on the only expansion and reproduction of the empire , we are dealing with a territorial war where people don't matter, what matters is the desert, but the desert, let it be without people, let it poison the er, but the more the letters of the winter to grab lands and er the causes of the famine and the causes of today's russian-ukrainian war, they are the same and the origins are the same. not here, er, what er, the fact that today it has gained a lot of publicity, and we just the world knows about it, the world has the opportunity to react. in the 33rd year in 21- th year 46th 47th year, the world did not know anything, this is a dark spot in the history of

ukraine, and we did not have the opportunity to address the world, although the voices of such people as sheptytsky broke through to announce such people as milena rudnytska, in the end the voices of our contemporaries emerged, including james mace for a long time, there have been no uh, for two decades, there is almost no one on this earth, but he is our contemporary who, for the first time among western western historians, so deeply researched the holodomor in ukraine, and it was he who came to the conclusion, leading the commission of the famine, uh, of the great famine, uh, the phaneris commission, this is the commission of the president and the congress in the united states of america, he

came to the conclusion that the most terrible crime in the history of mankind took place in ukraine, genocide , we again and again turn to our historical memory uh we light candles and in this full tembla once upon a time we er-er this is an idea also jeans and it used to be er-er again and again every year to people in the november days outside the field of candles in your windows today there is no need no need to contact anyone candles are burning and they say the most terrible darkness before the dawn, candles are burning and uh, in this world of our memory and our construction, the face of evil is very clearly visible, which cannot be obeyed, which cannot be allowed to win here, our uh, on our territory, because that today we will be tomorrow

europe will be whole tomorrow and after tomorrow the whole world will burn and in this fire no james warned that the fate of not only 20 years ago he warned that the fate of not only europe not only ukraine but the whole world today ukraine, he knew that sooner or later russia, gaining strength, gaining strength, gaining strength, sooner or later , will go to ukraine anyway, why to ukraine , because all without their own roots, it appropriated our our historical heritage, the history of kyivan rus, from there itself, it derives e- e derives its genealogy e-e and without this historical e without these roots without this anchoring of the history

of russia loses all meaning this is an intellectual catastrophe this is again emphasized by james mace and russia again and again goes for someone else's thank you ma'am natalya ms. yurii, what do you think ms. natalya mentioned this phenomenon of the devouring instinct why does it continue to reproduce this devouring instinct changes centuries change people change in russia regimes political classes change tsars general secretaries presidents but the devouring instinct of new territories remains unchanged please well, if we we are talking today, we are recalling these events related to the holodomor, uh, natalya very successfully told uh, about these motives, so to speak, rather than

politics, the ideological motives of russia's actions, but in these actions are quite material things, i will simply remind those who are watching us that the specificity of ukraine in those times in the 30s was that it, together with the north caucasus, provided more than half of the grain that was produced in the entire soviet union, you understand what this meant and when they started here there are problems in ukraine, then in the kremlin, the first reaction is the first, the first is if the first reflection was that ukraine has huge reserves that people do not want to give to the state, that is, they did not believe that here, although stalin himself spoke, he spoke at one party meetings and said already in the 31st year in 1931 that a number of fertile areas were in

a state of ruin and starvation. these are his words, this is the very last quote, nevertheless, they did not look at ukraine, you understand. - an inexhaustible source as a source of consumption and at any price. they wanted to take grain from the peasants so that to these political-ideological or historical-political motives, one can say, completely material, completely material interests are added, just like today. look how they act what they want today, attacking us, taking these territories from us. so these are also incentives, and i wanted to remind you of one more thing that is completely correlated with what we see today. so, if our meeting with you was yesterday or tomorrow, i would have told you about some other documents and today, on november 26, 1932

, a special decree was printed by the people's commissariat of justice and the general prosecutor of ukraine at the time, which emphasized in black and white that repression is one of the powerful means of overcoming class opposition to grain procurement, therefore it is allowed apply merciless measures to those people who were called kulaks and then all class enemies who inhibit uh-uh, it means how they expressed themselves then, they expressed themselves in the categories of those those years, the successful struggle for bread. that is, you understand when at that level terror is allowed, what russia is creating today it has long-standing roots, and it, too, this method of repression was openly declared and used in the organization of this terrible tragedy

of this famine in the beginning 30 years ago, we did not we must forget, looking at the events of today , we must not plunder what was done then, it is very, very connected, but it turns out that, well , in our understanding, 90 years have passed and now we see all the same things that can overcome this evil, you know with the question about evil. this is not such a simple question. when hitler initiated the genocide of the jews, the extermination of the jews, there were people who told him, wait, this is a crime, you will have to answer for this, you know what he said to hitler, the answer he said and who answered for the armenian genocide and who a who organized some actions, you understand, that is, when

there is no unanimity in the fact that to call evil evil, do not make any compromises. and you and i see what is happening, let's say here recently, er, in relation to russia, such soft er, pressure on ukraine uh, in the name of her conducting some kind of negotiations. so , when this consensus will not be in uh, in the full sense of the word on a global scale among the world states, then evil will not be punished. if we talk about comparing this tragedy, 32- 33 years ago, today is a day to bow down bow down to all those people, journalists, first of all, who are filming what is happening, because russia will very quickly erase from history what

it is doing itself, this is all the violence, all these acts of anti-humanity in anti-humane actions, as they are doing with the former stalinist camps , they they are simply destroyed and they do nothing , they do not restore as if this did not exist in history as if this did not exist in history. that is why this international solidarity and the understanding of compromising with such people are extremely important here and with such figures as we see today in power in russia with seven scoundrels who prepared for absolutely everything in no way should thank you mr. yury mrs. natalya but remembering the historical experience so to speak the issue of nazi germany still after the death of hitler the german nation repented for the evil that it had committed against other european nations and against the jews, in particular for the

holocaust . the russians are doing in ukraine, i ask you for your word, of course , the poisoning of the germans by nazism and the hands of nazism , it has its own history, but it is very short-lived. consider it a decade, a little more , and then a very long way of understanding what happened to them and repenting of the history of russia this poisoning is very systemic and very long, i'm not sure, and it's very long, and it's very long

in the history of russia, there are no traditions in the history of russia to remember something in a negative way about your history in history russia russia russia always right russia attacked the poland of pushkin's time this er-e turns out to be a family sport of the slavs russia attacked finland it turns out to be some kind of such a short-term conflict operation and something er-er about er-er about afghanistan we have already forgotten about chechnya as if not it wasn’t the chechens, and uh, led by kadyr, they love russia so much, as if there were no murders, as if grozny was not burned. history has a great tradition of forgetting what is not beneficial to them and glorifying their history. some of their victories are

fictional heroes. mostly fictitious for the most part, they have no connection with reality, so i think that this is a very long and very difficult path for those who are aware of it, but i have to say that uh, it's still a jam, he said, he always repeats hrushevsky, that russian democracy begins and ends where it begins they don't care about the ukrainian issue, and the very existence of ukraine is a mortal insult to russian intellectuals, to russian democrats, the very existence of uh-uh, why do they leave us alone, perhaps so that we love them, but they are with us

they are killed in order for us to love them for us to say that we are the same as you and that we that we are yours that bowed down to great russia, this will not happen eh panschivaval very correctly said that only here is only evil which is illuminated only evil which is manifested which shown all over the world only only light can be defeated uh-uh um this is evil and ms. natalya yes thank you nataliya dzyubenko mays and also yuriy shapoval were our guests in direct communication with the studio thank you unfortunately, during our discussion, we have to shrink a little maybe a conversation actually our tatyana's court control, let's watch it later, news on the espresso channel, just stay with the press, a special project, the world cup

, espresso tv channels, the history of families, an award from the hands of queen elizabeth, victory at any cost, it was the hand of god, the hand of his actions, maradona, the great champions, zidane heads the goal of france, the owner of the home world cup idols, the brazilian puts oliver kano on his knees and all of germany provocations mattress provokes zidane, the legend leaves the field, the long-awaited trophy, the 116th minute of the match, the name is with the ball, the goal, drama, how difficult now watch leo messi, the world cup is

still out of reach for the argentinian. in ukraine and the world, vitaly portnikov, the host of espresso and invitations, experts based on facts give their assessment and forecast of the development of events, you want to understand how our today will affect our tomorrow, watch saturday's political club, what saturday at espresso, you brought me apples. and how did you know that people always bring me apples, lord, to the city of kyiv, the president of the russian federation and the patriarch of

kyiv. congratulations, this is judicial control, and i am tetyana shustrova. since 2016, judicial reform has been ongoing in ukraine, it will be successful as soon as possible . completion is one of the main factors that will help ukraine maintain the status of a candidate country and continue its further path to the european union. currently, the key tasks are a complete reset of the main judicial bodies of the high council of justice and the supreme qualification commission of judges, following this , the most scandalous district administrative court in ukraine should be liquidated, and due to the full-scale invasion of russia, this link of the reform is postponed and odious judges continue to increase their fortunes by making dubious decisions in the name of ukraine, today we will tell you about one of them but first to the news of

ruslan yukhimuk, a former judge of the north donetsk city court of luhansk oblast, was sentenced to 12 years in prison freed for corruption and illegal possession of weapons in 2015, detectives of the national anti-corruption bureau exposed the judge together with an accomplice in receiving a bribe, he demanded and received four thousand dollars for refusing to comply with the request of the prosecutor's office and due to the imperfection of the judicial system while the verkhovna rada granted permission to remove yukhymka's immunity he took advantage of judicial immunity and fled to russia, so the higher anti-corruption court sentenced ruslan yukhymka in absentia. this story is very revealing and demonstrates the urgent need for a fully functioning higher council of justice, it is the only one with the constitutional authority to grant permission to detain a judge in the

volyn court of appeal, the new and old chairman was re-elected to this position, viktor gaponchuk . of the volyn region court of appeal, viktor gaponchuk is known for his ambiguous decisions , for example, in 2017, he freed from punishment his colleague, the judge of the lutsk district court, andriy sivchuk was convicted of driving under the influence of alcohol , the court deprived the judge of his driver's license for a year and imposed a fine of uah 10,000 , and victor gaponchuk canceled this decision due to an alleged procedural violation for three lifeguard administrative offenses against the investigator andriy yevhenovich, about bringing him to justice under the second part article 123

of the criminal code of ukraine, close the proceedings of the administrative offense case against andriy ivanovych sivchuk on prosecution under the first part article 130 of the code of administrative offenses of 2018, with the participation of gaponchuk, colleagues of the judges significantly reduced the sentence of volodymyr migaso, who in 2016 drunkenly hit a 16-year-old lyceum student as a result of a road accident. with two cars and was forced to stop, the court sentenced migas to four years of imprisonment, however, the gaponchuk panel changed this decision to three years of probation , while excluding the aggravating circumstance that migas committed a crime while intoxicated under the appeal court, then the

protest action took place viktor gaponchuk has a large family of judges and influential relatives, he is a cousin of the wife of the head of the cassation administrative court of the supreme court of ukraine, mykhailo smakovich, in 2018, gaponchuk participated in the competition to the higher qualifications commission of judges and did not pass last year, the chairman of the volyn court of appeals declared that he is a co-owner of an apartment in lutsk with an area of ​​71 square meters and also together with his family they use an office apartment of 80 m², apenchuk notes that he does not have his own car since 2013. he drives his father's mitsubishi outlander 2013 car, worth more than uah 304,000. meanwhile, his wife, gaponchuk,

bought a new toyota rav4 hybrid in 2020 for uah 1,125,000 . gaponchuk's wife earned in the 20th year 10 times less than 120 and a half thousand hryvnias, the annual salary of a judge is 1 million 860,000 hryvnias, and while his wife is spending insane amounts of money on a crossover gaponchuk with his judge's minimum wage, he takes loans in 2020, he borrowed almost uah 640,000 in cash and did not indicate the funds in the accounts, although the family had bank accounts, we called viktor gaponchuk to talk about his efficiency and integrity hello, i congratulate you, mr. viktor, this is a judicial control program on the tv channel espresso, you were recently

re-elected as the head of the volyn court of appeals, how effective do you consider yourself to be in this position ? petro decided. plan to implement so that public doubts about your integrity and generally questions about your judicial decisions disappear first of all, i need to know what you are talking about, what is this, give an assessment , this is just in 2017, you released your colleague from punishment, talk if you have any questions, come let's talk, we hope that the successor of the qualification evaluation, which will be conducted by the new composition of the higher qualification commission of judges formed as part of the judicial reform, will carefully investigate all the facts of the biography of chairman volynskyi of the appeals court and will issue a

fair decision regarding viktor gaponchuk the district administrative court of kyiv is known for numerous corruption scandals nabu detectives suspect the chairman of the court pavel vovk and his colleagues of creating a criminal group with the aim of seizing power, while vovk's own brother was exposed for receiving a huge bribe of one hundred thousand dollars to transfer to the judges for a certain decision last year, the president of ukraine volodymyr zelenskyi finally submitted to the verkhovna rada a bill on the liquidation of the scandalous court of his the review was planned to begin after the restart of the high council of justice and the high qualification commission of judges of ukraine and due to a full-scale war, everything did not go according to plan, so the liquidation of oask is postponed in the meantime , vovka's friends and publicists continue to administer justice to the collective, together with all my

colleagues, the judge of the district administrative court kyrylo garnyk recently accepted he was caught drunk behind the wheel and now the judge himself is the defendant. and kirilo is handsome , a former member of the russian star factory , he sings yomastechko even now, but already on yamaha clavine piano cost about $5,000. it's all about us and our year, the judge is known for his dubious decisions and baseless bans on peaceful gatherings, in particular, in 2013 he banned a protest against the

visit of russian president vladimir putin and patriarch kirill to ukraine, so indeed in 2014 i made a decision to ban peaceful gatherings in connection with the arrival of the president of the russian federation and the patriarch of kyiv to the city of kyiv , it should be noted that for me personally it was more of a religious issue than a political one , in the end a combination of such political decisions in recent years, in particular, contributed to russia's full-scale war against ukraine, now continues to judge, continues to make decisions , continues to live, buys property that is difficult to explain by official income, according to the data of the public integrity council from 2011 to 19 years, the combined income of judge harnek and his family members amounted to

almost 3.5 million hryvnias, in the same years the family was able to purchase two cars in kyiv, audi a5 audi q5 audi q7 and an apartment in kyiv with an area of ​​almost 200 m², the total cost of everything purchased is over uah 12 million, which is almost four times higher than the combined income of the family, and this is only because the market value of only his two-level apartment in an elite residential complex in the center of the capital in 2019 could reach 20 million hryvnias, and it is unclear where the savings came from for several million. and at the same time, he actively led at least his his instagram page is now closed. but

when it was open, you could see a lot of different travels, such as peru, spain, and italy. in 2016, kirill garnyk's five-year term as a judge expired until 2020. garnyk did not administer justice and did not work, but the payers taxes continued to support him and pay him a salary. at the end of october, judge kyryl garnek was caught driving under the influence of alcohol. he refused to undergo a medical examination and ended up on the dock. this case is being considered. the pechersk district court of kyiv is known for its cave-like level of justice already at the stage of receiving the case materials, the court employees tried to hide the details of the incident contrary to the requirements of the law , the essence of the case was not indicated on the website of the judiciary, i.e. for which

offense the good ones are being prosecuted, an interesting fact is the case of kirill garnyk in pechersk judge vita bortnytska is considering the court, she can be said to specialize in cases of driving while intoxicated, experts found at least 46 such cases that judge bortnytska simply shut down what she did to save the culprits from punishment, we will monitor this case and we will definitely tell you whether the judge kirilaharnyk was brought to justice, as of today i had all this in the program under judicial control and i am tetyana shustrova. if you know the facts of corruption or dishonesty of the judiciary write to me on facebook or to the e-mail whose address you see on your screens, we will meet in exactly a week, all the best