it is much easier to defend the main one than to attack yes, you are sitting there dug in, well, technically it seems, but the ukrainians have shown that they can, the ukrainian army . as the greens say, yes, it is more like a steppe there, it is more difficult to move, that is, the enemy sees us. he also has drones there, yes, a surveillance system and he sees our movements. but we have two such big nuances now it’s already sub-zero temperature at night, that is, the russians have to dig into the ground, and the frozen ground is one time, yes, and it delivers top fuel and necessary, well, it’s just, well, wear and tear blood, it’s necessary because we need to warm up. well, the tanks are constantly working, they are warming up for our military in this

context, but a little it is easier because there are systems that can be cut all communications and here they are pulling towards themselves where is the fuel and there is a kit of ours cutting the piles they came because i did not bring the kit and such a situation is created when well it is impossible to simply continue this educational defense , as it was from kherson, in theory, kherson was to be taken. well, it’s simple andria, yes, this is urban development, yes, this is urban fighting . there were no battles yes, let's now listen to mr. serhiy kuzana, head of the ukrainian center for security and cooperation. so , mr. ivan told us where it is more profitable for whom one part and one part there are a lot of ukrainian troops in these directions and it

confuses us or it confuses the enemy today. not here, in principle, the picture is clear for us . in any case, it is very important to cut off their southern grouping, the entire southern grouping, that is, relatively speaking, along this line starting from mariupol is volnovakha. well, there is vugledar. if we say so, it is very important to stop their railway connection there, and this railway connection in particular, the occupiers understand this, and in today's modern conditions, it is impossible to concentrate large forces on in some direction, which would become an unnoticed group, therefore, of course, you can't hide somewhere behind the hill, accumulate, and attack unexpectedly. that is, these are not small groups , concentrated forces, the situation is complicated by the fact that now here is this snow on the south there

eh well, the weather is such that the ground is wet, and this of course slows down the progress of any heavy equipment, but at the same time, eh, the very fact that we went to the banks of the dnieper eh, of course, it liberates our reserves and because and because the occupier is already preparing precisely along this southern or front line, they don't understand that he doesn't know our operational plan, that's why, of course, the further the release will disperse his units, that is, all those who left the right bank, the more his front line will be unprotected and accordingly, we will be able to organize to organize a more successful attack in one of these directions, because i still have a question

for you. somehow betrayed the russians, usually general morozov always sided with the russians. and now general moroz betrayed the russians and went over to the side of the ukrainians, and this weather makes ukrainian actions possible and makes russian actions very difficult. explain why, if you agree with this, mr. sergey, i absolutely agree e- eh and now we can already see how this is broken, this is quite one of the biggest myths of the pro-russian army, as if it can defeat anyone with the help of frosts, because they say that the soldiers are very resistant and defeated the germans too defeated the french and now they say that the ukrainians will also win in fact this is absolutely this is

absolutely a myth and we can already see that in terms of providing russian units and russian soldiers and in this regard, they are significantly worse than our defense forces, that is, they do not receive those warm things that are needed that will be needed already in sub-zero temperatures. and i will remind you that the sub- zero temperature is just starting here, that is, in fact, the frosts have not yet started, such real frosts, so they do not receive individual support, they do not receive enough food and also medical support, and this is, in this regard, the respiratory season, the season of diseases, of course, this is a necessary condition, and in this, too, there is a big difference with our defense as a whole, which are in better positions, better equipped, better equipped, and therefore gradually we are now we have not yet

seen such an effect. but with the increase in frost we see mass diseases and, accordingly, a decrease in morale , so general moroz is completely on our side. thank you very much, mr. ivan stupak, military expert of the ukrainian institute of a future employee of the sbu from 2004 to 15 years and serhii kuzan, the head of the ukrainian center for security and cooperation. well-dressed and armed regiments arrived near moscow and repulsed the german invaders, where are these siberian regiments, where did they escape, i guess in the meantime we go to poland, to poland there is a cube of koreiba, a polish political scientist he speaks russian, i understand ukrainian i i'm losing my mind - what language to speak in, but, well,

i will speak somehow, i won't leave you without understanding what mr. koreiba is thinking, for example, what kind of problem do they think about war in poland, do they believe that russia can resort to aggression against the republic of poland, you see i understand ukrainian very well but i will speak russian we we we we we we we my radius of ukrainian it will be a humorous program in russian please no questions in poland we see a national consensus причёт in the whole society on the subject of цели этой войны eh, from the point of view of poland, ukraine is waging a war not only for its survival, not only for its water,

but in general for the architecture of security and international relations in the whole of eastern and central europe. years ago, it is possible to end the imperial period of the history of russia, the one that brought mountains of destruction to all the peoples of central eastern europe with the legacy of civilization. so we understand that this is not only a struggle for our freedom and yours the struggle for values ​​for the way of life in which we want to live is also a struggle for our interests, economic strategists and others because we remember from history what peace was like in this region without russia without imperial russia, this is one of the most

prosperous regions in europe, and we see, we heard from our parents, from our children, how did this region become when russia came there, it brought nothing but destruction, violence, poverty and resistance. for ukraine not only because we understand that ukraine is now experiencing its 1920s and is forming an image of the future, fighting for itself, for itself, for the preservation of itself, but also so that all of us in central eastern europe can live as we want without the russian threat what do you think

? good luck . what do you think, will our friends from eastern central europe be able to convince western europeans of the words that they have now produced? the problem is not only us ukrainians or you poles , this problem affects everyone, after all, for them , moscow is much further from them than from warsaw to moscow or from kiev to moscow, we suffer more, we know more, and some frenchman does not understand beautiful russian at all, good ballet excellent tolstoy good culture let's be friends and not understand and not time we explained to our friends for at least two years and that is another 30 years that they have a wrong strategy that they are trying to work with russia in the mode of convergence of russian and european friendship models it will not work because these models are not

compatible, they are completely competitive alternative, they did not understand how it ended in the case of, for example, the energy strategy of germany and, accordingly, the entire european union, i have seen it in recent months . so, explain our point of view to people who have never lived near russia er, to whose country russia has never come. and if it did , it was not for long. poland is a moment in which you need to understand that it would be very naive to think that there is a certain a-a let the common line be a common interesting one and in all europe yes indeed there are points in which our interests coincide but there is no common vision of russia in this our task is primarily

yours, but also ours, to reformat russia so that they in france and germany could no longer work with the russians as they have worked in recent years. they do not imagine europe without russia, they believe that when russia is defeated, it will disappear and fall apart into several pieces, it will be a great tragedy. many of them are the same imperialists and colonialists as the russians, and they perfectly understand each other and work in the same paradigms . who have freed themselves from the colonial fire and russian realism, we understand what this is, and the peoples who oppressed others will never understand this, so in this case, you need to grow up, er, stop thinking that the west is something for us

to decide and do what you are doing in a methodical, planned, and clear way to squeeze out russian imperialism, here is this katsapskaya buta, and from our country, if we don’t do it ourselves, the west will sooner or later come to an agreement with the russians, they have already demonstrated this perfectly, and in poland we understand it very well we remember yalta, when we were sold to churchill for stalin's promises, you think they can't repeat it perfectly , i can they will support it as ukraine will begin to doubt the ukrainian position of the armed forces will begin to depend on one or the other

. politics in the west they are the same. not we in poland, not our friends in the west, did not understand the behavior of the leadership of ukraine and ukrainian society, everything else was calculated , everything was understood that there would be a war, and everyone understood what russia's goals were and how it would act the only thing that is unknown at this level was the behavior of ukraine, if ukraine did not want to fight, if ukraine did not fight for itself, then two weeks later, from the beginning of the conflict, they already agreed with russia to divide ukrainian lands , as before, many other countries, including look at poland for a second, a second, a second , the last question, the last question, it's very important , look at what they think in poland, what do you think , the establishment, the polish military, the poles, the military in poland,

society in general. well, this rocket arrived now the ukrainian war is going on, maybe some russian missile will arrive in five, maybe some ukrainian missile will arrive again that would like to shoot down a russian missile in general poland is turning into such a front-line or even almost front -line state what can the poles do? этому противодействиявать что будет если будет пятый серече пятый или 10 crossing the polish border with some kind of rocket or some kind of bomb or some kind of projectile что делать что делать пользования что делать продажа пятый или 10 it is impossible for ukraine to defeat russia and convince our allies, because we have already given almost everything we could and now we are buying weapons at a rapid pace so as not to lose

our own defense capabilities, but our friends have such powerful means to end this war very quickly and all of our diplomacy , all of our foreign policy is now aimed at convincing them that they will help ukraine more and get more help because we understand that this is a fight for your freedom and ours that we following and in this plan, the polish elite and the polish society are united as we never understand that yesterday georgia today ukraine tomorrow poland but the russian mentality does not change, it is impossible to reform russia, it can be defeated and once there is such a chance, the people and the country are ready to eat do and i doubt everything that ukrainians are ready, we need their support in this in every way , because we understand that any armistice, any compromise with russia will have a tactical

nature, strategic plans of moscow, they are not меняются 300 лет thank you, whatever korea the polish political scientist was in touch with us. thank you to him. thank you to poland. thank you to the polish people for such ardent support for ukraine. york - we will move to warsaw or from poland to the united states, i hope that eisenberg's game is already a traditional interlocutor waiting for us. yes, we will see him, mr. igor. good health. freedom, which will be on monday, yes, great , great, but we have a question. i don't know if there is dignity there or not, but trump announced that he will

run for the position of president as a result, then the question arises, and there are a lot of conversations about whether there are any criminal cases against trump the attorney general has appointed a special counsel to investigate this case and the case against trump. trump's support within the republican party is no longer as clear as it was at least before this election on november 8, as far as trump's real chances as far as we can imagine trump is the winner of the republican party and the president of the united states. i would say that his chances are less than there were in the 16th year to become the candidate of the republican party and

the chances of, say, winning the election if there will be such a candidate. they are less, much less than they were in the 16-20 years. well, the republican party has opposition to him now, and it hasn't been for a long time. it was such that, well, it could actually be ignored. and now she definitely is there will be republican candidates who will have the desire to nominate the president and compete for the nomination from the party, so there will be a struggle if it ends, it is difficult to predict because it is very early. the fact is that trump announced that he is running for president, well, actually, not for in order to somehow start an election campaign a-a he thinks that this can protect him from the investigations that are being carried out in

which he is a figurehead. well, yesterday a special prosecutor was appointed for one of these cases, he also thinks that it will help him to raise money for the investigation, they will continue. the status he has now is for him to announce that he is running for president. this cannot be protected from investigations . well, he will be able to raise money because he has many supporters. of politics, he led from 15 to 20 million people to the polling station who before his appearance did not vote at all because there was no such electro-legal, pro-participation candidate. well, people send him money in the amount of 5-10-15 dollars, if 20 million are given for 15 dollars, quite quite good money, that is, he collects money for his activities, dan igor,

look at one more very important question, what specifically did we talk about with warsaw, with poland, about this missile, which everyone already understands that it was ukrainian, well, it was accidental. the question arises, well, another missile will fly to poland, another missile will fly, i am not saying specifically which russian missile it may be, it may be a ukrainian one that would like to shoot down this russian missile and accidentally hit polish territory but poland can turn into some kind of factor of instability, already military not political instability and all uh, in these conditions , nato must do something, the united states must do something. that is, this is such a new reality when there is no war, when everyone says yes, it's a coincidence, they didn't want to aim

directly means to the polish territory, but that's what happened and so on and so on and so on until tomorrow it will happen the day after tomorrow after after and in the nato charter it is not written it is written the fourth article of consultation the fifth article of war there is no third or of the sixth article. where is it written that in the event that rockets fly in from time to time, we take such and such actions? two words, please. i think that the non-nato alliance of blood states should do everything possible to significantly strengthen the air defense of ukraine so that simply the missiles do not hit the targets in to ukraine, not so that they could not fly to poland, in fact, so that they could not take care of them to ukraine, so that they would be destroyed in flight. and even better would be how to destroy them where they are not stored in russia before they they are loaded like this, or ships or

relatives, in order to forcefully launch e-e into ukraine, and this should be handled by the states and other nato countries. i think they understand this, and it follows directly from what the minister of defense said to the head of the united of the committee of the chiefs of staff of miley on wednesday after the next rammstein , that is, they emphasized that ukraine should have a frantic air defense and it is already effective that they will work on it well , the problem is that it is impossible to do it today for tomorrow, but it must be done constantly, ukraine must be provided with more modern means of air defense until otherwise it will be exactly what you are talking about, otherwise the missiles will start flying into poland, they may start flying into

other nato countries, and this is a big problem i have mind you not only not only but with this random ukrainian anti-missiles just russian missiles can start sweeping there and it just put a mark on the brink of a full-scale atriotic world war and now see if there is a discussion in america maybe they are televised in newspapers among the expert community, because in ukraine very, well, not very often, but such a possibility is discussed so that, without closing the sky over ukraine, understanding that this is a white incident , that is, an excuse for war, to close the sky over poland and at the same time, so to speak, over western ukraine, because everyone says that if simply polish nato planes will fly over poland and

make sure that nothing flies in, then they will be able to randomly track and shoot down 300-400 km along our western border into the territory of ukraine ukrainian and russian missiles, or some kind of weapons, is it generally discussed as a possibility or does everyone understand that this is the same case in bila, if only poland raises its own or nato raises its planes, then this will be a reason for a solution war that will turn into perhaps the third world war, i read this among other discussions of this situation that it is necessary to strengthen the air defense of poland in general on the eastern flank of nato. by the defense of the west of ukraine, ah, because well, i think that

because it’s a matter of what in this case can be said about what i will take away. he said, well, if we assume that american planes will protect the airspace of ukraine at some stage, they will to have an air battle with russian planes well, it could really be some kind of spraying, that is, the united states would like to avoid everything, can the polish forces, let's say , against air defense shoot down missiles flying to the west of ukraine, i think that technically it is maybe how it can be practically implemented, frankly, i don’t know, i think that they won’t tell us this, even if it is discussed objectively here, let’s say at the level of the general staffs, at the level of their poison experts, they won’t say this anyway

, that’s what is discussed absolutely openly and objectively is that the air defense of ukraine should be significantly strengthened, that ukraine should be provided with more modern means against territorial defense, or should it be significantly more saturated with frantic so that the missiles could not reach of their targets so that they are shot down far away on the approaches to the village, this is being discussed, floating, i really hope that it will progress, that is, that ukraine will receive new means of air defense, mr. zaber, look at one more important question, i am honestly lost, but i have no conviction in this matter that russia, that america is putting pressure on ukraine, as it were, and inclines to the possibility of negotiations, despite the fact that there are some words from the military and political leadership, i still don't

really believe. what do you think we can do? i just ca n't imagine the result, this is the state of affairs on the fronts, it makes no sense to put pressure on ukraine. ukraine is not on ukraine. you can't press on ukraine while the ukrainian army is moving forward. do you believe that there are such efforts by the white house or around the white house to somehow make ukrainian children more cautious, maybe more inclined to negotiations, please, mrs. game no i leave. i don't believe in this, not only do i not believe, i just see that the opposite is happening, that both the president and the secretary of state, the minister of defense, i repeat that they will not force ukraine to host, as well as negotiations, that this will be decided ukraine, when it will negotiate on what, i will determine the position of ukraine on what

the same general millin said, for example, or what they said by jack solliver that ukraine did not completely reject the possibility of any negotiations mili explained his point of view last wednesday that he believes that russia is now in a very weak position after the many defeats it suffered at the front, after a completely strategic defeat it could not achieve anything from what it planned that this weakness of russia could be possible in ukraine er use it in order to er achieve by diplomatic means what is difficult to achieve by will, i.e. the withdrawal of russian troops from the territory of ukraine but at the same time, all american leaders emphasized that they absolutely do not see that russia is ready for such negotiations, on the contrary, the same mili said on wednesday that

russia continues to fight from what we see, we see that it will continue to fight, that no changes to their position are visible, so i think that it is absolutely impossible that the united states will demand some kind of peace from ukraine i don't think that it's impossible for this eisenberg game , i have 20 seconds until i pass the word to the charming irina koval. and now i 'll say the following: it's the russian attitude. they are pressing this is a lie this is being thrown up by the russians here is iryna koval thank you mykola in just a moment i will tell you about the injuries in the line for bread and also about the horror