well, the first one didn’t turn out to be clear that the russian army can’t fight. and that’s why prigozhin was called, and he really is one of them. that’s a dude. the formation bank is one of the more effective parts of the russian army, although it’s called he is a good man of soil against a good man and a self-made man, which was revealed, for example, in the battle of bakhmut, where for several months he tried to take bakhmut, but he collided with professional soldiers of the ukrainian army and, in general, he broke his forehead, although during fasting by zelenskiy, bakhmut, he generally frowned. on the other side of the front, he said that dear vladimir sanich, we are waiting for you. here we are now , morzianka, and he arranged some clown demonstrative shots in the direction of the ukrainians. well, that’s all the cursing, so to speak. well, that’s the firm’s

signature piece of mm. prigozhina. this war of russia against ukraine is not just criminal, it has a certain irrational dimension , as you rightly noted now, this irrationality is intensified by an inertial process, we understand that putin does not care about the death of his fellow citizens and he will surely be ready to throw and throw and throw corpses in the style of marshal zhukov you, as a sociologist, what do you see now, the main trends , in particular, it is about support within the russian federation for the scenario of a big war, a long war, or the possibility of getting out of the war with the help of one or another i do not know

propaganda tricks means the first totalitarian fascist regimes such as putin's regime, which is now in russia, there can be no sociological survey at all, here are the data of any sociological questions. when a person in the third reich or in the stalinist ussr or in putin's russia is asked on the street or on the phone how do you relate to the politics of adolf hitler or и очень постовый or vladimir putina, well, of course, the person responds, it means that it is natural, it is good , of course, even the major

is supported. the data hear 90% of the respondents refuse to answer social questions, they refuse to answer and what value do the remaining five percent have there? they refused, i don’t know, so let’s forget about mass polls. there are oblique indicators. sociology in russia is possible, but it is difficult. there are oblique indicators. there is an indicator called demonstrative behavior. the occupation of crimea is a symbol of support for this. and this crimea is a badyorgiiv ribbon, and i saw this ribbon in huge quantities in the subway, on

backpacks, so to speak, on buttonholes, and there in the hair of girls it means on a briefcase on handbags and on cars in huge quantities and it was indeed a symbol of support, this is our crimea . cars, mainly in administrative buildings, here please , as many as you like, which means the cars that i myself saw, such as the cars that had rare single cars, where was this floor of the swastika on them, the windows were breaking well, the wipers broke, and so on, that is, in fact, this is the kind of support that would pay off for crimea . the second indicator is

the ratio of the mobilized and the people who moved to the opposite side. 320,000 mobilized for approximately one million people who, er, simply got together and went abroad to flee from mobilization, that is, the opposite side can be evaluated differently there, this is a separate story that in the chapters of those who fled from mobilization, there is reluctance to kill ukrainians or more degrees are desirable to die in ukrainian chernozems, but in any case, this is artificially not support for the war, therefore, in general , such a ratio can be used in different ways to indicate that the ratio of support for the war and not support for the war is still in favor now this is mostly in the direction of non-support, and the fact that in the public space now, there is mostly hysterical

support for the war, and er, they mostly squirm and laugh, and er, so to speak, falls into a trap, er, so the supporters of the war, that’s simple evidence that public space is completely monopolized by the state is monopolized by propaganda monopolized by the information war, where are the participants of russia and figure it out, and we understand that just as putin was walking and gerasim, you are all this criminal gang, they hope that this inertial process will last as long as they need, a year, two, three well, here is the moment. what in your opinion can become a certain moment of crystallization. the afghan scenario was repeated, in particular , it is about the withdrawal of the soviet interventionists from the republic of afghanistan, let's give one point

when uh- eh vyvodyl prikasov vyvode political decisions about the military withdrawal from afghanistan even something strange. to compare gorbachev's putin, gorbachev did not accept me directly responsibility for the afghan war, and for him it was very organic. i can say with confidence that putin will not order the withdrawal of troops from the territory of ukraine, at least i do not see such an opportunity, it means that it is rather unpleasant news for me, it was that the russian public space, the russian television, the russian government practically does not reacted to the liberation of kherson. i thought that it would be a rather

serious blow. russian television, the russian public authorities, and the russian public authorities were able to withstand it quite easily. the question is how serious it will be. this is a serious question. i think that the pudinsky regime will not be able to withstand this blow so easily because, after all, crimea is an absolutely iconic phenomenon and, in general, it will swallow the liberation of crimea so easily, as they invited the liberation of kherson. well, the difference between these scenarios is conditional, but i don’t see two scenarios. the first scenario is putin, after all, after the defeat, he will not withdraw troops . that is, do not count on it that putin will withdraw under some circumstances , this means the end of the military

unit, he wanted to tell the first scenario that the ukrainian army will drive the russian troops to the border there in 1991 so that the absolute right does not mean that putin at the same time keeps his regime in his power - this does not mean the end of the war. the war will change. it will simply become the front line of the russian-ukrainian border. this is huge . the entire russian-ukrainian border will become the front line, and this war can last very long. rumors that the russian-ukrainian border is over the resources are unjustified rumors and, in my opinion, they are harmful and naive because they are, that is, such a cap of a zakydaisky character. no, it will not end in russia, there is a sufficiently large mobilization resource, officially , it is 25 million. like

one and a half 2 million. well, it’s still a big resource , and putin can, moreover, it’s a renewable resource. and that’s why, uh, i think that the war in such conditions can last quite a long time, it will change its character, but it will be a long, protracted war. option - this is still a tatar defeat and where is the occupation of crimea and donbass - this total defeat for putin will lead to the collapse of the putin regime due to, first of all, indignation in the army, that is, in fact, that's it, here you are mentioned afghanistan, i will say that there was an afghan syndrome, and everyone who lived in the soviet union at that time knows what that is, uh, when very badly traumatized people came from afghanistan who did not understand what was done to them, why they died there,

why they uh, so to speak, uh, they lay in to the guts of their own a-a and their own and their comrades-in-arms why are they there that's why what happened to them with them why did they leave then that is, these people are poisoned by the war, traumatized, they came to russia, they made up, including who some of them became professional killers, some of them got drunk, uh, hung out there, uh, drugs , etc. and the ukrainian syndrome that threatens russia will be many times more destructive for russia, the people who will come from the front, uh, that means the remaining alive, who will not lie in ukrainian black soil, these people will be combustible material for the civil war, for trouble, this is about the same as millions of russian soldiers climbed out of the german trenches during the first world war, came to st. petersburg, to

moscow, and arranged to participate in this october coup and then they arranged what became the curse of our country in 74 the minister of war of the tsarist government, sukhomlinov, and with the chiefs of the relevant headquarters there were colossal problems because it was about losses at the level of millions, we are talking about the dead, wounded, deserters and those who surrendered as prisoners, but it was also on a large scale here, we understand that this flywheel is only unfolding like this with taking into account hitler's plans, in particular, or hitler's or stalin's plans regarding general mobilization in russia. here, for sure, the key point is the so -called level of absorption of corpses, that is, a

category that can determine the negative sharply a negative reaction from the population regarding the war and the specific introduction of hostilities means the first russia possesses i have russia not only the state not only putin but also russia how er-er the population is absolutely immune the number of dead more than that in russia s-e-e-e-e-e-e-e-e-e-e-e-e-e by the way, fundamentally different from soviet russia , because in russia the second anthropological type was formed in principle. it doesn't matter how many people died , moreover, the number of people killed is a matter of pride, the more people died, the greater the feat, so putin can, um, kill

300 thousand people in this war, he can kill a million people , no reaction to this. there will be a reaction will be on the territory of russia, uh, as an imperial state - this is actually a state that serves as the main walrus for protection , this is huge territories, and russians are proud of their territory, and uh, this is for the sake of this territory, they are ready to make sacrifices, and if the beginning of the dead, there will be no reaction, the reaction will be to the loss of the territory, and the territory will be lost, the attack cannot lead to the fact that self-destructive forces, power structures, despite the fact that from the very beginning of the leadership, the generalate they supported this war, they understood that this was stupidity, putin broke down in honor of the knee, he accepted a single personal stepdaughter, and he directed a single decision on the start of the war, and as

a result, he got what he got. i think that in principle, this is the second protest script pervyi scenario inertial eh what makes the war that is eh so to say the current table war eh where the front lines will be the russian-ukrainian border internationally recognized i emphasize the mona border will there be a front line and not a second line soprenovenie as eight years uh, so to speak, and the internationally designated border will be the front line. the second option is the collapse of russia in confusion, and this is a completely possible option that threatens and leads to the decline of russia. this is the third historical stage the collapse of the russian empire is a natural current of the existence of the russian project in history, and i am well, as a sociologist, as a researcher of russia, i argue that in the

end, hey mina, this scenario will be implemented , maybe not immediately, maybe after some period take this protracted war, but i think that the collapse of the russian empire is not inevitable, er, in terms of time, it is irresponsibly assigned, this is not the subject of accurate forecasts, so to speak, but what is the foreseeable period, er, russia, how about that, er, a historical project in those граних користой мы видим сегодня перестанет сестовать well, that's how it happens. the empire is mortal, and as a rule, such empires as, uh, the russian empire are always special. they always remain in death . there are also certain extremely painful moments for the russian regime, in particular, mysterious explosions at the airfields of the strategic aviation of our time, we remember i'm talking about the matiasarus pilot who landed on red

square. well, according to that, something happened that , according to putin and the russian air defense, should not have happened. yes drones flew, so to speak, to strategic airfields, one of the first important successes of ukraine was the destruction of the plagman cruiser moscow, and it was destroyed by ukrainian weapons with this ukrainian -made naval missile eh, at the airport not far from saratov, it’s important, well, the airport is a military airfield called engels-2 eh, it’s a matter of principle which make it possible to destroy military objects in the depths of russia and that

now this is a military military plane, well, in the sense that the bombers are strategically moved if i go to the airport in murmansk, it changes significantly, that is, there is much more difficult logistics, at least it is more difficult to use them in that number for blows then to the man, although in general these blows continue to be very effective, but this is mostly due to iranian aid. as far as i understand, the situation is becoming more complicated for россии and er, from the war to the territory of россии he is already working, and er, it means that this does not change the roots of the next picture of the war, that is , it is already a completely different story, unfortunately, i have to end our conversation here. i am grateful to mr. igor for this frankness. analysis on the air of the espresso tv channel, and i want to remind our viewers that now a former deputy of the state duma of the russian

federation from the opposition party apple, sociologist, journalist ihor yakovenko worked for them, the air time of our program has run out, stay tuned of the espresso tv channel - my brilliant colleagues work for you non-stop, take care of yourself and your loved ones, learn about the most important things. see you on the air of happy holidays. we will listen to people suffering from rheumatism . but arthritic, it is impossible to get used to it, it does not allow you to move. i tried everything. and at the pharmacy, i bought a yellow cream dolgit, it saves me from pain in rheumatism, reduces swelling and improves the mobility of joints. dolgit is the only yellow cream for pain in the joints and back. movies, television, sports.

choice choose what you want on megogo a time when ordinary things acquire miraculous properties a time to gather together to celebrate and we will decorate our christmas trees even in times of war our christmas trees will become places of strength we will meet christmas together with our military all together we will become even stronger and as in carols the light wins ukrainians will defeat the darkness in life as well. ukrainians will defeat the moscow occupations. look with a sincere eye at the son of god on our land . a gift came down from heaven to ukraine. may it be glorified forever and ever. merry christmas

. every week, the saturday political club helps to understand processes taking place in ukraine and the world, vitaly portnikov, host of espresso and invitations, experts based on facts give their assessment and forecast of the development of events, you want to understand how our today will affect our tomorrow, see saturday's political club, what saturdays are not espresso , see this week's program, collaborators , list of miklushka, judges, traitors how did the servants of themis turn into the hearsay of the kremlin, do you want me to call the police again, what retribution awaits the werewolves in robes, unknown good men shot nikulin and how many more

collaborators are still judged by the name of ukraine every war gives birth to heroes unfortunately for the helpless, in today's episode i will talk about collaborator judges, you know about those agents of russia in dark robes, only not with a beard and a cross in hand , but with a hammer and the right to judge, and i will also explain what they are especially dangerous, do you remember the story of how the so-called court of the terrorist dpr sentenced three foreign volunteers who fought on the side of ukraine but were captured by militants at the beginning of the summer, two britons and a moroccan were sentenced to death because they fought in the ranks of the armed forces, fortunately, they exchanged legionnaires at home in safety. what can you say about the judge who decided to take their lives? oleksandr nikulin, a former ukrainian judge, now a collaborator who calls himself a judge of the supreme court of the dpr

, found himself one step away from the court of god. at the beginning of november, an unknown good man shot nikulin by collaborators survived, but learned his lesson. now he will definitely not take someone else's life lightly, realizing that the punishers have not yet achieved their goal and death is following him, it is not difficult to guess what fate awaits the rest of the judges are collaborators, and there are only fifty of them in donetsk region. each of them has already received his suspicion from the prosecutor's office. if the employees of the terrorist themis are not sent to the next world by explosive bullets in the entrance or an accidental road accident, they will sit behind bars in a ukrainian prison. somewhere like that for 15 years everyone is suspected in absentia, the facts of criminal activity have been announced to him, and most of them have to wait for the de-occupation of donetsk region and detain the pseudo-judges if they survive. what are the dangerous collaborator judges? they have considerable powers and opportunities, in particular

access to state secrets and registers of personal data of residential addresses and property. they have access to information about government representatives, public figures and their families, and all this in unscrupulous hands can turn into a heavy weapon against ukraine and ukrainians, for example in the 14th year due to russia's occupation of crimea and donetsk and luhansk oblasts, more than 500 judges went over to the occupier, then there were recorded cases of the use of the court seal for fraud with property, the loss of case materials containing state secrets and entering fake decisions into the ukrainian register, now in the conditions of a full-scale war and the creeping occupation of ukraine, we have an even bigger problem, many judges are collaborators who act in the interests of russia and against whom criminal

cases have been initiated. she is not famous for her integrity and has already received reprimands from the high council of justice. on september 16, she unjustifiably forbade activist maksym kornienko to film a court session in khanyiv the court employees covered the camera with their hands and obstructed in every way, then the judge even called the police, the activist was accused of malicious disobedience to the law enforcement officers and arrested for 15 days. on the same day, she issued a decision on arrest. the group is worried after this, the judge also threatened journalists. and what about handing out arrest warrants to everyone who disagrees is not a problem for her, do you want

the truth of justice to release khanyova , however, over time, the decision to replace the judge was suspended from the administration of justice for only six months, and later she even went for a promotion in may 2020. she headed the vovchanskyi district court of the kharkiv region . now iryna ukhanova, the oppressor of the occupiers , helped the russians create an occupation judicial body on the basis of the ukrainian court . on february 28, she gathered employees of the court apparatus and tried to convince lured them to go over to the side of the enemy with ten thousand rubles and assured them that the russian military did not pose any threat . who is sentenced to life imprisonment and according to ukrainian law she has not been released and de facto is still a ukrainian judge and in khanyova not one has gone to cooperate with the occupiers and some retired judges, in

particular in the temporarily occupied melitopol , they go on life support by the state and deprive them monthly payments ukraine is also currently not possible, however, we hope that in the near future the supreme council of justice will be replenished with new honest members who will be able to correct this , sbu employees exposed the kyiv judge a supporter of the russian peace, he agitates acquaintances to support the occupiers, justifies russian aggression, and calls ukrainians fascists, i.e. bendyrov people are oppressed, fascists ride all-rounders here , they feel good about you. when we don't need this war

, the youth informed the judge about the suspicion of inciting collaboration and justifying russian aggression, for this the judge himself will be on the dock and on the bunks can spend as many as 15 years distinguished himself and another crimean judge from yevpatoria, he contributed to the new wave of deportation of the local population of the peninsula to siberia, a former judge from the temporarily occupied crimea, after the seizure of the ukrainian peninsula, he voluntarily joined the invaders, for this they appointed him the so-called judge of the yevpatoria city court, while in his position, an enemy publicist made illegal decisions regarding the forced deportation of local residents to remote regions of the russian federation, including siberia, we already went through this in history lessons a muscovite invades our lands, the local population is taken to siberia, then declares

our crimea here, our people live there, they speak russian in kyiv, four more judges from the temporarily occupied crimea are being tried for violating the laws and customs of war, larisa likhacheva, mykhailo bilousov, viktor mohylyanskyi and andriy kulishov in in 2014, after the occupation of the peninsula by russia, they betrayed their oaths and went to work for illegally created judicial bodies. for eight years, they all persecuted crimean tatar and pro-ukrainian activists in crimea and passed sentences by name russia was deprived of liberty and fined for participating in peaceful actions against these so-called judges , criminal cases were also initiated for committing high treason because the officials are still in the temporarily occupied territory , they are tried in absentia, and this simple god judge decided to take advantage of the war and build a career before the occupation oleksiy

turchenko of mariupol was a judge of the district court until the arrival of the rashists, he completely voluntarily took on the duties of the chief of staff of the primorsky district court created by the russo-nazis for such a former court ukrainian themis will be sentenced to 12 to 15 years with confiscation of property. by the way, this is not the first prank of the collaborator. in 2014, he released from responsibility the owner of the donetsk printing house that printed bulletins, military tickets and propaganda newspapers for the militants and removed all precautionary measures and released the so-called press minister of the terrorist dpr volodymyr nesterenko, for this activists set fire to turchenko's car in 15th year, this time the judge will impose a much more severe punishment on the lover of the russian dimension for treason. we have already talked about lovers of the russian world . how can we not mention in the release the scandalous judge of lviv, until recently a member of the supreme court