well, the main thing is that the enemies in the main languages. it seems to me that they really created such a good metaphor by painting on this facade on this fence, uh, these figures of russian culture, first of all, leo tolstoy and so on, these figures who cover up their crimes and you can often hear there that russian culture is so great, even the pope said about it, well, they can't read dostoyevsky and tolstoy or be really that bad, the metaphor must be remembered dostoyevsky crime punishment for 10 pages of how the same russian killed a civilian grandmother because of not repaying her debts, then a bunch of pages about how he hesitates whether he should do it or not. it seems that dostaevsky in his time described the portrait of a modern russian very well because i really have

a drama theater listed, it has been listed for about a month and a half, completely covered with these banners, an excavator is working inside there, because they have begun to dismantle the rubble little by little again, and for what reason it is quite unknown, but it is in this condition preserved for today, the chatter about the fact that they should restore it continues, but there is a very interesting thing. such a thing is a person or a contractor from st. petersburg who was supposed to restore and rebuild this drama theater. the work has really stopped. unfortunately, our drama theater has become a real monument of the russian occupation, the destruction of russian myths and russian culture, the demonstration of what it gives birth to, including in fact, what the russians think about us from the cultural side is also there, of course, on this banner is shevchenko, and it seems that the knowledge and, in principle, the recognition of ukrainian

culture is limited to that, so if someone needs to see what the russians think and what they want to do with ukraine, they should look at the dramatic the theater in the state in which it is today is always pleasant to shevchenko, it is interesting because somewhere in luhansk someone also noticed and in the photo that shevchenko is already signed as a russian writer somewhere i even found this photo now i will try to illustrate, so as not to be silent about the russian writer shevchenko. and if i don’t find it, maybe later it will float to me somewhere . they cover themselves with ukrainian writers to show that they also respect ukrainian culture. what is this? what kind of effort is this ? to appease the people of mariupol in this way, but in the same way, we see how

the kremlin's politicians hesitate in principle because they cannot admit what to do with ukraine in the end and what to stop at from the point of view of the merits that they provoked to the fact that they stopped at the fact that the ukrainian language and literature must be preserved, and the symbol of this is exclusively shevchenko or others, then it was decided that neither language nor literature can be preserved; in fact, its teaching in schools was banned, but the monuments of shevchenko monument at least in mariupol. this picture appeared before the changes were made. it seems that he is still wearing a sneaker. well, again, we understand that the knowledge of russians in principle about the history of the history of ukraine, in particular, is meant by the general public because it is limited to approximately shevchenko and what was taught in soviet times nothing would have changed for us if they knew the truth or started to understand shevchenko i think it would be this

photo again well, it is almost signed that this is a russian writer who was born and grew up in mariupol great history and great cultural heritage partially stolen now by a russian. they call him, er, a russian artist. well, someone called him, they want to know right away that we know all his best paintings there, by the way, they are in the hermitage in russian from there, i don’t know what time and that is, they were exported there decades ago, a long time ago, and this is a product of the imperial culture, of course. in their treasury, i wanted to ask you about one more mariupol resident. he is a deputy of the state duma of russia, dmitry sablin. here it turned out that dmitry sabrin, who comes from mariupol and he is a deputy of the russian state duma. he bought 11 apartments in kyiv for us. and sometimes

he is not going to mariupol to buy a home there. and he actually has enough there. that is, a significant share belongs to azov mash, it seems, still. the share that was in the state stolen for him, by the way, and his and vashchenko and all those who were in charge at that time of the mozovmazh state enterprise and who actually destroyed this enterprise, that is why mariupoli, i hope, i am sure that there is a lot that belongs to him, in fact, it is unofficial to him, he has criminal partners there is also such a petro ivanov, yes, these apartments are very interesting, we have already said that it is logical to nationalize these apartments and give them to people from mariupol who are in kyiv, not to evacuate them. they are sure that these are not apartments there khrushchevs of some sort, let's place the people of mariupol there , why, no, kyiv in three days, yes, and this sablin is

indeed the author, in fact, the curator. on the territory of mariupol, from the point of view of the russian occupation of the russian spring , it is directly related to everything related to the destruction of mariupol to the organization of this government of mariupol, in addition, it belongs to the actual peace, so if you look at the branch yes if we spread it his curator from the fsb, then there are curators from the military intelligence of the ministry of defense of the russian federation . everything is clear now. he seems to be at the front, well, at the front, well, at least some medals have been received , and there is another such story that also seems interesting to me, what about what this country is known by a singer , so very recently, her name is the last

train from mariupol. did you hear her, mr. petre , did you hear her? take it at least in english. well, of course, this song. in my opinion, according to my personal taste, let's listen to it very carefully, and then we will discuss a little, well, literally, i don't know one verse. it's just in english. i'll read a little later the translation for those of our viewers who don't maybe they don't understand english, what's that song about, ah, with a mariup of their shoulders

, they dreamed of the upa, these javanese platform zivert, we're looking for something, the lantern girl sings susan vega about the fact that this is the last train from mariupol, all humanity is fleeing on it i i heard that on the last train from mariupol there was god himself. he was frightened by everything that he saw. the last train from mariupol. all humanity is burning. if translated into ukrainian, there are such words as for the people of mariupol . from time to time they mention ukrainian cities destroyed by the russian invaders, well, this is important to us, it is clear that every mariupol resident, well, it hurts a lot and we can hide this pain to infinity but it is nowhere from him

in fact, we keep coming back to it and it’s important for us because, believe me, mariupol teahouses take all this very special. those who work with the information field understand that the priority is simply more operational, some things, melitopol, berdyansk, yes, i don’t know, i don’t know, bakhmut, and so on, and so on, and so on, but if we say, let’s skip the mariupol man, he is very strongly reacts to this because he says that we are not going to bring the overgrown rumors about mariupol back home , well actually we know for sure and the research we conducted about the mariupol residents there we know that even from the first times before the occupation there were more than half of mariupol residents who are in evacuation

now we are ready to return home despite the conditions in which we will have to live and this is very important for us and but with the mariupol people with the return of ich bul-bol, which is called yes, but there is a very important thing for the mariupol people and that too is it clear or words give retribution, the majority want to return to pay back and first of all to find all these traitors and then to join and are already joining in the search for the russian military who actually did all this and first of all the question that is relevant for us and for all of us is exactly these pilots that you they sold the place. of course, the drama theater, the maternity hospital is our whole center. well, it’s just the deliberate killing of civilians, and if you take such a year to heart, yes . and when we fire at the hail, they understand where it ’s coming from, but the nobleman sees where he drops the bombs. and that's why the question is not even revenge, it's revenge

, it's very relevant for the people of mariupol, what's up, sir, so thank you very much for this conversation , i don't know, i'll find out, in fact, i have such a teenage love, i loved it very much and remember it, and everyone there superchan alentvd channels were spinning and my songs were playing with dino well, glory to the nation on the iphone was even there, there is a song well, that is, it was very, very important for us. i could not imagine that one day she would finish singing a song about mariupol and this there will be a song about the war, well, ukraine they discover, in fact, europe discovers its own for itself, they stop thinking that there is some there is russia and so on, it is somewhere in the east, that it is not important in us, they recognize them, they recognize them as part of the western world, as part of european civilization, western civilization at a very high

cost, but in the end, jesus is like that nvk is sometimes a promo for mariupol, not about some kostroma, i don't know, listen, i want another interesting story about how we are supported in the world as foreign people, not those who have no connection with ukraine. some actions, for example, i found out about the scotsman david fraser, who arranged a single picket under the building of the russian consulate in edinburgh, and he leads it, what does his etiquette look like, this is his tesla, he painted it blue-yellow and he is sitting in this carpenter's house under this consulate, they say that the police come there from time to time to watch him, but not to drive him away, but to ask him if he has ever been frozen because

the air temperature is already descends 7° minus well of course there is for our military when you can say that in such conditions it is nothing like that, but actually nine says that the ukrainians are currently experiencing probably the hardest winter in their lives. that is why he wants to support ukraine. and that is why he wants this consulate to be taken away from of edinburgh because , er, because, well, actually, this is how we need to support ukraine . has four children and does not want to he was ashamed to look them in the eyes. i don't want anyone to get tired of this war or forget about it. perhaps i even look a little

old . people also come to support and ukrainians come to treat him to a treat for such a show of support in ukraine, the best place for single pickets because not everyone can charge i didn't think about the test, now it's even an incomplete version. that is, let's remember this story from the movie, do you remember this match photo session of putin in mochilskoye in 2009, which flew into the other world ? parodies of these pictures with putin, when putin is sitting on a horse with a bare torso somewhere in some eurasian space. he probably imagines himself as the new tamerlane who conquers half of the planet earth, maybe the other half of the earth

well, remember this one with him when he's sitting. no, maybe for a while, i can show you to remind me how she looked, er, how putin looks. putin decided to repeat his youthful exploits, if you can say that in 2000, yes. yes, yes. there is only at the beginning of the stand, he and she are climbing for a short time. we retreat means we we're coming here, putin and his horse decided to show it, just skin something quit, he doesn't want to drive putin, he doesn't want to be taken, everyone stopped and watched putin starts to give back putin gives up, rakes , stops and, so to speak, advances backwards, and here already some girl wants to propose him to her

emperor he says help, wait for yosyp hahaha , show it there, it was so interesting, and then they grab it, no, say, i can do it myself, everything is fine, now, let's go here, they are already approaching the point where they accepted an ax, here they went out to meet this one the girls around him like that, well, the cat decided the action in short anyway, he says no, i went back and forth and back, he says to the bunker, well, this is the story, if he hinted to putin what should be done about the war in ukraine, take his own, he was there before in 2009. well, putin is no longer well, you look at the photo, it’s absolutely the same, and putin handed over handed over uh-uh 20-year-old man with clothes some uh-uh with sit here i drive only a man with a bare torso i’m already our serhiy zgurets military expert director of the information consulting company defense express mr. serhiy good morning

good morning, i greet you, andriy, this is actually a colossal video that you showed, because it lifts the mood and really demonstrates the real movements of the russian federation . that the russians can repeat the offensive in january-february, uh, and if so, where could this offensive be, that is, they want to repeat kyiv again in three days? well, in fact, we are evaluating various risks for and this is one of the probable scenarios, but not a hundred percent guarantee in any case. now we are talking about the fact that the enemy is trying to get the front lines that he has left and carry out offensive actions in the bahmut zone, where can

we now talk about the fact that he will open new fronts? i think that so far, it is premature, but here the only explanation of what koliba is talking about is that there are actually 300,000 bulls, of which i have 5,600,000 already thrown to replenish losses, and somewhere there 150 more are located in the territory of the russian federation, which are gradually trying to form in certain new units, and now the russians are really delaying the time in order to at least somehow equip these units with such a less decent military force, and that is why exactly these risks of other moods, in particular, from belarus, from other directions , they appear from time to time in the information space. but in any - in any case, these are not the risks that can be critical, because we are now talking about the fact that all actions for the next two or three

months can be connected, first of all, to nastia and russian initiatives, actually to ukrainian ones initiatives because right now we are also preparing reserves and have our own vision of what the front line should look like in the near future and after the new year, meanwhile, mr. kuleba also made a cautious forecast. he said that we do not know when the war will end, but it would be very good if we ended by, for example, the summer of next year, what would have to happen for this, what could it look like if, for example, in the summer of next year, this war would end. give forecasts for a more complicated thing. and here it is that kuleba looks quite realistic, because other ukrainian officials really talked about the fact that the war will end next year,

that it may happen in the summer, and so on, and these forecasts, well, actually, on the one hand, why are they needed, because they certainly give such an optimistic signpost for the ukrainian population, and on the other hand, we understand that behind every forecast there is a significant, significant effort of the ukrainian army, which must support it with its own forces and the lives of our soldiers on the battlefield, so that i think that it is really premature to make predictions now. but in any case, we understand that in parallel with these forecasts, an active discussion is taking place with our western partners regarding the strengthening of the transfer of weapons technology, because if we have a sufficient number of personnel to receive deterrence even new waves of russian mobilization, the strengthening of our new brigades, new units that are being created directly depend on the amount of military aid that comes to ukraine, with this, as you understand, it is still necessary

to add more dynamics so that our new brigades are really 100% combat-ready." in principle, i trust and they summarized the analysis there of russian and artillery and about technicians and others and personnel and in fact they say that everything is equal, let’s say so, the potential of the russian army, even despite the significant depletion and destruction of the

ukrainian army on the battlefield, it still fluctuates in within one year, the hungarian conditionally says that the stockpile of artillery and tank ammunition still allows for military action similar intensities as now, for at least a year, this means that they actually have a certain stock of ground equipment, they have a stock of artillery with sidearms, now it is becoming more difficult because there was also british and american development about the fact that they are starting to take old ammunition but for the old prykarpattia, for the russian army, you are not a limiting factor. rather, it is the nathkhvit standard or the american standard. and actually, what are we talking about now, this number of mobilized people, which are 300,000 so far, and then this mobilization was arranged everything remains the same, it is aimed at partially gaining time during this period, accumulating additional manpower, even poorly equipping , so i think that next year we will move into

such a new stage of hostilities, where we will have installations, we will deal with a larger number of enemy personnel, which is exactly i repeat, the western side must also be supported by new systems in order to prevent this advantage from being lost to some quality, so that the quantity, not the advantage of the enemy, does not affect the changes on the battlefield, for the worse, but for the worse. the austrian expert in cooper, yes, cooper gave an interview, we must have seen him, i hope so. he says that he really would like the whole war to end sooner, but in his opinion, russia is still there are a lot of human resources. that is, there is a mobilization resource of 140 million, after all. he also says that at least nominally they had 1,200 tanks, as he says, and it is obvious that russia is there. although they are in what condition, they will be deconserved and repaired, he says . this is because it is a day off

his thesis that russia will no longer be able to win this war and will not be able to achieve its goals, that strategically they have already lost, nevertheless, they have the means and opportunities to wage this war for years. this is the opinion of the expert. if this war, do you also agree with this assessment and if we are talking about a war that will drag on for years, what will this war look like or will it be the same as we see now well, in fact, when we talk about the conclusions of that cooper, in principle, i would frankly, i trust his aviation assessments, but i do not trust because what is happening on the ground, you are an expert and austria seems to me not not not low there not not recently not not fought from the point of view of evaluating combat experience at the same time everyone is really starting to talk about a war of attrition and the russian side is starting to think about such a thesis but it is necessary to understand that what is being said is innocent between ukraine

and russia, the european community stands behind ukraine, and the united states stands together, and together we are talking about the fact that the potential of the anti-russian coalition is an order of magnitude greater than the potential of the russian federations and we actually understand that a country that has 2% of its gdp cannot long resist the alliance, which has more than 90% of the gross world product, this is an extremely important economic component of this war, and we are not alone, and that's why i'm sure , in fact, that europe and america are interested in this war lasting a long time. we remember that sanctions, in principle, affect russia, but not so quickly, and on the other hand, when we talk about only part of this confrontation, only the front line . but i think that from the year to to three this one

the forecast that looks the most realistic may just be such an estimated time scale to the conduct of hostilities with the complete destruction of the army of the russian federation, and actually then control over the russian federation as a whole, so i think that from one year to three is quite such a realistically optimistic scenario as this will affect the front line, the front line must not be connected with our losses, it must be poisoned, you can draw certain conclusions and then make it so that the enemy simply cannot sneak up to our line of defense precisely due to changes in technological approaches, so far this is only possible in the field of anti-aircraft defense, but after all, it is necessary to slowly descend to the ground and change approaches to repelling the enemy on the ground precisely due to new incomes from the western countries, but i still have two questions there are two er one er let's say two er

actors of this war also known since the 14th year. this is the russian war criminal ihor girkin. this is oleksandr khodakovsky, a former citizen of ukraine and a collaborator who went over to the side of the occupiers and became there or there by the so-called minister of defense of the dpr or something like that, i don't remember anymore, yes, it was a long time ago, two of them, well, let's say that two spoke in public space, with one, but a joint assessment with conclusions, the joint assessment consisted in the fact that one and the other believe that russia will lose this war and if it does not change its approach, it will lose forever and but different conclusions were drawn khodakovsky said that the last chance is nuclear weapons, they must be used already because otherwise there will be no victory and well, girkin said that just and nuclear weapons cannot be used in any case, because it will not do anything, just eat the situation, instead, it is necessary to mobilize as in 1941, and only thanks to this mobilization with a multi

-million-strong army, russia will be able to defeat ukraine and collective action, what do you say about it? well, actually, now e- russia, the russian military, the political leadership implements such a concept , that is, a fortress under siege, in fact, they are already moving towards the concept when all these mobilizations are getting old with the war, the west and with nato, it is first of all directed for those and in order to form such internal convictions that a different period has already arrived and we must rally there. in this way, support the government and do not criticize anyone, although this will be accompanied by an increase in repression in the russian federation, because it will clearly be and it will simply turn into such a large-scale gulag because only in this way it is possible to change any options for resistance attempts, how

does this affect the number of personnel in the line-up that can be thrown for destruction, but the very system of the construction of the russian army does not provide for its flexibility, which can change the approaches to the work of the russian army. to be honest, i really do not see the prerequisites for the russian army to act differently. it simply structurally has systemic flaws that will not change the situation for the better, but only quantitatively personnel indicators are the only factor that actually disturbs us and threatens us, so that the issue of nuclear weapons, that is, in fact, these are already the things that have already been discussed before, powerful countries directly proved the russian aside, what will it be related to the rapid destruction of the russian army, i think that now the topic of nuclear weapons has descended to the level of the marginals to which we carry nekhodarkovsky's slides, only

the question about the patriot well, but what is there to discuss here, date - they won't give it well, let's wait and see what it is will be as soon as possible, because indeed this hope must become a reality as soon as possible . the express was with us. this is the end of our second hour of the marathon. well, traditionally, at the ninth hour, we remember all those ukrainians or their lives, ukrainians and those people who think that they thought they were ukrainians or their lives were taken by the russian invasion, the russian war, a minute in memory, let's remember everyone, let's honor the memory of the ukrainian military with a moment of silence