some symbols are considered to be theirs, absolutely, from such an outdated, rotten, backward empire, so read better your dugin, get ready to move into the hole, and that’s where the bull and water with milk are, or how about water and bread, this is basically your future, oh well but it wo n't last long either. because only you will grow up to the age of 16-18. you will be sent to slaughter and uh. well, here it is, in principle, fate, if it suits you, then for god's sake. well, listen , people have free choice they said something in in principle, you have 140 million, it seems like a lot , but you know, here it is 500, there is 600, there was a slightly different anecdote, do you remember there, he says that they also came , one of them came, he says, uh, here, so-and-so came to the carpathians, he says, how do they say you have such and such here, as if you live in retirement and you have everything and a big house and everything is so beautiful and everything and well and he says and two cars how are you

there he seems to be happy he says well we are there son we just go somewhere he says well in short they used to go and catch those russian tourists in bukovel well, in short, they explained to them what was wrong, and he says, well, he says take me with you, they took such a person, they hunted down those tourists, sent them where needed and took their shorter money for the reconstruction of the armed forces and said they collected 20 kopecks. well, there was no such money, so the one that i collected, like those millions, so far. well, a penny to a penny, a penny to just a few pennies and we'll talk about oleksandr yampolskyi or yampolskyi, i don't know, correct us now, the director of the delohite consulting company in ukraine , oleksandr, good day, eh, i don't know if the accent in your last name is correct correct me if i'm wrong. actually, penny to penny, the holidays are approaching, uh, in some cities there are traffic jams on the streets, people are storming, despite all the rocket attacks, they are storming stores and buying

gifts, uh, how much in total did you conduct a survey, how much in general are ukrainians going to spend money on gifts a how many ukrainians are going to give such gifts to our armed forces of ukraine for st. nicholas, er, for the new year, for christmas, so that we can live more calmly, er, the majority of ukrainians - this is still almost 60%, er, despite everything, they plan new year's and christmas shopping although, unfortunately , they will buy less this year than last year, less than in 2021, in the top three product categories, the first is food products , children's products, and clothing for shoes, but the key thing we noted for themselves this year, it means that more than 60% of ukrainians plan to use a part of their budget

to donate to the armed forces of ukraine or to help civilians who have suffered from the war. this is a fantastic center. they advertise there that they have started a very cool volunteer, well, i forgot his name, well , you can distinguish something there by the legs, because they are all dressed in the same orange vests, and otaki such good vests, it is obvious that they were all given out somewhere in a centralized factory near moscow or there she sewed for big money about having played half of the state order, a person and not everyone from vladivostok to and there collected there, i don’t know, maybe thousands of 100 rubles, but slam didn’t even pay for those from that one vests, but why am i saying all this? i am saying this to the point that when surveys are also conducted in them , are the same people who answer affirmatively to the question, do you support the war in ukraine, when they are asked a question, are you

ready, for example, to pay some money? to help in some other way, most of them absolutely, and most of them say no. well, you know, of course, this was not the subject of our research, but even if you look at how their meetings are held, this is the case in the country of the sponsors of terrorism . day one collected 0 rubles day two collected zero well, look how we collect, we can collect in an hour, the meeting closes recently, i reported again how much 200 million was collected there literally in a few days, come back alive - this is a fantastic result tarasov, congratulations. by the way, he finally received an award from the state for his work i also wanted to ask about yes. there is also an interesting point in your survey to write out whether ukrainians are ready to buy goods that are somehow related to the russian federation, as now with this because we

, when the war started in 2014, some people said so we decided to ask ukrainians separately whether they are ready to buy goods not even from the manufacturer of the country sponsoring terrorism, but goods if their manufacturer or seller has not left the market of the russian federation and our question what was planned in that and will you buy these goods even if they will be cheaper than others than 65% of ukrainians, almost 65% of ukrainians answered that we are not ready to buy goods from those manufacturers or those sellers who have not left the russian market, therefore well, from our side, from our company's side, so to speak zapochku started this trend of exiting the market

of russia and belarus that it happened at the beginning of march. we call on other international companies to leave the markets of russia and belarus and not to support the economy of these countries. these consumer sentiments, that's what the df is, some people say, it's a war, they go there , i don't know, to look for shoes, revenge, or some gifts, but how to explain to people that if we take the country's gdp, then the fall of the economy is in including what, for example, people simply buy less from us, more than 8 million have gone abroad, these are mostly women with children, but these are buyers, but how does the fact that people stop buying something affect the country's economy , of course, of course, unfortunately, it affects, but we see that even those citizens who left hmm let's do it temporarily i emphasize temporarily we

all have hopes that temporarily left left ukraine they continue to support the country's economy they will carry out new year's and christmas shopping just in time for their friends for their relatives who remained in ukraine and they will have an average check higher than the average check of those citizens who remained in ukraine, that is, they will transfer the quality of the funds here and it will still be support , they will transfer or they will buy online a product of a ukrainian manufacturer of a ukrainian brand place and this money will be introduced into the economy of ukraine, did you actually study whether after february 24 the desire of ukrainians to buy something ukrainian grew? the invasion somehow sped it up, it gave it some kind of momentum, it sped up for us, moreover, we

conducted a new year's survey this year for the first time . and every year, in principle, we conduct a survey on consumer attitudes for the entire year and already last year and the year before and in the 22nd last year, we noticed that ukrainians buy more goods that are made in ukraine, that is, goods that are made in ukraine, and again, they do not just buy and you are not ready to buy even if these goods will be more expensive than other goods in a matter of minutes. well, this is also a kind of patriotism. thank you, mr. oleksandr. oleksandr yampolskyi, the director of the delohite consulting company in ukraine, was brought in by us. we talked a little about how the purchasing mood of ukrainians changed in connection with the full-scale invasion. well, now let's talk with serhiy bulba, a public figure, the head of the white legion, and about what can we expect from

putin's trip to minsk, which was announced for monday, will he succeed in persuading lukashenka to take shoigu with him, who is supposed to meet with these bastards with his visa in belarus, for example, he is now calibrating the announced training, it is just easy to look for him for several days, he went to all the hospitals once a day with a dozen colonels, but what will we do with this plan, how do we wait for it to be signed, uh, a bunch will seek to legally confirm the presence of russian troops in our country, it has become time to permanently yes belarusian territory

lukashenko refuses to negotiate for you exclusively for the sake of the left. russian funds, unfortunately, that's all that if so he is now allowed, which lukashenko in principle worked out that the stadium will rotate him and in the european health promotion for the health of the vatican yes , but they have already been deleted as well as the next such statement was made public and even that was emphasized wisdom, and the popes, uh, throw some here and negatives, but what is the defeat that lukashenko was lying in the help of vatican tinctures, now you need them, because the influential person is boring, the insects are boring, the

parents are doing nothing else, so that lukashenko in your opinion, we are constantly talking about the reality of such a situation. we are raising this question about the fact that, well, again and again, this issue has become active because valeriy zaluzhnyi said that it may well be that the concentration of troops is not there now, in a month, 2-3 strike groups the group from belarus will try to repeat the attack again, cut off the supply of western aid, and attack kyiv or west of kyiv from the territory of belarus, what do the belarusians themselves think about this unofficially, but in conversations. maybe you know how they feel about this dangers, what are the moods of the belarusians themselves, the moods of belarus themselves again. you will understand that for the belarusians, it is a cult, that this is a war, it really didn’t bother anyone, that’s it for them, but that’s what is virtual, that is, that i don’t see this tv, but i don’t, in what physical way and it’s not ego

, there’s no modeling, that’s why it’s not yet connected, it’s virtual, that’s why people are so excited about this first pistol, i’m saying that i’m encouraged to introduce more than my own, even the military enlistment office, because for them it’s a deceased beggar from poland, it’s they really don't want to fight, they don't want to fight with ukraine anymore, it's true, they will take time, not even half an hour, they were constantly wound up so that the war is known, the west wants to take it, they say, poland is going to take it from ukraine, take lviv, belarus, i want to take a bunch, and my men, be ready to drink in vain - the west, but what the fuck что всё то есть радио lukashenko smoked всё это it reminded me of such a great imitation, as it were, we had five dry ones like a brigade naked.

it's not good, too. airplanes, and 50, then give me a muzzle to you, the truth is, the christmas tree will be traced. well, with such sick people, this is what, uh, how would velikaya arrive in gomel region, if that was the case, by r-27 cars, even there, they are not going to take a medical route. a large area of ​​hominskoy oblast and that's all, i'm not going to take a wound and what is being said now on e-e propaganda media of belarus as the main message is that the west is threatened by the main ones, yes, that is, they continue this line, there is nothing else and about ukraine these mobs

which is on the belarusian territory, what is it, who are you driving there by force, as it were, not asking everyone, no, they do not agree, 50% of the tech mob came correctly - these are volunteers who signed up themselves . go to the videos, where is the cook standing , for example, iron randolph, 1 pan, a huge green, is cooking the same thing. well, it’s natural ukrainian chevrons, chevrons of the armed forces of ukraine and anvars , the head of dubok. there is still a minute left, er, they are trying to conduct some kind of polls on the territory of belarus

, some independent ones, and here they are the latest, er, they found out that somewhere around 16%, er, 16% of belarusians are ready to leave us mass protests believe that the situation in the country is developing wrong someone will say that this is not much, but i will remind you that the protest mood of ukrainians was not higher either on the eve of the orange revolution or on the eve of the revolution of dignity, the numbers are the same somewhere, it's just that these were people who were ready to come out in reality and in fact the 10% that came out, they provided a change, an absolute change in the configuration of the government, and i don’t know the country’s agenda. how do you feel about these results? you understand because he and i will see , but we in belarus live in the soviet union’s komanlka, and the old radicals are absurd because that i even feel that i am talking, time is running out, do you see these tracks, for example, ginseng

, in fact, bags for the fact that i filmed a video, how is it now, kyivska, how was the situation in your ukraine, такой не было сейчас we did not have such a thing eh well, still we believe, we hope, i really, really, really want to see belarus, moldova and ukraine as some kind of a single such wall, a new wall that will end. state and develop democracy, we will help them with advice, why not? and so, i believe that sooner or later it will be. thank you very much for this conversation. bulba, a public figure, the leader of the white legion , was with us. we also thank you, our viewers, for being there. with us andriy sychuk lesya vakulyuk thank you for staying with the press further judicial control for your attention watch this week in the program judicial control with tetyana shustrova who and why

is disrupting the judicial reform in ukraine at the moment ukraine is failing its own plans with a bang how the government cements political appointments to the constitutional no one even thought to consult the court with the european union before approving this text for the second reading and new details and the drunken driving of judge harnik. congratulations, this is judicial control and i am tetyana shustrova in the summer ukraine received the status of a candidate for membership in the european union on the condition of fulfilling seven steps, key among them are the reform of the constitutional court and the continuation of the judicial reform president volodymyr zelenskyi publicly promised that ukraine would fulfill everything by the end of autumn, later the deadline was moved to the end of 2022 and now the reform of the constitutional court of ukraine was under threat, who and why is trying to undermine the european integration of ukraine, we will tell

you today, but first, the scandalous news the district administrative court of kyiv was liquidated, deputies of the verkhovna rada supported the draft law that provides for the suspension of the court's activities, 310 people's elected representatives voted in favor, the parliament also approved the draft law on the formation of the kyiv city district administrative court, the law entered into force on december 14, the decision of administrative cases will be temporarily carried out by the kyiv district administrative court under the leadership of pavlo vovka oask became known for the suspension of the acting minister of health ulyana suprun by the cancellation of the nationalization of privatbank ta was to play a major role in russia's plans to return viktor yanukovych to the post of president in the event of the capture of kyiv in the spring of this year in 2020.

vovka announced to his deputy yevgeny ablov, five more oask judges and the head of the state judicial administration zenova in the cold room suspected of creating a criminal organization and usurping power, the case is currently being considered in the higher anti-corruption court, the judges of the constitutional court were released at a special plenary session of the body on on the basis of personal statements of authority, iryna zavhorodnya, serhii sas and igor sdelenko, all of them were appointed according to the parliament's quota, respectively , soon the verkhovna rada will elect new judges of the constitutional court, as the analysts of the de jure foundation note, it is possible that the majority will obviously try to appoint their candidates to high positions, as happened in the summer of olga savgyra, before that she was a deputy of the servant of the people, the higher

anti-corruption court began to consider the criminal proceedings on the accusation in the oazko court oleksandr bragina, who deliberately did not submit an electronic declaration, the judge did not issue a digital signature , allegedly due to religious beliefs, meanwhile, the declaration in paper form was not accepted by her. even one year of imprisonment, meanwhile , the case of another judge, kirill garnyk , who was caught by police patrolmen while driving drunk the pecherskyi district court of kyiv began to consider, according to the case materials, beautiful in a state of alcohol intoxication drove an audi car on velyka vasylkivska street, patrol officers

detected the smell of alcohol, reddening of the face and trembling of the fingers, but beautiful refused a medical examination, this happened on october 2 at 10 o'clock in the morning of last week, the judge of the pechersk district court, vita bortnytska, who is known for extorting drunk drivers, decided to send the report of the police work because in the decision patrol officers appear at a different time, not ten o'clock in the morning, but nine o'clock 56 minutes, in addition, the place of commission of the offense territorially can belong not only to the pecherskyi but also to the holosiivskyi district of kyiv . in 2021, ukraine spent uah 1 billion on the liquidation of local general and local appeals courts and the creation

of district courts instead. of these funds, almost 400 million were used ineffectively, in particular, 254 million from of the state budget went to pay remuneration to judges who did not administer justice, this happened due to the improper work of the high council of justice and the lack of authority of the higher qualification commission of judges who did not perform their functions on the timely dismissal of the servants of themis. in june, ukraine received the status of a candidate for membership in the european union, subject to the fulfillment of seven key steps, among which the implementation of judicial reform and the reform of the constitutional court two years ago, this court caused a real constitutional crisis in october in 2020, he issued a decision to close the public register of declarations and abolish criminal liability for failure to submit or falsify

electronic declarations. this caused mass protests from civil society. the president removed the head of the court, oleksandr tupytskyi, from the position of a judge, and soon dismissed him. of europe in matters of constitutional law, such a crisis situation became possible due to excessive political dependence judges of the constitutional court and there is not enough clarity in appointing them to the position, therefore the commission called for the introduction of a real competitive procedure for the selection of the servants of themis as soon as possible. accordingly , the ambassadors of the g7 countries made a statement. currently, the judges of the constitutional court of ukraine are appointed by the president, the parliament and the congress of judges. and although the constitution specifies that the selection takes place on a competitive basis, the procedure that is currently prescribed in the

law does not provide for a real competition, each subject of the appointment formally conducts its own contests that do not in any way ensure the verification of candidates for compliance with the requirements of the constitution, so the risk of political influence does not decrease , the chairman of the board of the de jure foundation, mykhailo zhirnakov, told our journalists, in order to prevent this, the selection procedure must be competitive and there must be a commission in which there will be independent representatives international partners of ukraine and representatives of the public, such as the public integrity council, on december 13, the parliament adopted a draft law on the creation of the advisory group of experts, which will carry out the verification of all deputies for the position of judges of the constitutional court, the project specifies that the group will include six members, one each from the verkhovna

rada of the president and the congress of judges of ukraine, one person from the venice commission and two persons delegated by international organizations. by the way, the group will analyze each candidate for compliance with the criteria of integrity and professional competence, and this could be resolved as a first step towards fulfilling the priority requirement of the european union and the recommendation of the venice commission, but not exactly in this scheme, there is no provision for the participation of representatives of civil society, instead , representatives of the authorities will continue to participate in the selection of judges, so the threat of political involvement does not disappear, mykhailo zhirnakov insists, instead of the public, it is provided that in the advisory group of experts, that is, in the competition commission, which will carry out the preliminary selection of e- the judges of the constitutional court will be three representatives of independent international experts and

three representatives of the power of the president of the verkhovna rada and the congress of judges, which the venice commission itself calls a direct threat of politicization of the process, while the independent selection commission itself is being introduced in order to depoliticize the process, an essential point according to the draft law, by the members of the group of experts. thus, future constitutional judges will be chosen by the generation of representatives of the so-called system, this is also people who professionally grew and were formed during the times of the ussr, by the way, the decisions of the groups are not mandatory at all, so the parliament, the president and the congress referees will continue to be able to appoint manual

referees to the ax. - in fact, political bodies will be able to appoint anyone recently, the ambassadors of the g7 countries once again emphasized that judicial reform, key to the new selection procedure for the constitutional court of ukraine , remains a key priority and should be agreed with the recommendations of the venice commission and, in turn, in its conclusions on the draft law on the advisory group from the competition for the position of judge of the constitutional court insists on the mandatory need to involve civil society, however, the parliament and in particular the servant of the people faction is in a hurry to adopt a draft law that goes against the recommendations of international partners and

actually cements political appointments with the european union in general, no one even thought to consult before khvaly adopted this text to the second reading, i.e. imagine we join the european union. the european union is our key partner. water is what during the war and during the actual blockade of the mp they are trying to deceive the people of ukraine and our key partner, the european union . accession to the european union, instead , according to experts' conclusions, ukraine is currently failing its own plans with a bang, a consortium of ukrainian analytical centers and analysts conducted an analysis of ukraine's implementation of the seven steps on the way to of the european union and the conclusions are disappointing, if the government does not

change its approach , it will be simply impossible to complete the criteria within the stated time frame. the people from the president's office are really determined to disrupt the judicial reform, and with it, accordingly, european integration, according to experts, in two and a half months, ukraine's overall score increased from only four and four to four and seven out of 10 necessary to confirm the status of a candidate country, i.e. by three tenths of a percent, or not the only eu criteria where ukraine has shown positive dynamics since august, the reform in august, experts estimated its level at zero points. since then, several important changes have occurred, however, progress has slowed down at the moment, there is a threat that the reform of the constitutional court will now collapse with it, accordingly, european integration in general, the judicial review of it is only six out of ten

, now ukraine is convincing the european union to create an evaluation mission as soon as possible but experts they emphasize that if she had come to kyiv right now , we would have failed the exam today, i had all this under judicial control and i am tetyana shustrova if do you know the facts of corruption in the judicial system of ukraine or you want to tell about an unscrupulous judge, write to me on facebook or to the e-mail whose address you see on your screens, we will meet in exactly a week, all the best