many people and public figures are outraged by this appointment, uh, in nadiya, what is the possibility that they will be listened to, or is it possible that ms. ilashchuk was recalled from this position, and will they finally hear those ukrainians who say that, well, it is not possible to appoint such a person to such a position in such a time time, well, now everything depends on the usual from the president of ukraine, who signed the decree on the appointment from the minister of foreign affairs, who tried to justify this appointment . an administration that has been doing something for three and a half years that you don't like, maybe someone doesn't like it, so they made such a decision, and i think that it's the

president who doesn't know her personally. there are other people who are engaged in diplomacy. in the president's administration, you know what the office, in fact, he now leads external and internal personnel policy, and he determines what should and should not be. i am sure. well, with horror. to tell the ambassadors of the big seven how ukraine will conduct its policy is not absolute , it is not part of his competence in his task, but if he has such an influence on personnel appointments and on the implementation of foreign policy, well, unfortunately, i don't see anything good in this, let's just hope what can we say to the same service lady. she was in bulgaria and will be assisted by a professional team that will still be able

to solve the issues and tasks that the president poses, although again this is a blow to the authority of ukraine as a state thank you, mr. yaroslav yaroslav voytko , an expert-international diplomat was in touch with us, we talked a little about the activities of ukrainian diplomacy during this difficult year, meanwhile, users and journalists found an interesting announcement about the activities of olesya ilashchuk, who is currently appointed as an ambassador of the embassy of ukraine in bulgaria, if we can show this ad there, she conducts uh, uh, uh, she conducted trainings in 2017. someone dug into the training well, it was called женская сила секреты соблазнения экспертной сексуальной мастерство как to get what you want from a man with advanced techniques, she conducted an oral manual caress training in kryvyi rih, er, i don’t know if it’s some kind of coincidence that this motherland had

our president, or if it’s just that this city was among the other cities in the training program, however users, journalists, various videos where she conducts these trainings about how to seduce a man, those techniques, maybe there is also such a video, who knows it? and now, what could be, i think that she taught those women and men some kind of applied meaning, maybe such people also came to her trainings, although the training shows how to seduce a man, but we live in a free world, that's why there were probably all kinds of listeners, eh, i don't know how useful these skills will be in the diplomatic service , they were useful. he has an expectation, that means they were useful to you, here is the answer well,

no, well, there is probably a gift of persuasion, some one hundred percent, maybe it just works, you know, that is, he will go to bulgarian, a little pro-russian orientation, and so on he will build a conversation correctly, he will find some nlp techniques, maybe hypnosis, maybe some more charms, bars, solutions, maybe even lessons, all kinds of amulets, talismans, well, in a word, something and it will work like that, a person will fall over on the second day, stand on the left foot and suddenly become a ukrainian patriot, forget the bulgarian language and even the old woman speaks bulgarian with a galician dialect. not chernivtsi. chernivtsi is like that, and in general she just gives us all the weapons that only bulgaria has. so let's see. i think there is an iron calculation in foreign policy departments of ukraine. so, let 's not get ahead of ourselves. the government of the fart

always succeeds in everything, even when everyone says that nothing will succeed, so that. so, now we will talk again about military and military topics, and i would like to offer our viewers such a this week there are all kinds of videos from the ledge that reach us. the first video we were all surprised by was when the russians decided to make a video about europeans who freeze and as a result eat their beloved hamster. the video was without words, their next video already appeared with words there, the characters of that video spoke in german, although i don't know what the germans would do if they responded to this video , was there any russian accent, whether it was german or not, and there was already a full one in that video a gentleman's set and a dog eaten uh and uh air alarm and dad some kind of this what is it called lord with a gas mask and and gifts sports pants with a pixel well,

now the russians shot another video but already us actually of course those videos were not so much on the europeans for the sake of themselves but now they already have one more motivational video for the russians, let's watch it together.

they are poor, that is, it's just a miracle, you're watching this , but even in this video, something was destroyed, a hamster and a dog now crushed an orange tree vladyslav seleznyov , a military expert and a colonel of the armed forces of ukraine, watched this video with us - great p vladislav, how did it motivate you, it didn’t affect you at all, although you must give credit, you look at what russian propaganda is doing, it writes for a reason, it spends two billion dollars a year on its existence, because, well, among other things , they constantly spread the same lies, including with the help of such social videos it is obvious that putin's propaganda in this way is trying to motivate the russian environment to participate in the so-called special high-level operation, and it is for good reason, because

it is obvious that starting from january, maxim with february, and then a new wave of mobilization will be launched - this is obvious, because why the bulls that were called up this year in the period from september to november, well, in fact, they are already coming to an end, because the number of russians is increasing every day by several hundred people, and of course, the trend that we are now we can see that it will continue, because then how many generals , uh, often, often, are engaged in incredibly stupid things , they send ukrainian positions to be well fortified, badly equipped, poorly equipped, poorly equipped with russian assault rifles units, they will very quickly, due to the effective fire of ukrainian artillery, turn into the same good flat ones, that is, 200 russians, and this story will repeat itself every day . they say there is no success at the front with regard to missile terror tactics, but we have success in destroying the critical energy

infrastructure of our country. well, obviously, this is some kind of satisfaction, although there is some kind of amber in these er, especially in order to turn on the wind for us, i went outside, because probably at home, er, the electricity went out, or where you were , there is no electricity, there is no stable internet connection, so yes- yes, to hear it, i went out here, uh, of course, i ’m still asking about their mobilization resource, that is, he went to us in the russians, the most surprising thing is we, we probably understand their plans, in fact, well, even this video, it ’s hard for me to imagine such a video somewhere on ukrainian television or anywhere else he did not motivate anyone to do anything, in fact , first of all, he is untalented, his message is like this well, he is not designed for terribly stupid people

, first of all, secondly, more precisely, thirdly, if he finds them, they spend 2.5 dollars, to be honest , mr. vladislav, as i see now that the mercedes that is in the frame is probably not rented. and this is something that was stolen for the allocation of resources and the producer bought it for himself, this er, this mercedes, and for the rest, the actors were already hired there for a bottle of vodka, which is called and here is something this is exactly how we shot it in the frame well, we see those who come to fight with us , where are they from and what are they, and in this video we see some elite district in some st. petersburg or moscow, and well- dressed, even those men who are actually boys, and these women are also well-dressed. in some such uh hats on half heads, well , that is, this is some kind of no no not all of russia, yes , in fact, it seems to me that the target audience of this kind of social video is more

residents of large cities of the uh russian federation, because residents of uh depressed regions of the russian federation they can allow yourself to live in such elite residential complexes, and that's why we see this year, but as we continue, we actually understand the russians that we are very surprised about them and what the fighters say about, for example, in bakhmut, eh, this is their fatalism, their willingness to die that is, we sometimes don't understand that, but we talked about the same thing with bohdan yesterday. what a sweetheart i was. i talked to the culturolas. he said that we constantly say, why won't they rise up, why won't they do something, why are they going to die ? why do they support this war? but we are not slaves. but we cannot understand that they are all slaves. there is no such thing in them that they will rise up. they do not even have such an idea. they do not have that dignity. we are there and

you think that it means that the neighbors must have it, but they just might not have it, but actually this fatalism that we see in those prisoners is the video when that prisoner is wounded, they blow themselves up with a grenade and no one kills him, he knocks himself out, well i.e. probably he could have survived, but you may not have been able to. maybe there, we heard that the wagnerites have a special unit that kills those who somehow got in the way on the battlefield, but this fatalism is whether it applies to all sections of the population or they can supply those idiots who will go and die like those wagner prisoners without end and without end , judges from what we see with you , in reality, this is how it is, and the same long-term selective selection has come to the point that there is no resistance in the majority of residents

of the russian federation, separate cells, separate activists, separate e-e opinion leaders, they either covered their heels by leaving the borders of the russian federation or e-e hid, waiting for some changes in muscovy, but it is obvious that the same united resistance movement has no immediate prospects, hardly it will be because there are neither prerequisites nor relevant movements that were supposed to concentrate all this activity on their own interests and, accordingly, all these interests will ultimately be transformed into the interests of the russian federation, because it is impossible in such in the conditions to live, what are the tasks facing the ukrainian army in front of ukraine in 2023, what should it be and what challenges are also facing us well, it is obvious that we must understand that the year 23 is becoming, must become the year

of our victory, our triumph of courage which will be realized er and our transformed victory from outside as a way of destroying the enemies by liberating the territory of ukraine at the border of the year 111. of course, this is an extremely ambitious task that needs to be solved by us all together not only by defense of the ukrainian people, which acts with the support of our western partners, we need weapons, we need ammunition, we need world support. this is obviously a very important factor that allows us to look confidently into the future, and we see a lot of statements by leading experts and leading experts who are convinced that victory will be with ukraine and only the question of the price of this victory, in your opinion, can russia in principle still turn the course of the war in its favor and in some way that they performed a very important factor of e-e

influence on the situation in such a way that save hundreds of hundreds of thousands of lives of their own soldiers. they only have to gather from the territory of ukraine and then go on the negotiation track regarding the compensation of those property losses that ukraine suffered as a result of full-scale aggression, this is the only opportunity for russia to get some kind of victory, that is, a victory by saving life and health i, those in which are currently participating in the so-called special military operation, they do not have another way in any other option, all those in which the russian occupation army that are operating on the territory of our country or will become cripples as a result of transfers will be put dead as a result of the destruction of the ukrainian defense forces, well, that is, putin is determined to fight to the last, he does not care that they, those russian soldiers will become cripples, will they lie somewhere on the battlefield, will we be missing , will they be packed there piece by piece into a

ball and sent home, so this war can continue for a long time, because there is a lot of mobilization stock in russia, can russia succeed except that she will bombard us with her chmobikes and other all kinds of mobikes, e.e. to some to some other way, now there is also terror , this missile, what, what else could be, will putin's russia dare to use a nuclear component, i think not, as well as biological and chemical weapons of mass destruction, the russians will not dare to use them, because according to the appropriate means of communication, i think that the experts on the territory of the russian federation, who take care of me, including with these issues, have received absolutely clear the signal will open a non-collective institution, an attempt to use weapons of mass destruction of the russian army will lead to fatal consequences, both

directly in the midst of those actors who make such decisions, and for the russian federation as a whole, and those plans of the russians to prepare a few more divisions, reformat their aviation there and strengthen them, arm them with the latest weapons, i don't know, they are constantly telling me that the aromas are already going to donbas, that they have already transferred the fifth-generation su-57 planes there with an unspecified number, whether two or four, i don’t know for sure whether or not four. it seems like a lot of guns. will the russians really manage to prepare such an army, a new invasion army ? literally the other day, i spoke with the guys who left the territory of the temporary full crimea, one of the reasons why they left the occupied

territory, after eight years of being there, is the desire to avoid the same mobilization processes that, in their opinion , will not start in crimea, including in january in february of next year, so they are ready to fight with weapons in their hands, however, the aggressor in the ranks of the ukrainian defense forces, but they are not ready to go to the spell as the same chemobiks in the russian occupations. so it is obvious that human resources in the russian federation, but in terms of technical resources, they have very, very serious problems, because it is obvious that the sanctions are working, it is also obvious that the defense industry of the russian federation is to some extent fake and unable to provide for all the needs of the russian people, that's why i think that there are statements, there will be efforts, but will they be implemented, it is certain that no, i mean about the creation of new units and units of associations of associations with the help of which putin hopes to win this

fraction from ukraine thank you mr. vladislav vladyslav seleznyov military an expert colonel of the armed forces of ukraine joined us on the air. well, we continue to sum up the results of the year a little, and in fact , all kinds of influential foreign publications, for example, the british deconomist, e-e, also write their summaries of the year and in one of these summaries he actually called ukraine the country of the year and dedicated an article to ukraine and actually this one you can see on the screens now and this article ended with the words glory to ukraine well, this is also such interesting information if i say colleagues from nv which until now it was called novoe vremya, it was deciphered, they decided that this name no longer corresponds to their values, and

from now on it is officially deciphered as new voice, new voice, and they remind you that the name was even before the occupation of crimea, then you remember, you probably don't remember, but it was beautiful jedan sanasom er, it's us sundance, my god, i've already forgotten everything, the americans and the american investors who came here founded the magazine, the first ukrainian newsweek, what was the course of the correspondent, who was then squeezed out of him after yanukovych, they made him a cesspool, er, informational, here everyone is in the studio the journalist team resigned as a sign of protest and then founded, after the victory , there are dignities, new times, which is already called no voice, a new voice, and we hope that these times with ukraine will not be repeated again, because we did not want our old rakes, er, they beat us, er, everything is changing, and

today klitschko wrote and has 10,000 likes, by the way, we renamed a million streets in our city, the de-russification of the city is going on, well, vitaly, well, it’s true. everything is cool. everything is cool. well, look in odessa. shchors is doing it in the capital of ukraine, you are waiting for him to be hit by a bomb like your head, someone is cutting himself. and if it doesn’t hit, well, you can’t rely on the muscovite, you have to do it yourself , be cheerful. shchors, go away, and there is someone else there who is terrible. well, that’s it. later the head of the analytical direction of the anca network is in touch with us mr. ilya, we welcome you to our airwaves good day did the economist name ukraine ukraine of the year as ukraine did it manage to survive in economic terms would

we actually manage to survive on our own if not for everyone's help of those countries that are now calling us the country of the year, of course there is no help, if it was not there, we would not be able to resist because we fulfill our obligations directly to the citizens to finance our army with such a financial resource of such a potential there was no ukraine, but what can be said about what we have in the pluses, why did we achieve what is positive, er, this is a question, for example, of the banking system, the banking system from the first day showed its sufficiently high stability of the reforms that were carried out from 15 to 19 years, when the cleaning of the banking system took place when the appropriate legislative norms were developed and adopted, and an improved management system for supervision of banking structures was developed, it allowed us to directly enter the war with a sufficiently stable system, and we see that even these attacks

even this destruction made it possible to continue working, even for those people who believed that abroad they had the opportunity to receive their funds, to withdraw, to settle calmly in relation to a-a business, then there are certain stages, stages of course march april - this is a significant drop, then it is on the shutdown of the enterprise, this especially applies in the occupied territories, there is significant uncertainty, high risks of destruction of infrastructure, destruction of direct production facilities, etc. already in april , decoupling began to take place, business began to actively return and we can see about may, june, july and august. and this is the recovery of business over the depopulated territories, the economy has already become more stable, business has adapted, and it would be good if there was a 30% drop, of course, this is a

significant drop, but we see what in the last two months, there has been a very strong impact on our energy infrastructure. as a result, the company is now again forced to stop and optimize its activities, and as a result, we will have additional lost a few percent of the domestic product, that's why the business still survived, it survived very well, it continues to work, continues to function, but still, the losses for the economy as a whole are very significant , you understand. you are talking about unconditional achievements, fantastic, fantastically professional, cool work of the bankers of the banking sector of the national bank, who were obviously ready for this war, were preparing for this war, had

an action plan because the first decisions were made lightning-fast literally two hours after the invasion and but you very well remembered those people who tried to carry out this reform and i'm just now thinking about the fact that, for example , pikalov and koshovoy - these are two people from the 95th block of comedians today received orders from the president of ukraine for their activities now during the war to support morale and so on and so on, i in no way undermine the fact that they deserved these awards, but these are the same people who ridiculed gontareva and behaved very badly, and it seems to me that now a good it would be time to celebrate valery gontaryu and yakov smoliya in the same way for the

very important and difficult work they did in securing, protecting, preparing the ukrainian economy, the banking system for the future invasion, and the future war. well , in principle, for any situation, i am completely i agree with you why because it really is a special merit of valery gontareva and as we can see how negative the attitude was in society as a whole and i would like to say that not only directly but also not always ukrainian people, ukrainians, they adequately assess the changes that have taken place. i remember poland when the reforms were carried out there, how strongly they hated baltserovych for his reforms, and now you will see how poland itself is flourishing accordingly, to what extent they have stable institutions, how much economic growth they have, therefore after all, you must always trust those people, professionals who understand, experts who understand what

the country needs to do. do not be guided by populism, do not be guided by some very narrow personal interests, but also in the interests of the state, what happened directly from 16-15-16 and the 17th years was the management of the interests of the state to build a stable and powerful banking system. then, well, you absolutely rightly pointed out that these decisions were prepared in advance and as a result, they were lightning fast adopted system was protected from hackers, many people do not know how powerful the kharkiv attack was in the first days of the attack, not only a military invasion, but actually they wanted to stop completely all our information services and banking system in the first place and they did not succeed , that is, our banking system and our treasury system, it turned out to be very reliable and stable. and do you know anything about the mass media in

privatbank? have you heard anything about this situation, what is it connected with, well, the term as they say that he came and the leadership of the supervisory board began to be changed, but let's see how the situation will develop further, why because previously the supervisory board showed itself to be lightning-fast, it defended the interests of the state directly in international courts, it did not allow kolomoisky's plan to be implemented in order not to pay on the related credit of privatbank, which became state-owned and in this way, but to actually rob the state, which was forced to take on the debts created artificially by kolomoisky in front of his structures, i.e. she showed a very reliable, effective and result. of course, how will the new team be? i still receive the world e-e comments on the forecasts of how the year will continue to develop in the situations of privatbank, for example, i do not have any significant reservations, if you can

try to give a forecast of the economic macroeconomic situation for the next year in a minute mr. ilya, would you dare to try this? of course, this is not a noble thing. well, i can say the following. why, because first of all, it is very much left to how the situation at the front will develop, but in the de-occupied territories and in the territories that were not occupied, we can to say the following: investments are already starting to arrive, enterprises are starting to recover, it would be very good if the government, instead of thinking of a marshal plan and dividing hundreds of billions of dollars, thought about business today, because business today is in those he continues to suffer from difficult conditions, i have already talked about this constantly and this problem has not been solved, a lot goes into the blocking of tax invoices, in fact, tax invoices now do not allow business to work, so for next year, create appropriate conditions, so we often talk about investments, but we need to

change our minds, not investments we need we need international corporations of all international corporations that are possible to come to ukraine , american companies, french companies of the european union, they must be invited here and construction contracts should go to countries that give us money, and in this case, of course, ukrainians will work, we will receive wages, we receive taxes accordingly, but we will make this process transparent, so we must make sure that companies have the opportunity to enter, they would have the protection of our judicial system, they would have a suitable climate so that they do not create artificial obstacles for you to carry out your activities on the territory of ukraine and thus prepare the ground so that all this can be done for we don't even need to have the end of hostilities yet. thank you very much, mr. ilya ilya