with electricity resources to renew those enterprises that worked before the first attacks on the power system, then if we are talking about reconstruction and, er, restoration, er, first of all, no money at the moment, er, has not been provided by our partners specifically for reconstruction, they provide us with funds, america, for example provides 1.5 billion per month, this is money that you and i eat, and this is what closes and the europeans also provide somewhere around this amount, it simply closes holes in our budget, i.e. the money that comes from interstate partners goes to social benefits for pensions for teachers' salaries for everything we consume in the country because everything we earn in the country we give to the armed forces for our defense and security , so at the moment we are talking about the fact that something is being rebuilt from scratch, we are building a city, a garden in the country of sat and so on, now she unfortunately , it does not go and no large amounts of funds do not

come, if something comes, then it is a place for local communities to restore schools, to restore social infrastructure, there are no large projects at the moment, but on the other hand, i want to tell you that there is no understanding what we will do on the first day of our victory yes, what will be rebuilt first, which enterprises do we need, how do we want, which investors we want to attract , this is what needs to be done right now, so that those big investors who want to invest billions and millions in ukrainian economy tomorrow they knew that in the afternoon after the victory they can come in and start building factories to develop their business and so on, he writes. to be honest, i am very skeptical about who will come and develop the economy and business of our victory with you well, there is a certain skepticism, so to speak, and i understand it, so on the other hand, we do not forget, by the way, i support your somewhat skeptical and cautious

view regarding the level of losses of our industry, so to speak, we understand that the decline of the economy is multifaceted and let's not forget that since millions of ukrainians earned abroad, so to speak, by importing living funds into our economy, what chains were formed at the time, that is, at the grassroots level. well, accordingly, the fiscal policy is approaching accordingly. changes for the better or for the worse will be in the fiscal policy. i think that the fiscal policy will remain until the 23rd year, it will remain de facto as it was in the 22nd year. i do not believe that anyone will do radical tax reforms during the martial law because the first companies and employees are not ready for this in order to implement a categorically different system of tax administration, you must

first train accountants, train employees, train tax officials and then start this whole machine on this moment we we understand that many people have left, many people work from abroad, i don't think that anyone will be able to implement a radically new tax system during the 23rd year. state, but what should be thought about the new e-e tax system and the new economic model, starting with the post-war state, this should be done because with this tax burden, in principle, investors are not interested, you understand, and nina's salary, not for all other taxes, not for very with difficult and burdensome administration of taxes with checks with all the prices complicated, no bureaucratic regulations, we absolutely lose to most of the countries of the world that are building their economies, we can not offer anything better than in other

countries where there is peace, where there is stability, where there is people do not leave because we must understand that we will also have a demographic crisis , many people will not return if the war drags on, and therefore we need to understand and count on the fact that in reality we will stop building castles in the air and realistically see how we can be more competitive and better than other countries and offer this to investors. if we do not do this, no one will come to us either during the war or after the war, we remember how difficult it was for investors to enter even without the war because the judicial system does not work the tax office is not working normally and we know many other problems with you on the bureaucratic front, on the regulatory front, i would say yes. therefore, it should definitely be done and done actively so that with the beginning of the economic recovery or restructuring, i would say yes

she said not the restoration of reconstruction, all this began to work, but during the martial law i think that this is unlikely to happen, i also have corresponding fears . acquired such a great public resonance or there is a need for public resonance, but we understand that for a powerful foreign player, the system of rules in which he would play must be clear. our government and our authorities should do it with the aim that big money while the war is going on means big money for the development of ukraine rather than anything well, at least that is what ms. yuliya klymenko says.

to apologize because i had a power outage and i was actually forced to stop the conversation. let's take a look at today's ratio of the income and expenditure part, then we understand that all financial aid, macro-financial aid, goes to ukraine, well, in fact, it goes to finance social programs, which today the state has obligations to the people, actually when you and i will take a close look at what the international monetary fund wants from us today, that is, the main ideas contained in those papers concern primarily the increase in tax revenues, the actual changes to the tax legislation

which they propose to do are not aimed at improving the investment climate, they are aimed at reducing the state budget deficit , therefore, let's say, the abolition of two percent of the turnover tax there, a return to the lifting of the moratorium on the actual inspections, a return to a full-fledged the introduction of disbursement and cash registers, all those things should first of all be aimed at reducing the budget deficit, i.e. so that there is not such an extremely gratifying gap between income and expenditure when we talk with you about the recovery of the economy without a full-fledged it will be impossible for an investor to come, and it will be impossible for an investor. well, i have a deep conviction that he will not come during the war, so i think that the question of restoring critical infrastructure and the question of restoring normal life in relation to those destroyed

things really takes the budget will continue to take this on itself, but when we talk about uh, let's say the full reconstruction of the ukrainian economy, this is only the post-war period. thank you. and finally, i would like to clarify in your opinion how much it will become. hryvnias next year, if the question is not too difficult and long, so to speak, we have literally a couple of minutes left, oleg and then mrs. yulia, well, look in the budget, those 42 hryvnias are the official exchange rate, and i think it will be lower. well, we traditionally always put it into the budget the exchange rate is actually higher than mine. in addition, if we receive the 47.37 billion dollars of aid that was announced, i think that the total amount of foreign currency inflows to ukraine will be enough to keep the official exchange rate at 36.6 and somewhere around those colors

what is cash today? i have a great hope that somewhere at the end of the 23rd year, we will combine those rates and get uh, this is the order of formation of uh, the market rate of the dollar. the hryvnia exchange rate that we had before the active phase of hostilities, mrs. yulia taking into account the fact that the money has to come, so to speak, it is about 38 billion dollars from our partners to cover the deficit, so there will be less of it because there is a part of it for those who, if they go for weapons, but the eu promised us 18 billion and america promised us one and one billion in a month therefore, in principle, we will cover the budget deficit. and i agree with my colleagues, who just said that we should not expect any radical fluctuations in the exchange rate. it is not worth it. it will be plus-minus around

36-37-38 . as always. course - this is probably the smallest problem in our country, but what we need to think about now is not even the construction of the building , because the reconstruction will really be done with budget funds, and we need to sit down and come to a consensus about the reconstruction of our economy. time is running out and there are no fresh ideas so far, to be honest does not float to the surface thank you very much ms. yulia thank you very much mr. oleg yuliya klymenko people's deputy of ukraine oleg penzin executive director of the economic discussion club and now i am passing the baton to our colleagues tetyana shustrova will now present an extremely interesting conversation in the format of the judicial control program and i wish you, dear tv viewers, bright and clear new year's and christmas holidays, see espresso after this week in the judicial control program with tatiana shustranova, the desperados of the year as

candidates with a dubious reputation and sky-high tried to get to the supreme council of justice with their fortunes, an interesting question. this is how it happened. this is how it happened. it was incredible judicial luck. what manipulations with the declaration ? those who criticized the judicial reform are trying to get to the higher bodies of judicial power. congratulations, this is judicial control, and i am tetyana shustrova together with the team. i wish you a happy christmas and new year do we believe in the victory of our armed forces or do i courage and resilience impresses the whole world and thanks to which for almost six months we have followed the judicial reform that

is taking place in ukraine and is one of the key requirements for our entry into the european union during this time the competition for the higher justice, the selection for the higher qualification commission of judges has begun, a number of important laws have been passed and the corrupt kyiv district administrative court has finally been liquidated, summing up the results of the year let's remember those despairing spirit of the representatives of the old systems that tried with all their might to disrupt important transformations for ukraine, trying to get to the renewed judicial bodies, and fortunately they did not succeed. to your attention, a digest of the judicial control program with the most interesting episodes of 2022. on august 17, the interview was held by the head of the kharkiv

appeals administrative court, gennady borshov in 2017- he had already tried to become a judge of the supreme court, and the higher qualification commission of judges recognized him as unscrupulous, and why then, in particular, questions arose about the judge's opaque fortune and the property of a dubious origin, for example, bershoff claimed that the land cruiser worth over a million hryvnias , which he uses, supposedly belongs to his mother, who had no official income, or even a driver's license, but according to the elder, she worked in a harmful industry for 30 years in order to afford an expensive car and, according to the declaration, to give it to her beloved son 850,000 uah in cash and real estate, according to borscho, the family was provided by the wife, first she bought an apartment in the center of kharkiv, then an apartment in

yalta in the public council of virtue they emphasize that the value of the property indicated in the declaration is understated by at least a third of the market price, which may indicate deliberate manipulation. he has been gone for several years. he has been living in a building that he does not put into operation . was in yalta with an area of ​​52 m², which was purchased in october 2013, he indicates that it cost only uah 149,000, this is a ridiculous price, not even for yalta, for yalta, and even more so for such an apartment square in the resort town of gurzuf, and during the interview he gave such a very funny explanation about the fact that they agreed with the buyer and the seller for such a price. his

wife's business, which allowed the purchase of expensive real estate, is very secret, because even gennady borshov himself did not know in 2017 what does she do, we called the candidate for membership in the supreme council of justice to ask if he remembered who his wife works for, mr. gennadiy. congratulations, this is a judicial control program on the espresso tv channel, we have a few for you questions how was your interview as a candidate for the vrp, were you asked questions about business wives are engaged in your wife really wants our journalism to be invited i will tell you when i was to communicate with journalists but i asked who doesn't call you and that's why i can't comment higher

qualification in 2017 , the commission of judges of ukraine recognized gennady barshov as an unscrupulous judge of the supreme court. he never became a judge, but as we can see, the judge is persistent and does not give up hopes of becoming a member of the supreme council of justice. this is marina kuhar, she is a judge . kharkiv district administrative court and wants to be a member of the supreme council of justice, however, her judicial career has very ambiguous episodes. for example, for several years in a row, marina the cook forgot to indicate in the declaration the 130-square-meter apartment in kharkiv in which she lived until she suddenly became its owner. no, no. she bought it, received it as an inheritance, how exactly did she manage to turn it around and to which family the connections made her the heir is unknown, however , the story is too similar to the manipulation of the

declaration of wealth, presumably in this way marina the cook could hide the real value of the apartment, which she most likely just bought. but this is not the only case when marina the cook has a relationship with dubious real estate. the kharkiv judge was the owner of the prestige cooperative. according to the so-called cooperative scheme of kernes dobkin, the cooperative received an elite plot of land in kharkiv for free, next to the sarzhen yoke, and later it was transferred to private individuals, this may indicate the involvement of the candidate cook in the scheme of theft of communal property, as reported by the anti-corruption center, the father maryna the cook has a joint business with the former people's deputy from the opposition bloc dmytro shentsev, whom russian president putin awarded the medal for a great contribution to the preservation and popularization of the russian language and culture

abroad, and with businessman volodymyr levchenko, he is a co-owner of the company that received more than uah 50 million for the construction of the project wall on the border with the russian federation right now we can assess its reliability as a candidate for the people's party of ukraine vasyl kuhar was a deputy of the kharkiv regional council from the opposition headed the kharkiv commercial court of appeal local changes once linked him to raiding ties to criminality and the discrepancy between lifestyle and official incomes judicial career and biography of the candidate for the supreme council of justice maryna the cook is far from flawless at the end of august the ethics council held a meeting with her interview, the official results are currently unknown. therefore, we decided to inquire how marina the cook herself evaluates her integrity and the likelihood of becoming a member of the

vrp and called her. congratulations, ms. marina - this is a judicial control program on the espresso tv channel, we have a few questions for you. how was the interview as a candidate for the vrp and do you consider yourself a virtuous candidate? the organization is a tv program on the espresso tv channel. by pro-russian political forces, i don't want to, i don't want to, and i won't. this is the conversation we had with the candidate for the highest judicial authority, unfortunately, even with the beginning of the war, which forced citizens to reevaluate a lot of things about the defiant corrupt and connected with russian deputies, instead of

sitting at home in their undeclared apartments, they continue to push themselves into power where they obviously do not belong and do not want to understand that the way it once was, it will no longer be. of the most active blockers of judicial reform last year, he was building the creation of an ethical council, he claimed that judges do not like this law, and internationalists criticize the council, this is wrong, the judge who blocked the ethical council recently goes to her for an interview, i wonder what he hopes for, an expert from the anti- corruption center, halyna chyzhik, does not hide her indignation, it is disgusting to watch the monyach who spoke about the fact that the ethics council is not constitutional, the participation of international experts in this is not constitutional, he is now going to

participate in the competition we assume that bohdan monich forgot that he is against the judicial reform , which he now wants to be a part of. but we have not forgotten about his bright past. munich headed the council of judges in 2019, the district administrative judge court pavlo vovk, an official from the yanukovych era, andriy portnov and the then head of the presidential administration, andriy bohdan , ousted the chairman of the council, oleg tkachuk, and replaced him with the convenient bohdan monich. this was recorded on the so-called vovka tapes released by our colleagues from the investigation. nikka ne smogu ukraine nikka

proek and so on he followed orders and did not touch the district administrative court publicly defended him and criticized the presidential bill on liquidation because he is obviously dependent on judicial clans and influential judges , such as pavlo vovk, the chairman of the district administrative court, and bohdan romanich got his position as chairman of the council of judges thanks to pavel vovk, he obviously acts according to the instructions which he receives from the same head of the ops, pavel vovka, there and from other leaders of the judicial mafia, with the beginning of the full-scale invasion of russia, bohdan monich did not lose his enthusiasm in the fight against judicial reform and independent judicial bodies taking advantage, he tried to eliminate the ethics

council from evaluating candidates for the supreme council of justice, in particular, he demanded that this function be transferred to the council of judges headed by him, the judicial mafia simply decided to use the war in order to try to eliminate the ethics council from reforming the supreme council of justice, that is, again, to ensure getting the right people to the supreme council of justice, in april of this year, meetings were held on the basis of the committee on legal policy of the supreme council of japan, or did he comment there various initiatives, advocating for actually transferring the powers of selection and possibly even election during martial law, that is the joy of the essence, that is, even a congress of judges would not have to be convened, the council of judges, which it heads, would have to choose new members by itself at the high council of justice because it is alleged that the

war writes everything, bohdan monyacha's family owns three plots of land, a 330 -square-meter house near zhytomyr, and several apartments in vinnytsia and zhytomyr. it should be noted that monyacha also has a special judicial superpower to buy real estate at a price several times lower than the market price, according to the declaration, a house with more than 300 square meters costs $19,000, and an apartment in zhytomyr is only $1,900. we would like to be happy for such luck in buying real estate, however, unfortunately, we can only state that this is very similar to banal manipulations and attempts to hide real wealth bohdan monyacha 's mother loves her son so much that she gave him more than half a million hryvnias over the course of several years, although her official income in

those years was a little over 32,000 hryvnias. the head of the kivertsi district court of the volyn region, viktoriya koretska, she prefers to become a member of the high council of justice and considers herself worthy of this position. she is very self -confident, considering her biography. episodes deserve special attention, why did you sell yes , of course, an interesting question, unfortunately, this happened and some time passed. we realized that there would be no need for us to build there and we would not be able to go there so they lost driving in 8713. viktoriya

koretska not only makes, as she says, ill-considered decisions, but also forgets something, for example, for several years in a row, to indicate the car in the declarations, which language do you use, you start declaring this car only in the 16th year , at that time it was the 14th or the 15th -he has been recorded crossing the border, for example , you personally in this car probably did not think about it either, and forgot several times to indicate in the declarations the land plots that she owns together with her husband, oleg koretsky, the prosecutor of the general prosecutor's office and in general, to inquire where her husband lives regarding accommodation well, he doesn't add, i asked you more than once. he claims that i live with a friend of mine. i don't rent an apartment because i don't

have enough money to rent an official apartment. friends well, really enough friends. he has been working in the general prosecutor’s office for not the first year, just without commenting on his friends, for example, we believe all the more. the judge honestly told how koretsky’s work in the prosecutor general’s office helped him in this, probably once. friends also helped the husband of koretskaya lyubomlsky, the inter-district prosecutor of the volyn region during yanukovych's time, to get a promotion instead of lustration. in 2016, the father of judge victoria korytskaya, a pensioner , bought a house of almost 200 m², in a beautiful cottage town according to the judicial tradition , he bought it for 1 million uah, although the market value of such the same house without renovation from the developer , i bought it for two million, and on the same day, i gave it to

my daughter and my son-in-law, the prosecutor, for indefinite use where did the pensioner's father get such funds from ? viktoriya koretska of course he does not know that this house was purchased by my father, he is engaged in entrepreneurial activities, he is a pensioner for pensioners of the ministry of internal affairs, he pays taxes on a single tax, when i applied for the date of information, he refused me, which he submitted, accordingly, a notarized statement that he refuses to provide and disclose any information about his e-e business activities according to the de jure foundation, the judge is known for exonerating drunk drivers from punishment on the basis of the expiration of the terms of consideration of the case at least 10 times in 2019, she helped a driver who, in a state of alcohol intoxication, hit a cyclist to death. koretska sentenced him to 5 years, but released him from the punishment and did not even deprive him of his

driver's license . - in fact , a person who did not just commit the offense of drunk driving, but simply hit a person to death and did not bear any responsibility, is actually relieved of responsibility, and it is obvious that such judges not only cannot a-a participate and do not determine who should be judges and who should not be what actually belongs to the competence of the supreme council of justice a and in principle, there should not be judges, we called viktoria koretskaya to ask about the origin of the wealth , there is the declaration and smearing of drunk drivers hello greetings you, mrs. viktoria, this is a judicial control program on the espresso tv channel, we have a few questions for you. please tell me why you keep forgetting to indicate property in the declarations, for example, cars or land plots , when to call you back. it was

the final digest of the judicial control program with the most interesting episodes of 2022, the candidates whom you saw, fortunately, are no longer participating in the competition for the supreme council of justice, however, they still have high powers as judges despite a very dubious reputation, large fortunes of unknown origin and a large number of disciplinary proceedings regarding judicial decisions for them as well as the judicial reform in general we will continue to monitor and in the new year may 2023 bring us victory greetings this is freedom lime my name is vlasta azure war by war