one more piece of news, dear editors, forgive me. i know we have a story time, but i have to say about it, uh, there is a message today that 50 ukrainian soldiers were returned from russian captivity, among them 19 defenders of mariupol, 12 of whom were evacuated from azovstal, the head of the president's office reports this andriy yarmak of ukraine emphasized that it was possible to return 12 defenders of mariupol, 12 were evacuated from azov, and 15 prisoners from the chernobyl nuclear power plant and seven from the snake island were returned, a total of 20 national guardsmen were returned 12 soldiers from the navy, 10 soldiers from the armed forces of ukraine, six from the state border guard service and two defense officers from the military, two arrest officers, 48 ​​privates , and sergeants, let's move on. to go to a

safer area in april, entrepreneurs and slavyanska alla and yuliya and their employees ended up in ivano-frankivsk and later opened a coffee shop here, they also tried coffee and our correspondents left on april 9 after on the 8th, that is, black day, and in the calendar, when there was an arrival at the kramatorsk railway station, it was, you know, that point when you realize that there is nothing more important than life . my mother needs to do something in order to protect them as much as possible , and the situation, of course, was not the best , to put it mildly . we didn't dare to open a business, we hoped that we would return home soon, and later

we realized that we would have to stay, so we started to get ready, first we baked desserts, and later we thought about a full-fledged establishment. we started looking for premises, you know, there was no money . we're a coffee shop, well, that 's what i'm saying, it's not about business, it's about the state of mind, it's impossible to live without it when you're still 6 years old. you've been living in this rhythm for six years. you've been doing what you like. you smile, then you are left without it, and well , we need to somehow move on, we need to do something , we need to rebuild, we need to rebuild our country, help it , help the army, because we did not have the opportunity to do this when we only baked desserts. we received a grant and with guaranteed funds, we opened a coffee shop here in the spring, the entrepreneur bought all the equipment in a new place, because it was possible to bring

only some decorative elements from slavyansk. and this deer, deer , is quarantined, by the way, because yulia sewed it in quarantine when i was on a flakdown and i was employed by her. she made it completely by herself, she tied the sweater , shoes, jeans, everything she did herself, he already misses us a little because at home the children love him very much , they dragged him right by the neck, that's why he is like that in our house, well, it's our symbol, i'll tell you honestly, we ca n't go anywhere without him we go partly decorative elements pots they are so cool we have all kinds of iron horses there is that head of a fish i don't know i really like it because it's so crazy we brought it from home the owner of the establishment yuliya says the menu was left as it was in slavyansk so among the offers there are also drinks that the inhabitants of ivano-frankivsk have not tasted before. we have a very interesting drink, uh, philadelphia. it is made with philadelphia cheese there.

well, this cheese is the same, it also includes pink himalayan salt, it is so very delicate, but very rich. creamy and a little salty, i haven't seen anything like this in frankivsk, for example, after a few months of working in ivano-frankivsk, the coffee shop became one of the favorite places of both locals and immigrants khrystyna came from kharkiv tells that the owners of the establishment are also internally displaced people by chance and now have become their regular clients, primarily to support and talk. i came from home myself, left everything there and started everything anew. it is very difficult and somehow i want to support, take friends everywhere , tell someone else to guide my parents make such a small advertisement so that more people come here and the establishment is really good here, it's delicious and it's always nice

to talk to both the baristas and the owner, they're all happy regardless of whether you're from frankivsk or kharkiv or somewhere else, in addition to aromatic drinks and delicious desserts, the cafe hosts various master classes for children and adults, and part of the proceeds are given to the army to win and return home from prykarpattia as soon as possible ivan haruk ihor gursky tv channels espresso so we understand what to translate a coffee shop is much easier than geolocating such an agribusiness, but there are also similar cases, in particular, serhiy sviridenko, in fact, what kind of coffee shop did the cossack yard work like that on his farm in ivano-pil that near kostiantynivka in donetsk region, he produced craft cheeses and strong delicacies, well, the front line began to push him, he managed to relocate to

volyn. in volyn and in donetsk region, glory to ukraine radio to see you as a hero . glory good evening if you can . one or another of your agrarian capacities from donetsk to volyn well, what do i want to tell you, and we planned the relocation sometime in june, in the second half of the year, because our communications were already a little destroyed in the cities, so it was difficult to introduce business precisely to trade because the whole business

. 100 mr. sergey well, you have been working in volyn for some time now, your farm is working how difficult was it to sell your products, we have no doubts about your skill in that you know how to run this farm and turn it all into cool craft products but was it difficult to sell them to the consumer. look, so far in volyn, we are not working at full capacity. there are several reasons. the

first reason is the lack of working capital. this is the reason. look at our product. it has a certain similarity with what we are doing today. and we are starting to sell. in a month and a half, because these are healthy products, it is hard cheese, cheese, such a less light product , we have already started to produce and partially sell the products that we had in donetsk region, that is, we have a series now for one and a half to two years, and we partially sell it, but in volyn i am here in this place logistically, i am in my position so that i am at home, but this is clearly because near me it is 40 km in one direction and 40 km in the other direction to the regional centers - this is at the same level as lutsk. well , here it is closer to kyiv and to lviv, where she

often invited us to fairs but we will talk to serhiy, the border is also not far away, is there a demand for your products? it is possible for our neighbors who want to support ukrainian to get to know the ukrainian craft product, the most important thing is not to give it up. to constantly make deliveries abroad well, for example, the fact that you still need to have a certain number of documents that are again, hmm, well, a bit expensive for me, at the moment i am not ready to do all this, but it is possible in the future. that is, we do not stop at the same thing. there are also issues of popyk in germany and poland, but now

at such a private level. well, we understand that this is also a question of certification of the corresponding products so that they can be sold in the countries of the european union, and what is the situation with our trade networks. do you manage to get access yes, because well, i think there was one story in donetsk region. here in western ukraine, the story is a little different . thanks for the rent from the veterans' fund. it's going to happen. ask for it. well, i couldn't. i'm sorry. the retail chain is big and beautiful. zhigulyakh is what it used to drive pigs on. it's somehow, well, first of all, it's not beautiful, and secondly, it's dangerous. and all the services

, so what? we deal with networks. i am sure that there is a network for a network, but for private small shops , they will be 100% in order to start and they will like everything and we will trade very successfully. and how are your relations with the local authorities and neighbors? there is no such thing. i came there from donetsk and so next well, in general, we understand that the issue of documentation of accompanying all kinds of things is also a difficult story, because moving from a saturated place to a new area of ​​documentation falls so far there have been no questions regarding relations with the local population, look how often i hear some stories that there oh no do they like people from donetsk or i don't know for some reason they all like me no matter where i am i'm sorry i'm here maybe i'm like this all the time oh they give

an apartment only for the price there, what else are the taxi drivers driving for the road so that i don't want to work because that entered, well, it’s such a delusion. and the most important thing is when i hear such stories. no one has ever encountered them personally, or a best man, or a friend, or a brother, or an acquaintance , a friend, or only one person said, you know. i don’t know this karstology. i’m very similar to people , basically anyone. well, maybe it's my personality. well, i'm wrong somewhere, but i've never in my life heard someone so free about what city you're from, what country you're from, what's your skin color, or how do you speak ukrainian, well or a little surzhy with the donbass accent does not have these problems, mr. serhii. uh, in donetsk region, where you

used to be based, where you used to live. 15 km, but first active hostilities well, i will tell you this in two weeks, they came from 30 km to 15, they cannot advance further, i foresaw it if i foresaw that there would be a war and you know, i am glad because i foresaw the service of our block they no way they will pass firstly very very dense line of defense that was built in the 14th year secondly here they go there i'm sorry now it's hard to say without there to there there they find for rotation very serious fighters started there there was a heroic 35th brigade guys we all

know the black zaporozhets there were, that is, well, i’m sorry, there’s such a wall, it’s practically impregnable, when we win, what will you do when you return to donetsk region ? will you see it, well, listen, it’s not toys, it’s time to move the production, and then in six months, when it will be well, i think so, at the beginning of summer the war is already ending with our victory, we won't let it go, nothing will happen in six months to go back, firstly, it's expensive, secondly, i'm sorry, i fixed it in one place, then the second one back and forth, it's not interesting but i do not exclude the possibility that i will build another farm on that in the very place where she was, well, there are certainly certain opportunities for this in the future, that is, i believe that after our victory, well, after all, the european union and the united

states of america will be very powerful in helping us in the development of small business and we will be possible for all with the help of building a certain number of branches, my business is craft, but it does not envisage the processing of a large amount of raw materials in one place, then there will be no craft, so at least five farms in ukraine must be opened. that is, this is transcarpathia, this is ukrainian crimea, this is the donbas , we already have volyn and somehow we will pay you in the middle of the night and we will be fine shevchenko thank god god give you strength patience and success serhiy sviridenko actually like a cow farm cossack yard he moved his goat herd from donetsk region to volyn to speak and it doesn't seem to be developing further, do you remember how during the last 8 years such very strange institutions were heard,

listen to the donbas, people there with a pro-russian position or the russians themselves spoke about it very often well, here we just heard the donbas no, just the population structure in the donbas was extremely different, there were ethnic russians who were who acted as an instrument of colonization, on the other hand, there were ethnic russians who were brought there to work in excavations , etc. it is with great regret that we are saying goodbye to khrystyna yatskiv for today. our colleagues are intercepting us. at the moment, you are waiting for judicial review with tatyana ostrova. watch this week's program for judicial review with tetyana shustrova. the new old head, as the re-elected head of the volyn court of appeal, released his colleagues from responsibility for

an administrative offense . regarding persons that andriy is drunk driving, for which they will judge the scandalous judge oasku continues to make decisions, continues to live, buy property, and what are the decisions of kyrylo garnyka introduced in ukraine the russian peace decisions on the prohibition of peaceful assemblies in connection with the arrival of the president of the federation and the patriarch of kyiv to the city of kyiv. i congratulate this judicial control and i, tetyana shustrova, since 2016, the judicial reform has been ongoing in ukraine, its successful completion as soon as possible is one of the main factors that will help ukraine maintain the status of a candidate country and continue its further path to the european union, the key tasks at the moment are the complete reboot of the main judicial bodies of the high council of justice and the high qualification commission

of judges, as a result, the most scandalous district administrative court in ukraine in kyiv should be liquidated, and due to the full-scale invasion of russia, this part of the reform is postponed and odious judges continue to increase their fortunes by making dubious decisions in the name of ukraine. ruslan yukhimuk was sentenced to 12 years in prison for corruption and illegal possession of weapons in 2015 by the national anti-corruption bureau of the luhansk oblast court. the bureau exposed the judge together with an accomplice to receiving a bribe, he demanded and received $4,000, for refusing to satisfy the request of the prosecutor's office and due to the imperfection of the judicial system, while the verkhovna

rada granted permission to remove yukhymuk's immunity, he took advantage of judicial immunity and fled to russia, so the higher anti-corruption court ruled the verdict of ruslan yukhymko in absentia this story is very revealing and demonstrates the urgent need for a fully functioning supreme council of justice, it is the only one with the constitutional authority to grant permission to detain a judge in the new old chairman of the volyn court of appeals, viktor gaponchuk, was re-elected to this position. he has been working as a judge since 2005, first of the lyubeshiv district court, and in 2010 yanukovych appointed him as a judge of the court of appeals of the volyn region. viktor gaponchuk is known for his ambiguous decisions , for example, in 2017 he released his

colleague from punishment the judge of the lutsk district court, andriy sivchuk , convicted him of driving under the influence of alcohol ; the court deprived the judge of his driver's license for a year and imposed a fine of uah 10,000 and viktor gaponchuk annulled this decision due to an alleged procedural violation of an administrative offense against investigator andrii yevhenovich , holding him to account under the second part of article 123 of the code of administrative law, he used an administrative offense against the persons of the officer andrii yevgenovich , of bringing him to responsibility under the first part of article 130 of the code of administrative offenses administrative law violations with the participation of gaponchuk significantly reduced the sentence of volodymyr migas, who in 2016 drunkenly hit a 16-year-old lyceum student as a result of a road accident, the schoolboy received serious injuries, the driver

tried to flee the scene of the accident, however, he soon collided with two more cars and had to stop . the court sentenced megas to four years in prison, however, the gaponchuk panel changed this decision to three years of probation at the same time, excluding the aggravating circumstance that migas committed the crime while intoxicated before the appeals court, then a large protest action took place viktor gaponchuk has a large family of judges and influential relatives he is a cousin of the wife of the chairman of the cassation administrative court of the supreme court of ukraine, mykhailo smakovich, in 2018 gaponchuk took part in the competition for the higher qualification commission of judges

and did not pass. together with his family, they use an office apartment of 80 m², apenchuk notes that he does not have his own car, since 2013 he drives his father's mitsubishi outlander 2013 car production costing more than uah 304,000. meanwhile, his wife olena gaponchuk bought a new toyota rav4 hybrid in 2020 for uah 1,125,000. note that gaponchuk's wife earned 10 times less in the 20th year than uah 120,500. the judge's annual salary is uah 1,860,000. and while his wife is spending crazy amounts of money on a crossover, gaponchuk with his judge's salary, which is not at all the minimum, takes

out loans in 2020, he borrowed almost uah 640,000 in cash and did not indicate the funds in the accounts, although the family had bank accounts, we called viktor gaponchuk to talk about his efficiency and integrity. congratulations, mr. viktora. this is a judicial control program on the espresso tv channel. you were recently re-elected as the head of the volyn court of appeal. how effective do you think you are in this position? after re-election , you plan to make the public 's doubts about your integrity disappear, and questions about your judicial decisions in general. well, first of all, i need to know what you are talking about, what is the date the evaluation, well, just look, in 2017, you

released your colleague from punishment, we hope that the successor will conduct the qualification evaluation, which will be conducted by the newly formed higher qualification commission of judges, which was formed as part of the judicial reform, will carefully investigate all the facts of the biography of the head of the volyn court of appeal and will make a fair decision regarding viktor gaponchuk, the district administrative the court of kyiv is known for numerous corruption scandals, nabu detectives suspect the head of the court pavla vovka and his colleagues of creating of a criminal group with the aim of seizing power, while vovk's own brother was exposed for receiving a huge bribe of one hundred thousand dollars

to hand over to judges for a certain decision. the council of justice and the higher qualification commission of judges of ukraine and due to the full-scale war, everything did not go according to plan, so the liquidation of oask is postponed in the meantime, friends and publicists vovka continues to carry out justice by my colleagues, this is the judge of the district administrative court, kyrylo garnyk, he was recently caught drunk driving and now the judge himself is a defendant. and kyrylo is a handsome former member of the russian factory of stop stars . he sings now, but already on a yamaha piano , the clavine cost is about $ 5,000 . everything goes, the

judge is known for his dubious decisions and groundless bans on peaceful gatherings , in particular, in 2013, he banned a protest against the visit of the russian president to ukraine vladimir putin and patriarch kirill so really with the arrival of the president of the russian federation and the patriarch of kyiv to the city of kyiv, i would like to note that for me personally it was more of a religious issue than a political one

. continues to judge continues to make decisions continues to live buys property that is difficult to explain with official income according to the data of the public integrity council from 2011 to 19 years cumulative the income of judge garnek and his family members amounted to almost 3.5 million hryvnias, in the same years, the family was able to purchase two audi a5 audi q5 audi q7 cars in kyiv and an apartment in kyiv with an area of ​​almost 200 m², the total cost of this purchased over 12 million hryvnias, this is almost four times higher than the total

income of the family, and this is only in 2019, it could reach 20 million hryvnias, and it is not clear where the savings came from. and at the same time, he actively maintained at least his instagram page, now it is closed to him. kyryl garnek's five-year term of office as a judge ended in 2020. harnek did not administer justice and did not work, but taxpayers continued to support him and pay him his salary at the end of october judge kyryla a handsome man was caught behind the wheel while drunk, he

refused to undergo a medical examination and ended up on the dock, this case is being considered by the pechersk district court of kyiv, known for its cave-like level of justice, already at the stage of receiving the case materials, the court employees tried to hide the details of the incident , there were no legal requirements on the website of the judiciary the merits of the case are indicated, i.e. for which offense garnet is being prosecuted, an interesting fact is that the case of kyril garnenka is being considered by judge vita in the pechersk court bortnytska, you can say, specializes in cases of drunk driving, experts found at least 46 such cases that judge bortnytska simply closed, thus saving the culprits from punishment, we will monitor this case and we will definitely tell you whether

the judge of the kirilagarnik was brought to justice today in to me, it was all a judicial control program and i am tatyana shustrova. if you know facts of corruption or unscrupulous judicial proceedings, write to me on facebook or to the e-mail address of which you you see on your screens, we will meet in exactly a week, for good news time on the espresso tv channel in the studio of iryna koval, so i will just tell you about the most important events at this time, many suffered and kherson, even after the deoccupation, is constantly under constant fire from the russians