bags between the authorities in society and the interpretation of certain laws and which is normative in its approach, i.e. the decision of the constitutional court is the final point to a certain extent am i wrong to a certain extent yes, but according to the law on the constitutional court in the following principle well, there are ambiguous provisions, but it is allowed to list the decisions of the constitutional court itself, that is, the so-called dynamic interpretation of the decisions of the constitutional court is applied to the post of article in the constitutional court thank you, you are extremely interesting topic, thank you for this professional analysis oleksandr moskalyuk, a political scientist who also specializes in certain types of jurisprudence, we will now turn the floor over to our journalists, they will inform us what has happened in ukraine and the world in the last hour, iryna koval is already on our screens, colleague

, thank you for the word, colleagues, literally in a moment i will tell you about the situation in different regions of our country. so please wait in ukraine at six o'clock news time on the espresso tv channel in the studio of iryna kovaliy, i will start our episode with the situation on donetsk region at least three residents were injured as a result of the shelling of yampol, the russians attacked the central square of the village at this time, people were receiving humanitarian aid there, said the head of the regional military administration, pavlo kyrylenko, in addition, the administrative building and 7 more residential buildings were damaged, and the russians shelled kurakhov in donetsk region, there were casualties and wounded reported to the head of the rakhiv community, roman padun, more information is being found out. meanwhile, the

national guardsmen shot down a cruise missile from small arms, as reported in the northern operational-tactical unit of the national guard, during the last massive missile attack by russia, mobile fire group 27 of the pechersk brigade shot down a cruise missile kha1, the missile was flying at a low altitude, it was managed to hit it with large-caliber machine guns and fire from automatic weapons, it is noted that in the national guard has created calculations for countering airstrikes, in particular for shooting down missiles and kamikaze drones, together with air defense, they are already demonstrating their effective work, a miracle, unfortunately, not a boy who was searched for in the kharkiv region was found dead, the child drowned in the lake, they told the regional police herman shcherbina disappeared in the village of krutoyarivka on december 5. earlier,

more than 400 security forces were involved in the search for him. during three days, they were helped by rescuers and volunteers. the dead were only seven years old. russian agents in the abbot of the temple of the ukrainian orthodox church of the moscow patriarchate in lysychansk was sentenced to 12 years in prison, the man passed on information about the proposals of the ukrainians to the occupiers defenders in the north donetsk region, in particular, he reported on the number of soldiers and equipment, in addition, the priest told the aggressor about local people who could resist the occupation, law enforcement officers detained him in april this year during a special operation , the special security service was informed, the sbu also exposed another priest of the moscow patriarchate in luhansk region, he turned himself in to the russians locations of members of the resistance movement, it was based on his information that the

occupiers kidnapped two ukrainian patriots the priest is hiding in the temporarily occupied territory, our diplomats have been receiving anonymous threats for a week now, ukrainian embassies and consulates are operating under heightened security measures, noted foreign minister dmytro kuleba, according to him. over the past two days , suspicious packages have arrived at the embassies in italy , poland, portugal, romania, and denmark, as well as the consulates in gdańsk in general 31 cases are known in 15 countries of the world, the campaign of terror against ukrainian diplomats is unprecedented in its scale, not only in the context of ukraine, but and at the global level, kuleb emphasized, 441 cases of violent death of civilians in ukraine were documented by the monitoring mission of

the un high commissioner for human rights. this is the period from february 24 to april 6. could be due to the element of camouflage clothing or previous experience of military service, the office of the un high commissioner for human rights notes that the real numbers most likely much higher, since the work to confirm another 198 murders is ongoing, i will remind the un high commissioner for human rights, volker turk, spent four days in ukraine, he was in charge, he visited the liberation of the territory, in particular, bucha and raisin. meanwhile, four more ships left the harbor of greater odesa, they number more than 149,000 tons of agricultural products

for asia and europe, including bulk with more than 37,000 tons of oil for india, the ministry of infrastructure said at the same time that 20 dry cargoes are being processed in our ports, and three more are already are moving along the grain corridor to ukraine, they plan to load more than 162,000 tons of food on them, the holiday in their own apartments in the capital , they repaired a house on chornobylska street that was damaged by a russian missile, an enemy projectile hit the 16th floor in march , two people died there, half of the apartments burned down completely, however the inspection of the technical condition showed that the house can be restored in a multi-storey building, the facade was insulated, new windows were installed, the partitions were replaced, the elevators, the roof and

the entrance were repaired, the precast reinforced concrete was reinforced elements have been installed with new electrical and plumbing networks, workers are completing social repairs in apartments, mayor vitaliy klitschko said, so in a few days residents will be able to return to their homes, pea soup, pasta with meat and sweet tea, such comprehensive lunches have begun to be distributed in kharkiv for free, the menu is constantly changing and already almost 40 such points have been opened on the initiative of maria here and they cook and distribute immediately, they work every day, everyone willing comes with their dishes and often takes immediately for themselves and for neighbors, in these queues you can meet not only lonely elderly people and often those who have lost their jobs due to the war, in a day all points together can feed more than 15,000 kharkiv residents chuk

who will enter the third day comes thank you very good very very simple well how to help people oh, if grandma, god, there is no one, and she asked for someone everywhere, help came from the rear. the other day, berdychiv businessmen and restaurateurs united to hold a charity fair. the proceeds will be directed to a generator for the military. what treated the townspeople . our correspondents will tell us how much we managed to collect. before the war, svitlana was a housewife, and with the beginning of the full-scale invasion, the woman helped the ukrainian defenders. on the first day, i did everything at home, baked bread , pies, baked everything, and gave the boy to the teroboron, and

when i received a question whether i could join the of this event yes, i joined borscht i made jelly i made blood pudding i baked pies how long did everything take all day yesterday sausages buckwheat dumplings jello baked goods no one takes money in advance for sale. here, people choose what they want to taste and put bills in boxes right there on barbecues and in cauldrons, borscht is prepared. kulish and meat. they prepared themselves dumplings with different fillings, then we have armenian cabbage rolls, since we have more german cuisine, we have meat on the grill, the menu, that is, shish kebab, lyula-kebab, mackerel with a grill, the initiator of the event,

a local restaurateur, before the war, says her woman the restaurant was working now, not because of her business, only a shop in the village is open, but i am convinced that it does not interfere with helping the military, you know, if i were younger, i would cook food there for the boys on the front line today, because of that, today we cook here and treat those who take part in helping our armed forces the idea of ​​the charity fair is not just to put boxes and announce a collection for the army, together with like-minded people, they wanted to organize a gastronomic cultural event for people, the boys are freezing today, the day before, how do they cook food on bones, that's how we cook today. we want people to feel that atmosphere in the cold, without light, without heat , our boys are fighting, they are protecting our rear with you

, that's how we worry today and want to be comrades in this work of ours. at the photo exhibition , the consequences of the war in ukraine were shown . joined the fair to support the military, for us not to intimidate with any blackouts or shelling, in spite of everything we will unite and we will be together we will go out on the square we will collect donations for the armed forces and to help our armed forces and displaced persons and residents of the occupied territories, such measures give an opportunity for a wider public to join a good and noble cause. lieutenant of the brigade for the eurasia division, funds from the berdychivlians . now, during the total war of destruction waged by the russian federation against us, this is the best such reason to meet

and gather to support our army and in general to see each other not just to celebrate while there is blood on the fronts, but to really do it with some benefit for our army and for the people as a whole, now he and his brothers lack a diesel generator for military personnel , in total, they collected almost one hundred thousand hryvnias from zhytomyr oblast yuliya synelnikova vitaly sinelnikov tv channel espresso and not encouraging news just arrived in donetsk region, six people were killed and five more injured, these are the consequences of the massive russian shelling of kurakhovo, the chairman reported of the regional military administration, pavlo kyrilenko , according to him, the russian invaders struck in the middle of the city, the market, the gas station, and residential buildings came under fire. at the same time, the president's office reported eight dead people , the lights on the border were norwegian partners, they handed over

powerful generators to the ukrainian border guards, from now on, the military personnel will perform their tasks as best as possible and despite russia's energy terror , in particular, they will be able to counter the illegal movement of radioactive materials chemical bacteriological or nuclear threat and for now, this was all the news for this time, wait for the updated issue in less than an hour, namely at 17:00, and you can read more on our espresso tv website, a summary of the main ones on the espresso tv telegram channel and on youtube my colleagues khrystyna yatskiv and antin borkovskiy continue the broadcast of the espresso tv channel. let's see how people

suffering from rheumatism and arthrosis live. it changes , yes. i applied dolgit in the morning. now let the dolgit cream relieve pain, reduce swelling and improve the mobility of the joints because the joints are already breaking the only yellow cream for pain in the joints and back, ask at pharmacies dobrogo dnya pharmacy and one social pharmacy dolgyt cream 100 grams with a 20% discount. this is happening, only two national teams will meet on the fields of keter to find a new winner. watch all 64 matches of the world cup live on the megogo media service. the war in ukraine is the main topic for ukrainians. programs people what

have information and shape public opinion , people who defend ukraine and create the future, the main and interesting thing in the program is the verdict of serhiy rudenko monday through thursday at 5:10 p.m. repeat at 9:30 p.m. watch this week's program collaborators miklushka list of hundreds of traitors from all over the country for what to sell exchanged the motherland was headed by the occupation administration and what punishment do the lackeys of the kremlin receive on ukrainian soil, watch every wednesday at 4:45 p.m. marathon of the espresso tv channel in the midst of many events,

in particular, this also applies to the domestic political situation in our country, today three judges of the constitutional court wrote statements of resignation, of course, of their own volition, the story is extremely serious, but much more has happened than this, without a doubt, memorable event khrystyna yatskiv and at this hour from we are oleg synyutka, people's deputy of ukraine. we congratulate oleg. glory to ukraine. glory to the heroes. congratulations to the viewers. espresso . the communications department of maryan gaiovsky literally direct speech on wednesday a special plenary meeting of the judges of the constitutional court was held at which the issue of the resignation of three judges was considered based on the statements submitted by them, as a result of the meeting, the judges supported the resignation of judges sdelenko sas and zavhorodny thus, according to ms. gaiovsky, in the constitutional court now 13 judges are needed for a quorum on the 12th

people's deputy oleg synyutka, respectively, we would like to ask you your vision of the story with such and such triplex, yes, the resignation of three judges of the constitutional court in any country itself caused a great discussion, well, very much so. in my opinion, it is a significant event and a very dangerous event, because exactly all the thoughts of ukrainians are drawn to the war, and ukrainians now, i am convinced, do not respect the constitutional court, the supreme court, the anti-corruption court because somewhere it seems far away and somewhere it seems not at all important and for sure ukrainians believe that it will not affect the situation at the front and the war is the main thing that occupies the minds of every ukrainian today and in the end it is normal but i would so simply did not relate to this event because the history of the constitutional court is the history of

probably all three years of zelenskyi's presidency, we have already seen such a very rapid attack on the constitutional court and then the constitutional court as a guarantor of compliance with the law in ukraine constitutional court how such a source of stability, which is a certain balancing factor between the government and society. unfortunately , today i am convinced that i am under attack again because last week there were events in which i i see that the mass media did not pay attention and the ukrainians definitely did not pay attention, and this was an attempt in the ukrainian parliament to rotate or change the legislation that related to the constitutional court under the so-called accelerated procedure to submit three amendments and let's quickly vote on all of this and the parliament refused it to do because, despite all the flaws

of the ukrainian parliament of this convocation, common sense and the desire to at least somehow comply with the current legislation, even in the conditions of war, is beginning to dominate and precisely because of a week we see, you know how all the sayings are, we don't wash , we roll, anyway, the government is trying to achieve, and i am convinced that this is exactly how the judges of the constitutional court are resigning, i don't know if this is the same story that happened with the head of the audit chamber, do you remember that the head of the audit chamber is resigning and a very quick process of dismissal of the attempt to dismiss the head of the accounting chamber, and again last week it happened well, in my opinion, according to hitherto unseen facts, because the head of the accounting chamber was not allowed to hall of the verkhovna rada in order for him to report to the deputies and again to the parliament, no matter how limping he is today, the deputies

refused without such an obvious violation, as in my opinion, to dismiss the head of the accounting chamber, and it seems that against the background of the war, against the background that ukrainians today all their efforts are thrown in order to ensure victory over the muscovites and where is another shadow process and this is the new process called the usurpation of power and we must do everything possible today so that victory is not just ukraine won not just a blue-yellow ukraine and the ukrainian nation, but a democratic ukraine won, why is it important that insults are also important, the constitutional court is one of the guarantors of the ukratism of development, so because it is not only about the legislation, it is also about the interpretation of the legislation, it is the interpretation of the powers of the authorities and so on. and yes next in the event of something, where will this or that bill be taken, which raises

questions, so to speak, in the direction of different readings to the constitutional court, ukrainians are ready to vote today in action in the elections, i think not. and if the constitutional court yes, since it is legal, how can electronic voting be then? yes, of course. tell me, please, ukrainians today are ready to think about elections under martial law, i think not. and if the constitutional court gives such an explanation, and in fact it is a very, very dangerous process for a democratic ukraine, because only a democratic, democratic ukraine can become a member of the european union and nato, and we must always remember that, and it belongs. what do you think could have motivated the three judges to submit their resignations this means that there is pressure inside the constitutional court, the relevant forces are putting pressure on the judges in order to vacate the respective seats. well, please tell me, the judges do not like working with the judges of the constitutional court. moreover, there are three or four

months left for the end of their term of office, i think that when they will be about this is talking, and sooner or later everything secret becomes obvious, we will hear enough interesting details, i have a small insider, yes. so, judge sdelenko was just a judge-rapporteur on lustration and he left like this the case is being considered in a closed part, that is, in the part where the decision is to be made, since sdelenko has left, now his cases will be distributed among other judges and everything may drag on a little. well, here is the question . er, so to speak, not very much , but that’s just khrystyna, thank you for such firmness and clarity, but let’s look at the composition of today’s representatives of the government, in particular, the office of the president, some of them were just accused of giving what

according to the law on illustration, they should not have the opportunity to participate in the work of the authorities, and they participate in such a way, that's why i think that this is already a very dangerous signal. our euro-atlantic partners so because well, they are watching it extremely carefully, but the judges wrote a statement themselves, so to speak, according to what our euro-atlantic partners will say. well, you see , it was such a decision, we must always remember that in europe, in the euro-atlantic, values ​​dominate regardless of what your surname is, regardless of who you were and who you want to become, if you correspond to these values, then this society means that this person has the right to life, and today the worst thing that can happen in ukraine is this

punishment of these values ​​that the european euro-atlantic space lives by. well, let's hope that the existing composition of the constitutional court will cope despite the fact that three of the judges were personnel. well, i think that some important let's put it this way, the projects. i think that these versions that were already heard today during our discussion, this is a question of interpretation of the elections, this is a question of interpretation of the illustration, they are mostly those that are on the surface and that are discussed in the slums of ukrainian politics, well, in any case, we understand it this way let's move on to another topic, but which will also be directly related to the same constitutional court, three draft laws have already been registered in the verkhovna rada regarding the future

fate of the uoc mp or, as they say, the russian the orthodox church in ukraine, well, this is a question of wording. well, we understand accordingly that the order to our cabinet to write the fourth draft law, yes, and the constitutional court would be very useful here too, in the event of something, if questions arise within the walls of the constitutional court today about an action with a demand unlock the law on renaming at least the church of the moscow patriarchate e-e contact us lyudmila filipovych doctor of philosophy professor vice-president of the ukrainian association connoisseurs of religion mrs. lyudmila, we congratulate you glory to ukraine good day thank you for the word yes er-e longer time er-e ukraine thought in what way let’s say yes er- yet still align where it will be appropriate the ukrainian orthodox church of the moscow patriarchate a-a in conditions when for example, some

of the priests of this church could be collaborators with the gunners. and it seems that the first verdicts on this matter could help the further development of the whole situation. today it became known that a priest of the ukrainian orthodox church of moscow was sentenced to 12 years behind bars. patriarchate from luhansk oblast for just informing the russian army of the proposals of ukrainian defenders, the security service of ukraine informed about it. it is about a priest from the church in lysychansk in mid-april 22. he collected and transmitted to the russians information about the number, deployment of equipment and weapons of the armed forces of ukraine in severodonetsk and nearby settlements of mrs. lyudmila, could this be the starting point for banning the ukrainian orthodox church of the moscow patriarchate? i think that he was tried not because he a priest, and not because he is a priest of the ukrainian

orthodox church, but because he, as a citizen of ukraine, betrayed his motherland, and i want to emphasize precisely on this point that for some reason it is believed that in our country people are persecuted for their faith and follow unbelief, while at the same time neglecting to fulfill their civic duties our duties are our civic duties, what is written to love our homeland, everyone to build it and so on. and what you see now is that these events will be treated as persecution for believing that we do not have freedom of conscience, that we have people are being discriminated against because they are members of the ukrainian orthodox church. i believe that this is absolutely wrong and it is necessary to explain to people that they are not judged for their faith, but for the fact that people, being believers, who must fulfill the commandments of jesus christ, and by the way it is written that one must love one's neighbor , oneself and first of all one's own neighbor. this means one's

neighbor, that is, one must love ukrainians with such a duty and this call, oh people. i would not like you to say that this became the starting point. let's see what added to himself of the undesirable acuteness of the situation in our country, we understand that the parishioners or believers of the moscow orthodox church of the moscow orthodox church also know that there are many different combinations in the names of the ukrainian orthodox church of the moscow patriarchate, so to speak, could give rise to the corresponding consequences. we would like to regulate everything in to the legal field and in the field, so to speak, to an honest one so that no one is offended . you saw the ways to get out and remove the situation. well

, in principle, from a dangerous plane. we asked the question very correctly, and i think that this appeal is not only for me, what would we see as a way. to meet with representatives of the church, representatives of the state, the presence of representatives of civil society and seriously discuss this issue in which you know such radical methods that are offered today or by people who they are poorly versed in the specifics of religious life , so let's immerse everyone and send them. who will plant them? we want to repeat the experience that our state had, being part of the tota of good empires, in particular, the russian empire and the

soviet empire, and act as it was done. there 50-60 years ago, the fact that we, with our european integration intentions, want to be legal, what is contained in the essence of the ukrainian orthodox church of the moscow patriarchate, and we understand that we must move cautiously but decisively in in our studio, people's deputy of ukraine oleg senyuka registered three draft laws, the fourth one is on the way, well, at least the cabinet of ministers should work on it, mr. oleg, what ways do you see, well, first of all, this event that is happening under the constitutional court, why is the picket of the constitutional court happening, it is connected with the church because in the constitutional court considers