the game ended with a score of 0:1 and before the news i told you about the most important thing for today thank you to our energy workers doctors without exaggeration to the critical armed forces of ukraine for another normal day and we will meet tomorrow read more about important things on our website espresso tv also subscribe to our channels at on social networks we are on youtube telegram on instagram twitter be close to people who suffer from rheumatism but arthritis is impossible to get used to it, it does not allow you to move i tried everything and at the pharmacy i bought a yellow cream dolgit, he saves me from the pain of rheumatism,

it is long, it numbs the pain, reduces swelling and improves the mobility of the joints, back pain, special project, world cup , tv channel, espresso, history, will receive an award from the hands of queen elizabeth, victory at any cost, it was the hand of god, the hand of diego maradona, the great champions, zidane heads the national team france the owner of the home world cup and destiny brazilian ronald to germany provocations mattresses provoke the legend leaves the field the long-awaited trophy 116th minute of the match name from the ball of the championship

of the world still remains unattainable for an argentine new generation of chilean nationals watch a special project football format mundial on the espresso tv channel from monday to saturday at 2:40 p.m. and on sunday at 11:10 a.m. saturday political club program vitaly portnikov greetings good evening good evening so today we will talk in the first, as usual, our program included the passage of the russian-ukrainian war, in particular the exchange of prisoners, because recently

, thanks to the ukrainian authorities, we are receiving good news about this and the exchange is carried out, russia more often came to an agreement, we will also talk about the situation on the southern front , will the russians manage to get the left bank part of the kherson region? well, what is happening in the east of ukraine, but you can see that on our desktop, as well as in many windows of our compatriots, ukrainians all over the world, today there is a candle of the holodomor the anniversary of the genocide that was implemented by the soviet communist government or it can be called such a reincarnation of the russian imperial power on earth , you remember it, angelica, as during the ten-year-olds said, well, you can't think that it was an artificial famine, well, it was not possible to destroy millions of people on purpose, it was bad management, and when historians said, including zahidnyi, and no , it was specially organized, steel wanted to destroy, the ukrainians said it was just slander, slander

on the communist party was slandered for what was happening in the country. yes, of course they could be bad organizers, but they had never in their lives specifically destroyed so many people. well, today, when the russians absolutely confidently destroy dooming the critical ukrainian infrastructure to death by the way, a huge number of people because you are reading a person may not get there a fast person may not operate on time a person may not be helped these are simple examples then we understand that they are absolutely calm this is not even stalin it is only putin who could absolutely do this to do and now many people have candles not because they remember the holodomor, that is why it is necessary to somehow live in their own homes where there is no light destroyed by the same russians who destroyed their great-grandfathers ten years before and grandmother vitaly, what is happening right now can be called the holodomor because there are certain disputes about the legal terminology of that and exactly how russia is

destroying us. yes, russia as a nation is definitely not a holodomor yet, because russia cannot block the supply of products to ukraine, but the holodomor is weapons are also amazing. so what does a person who was allegedly born in a city that lived in the blockade and for whom, in principle, the value of the life of an ordinary person who is experiencing such a siege should be important despite all political goals, does this but did you hear what putin said to the so-called soldiers' mothers whom he took away from the people ? listen, well, so many people die from alcoholism, so many people die from uh, traffic accidents. and your children died, at least for something valuable. i remember that when in 2014 there was the first wave of invasion in us, uh, on public television in russia, a member of the public

chamber of the russian federation spoke to me. he seems to me to be a church artist, and when you asked, do you really think that the russians will go to war now, and this person is a supporter of putin, he said, well, you know in russia such a life. what is better to fight than to sing? did they bring their people to such a scottish state? do these people think that it is better to die somewhere in the war than to live in russia and they want us to be in the same scottish state as they live? but i have to say that when was holodomor - this was also a cattle state, the victory of the proletariat, the dictatorship of the proletariat, you can steal bread from a peasant to fill your belly, party waste paper, and the rural population at the time of the victory of the bolshevik party was 80% of the population, by the way, when they talk about the dictatorship of the proletariat is not just the dictatorship of some party, it is the dictatorship of the minority of the population over the majority, and now they want to establish this in our country. we should not forget

these historical events so completely, and now we have some opportunity to take revenge on vitaly the russians for what they created with our nation, in particular , because how many millions, several million ukrainians, according to various historians, statistics are shown in different ways, but still, millions of ukrainians died during two famines. we can move on to the discussion of the e-e foreign policy block, first of all we will start with the foreign policy block valery chaliy ambassador extraordinary and plenipotentiary of ukraine to the usa during 2015-19 chairman of the board of the ukrainian crisis media center p valery greetings i congratulate you glory to ukraine glory to the heroes so let's start with e- from the grain summit that is currently taking place in kyiv, there are many leaders who have

not been to the ukrainian capital since the russian invasion, let's say the prime minister of belgium wanda crew arrived in the ukrainian capital, however the attention of observers is drawn to the arrival of the president of the country, which takes a soft and special position in the european union regarding the russian-ukrainian war, not only on this occasion, the president of hungary, mrs. novak, she is in kyiv, she is meeting with the president of ukraine. what do you think this means, dear valery ? is this a turn in politics or just another viktor orban maneuver, we knew that and the previous presidents of hungary, they differed with their position from the example, so to be honest, nothing. the manager of the position in hungary and, accordingly, the body

, do not forget that this populist position of his was formed, for example, on the fact that he pays people the 13th salary and 13 pensions at the expense of cheap russian energy resources, so very quickly the position of hungary will not change, unfortunately, regarding the grain site, this initiative is understandable ukraine is showing its role in ensuring security in the world. i believe that it is er. it can help, but the main thing is that it does not distract from the main issue, namely the citation from russia against ukraine and the destruction of not only the ukrainian infrastructure, but the ukrainian population as well. if you allow parallels with the holodomor, there is one thing that surprises me. for some reason, we started mentioning the holodomor again, only in it. today is the 26th week. this is wrong

. it is satisfactory, it is weak, it is empty, and it does not contain the word genocide , and why we did not work in this direction. i do not know. of the ukrainian people, joseph biden has already recognized the german genocide, which later received such recognition from the congress from the ukrainians, why did we not receive such recognition from the us executive this year? there were a lot of details, i don’t know how likely they are, of course, but they are interesting, let’s say that there was an american or chinese agreement that the chinese were

keeping russia from the very idea of ​​using nuclear weapons in the conflict, and in return, ukraine does not receive combat aircraft that planned to transfer them to poland, by the way, the aircraft were absolutely real and we did not receive them, and the threat of using nuclear weapons was, well, that moment was virtual, and we can see the result, and the question arises if indeed, china can play such a game, so it can keep the west from taking any decisive steps towards russia for a long time, they say that we are the guarantors of non-proliferation of nuclear weapons and nuclear war, but you also have behave politely, don't give anything extra to ukraine, they will tell you honestly, i can't confirm me, there are no facts to say that such an exchange took place, i can say that according to my observations, there was a threat of a nuclear attack on ukraine in march, there is no such threat today, as far as china's statement

regarding the inadmissibility of the use of nuclear weapons it is connected with other promises. it is difficult to say, but we can definitely see that this statement means that it is so easy for russia to play blackmail with nuclear weapons. well, let's not talk about airplanes let's talk about missiles 300 km or long-range political decisions in the usa are enough here and china does not stand on zavorivskyi. by the way, regarding the united states of america's help to us, recently lieutenant general rigoteras gave an interview with the high command of estonia's defense decisions and he stated that the us could end the war in ukraine in two weeks, in particular by providing us with a squadron of f-35s, but they do n't . so why, if there is such a possibility?

what did general minli, the commander of the unified command of the four-language general, said a long time ago, he testified in front of the congress with his questions about how the victory of ukraine over russia will end the war in ukraine, he told the usa, for this, you must enter the war on the side of ukraine and the war will end in two weeks, it was announced but it won't be like that, that's why the usa won't enter the war, well, at least for now, it would be very irresponsible to say something about it, so in principle, without 35, is there a lot of different things that could be provided ukraine and work for our opportunities. well, i would say that such statements can encourage you from the administration, you see determination, but they are hardly realistic. i am cautioned, i will tell you frankly, there are issues that are purely political

operations of escalation management, and you are being demonstrated by the united states now, in my opinion, the right in my opinion is focusing. it seems to me that they are starting to make mistakes that they made in february of this year, for example, some steps must be taken in time. well, for example, if there are already strikes on the infrastructure, that is somehow the wave of escalation has already passed and we have not seen any answer, well, from the point of view of providing more powerful systems, especially in fact, now putin is ahead not by one step but by two and the explanation is what was it like before if the usa here provides more powerful weapons, then use powerful strikes somewhere to ukraine well, yes, i'm sorry, but now

i don't see any circle from the side of the usa, and that's why i'll honestly tell you, i thank the usa. i'm very grateful to them for everything, but what's being done now does not suit me at all, absolutely because the resource of ukraine is not infinite, that resource which ukraine invests is people's lives, and i'm sorry, some kind of drone or missile is not worth the life of one of our beehives, so let's talk, mr. valery , about the sudden death of the head of the ministry of foreign affairs of belarus, volodymyr makei . do you think it made sense for lukashenka to remove him personally? i only knew him at the negotiations. well , he will find him where we met as part of the delegation .

a person is talented in foreign policy and that's how he lived the life of 10 years of ministers, it is not known what, what, everything else - this is conspiracy theory, it can be considered that this is some kind of black thread of lukashenko, if it is really a murder, i have no confirmation of this, but what it is looks strange for such a person for such a person who, according to the report, destroyed yesterday, there was a very active order when the ministry of foreign affairs did not send it out very suddenly , this sudden death is very alarming. it's really not sudden, it's that these situations are not spontaneous, prepared, so you have to understand that we have questions not in the belarusian direction, in principle,

if we talk about the situation around the belarusians , you see that alexander lukashenko is now making statements that vladimir putin cannot even afford when he talks about the fact that if ukraine does not surrender, the complete destruction of ukraine will take place, as you think. these are just the words of a light-hearted woman, or is this the plan that the russian and belarusian leaders have already agreed upon? well, i'll tell you i'm honest, it's just from my own materials. i think that the departure of russians from the territory of belarus will still take place . well, all the logic is clear. what will be the proportion of belarusian mercenaries for money? it's hard for me to say, but what putin pressed lukashenka. i almost had no doubt that i could pocket it. i have already announced three days, i will take it, there is no one to choose the sound, so take the statement today valeria and at the end

of our conversation there are already a few minutes and there is still let's talk about the osce parliamentary assembly, the ukrainian delegation plans to boycott together with lithuania and estonia. if i am not mistaken about these delegations and the meeting, after all, russia was never excluded from the osce and it will participate, although poland in principle canceled visas for the russian delegation to travel to europe for the meeting. in the parliamentary assembly, it was precisely prevented from excluding russia or political motives, and with your permission i want to remind you what the osce is, there was once a meeting of security cooperation in europe after the helsinki agreements on a new era of peace and, most importantly, the inviolability of the borders that were established after the second world war, well, this

organization in various spheres had to go through all these issues now to regulate. unfortunately, there is nothing. because russia destroyed the basic documents of the osce , therefore, in principle, i think it would be right for this organization to start kuzya and well, i don't see any benefit from it today, except perhaps for the issues of election processes, so what the sub-section of critical human rights institutions is doing in this part of the osce can do something in terms of security or somehow, that's why, even if we boycott, nothing negative will happen to us, well, on the other hand, you remember how strangely the situation in the case of europe developed, the ukrainian delegates said for a long time that it is not worth making concessions to russia, it is not necessary to change the rules, it is not necessary to allow russian delegation to a-a meeting before

it fulfills those conditions in connection with which sanctions against russia were introduced, well, the answer is, but it was a complete disregard of such sentiments, everything was canceled, the russian delegation was let in that literally in six months, to expel russia altogether for treason to europe, you know that this is not a lesson, it is difficult to say now, in fact, how to act in relation to such and such established organizations, ideally, it is better for russia to be thrown out of here, ukraine to remain, to somehow change the structure of the organization, the internal reform took place, but unfortunately, unfortunately this does not happen with such organizations, some of them will be forced to completely change their statutory documents, and the russian war against ukraine will be the catalyst for these changes in the regions, and it also showed their inability in many ways. and here, completely in

the field of security, they showed that they can do nothing at all like ion. by the way, the security council is the same, this is the same situation, i listened to this, this is the last crazy extreme and the last meeting without the un, i will tell you this is the result and the effectiveness of the norms of listening to this god who carries such a uh, well, it's a lie to say it is already mildly said, that is, why is it all being listened to , but i can't see anymore. of international organizations is probably no longer the most effective mechanism for conveying the opinion as the position of the entire country in the world, so it is probably necessary to act outside the norm, but the main thing is to act inconsistently, so that all these initiatives are coordinated with

partners or the head of understanding who supports you well, for example, there is a crisis in the field of security, well a serious crisis organization in the field of security, this is the osce in europe and it has its security structure, i.e., we must act proactively and positively by proposing a replacement and not just liquidation, but i emphasize once again that sometimes a boycott can be the right action. we only need to count on the future, what can not be done next . in 2015-2019 , the chairman of the board of the ukrainian crisis media center was with us in the direction of communication. and to conclude this topic, i want to talk to mr. the activities of the osce and the president of ukraine volodymyr zelenskyi also repeatedly criticized and said

that not enough was done during the nine months of russia's war against ukraine to stop this war or at least somehow help us. it was created like that, moreover, i believe that mr. valery is absolutely correct in principle when he said that the osce is based on the helsinki act, which in principle speaks of borders that should be inviolable in europe precisely based on the helsinki act. i want to remind you that the soviet union of the former yugoslavia should disintegrate along the borders of the union republics that were considered sovereign states within the framework of these formations. a sovereign state that united the soviet union with other socialist republic of slovenia was a sovereign state that united with

another socialist federal republic yugoslavs like the czech republic and slovakia, they were sovereign subjects of czechoslovakia. but russia violated all this not even when transnistria of the southern grid began, but with crimea first of all , and from that moment on, no kerch act exists because in europe the borders were violated, the helsinki act turned out to be absolutely ineffective from the point of view of the territorial integrity of the states that signed it ukraine is one of the heirs of the soviet union and the russian federation so that in this regard the osce is already in a situation where they in principle, we should not have been in such a situation because the countries that signed helsinki, as they had in mind that there would be such territorial integrity, you know what we can say about the helsinki act, because the russians did almost nothing in the kaliningrad region of the russian federation 30 years ago, which they could not

understand in any way will this territory be the final territory of the soviet union? or maybe it won't always be like this? it's not certain , and by the way, that's why kaliningrad looks like a terrible soviet regional center. and even though it's königsberg, gdansk looks like a beautiful city with a german- polish heritage. these were completely different approaches because poland was confident in its borders and the ussr was not in 175. everything changed, and after 2014 , everything changed again. here is the whole story with the helsinki acts and all these organizations, so what do you want from them? thank you for the clarification and now we can go to the block of the russian-ukrainian war. what is happening on the fronts ? good afternoon, so let's start with a about

what is happening on the eastern front directly . avdiyivka kramatorsk bakhmutna has repeatedly informed the first general staff and the supreme commander-in-chief that these are the hot spots on the eastern front. how do you see how the situation will develop further because there were prior reports that russian troops will regroup to the east, and now the leader of the eastern group talked about the fact that in fact they are unable to do this due to the change in weather conditions. well, when we talk about the eastern the direction about eh pakhmuti, what enemy is not trying already to not take the bait from the front to the sea is now trying to carry out eh encircling actions there from avdiyivka and maryanka, then this is a rather complicated process associated with significant losses. from the enemy, we

say about the fact that the methods are already being used there when, relatively speaking, these buggers are trying to direct them to our defense at the expense of drones from above, trying to operate everything as such, such a computer heats because it somehow compensates for the shortcomings of these combat training bugners who were recruited from criminals, and this direction really remains extremely difficult if we take into account even the statements of our military leaders, where general gromov, the deputy head of the department, said that there were up to 290,290 spectators. and so , for the past week, just in the vase of donbahmut and at the expense of a significant number of artillerymen the enemy is now trying to try to press in there in marinka, in fact, he went to the middle of the city and

there are just such active hostilities on both sides of marinka - this is the boundary that somewhere built from the 14th year outside of minsk, there were two sufficiently powerful fortified engineering structures, but they actually now, well, cease to exist for the use of artillerymen, if in any case this direction is politically significant for the enemy, but even advancing to the extremes there is 100 m ahead theoretically, it does not in any way affect any active forces there, or even more so , strategic changes on the front line. so, the area there will be difficult, but without fundamental consequences for our line of defense. and say with a trailer sergey, how do you in principle imagine the development of the situation at the front precisely in connection with the blockade attempts, or can russia really think that it is stopping the ukrainian army by destroying the civilian

infrastructure ? with our lives, we are talking about the fact that we are in the area of ​​​​proka. we talked about the agreement there earlier, the donetsk bakhmut zone, where the enemy is trying to advance, the central has criminal asphalt. we are trying to advance zaporizhia until that such a moment is somewhat frozen in the kherson center, well, there is no change, but the dynamics at the level of the front, that uh, there is no connection here, because in fact, these are two such parallel processes, where in the second process, the impact and the critical temperature, the enemy first of all calculates in some way to influence the stability of the population and not on some such strange swearing of the states, that is, the ukrainian population will put pressure on the ukrainian authorities to try some negotiations, i do not think that this is an absolutely illogical expectation of the enemy, and on the other hand, destruction of energy, the venation of logistical birds there, and the impact

of strikes on their own energy supply facilities is expected that it will affect the persistence of the defense, but i think that these are even expectations and it will not affect the situation at the level of the front in a popular way. let's say more such aggression in our soldiers in order to quickly liberate these territories that are currently occupied by the enemy, mr. serhiy regarding the kherson region and the left bank directly from october afternoon natalya humenyuk has already informed that the russian troops do not hold the left-bank kherson oblast, in particular, because of the fact that the weapons of the forces of ukraine control with fire, let’s say, the most important roads along which the russian troops move, and that is why they even if they try to somehow escape, we will still be able to destroy them and how soon