is actively investigating or prosecuting any of these cases, we again call on the russian federation to immediately investigate all violations of international law and bring the perpetrators to justice thank you thank you matilda now we can answer the questions we can you can ask as many as possible just introduce yourself and settle the organization microphone which we need to take dmytro didura tv channel espresso and recently

i congratulate dmytro didura tv channel espresso recently the head of the luhansk regional military administration published photos of the execution of civilians in the territory of my native luhansk region. have you already received these photos or communicated with the authorities regarding these recent photos that were published, and do

you already know about the execution of civilians in the luhansk region, because there are many reports of persecution of people there? thank you, there is another question , but whiskey radio can you name the person or people responsible for these murders, and if possible another question, how can these violators be brought to justice? is there another question, iryna, a society journalist, has it been verified

both videos from the scene of the event, are they really real , in particular, and where russian soldiers opened fire during the surrender of prisoners? so, what are the results of the investigation to be expected in general? and one more question, if possible, the international human rights organization amnesty international called the investigation of the international criminal court on ukraine selective justices in the organization emphasize that when investigating war crimes in ukraine, the court denies justice to other countries. is this really true or is it just russian narratives? quest thank you for the question. i ask the commissioner and mrs. god to answer your detailed questions

. to them, this s- for us is an insert, but we continue to try to get it, but this issue is separately important regarding the names of the people who are responsible, we do not conduct a criminal investigation. we have, of course, established the identity and checked a-a, but we have the right to say who it is, who these people are, since the answer to this should be given by the criminal investigation itself, which should be

conducted by the ukrainian ravens of the authorities. of these videos, yes they appeared, it seems that they are authentic, but of course we do not know what happened, for this we need to work in more detail and i was told by the authorities here that they violated accordingly, proceedings regarding the international space station and the international space station have responsibility is a responsibility that applies to all countries in which the international space station has jurisdiction. of course, this applies to the whole world, if of course the country has ratified the statute of the international space station and, of course, their version applies to ukraine, of course, and as i said and stated the number of cases is as it is here, you

need to intensify this fight, we had a great conversation with the prosecutor general about this thank you for the first question about the execution of civilians in luhansk, when we receive information we we are analyzing allegations in russia about arbitrary executions and other killings of civilians, we have information about other arbitrary executions and killings in other regions, not only in those covered by our report, and we will collect information, in particular, about the kharkiv kherson oblasts and other regions of the country in our report, we focused on these three regions: kyiv, chernihiv, and sumy. since we have had access to them since the summer and this allowed us to analyze these murders very deeply, we have full

it takes some time to confirm all the information we receive, it takes a certain amount of time, and that's why we focused our report on these three areas, but we will continue to report on other statements. have to establish the identity of the offenders , the victims, the witnesses usually did not even know about my identity of the offenders, they could usually describe certain details, their ethnic features, ethnic affiliation, or the language they used to communicate with some signs about the uniform they were wearing, but not the details. well, what about the name or title of these

violators, so we and our information is based on interviews with witnesses and victims, and in our report, we also determined which units were at that time in in these areas, that is, we have information about the military units and military units that were there, but regarding the combination of that information with individuals . i answered the third question. thank you. another question. i wanted to look more broadly. you are talking about three different

regions. how representative is this if we take into account the whole picture, that is, how outrageous is it compared to the rest of the violations or war crimes? i wanted to ask about the signs of the signs of genocide as the mission is working. they conduct very detailed interviews, as

my representative just said, with witnesses and victims of these areas, and we very carefully document what happened. and we need this time. we are not the first, we are often one of the first there. appear in anything very quickly appeared already but in order to have all the details we need time that we uh what a picture we see here we were in izyum recently literally yesterday on him who was recently released we continue to receive information about arbitrary executions or enforced disappearances, the destruction of hospitals or schools, and, as i

said, an apartment building, let's say, which was destroyed, 50 people were buried under it. which they worry us a lot about the issue of genocide , then we focus on documenting what we see on the ground er in this case war crimes in the form of intentional killing so we see clear signs if we think about the whole complex does it constitute genocide or not it is not i don't have to do it, the international court of justice has to establish it, but we only see what we see. yes, i wanted to add about the situation with arbitrary executions

and murders on the eighth, as the high commissioner says, we are analyzing different districts, we are documenting cases of arbitrary loss in kharkiv, in the rural region, in the kherson region, i can say at the moment what is indicated in our report bucha, ah, in bucha , there were, as usual, large volumes of arbitrary straits , this is a city where we saw a very large volume of arbitrary straits. we have not seen such numbers in i don't know about other districts, it doesn't mean that there aren't any such cases as there were .

there are 150 for one or two questions if they are thank you for being with us the report will be sent to you by e-mail as well as the report thank you bye i will remind you that we just watched the press conference of the un high commissioner for human rights who is in kyiv emphasizes how cold it is now in the ukrainian capital, entirely in ukraine, and how against the background of all this, the bad thing is that our energy system is on the brink due to missile attacks by the russian federation. before that, you cannot get used to what russia is doing in our the country cannot get used to it, emphasizes folker turk , the un high commissioner for human rights, we will certainly

analyze everything that we have just heard from mr. turk in a call from his studio oleksandr pavlichenko, the executive director of the ukrainian helsinki union for human rights, with whom the press - at the conference, we have already managed to outline the issues of the issue of accountability and to whom exactly is the accountability of all those crimes that are already recorded in ukraine by the russian federation p oleksandr , thank you for listening to this press conference with us and i would like to ask for your reaction. what would you like to say about what you liked and what surprised you? it's a good question, and when we talk about the results of the press conference, it is necessary to say about the conclusions that were drawn. voiced and based directly on the experience

gathered by forkarter tuning and his team during these few days of stay in ukraine, i repeat that they are uh just like uh team well, let's talk like that with our hands i'm going through those uh folders that uh can be uh laid as a basis for the next court papers and here, in my opinion, the uh position that uh determines today and was formulated uh was regarding uh possible the creation of this tool of prosecution, since the process is now a question, but it is not

, to date, finally formulated . why is the creation of such a tool? it should be created under what conditions, and this is the question for today. what was actually about the reference during this press conference with the relevant conclusions and proposals regarding the possible creation of such a court and how realistic it should be even the organization of the united nations has been confirmed, oleksandr, look at the current stage, we understand who is directly responsible for the military aggression of the russian federation against ukraine, the higher political

leadership of the russian federation, those people who the people who implemented them and the so -called affiliated structures that ensured the functioning of various criminal organizations directly gave criminal orders regarding the invasion, in particular, we are talking about the power bloc of the russian federation, well, affiliates are meant, i don’t know, the relevant departments that deal with the economy, sanctions, stabilization, tailoring and so on and so on and so on i.e. at one time this formula was used meritoriously during the nuremberg final. i wish that all the conflict proceedings and so on could distract us from the most important full responsibility of the highest political and highest military-political leadership of the russian federation and as far as we understand

the number of crimes is such that it should already drag them to hell regardless of their personal presence on the bench defendants, do you think there are any chances now, using the already existing institutions, using the already recorded crimes , to start an appropriate investigation, the investigation is already underway, and when we talk about the need or about the chances, the necessity is there, and these chances are already becoming realistic today, because, i repeat, the office of the prosecutor of the international criminal court is conducting an investigation, they have taken several specific cases with which they are already working and accordingly e- eh when we talk about the level of organization of the united nations eh this is a question of creating either a new instrument or strengthening

an existing instrument what is the international criminal today this is the question and we talked about it just in the previous to our part, the inclusion of the possibility of competition between the existing instrument, of which the criminal court for prosecution for such a category of crimes is the only one today, and, accordingly, the possibility of creating a new instrument, which can become this tribunal for prosecuting the crime of aggression, to what extent it is realistic, it was just important to hear from a representative who represents the global organization of the united nations and, accordingly, the possibility of obtaining the appropriate number of votes not in the council, but through the meeting

of the un general assembly, this is precisely a very problematic issue, and without any guarantee or, for example, realistic achievement of a positive result regarding the number of appropriate votes during the voting in gendsa weapon, such an issue is unlikely to be the people. therefore, this is a question about creating, let's say such a parallel instrument in terms of mandate what is the international criminal court instead, we should now say that it can be a regional instrument at the european level, it is approved by its, for example, powers confirmed at the level of authority e-e through such organizations as the european union as e-e supporters of the

kupa and accordingly given the corresponding mandate. ukrainian helsinki union for human rights we have 10 minutes left before the news to talk about the security and military situation in our country ivan stupak former employee security service of ukraine, expert of the ukrainian institute of the future, welcome, mr. ivan, with antin's permission, i will ask the first question, which will be related, even i want to say hello, be in time for the question . now we are talking about cherkasy, volyn and kherson regions, uh, a whole series of objects, this men's monastery, as i see now, and churches the cathedral in the city of cherkasy, for example,

well, more than a dozen such objects of religious purpose are now under the cover of the security service of ukraine, the sbu's operation continues through these institutions. but what do we have now in the context of intermediate results ? ukraine has issued many leaflets, many propaganda materials, and there are unknown persons there without passports issued by pilgrims, they live here, well, we need to find out who this person is, what kind of pilgrims they are, do they have them ? relations with the russian federation, that is, the accumulation of primary materials is underway in order to be able to later and in a certain perspective there are so many fire adjusters, propaganda of

english literature and such a resume. are there grounds for covering up this bench of the russian patriarchy and they will decide? i think there will be grounds, there are grounds and information about the movement money, not only this, is generally not taxed to the church, how much money, where did they spend large amounts of money, what movable and immovable property did they buy, and how did they transfer this money to moscow? or give half as franchising, well , on the other hand, ivan, we understand that it is strange not to find some or other parishioners in the monastery , because it is not a strange practice in general, we understand that propaganda literature does not mean fixing the fact. conducting propaganda, that is, not so to speak, this case can always be reconciled. well, the

key question is, so to speak, the people who were involved in the protection of certain powerful figures of the russian church in ukraine . but well, the investigation should go in different directions and the financial instruments, what are the valuables purchased, where was the investment, this is very important and counter-intelligence work, what kind of people were they in contact with, who came, you must understand that if you left otaki's active investigative actions are already on the surface, which means that it was carried out in any iceberg. yes , what is not visible under the water of secret work is the whole set of measures provided for by the criminal procedure code, and wiretapping of phones and surveillance of sedges and sedges and technical penetration of

premises that is, i think there is already so much material accumulated there that when the state leadership will show yes what is there and here and the money is here, the people who helped there and the guards who were possible and it was planned to involve them during the creation of the russian federation so that they are there guarded somewhere, yes, or strengthened subversive russian intelligence groups. i think there will be enough grounds for a decision to be made in the first cabinet of the united states. we will close this bench and goodbye. well, as they say, let’s wait and see. there is also news that, you know, won’t let us go for a couple of days. russian airfields where they station strategic aviation well, and accordingly knowing mr. ivan that you monitor so in particular hostile attitudes , in fact, in your opinion, what kind of feedback did it have among the russian generals and the highest criminal of the leadership of the russian federation. yes, we don't know

for sure which bpl flew there yesterday, soviet-made, or now our kulibins, so to speak, in cherkasy, organized it in one way or another, so to speak, a podvalchik, well, in any case, it flew and it flew not just anywhere , strategic aviation nuclear triad so, what are the moods prevailing among the russians, so to speak , but look, well, first of all, no one confirmed that this is ukraine, let's say some patriotic citizens decided that's how let's do this with russian planes. maybe there are some russian ones, that is, right here, well, it is not known what is unknown, but cool people. i like the cool work, and what is the nuance . watch this, it is very actively compared to this moment from matios moroz. i will remind those people who i am not familiar with this person. this is a person who, at the end of the existence of the soviet union, landed her

plane from germany directly on red square. after that, the heads of the great e-e generals, marshals of the soviet union, who directly they were responsible for anti-aircraft defense, yes, why didn’t they shoot down, it was necessary to shoot down, and here it was the collapse of the soviet union, and by the way, there was an episode with boeing. and the south korean one, which was the same story. what are the russians doing? people must be relocated from all military airports in the radius 10 km, it is simply necessary to forcibly introduce the spouses of the army officers, who will constantly make rounds to check all the buildings that are in pain, some are located in the radius there, that is, 5-6-7 km from the airports constantly to hear, that is, they really have it. otaka, this is the hysteria that something should be done and not just wait, but the russian generals decided. well,

let's move these planes somewhere far away, first of all, it was a blow, maybe not as much as the material base itself, and then it was also damaged it didn't take off, it flew to the strategic airfield, something crashed, it killed the ground personnel. and the question: where were the s-s400, yes, there were some tanks, and they were all on the ukrainian front, and here is the question : what should be removed from the ukrainian front? partly to take them after all for the protection of russian airfields, that is, there are a lot of questions and very few answers. that's how i put it, there are a lot of questions, and in addition, how and who exactly can be responsible for the relevant problems of the strategic aviation of the russian federation . in some places, the states are even beginning to justify themselves in the context of the fact that they did not provide ukraine with weapons capable of carrying out strikes on the territory of russia and did not encourage kyiv to take such actions

, the state department reported at the same time as the head of the pentagon lloyd austin declares that the usa does not prevent ukraine from developing its own long-range strike potential , but in the context of these two, let's say, tpps, which in principle do not contradict each other . we didn't ban them, we don't encourage them. but at the same time, we don't ban what they want and do, and this is a thesis for there, well, not for an internal user, for an external one, for russians, and in recent days there was this thesis, yes publications appear in the washington post that hymar is exactly like that, let the mars be reflashed before going to ukraine so that the ukrainians could not use them for long-range combat.

so this is a game, i regard it as a game and primarily for russians. the russians are listening. we ukrainians did not transmit anything so long-range . they are watching if the russians will react. that is, it is such a cynical game, uh, and it works in principle, the russians have nothing to answer. well, what will they say, it’s all the americans. no, it’s an unknown technique, it’s obvious that it ’s a western production, in fact, it’s a game we don’t have there , we play well for the proposed rules are great. thank you and you. stupak, a former employee of the security service of ukraine, an expert of the ukrainian institute of the future, joined our broadcast . reactions lord what am i saying the sign of the informational electrical editorial office to the editorial office of news information