uh, in the 23rd year, both oil products and gas are getting less and less. well, we know that there is already 90% of gas there, and the russian federation has lost the market in europe. if we are talking about europe, the same will happen with oil products, and it is not on the black markets. will be able to sell, taking into account what we said, what the president also said, what zelenskyi said, what the head of the office ark told us, but when they will not be able to sell precious metals, well, this will have a critical impact on their economic situation in general and on the possibility of continuing the war, well, and in the end, i will influence some movements within russian society because, again, the social sphere will not be covered from the russian budget in the amount that it should be covered . what is your opinion? our economy, well , is it possible to talk about it during the war?

things, did you survive the blackout, how long did we have, in general, the energy tsarana and the ukrainian society as a whole, well, about personal experience, first, yes, you know. for me, it was probably sung, and by the way, i came up with a new song, uh, a christmas song, and you know in this a dark period, in a secret time, in a cold time, an absolutely sad song appeared, and it's just right for me, it's also symbolic, you know what a miracle, a miracle, strange at christmas , magical. you know key message but uh, how i experienced it for me, i think that the worst thing was the lack of information , that is, it doesn't matter to me whether it was cold there or not, thank god i evacuated my family , so it's easy for me, somehow it's easier, you know, because i'm not i only take care of myself, but it's warm, let it not be

warm, electricity is there, there are some batteries, i use them. by the way, my friends from holland gave it to me for my birthday. i sent it to ukraine. and hmm, there's no electricity. well, no problem, and there's no internet, that's it for me. it's already difficult and there is no mobile connection either it's already difficult because well, when you sit in complete uh, what happens in information isolation, this is yours , this is the most difficult for me, and how did ukraine survive, well , the energy system, in fact, ukraine shows some incredible examples of endurance, and because i talked to various representatives of the energy industry and our ukrainian and colleagues from abroad, in particular european countries, they say that european countries, most european countries have not managed without this situation, how is ukraine coping, listen to us there have already been seven waves of such massive strikes on

the power system, and our energy engineers are finding an opportunity to switch, and there are still some spare parts in order to rebuild something , switch and provide electricity to people in a different way so that everyone has at least a little of this electricity. that's why it's a very durable power system that inspires our partners today. well, thanks to our partners, we still get enough sipjets. and today there was information about powerful transformers. more precisely, a transformer i received the generator from france from other partners, that is, the partners help us and we should thank them, but i think that for the majority of ukrainians, this is the experience that we have gone through. for some even more, this is such an experience for the future, because we do not rule out that there

could be at least three such massive strikes, as the secretary of defense security danilov told us, he already said that we remember the first of october 10 was like this until the last one said that 3-4 times, yes, let's be pessimistic, or three times is possible , although not exclusively, what will happen more, i just remember three scenarios that were drawn by experts that it could be a blackout of the left bank, a blackout for one or two days there, 24 or 48 hours, a blackout for even a week, and now you are talking about what we managed, but with the blackouts, which, relatively speaking, lasted 13 days, so experts say that it was not a blackout, because a blackout is nothing at all, it is such a critical situation for the energy system of ukraine, oh, clouds, but it did not happen, and this is thanks to ours energy and, well, the powerful work of our air defense forces , because with the means used by our papoo - it's unbelievable to shoot down for so many years, but here i don't have anything to explain the logic of the russians. well, of course , they don't understand anything about us. they think

that they are such a method they are taking the civilian population hostage and that they are pumping something out there, they will impose their conditions on us, but they launch a lot of information in the ukrainian language among our society, a telegram channel, and so on, that you are everywhere how can you tolerate the zelensky forces there it warmed up to him, all is well. and we, the president, just like that, save electricity very much. when we were at the press conference in the last one, all the corridors were absolutely dark, well, absolutely right. listen, well, i talk to different people, including those who are there at in power in various ministries and you are all presidents and all of them are exactly the same as all ukrainians in exactly the same way, these are all hard times and we don’t have that here someone is more in power the more opportunities someone is less in power less opportunities no all the same we are going through this whole situation, but what will definitely not happen from what the russians think, listen to me, they passed on a very interesting material that one major of the usaf

in 1994, in the fourth year, defended his thesis when he researched not blockades, but exactly the same strikes on the power system there is 90% outage, the power system of north korea, vietnam and iraq a and e. he looked at what those who struck expected four effects, e.e. disturbance in society , a change in the opinion of the political leadership, e.e. that cannot be restored. well, and economic decline a so, in all these positions, in all these positions , the task of those who could make such a blow to the energy system is not being fulfilled, and especially when we are talking about ukraine, because as our famous goalkeeper oleksandr shovkovskyi said recently that we are gathering even more in circles, that is, the people of ukraine he is going to fight even more, he will definitely not give up, well, you remember what the president said. by the way, i would also write a song for this .

you can watch it on youtube. i, uh, you mentioned the office of the president, you mentioned the government offices, i'll tell you that during our broadcast, our conversation, we also have only in this city, in this location, uh, the soffits are burning, so to speak, so and so that in other countries i went there where you can wash your hands and there is nothing to do again we call on you from each of us and it depends on you how quickly our energy engineers will cope dmytro vasilov political scientist thank you, thank you strengthen the borders of ukraine to drones , join the meeting of the border guard of the settlement military humanitarian and financial aid, these and other issues were discussed by the prime ministers of ukraine, lithuania and poland as a result of their meeting, the ministers of the three countries signed a statement within the framework of the lublin triangle, among other things , it talks about countering

russia's aggressive policy and investigating its war crimes ukrainian -lithuania and poland are united by common goals, common values, a single position in assessing challenges and threats, as well as a common vision regarding resistance to russian aggression and rapprochement of our victory has prepared a new aid package for ukraine in the energy sector, which is more than two million euros, russia continues to bombard civilian and energy infrastructure in ukraine, this is a large-scale humanitarian crime, barbarism, and we must confront it today. ukraine will help the world avoid a food crisis thanks to an international initiative to inform ukraine immediately, two dozen countries declared that they were ready to finance the shipment of ships, said deputy head of the president's office ihor zhovkva, more than 20 countries

only took part at the level of their leaders, the respective ministers, and also pledged to finance the sending of the corresponding ships with ukrainian grain, ukrainian grain, and other agricultural products to the poorest countries in africa and asian countries, i.e. ukraine has grain, ukraine has ports that, fortunately, are now functioning and ukraine what is most important is the will to help the world, the poorest country in the world, to avoid a food crisis, the newly elected republican congressman michael michael supports providing ukraine with long-range missiles such as said on the air of the abc news channel, if we give them what they need, they will win, if we don't, it will be a long, drawn-out war, noted politician michael michael, who will soon head the congressional committee on foreign affairs, one of the key factors in solving the

issue of defense assistance to ukraine, they were the first to arrive on the scene hit by a russian rocket on november 23 and began rescuing people, the patrol police released a video from the award-winning chest cameras of patrolmen andrii butsenko and volodymyr shyshkov, they were patrolling the streets and nearby a powerful explosion rang out to the place of impact, the law enforcement officers ran on foot, because a big traffic jam immediately formed on the roads at the place of the explosion. the patrolmen immediately began to provide medical aid to the victims. very soon, military medics, rescuers and ambulances arrived at the scene. to the

word beat and you are free to choose exactly how you want to get even with the enemy, who else puts not just a dot above and but two dots above and it is difficult to convey your feelings because there is a lack of words, create new ones, we do received the art and future of the ukrainian language of the free on november 13, 1708, moscow troops destroyed the hetman's capital baturyn and brutally killed all its inhabitants, about 15,000 ukrainians, the crimes of the kremlin they always say we can repeat

the real ukrainians are peaceful, kind in soul and sincere in heart as long as they do not touch us because if we go against us by war, the nation will show the cossack character to live in peace the greatest value is to win a victory in the right honor the rules of a warm country healthy care thank you for regulating the heater and ensuring sufficient temperature without spending money on the wind, we will beat the winter together, the rules of a warm country,

a high-rise building, unite with neighbors, inspect the house, attract specialists for insulation , prepare batteries, repair and adjust windows and doors, check the wiring, take care of a warm room and personal heating devices, take care of those who find it more difficult to develop an action plan in an extreme situations discuss the need for a backup generator to equip the premises for joint heating let's beat the winter together what about us we continue our broadcast. russia has already spent a quarter of its budget on the war in ukraine. in particular, we will cite the data of $82 billion spent on the war in ukraine. let's talk about the prospects of this military campaign in general with

our guest and you. stupak, a military expert of the ukrainian institute, a consultant of the future committee of the verkhovna rada on national security and defense greetings, good afternoon, i have a question about sanctions, this economic mess is getting longer and longer, sanctions, more money catastrophically lacking and how russians in general, their military and political leadership will or plans to wage war in the future, in particular in the 23rd year, when these finances and money are completely lacking, this means that russian society will receive less funds, less will be how funds for the development of the economy will be made up and different industries there yesterday putin presented. yes, there is artificial intelligence. yes, what kind of artificial intelligence is there? if they can’t make a proper smartphone, the air transport programs are stopped. they take engines there that were already in they made an innovation, i.e., for the civilian segment, money is wasted, yes, this budget , but for the military segment, it is increased as much as possible, for example, for the needs of law enforcement officers, the fsb, the national guard, the investigative committee of intelligence, military

intelligence, the budget was increased by about a third, that is, it will be chosen for the military, give them more rations, yes, more food in order to maintain their loyalty in this way, this also applies to the military, that is, he is not personally interested in putin - it is the general kremlin that is not interested. in order to be a strong population, all the money for the army, if the population is dissatisfied, there will be a law enforcement unit that will constantly screw everyone, as they say, yes, er, give deadlines for discrediting the army. yes, there is the opening of this operation, that is, they plan to go and so on. well, but our general staff got a very interesting one called the conclusions of the war with nato in ukraine, this document is being distributed. among russian military personnel, there is talk of the fact that they need to attract another 5 million russian soldiers to win the war, and it is also very interesting that they they self-diagnose what mistakes they have, among the main problems of the russian occupation

forces are the inability of commanders to command personnel in the troops, the unsatisfactory state of discipline and combat training, the obsolescence of weapons and military equipment, the impossibility of commanders making decisions without a mandatory origin with the command, etc., and at the same time, every document it is noted that the defense forces of ukraine have a fairly high level of equipment, and their commanders at all levels can independently make decisions in combat conditions, well, we thank them for compliments, it's actually very nice that they themselves evaluated us and accordingly gave themselves such a diagnosis, which is in principle true. the question is that 5 million. we remember, hmm, what was the dissatisfaction of only the federation when this partial mobilization was announced, that is, they allegedly called these 300,000 from one on the one hand, we understand that these 300,000 will end very quickly, considering the numbers that are already dead, but on the other hand, how can putin afford another such wave

of protest sentiments? and i literally have two words from about the list of which they said the last point yes, about decision-making and this is really a story, it is without exaggeration many listeners or viewers well , what? subordinates cannot do anything until there is a sanction from above, and here they are sitting, waiting for this instruction. and time is running out. and the european model, which ukraine has adopted, allows the heads of secondary education. yes, and nativska in general european in general, that is, if you have the authority at your level, you don’t need to ask. you don’t need to ask someone, you don’t need to call, wait for approval and the decision is made quickly and efficiently, this is very important, and it’s about 5 million . 25 million, what is the potential? listen, they collected 222,000 with such efforts. they met people at the entrances

. yes, they fished out money at work. they offered 222,000 with a plan of 300, but then 222 and there trindumbim, we collected 300 there . plus there are 120,140,000 where they started, that is, i would have understood that the plan was blown up, now a little bit back perspective, but in the spring, yes, they collected conscripts for 30% less than the plan was. yes, it was spring when they just entered. they seem to be still strong there. and now, on november 1, the next recruitment of conscripts began, we let's see what the trend is, it's even smaller, it's not that it's not about 5 million, i'm sure that the recruitment plan for 100,000 people is a very, very big effort for the russian machine to recruit them there. so to speak there was also a very important point that it turns out that the russians are fighting on the territory of ukraine, not

with the ukrainians, the ato. so it is easier, of course, for the average russian, yes. well, let's say that, not quite. far, yes, but america is the enemy of nato - it is the enemy of europe - it is a decaying west and this can in some way encourage them at least a little, you know, mobilize them. it is possible to push their men to the front in this war. i think it is possible to justify the failure, that is, they have not had any victories, that is, yours, well, it’s all thanks to our troops . it’s all a kind of regrouping. it’s a voluntary act. there’s something else. there are no victories, and we have to somehow feed the people of the depths. the people there, that streamous deceased, yes, what did he say when we retreat , it means that we are advancing, but well, i’ve been feeding for six months already feed the russians, well, it's hard to explain with one raccoon, er, stolen from the kherson zoo. well, it doesn't justify the situation, and we have to explain that

if the ukrainian and i had sat down, we would have killed them. this is how they explain it, to put it mildly, i don't think that it will provoke any kind of wave there, wow, everyone ran to the military commissariat, although you remember the head of the federation council matvienko, yes, there is a fortune teller of ukraine. everything turned out the other way around, 700,000 from 700,000 to a million fled, and the military commissars there forcefully dragged up to 200,000, let's not be nervous, let's all sit quietly together, the parliaments thought, the ukrainian parliament and the russian thought, let's discuss, let's be to be nervous, but we see that this is reconciliation or, let's say, an attempt to sit at the negotiating table, it is not only the sound of matvienko , lavrov or someone else, and the military has repeatedly emphasized that it would be worthwhile to speak russian, but to sit at the table and talk about the fact that it is necessary to make a

tactical pause, so at least there for the winter period, what do you think, in general, for the russians, this is a critical moment here already for now it has already come, what if this does not happen now, if there are no frosts now it will be then that these three months will winter, as budanov predicted until spring, they will be decisive for the course of such an addition, besides the fact that matvienko is also there, and because zelensky said that i will not hold negotiations with putin, and immediately matvienko appeared on the horizon, who tried to the level of parliaments, maybe we will sit down, let's talk to the military, and yesterday was interesting, such a revealing moment when the belarusian dictator says that we need to sit down, we definitely need negotiations, and look at the trend, it's very interesting. what ah is trying to kill k- klin, yes, between the ukrainian government and the people, does he say that he starts, starts really simply contemptuously that you are zelenskoe, yes, there in dirty shirts and t-shirts, the people are freezing, yes

, without light and he is in the light, in the heat, that is, he is trying to kill but at the same time negotiations, if there are no negotiations, there will be no ukraine. i understand that this is already the apogee, that is, putin is being told so there sasha, go on camera, tell us that in ukraine it is necessary to conduct negotiations, they really do not need at least a couple of weeks for that in the meantime, they will adjust their logistics plus or minus there, but ideally by spring during this time they will adjust the logistics as much as possible, they will make an import replacement of microcircuits there, they will bring some military equipment there, either contraband, or they will set up its production in russia, they will drag their mobiks of their chmobics, then they will become more or less full-fledged soldiers for 3-4 months - this is enough time to prepare them and in the spring the counteroffensive will start again 2:0 there to liberate the territory occupied by the ukrainian invaders, that is, all this will start again, so it is not possible it is not worth giving a single day at all, the head

of the british ministry of defense said the other day that, as advice for the ukrainian army, for the armed forces, in no case do not stop. it will attack absolutely 1,000%. well, actually, this is the only way we see the situation, in particular valeriy zaluzhnyi said that we will not stop here under any circumstances. even if some of the politicians had this opinion, we know exactly what our military thinks about it, and they are not going to give back and they definitely want to take revenge on everyone, but now there is a certain uncertainty because the military says that now it is very logical and simply easier than it was before to liberate crimea. however, our partners, in particular, the united states, have an ambiguous position regarding crimea, because there are different opinions, not everyone agrees that we should liberate crimea through the west with weapons, because they are afraid of escalation, they are afraid that the russian federation can strike, in particular, with nuclear weapons, it turns out that now

we have to fight for donbas, at least eight, even though the military says that we could now to liberate crimea, what are our chances, although donbas is also a symbolic region for putin, and as our president says, a russian man will never forgive putin for the loss of donbas . to explain why, just a couple of days ago, he signed another piece of paper, well , a decree, yes, about the liquidation, i sincerely repent. i didn't know that there was such a story as the central bank in the territory of the lrdshchyna. well, honestly, i think that the army was sent there and that's all there is no one else, the liquidation of the central banks of these republics and the creation of branches of the russian absolutely worthless, but the paper with the staffing schedule of the kherson region, you remember it was like this, but it is monetary, it is blood, that is, money. that is, it is the blood of the economy, that is, i see that it is blood, it will not

be blood. yes in these regions, now regarding crimea , look at crimea - this is a big, large-scale project, and before measuring this project there, we should all ask ourselves big questions, this is really not a philosophy, in any case, when we we go to the borders on february 24, 23, we sit down with our partner and ask if they are with us or not, if they say, guys, we are with you, then ok, this is one way out, then the big question is how much time can we afford to liberate crimea, how many military personnel will be involved in which losses, we agree, and after which bar we will say that this is not a passive burden, we will not be able to free it, there are crimean mountains there and forests there, its saboteurs, well , russian saboteurs will be hiding there as long as we can do it. they put a flag on the embankment of the yalta embankment, what to do with the russians who stayed there and have no desire to leave, they say how i bought this apartment there in the 15th year, this is my passport of ukraine , i don't want to receive it

. european direction, there are many questions that need to be answered now before the start of the operation, not like the russians . luhansk region is more realistic. it's more. well , it's not because of inertia. and it's more promising, but crimea is only politics. it's only with friends. if our friends don't support us, they'll say it's apt to you. it's up to you . this burden is a burden on its own, that's why these options appear there. and let's agree on postponing the freezing of crimea for seven years . do you remember all these stories, because no one wants to expose themselves to such an open confrontation? we thank you for the opportunity to communicate on this and other topic ivan stupak a military expert of the ukrainian institute of the future, a consultant to the verkhovna rada committee on national security and defense, was with us just now, he strengthened the borders of ukraine with drones

, join the gathering of border guards during the escape from mykolaiv oblast, the russian invaders robbed almost all the houses in snighurivka this was told by ivanna, the head of the snighuriv city military administration in kuchta, the russian military took out almost all the communal equipment and robbed most of the homes of local residents they left only what they could not take out because it was immovable. in addition, the russians destroyed schools and administrative buildings, many residential buildings are currently destroyed, special commissions are assessing the extent of the damage. the president of the russian federation putin and his closest entourage, this was stated by the people's deputy , head of the permanent delegation of ukraine in pariya maria has zentseva, russia must

be brought to justice for all war crimes, the world is already taking important steps in this direction, the deputy emphasized, the war against ukraine began in 2014, before that there were also moldova, chechnya and georgia, but we insist that the international tribunal focus on those the events that took place in our country after february, so that the occupiers did not do it, we see that putin's plan has failed, the ukrainians will not give up and we will definitely survive this winter, and then there will be our joint victory with those countries that support next week may be difficult russia is already preparing new terrorist attacks against the energy facilities of ukraine, but also the military authorities and emergency services are already preparing, said a people's deputy, a member of the committee on national security, defense and intelligence, let's go to arkhamia, according to him, a lot of training has been carried out energeticov works, everyone knows how to act, but every ukrainian should also take extra care of himself and his loved ones, stock up on food, water,

charge power banks and find out the addresses of the nearest the work of the ukrainian energy system has been stabilized by archamia. this was announced by the prime minister of ukraine denysh myhal. he also added that ukrenergo receives funds from western partners for the prompt repair of damage caused by russian attacks, and more than 4,000 unbreakable points have been put into operation throughout ukraine - these are places where during the absence of electricity at home, you can charge your gadgets and keep warm, unable to win on the battlefield, russian terrorists are trying to destroy the ukrainian power system in order to break into shopir as of the end of the week we managed to stabilize the operation of the power system the power deficit remains at the level of about 20% more than a thousand specialists work daily on the repair of networks sbu conducted an inspection of the ivano-frankish ukrainian orthodox church of the moscow patriarchate counter-intelligence

security measures the security service is conducting how to counter the subversive activities of the russian special services in ukraine, law enforcement officers inspect the territory and premises of the diocese for prohibited items and check persons for the territory of the temple in relation to their involvement in illegal activities to the detriment of the state, the inspection of the diocese takes place within the limits of current legislation , the sbu is informed. well, that 's it . silence in ukrainian regions