to be below 60%,

until even if this year we go over a hundred ok - it is unpleasant, but in principle for the eyes well, for the country and actually survived a real war, it’s not that it’s very problematic a-a moment one moment two uh-e a large part of this debt that is mentioned is internal debt and just one actually has money that just runs back and forth through the system a-a internal the debt is there national bank and state banks and well, in principle well, considering that this is a transfer from pocket to pocket, you can somehow, well, deduct them from this one, that is, the indicators significantly improve there well, if we could actually return to the gate crisis and the level and well, conditionally we read that oschadbank buys the ministry of finance's reserve fund and finances the budget deficit, this is not a classic coastal load - these are securities that simply sit on the balance sheet of the same state bank, and the moment is three, all these debt obligations can, well, it won't

happen, but if it is necessary, it can be done in one year, and it will be repaid, because it is true. now we are accumulating debt. well, the debt is so every every month, where it is defined by debt borrowing, the budget deficit from the other side, and again, more than 150 billion e-e of direct losses of ukraine in war with russia just destroyed infrastructure and about 3 million dollars of indirect track estimates, i.e. all that we should earn in 2022 and 2023 there military e-e forecast yes , what is now is an understandable loss of ukraine. all these funds, they can be in the perspective of attracting civil servants, the difference is repaid, the difference is directed to the restoration of infrastructure. well, in general

, the restoration of the economy, thank you corn economists ukraine economist was with us in the only news well, we have information israel hit the syrian air base used by russia, reuters reports that israel launched a missile attack on the sheyrad air base, which was used for military purposes, and russia was hit on the airstrip as a result of which two servicemen were killed three were killed, wounded , the citizenship of the victims is not updated, the link to the raiders is not updated, these events and not only these events will be discussed further by our colleagues maria skyba and maksym sikora but after a short pause, stay with the marathon, the only news is ukrainian gives freedom, the occupiers tighten their tails when they hear the pro-ukrainian palyanitsy and pavlo, and we haven’t mentioned the 30-letter words yet, although we have affectionate words for everyone, we will find us, don’t destroy us, protect us, the power of the three

forms of the future tense, we will go, we will go to despite all the victories, the ukrainian language is free, my native donetsk, i last saw it in 2012, and soon the war will take away from me the opportunity to return home for almost 9 years with the beginning of a full-scale invasion, training has been postponed to second plan from the first days i started volunteering like some of my fellow ukrainian gymnasts about three thousand athletes and coaches are currently defending the independence of our country more than 100 of them will never return home to our training halls orders but we must not be silent we must not silence the crimes of russia against ukraine, as russian and belarusian athletes do, and their silence is support for bloody russian

terror, and terrorists have no place in international sports. i call on all citizens of the civilized world support ukraine on the sports front, share your posts with the company's hashtags and call for a boycott of russian and belarusian athletes , it kills with the support of the ministry of youth and sports of ukraine, you can believe in victory, pray for victory, donate to victory, and you can also invest in victory and even receive from profit from this, buy government military bonds. it’s like a deposit, only not in a bank, but in the state and the army. you just take action and choose. they vary in terms of maturity from six months to one and a half year, profit depends on this, for example