concrete guarantees that in the event of an attack on ukraine, let's say, britain or the united states of america or france, or all of them together, and in this regard, they were all signatories of the budapest memorandum, and it is in this sense that we must act. and i would like us to make it clear and it is clear at the state level that we held to one of these absolutely correct positions, submitted an application and are doing everything to ensure that this application is considered as quickly as possible, and at the same time we negotiate with our allies, real allies who can protect us, in fact, the whole step uh, what is the whole path that we have to go through now for volodymyr that then the last question i have for you is that we see that the act is russia or terrorism in relation to ukraine to our people what they declare and if in confirmation of their actions this there is absolute blackmail, yes, or we sit down at

the negotiating table, the ukrainian authorities know what to do and how to stop it all. and what else can they resort to, what levers do they have left? they can still mobilize there 300,500 million e-e of this cannon fodder. well, then the question arises if they can't make ends meet with those three hundred thousand, they can't e-e, as they say, teach them to arm, clothe, feed them, so where will they be what to do with five hundred thousand of these bulls or mobs, as they are now called, that is, this option seems to me to be rather ghostly, they still continue to think that it is possible to use nuclear weapons, there are various options , from tactical to - in the east to no

tactical uh somewhere further on, but it will be clear to everyone that this will be the last day of pompery for russia , because it was clearly and clearly warned then that your so-called armed forces were left with horns and hoofs, the third option of using chemical weapons, which actually is no different from the use of nuclear weapons the weapon option is the same, that’s why it seems to me that this is why putin is shouting at all the intersections today because of his politicians who are preserved in europe because of these useful idiots who need to sit down negotiation table but i think that now we will dictate our terms and in this regard i am honestly happy when i recently read such a clear and unambiguous position of general zaluzhny, he wrote that the

ukrainian armed forces will not make any compromises and until we will not expel this abomination from the ukrainian land, there will be no talks about negotiations about compromises and so on. this is our position. yes, it is unanimous and it is actually very good. thank you , volodymyr hryshko, minister of foreign affairs of ukraine in 2007-9, the head of the russian research center, oksana savchuk. it will be able to spread on youtube, it is important for us if it is not difficult for you and you like this content that we make, and also write in the comments how you are going through these days after the shelling. do you have a light, how do you see us in the end ? all perceive what you think about it, what should we do next , how should we react, are you still ready to endure and live in such conditions, it will be interesting for us to read p oksano, you

know i analyzed the recent situation this week, did the number of people who left their cities, who do not have heat now , increase do not have electricity or have they moved, for example, to frankivsk to lviv in transcarpathia, and yet there is no such mass migration for which we were preparing for which the government was called to prepare various e-e areas, people could survive the winter for the time being there are no migrations, and i understand that people still stay in their homes, they do not leave it , they begin to adapt to the existing conditions. i think that this ingenuity to adapt under any conditions is definitely a feature of the ukrainian nation. we have

genetics, for sure, that it is not so easy to break us, if it were possible that europeans did not have light, or on the other hand, then it would be completely different from what a worthy european nation shows today, that is, the example in the future that we are showing today you see how our entrepreneurs quickly begin to buy generators themselves, prepare something, offer something at a minimum, only to work, only not to close, only so that people go to work. the same situation in hospitals. that is, it is self-giving of help, it is very important, very important that today there are a lot of people who remain in their places who remain at their responsible jobs who have not gone anywhere who are ready to survive this winter for the sake of victory it is actually not

easy, first of all for our armed forces let's be honest, we all understand this, everyone gives it to himself, in fact, a high rating. that is, we perfectly understand today that despite all the troubles that we have every day, we must continue to help our boys because, uh, in the cold season, because we need er, they have additional er, in fact , there are heating bags in order to need new clothes, and all this is actually necessary for you and me to continue to collect and send to the front. why do i say that because for three sundays in a row, we hold such charity fairs and there is somewhere like that i coordinate these things, we do it mainly in different micro-large microdistricts of different cities, i want to tell you how much next, there is this big adrenaline , great cohesion of people, children, how is it all

really unifying, there is no panic, i have no case of strength and it doesn't matter what someone says, well, how much we have been collecting for 9 months. we have been sending it for 9 months. maybe the state should give it. no, there is no such thing, because everyone understands that in this country it is our country and each of us should do something. someone can come and buy them, and the third one can buy spare winter tires or boots or other things for it and send them to the front, so i am convinced today that in ukraine it is clear that everyone has their own place of work, and those people who stayed especially in kherson, but even planned several trips to kherson and now the situation is again in kherson so difficult, there is shelling and people now need to provide additional help with warm things , you understand. take into account that they need those products that

they can simply eat in the conditions that they have because there is no way to cook. they have no opportunity and i want to tell you. we have read a lot this week . even at the beginning of the program, you talked about the month of november, and we understand that the world began not only to talk about the war in ukraine, but today, little by little, they are beginning to experience those historical events , this genocide that took place against ukraine during this holodomor, that is, the same romania that recognized the main holodomor as genocide against ukraine. i think it will be a number of other countries, a continuation of the fact that 18 countries, as taras says, will mean that the movement will continue that is, europeans are starting to understand a little bit the essence of this war, an existential war, a war for the survival of our nation, if someone did not understand before why

russia attacked us, then after delving a little into the history of ukraine, well, from the european side, because we are of course different, they are finally starting to realize that russia i never wanted to see ukraine as an independent sovereign country that all the last years, three generations of even our relatives survived it, resettled in siberia, the holodomor, that is, it was a primordial struggle against us, just this once in the modern world, we really have videos, we have gadgets, we have photos, we can show it to the whole world, and maybe earlier, when our people were expelled, when our priests were shot because they simply did not want to convert to that belief and be agents kgb to tell what people confessed, or is it just that we have a ukrainian insurgent army, even if you helped someone, your family was sent to siberia and

there were other moments, this meant that this did not happen then, you remember how information from concentration camps is difficult reached the civilized world today, this is all happening. believe me, it's not that simple either, because if we talk about prisoners. and everyone in this studio is colleagues and had something to do with what we ask, we always check which of the people is in which situation today to find out information about how our prisoners are kept in russia today, even for the modern world, it is extremely difficult because it is a really closed country that does not follow any rules. i hope that all the sanctions that are currently being talked about, about the new package of sanctions there will be those that will really affect the price of russian oil, which will fall, and the fact that the world will begin to renounce the fact that it finances terrorism , what you said is true, if you finance russia, you are an accomplice to terrorism, and that is a

stain on your reputation, you know of blood for what is here for what russia is doing today and what belarus is saying well, we perfectly understand that lukashenko actually has an influence in certain moments when he is told about it, that is, i am convinced that he is not an independent player once upon a time we remember was in we are such a president, a state criminal, yanukovych , who was exposed when he was still interesting to someone, but now he is no longer interesting to anyone and, as they say, does not show him, so our task today is really to be ready, i would also say that we all need to prepare for all territories of our ukraine and don't just say that there is an active war in the east or in the south, but here in the west, no, i 'm afraid that we just have to be ready to continue our struggle. well, light is light - it's us and you, our emotions, our actions, our kindness things are what the guys need, so you are standing

right here in the comments, they write to us zaporizhzhia, now there is light, there is water in our neighborhood, there is no heating in other areas, there is yesterday for about 3 hours, there was nothing. the main thing is that we are all alive, we can endure everything, glory to the defenders of ukraine tetyana beylik thank you we are also with you and zaporozhye, stick together. all of ukraine is together and we will overcome everything. yuriy kamenchuk. thank you for your word. in fact, remembering at the beginning what conditions russia has put us in, we must remember what conditions exist in russia itself, not in every country. corner i am silent there, even about some remote areas of certain supposedly developed russian cities there is no electricity and water there are no normal living conditions and we have learned to survive and value, we know how to value what we have and what we have acquired and can survive in these conditions

even if it is very difficult, we know how to get together and come up with how to keep warm is to feed each other, share something or invite a guest, you know from one situation from one side even these eyes from a power cut i noticed the beginning to connect families more because they started visiting each other or where there is light or so to save money at the same time and talk without being distracted by gadgets, especially when there is no internet , that's another plus that we find in such a difficult situation is clearly handled by the energy industry. it is a great honor and praise for them, and a big thank you to those who did not leave ukraine, they will probably already be at a respectable age or having opportunities, for example, three children or some other circumstances, they are really saving themselves now. it is true that we and the committee they went to the kharkiv oblast kharkiv directly , the energy facilities looked and asked who was doing this, well, there is a question, the truth is, at the beginning of the

activity to oblenergo kharkiv who actually did it, it was the local utility workers who took over and then, i'm sorry, they pulled everyone else back because they were too scared, but you see thank god they recovered and there were moments when in kharkiv with light, despite the proximity to russia and the number of shellings, it was even better than in kyiv, this means that kyiv needs to think about in spite of the fact that the city had to deal with it as quickly as possible and such statements that are not direct but actually ukraine and the world heard allegedly from the head of one company that it would be better to leave ukraine because it will be difficult with electricity, in my opinion, there is no sound at all. it would be better phrases were heard about what such companies, private, state, and others will be able to do urgently now to ensure the decentralization of energy supply or additional

reserve lines or to provide the same generators. or say about what you know we we thought about it six months ago or 8 months ago. we ordered this generator and here we are. we will install it despite everything. yes, no. that didn’t happen. i don’t want to, uh, now throw all the lumps in one place on everyone yes, but in some cases individual managers should have been aware of similar situations a little earlier and not react only on the fact, in any case we should also remember that all the statements coming from russia and belarus are coming from two specific people, it is a civilized word to call them but the belarusian president is simply that marionette, you know, sometimes i don't like to get personal, in this case, i think i'll be

forgiven, self-proclaimed, that's understandable, but i think he played hockey too often, there must have been some accidents, because he , ah, not only slows down, repeats no those are not what is needed from not what is needed and he is completely out of reality completely putin i continue to say this is an absolutely lying poker player you know with all due respect to the game of poker because then- it is even considered a sport to all players ah not everyone who blocks is behaving dishonestly, that is because sometimes what is called a complete fake, that is, pretend until it becomes a reality, so it sometimes works in this case, everything that comes from putin is aimed only at justification and i will continue to say that this is whining from the very the beginning that he failed to achieve in three

days, that in fact all these medvedchuks and all those who were close to him created this false belief that ukraine needed a russian peace, even for some reason it reached some individual instances on fortunately for the ivano-frankivsk region and the lviv region, the sbu caught such agents and they continue to do so. and the latest shellings, i believe, are also related to the searches of the russian orthodox church in ukraine and the lavra , because they once again saw that we are not afraid. we are going there, someone says that allegedly i have been thinking for a long time that no one believes this, but continues to think that the state should not interfere in the affairs of the church, but when it is a church and in fact an artificial one, when it is a church actually created by the fsb- shniks .

of another church. it's everyone's choice. i won't interfere , but we have the facts. unfortunately, the spread of information for russian peace and weapons and money, etc. to do better, now we will encounter a certain conflict, for sure, in order to turn the situation around, as there was once a crossing of kyivan rus, than later we will again restore some agents there, and so on, as regards the support of the world for ukraine, and on the contrary i call on putin to lie and continue to sit down at the negotiating table, in contrast to what the chinese representatives actually say, also

without recognizing the terror of russia, sit down at the negotiating table, this is what they want to lead us to. of ukraine for the restoration of the negro structure for the provision of hospitals in other cities, this is solidarity, this is the solidarity of ukraine and the entire civilized world, i believe we exactly strongly community we know exactly how to help each other and expose in this difficult situation and what can still be affected now is to insist on keeping the price of russian oil for those who unfortunately continue to use it. we lowered it not to 60-65 dollars, but to 40 30, even as our baltic colleagues said, this can definitely strike, ideally, of course, not

to negotiate on the price, but to completely block the pipe, that's when russia will feel how the soviet union was once destroyed by the price of oil, and russia can also break the load. everything can be as we see how is everything happening? it is possible. we are also waiting for it. we are joining markiyan lopachek via skype, junior lieutenant of the armed forces of ukraine , secretary of the lviv city council. glory to ukraine, you , mr. markiyan, are telling the truth about the blackmail of russia. what we are hearing now from them is the chorus of the energy system of ukraine and ukrainians who were left without electricity without heat sometimes and no water supply, but you have to sit down at some table and negotiate with them. how do you react to this? what do the military think about it? please tell me, there has been

extremely heavy fighting here for more than a month now. to comment on anything else, you need to contact the general staff. what can you comment on? no, what about the negotiations? well, probably since the end of february, we have been spending the night every month, every week. it is possible to talk about what could be talked about in march after buchi or in april or now it is an absolute nuance there is a clear position of the state leadership of the general staff of the first negotiations if such are possible in general they can only take place after when all the russian troops will be withdrawn from the territory of ukraine, when all the losses will be compensated and then it may be necessary to sit down at the negotiating table, although most likely my

personal opinion is that by the time when negotiations will be possible with such a state as the russian federation already at that moment will not exist because the processes that are taking place now, even if you pay attention to 90% of the territory of ukraine after nine months of bombardment with rocket attacks , are now in a much better infrastructural state than, uh, 99% of the territory of the russian federation, where there is no sewerage, no water, no gas supply, and so on, that is, as of right now, i believe that there are no skims and there is nothing about it. new statements are appearing today, we treat them with great skepticism, but nevertheless i am interested in how the military perceives all kinds of threats, including lukashenko, who

says that if ukraine does not go to negotiations, then destruction will follow. how do the armed forces react to such statements ? for apples well, it's not the first time that we hear some simple-minded people who have absolutely no basis and this convinces us once again that there is simply nothing to talk about with those people. because of the way things are going on in them. and in fact, it is necessary to understand right now that belarus and russia have started, uh, not for the first month, they are in trouble and their every next step

simply worsens their situation, they are forced politically, even for their constituents, for their population to make some stupid statements to explain to the father what we are doing with mobilization, with isolation and all other points, that is, they have to declare something, they have to show something, they have to declare some, well, just idiotic things, and of course the whole world looks at them, you know, as such idiots they are boiling in their own cauldron and think that they are going to fool or frighten someone there once again, in fact, ukrainians no longer have any fear and any threats or statements. well, let them speak, mr. komenchuk, i have a question for you er, you said a wonderful thing that negotiations may not happen because there will be no one to talk to. russia will fall apart. i have a question for you, including a representative of the city council. please tell me when the state property fund of ukraine and the department

of lviv city council for the management of communal property will take over all moscow property. and what will we turn the kremlin into? i think that the law clearly plans in our country. we have a good prozorro system. put the winner up for auction, then they will be able to properly service this room, thank you, if we talk about more practical stories, we understand that the situation with energy is what it is, we will definitely hold on . from the sale of electrical appliances, which are simply reflashed on the go in a big charger, but in kyiv they open a store in order to turn on generators so that people can simply

charge their gadgets, and this is an example when we in their places, everyone can help those who need it. but nevertheless, what kind of winter should we expect if we look at things realistically and how the same lviv residents have what they should prepare for? it may be winter, well, look, war is such a thing that it is very difficult to predict something, there is no separate case with an extremely unpredictable insidious and under lemborog who cannot, let's say, oppose anything as of now on on the battlefield, not having the glory of any bright victories, he is simply terrorizing the civilian population, and we must pay attention to these things or these moments when they said back in the summer at the beginning of autumn that it could be a difficult winter, that

we had to prepare for it, surely we had to start preparing even then, and these people who they actually did it, well, well done, winter can be hard, these statements were also made and i heard the naysayers of the ivano-frankivsk svobody ruslan martsenkov made appropriate appeals to the residents of the ivano-frankivsk klitschko in kyiv recently said that he might have to move to the center of the city of course, you just have to understand that it is much easier to survive the cold weather, to survive the situation when there is no electricity in a village in a suburb of a big city, than in a sleeping area, and of course that those people who have the opportunity for this period of time can use it there or turn to their relatives or it is possible to accept someone or it is possible to move in with friends there. it will simply be much easier and much easier for the state authorities and much easier for local councils and much easier for these people, if there is

no such possibility. a shoulder and a helping hand to those who can't afford it, those who can't afford it, to lonely people, to older people, these things are here. that is, how will we help each other? we will help each other as much as possible, and the winter will be difficult for us, but we are sure of only one thing, that we are definitely we are going through this winter normally , we will survive it, we will definitely win , everything that was destroyed will be restored and we will do it. this is much better, but you can't talk about the occupiers like that, because here they are. for decades, i'm glad you're a coward, it's finally your turn and it's your turn on our broadcast, it's interesting to hear from you an analysis of everything that's happening right now, maybe some of your observations, how

is a full-scale war with the russian federation, how weak is our enemy now, we 've already heard a lot, but that's all well, we understand that they are ready anyway. we are ready to fight to the end. we are ready to stand to the end. here is the question of who and when. we are analyzing the issue of negotiations, whether to sit down or not to sit down at the negotiating table. we must first of all to find out and what are the stakes in this war, what are the stakes in muscovy, what are the stakes in ukraine, what are the stakes of everyone involved in this war, uh, for muscovy, there is obviously only one stake, to restore its status as a superpower, to return at least to the status it lost as a result during the cold war, during the cold war, muscovy was one of the two

poles of geopolitical attraction, which planned to control the maximum that it could control. countries, that is, being a super power, they could do it, they lost it. therefore, in this war, they have only one revenge in order to make this revenge, steps must be taken. and the first step is the conquest of ukraine, if they failed at the beginning, how much to take kyiv to seize ukraine, it is obvious that there was a backup plan. and how many backup plans do you have? i don’t know if they were there or not.