precisely people, because our human capital is people who are self-sacrificing, professional with unique e-e skills, this is precisely the biggest contribution in the future. many experts clearly say to the closed regime that yes, crimea is an absolutely realistic goal for this year and therefore we must continue to work, but the question of what to do next with the russian federation, which nuclear weapons do they have, where are they no and who will be putin's successor is not understood, where they have fear that if it is a parade of sovereignties, what will it strengthen china, which will start uh, uh, let's say parts of russia increase their uh, influence, presence,

expansion, so our task is precisely to explain that the loss of russia - this is the weakening of china and, in general, the entire club of authoritarianism, and only such messages should be added to the decisions of the consolidated event. well, it is important to go and work in washington already with the start of the new congress with the republicans , and to convince them of these arguments that ukraine and so she has already given her counter-arguments and convinced why the acceleration of victory is in the interests of both the united states of america and nato and, in general , everyone who is in the rammstein coalition and the democratic world. foreign policy expert, chairman of the board of the network for the protection of national interests and nts, people's deputy of the previous convocation,

mr. kolleba said that the next meeting in the rammstein format will take place soon and we can wait for the news. well, as long as we don't forget about the pre-war era, we will tell stories, but preparatory. the court hearing in the case of a people's deputy in our country regarding the offer of a bribe to a policeman was postponed yesterday due to the suspect's non-appearance. he can distribute humanitarian aid, according to the lawyer, the official version of the people's deputy fell ill with covid according to the version of the investigation, we will remind you that in august 21st, the people's deputy offered 150,000 to the patrolmen so that he would be allowed to leave the scene of an accident that happened with his participation, see the story this story gave rise to many humorous internet memes on the topic of deputy trukhin and lisnyk, i will come there. and many more serious questions for the law enforcement system

. on august 23, 2021, a road accident occurred near kyiv in which six people were injured. almost immediately, the media reported that the driver of the car that caused the accident could be deputy of the servant of the people , oleksandr dorynyn, there were speculations that he might have been driving in an intoxicated state. did you find him behind the wheel of the car that was caught? who was a passenger, and i had no right to comment because i gave subscribers in the first place, not disclosure, 5 months have passed, the investigation has not yielded any results, they say that the recordings from the chest cameras of the police have been deleted and it is impossible to establish the truth . made public the same video recordings, they testified that trukhin could not only be behind the wheel, but also tried to disappear from the scene of the accident, everyone

is ready, he promised to solve the issue with the minister of internal affairs, denys knastrosky place and offered the law enforcement officers 150,000 something that was lying in his bag in the trunk . 150 is what happened. this is candy with chocolate and cookies. viktor sklema , assistant to the deputy of the poltava regional council , took the blame for the accident. the punishment that threatens the deputy with up to four years in prison, this is the plot, well , we will talk about this one, about the other, articled

kozachenko, a public figure, a lawyer, the head of the public lustration committee glory to ukraine glory to the heroes, we are glad to see you well , we would like to ask you about the prospects of this no doubt high-profile case, having more than 20 years of practice in the courts of ukraine, it is extremely difficult to predict the future, because the political influence on any case, public influence in in which case and judges usually make decisions that are comfortable for them, uh, taking into account all the circumstances of the video, which was a little wrong, it is obvious to everyone, it was so widespread, but i would pay attention to other problems, first of all, this video it became known six months after the accident occurred and about six people were injured,

and it became known thanks to investigative journalists, and the law enforcement officers themselves and these people who are supposed to prove were underreported . police officers are still not able to act publicly and protect the law, but are looking for ways to do it because they themselves do not believe in the system in which they are and the fact that they should investigate the case, they have already done it only after there was an investigation, it took them as much as six months to take the case to the court frankly enough. there will definitely be problems here and there will be problems regarding whether there is a video that is possibly obvious to everyone, it cannot be obvious to the court, unfortunately, because

it is necessary to understand that what years was it on the video, is it admissible evidence or is it because it has been walking in different ways for too long and er. most likely, the defense will try to knock out this evidence in general, this crime is possible for up to four years, but there and it is not enough for small states from a thousand tax-free minimums of citizens, this is a symbolic amount, then for the more fundamental issue is that the person against whom the sentence has been passed cannot be a people's deputy, and directly the same there is already a decision regarding an administrative offense where it is assigned to an assistant directly of the people's deputy and to what extent the investigation in general did everything possible to really establish who was behind the wheel, this question

will only become known and the development of events and additional information and the position that will be lit up during the trial and what is obvious and fair to all people, let's very much hope will be properly proven in court with proper and objective evidence, because exclusively legal laws should be applied to any person of any person procedures, we agree, the procedures must be legal , but we understand that any situation very often contains, so to speak, a corruption - genic niche for many clever people, well, accordingly, we would like to ask you about the fraud with property by one of the actors mr. dovbenka seems to have been put on the wanted list, the organizer would not have a criminal group, you know, the

legal environment of lawyers is so sensitive, and in principle, those who everyone knows make people there ridiculous, impartial citizens who at one time or another were curators or key personal decision makers of financial and other procedural issues in an informal way regarding real estate, in particular dovbenka, which connects e-e not only with the army, it is connected with real estate registers, its direct e-e is connected with the army which e-e resolved the issue regarding the property that was in its implementation, which was then realized there at public auctions, as in this case they are talking about auctions that were planned in such a way that only one person could win, and that the property was transferred,

and the assessment of such property was carried out at a minimum in order to increase the corruption component as much as possible , therefore, everyone knows these personalities, and if in that situation there are also officials, in particular, the ex-head of the army, who was also suspected and the case went to court, who directly put signatures on the documents of the top andriy dovbenka, it is necessary to understand what kind of evidence we all talk about again, everyone knows, but is it proven by proper admissible evidence that the law enforcement agencies are able to do this in order for the court to make a decision, what evidence was handed over because, for example, andriy dovbenko, if he took part in this, then it is clear that this was an unofficial, informal participation, which must be confirmed by what evidence , testimony, what kind of testimony by people, it is additionally

possible to remove information from communication channels from concealment, that is, what kind of evidence is this? we don't know as of today, but the fact that he was declared wanted also raises the question, because if a person publicly declares where he is and officially provides documents, then he is declared wanted - let's say that they act on the account because in those cases it is necessary to apply international legal assistance, to apply legally to the countries, to go to absentee, for example, pre-trial investigation, if the article - it also provides for collecting evidence and searching and saying that we cannot find the question arises, you may not want to find a person, because if a person clearly states in which country he is located, mechanisms must be used and the pre-trial investigation must be brought to a logical end, because every crime must be investigated, every crime must be evaluated by law enforcement

agencies and transferred to court and it is a pity that all our crimes are investigated in this way as soon as a person ceases to belong to the authorities, because regarding criminal proceedings against such persons as andriy dovbenka, everything would be interesting as well as investigations concerning those officials who are in positions all the time and who do not stop acting illegally in relation to the army or in relation to state registers because such cases also occur. thank you ms. tetyana for your professional comments. tetyana kozachenko, public figure, lawyer, head of the public illustration committee we are in touch now we have judicial control with tatyana shustrava do not switch, watch this week in the program judicial control with tatyana shustrava the parade of desperadoes as unscrupulous candidates tried to break through to the higher judicial authorities, he should not have

been confirmed as one who can administer justice, but unfortunately, the higher qualification commission of judges concluded that it did not take into account the candidates for the vrp . it is possible to buy valuable property for nothing. congratulations, this court is control and i am tatyana shustrova together with the team. i congratulate you on christmas and new year's holidays. do we believe in the victory of our armed forces? do i courage and stability impresses the whole world and thanks to which for almost six months you and i have been following the judicial reform that is taking place in ukraine and is one of the key requirements for our accession to the european union, during this time the competition for the supreme council of justice has ended, the selection for the higher qualification commission

of judges has begun, a number of decisions have been made important laws and finally liquidated the corrupt district administrative court of kyiv summing up the year let's remember those desperate representatives of the old system who with all their might they tried to disrupt important transformations for ukraine, trying to get into the updated judicial bodies, and fortunately they did not succeed. for your attention, a digest of the judicial control program with the most interesting episodes of 2022, today we will tell you about judge elena kruhylina. she works in the kharkiv court of appeal, although she will become a member of the supreme council justice and a very compassionate drunkard during her judicial career, kruzhilina helped avoid punishment for at least 19

drivers who drove cars while intoxicated drunkenness, mostly the judge just gives the drivers bail and closes the case, she made a lot of decisions that we overturned the decisions of the courts in the first instance about bringing to justice drivers who get behind the wheel while drunk and commit the actual road accident, if the first instance, for example, was deprived of driver's license, kruzhilina, she very often canceled such a decision and applied such extreme punishments as transfer, for example, to the surety of the labor team. olena kruzhilina is so used to this practice that nothing special even in one of the cases, she made up a drunken driver as surety for the collective, which he himself leads, in another she did not deprive the driver of his license

because it seems that the violator needs a car to perform his work. elenia kruzelinia also needs a car and it is not easy. in 2020, she bought a mazda - it is an x5 of 2019 issue a for almost a million hryvnias, in the end, according to the declaration of the judge and members of her family, they also do not deny themselves expensive purchases. in september 2020, the son of kruzhilina bought three plots of land in the balakliya district of the kharkiv region with a total area of ​​almost 3,000 square meters for more than uah 60,000 . among her savings, kruzelina listed uah 280,000, 25,000 euros and $32,000 in cash. she owns two apartments in kharkiv, bought in 1995 and 2018, but the

judge did not specify their value earlier. the higher qualification commission of judges established that olena kruzelina violated the law during the hearing of the case, she was almost fired for breaking the oath due to the fact that they changed the decision of the court of first instance in the case of the road accident and it was about compensation for the damage caused by the road accident and they significantly reduced the amount of compensation e-e later the supreme court overturned this decision pointing to very significant violations committed by the judges of the court of appeal and actually on the basis of this the higher qualifications commission of judges recommended the dismissal of judge kruhleina, but the higher council of justice refused to do so stanislav yurchenko head of the swativ district court of luhansk region and he considers himself worthy of the position of a member of the supreme council of

justice, although he himself was repeatedly held responsible by it for violating judicial ethics and even the law in 2012 yurchenko himself saved from criminal liability the scandalous roman landik, a member of the luhansk city council from the party of regions and the son of ex-people's deputy volodymyr landik, who was accused of beating a woman who suffered a concussion. the video from surveillance cameras clearly shows how roman landik uses defenseless force in a luhansk restaurant. however, judge yurchenko called it a necessary defense and acquitted regional deputy stanislav yurchenko, who was repeatedly brought to the disciplinary hearing by the high council of justice, a member which he now wants to become. for the first time in 2018, when the judge

violated the presumption of innocence for yurchenko in his articles in the newspaper, he repeatedly allowed violations of the rules of judicial ethics, in particular, he published matchmaking information in the local newspaper. criticized the state geocadastral inspector, then it turned out that all the people were checking the use of the land plot of the enterprise headed by yurchenko's wife and the disciplinary chamber of the supreme council justice brought him to disciplinary responsibility precisely for the fact that he claimed that these persons committed crimes, although in ukraine there is a presumption of innocence, in 2019 the judge was again brought to disciplinary responsibility for the fact that he delayed the consideration of the petition in the criminal case and also forgot to notify in time that the

party u in this case, she offered him a bribe , the law sets a deadline for this at 5 days, yurchenko waited for two months and continued to consider the case in explanations to the supreme council of justice, the judge later explained that he allegedly took the offer of a bribe as a joke, but when he was told about his dismissal, he interpreted it as interference in the court's activities. of course, that could have influenced the change of position of this judge, and this, unfortunately , happens repeatedly with ukrainian judges, and such jokes are actually about illegitimate gain about interference in the professional activity of the judge, as a result, everything boils down to the fact that the judge allegedly misinterpreted such words. we

have already told you about one of the candidates for the supreme council of justice, judge vinnytsky of the district administrative court of oleksandr vilchynsky he has crazy fortunes that are difficult to explain and many stains on his judicial career and what was our surprise when we saw him and in the competition for the higher qualification commission of judges, one can only envy this self -confidence. a place in the higher bodies of the judicial branch oleksandr vilchynskyi headed the vinnytsia district administrative court since 2015 for three consecutive terms, this violates the legislation on the term of office occupying an administrative position, which provides for holding the seat of the head of the court, can be held for no more than two terms, however, oleksandr

vilchynskyi is well versed in the tricks of maneuvering, the expert of the de jure foundation, stepan berko, explains how it was possible to circumvent the law, many judges use various tools in order to somehow justify their stay in these positions in particular, for example , they leave this position prematurely and then claim that they did not meet the deadline because that is why they can once again embrace espano vilchynsky, the situation is the same as the day before of a full-scale invasion of the implementation of february 2, honoring the powers of the head of the court and going on vacation for a whole month or more, having time to go abroad, such facts, etc., raise questions for such an outside observer

. this happened coincides with the beginning of the vacation coincides with the date of the large-scale invasion and this judge is higher abroad, we do not know whether oleksandr vilchynsky has plans to sit in the chair of the head of the vinnytsia district again administrative court, but there are already many questions for him. oleksandr vilchynsky lives in his mother's luxurious estate with an area of ​​more than 630 m² in the suburbs of vinnytsia. in 2017 , the judge's wife bought an apartment in the center of kyiv, in the elite pechersk district, the apartment in this building costs from uah 5 million. vilchynsky claims that the wife bought

real estate is at least three times cheaper, as soon as the judges manage to do this, uah 1.5 million , the declared value of this apartment is 34 times less than the market value, that is, it is not clear how they always manage to buy real estate at very low prices, even this value is still more than half a million hryvnias exceeds, well, if the total declared income of bilchynskyi and his wife for this year, not to mention the money that needs to be invested for e-e repairs or any type of decoration of this apartment, i.e. not even taking into account these things, in 2018, matei's wife, in the summer of 2021, declared there an entire hotel-restaurant

complex dvor litynskyi with an area of ​​almost 2000 m². on booking, it was possible to book this hotel as early as 2019, but in the declarations for both the 19th and 20th years, oleksandr vilchynskyi forgot to indicate it in 2019. . for only uah 590,000, which is at least all times lower than the market value of the land in this regard district, a neighboring plot was purchased by their 23-year-old daughter, there is no information about any of her official incomes that could explain the purchase of a rather expensive plot of land in such and such a national point. meanwhile, the retired mother of oleksandr

vilchynsky, in addition to the huge estate where the judge himself lives, also has one smaller at 245 m². roadside service complex for 530 square meters and two inherited plots of land , as well as according to our colleagues from the court publication as of 2019, a real fleet of five cars, one mercedes-benz she gave the s-class to the already mentioned granddaughter anna vilchynskyi, this is all done in order to avoid the obligation to prove the legality of the origin of the money with which all the property was purchased, but it does not help because such questions arise, and here is the former head of the vinnytsia district administrative court oleksandr vilchynskyi according to the declarations for previous years, there is nothing but a car and a motorcycle. although

he still has some good friends, a friend of the judge, the scandalous deputy head of the district administrative court of kyiv, together with chairman pavel vovkom, he is suspected in a criminal case of usurpation of power, our colleagues from the investigation of info filmed how a few years ago oleksandr vilchynskyi came to congratulate ablov on his birthday, he celebrated in the company of volodymyr butenko, a member of the higher qualification commission of judges, a little later during the qualification evaluation of oleksandr vilchynskyi butenko will be the chairman commission which, of course, recognizes the chairman of the vinnytsia district administrative court as virtuous and suitable for the position he holds, despite the many the facts of vilchynskyi's biography, which contradict this, despite the assessment of experts and the conclusions

of the public integrity council, he should not have been confirmed as one who can administer justice, but unfortunately, the higher qualification commission of judges did not take this conclusion into account in the composition of the chambers that considered this decision, where did mr. butenko belong whom vilchynskyi obviously knows, because they attended the birthday of one odious judge together. interests with one of the members of this colleague. this is exactly how this panel recognized the jury as meeting the requirements of integrity. now judge oleksandr vilchynskyi wants to be a member of the supreme council of justice and the supreme

qualification commission of judges of ukraine. provide recommendations vilchynskyi received very reliable from zenovy holodnyuk, former head of state of the judicial administration of ukraine, a person involved in a criminal case, in particular, he appears in the films vovka, if these types and the investigation are to be believed, in fact, mr. holodnyuk appointed persons loyal to the vovka court to the higher qualification commission in exchange for the fact that wog judge pavlo vovk in his district administrative court of the city of kyiv will block decisions concerning mr. holodnyuk we hope that the competitive commission for the selection of members of the highest qualification commission of judges of ukraine will take into account all the facts

of the biography of oleksandr vilchynskyi that we have mentioned and make a fair decision for him. this was the final digest of the judicial program control with the most interesting episodes of 2022 candidates whom you saw fortunately no longer participate in the competition for the supreme council of justice, however, they still have high powers as judges despite a very dubious reputation, large fortunes of unknown origin and a large number of disciplinary proceedings regarding judicial decisions for them as well as for judicial reform in general we will continue to monitor and in the new year, may 2023 bring us victory and much happiness, we will meet in exactly one week