what do we understand about the prospects of this direction? the enemy understands that the general staff has come up with some more cunning ways to drive the enemy into a trap. but the experts of the institute for the study of war believe that after the liberation of kherson, hostilities will intensify in donetsk region, in particular in the bakhmut region. according to the ukrainian military, experts , the russian army needs active combat operations in donetsk region in order to show at least some victories in this war . serhiy zgorets believes that the russian federation will take all measures to reach the borders donetsk region, in particular, to carry out active combat operations around pavlivka. and for the ugledar, because when it becomes difficult to provide russian troops through the cream, they will need to look for new ways of providing support on the left bank of the dnieper, and they are located in the rear of pavlivka. it is quite difficult to evaluate the russians because these political approaches about what we need victory at any cost, against the background of their collapse on the right bank, will provoke a number of inadequate children, that is, a significant number of forces that rush in the

direction of ugledara and bakhmut, not counting losses, this will cause possible individual tactical successes with pushing through our defenses, but i repeat, in fact, these pushes can be compensated for by our forces, because we also have a significant number of forces released on the right bank, which are in a much better condition, and actually these forces which are were kept surrounded by the russian group, how the krasilis can strengthen our actions in the bakham region after fleeing from the right bank of the dnieper to the kremlin announced that they want peace talks with ukraine however, international and ukrainian experts are convinced that russia is asking for a pause in order to regain strength after the defeats in ukraine, now the ukrainian army, as they say, is on the mend. that is, it now has the momentum associated with victories. is it on the shoulders of the

enemy to go into the zones that he controls, i.e. now we cannot make stops, no matter how difficult it was for us. because at this time it is even more difficult for the enemy, and this means that we can just to catch up with him there and on the left bank, what does the separate combat operations there in the area of ​​the kinbursk spits mean, now we have both the autumn and winter periods to use in order to push the enemy as far as possible from all directions, to force ukraine to negotiate. the russian federation is also trying, through massive missile attacks on objects of critical infrastructure this statement was made by the press secretary of vladimir putin, dmytro piskov, saying that this is the result of the actions of the authorities, who refuse to negotiate, however, after the last attack part the missile ended up on the territory of poland, so our neighbors started talking. isn't it time to close the sky over ukraine in conversations between journalists and experts, or close these

questions ? to close the sky over ukraine to close the sky over ukraine ukrainian authorities and the military are asking that since the beginning of the full-scale russian invasion, this topic has become topical, especially against the background of conversations about what iran can start supplying russia with ballistic missiles with a range of 300 and 700 km. according to the spokesman of the air force command of the armed forces of ukraine, yuriy ignat, a powerful anti-missile defense system is needed to combat ballistics, which ukraine does not have, the pro system is not just some single installation, it is a global system, it is an umbrella under which europe hides or the umbrella under which north america hides canada and the united states which organized a single up-to-date system about

with radar means of long-range detection with tpo means, there is a single anti-missile system, that's all. yes, there are means in the world that can knock down ballistics, but they cannot do it 100%. if we are talking about such ballistic missiles that iran has, if they will be used, well, in such a massive way, well, how can we effectively oppose them, he gives how to destroy them where they are launched from, experts say. at present, in the russian federation, more than 200,000 are mobilized and are waiting for equipment for their preparation for several months, so ukraine should make the most of the autumn-winter period, because in the spring we can expect a new russian offensive - experts say it could be belarus or

the direction of sumy zaporizhzhia, but for this russia will need even more forces than at the beginning of the winter invasion. will not accept any compromises from the russian federation regarding the end of the war, one simple condition - russia must leave this territory of ukraine khrystyna parubiy nazar melnyk espresso tv channel thank you for the interesting story 9:34 on my watch, among other things, i have interesting information from the head of the servant of the people faction, david arahamia, he wrote in a telegram that the people's deputies from the servants of the people of valevska decided to inspect more than half a thousand centers of indomitability in the capital inspect yes such yans complain about the inconsistency of information regarding the work of the indomitable centers in the city of kyiv, rahamia wrote to correct the problem and legally inspect all 530

locations . the word actualization is shorter than the data, solve problems with equipment, logistics, and the functioning of the location in parallel. people's deputies start their inspections at 9 a.m., that is, they have already been inspecting the unbreakable points for 35 minutes. so we will wait for the consequences . in the past, you damned new summers that came just against these soviet methods, when uncles with bellies walked around and tied ribbons and inspected someone there, just do it, take care of things, no need no one should be inspected. deputies' work is to go and check on this. they talked about updating that points of invincibility. they have representative functions and at the same time we are solving something. i am very sorry that

they think part of our audience is so stupid that they will perceive this comedy. i think that it is possible to activate it. in other ways and it is already necessary to inspect no one or to do it with another method so well , whose job is to inspect so this is the flint terrace , the commissioner for the protection of the state language, he inspects just who is speaking, mr. taras, welcome to our broadcast, good morning, glory to ukraine. well, how are you ? how do you feel about these inspections? please tell me how much i know about such centers of ukraine. i was recently in my native city of mykolaiv . our city, as one of the outposts in the south of ukraine, needs much more help and attention, not only from the people's deputies, but also from the

international community. they defend the city in the way they help in odesa and kherson and in the way they protect the ukrainian language and i like it. as natives of mykolaiv, the commissioner for the protection of the state language, well, the city of mykolaiv, wanted to ask about the story with the mayor of kharkiv, the fine for the russian language in social networks and on television, they imposed a hryvnia fine on the mayor of kharkiv and for using non-state language, is this work, or is it the result of your e-e inspection inspection? the answer from him he said that he would speak to the townspeople in russian, panterekhov, and in the council of ukraine, article 12 of the law on ensuring

the functioning of the ukrainian language as the state language stipulates that the working conditions of the state authorities of local self-government are the ukrainian language, this applies to official meetings, events, meetings, the language of working communication we have repeatedly talked about the fact that in the conditions of a full-scale invasion, the citizens of ukraine demand an important price for reliable information about the driver's flight and issues related to defense protection by the counteroffensive of the armed forces of ukraine, the state language, who is he, before the decision of the constitutional court of ukraine, citizens of ukraine are not obliged to speak languages ​​other than the state one, regarding the situation with compliance with the law by individual high-ranking officials, eh, how long have i been in my position, we constantly emphasize that citizens of ukraine should be provided with attitude to their rights and freedoms, information on

the state language, and this also applies to the heads of regional administrations and to individual managers communal institutions, state enterprises, deputies of local councils in the 21st year, we had numerous examples of such violations, and we addressed such facts to local self-government bodies , carried out state control measures and demanded the elimination of the relevant violations in the 22nd year, this year there were almost no such violations left as for the kharkiv mayor, we sent repeated demands to three about compliance with the language legislation after july 16, when the amendments to the code of ukraine on administrative offenses came into force. the possibility of imposing sanctions in the form of warnings and fines. and in fact, after july 16, we also received appeals to citizens of ukraine who recorded the speech of the mayor in the state language, either on tv, radio, or in

social networks during the e-session of the city council there and so on, and therefore to all these repeated appeals there was a partial implementation of the law, but including the ignoring of certain norms, in particular 12 of the constitution, in the end for ourselves. work and the day before yesterday we actually had a case review and we invited the mayor or his representatives to join this conversation well, in the end explain the situation, the employee warned the warning, there were no representatives, but as for this fine, it is a minimum of uah 3,400 , according to the law, it will go to the budget of the city of kharkiv but there is an opportunity, accordingly, to challenge our protocol in a court of law. this is an absolutely normal right to challenge your resolution. and what did he say about the use of a foreign language? he said. i believe that

today we have completely different matters. i believe that the most important thing for us today is victory. officially, i will speak ukrainian. as for communicating with kharkiv residents, i will communicate in russian. well, does this position that has won now have the right to live? the most important thing is no, no, no. has a relationship, it doesn't matter what language we have this victory. what do you think, you know , kharkiv is ukraine and kharkiv region suffered the most during the famine years, i remember these photos from the street of the great center of university industrial 302-33, kharkiv was ukrainian in 1937, when they exterminated the ukrainian intelligentsia, one by one they took away writers from the school building, which was destroyed by the

russians in 22 and skovoroda, let's not forget what russia did to the karazin university and the hryhoriy skovoroda museum, in what a shameful state they were in the occupation and what remained of the liberation after the ravages of the occupation territory, let's not forget what happened in izyum in many other towns, i have a huge number of friends, colleagues and acquaintances who truly believe in the revival of slobozhanshchyna as one of the most important outposts and citadels of the ukrainian spirit in the north-east of the ukrainian state, so i hope that this position is the position of the code acceptance of the law by the vast majority of citizens of ukraine. it is acceptable. i look at the reaction of citizens and everyone followed this public discussion between the secretaries of the authorized representative and the kharkiv city chairman, but i will say to him that he really does a lot for the city, he does a lot

to set an example for other mayors, but the issue of protecting the rights of citizens is also the protection of their right to receive information and services in the state language of the kharkiv city mayor , and not only in ambiguous questions are being asked in ukraine, but also abroad, and even among them for foreign colleagues. and why was he allowed? does he have any intelligence for this, is it true that the ukrainian language on the territory of ukraine before ours victories and there, please communicate with foreign representatives in english, any other language, especially when we become a member country of the eu, he is churchill, yes. and what are we fighting for if the ukrainian language is not up to date, when ukrainians are just killing on the basis of national identity? taras, here is the wording interesting for the use of russian in social networks and on television, social networks are also considered an official sphere, we are talking about the official pages of the mayor of kharkiv in social

networks. we analyzed the same, but according to these facts we sent a warning and with a demand for elimination, i.e., official channels of information about the activities of bodies and sensogovernance, the same points of inviolability must be ensured by the state language, so i hope that this parameter will be eliminated and other officials, heads of local administrations working in different corners of ukraine, but i emphasize once again that the protection of ukraine is the protection of the ukrainian language, national interests, it is also the ukrainian language, address well, we have a television channel, it is called freedom such a foreign language is in russian, and there even ukrainian officials are sometimes asked, at least they were asked before, to switch to russian , so that it would be clear to all consumers of this tv product of the freedom channel , an official and an elected mayor, for example, should behave,

if the journalists of this channel ask him to speak in russian so i will tell you, for comparison , the freedom tv channel has changed its information policy, and as far as i know, the ukrainian language has become much more there, including performances, i.e. sadovtsy began to be heard mostly in the ukrainian language, but it is registered as a channel and broadcast that disseminates information about ukraine outside the ukrainian state, because as for the officials, i insist that they must and are obliged in accordance with article 12 of the law to speak the state language. well, of course, television must provide ukrainian citizens with information on their state language tv channel, if we are talking about the format of our own agreement, then it must be in all languages ​​of the eu member states we must be understood by brussels and copenhagen, and this is extremely important. in the current conditions, when we need additional support from the international community in the fight against

russian aggression, that is, if someone there, at the request or at the request of officials, says that he will give an interview in russian, he will receive 3400 from you you know correctly that representatives of foreign media approached me so that i would, say , provide information in another language, i always communicate in ukrainian and i demand that if you want to hear me and even if you want to hear me somewhere behind across the border, please translate, provide no translation performances, mostly this is implemented a full month ago, i don’t understand what prevents our officials from complying with the language law and demanding that other people translate for them if it is necessary for one or another editorial policy of local self-government, who will be next according to according to the law, our secretariat monitors not only the speeches, but also the specifics

of the abolition of the ukrainian language in these areas , in accordance with the articles of which they came into force 25 on november 21st, i would like to remind you that the kharkiv regional council approved the regional program for promoting the mastery of the ukrainian language as a state. at that time, i had a meeting not only with the regional leadership, but also with the mayor, and we talked with him about the need for such a program in kharkiv itself. because the actual examples of violations are one of the largest in one of the largest regional centers of ukraine, as it seemed to me a year ago that the opposition of the mayor, who spoke to me in ukrainian, was completely balanced and pragmatic why didn't this happen? i understand the war there and so on, but only this year a huge number of united territorial communities of regional councils and city councils rejoiced at such programs, provided their citizens with

free courses and, of course, took great care to make the ukrainian language no longer we forget that the city of kharkiv has suffered perhaps the most among many regional centers, and therefore the issue of protecting the ukrainian language is the key. why do such violations continue? it is difficult for me to explain, but the reaction the law is as it is as we have demonstrated such consequences. i will hope that we will not have such examples. and if they do happen , we will not take appropriate measures for you. what other violations of the law are currently being developed by your office of the language ombudsman? well, except for the kharkiv city case by the mayor, well, this is not exactly our terminology. we do not have developments, these are law enforcement agencies, we study, monitor and effectively respond to citizens' appeals after july 16. ukrainian language for the internet and zokr and necessarily for user interfaces, that's why we actually have a number of appeals, in accordance with which

we carry out state control measures and impose separate sanctions on certain online publications or on an online store that do not have a start page in ukrainian including after july 16, we have already imposed a number of fines on representatives of other areas where we have recorded a violation, this concerned the cents of several universities of representatives of the service area who gave or did not give their explanations but they paid the corresponding fines to the local budgets. i think that ukrainian society today does not ask the question with a grain of salt. should we or should we not obey the law? on the air and once again to talk about important things for all of us

. lyudmila, we congratulate you greetings good day a-a today we commemorate the memory of the victims of the holodomor, so in us, petrovych explained that it will be 90 years next year, because the 33rd is considered the peak year. although the holodomor began in the 32nd, but this year, the 89th is more like this. explain your position, how should we treat this date , today is the first time we celebrate it during a full-scale war, and it was also a special operation against the ukrainian people. well, first of all, we do not use definitions, we celebrate e- let's pay tribute to the memory, let's celebrate because after all, we are talking about the anniversary of the tragedy, but you know, we are talking about

the agricultural year of 1932-33, many people simply do not know that it is not an astronomical, but an agricultural year. then it was taken as a basis when terrible requisitions were carried out of bread this year began on july 1, that's when they started to harvest in ukraine, then, and er, there were crews who tried to remove this bread as much as possible, but this year ended, er, it turns out to be astronomical next year, at the end of june, you understand, that is, from the moment of collection, it is impressive and during the year until the moment when the new crop ripens. so, we are talking about the agricultural year , you know, the greatest peak of losses from the famine

, absolutely correctly, volodymyr noted this precisely in 1933, because according to demographers , it is approximately 3.5 million people, but in 1932, 250,000 people died from the famine, and demographers calculated that in 1934 it was another 160,000. actually, those that are being carried out this year at the state level are defined as measures from the 90s ago i think there is absolutely no mistake here, and we can say that all our events, which are currently held in honor of the victims of the holodomor in the 1990s, ludmila's question is about the recognition of this date by various parliaments of various countries in the bundestag. germany has prepared the recognition of the holodomor

as genocide. they will vote next german deputies, the parliament of romania already recognized the holodomor as a crime against humanity and the ukrainian people, the upper house of the republic, the parliament of the republic of ireland , and the parliament of the republic of moldova recognized the holodomor as the genocide of the ukrainian people, is this related to the anniversary of the round date? or is it more related to the full-scale russian aggression? this is the wave of recognition of the ukrainian holodomor, because until this moment in this country, they recognized that it was not until the anniversary of the nedorakovyn, namely in connection with the fact that russia's current war against ukraine explains and clarifies a lot about the events that took place in the early 1930s in ukraine , that is, it is now absolutely obvious that we are

dealing with genocide against the ukrainian people and we are practically dealing with such a continuous process, you understand, it was actually written by raphael, who spoke about the fact that the soviet genocide in ukraine is a classic example of genocide and probably one of the unique examples of the longest genocide. that is , these are two components of the same process, but regarding the recognition of we still have extremely great prospects and tasks for work in this direction, because we are talking about dozens of countries that recognized the holodomor, and in the world we know of more than 200, so, in principle, this recognition is for us unbelievably important, unbelievably because every time a state recognizes the holodomor as a genocide, it is once again a confirmation that the

subjectivity of ukraine is recognized and that such atrocities and genocide in the centers of europe are a crime. for us, this is extremely it is important, and pope francis himself said he spoke about the anniversary of the ukrainian holodomor, vatican news provided his direct speech, we remember the many suffering ukraine all saturday is the anniversary of the terrible holodomor, a genocide of mass murder the famine of 32-33 artificially provoked by stalin , we pray for the victims of this genocide and we pray for the many ukrainian children and women of the age of children who today are martyred by aggression , said pope francis at the end of the general audience this wednesday, and you know what i mean in these words. i liked everything in principle and i am grateful to pope francisco, but that the holodomor was artificially provoked by the steel or just one stalin or the russian government. it seems to me that there is

also such a personification of alya and putin is bad russians are good and here the popes are too, stalin is bad and the russians have no relation to this, you are absolutely right, i would like to make two comments here, firstly, we should add the holodomor as a communist imperial genocide and this is extremely important because the organizers of this crime of genocide it was the union power, because the soviet union was an empire, and in fact the sovereignty of ukraine with ukraine was first occupied, then the sovereignty of ukraine was appropriated by the union center. so , the organizer was the union power and definitely not only stalin because kaganovich molotov and mikayan and many, many others were also there with him.

so this is the union power, so you are right here, the emphasis is wrong, but i would also like to draw attention to one important moment today when we honor the memory of the victims of the holodomor. we must think about what significance this has for us. why do we have to talk about it today and it is obvious that it has been a long time ago. must remember that the absolute majority of people in those terrible, terrible times of ukrainians survived and preserved their identity, and this happened absolutely not thanks to the soviet government, but thanks to the fact that people, just like today, fought for their families for their lives, had incredible survival strategies, there were a huge number manifestations of mercy between ethnic mutual aid, i.e. resistance to the 30th year in ukraine

was the largest in the entire soviet union, and unlike other regions of the soviet union, not only anti-communist but also national slogans and documents indicate that actually people sang uh ukraine is not dead yet and hundreds of us went to the machine guns of uh gpu and also this is solidarity between uh big country and western ukraine due to the fact that in western ukraine for the first time in 33 the first book about the holodomor appeared in the 19th year, that is, this topic is important for us today, also because it should motivate us to fight against our state, our statehood, because now there is a war, but also for our civil rights, e-e, against poverty, against the violation human rights, that is, this is not a topic for us only a memorial, although of course, these are the days when we

light a memorial candle and remember to kill him in bulk, and mrs. lyudmylo, what are the causes of the holodomor ? you have just raised a topic that is often discussed in the public space . therefore, at the root of the hunger there may have been some natural factors . today, scientists who deal with the problems of the policy of creating hunger about the managed wheel have already clearly come to the conclusion that if a famine occurs under modern conditions and it involves a huge mass of human victims, the responsibility always lies with the government. it is a matter of the movement of the government and therefore