i think that i will be the first to answer. i think that, as i said, the north atlantic council often supports and the military supports constant contacts with your country here and there, and there is no doubt that there are constant visits, exchanges, both public and private, what can i say about the restoration of us at the next meeting of the commission ukraine nato yes, i think it is foreseen at all subsequent meetings of the ancient council. i know that they are scheduled. but i think that all the meetings we hold are very fruitful and very active. and as for next steps i think that ukraine needs to preserve this military moment of military impetus and it gives the opportunity to be successful, this

does not mean that we have to wait until you completely push russian forces completely out of ukraine before we start talking, we need to create the conditions now, the conditions are not they are suitable for negotiations, but it is necessary to do the first thing: get out so that the russians withdraw their troops, thank you; the second thing is to return the people who were kidnapped or who disappeared; three, reparations; and number four, international and legal procedures, and after that, he can talk about security guarantees, whether ukraine should become a member of nato, exactly such instruments can be used in these negotiations , because it is under such conditions that we can say that the security of the country largely depends on

ukraine being a member of nato. therefore, i think that it is necessary not afraid of these discussions in 1999, we began to use diplomacy at the beginning of the campaign against the uh, the sycophant in yugoslavia, and we showed by sycophancy that he did not have any military alternatives, and uh, in the end, he accepted the decision to withdraw his troops through military and peaceful means. so the people who brought him this proposal were not the united states, the ambassadors of the black mordins and marty, and the akhtessars, and that's how it worked in 1999 and we avoided escalation. since we were

lying, i saw that he could not do anything to achieve with the further use of e-e force and the situation in ukraine is actually similar now, therefore i would like to call on the united states to call on and continue to provide military aid and support to ukraine , to put pressure on ukraine from the side of russia, and ukraine received militarily at the same time not to close the channels through which you can communicate with putin so that he leaves. we do not give any exit strategy, he sees himself as steel, we just have to ensure that he gets out of ukraine and as soon as possible, mr. general petrovich, a question from the

prime minister very correct, and i want to thank you , mr. yatsenyuk, for everything you have done for your country and as prime minister. through suffering through trials to surrender bend but he simply does not have the courage to look in the mirror at a person who has done a lot of harm to his country, probably more than anyone, and now he is bent on destroying your

electricity supply system so that as much suffering and pain as possible is caused to the ukrainian people and so that the united states and other countries do not supported ukraine all this, all these attempts will fail and what he is doing only reduces and not only increases and does not weaken the determination of ukraine and those who support it, i was in the womb a few weeks ago and i watched how the price of natural gas changes, all this is also connected with the fact that other sources of ukraine appear and all this will definitely have

consequences for russia, our determination in washington will remain at a high level and you, uh, heard it from our congressmen and from, in particular, the republic, which will have a majority in january , i would like to emphasize once again the courage of the ukrainian people, who are so heroically and decisively fighting all these trials, sooner or later, putin will understand that russia will not be able to withstand this the pace of the war and then their behavior will change , then the time will come for us to put forward the conditions on

which peace can be based. the time will come when russia realizes that their losses on the battlefield and economic losses and other negative consequences for russia are already such that it cannot allow this to continue, then the time will come to put forward these demands, there should be not only an agreement on supporting ukraine in relation to its reconstruction and there must be reinforced concrete security guarantees for ukraine, without which we will not be able to achieve the desired result of peace, thank you mrs.

mariana generala clark, the question was for both generals, actually the antonym can give the floor to general the chicken, but i am also ready to answer my part of the question for us well and then i will start whether putin will use a nuclear weapon is a million dollar question. i personally believe that if you actually try to read his thoughts, it is absolutely useless, but no matter what , he has the opportunity to use nuclear weapons. therefore, we must be aware of this and must have certain deterrent mechanisms in relation to

such a scenario. i can say that the military benefit from the use of tactical nuclear weapons is quite limited . otherwise, you will be solved by hundreds and thousands of projectiles, bombs, etc., but the ukrainian armed forces are quite inflexible and quite mobile, and they are quite skillful avoid and yes, on the part of the russian army, but we see that russia still has a lot of

conventional weapons in order to try to achieve its goals, demonstration use of nuclear weapons is also possible, but this would have all the negatives that can occur after the use of nuclear weapons, and not would give nothing, um, no military effect. that is, everyone saw this and the nuclear cloud and used it simply for demonstration. it is unlikely that it will be attractive to him. height or in fact an attack on some city and in order to prevent this scenario, let's say if there is an attack on some city, let's say somewhere in the central

regions of ukraine, let's say in vinnytsia, and then the ultimatum for ukraine to capitulate, otherwise kyiv will be next in order to avoid this scenario, we will again we have to understand that what can change putin's thoughts in this regard - it is not the use of weapons in response to the addresses of weapons, no one will use nuclear weapons against him, and this is the complexity of our situation, how can we restrain him knowing that we will not to respond to it with nuclear weapons is the use of nuclear weapons. i think and i hope that there are certain private conversations and contacts between the united states and russia in order to convey absolutely

unequivocally what the consequences for russia of any use of nuclear weapons by russia may be. i hope that they will get it somehow, i really hope so. thank you all for the questions and answers. we started this panel with a video address by minister reznikov, then the banker, mr. buduren uveziy, clark and general petrovich joined us, after that we we are very grateful to each of the participants in this discussion. meanwhile, we will continue. petro burkovskyi, representatives of the democratic initiatives foundation, and i, fk kucherov

, were asked to speak in english, since the audience for this presentation is larger, it is actually foreigners for the country who support ukraine, so i am interested in hearing about associology and what our society looks like today, please pay attention, i wanted to say that history only says that no one takes it into account lessons and sociology, although it is not studied at school, but its research results are still considered for foreigners, sometimes it is difficult to understand why we are fighting so much and how we see our victory, what we are ready

to do to achieve this victory, how we see the possible limits of this e- e war and what are the economic possibilities and limits of our allies here you see support and victory it happens only once every four years 32 national teams will meet on the fields of the boat to find a new winner in the ideals watch all 64 matches of the world cup live on media service megogo special project world cup tv channels espresso story semanga will receive an award from the hands of queen elizabeth victory at

any cost it was the hand of god the hand of his actions maradona the great champions zidane heads the goal of the french national team the owner of the home world cup and destinies the brazilian ronald in germany provocations the mattress provokes a wall on the legend leaves the field, the long-awaited trophy 100, what an injury, how hard it is to look at leo messi now, the world championship is still out of reach for the argentine, the new generation by filian bana, zionists, watch the special project world cup football format on the espresso tv channel from monday to saturday at 2:40 p.m. and on sundays at 11:10 a.m. i am iryna koval, mother, wife, host of the espresso tv channel. i am also a volunteer. our soldiers at the front

need a lot of things every day, and that is why part of my life today is help to the armed forces of ukraine, and i am very grateful to my colleagues for supporting me in this, you are our soldiers, i can distract myself from the continuous stream of news, at least for a short time, admire nature while walking with simba in the park, i see beautiful things, it would seem in such simple things. i know that my family is behind the backs of fantastic people who protect our dear country at the cost of their own lives. it is the least i can personally do to thank our indomitable defenders, transfer funds to the needs of the army, join and you, each of you can help even a small contribution to support troops saves the lives of our soldiers and

brings our victory closer mykola veresen vitaly portnikov and the main topics of the week if it is used against ukraine god forbid really tactical nuclear weapons will definitely change the world stories, problems, analysis and personalities are waiting for us , john gerbs is the former ambassador to the united states in ukraine. thanks for the transformation, you have questions, you will get answers, so the question is waiting for you: how to understand sports in september, every friday at 21:30 on espresso glory to ukraine, this is a verdict program, my name is serhiy rudenko good day and good health to all, today is the 279th day of the heroic resistance of the ukrainian people to the russian occupiers. believes that russia's strategy to destroy ukrainian

energy is becoming less and less effective, meanwhile, the pentagon announced that it will allocate another 1 billion 200 million dollars for sams systems for ukraine, the russian army will continue to lose manpower and equipment on the eastern and southern fronts on december 1 russia has already lost 89,440 people in ukraine in just the last day, the armed forces of ukraine destroyed 560 orks at the beginning of the great war, the russians have already lost 2,915 5.87 tanks in ukraine, and you know, they have 1,904 artillery vehicles systems 395 rocket systems of salvo fire 210 air defense means 270 hecopters 260 e-e one e-e plane 4,441 units of automotive equipment 16 ships boats 531 cruise missiles

1562 drones 163 units of special equipment putin's last winter skabee simonyan prepares russia for defeat well, lukashenko wants get security guarantees for yourself and your family at the event, we will talk about this in the next hour, contact us ihor romanenko, retired lieutenant general, former deputy chief general staff of the armed forces of ukraine, mr. igor, i congratulate you, i'm glad to see you. thank you for joining us on the air. i also congratulate you. so, igor, let 's start our conversation with winter today, winter has begun and the last winter has begun. to outline with what and how

ukraine is entering the winter at the front and with what russia is entering the front at us on the front line, the conduct of hostilities continues, both offensive code offensive with the sides and defensive, i.e. quite complex er actions are taking place and this er let's say against the background of the transition from autumn to winter in difficult weather conditions, i would like to remind you that the advance is slow in the north of the luhansk region, the match stone opponent of the legal there counter strikes in the donetsk operational zone, heavy defensive battles are being conducted by the forces of the defense of ukraine, the adversary

transferred his forces from the kherson direction under his forces to his own forces, wagner, who is already more than 200 . the so-called temporarily mobilized appeared, i.e. any formations are assembled and attacked by the enemy , including the division whose distance was carefully monitored in the belarus training center, that is, the personnel of the division that they trained, but also threw planes at uh, the southern and eastern directions, because there is not much fighting there, and uh, the grouping of the armed forces of the

russian federation does not have enough forces, as for the kherson direction, by god, they are going to the kinburg spit, as you know, and also our artillery is inflicting blows to the fruit of the corresponding supply routes from the crimea to the south of the enemy grouping and vice versa, it is fundamentally important which of the parties will be the first to be able to group the forces to strengthen the reserves and concentrate them on the main directions or offensive actions will they concentrate the forces on defense by the way, our reserves entered the area of ​​bakhmut ugledar, as professionally reported, and in

this regard, despite the fact that the one who is trying to bypass bakhmut, to make an operational coverage , that is, to encircle the opponents, he did not completely these propagandistic statements that bakhmut have already been heard did not take the same picture in front of kyiv and in a different way this is an attempt to give off what they would like for the fact that i am the truth. the grouping of the enemy's troops, the technical one is being reinforced, they transported the e-e with the letters and the missile complex and the military tender m2 engineering equipment, but in relation to the declared formations of the joint groups of the enemy, russian

and belarusian, there is no possibility because we are already a target they themselves discussed that they are plugging such possible holes in the east and south of our country, but according to the aviation company of this group in belarus , they advanced further, there are also concentrated complexes of splista s400 navigation stations that were watching our country from the north, in fact, almost to the south, they brought mig 31 kalm which are the carriers of the

dagger missile, but the grouping of m. the actual course and, accordingly, the finale of the russian-ukrainian war, we hope that this war will end with our victory, no one has any doubts about this, but it is precisely in this next 3-4 months, starting from december and ending already in april, that the main points of this battle will actually be resolved, sir generals, we are recruiting mr. general, unfortunately, unfortunately, we lost contact with hero romanenko, he is a retired lieutenant general, deputy chief of the general staff of the armed forces of ukraine in 2006-2010, we are talking about the situation in the eastern and southern on the fronts in ukraine, as of december 1st,

winter began today, and yesterday there was a meeting of the commander-in-chief and the president of ukraine. he informed the important questions that were raised at this meeting, in particular . donetsk region, luhansk region, kharkiv region, zaporozhye region, kherson region, crimea, the frontline territory, our state border, we analyze the intentions of the occupiers we are preparing countermeasures even more powerful countermeasures than now, we considered the issue of providing the military and the supply of new ammunition equipment, held a separate

meeting on energy and communication issues, we are recording the results of what has already been done to protect our systems, we are preparing new solutions, we are also preparing new solutions to prevent any possibility russia to manipulate the internal life of ukraine in due time, we will detail it, and this is what zelenskyi said about yesterday's meeting of the commander-in-chief , meanwhile, we are in touch with major general retired generals are flying, where are you going to give p general of the lieutenant general, retired deputy chief of the main general staff of the armed forces of ukraine in 2006-2010s ihor romanenko, mr. general, is it true or are these words true that during this winter the main thing must be decided - how will it continue and how long will the russian-ukrainian war last. we hope that we will

certainly win, but the end of the war in this 4 months, starting from the first of december and ending on the 30th of march, obviously the most difficult months in this war will obviously be the withdrawal of hostilities during the winter, the main thing that will happen in the spring and summer will definitely be decided. this is a rather principled time . with a victory of an operational level, such as in the kharkiv direction, in the kherson direction, then the totality of these victories, let them be operational, can constitute a strategic victory for the liberation of the

east or the south there, or is it possible to make conditions regarding the fact that he went against them from the crimea, there is such a probability, but in many ways we know this for nine months, we have seen it for sure, it depends on how quickly the supply of heavy complex weapons that could be used for c- the achievement of victory in this action, which we talked about, and this is fundamental and important, therefore, in the next 10 days, several weeks, it will be clarified where the general staff will determine the main direction of action , and chipka must be imagined for carrying out the code offensive actions require other conditions. that is, it is not

only weather that there should already be solid roads for the movement of heavy equipment. there should also be weapons of an offensive nature, which include combat armored vehicles on land - these are tanks in the air and airplanes. technicians who, unfortunately, have not yet made a principled decision regarding supplies from our allies well, first of all, this is the military-political leadership of the united states of america, the head of the russian foreign ministry, sergey lavrov, again spoke about nuclear war, saying that nuclear states should not wage a war at all because it can turn into a nuclear one, of course the west is to blame for everything, it is the western states that accuse the russian federation of preparing provocations, while they themselves are already waging a war against russia