that is why this reality of the economy and in russian, which, let's say , very quickly returns to the soviet times, as they are that account, mr. ivan. but at the same time, today's no, not today's, but fresh news and two days literally about the fact that russia will allocate 100 billion rubles of credit to belarus for import substitution hai they will first find uh, 100 billion years ago, you can say that the senior tasks and they uh, when they had such reserves, they could really afford it. now, times are a little different, immediately the statement of one turkish journalist when uh the russians went there for three days as part of the black sea grain initiative and declared that they would not let the boats through - on this initiative, he immediately said and you have something simple that you really had a

way to stop these caravans in february, march, april, and now it is not a fact therefore, when russia makes such statements, you know, first of all, they must somehow take care of themselves, although, again, and based on the logic of gas supply, when they have 40% gasification, and they think more about how bad it will be for europe without gas, they can do the same in the same way, that is, if the image of such a powerful country is preserved, they will be the last money in belarus, but the problem is, by the way, with the rules of russia in general . i don't really know, firstly, 10 million, secondly, if even there really are 10, it means that they have money for 10 months, unfortunately, this is not very good

news for us, but time passes so quickly, what is for them they will also quickly run out of this money, let it run out faster than in 10 months, it would be good for us thank you, mr. ivan, for the news about the economy of russia, ivan uz, the chief consultant of the institute of strategic studies, candidate of economic sciences, the only thing i think about is those people who do not they live in gasified villages in russia, they don't have anything to compare them with, they don't have to compare life with gasified villages, that's why they live and think it's normal, i don't know if it's true, but that video circulating on social networks is possible someone already laughed so hard because well, it doesn't fit in my head, but it seems that the conversation of a russian soldier with some mother , wife or sister was intercepted, where he says serve, you understand they even have cats, they have separate toilets for cats and they don't throw sand there - then there is a special m-m god, my sons of the russian language are missing special granules yes and you why

why why is this one why cats have separate toilets in a word well i don’t i don’t know what to say whether it’s true or not it’s amazing if if if that's true well, they live in a completely different world than the one we live in. even though we are not a super-developed country even during the war, we can’t boast that a non-ukrainian cat lives in much better conditions than the average russian - that’s understandable, listen, gentlemen, in the meantime let's talk a little about the next topic. bohdan dolin is an aviation expert and manager of the aviation sector. we are joined by mr. bohdan bohdanovich. good day to you. good day, listen. and over the popular theory, i would say that it is conspiratorial and about the fact that this missile attack on polish territory is after all a

russian missile and it was flying there specifically for water, this is a small village in the lublin voivodeship not for nothing , but because there i don't know if someone was drunk or some inadequate gunner accidentally killed the coordinates of lviv's longitude and kyiv's latitude, and instead of flying somewhere to kyiv or vice versa to lviv, this rocket arrived like this, turning around, conventionally speaking, this this this this this guidance ended up exactly in the beehive. to be honest, i tried to check it and there really is an error of a few minutes, well, the longitude is literally a few kilometers, there are several nations, it really looks like the truth. well , it looks like the truth. i understand that in this conspiracy theory is at least a little bit like the truth, including those that, for example, 5g towers carry covid and so on, why not so

to speak well, nevertheless, can it be considered that such a theory makes sense? yes, look in fact if in general, to analyze such events of such a nature, then it is impossible to say that such a version can take place there, or that one of the versions may not be true. at the same time, it is still necessary to wait for some preliminary results of the investigation including with the participation of ukrainian specialists, because we know that this is not the first case when there was a similar incident, i.e. everyone still remembers in march at the beginning of the war there was a case when uh, accordingly, there was a plane uh, a reconnaissance drone assigned there to detect anomalies air defense then 144 crashed directly on the territory of the european union and it crashed right near the city

whose name was very, very similar to the name of the ukrainian city. here, of course, it was written in latin. therefore, it could be one of the options, but as far as we know, how did the investigation of that incident end? it was a russian plane there, not a russian plane , it’s still unknown, or it’s just the results of this investigation. they were classified in order to simply not raise any additional uh, uh, i don’t know excitement or uh, an additional increase in degree exactly of this military from the point of view of the european union and from the other side, we see that in fact a very similar situation has now occurred with the fall of the missile territory of poland. well, but it is realistic without expert conclusions to say whether this is a pattern . that zaranovka adhere to the previous conclusions , the preliminary conclusions are still that it is an all-ukrainian missile, that it is our s300, which did not

detonate, did not work, this is the destruction of the system, and in this case, in your opinion how true is this version, or could it really have fallen to polish territory then, and why was it not intercepted by the poles, for example, in this case, their vocational training system, if we speak there as one of the options for a possible uh-uh, how did it appear by rocket to consider this, but of course well, for now only one of the possible options if we talk about the flight distance of a rocket, then of course the flight distance of a rocket allows you to perform such a rather long flight but at the same time it is necessary to understand that it is only possible evaluate, understanding from which point the missile could be launched for interception, of course this information for today will probably be classified and only there people from poland will never be able to get this information , analyze whether ukrainian systems of this type were at the appropriate distance from the zone the fall

of the rocket, in addition. if we talk about the same destruction, we must understand that indeed the s300 rocket is a rocket developed and produced in the soviet union, they are already quite old. here's how from the point of view from the point of view of the technical condition, of course. there may be some or other nuances that will lead to the failure of this equipment there, this incident or the russians will not want to touch the sky protection itself on the border with ukraine of the european union once again. maybe there is no longer a ukrainian missile namely, the russian missile will reach there, well, look from the point of view, if we are talking about the missile, the object that was discovered, then we must understand that first of all, of course, there is a part of the missile complexes that were captured in kherson oblast and zaporizhzhia e-e region or ammunition for them, so it is not

excluded that this is one of the options that the missile could also be ukrainian, as we saw that at the beginning of the war, the russians actively used sea mines that were previously captured in crimea , accordingly, they launched them into the sea there and they declared to the whole world that there are ukrainian mines floating in the sea after detaching it, this is already one of the proven facts, therefore, it is also one of the options that should not be excluded. here, uh, and therefore if we also talk about the use of rocket estimates, then they are unlikely to they did so openly there, but it shouldn’t be ruled out either, because we see that the enemy is absolutely inadequate in defining targets and direct decisions regarding their defeat. well, it seems to me that the poles are so serious about such a theoretical and maybe even a practical threat. can we show the video, will try to explain what you will see now, this is a plane with the polish football team

that went to qatar for the world cup, pay attention to how it flies, with what escort, we can show this video and next to the civilian plane, we see two military planes, taking into account the history of poland, the fact that already one plane with the leadership of the country crashed completely due to circumstances and near smolensk, you know that then a lot of people died. well, the entire leadership is actually polish and by god, including it is so the president and the leaders , yes, no, it’s illegal, god, komarovsky said, mr. bohdan, that’s what we’ve seen now. i understand that these are two polish f16s, which we dream about so much,

yes . intercepted. it is part of the general air defense system and, together with ground systems, that is, anti-aircraft missile systems for the destruction of this and other beautiful objects. at the same time, the air component, if you are talking about the nato countries, they have an air component. airplanes, they are much larger and more important element of air defense systems than even replacing the station on which today ukraine and of our sky, when when can we get so many of those planes so that we are not afraid of such massive missile attacks, which russia obviously, uh, has already even

admitted to the sand, saying that we are doing it there in order to incline you to peace negotiations and obviously, they will continue to resort to these steps, how many of them will be enough for their reserves? if we talk about the possibility of transfer, we see that negotiations are actually being conducted from the first places of war . at the same time , unfortunately, no real serious agreements have been reached. there were only certain supplies for simple parts for restoration or repair from those ukrainian parties that were on the territory of ukraine on the ground, but about the transfer of some equipment , either new or in principle of the same class or from other manufacturers, so far only unfortunately in the conditions of negotiations at the same time, there was information there about the potential opportunity to train korean pilots who could operate targets like this, but of course it can take several months from the point of view of training specialists who are able to serve to export such machines for up to six months, and maybe even a year, depends on the e type and the complexity of the e-e

equipment. in contrast to the soviet ones, for which these pilots were preparing. for sure it will be intercepted and shot down and no one will be harmed by this neither people nor objects as critical infrastructure and neither other objects yes if you are talking about the sky protection system at all, it is necessary to help that any system has the so-called that or another probability of interception, that is, there is no system that 100% guarantees that all launched missiles will be intercepted, that is, it is always about probability, if you are talking about soviet systems, then as a rule, there is a 30% interception, uh, and more, up to 50 is considered a very, very good result if you intercept most of them, then it is generally better there than, for example, typical soviet systems . if we talk about the number of aircraft, it is difficult to make assessments here, because it depends on the existing network of airfields, that is, there are several such

can be based on how quickly they can rise in the air, what part of the space they can cover . if they can’t, turning it off after detecting the missile, and it also depends on the presence of tools for detecting such objects in the air space, quickly reach it and also destroy it if it comes out. here we are talking about hundreds of planes, i.e. from 100 to such. perhaps even more depends on how many planes remain in the ukrainian state today, mr. bohdan, we basically said today at one o'clock at two o'clock there, ours is still our marathoner about the same thing, they talked about it with serhiy zgurts about what a-a can we do the same, for example, because we for example, the russians use it every time we have an air alarm and they report that they are shelling us, for example, with these 103 x55 yak or 555 huts. and every time i think that it is possible that these missiles have ukrainian

engines. that is, they are engines that were made by ukraine, and now these missiles are flying with the help of these engines to destroy ukrainian infrastructure and kill ukrainian citizens but doesn't this also mean that we have a complete production cycle that would allow us, for example, to modernize our neptune , to what extent is neptune a promising project to create a ground-class missile on its base that could, for example, reach moscow, for example, and how much it is easy to do quickly in order to accumulate, even i know there are such stores in order to penetrate, for example , an anti-aircraft system. should we test the anti-aircraft system of russia? yes, look . in order to talk about the increase and expansion of the parameters of the existing system, it is absolutely necessary to ensure that the system that has already been developed has been brought to the e-e serial model so that

its characteristics meet the e-e basic needs that were put forward for the system, it was in accordance with the concerted accepted by weapons and then we can talk about the next stage, that is, the expansion of the parameters of this system, of course you understand that this system is a deep modernization of soviet developments and what it is today. in a certain sense, we already have, that is, a certain number of machines have already been produced that successfully perform tasks - this indicates that we have the material base and we have the technologies that allow us to write this production a that is, neptune is a rocket. i don't know. it's a ballistic missile. it's a cruise missile. what kind of rocket is it? just for us, for dummies. can it , for example, be inventoried to fly 2,000 km, for example, to reach moscow itself? well, this rocket is its key task. there is just e at the same time, we see

that there are certain signs that this missile can be used not only for naval targets, but it requires some refinement. it can be launched from a water carrier as well as from a land carrier. the range of the rocket can be increased there, of course, but on the condition that technology will be necessary, engines will be needed that allow this rocket to be launched at such a distance , and the most critical key is just for the city electronic control systems and navigation systems in order for this missile to be able to reach targets in enemy territory under the conditions of zavad deployment or the operation of the air defense system, i think it is necessary to search for boguslayevo 100%. he has a couple of engines somewhere there that will be just right for us. thank you very much, the aviation expert and manager of the aviation sector was also with us . let's move on and add dmytro razumkov to our conversation - he is the chairman of the verkhovna rada of ukraine in 2019-2021 and a people's deputy,

mr. dmytro good morning good morning, but we saw this news, and the news seems to be from the world sports, but one way or another, this is news from the world of politics. so, the national olympic committee was headed by mr. gutsait, and who are his deputies? yes, no, the members of the committee, hryhoriy surkis and nestor shufrych, are interesting to me here at once. well, for example, everything in general well, the idea is that we have a minister and the head of the nok. well, let's do it right away, then, for example, let's make the minister of sports, for example, the honorary minister of sports will be yarmak . and the head of the nok is also yarmak. with an umbrella well, it’s simple. is it a normal idea to take a minister and also add the

national olympic committee under his command, well, first of all, well, and also these obnoxious figures are really enough , the zazhurich is like that. well, the impression is that this is news from some parallel world of viktor yanukovych’s presidency. well, i don’t know i did not take part in these elections, the only thing that i think is that the minister of sports has something to do besides science today, there are many issues related to the development of sports in order for ukrainian sports to work on the world stage, especially since today for there are all reasons for this, we see support from our international partners and from the world , eh. i really want such appointments not to affect the work of the ministry, because when you take on too many things, then so that it doesn't turn out like that. what are you failing at? one other thing. it's probably too early to say now. let's live and see how it will work, but i'm always in favor of better

doing one thing, but doing one's work well, because then we won't have an effective olympic committee or an effective ministry . for several weeks we have been watching the interesting story surrounding the dovzhenko center, which deals with the preservation and development of cinema, and the fact that it was headed by a cynologist who already wrote a statement and said that she was offended by the cultural community because the cultural community was uncultured and did not want to accept her although the cultural community , after all, wanted everything to be transparent and to be headed by dovzhenko, the center of this institution, a person who passed the competition and, in principle, showed effectiveness in this position. now we see that nestor shufrych, i don't know what he has to do with sports, what he has in common with sports, but he is now in this national

olympic committee, and in addition to all that, he is also in charge of the committee on issues of freedom of speech, and it's something like, you know, like antonyms freedom of speech and nestor shufrych that is, you somehow look like that it's as if someone specifically just seems to be mocking me i don't know , that is, to appoint a dog trainer to manage the cinema center should do it people who i don't know there, i agree with the ukrainian director only vladshtein is still a slap in style, see how caligula once brought his horse and favorite into the senate in order to humiliate the senators in this way and here it is as if ah, you are doing movies here. this is some kind of slap in the face. it seems to me that the civil society, first of all, how to deal with this. well, and also the journalistic community. well, nestor

shufrych, the head of the committee for the protection of freedom of speech, it’s simple. well, it’s funny. i’d rather believe that he really a fan of the soloist's flange, as he once said in an interview, than the fact that he is effective in this position, i think that i would be better for you then to invite ivanovich, who is not old enough to talk to , that's right, we're already up to his effectiveness in this well , i'm hardly here i look at it as a specialist, why i understand, uh, well, i definitely wouldn't go because it's not exactly a war, but there is a chance that the deputies will somehow reconsider, well, for example, at least they don't have an influence on such decisions, i mean now the committee on issues of freedom of speech if we speak about the committee on freedom of speech, it can be changed by the head. the chairman of the verkhovna rada can only propose it. he submits the appropriate submission to the verkhovna rada , it considers and makes a decision. there will be a submission, we will

make a decision. he also did not express a negative opinion , and why the deputies cannot independently change or remove the head of the committee, well, there is nothing to do with the police force, as of today, psg does not have two groups, and according to the current legislation, such changes possible only if changes are made to the constitution, then yes, or actually written statements from the deputies what is happening now with the territories that have been liberated for quite a long time, many months, uh, how is the recovery of these northern regions in particular going on ? and the parliament, the processes that take place there. well, in fact, i recently

visited sumy oblast with my colleagues, and now i would like to say that we are fully prepared for winter, the cities are prepared for the return of communications and light and a lot other things, unfortunately, no, we were in okhtyrka last year, we were at the chp plant, it was not restored, and what would i like to talk about now about political games that also take place in certain regions, and plus, you know well, remember what they said in the spring. i remember that if i'm not mistaken, tymoshenko said that we will allocate uah 65 billion and thus delay 10% of the needs for temporarily displaced persons. i'm not even talking about those territories that were liberated recently, for example kharkiv oblast or kherson oblast , the situation there is clear, i can to speak for example about chernihiv oblast, i can talk about kyiv oblast, about sumy oblast, where well, you don’t have to go far in your time

there, 250 m from my house, flew in, flew in, hails , but there are still houses without windows, but without windows, it is still possible to live somehow it's difficult, and the problem is not only that it will be cold in the house, the problem is that people will go, there will be borders and the dream of a vishrichuk will come true, not only hers. as you said, you'd better go and survive the winter there. and it's better in general to always stay there, it's not a state one approach because if they go with them, the economy will go with them, they will go with them, the state will go into the future, and today there are problems with electricity, uh, with power supply, they also affect the fact that they do not work normally in ukraine, unfortunately, i am trying to practice, but unfortunately, uh- as they say, not everything

was done in order to protect the critical infrastructure because everyone understood that they would be hit, they would strike at the objects of energy supply at the gas production station and this had to be done from half a month ago unfortunately, we have what we have. and the question is not that you and i will not have several hours of light each, or how to say it will be several hours of light each. state, we have a hole for the next written founder for the next year's budget is 50%. as the ministry says, 20% of gdp. and if we take budget revenues and budget expenditures, then the revenues are 1:27 trillion hryvnias, and taxes are two and a half, that is, 50% is not enough for us and eh

we cannot finance our function through external borrowing. we can finance military needs. that is why it must be done exclusively at the expense of the ukrainian budget . lost jobs, you see the forecasts for next year and when i spoke with the next policy about the fact that we need to start business as much as possible in kyiv region, sumy region, chernihiv region, in those territories that were released in order to tie people to these territories and give them the opportunity to stay in ukraine and work to provide for their families at least somehow to provide their families with their elementary needs and there was simply no time for this and the state yes, very often there are so many questions for people today,

dmytro, i still want to show one with him, when we already showed it there. a couple of days ago, it is november 14th, the visit of the liberated kherson by president zelensky, who visited the city that was just liberated, very good emotions, a very correct visit, in particular with him so-and-so reznichenko also arrived. it seems that this is the head of the ova of dnipropetrovsk. and now you are talking about the fact that sumy oblast is underserved by chernihiv, but for example, dnipropetrovsk oblast, where there were actually no russians, spent the most money than all other oblasts on the restoration of roads there and so on and the like, but only and so it was restored, as journalists and investigators found out, that it turns out that there more than 1.5 billion passed through the firm of a fitness trainer, who is well- acquainted with this chairman, ova riznychenko, nevertheless we can see him again at this meeting with germany. everything is fine. the president took him with him to kherson, or not

the president. i don’t know who is giving him a hand. the fair is all satisfied and happy. is everything okay with this? because there must be a reaction, and what should it be? the reaction now, i remember, i made contributions to the president. i think we saw the reaction of the authorities here. i think we should see the reaction of the sap, after all. the good question is whether again big construction without any corrupt elements there immediately after the great victory because when you go there on a business trip i went there with colleagues of a smart business trip to the east i see how roads are being built i understand when bridges are being restored in order to provide the ukrainian army with shells by those logistical routes

there are no questions. if it is for the needs of the army, it is good when the roads are being repaired . so that the equipment could reach the front faster, this is happening, but most of these works are happening thanks to the local or regional, but when i see that highways continue to be built . dnipropetrovsk oblast well, i understand everything, but today uah 1.5 billion would have been better spent on the ppp system, including for dnipropetrovsk oblast, the only thing that matters is how it was spent. because you know our colleagues who succeeded get to to