that is, is he under arrest or in prison of the russian occupiers, yes, there is such information, mr. roman, there are a few more such nuances of questions in the kherson region, can the enemy now pull his forces from the occupied crimea or is he deprived of this opportunity? i think that they have other there is nothing going on from crimea, including the military, military and equipment, but the actions of our military and their location indicate that we are beginning to control, let’s say, these processes of the enemy’s movement, and i am confident in because it is under the clear fire control of our armed forces and there is already information that in some regions of the region the russian troops lack weapons and ammunition, so let's hope

that the situation in them will be critical, well, in any case - in any case, we are talking about the nearest period, on the other hand, we understand that the filtering measures on the right bank are continuing, so to speak settlement office that opened its branch in the occupied territories of the south. how are the filtering measures going? what are the catches and in general what are the dynamics of the process? those detentions that they officially report are

only the tip of the iceberg. i think that there is a lot of shield information that cannot be made public or is simply not made public enough. unfortunately there were collaborators, those who escaped to the russian federation and into the controlled territory were able to disperse and want to infiltrate, but the special services are working, and i think that this is a process that will not last a day or a month, and there will be a lot more information about these or that, including officials who interacted with the occupiers and helped them directly in the process of both the occupation and the occupation actions on the territory of the kherson region, mr. roman, for a long time we talked about the deportation of our ukrainian the population in the territory of the kherson region in the territory of the admissibly occupied crimea and even

the russian federation directly in the late summer and early autumn there was talk of children whose parents were persuaded to leave and then the parents lost access to these children, do you know something about development and, in general, about fate, because we are talking about several hundred children. as i understand the current number of children, i am not ready to speak now, but literally yesterday i had a conversation about this, well, this is one of the structures that volunteer for charity they help, including in situations with children, and we were just talking about finding these children and helping to take them from the occupied territory of crimea , that is, such cases, well, these are clearly facts, the problem of parents taking these children away is clearly a fact. and now, even centrally, there are already individual people and

separate structures of the organization deal with this issue in order to help the parents, er, take those children. well, that is a matter of that plan, so that would be correct. but the safety of taking children away is a very important question of some kind of grave that is being cared for today, that's how they did it, well, finally, i would like to ask you in the hall about the prospects of rebuilding the critically needed infrastructure in the near future, we understand that soon we will drive the enemy away and on the left bank , we don't know where they will roll back but the processes are parallel, so to speak, because raising kherson to the appropriate level despite the shelling, what is the problem?

we will repel the enemy, of course, when the enemy is there, the city will not be accessible to the enemy during artillery fire, he will be driven back to a sufficient distance, then we can talk about the systematic restoration of one or another infrastructure or the entire infrastructure in general, this is the first, the second, as of today, when the city is regularly shelled the main task is to at least deal with the problems that arise after the shelling or that were created by the occupiers during the retreat before retreating from the city of kherson. residential development of infrastructural facilities is suffering. so the same aspect needs attention and direct, let's say, some kind of quick response there, repairs or just at least patching up and closing the house in the apartment so that it is possible

to live there for the residents or at least leave the apartment somewhere after the residents return there and these are the main problems that currently exist in the city . the most important khrystyna yatskiv borkovskyi joins our conversation alisa sysoeva, journalist, deputy of the zaporozhye district council mrs. alisa, we congratulate you glory to ukraine congratulations to the heroes , glory to the heroes again zaporizhzhia is suffering from enemy shelling, this time from drones and s300 systems from the occupied territories, tell us about the consequences of this attack and how it is possible that the enemy's tactics are changing well, unfortunately, in this case, the enemy's tactics

remain unchanged. that they have the same situation, we are told by our military in the zaporizhia direction , they are shelling, they are shelling the positions, as well as everything they have . unfortunately, today we also had a terrorist act from russia, two villages in the zaporizhia district were shelled today, and there are three victims, among them a child a 15-year-old girl. fortunately, there are no casualties, but the destruction is here. as you can see in the video, the houses are damaged and the systems in them are now damaged. this is the gas supply, water supply, of course. zaporizhzhia district, this is 17 communities that are under constant shelling, and today they gave such a figure to the military administration that, as of today,

almost 2,300 buildings have already been destroyed in the zaporizhzhia region, that is, 2,300 people will be destroyed. they are the only ones left of these damaged houses . what can we expect from today? pity the enemy, he continues to introduce the same tactics every day, every day they attack the zaporizhia region, that is, a day when there is no shelling is, unfortunately, rather an exception from the entire mass terrorist attacks on our region, the number of residential buildings destroyed by russian interventionists. well, accordingly, what is the situation with the resettlement of people, whether they remain in zaporizhzhia or are they taken to other regions of ukraine, and in general, what is the situation with the city infrastructure? we understand that the enemy is targeting civilian objects in the whole country, but we see that he keeps zaporizhzhia, so to speak, under a particularly vile crosshair, unfortunately, that's what the city

programs say if people's windows fly out. and i know that you can apply for help and give people plywood also restores the infrastructure as for high-rise buildings. and as for such a private sector. well, you see, it depends. unfortunately, it depends on the scale of the destruction, so very often people are left without housing. well, to say that now people are evacuating en masse. unfortunately, there is no such thing. well, i always say that on it is a pity that the situation is such that all those who wanted to go have already gone, even in the almost-destroyed walnut tree of the past. unfortunately, people with families and even children still live in gulyaipoli. it remains to live under shelling, some may have nowhere to go, but there is no such large-scale program of growth with permanent residence

. unfortunately, there are no such shelters where people can survive for a while when there is a massive rocket attack on residential buildings, people were displaced from their children's schools, but as for the further restoration of housing. well, this already applies to some state programs. yes, you know that people there fill out applications, but when exactly it will be restored. well , unfortunately, it is unknown, ms. alisa, i know that zaporizhzhya the region can create a precedent that is very important for our country. when we talk about the gulyaipole -orikhov triangle. and these families refuse to evacuate even though there are no livable languages ​​left there and this actually endangers the lives of their children when we spoke the last time representatives of the local government

of the orihiv community, they noted that they would collect information on these families and maybe uh well, i don't know what to call it, but it is possible to turn to the relevant authorities with the initiative of somehow changing our family code, which in accordance with the state of war, so military of the state and its challenges, what do we know about children in zaporizhzhia region on the front line, in fact, they said everything correctly, indeed, families with children live there, and all the time, representatives of local self-government call on people to leave the occupied territories. i apologize from territory well, and purchased also from the territory where there is constant shelling, but we are a democratic country, so of course you can’t forcibly withdraw such a thing, but always when the authorities and deputies and volunteers turn to those people, they always say that

uh, being under regular shelling and i i want to remind you that orichov and gulyaipole are shelled every day, the number of shelling there is several dozen per day, and that people endanger not only themselves and their children, but also volunteers who bring food as well as people who have to restore already damaged social networks in order to be damaged in order to be there at least as much as a way of life actual responsibility, but unfortunately people really stay there and our people, our volunteers, of course they cannot not go there and not help them, this is how we have a difficult situation in this case, so to speak, i would ask your a civilian comment on the situation at the front in general

on how do you assess what information reaches you, we understand that the front is not only about battles and we understand that the enemy may be concentrating with the goal or with an effort, so to speak, in quotation marks, to level the front line, what is the situation in the zaporozhye region this is how the military informs us that the shelling really continues along the entire front line, that in the occupied territories they are preparing for defense, they are forcing the local population to build all kinds of buildings. and as a civilian a person who lives in this front-line city, i will say that, unfortunately, there are no changes at the front, they are not felt as there were shellings, so they continue, as there were these destructions, so they continue but of course and we also receive

good news. over the last week, there have been more of us they inform us more about the fact that they are destroying luggage for russians and there are more and more liquidated russian soldiers, we are told that in the occupied territories almost all hospitals have already been converted into hospitals, that is, they are full with them the russian military and of course every person who lives in such conditions, these news give hope that it is very soon, that victory is closer, that it is getting closer and that in the end we will expel those russian invaders from our land ms. alisa, by the way, about the liquidation of of the manuals of the occupiers, the collaborator mykola volyk seems

to have been picked up in melitopol just the other day. specifically, volika, they really say that this is his close acquaintance, that this is his friend, almost there . well, this person was also a deputy of the melitopol district council, she, as expected, crossed over to the side of the collaborators. as for him, regarding his liquidation, well, there are various rumors, the peace of melitopol will let us know most likely, now the occupiers are liquidating their own comrades because they are not doing well there, but we understand that there is a very powerful partisan movement in the occupied territories, literally those days yesterday ukrainian flags were also hung again, these are the so -called activists, activists of the yellow ribbon movement, they are pouring paint over the monuments, who are trying to

create again, that is, the fate of the collaborators is not sweet, and we have great news from there almost every week, and what concerns this particular collaborator regarding the state of health at the moment there is no information, and they continue to keep this information in some secret, but i think this is a wake -up call for all the occupiers’ followers that if not from the partisans, then from their own they receive but there was no normal life for these traitors there in any case. well, we understand how much they brutalize. this is how we received information from the liberated territories of the kharkiv region from the kherson region. what is the situation in the temporarily occupied territories of the zaporizhzhia region? in fact, the situation here does not change for people who support ukraine and who do not want to cooperate with the occupiers , it is also very scary to be there, they also

kidnap people, and some people who were also kidnapped and taken to the basement in february, there are some people whose fate is still unknown , kidnappings continue. and the mayor told us about some very terrible incident at the vasyliv checkpoint that a woman delivered first saw how the occupiers took her child and his friend somewhere, held them on their knees and well, somehow the building, then she heard automatic rounds well, they continue to give nightmares to the local population because, in principle, the picture they report on their propaganda channels does not come true, people do not want to cooperate with the occupiers there, the partisan movement and every the initiative that they want to push through their propaganda channels. it will definitely be supported, let's say, by our opposition forces,

that is, if they open a monument, it will be covered with paint, if she says that people are going to russian rallies, there will definitely be a ukrainian flag there is opposition and it continues even though in those cities it is dangerous for life, not only for health but also for life, a great real atrocity very briefly, finally in zaporizhzhia in the regional center several enterprises that were alienated into the ownership of the state due to military necessity are concentrated here, it is very important to understand that a large number of a-a residents of zaporizhzhia work at these enterprises, are these people currently provided with work, are the enterprises themselves working, or is there still some critical situation in connection i am connected with this well, as far as i know the information of the companies working there, only the management changes

. perhaps you understand whether the residents of zaporizhzhia have a job that many of them have been doing for a long time and whether they will keep it at night. i think that it will be known, but for now there are some changes . on the live broadcast of our telethon alisa osoeva, journalist , deputy of the zaporizhzhia district council. triple resignation of three judges of the constitutional court, the quorum seems to be beating, but still, the question is extremely not simple. oleksandr slava ukraine how do you hear us, good afternoon, as if it is normal, we would like to ask you what information is circulating

around the resignation of three judges of the constitutional court. well, look, in principle, such a decision could to be adopted because for such a decision it is necessary that a third voted for it, that is, accordingly, it is obvious that there was fodder. another question is if it is a political issue, well, i am not ready here comment i mean in what sense? the fact is that in two of the three courts, their term of office, which is defined by the constitution of ukraine for 9 years, ended in march next year. in fact, they did not complete their work for three months, but the fact is that they and the judge upon their resignation, the status of judges of the constitutional court is preserved because they had a sufficient term of office in the respective positions of judges of the constitutional court, and now , accordingly, the verkhovna rada must appoint

three new judges because they were appointed for quotas by the verkhovna rada of ukraine, as far as i remember and as far as i looked. well, it's just a non-trivial situation. if their term ends in march next year, they could still work for another 3.5 months. similarly , what they submitted their resignation on their own, at least this information is submitted on the one hand if it is a non-trivial situation you can say so and on the other hand settings examples such precedents they had absolutely understand it in fact, it does not change anything in essence, i said that there were obviously some nuances, but i will not comment here instead of them, let them explain why they are such participles, then every year since the 20th, it is now on the 22nd, i passed it since the 20th there were difficult relations with various authorities. yes, it concerned

various issues and it was obvious that there was a certain tension. well, it is possible that in order to relieve such tension, the judges themselves decided to write a statement, and accordingly, the constitutional court itself and their statements were accepted and voted by 12 judges well and in fact, if we talk about the constitutional court, we understand that it is one of the key institutions about its independence, they talk about the need and independence is talked about not only in ukraine, but outside its borders, we understand how difficult relations were, so to speak, with different courts in different of our own , respectively, here it is it's a strange story, well, the main point is how active the constitutional court can be during martial law.

we understand that in these conditions laws are not adopted as perfectly from the point of view of even the procedure as they were supposed to be adopted er, this means that obviously the body of constitutional control must somehow balance the conflict that sometimes arises within the borders of the parliament and check on the subject, including constitutionality and here, you know, you can mention well, for example, the history of the united states of america when the supreme court and the supreme court of the united states of america essentially perform the same functions and that we have the constitutional court of ukraine and in the conditions of the war, he was such a balancing lever in the relations between the president and the senate, for example, that is why i wanted it to really be preserved as an independent branch of government to the extent that it can be independent if this appointment is carried out directly by the verkhovna rada of ukraine in these conditions, so that it seems to me that everyone is himself

can give an answer for himself well, we understand, taking into account the difficult, i would say, experience of the last years of selection for vacancies and sometimes not quite vacant positions for a constitutional judge yes a judge of the constitutional court how do you see this selection, oleksandr, three chairs will have to be filled with really cool specialists, respectively. they need to be determined and hold some kind of competition. is there any hope that this will happen. purely and transparently, i would like such a hope to be the second moment, well, you know how the most correct option should have been a competition already carried out by the commission, when the verkhovna rada actually simply duplicates the decision

made by this competitive independent commission under such conditions. criteria and whether these criteria will be suitable for someone , for example, to some extent, whether formally or not formally. well, then what are we going to talk about as an option, by the way, to balance the appointment? well, maybe there should be some kind of quota principle. it is meant how many of these three courts are linguistically owned by the vyshyvans from the opposition. this is an extremely important point, and in general, what concerns the composition of the current composition of the constitutional court, we understand that a significant part of those courts appeared that during the previous political period, so to speak, now other people will be selected and they will be appointed as the current composition of the verkhovna rada, and there is also the question of the

quorum, so to speak, at the moment we have 13 13 active judges, yes, twelve, yes, and for a quorum, we need 13, we understand that well, there are still some unforeseen circumstances, the judge may get sick and so on. and so on, god forbid, of course, god bless them all with health, but even then, there can be such a situation. for example, the law on the purification of power there was referred to the constitutional court for consideration . of such key laws, in the end, you will decide whether they are constitutional or not, what is this ? we did not have a stalemate situation. i do not like this stalemate

situation, and there was a period not far away, literally a few years ago, when the court did not make a single decision for a year, for example, well, that is it. er with the periodicity of such a situation is another matter that this is really the first abnormal and really, look at us for a reason, the constitution provides that a single court is appointed for 9 years, you absolutely correctly said that uh, considering that the president and parliament are appointed for five years this was done so that there was indeed a balance , the assistance of the constitutional court in making decisions, the adoption of laws, well, not only laws, well, let us first of all have laws if we are talking about whom the termination is taking place powers, and the powers of both the president and the parliament, well, under these conditions, they will most likely continue, and whether it is martial law, of

course, this can lead to an imbalance, and to what extent it will lead to the president. well, let's see who will be appointed to this vacancy , those decisions will be admitted to the actual constitutional court, we can roughly guess that they will, so to speak, appoint excellent specialists in their field to these positions. yes, but maybe acting people's deputies, for example, because recently this has been an established practice in general, a deputy in the position of a judge of the constitutional court. how do you feel about this, mr. oleksandr ? there should formally be a requirement that would protect against certain political sympathies. i also mean that at the level of legislation, it could be written in detail regarding the fact that,

for example, a person must not be a member of a political party, a people's deputy, must not have been in local self-government bodies, for example , during the last 5 years there for another period of time before the time when she was appointed, well, that is, it would be possible to act in this way in principle, but do you understand what the nuance is in fact? and unfortunately, in the world, the same is true of appointments to the positions of the supreme court of the united states of america or to the positions of constitutional courts within the framework of european constitutional courts. well, this political aspect is a vivid expression of oleksandr novy, we simply remember what the situation was in neighboring poland when the authorities tried in every possible way to push the constitutional court from poland and the entire european community then became indignant and this don't joke the constitutional court - this is an extremely important body that regulates not just the relations between

the government and society and the interpretation of certain laws. and which is normative in its approach, i.e. the decision of the constitutional court is the final point to a certain extent. am i wrong to a certain extent? yes, but according to with the law on the constitutional court in the following principle. well, there are ambiguous provisions, but it is allowed to review decisions by the constitutional court itself, that is, the so-called dynamic interpretation is applied decisions of the constitutional court but in general yes, i'm with you as you like, i too would like the procedure for the appointment of judges of the constitutional court to be as transparent as possible thank you very interesting topic, thank you for this professional analysis oleksandr moskalyuk, a political scientist who also specializes in certain types of jurisprudence, we will now move on to the floor they will inform our new members what has happened in ukraine and the world in the last hour iryna koval