if there was also the responsibility of the commander in the event of something, if the order was not thought out enough, how about such very delicate stories, please well, i will tell you that in my opinion, it is because of this, the system has already been worked out , there is a system of military inspections, there is a law enforcement service military, and in the end, if we are talking about the conduct of this or that military operation after any positive result, god bless - that's one story. however , listening to the results of this or that military operation and there they give an assessment of the activity of each person, first, who proposed, second, what were the options for implementation, and how are there several, and

third , the results. techniques and equipment of both the enemy and ours, that is, as far as i am concerned, the system here is rigid, moreover, the so-called circular guarantee is impossible in our time because the system of military competitiveness when one commander and another understand that not at any cost not at any cost because that even ours nato colleagues, they already give a high rating to the management skills of our military why because we have unique combat experience since the 14th year and our middle and high-ranking teams are not scientists, they are not theorists who fight on maps or on tables and this is only fighting on the battlefield and this is very

serious simply in the end definitely a lot of compliments can be said about our military administration about this whole structure how does it happen and do you know of cases when at least one of the commanders took responsibility i just don’t know from the circle where i actually communicate. maybe you will suggest that there should already be responsibility for some malfunction or an order that was not proportionate to the losses for example or heals that had to be achieved. the time of martial law, when we win in this, not only the ukrainians do not doubt the whole world, then it will become known, i will say a few numbers, more than five generals were dismissed from their positions, including, and due to certain miscalculations, also senior the military personnel was removed from the performance of their duties, and based on these facts

, checks and other procedural actions are being carried out, and in fact, life goes on and the military makes conclusions, it is very important that these conclusions are objective and that whoever made the miscalculation really bore the responsibility, it is important that these miscalculations do not cost human lives, i mean the lives of our brothers and sisters, this is very important. thank you, mr. mykhailo, on our broadcast, the people's deputy of ukraine, lieutenant general retired mia mykhailo tsymbalyuk we are going further material e-e in poland presented the book war 2022 the anthology included the works of more than 40 famous ukrainian writers this serhii zhadan and maryana savka lyubko deresh e-e andruhovych and others invited a special to warsaw for the presentation to the guest well,

our colleagues will tell you more. sleep, my swallow. spring is coming soon . spring will not pass. may you dream of a fish or a pine tree from the side of the city . holding their breath, the audience listens as the ukrainian actress ada rogovtseve reads a poem. by the poet marjana savka, this is a lullaby dedicated to ukrainian children, sleep my swallow, little star, this is an address to the child who is traveling in the train and the mother of mothers, in particular, an address to the child who is sitting in the basement and hiding in a bomb shelter, the texts of ukrainian authors are presented in the ontology war 2022 refers to the period of the first months of the full-scale invasion, it is the reflection of famous ukrainian writers on the events in ukraine, essays and poetry, fragments of diaries

by various authors, in particular, serhiy zhadana privi from our car, ammunition is given to me to a volunteer, everything i will drop in the warehouses, the address of the occupiers is not selected, kharkiv was shelled with hail by the russians, it's not the army, it's the horde , volodymyr rafayenko , the author of the book, became the editor and one of the authors volunteers who, risking their own lives, took us in their own cars through these russian checkpoints, it was during the occupation that volodymyr wrote a diary, which eventually became the basis for the play i wrote the play she is currently it will be published, maybe in a month and a half it will be published by the

publishing house of geneta antonenko. so she wrote in blood, but not to write. i couldn't because i needed to somehow bring myself to my senses . she is proud of ukrainian writers and an actress, and dear, who today became the voice of the book war 2022 is really a war she somehow so stirred up, this is the best thing that people have excitement and it gives birth to some such, you know, new, completely new thoughts and translates them into creative projects into creative ideas and beautiful beautiful poems that appear now, well, every day, all the experiences of people who were affected by the war are very understandable to the actress, because three men from her family are now at the front, in particular, her grandson, they are three alexei at the front, three

alyosha are fighting and well, you can understand what i feel, that is, i feel nothing, they are leaving and i am already i can't live because i pray i pray i pray and when i am verified and your creative plans and yours what if there was not one plan to wait for the war photo lenses spoke at the event and the photographer behind the zrastali dmytro , a cossack man, shared his experience which is important for documenting both heroic feats and war crimes, the photographs evoke a certain e.e. let's say a constant reminder of people about azovstal that, through the prism of these photographs and the opportunity to speak at such events, i can constantly remind of all the prisoners of war who are still in captivity because we do not have the right to forget about them and to remind people about the feat of the defenders of mariupol and the defenders,

the anthology war 2022 is also designed precisely to document the realities of the first months of the attack russia to ukraine, one day our children and grandchildren will take this book and read it and understand why we were doomed to victory. the book is already being translated into polish. they are also planning to publish it in other languages ​​in various european countries. this is an extremely important plot and, of course, to our artists and writers who try to adequately describe the war, so the war must be properly described and presented, especially in the west we are going next 16:00 - 37 minutes ukrainian experts are christian about the description of the war and our way of the revolution of dignity before a large-scale invasion, probably the best thing that can handle this is the documentary film maybe remember this you should remember in 2016

the movie winter on fire winter on fire was nominated for an oscar, entered the shot list, and the creators of this, well, without a doubt, very cool documentary film. and yesterday they had the premiere of their next creation, life on the edge, in the moscow cinema, october, the ukrainian premiere of this film took place and in connection and studio pavlo peleshok, director and producer pavla's film , i congratulate you, glory to ukraine , it's really cool that you found the opportunity to present and show this film, let's tell our viewers a little about how it was created, under what conditions was the start, and under what conditions did you reach the climax? well, if the idea itself arose during our trip to los angeles in the 16th year, and after returning, we realized that we needed

to make a film about the full sequence of events that took place from the 13th year until now, we freed ourselves at the end of the 20th year and started working on the company for almost 2-2 years. here is this story about ukraine and about each of us for and we focused on the concept of presenting this information for the western audience, mr. directors, accordingly, i would like to ask you about a delicate moment, in particular, it is about financing, we we understand that any best creative plans without funding are doomed, as was the case with your tape, well, this issue was also dealt with by yurko, who is my brother, the producer of the film, eh. we managed to find private funds, these are our friends who work in the field and it is ukrainian

money that is abroad. that is, we did not consciously look for grant money or any money from the state or other partner countries, that is, this film is fully financed by ukrainians. how was the premiere yesterday in the cinema, october , were there many people, and what were the first reflections , someone once said if the audience applauds, then this is a bad movie, that is, i do not have such experience, because this is my debut as a director and producer of a full-cycle film from idea to completion, but after the final three began and people applauded until the very end end and of course there were tears and joy and people came out, came out silently, that is, they experienced it each in their own way, because this film

is, in essence, and it applies to each of us, we do n’t have the names of the heroes in it, so we tried to build it so that a person would not be distracted by the personnel, in particular, saw themselves for this whole journey, eight years of war. i think we succeeded just before the war. you were already there. i'm sorry. you were in the final stages of the invasion. the great war took its toll corrections and some of her episodes were also included in the film. unfortunately, she contributed her team. we were supposed to finish this film on the 20th dash. on february 27, we have the final year. the next year is called when the film is no longer touched during editing and it is painted and music is added but after february 22, our editor petro

tsimbalov. he spent 9 days in irpin in the basements with his family, he continued to edit because somehow our line producer antonina petromanska in the house from which the rocket was taken away from sevastopol square, well, that is of course, they made corrections and we corrected the ending. well, if we had corrected it, we would not have repaired the film, because the struggle was complete enough, because we made just such a thickness correction, and it is very emotional. in these 8 years, you don't know more terrible things like the trading of emotions, how can we show all this to

our friends abroad? managed to bypass this sharp corner. do you understand this is a good question about when we started editing the maidan, because we could not tell about the occupation of crimea and all the events that followed without a little reminder. and especially in the western spectator, what happened on the maidan and when we got to the issue of shootings on the maidan, of course everyone understood what should i show the shots of the people falling, but i decided not to do this on the contrary. because it is more emotionally terrifying for me to watch the reaction of people who see the death of ugu, and this works the best, because the films should be shown first. excuse the corpses and another 8 years to tell for an hour and a half so you don't perceive violence anymore, this is the term for pornography, violence, when there is so

much violence and your brain shuts down, you don't perceive either pain or emotion, yes, we agree with an extremely important point. well, mr. directors, we would like to ask your assessment of the situation with the dovzhenko center, we understand there is an institution, there is a powerful institution, and we understand that our country is in great need, in particular, we need to develop our documentary film industry, in particular, so that these are not isolated in one or another anti-berani, there must be some the system still has work to do. how do you see the way out of the situation with the care of the puzzling

situation? he will connect and let's say correctly to press this situation as simple as it stopped it is arbitrariness because it is just especially now and it is emphasized not abnormal it reminded me of the 13th year unfortunately my eyes this is such a bad bell this is a story about money a story about personnel tyranny or an attempt , so to speak, to prepare a certain political structure for oneself. and this does not exclude all these positions, that is, each and every one of pavel's criteria. finally, where to watch life on the edge . what about the letter on the oscar eh. now we have concentrated on the international

screenings that are still closed to you in order to attract distributors, and we will probably not be able to deal with the oscar there. because if the film has to go through the festival history in order to win somewhere and get into the long leaflet, we don't have time for that of course we wanted it but we have to show it already we have invitations to turkey and you in japan to thailand and well european countries all over germany to be a travel agency, that's why the question is that if the film becomes public, then if the chances of it simply getting into the film festival history decrease, well, we'll try , but that's not our goal. thank you, tell me about ukraine or there is no time for that. filmmakers pavlo peleshok, director, producer, yes, the film life on the edge is already appearing, yes, there is an opportunity to see it , of course, it is important, we are waiting, and it will be available

at last, tragic news at the front, an activist against the russian occupation of crimea, a former political prisoner of the kremlin, gennadiya afanasyev, died, information this is unfortunately confirmed, we kept her for a long time until some official data, and it is already reported on social networks. i will just remind you that gena was a person who in may 2014 year after the annexation of crimea, he was detained by the fsb of the russian federation, he was tortured and accused by leonidas of preparing terrorist acts, he was a political prisoner of the kremlin for a long time, but he was still managed to be returned to ukraine as a result of an exchange in 2016, and on the 18th, the european the human rights court obliged the russian federation to even pay afanasyev monetary compensation due to the inhumane conditions of the convoy. we offer our condolences to all family members, god is feeling . well, you have it for me, tv viewers. we invite you

to watch our product, yevgena's program miklushka list of miklushka collaborators see this week in the collaborators program miklushka list of werewolves in uniform, some of the former law enforcement officers swore loyalty to the occupiers at the last moment, that is, they are conducting some activity even before sbu employees helped the enemy capture kherson and how our partisans are driving the sellers of nasty werewolves crazy in epaulettes once heard such a term. it usually referred to law enforcement officers who, in their positions, engaged in racketeering and extortion , worked for crime in the regions or even headed it during the war, this saying acquired a different meaning, much worse, if a lot is known about the collaborators from among politicians and officials, because they are public people, then what

about the security forces who went over to the side of the enemy, everything is under a veil of secrecy. but my colleagues and i worked well and prepared for you another list of collaborators, this time in uniform after the invasion of the occupying forces, somewhere from the ground, like those worms, many former employees of the ministry of internal affairs, pensioners , illustrated ukrainophobes, and just skunks who they forgot their oath to the ukrainian people and left, and wherever they went, they ran to serve russia to the fascists under the guise of the people's militia and other pseudo-power structures, it was from such that the skeleton of the punitive agencies formed by the occupiers was formed, they told us in the movement honestly that the trend for this indicates that there is probably not enough all the same, personnel among uh, active law enforcement officers are therefore being recruited, and he is there pensioners in the ministry of internal affairs, in particular, we have such

cases from the side of law enforcement agencies , there were these people, somewhere was omitted at this moment because they do not become collaborators at the last moment, that is, they conduct some activity even before that. among them we can name volodymyr lapandin, ex-major general of the ukrainian militia, whose last position was the head of the main directorate of the ministry of internal affairs in the cherkasy region. after the revolution of dignity , he was dismissed and no one would have heard about lapandin, if information about his appointment as the head of the occupation police of the kherson region had not appeared, a logical question arises: how did he end up in occupied kherson, according to my information, lapandin has been in the past few years he lived in crimea, where he received a russian passport . from where was he sent to restore order in kherson, to recruit traitors to serve in the occupiers' militia ? bobryshev's number helps him. an ex-employee of the militia in the kherson region resigned in 2016 and joined a private company associated with an ex-gauleiter

volodymyr saldo, after the occupation of the region , saldo's collaborator found a place on the bench of traitors for an old friend by appointing bobryshev as the head of the personnel support department of the ministry of internal affairs of the occupying power. in short, his duties include agitation and even the compulsion of former law enforcement officers to work for the occupiers. whom to agitate for sure ? it was gennadiy garkusha. he was entrusted with the position of commander of the berkut harkusha battalion. since 2004 , he worked in the ministry of internal affairs. 20 hryvnias from children who smoke so as not to tell their mother, doris harkusha, until the senior resistance of the commissioner, participated in the peacekeeping mission in africa, later transferred to the special purpose police company, which was created on the basis of the same former berkut, which gained rotten fame by dispersal and coding on the maidan, is similar to harkusha in its taste for

bullying and style of work. berkut once led a battalion that adopted the worst inhuman traditions. their main task is to ensure order, more precisely what is order in the imagination of the invaders, to disperse a ukrainian rally, they are in the first ranks together with the buryats kadyrivs and other victims. and if you need to find the most axed ukrainians in kherson, maksym trubaev takes up the case, according to the sbu . he headed the criminal investigation department of the police in the kherson region. we called maksym trubaev and asked him how it was to work for the occupiers. maksym. good day, good. yevhen miklushko. my name is a journalist for the espresso tv channel. you are a former employee of the police

of ukraine, as i understand that you are not currently in the service of the police of ukraine, that the sun of ukraine with what series to me call, i want to hear your position, find out what you actually do let's meet and talk, let's talk in kyiv, it will be convenient. can you tell me by phone what exactly you do and in which structure , sorry, it's hot in kherson every 11 tomorrow if you don't mind dialing the phone, as you could have guessed. the very next day, such a call did not happen. journalists, in the end, the meeting in kyiv, so promised and long-awaited, apparently, is afraid of a warm meeting from the security forces of ukraine,

smaller positions in the anti-people's militia went to yevgeny stasenko rostislavov malinovsky kirill, yevgeny goryalov, maksym sherhnya of velikoselsky, and serhiy odintsya, their photos were found by my colleagues from the investigation.info, and the kremlin appointed a former employee of the sbu, oleksandr kompets, as the pseudo-mayor of occupied kherson, and the head of the anti-terrorist center of the sbu region, lieutenant colonel , led the entrance parade of traitors wearing epaulets in the kherson region ihor sadokhin was detained at the beginning of march in chernivtsi, now the investigation proves that it was sadokhin who in the first days of the invasion was on the radar of enemy aircraft and handed over a network of minefields to orcs looking at this respectable list of werewolves in epaulettes, you involuntarily wonder how many of them still wear the uniform of the ukrainian police or even have sbu

passports , they have information. the persons are not advertised, so i think that over time we will have quite a lot of information, even from those territories that will be occupied and on these cases that are currently open, that is, the process is ongoing so far we have not seen any real verdicts in the courts, but the pre-trial investigation is indeed being conducted, the more traitors we find among our own, the more difficult it will be for the occupiers to receive information. of the zaporozhye region, before that he was the deputy prosecutor general of the terrorist lpr and this is oleksiy selivanov , obukhov's deputy, until 2014

assistant to the minister of defense of ukraine after the expulsion of yanukovych, he joined the luhansk militants and became a member of the donbas militia after the occupation of part of the zaporizhzhia region. this year he moved to melitopol, where it turned out that he was a pedophile who forcibly kept an underage girl in his apartment, and this did not prevent him from assuming the position of deputy head of the main department the ministry of internal affairs of the zaporizhzhia region learned the other day that he was detained by the occupiers themselves, who say that he did not get along with those who were sent to zaporizhzhia to build a russian mir on the model of the lpr minor positions in the so-called people's militia were distributed to local collaborators of the trakyt wallet, the odd eagle, mikheev, alipov mitlenka , and shopov, all of them were declared suspicious of the evidence of their criminal activity, which was more than enough. mykhailo avsievich became a collaborator

back in 2016, when the liberators appointed him the prosecutor of the city of krasny luch that on in luhansk region, the functional duties of a traitor are very simple: laying flowers on all soviet holidays, documenting the so-called offenses against the ukrainian element and cutting off all attempts to remove the occupying power, keeping the residents of krasny luch in fear. and all yevich is helped by a few more traitors, in particular oleksandr emelyanov , named as the head of the investigative department of the krasny luch police, for god's sake, they look in this video as if they have spent the last few years drinking somewhere with a severe hangover came to investigate the sabotage, why did the slab fall off the monument to heroes in velika otechestvenna in lenin park, i understand that this was a provocation against us living here and existing workers, therefore we will fight this provocation in some way by means of force and law, and we are putting the whole thing on the line. for 6 years, the case was never

solved this year, after the occupation of many settlements in the luhansk region, several dozen active police officers took an oath of loyalty to the people's republic of china, only these photos can be established 20-30 collaborators from the markiv region, among them ivan biyansky oleksandr kogan ivan andronov daria krivypustova serhiy bilash denys baran oleksandr kulish inna bolotska vitaliy and yana lysaki chose a symbolic date for such an event of the national police of ukraine and immediately these werewolves earned themselves an article for treason, and this video from occupied mariupol is probably the most shameful of all that i have seen during the preparation of programs about collaborators, dozens of police officers dressed in military uniforms with white ribbons as workmen or simply in civilian clothes went to sign up for police service under the occupiers, had worked for 20 years before,

eh, no matter what kind of work it was, it was difficult to arrange, i got up, and in the hospital they will hear me continue the word only and i was a collaborator, add that now he will serve not his people, not his state. and for the foreigners who came to kill, it is simply disgusting, but it is gratifying that this video was put on the network without brains and our special services will be able to identify all the traitors after the deoccupation . there were collaborators from miklushka's list, we will see each other in exactly a week, but if there are advisers in your region, don't waste time, write to me on this e-mail or simply on facebook, we will make the scoundrels famous together so that this carrion would not have a chance for rehabilitation after our great victory, death to the enemies