congratulations on the results of the year. it is safe to say that ukraine is winning in most areas of the information war, that i am an important issue of public communications during the war, it is important to motivate and preserve the unity of one's own people, maintain the support of allies , prevent the enemy from gaining the support of other countries and demoralize the enemy's population, the unity and motivation of the ukrainian people no one has any doubts at all, even in the occupied territories, ukrainians resist even suspiciously in the surrounded the cities did not seem like our army, here the defense is fighting fiercely, it can be argued that we won the battle for the consciousness of our population even in the previous 8 years, when the ukrainians in messia stopped supporting pro-russian politicians and when the ukrainian nation found its place in the world, the only thing that succeeds in

russian propaganda is hnata russians to death, and even here the mobilization showed that as many escaped from it as it was planned to mobilize, russian propaganda was remembered throughout the world this year by nebenzion fictions about deadly trained mosquitoes and we are talking about the crimes of the russian army, what is it all a production? well, of course, white laboratories . how biological weapons were tested on ukrainian volunteers without them. this means that it is also a plus to the fact that the birds we want to infect in the calculated flight paths through russia. well, and to kiev for - in three days he went into the past. literally in the same 3 days, the russians attacked kyiv. well, a maximum of 3-4 ships can go on a raid. there are

literally 5 days left in strya. you can hide the dynamo match in half an hour, and there will still be continuing tanks already near kiev, i am not so immersed in this problem to say that according to the plan, they have it going with the russians, as they say, or as i feel it, i will write again i feel that the operation has been delayed for the second time in russia in this situation, be careful, how do you start a special military operation except for achieving your goals, so there is simply no victory, and of course the outline of this victory on

earth, they can lie in different ways, well it is obvious that they cannot be limited to the territory of the donetsk and luhansk people's republics, the main effort will be contiguity in the donbass and in the south, this is also normal. nikolaev , too, is still in such a not very understandable state, that's where our efforts should be, moreover, after the operation is completed, i don't know, i haven't seen such a requirement anywhere, but anyway the borders of the donbass are not signs of the republics already recognized by us, and the southern regions should be a demineralized zone of the order, but not less than 100 km, so that there are no

, so to speak выбули се бя без еще well, it is desirable, of course, in nikolaev. i am not even in kherson. as you can see, uh, and so, at first, the russian collapse generally tried to play with this story that they spent all these eight years about the civil war in ukraine , that they came to help someone there uh to change the government and the implementation of families it sounded like this with ukraine ukrainians the problem is that ukrainians who are not nazis are now fighting ukrainians who are nazis and it is necessary to liberate all ukrainians who are not nazis and those ukrainians who are nazis well, the ministry of defense briefing on the results of the first month of aggression the ministry of defense of russia showed that

russian propaganda has to explain to its own population both the defeats of the russian army and in general why was all this bombing of the victim why why why in general, they went to other cities, it happened, uh , now you will see. it was a briefing a month later, they were already talking about donetsk at that time. and the funds will be concentrated on the main complete liberation of donbass, that is, you see, the complete liberation of donbass was announced a month after the invasion, from that time, in principle, this was already the main thesis, regardless of where they retreated to where tried to step into any difficult situations, you start talking about the liberation of

donbas. despite this, they still tried to play some kind of uh, you know, in the evacuation of the entire population from big cities, uh, to destabilize something already, when the russian troops were practically leaving kyiv, it was clear they couldn't resist here, they tried to make up a story and tell that there is still such a person alive here, they don't release people from kyiv, look at dozens of messages, well, if not on time, there will be in a few hours kiev and which, despite all the prohibitions, which, despite the work of the security service of ukraine, send e-e information from the ukrainian capital, and here, in fact, the residential quarters of kyiv itself have already been converted into strongholds for the fortified positions of the formation of the kyiv

regime. people are simply driven into basements are not released from the city after these initial failures near kyiv and in the chernihiv region of sumy, russian propaganda tried to disperse such a story that the city must be surrendered well, in fact, it's the first month in general, and all russian propaganda turned out to be like this, you know. well, as if they all fell into such a prostration, they did not expect what happened, and russian propaganda lost a little even some understanding, and then they worked like this a story about the fact that they have to demoralize the population, that where the population is not, the ukrainian army will not be able to resist for a long time , that it can all be resolved quickly, you just need to push it a little, in general, this is the constant story of russian propaganda, and of russia in general it's to raise the stakes to build up, to try to

build up pressure, it worked in this war, it's bad for them, i'll say it right away but nevertheless, they did it, and that's why the main story is this - it was the first e that they cover themselves with the civilian population and you have to surrender the cities, the second is that you have to appear to be military well, that's it these are the rollers, well , they were constantly expanding, literally spaces . look, if they are protecting the city, they must stand . the troops came out from under kyiv, there was an article by tymofia sergeitseva about the fact that there is a need for ukrainization, denazification, where it just boils down to the fact that the ukrainians need to be killed there, classes in concentration camps, eh. well, this line practically continues to this day, but here are the nuances, how

did it go? russian propaganda is going on, what are the gains and where are the losses? let's talk with vitaly kulyk , the director of the center for the study of civil society problems. let's put it this way, i don't see the great success of russian propaganda if you point it out , that is, because propaganda has two uh, two numbers, the first is the audience, it's outside, that is, outside of russia, it's the occupied territories - it's a conditional world there, the west of third world countries, and the internal audience is internal target audiences, let's start with the external er external world. propaganda aimed at the west itself has completely failed, they did not

work on the western audience, and by and large , since about march, we have seen a complete fiasco, now pro-russian measures propagandists in most of the capitals , in fact, no one picked up their jeans, except for small er marginal resources, which in one way or another were repostolates or there were ahelled from rush to there in the chinas of the er third world, relatively speaking, or those countries that tried to maintain conditional neutrality in the war russian propaganda is also present in episodes and on a large scale eh no one in these countries perceives russian propaganda at face value, perhaps with the exception of a few countries eh, it can be said that even in these eh countries such as iran, such as the countries of africa,

the persian gulf, india, south asia, russian propaganda reaches only in the form of official quotes. that is, all these resources that were created by the demyans there for hong kong, for thailand, for the philippines, in india, in the persian gulf, all these resources are michael numbers, as a rule hmmm, they complained already in the first one and a half to two months, and the telegram channels actually died even in the middle of march, which were aimed at this audience. but regarding the russians directly, the russian panda inside the slippage of the russian team it began to be noticeable not immediately, that is, at first this drive that we are capturing the whole country, that here we are about to capture kyiv, then here we are

capturing half of ukraine along the dnipro, we will go to the dnipro, and similar narratives they and in general about the goals of the war, the justification of these goals , they found enough ground in the russian environment, it is not only polls that speak of it, ratings of informational energy programs in fact of propaganda programs of russian television speak of it, but starting from the month of may, may, june, the month of fixation begins the number of viewers watching propaganda programs by solovyov, semenyan, etc., that is, people switched from propaganda content to entertainment, and now the number of views continues to fall on all propaganda channels , that is, the consumption of propaganda messages , that is, the content that is produced, he finds

an internal well, irreversibility, let’s say, a decrease in the perception coefficient, that is, as in the soviet union, if you remember, was of two minds, on the one hand, you accept this information and show your loyalty to it and on the other hand, you understand that this is nonsense, that this is an empty empty balkan that is the elements of the information machine of the state, and that's how old russians say in which sociological polls that he fully supports putin's flights, that he will always vote for him, that he is for what everyone killed ukrainians, even this russian subconsciously or in some other way understands that he is actually in a relationship with her, and accordingly he begins to

consume her less and less, he does not exactly trust her, he understands that this is not true since a week ago he appeared such polls where such answers are interesting at the same time when we answer for the previous ones there are more than 60%. we are for the continuation of military operations and at the same time they say we are for holding negotiations and immediately ending the war. so , yes, we are two. each of the points is civilly visible. but look at it in june. well, they fixed it in june. they began to promote the idea of ​​what to do . let's fix the territory let's make an agreement, all these conversations started on russian tv about agreements about the fact that there should be some kind of agreement between the west and something else, and then they started to hold a referendum and at the same time there was this thesis expressed by semenyan, where should the scattering stop, let's listen to how it usually

is. in the studio we discussed and there, well, the boundaries of this are expanding. for years, the dnr, the lnr, and so on. and here are the rest of the areas and people where rady is and it will show and show the referees, whether our troops are coming, too, the majority did not want to live with us, and now they want to live with us. where are we coming ? i know how to shake germany, but who knows what’s

in a german’s head. and the french can be shaken there. i don’t know who can be there, too. i’m glad, just all the replacements, were the troops from berlin there? zaporizhia oblasts that have already declared their desire, well, the overwhelming majority of people believe that it is impossible to stop there and that it is necessary to go as a minium to lviv, well, by the way, this is a beautiful illustration of this double-mindedness, that is, when they themselves understand that the troops are coming and regardless of what the people there think, they all of a sudden, they write to me that they are very happy to be the speakers, by the way, there was a certain rostyk ishchenko, this is our fugitive who fled to the so-called criminal refugee who should be in a ukrainian prison for treason in fact, he talked all this time and for 8 years about the fact that the kyiv regime is about to collapse, that there are only a few days left until the defeat of ukraine, that ukraine will freeze, then

there will be gaza, then there will be no money, that there will be riots that will not fall apart by itself and it is not worth it to use military force because russia will collapse by itself, it is unsustainable and now this character is announcing something on russian tv channels, again, many believe that these attacks on infrastructure appeared after there something was attacked by the ukrainian forces, yes, it's all completely untrue. these conversations appeared in the summer, in parallel with the talks about the referendum, and they sounded absolutely clear even then. let's listen to the statements . so don't worry, mom. yesterday, there was hysteria, yes, they had the biggest one. the official mainland there are 1,000 people, ukraine admitted that thousands of people were killed, the british began to speak in general

. today at night, it will completely de-energize ukraine, it will destroy all the power plants that are there for another blow , it will always return them. the stone age is what i did today. the first thing i did was when i was in the forest. i was looking for a message . our rocket. action i'm just today, the feeling is right, and with the same expectations, it was very good, yes .

effest a-a products from boxes in stores and water that will not be found anywhere and this guy is carried by the wind by hand and a sewage system that a million cities are persuading in a week the chic will have a collapse and there will be lips internal catastrophes well at this stage i am more than confident that this is necessary for ukraine do and now when they are talking about everything related to the crimean bridge, these statements were from the beginning, we looked at it from july to september, and the crimean bridge was, well, on october 8, and they also talked about the conditions in the summer. why weren't there those strikes then? and now there is this , too, listen because it's basically interesting to know zelensky, and he said here that in russia, smart missiles are ending there and they will be soviet now, they understand the wording of russia very well, russia is ending, they take into account the

industry that ukraine will produce your industry is working and today we are looking at the average consumption of all missiles there is iskanderka 101 there are calibres bezradist where only 30 at what time is the task expected on saturday will increase delivery day 100 per day well let's even have two nazi rockets, it's 50 guaranteed serious targets, that is, in the summer, this is also july, in the summer, there was a plan to build up to 100 missiles, its stock, and then start firing 100 missiles at the same time, and then ukrainian air defense would not be able to withstand it. and that's what the plan was and propagandistic in order to break ukrainian resistance and, in principle, terrify the world. and here i am interested in what you think, because this is actually, well, to a certain extent, it is really a rather serious turning

point for the world. when they started giving us something with weapons, which they didn't give before and here it is interesting, you know how the expectations of the russian propagandists of the russian population, which seems to support these strikes and the real situation, well, let's start with the probability of strikes on the infrastructure said all the unreasonable experts who deal with our war in the west and in ukraine as well, and they were expected precisely in the fall with the beginning of the heating season, since it was necessary to strengthen the humanitarian component of this strike, accordingly, everyone understood that only the heating season will begin, the cold weather will appear, accordingly, russia will begin to strike at the energy infrastructure. therefore, it was expected, on the other hand, it was necessary to explain why russia is striking at these objects, that they

have only one meaning for you, that in this way it is not a strike according to the press of ukrainians, who are supposedly free people, and these are strikes on the infrastructure that supports the military power of ukraine and similar things to convince their citizens that they are doing everything right, that this is not genocide, that there is not a total national war war total destruction of civilians and this is a kind of special military operation - continuing the topic of special military operations, it is not very successful because even those who support , again, putin is acting, they understand perfectly well and this is shown by various polls and even just polls on the street of journalists about what people they wonder why this is being done, that is, where is this border, what, what, what else does russia have to do in order to force kyiv to negotiate, that is, it shows

, strictly speaking, the weakness of the russian army, weakness russia's lack of a negotiating position in the east. i wouldn't shake semenyan's solovyov and ishchenka studios there or what other former collaborators of ours are there. this is not what will not convince the russian citizen that a victorious war is taking place and the goals will be achieved. on the contrary, it shows more and more and more to the russians that russia will lose this war. and then another trend emerges, that is that now it is a war no longer with ukraine, not even with the west, but this is already a defensive war, because if they do not win this war, accordingly, in my opinion, it was said in to the previous e-e episode about the fact that there is only one way out. this is either victory or the destruction of russia, and this is the trend now

. e texts and ideologues, even sergeitsevta and other kremlin figures around also say that now the issue of russia's survival is in question, so it is, and in fact , they started talking about the third world war also a little not since april, but when they said it themselves, we are at war with the west, the third world war, it all sounded, you know, as if they did not believe themselves, and it was the same story with nuclear blackmail, with nuclear threats, as soon as they give us a new type of weapon, we will have nuclear weapons right there they are starting to show some launches there or something there or sarmat is there er, well, in training or there, how is it now, this is the last

time they stuck the yars into the mine launchers , uh, this is repeated every time, but there is also a very interesting story, first of all, this one there is a trend to talk about nuclear weapons. well, this kind of blackmail with nuclear weapons was supported by almost everyone, and even solovyov’s broadcasts are literally the last. well, he continues to do all this. because i understand that part of the ideological kremlin continues to blackmail with nuclear weapons because, well, it appears on tv, we see it, this blackmail is being repeated, but there was such a very interesting dialogue and let's watch it , because it is very, you know , new, characteristic. poland is going to fight of course absolutely absolutely absolutely nato er not quite nato a piece is mediated by us, well,

if military action is transferred to their territory, then when will er their aviation rise or start, so to speak, bombing our deputies, it does not do when we watch how the cut when she watches sarata, it ’s a single unit, so to speak, a drone attack on moscow, then we’ll say yes , yes, stop. they are preparing it in warsaw, it is possible to get people walking there, by the way, we don’t need our people . this is a war with absolutely nato on the present topic, it's simple, not an abstract red line, concrete, we consider it legitimate goals, this is this, this is this, and this

is what we want and try to fly, and we want to try the opposite and survive, because victory begins when you are not afraid of your own actions. how effective are our tri-series against missiles? petriv and it was almost the first time when the same solovyov started shouting about tactical nuclear weapons that should be used in ukraine before this, the general conversation was that tactical will never use nuclear weapons, but immediately we will hit washington, well, what is it called? and these statements provoked him in his own

studio . to the most confused who could not answer exactly where are the borders of russia, where are the official borders of the russian federation approved in the constitution of the russian federation, this is this. in fact, this manifests itself in two ways of thinking, because by bringing annexation and bringing these referendums, russia turned its borders from immovable to movable this movement of the russian borders can take place in different directions, both in the direction of the growth of the territory and in the direction of their decrease, and then this doctrine of the russian federation on the use of nuclear weapons, when there is an ex-distance threat to

the existence of the russian state itself, it loses any of the added value of any - what is the point of a threat because no one takes it seriously anymore and that is why solovyov is such a historian and that is why he is so cautious, shall we say, so critical and ironic attitude of other er-er maybe partially thinking characters of his studio to the demand to apply nuclear weapons, but i have a pessimistic forecast that the russian regime may still use tactical nuclear weapons, this scenario should not be completely written off from the possible scenarios of this war, and on the question of interpolation to nuclear blackmail and on the question of many, i do not know how much he it will develop, but we will see in

the next year, but i think so. thank you, vitaly kulyk, we will see each other after, after, i think we will literally be able to see what will happen in the coming months, christmas a time when ordinary things acquire miraculous properties, a time to gather together to celebrate and we will decorate our christmas trees even in times of war, our christmas trees will become places of strength, we will celebrate christmas together with our military , all together we will become even stronger, and as in carols, light overcomes darkness, so in the life of ukrainians will win the moscow battles, look with a sincere eye at the son of god on our land