where was multicam, which makes it difficult to recognize them, it is necessary to understand that it is very difficult in conditions of poor visibility or night combat, taras berezovets, a political scientist, is now a military man, a 40 -second bolt, you have ruslan, how effective is wagner’s anti-tank missile system, how effective is it on bahmut, well, such actions are the fact that they disguise themselves in the uniform of the armed forces is a well-known fact , but this creates friendly fire, i.e. shooting at your comrades, because it is no longer clear who is running and where, especially in the dark, what can i say that multicam is used not only by ukrainian fighters for example, i am a cartoon oh, this is very clothing and it is very ot

because who is running to you e-e.org or a ukrainian warrior is possible only by e-e tapes that are wound on the helmet and on the arms and on the legs and on everything if they disguise themselves as us and they are jumping into our camp, but let me forgive the guys. what kind of cases have i had, and in our brothers, in such cases, hand-to-hand and so on, i approached at 50 m, there was such a thing, they broke off with the help of a deminer, i forgot what his name is zmiya horynych dug trenches and tried to penetrate into our trenches because a trench is not it's just that the line is a branched network, like a circulatory system, and somewhere they broke into it and went to us and threw us at us in such cases . compared to

their african wars, uh, not liberating, but genocidal, they always made the dude a vandal, we will win and ukraine will be freed from the enemy . everything will be fine . turn on, and now let's watch economic news from andriyanitskyi. thank you, colleagues, really economic news, but let's talk today about the world cup in football. and how much money is spent there? and what and about other economic news ? live at 11:00 p.m. in a replay and when it's convenient for you on youtube more than 70 billion hryvnias of damage ukrainian energy companies have already caused russian missile attacks

restoration work on energy facilities that 70 brigades are involved in repairs, that is more than a thousand energy workers, prime minister denys myhal said the situation is difficult but controlled in all regions of ukraine, blackout schedules are in effect, however , due to the cooling of the energy industry, it is not excluded that emergency power outages will also be involved, in addition, the prime minister explained in in each region, the situation is different. sometimes the periods without electricity are longer . electricity actually russian terrorists attack these objects because of this it is sometimes impossible to transport a large amount of electricity to individual regions or districts, that is why the restriction

occurs unevenly across the country but i am told that the guests are already with us economic experts yevhen dubogrets, associate expert of the analytical center of the case of ukraine and mykhailo demkiv, who is also a financial analyst at icu company. dear guests, let's talk about such an unusual topic for our program as the football championship, money and sports, dear experts can you hear me good morning or so the final stage of the 2022 fifa world cup takes place from november 20 to december 18 in the boat this is an arab country for the first time in the middle east for the first time in the northern hemisphere in autumn and winter but we will not talk about the results of the matches who will win who will lose, and let's talk about money. how much does it all

cost? yevgeny. perhaps you have such information, and lately a lot of information has been spreading that this is the most expensive world cup in history, and it is probably the second number. - this is that the total expenses of the boat for the world championship amounted to 220 billion dollars, this figure , of course, looks very, very nice there, it is very big. it is more than 10 times more than russia spent on the previous championships, it was about 14 billion dollars, but it is very it is interesting. where did it come from? once in the 17th year, the minister of finance of kata simply told in an interview that we plan to spend about 500 million per week. and they came to the figure of 220 billion in fact. according

to various estimates, this championship will cost from 15 to 20 billion dollars, of which direct costs for the construction of stadiums are from 6 to 10 billion dollars and the rest are infrastructure costs for the organization of other things in the end all the same, it will be the most expensive in the world of the championship, especially considering the fact that such an end is absolutely not a football country, they had to build ions around one of the stadiums from scratch, the new city generally grew, new transport lines had to be built metro lines, that is, this is the money that the country will spend and it is unlikely that it will be able to receive there, maybe even 1/3 one third of these funds in the form of a refund, well, evil people say that even there the fans were brought for money, that this is a

major mass - it is also it costs something i don't know how true it is, mr. mykhailo hey, maybe your figures differ from what yevgen said, what is the total amount that will be spent, i heard some incredible amounts 200 billion 220 billion, well, that is, more than yevgen he says really this amount is fantastic, but it is necessary to understand what it includes, it seems to me that here the miracles of accounting appeared and took into account the general cost estimate, literally all the projects so large and grand that were built in katal for the previous 12 years, this includes the expansion of the airport with the construction of the subway, the construction of a new seaport, as well as the most expensive 45 billion dollars is the cost of building a new city in qatar and in which, by the way,

the matches are being held. that is, i do not know whether there will be an economic effect from these investments or not. the question is acacia, but they are not directly football expenses specifically for the holding of e-matches , the construction of infrastructure, it is more than 10 billion e-dollars, and taking into account the fact that all the matches are within a radius of 30 km. it looks like too many stadiums for which we probably had enough for normal conditions of one and the same this is the problem not only of this championship but of other sports competitions of the olympic games in general, when after the end of these competitions the infrastructure is not needed, somewhere it is dismantled and somewhere like athens it simply overgrows weed is no longer used and it is extremely wasteful. well, maybe all these

investments are paid off. we already know that there are also advertising contracts, there are contracts for the sale of broadcasting rights, there is a tourist flow, and all these tourists buy something and leave their money in the country that hosts the championship perhaps there is a sense in this, mr. mykhailo, an economist, is there such a calculation or not, and at the same time, i would like to ask if it is possible to show the diagram, the first graph is from the magazine by icons, where the corresponding columns are indicated yes that's how it is p. mykhailo, could you also explain what we see on it, well, actually, it happens for some reason that the expenses for holding competitions, most of them fall on the shoulders of the government, on the shoulders of local local authorities, that is, on taxpayers and revenues are very often er

taken away by others in the case of rights to er selling telecasts of tickets, they go to er football federation fifa er general of course bi- local business also has er has a big profit selling er e places in hotels selling some food restaurants souvenirs etc er but we understand one million er of these er fans let them each of them spend er well let's have $2,000 each. quite a lot of money, that means 2 billion dollars in total, we talked about much, much larger sums, that's why such competitions seem to me to be profitable only in those countries and cities where, in principle, the infrastructure is already built and ready.

zero and here is this diagram. i understand that the championship was occupied twice in russia in 2018 revenues from broadcast tickets and sponsorship money were greater than expenses and eh in hm seems to be in spain no no in mexico in mexico for the sixth year so here is one point yes what has already drawn the attention of readers according to the laws is that eh russia is actually even officially spent much more than what is shown on this graph, it was compiled by scientists from the university of vasan who analyze sports events in general, therefore, in general, and the russian championship. it is quite so contradictory that it paid for itself because there the costs were somewhere around 6 billion more than what is said there, and in general, they come to the conclusion that the world championships are indeed under hiring. yes, most of the olympic games

are not occupied, but there are no effects, that is, effects on the economy, effects on the economic development of the country. but again, at the moment, it is impossible to say is it true that they are covered by these direct expenses, or is it true that after or before such big competitions are held there, there is such economic growth in the country that it covers these government expenses and that is why the authors reach there more to the conclusion that such and such tournaments are more of an image , a live project, including a political project , that is, show the country, show that it is worth doing business with, show, as they say, the product, the person, it is more money from the tournament itself, so that, in principle, they learn that such a country exists yes, there is also a political aspect here, because we know that there are problems in the e-e boat with

democracy, there are problems in general between the arab world and the western world and there are often e-e some misunderstandings, but here they demonstrate even i watched on the e-fifa website there is a separate video dedicated to the fact that women have rights, women actively play sports, football in arab countries, it is emphasized that it is women's rights, that is, in this way, the country's image can be improved, but how many applicants are there or not, no one wants to spend such a large amount of money on sports competitions yevgeny ot you know here is a very interesting story once, somewhere around a year before 2006, there were a lot of applicants specifically for developed countries, er, and countries like germany,

italy, spain, or such football countries as brazil has always participated in these competitions. now the story is a little different. in fact , there are fewer and fewer. more and more countries want to hold such championships there. as they say, countries with an incomprehensible image, such as russia, are those countries that they know very little about developed. countries do not really want to host such tournaments, more conventionally speaking, european countries prefer to host euro matches, i.e. at, where the level of teams is stronger where there are more, where more fans are expected to come and well and as they say, from the same culture, the lord knows that recently there is a trend that not only efefa chooses countries that are not very developed in terms of football, as they say,

but also the countries of the world cup themselves are not so not very developed and uh, not very football p mykhaylevich, we will wait for one day that, for example, north korea will offer to hold some kind of championship in them, or they do not have the money for it, or iran , for example, i think so, we know that the country is under sanctions and supplies weapons in order to attack ukraine, but at the same time they have oil revenues and, in principle, they could spend such funds . will be held in the usa as a pair with canada and mexico, this will be the 26th year, and the host of 2030 is still unknown and there are good chances that one of them will be held as a pair by two countries, spain and portugal, and there are some small chances,

at least about it is now said that several matches until uh, they will let ukraine hold it, i don't know before that, these are of course plans for a very long period already after the war, but it seems to me that the situation is changing . if we talk about other sports competitions, for example, uh, the olympics, which are even more difficult to hold, then here are the next three the olympic games were their hosts and were determined in the end on a non-alternative basis. there was only one city that was ready to host it, and well , it was given this right because the price of hosting is increasing and will increase in the future. we still have one diagram for possible eh we can show it and then i will ask the experts to comment on what we see on it yes eh so the most projects eh on which funds were spent and how much yes mr.

yevgeny what is this 45 billion billion billion dollars were built, and 45 billion dollars were spent, according to expert estimates, precisely for the construction of the new building of this new city of useil. and also on the metro in the capital of qatar, 36 e have been spent so far, at least the estimate is 36 billion. well, direct costs for stadiums are 10 billion costs for construction of the new sea port. it is about seven and a half billion. that is, all the expenses of the boat that go directly to football and those that the country generally spent on infrastructure investments during this time when it was chosen as the host of the championship and until the time when the championship was held. it shows how much is currently spent on football, you know, for comparison, it gives a very cool figure for economists that in the 60th year, the

cost of the world cup in terms of one player participating in it amounted to at current prices $200,000. now in russia, from russia, now there in the 18th year, these expenses reached seven million dollars per player . this just shows how expensive it is to hold a championship, sports inflation, but it reminds me of something, remember euro 2012 in ukraine, and then the euro was built for it not only stadiums were built . well, for example, inter are the ones that we still use, and in principle, in my opinion, the investment was successful, because it turned out that in this way it was possible to carry out a reform of the ukrainian railway. but we also went into debt climbed in the year before last. yes, we continued to pay for euro 2012 from the state budget. i don’t know how in the past and this year mr. mykhailo missed this moment. were

such investments successful in ukraine during major sports competitions? well, that’s great. it seems to me that a debatable question, the answer to which we will learn from the fact we received a russian invasion less than two years after the end of euro-2012 which was crossed out a lot euro-2012 which was crossed out a lot that well at least that one of the euro-2012 stadiums, donbass arena , has ceased to function for more than eight years . many people actually say that they should fight for the holding of such competitions, football championships, and the olympics . is being built, in my opinion, this is a mistaken opinion, the government does not need to wait for anything to compete for some tournaments if they

want to build a road or build an intercity. you do not need to spend billions of dollars in addition to a hundred or so arenas if you want to upgrade your airports or build wider roads, i think it is necessary to move away from these things, the ambitions of leaders who want to meet with a large number of heads of other states, to take on pompous competitions, and if you need investments in infrastructure then look for funds for them, and not, at the same time, not to spend an incredible amount of money on holding sports competitions that last only one month, mr. evgeny, and literally two 30 seconds or 40 seconds, but stas, where is the question or varni to compete, well, it’s clear after the end of the war for holding such championships. i think it depends on what kind of economy we will be with after

the victory, because mykhailo is completely right that it can be done without a championship, on the other hand, when there are such competitions - it’s much it's easier to explain to taxpayers why their money goes specifically to infrastructure projects why we build stadiums , subways and roads because there is an anchor project because there is a world championship olympics or something else and that's why it's just much easier to sell and it's much easier and it is easier to build, but the answer to the question still remains open. if we need it or not, we will see. thank you yevhen dubagrejsa, expert of the analytical center case ukraine, mykhailo demkiv, financial analyst of the icu group of companies, today they talked about football, yes, money. well, as a conclusion from this conversation, there is a lot it also depends on the voters, if the voters are ready to perceive large infrastructure costs only as an add-on to the holding of some championship, then the politicians will do so. and if the voters will approach

this is rational, then maybe we will spend our budget funds more rationally andrianivskyi with economic news on espresso together we will win here could have been a black friday ad but we are canceling this ad we just want to give you discounts of up to 50% on megogo so that you can afford it in the future sometimes i have free time to rest, i have a choice and discounts to choose from, choose what you want on megogo, power to the camera

uh-uh-uh, we continue our broadcast on the espresso channel yehor shchycherenda gana valevska 8:24 a.m. today , november 23, wednesday, we continue with sergey dmitriev these are the chaplains, the priest of the orthodox church of ukraine, mr. serhiy. good morning. let's start with the operational situation in the kherson region. you are there now . please tell me what the situation is like in kyiv now . as the ministry of defense and our servicemen report that there is shelling and the situation is moderate, i wouldn't say that it is super critical, but the civilian population must be careful at the moment

it is dangerous there. please tell us about this story with the church. you wrote that it was liberated together with kherson. yes, this is the church of the great martyr varvara of the orthodox church of ukraine. it is in kherson itself, or where is it, is it a church on the territory of the city hospital, and in march it is was captured by a representative of the church of the moscow patriarchate who call themselves the ukrainian orthodox church. there were several attempts and the last attempt was already people with weapons and representatives of the occupying power and our priest and the parishioners were simply asked to leave, referring to the fact that the laws of ukraine no longer apply, our documents are not valid, and unfortunately for our people who

remained there, there was nothing else to do but simply leave and leave everything, and on the third day with liberation we came together with er with military personnel to this temple, a priest from moscow and the church he er quickly disappeared er did not meet with us, he closed all er doors we had to call the special service which, by the way, agreed to open for free change the locks the chief doctor who was currently hiding in kherson came to the castle. he was wanted by the occupation authorities and was arrested a couple of times. well

, somehow they managed to get out there and a small number of staff literally with tears opened the temple and said that the temple is now ukrainian again and there came several people who also work and were brought as priests who were also hiding and now this church again belongs to the ukrainian church in our community well, we understand that all the churches were under occupation, the churches were reoccupied as if no, they were not taken. there was one temple in kherson that was captured by the moscow patriarchate of the occupation

. some prices for er need er sale of candles and this temple he was er well known for the fact that there was never any er money there for any prayers or candles he was always so open and er no they never took money there from people, it is a temple, a church of the great martyr barbarians of the orthodox church of ukraine, you said about some service. i thought that you were a service that drives out the devil. do you know the damn thing, a special service or these hunters, do you remember the cartoon ghost hunters, yes, russian devil hunters. and this priest, he is also local. you or who came from russia brought or the place where he fled or what now the priest and they generally searched for him and even communicated with the priests of the moscow patriarchate who were also er

hiding er the honor of the priests of moscow square, she went with her collaborators, the occupiers, and the situation was as follows, er, the secretary of the diocese, er, maksym, unfortunately, i don't know, i don't remember, i don't know his last name, his last name, ah, they just gave it to patriotic priests of the moscow patriarchate or who came from galicia, for example, even now several priests are under arrest. they are in the occupied territory of kherson oblast . were originally from galicia. although they were also priests of the moscow patriarchate. in this way, they said that the kyiv authority ended here and