a-a last year it was 30 years since the proclamation of the empire by peter i, and they all returned to this empire on the dates of some non-existent history that they came up with and it was obvious that without ukraine, russia is impossible at all. because we reassured ourselves all the time and said, well, no, this is impossible, and what, um, our culture reassured itself, the whole world reassured itself because he said that in the 21st century, when there are digital technologies, there is the internet, everything is open, and it is very difficult to manipulate consciousness because it is potentially impossible to fight fake news, but it turned out to be the opposite and the whole world was stunned, i think it is also related to the correct, maybe not the right type,

the wrong saying, but i will say it with the error of capitalism in the sense that the capitalist world and the development of civilization allowed people live comfortably and in a comfortable everyday situation, we did not allow the thought that a real brutal war is possible where there is no safe place in ukraine today, but it happened and i repeat that i was sure that this war would happen i didn't know how to sell, except that when the western media already wrote about it, when putin's speeches began to take on more and more such outlines, er, er, absolutely, in my opinion, macabre and so crazy er stupid, even er, where some non-existent history of its own was simply being formed. i

used to tell my friends there, historians, and my colleagues all the time, what if a certain discourse is created that is filled with these words, if all the time there is scabby er, this hatred for ukrainians is more and more how snow ball rolled it up, it has to be fired sooner or later, well , that is, it was done for something, it was not done in order to be, as they said, implemented, minsky means agreements and so on and so on later that is, this is a story about a certain about the creation of a propaganda machine in which they themselves believed, that is the results of the propaganda they themselves believed before the creation of this er these words to me er a certain new elephant this russian so crazy some simply crazy new elephant to which they label the whole world well and then this appearance i guess i can't

to say i think there is no ideology in russia, but still elements of nazism are definitely there, and the appearance of these first elements of nazism when they started to be called nazis and hmm to call the whole world who simply did not agree with the russians, that is, a very simple scheme, i would even say hello - primitive if you do not support the dew of words, you are equal to nazism. you are a very easy formula that very easily enters the head of any alcoholic from under saratov and it works and has a certain result, unfortunately. by the way, what is the opinion that when putin hitler is compared he is happy about it, but i hate hitler and of course this regime is officially, er, officially condemned and this is one of the most terrible tragedies in general in the history of mankind, it should never happen again, but it seems to me that when

putin is compared to hitler with hitler, it is just a compliment to putin because he is so stupid and stupid and was not able to create the uh-terrible propaganda system that was in nazi germany and he is not as charismatic a person for his people as hitler was for the germans and in the period there during the late weimar republic , and even during the coming to power, and not even at the beginning of the second world war, but hmm, putin is stupid, he can’t be hitler, yes he is. absolutely stupid dictation, you said that this dictator was the main cause of the war, that is, if it was not putin, but someone else the other one, it couldn't be some kind of cold war, hybrid clay, i'm not sure, i don't know, i don't have an answer to these questions, i'm still a historian, i have things related to the things that happened, but today's

war, history shows us that no, that is, a big the number of russians is the absolute majority at the moment the number of russians do not hate ukrainians why do they hate ukrainians is unclear, they cannot answer this question, moreover, i will tell you that lately , ah, i am having fun as follows, this is my private sociology. yes, i decided to go to these roulette chats yes, and every day i even make my own system, let’s say, scripts that i use in conversations with russians. ask where are you from? i say i'm from kyiv or i'm from donetsk and donetsk, donetsk oblast, ukraine and it begins no, it can beat and you fascism and so on and so on and bandera, of course, the people of bandera

are nazis. he is different from the fascists. what do you know about bandera, and about the people of bandera, why are we all like that and they have absolutely no facts. that is, all their arguments are emotions and, as a rule, this is a dictionary that we call oksana's vocabulary. that is, having it is exclusively so they are so out of touch with the language and absolutely hatred and inadequate hatred and it is clear that their supremacy is completely groundless in my opinion. in their minds, it is correlated only according to geography, that is, they themselves, why are they nazis? because they believe that all other nations - this is not for the nation the people there are dagestanis, kazakhs, uzbeks, and uzbeks. well,

they call everyone there black, white, and so on. caucasian peoples, any peoples, for them, mongols are all subhumans, khahls and all the others . and why are they subhumans because you see them a big map, that is, a map of the world on which this country is big, when you start asking what, besides geography, you have the great, their main answer is the silence of the ophigelonsky, that is, well, ballet is great in other countries, and you also understand the question is what is russian, russian ballets, russian culture, well, that is the culture of which they are proud, the culture of mandelshtam , who died in the concentration camps, oh well, there was the culture of akhmatova, whose son was convicted, and the culture of tsvitaeva, who was hanged, the culture of yesenin, and it is still unknown

whether they were killed or not, so you understand they are proud of all those whom they destroyed, even brodsky, whom i can't tolerate, and everyone knows that this is his poem on the independence of ukraine, yes, even brodsky was expelled from the country, but the great brodsky, well, dear, you are medical underpants for money, yes, this is the whole of russian culture that is, here is the story that they are always proud of the dead, always and even if we look at the russians today, they always speak on behalf of the dead, well, starting from the name of kyivska and from kyivska rus and then on. they have some kings and then this one dostoyevsky tolstoy well and blah blah blah yes and i once thought and i began to read a lot of scientific literature why for them the martyrologist is the main story and i came to a very primitive but it seems to me very productive precisely from the point of view of the description of the russian world e- in conclusion, it is very easy

to speak on behalf of the dead, because the dead are silent, well, that is why they go to may 9 with these dead regiments, they have an immortal . well, because these dead people cannot say that the second world war was not ideal, where a soviet soldier is a show and freed everyone from the village with flowers, because any war is suffering - it is death, it is rape, and today we see a russian soldier , and even in their liberated territories in quotation marks, yes, kherson is their territory according to their logic. they committed and according to this means an offensive and now they are shelling their own city, well, that is, there is absolutely no logic, and when these eyes are dead, why is putin so sick of a made-up story? well, because it is very easy and a large

number of people both in ukraine and in any kreitse normally won't read complicated historical monographs, won't sit in archives , that's why there are specialists, yes, that's why there are documentaries about history, that's why there are popular youtube channels about history, so that history can be simplified and interesting, history is very complex. it's always ambiguous, it can't to be black and white and it is very easy to take any hero and make him a conditional hero yes or or anti-respect this is how you understand bandera and without relative languages ​​the personal attitude towards bandera when the manual type and from bandera is means that we need to think about why the soviet government hated the upa so much and fought and feared them so much and lost not 1,000 nkvdists. yes, and the soviet troops were combative, and there in the mountains, well, since when they

first went on a partisan campaign against the upa, soviet partisans and so on and so on and those banderas are burning them, the question arises why are they so bothered by bandera eh and you start to dig and understand well, because these are those who opposed the system and those who, because the soviet government destroyed everyone who in any way did not fit into their pantheon into their system of heroes or was somehow, god forbid, such a head that the support of certain soviet machines and we begin to think yes, the 39th, because western ukraine later learned about the western ukraine later learned about the process of occupation of the soviet 39th, even this collectivization itself, ah, and this is rape and violence. i am not talking about everyday life, about all these soviet norms, this whole upbringing , this whole system, where the teacher came in, the children stood up

. ah, horror, this is all, you understand, this is the constant violence in which we all lived on and hmm a russian person. she is always sick, you understand . the beautiful zabuzhko wrote an absolutely, in my opinion, brilliant article on how to read russian literature after bucha. and where was pushkin's street in my eyes and this story about how dostaev's pushkin does not work and like all the others, you know, i had an e- in the united states, in the winter or even in the summer, there is a discussion with an american russian professor who told me that the russian letter and culture have nothing to do with dostoyevsky, but the discussion was strangely in the church and there were many different people and i also made a certain manipulative gesture and i said, dear, i mean believers, and i offer you a very simple scheme in russian in

order to come to god, and in all of dostoevsky's works, without exception, there is this scheme in order to come to god as quickly as possible understanding of this word, i.e. to good, there to certain spiritual trials, yes, you need to do something, or kill someone, or rape someone, or kill someone again, that is, you don’t need the church, you don’t need good deeds, you don’t need conversations with yourself, you understand not all that that the bible is necessary to be either a fool or a rapist like nastasya filippovna there excuse me for what i am dear tv viewers for quoting russian literature, but know the dostoevsky thing and how and how and how and not only dostoevsky because here today and after the occupation of the north of ukraine, kyiv region , chernihiv region, and the horror that is still unknown to us, and

mariupol , kharkiv region, and the south. everything it's a horror that now the ship is being used and it is being used. pushkin is where the russian foot steps, there is a monument to pushkin , but the simple question is, why is there a monument to pushkin in syria? the russian word is russian culture, and where they promote russian culture, they privatize the space, and then they say that russian people live here, they need to be protected, but without this world , whose culture will we protect? and what are they they hate us if they always say that we are fraternal nations free, we are fraternal nations why do they attack us we are free , we are not fraternal nations at all this

concept of a fraternal nation is very convenient for russians because any concept of a fraternal nation will be taken more broadly in the family there is definitely an older brother, and for some reason, always in the concept of brotherhood, by default, everyone knows who is older, then we go to the soviet system, even to the soviet one, well, let’s take the soviet one so that everyone understands that in the soviet system, the older one a party figure, i don't know, the head of the fifth department, someone else had to default, the teacher had the right to violence, that is, the elder, just like in the family, yes, this is the upbringing in our families of paternalism, where the man has certain rights and he is the elder . the elder brother has the right to violence, and not only on behalf of the state, but in general to violence in some way, we see how russia is, i think that

she is an elder brother, russia seems to be logical, we will punish now, we will give our younger brother a kick, oh, oh, oh, dear, what what are you doing and you understand , i'm coming back to chat roulette again dear tv viewers a beautiful story which, in my opinion, perfectly illustrates the behavior of russians eh i talk to them ah and that means i have a gaikos in my hands and i didn't ask anything the first one and the russian told me he says he can't smoke. you can't smoke. i tell him i asked for advice, it's bad for your health, it's that. fifty and it's gone. who are you? well , first of all, you're my enemy, and i came here to talk to you with a completely different purpose, so that you shoot with words and try a little to somehow do something yes uh and you start to bring me up when i don't ask you - i didn't ask you

and that means that it is sewn into them that you understand by default this uh-uh desire for violence desire for education 68th prague 56th in hungary, the afghan war where a bunch of ukrainians died in cuba, ukrainians, it was a crime that we have not talked about yes, we have streets of internationalists, monuments to afghans and that's all for us heroes, but the question arises why the hell did the soviet government go to beat the poor people who live there in the mountains yes, and they suffered coffins came to ukraine also in coffins our people also came, all this horror , including the concept of the russian peace well , because the russian peace was being saved there, angela davis, and the russian peace in africa, and everything else, and everything

else, and from here this concept, the concept of brotherhood, this is khrushchev's saying, we will a-a fighter, the measurement of some forms until a stone is left on a stone, regardless of the fact that i was ukrainian from the beginning, yes and i grew up in a russian-speaking family, i studied in a moron - mostly in a russian-speaking environment at school and even at the university and that's why i probably have a right about it to say what and this you understand, the mocking russian peace today destroys to zero bakhmut is shelling kramatorsk slavyansk yes, from the russian territory, mariupol was destroyed, where a lot of people spoke russian, that is, potentially potential from the point of view of the logic of the russians, yes, part of the russians , they killed 50,000 people because they influence their brothers brothers want to be free

, this is the most terrible word, the most terrible, and at the same time they still carry threats in europe absolutely. europe has not seen such a threat for 80 years, well, since the second world war. and now , from the point of view of history, europe as well as itself should behave like this and europe fell asleep europe of this second no yes hitler simply fell asleep well, they didn't want to see, they didn't understand, they lived peacefully after the second world war , creating the european union, forming nato as an organization that protects and unites it at the same time yes, in this comfort where it is definitely impossible a world war within europe, yes, on the european continent, and they allowed it , thinking that ukraine is always a foreign country, and it is in the shadow of russia, just a little bit, yes, yes, yes, yes, let russia have a

claim on it, and she did not sleep on it either. doitler, do you understand this dictator? and for this now the european union and the countries of europe are also paying and will continue to pay because i am sure and i really want it that this war after our victory will end in a great russian civil war and it is clear that from the point of view of history and these interest centers i just wanted to ask everyone about cyclicality, if there is cyclicality in history, a lot of historians say that it repeats itself once every 100 years. they just said about citizenship there is cyclicality. i will say that i am absolutely sure that a-a but russia played its game e 100 years ago er-e this revolution of the 17th and on the one hand on the other hand and if we carefully study the 17th year well, not only the 17th in

this revolution the arrival of lenin and the establishment of soviet power and the establishment of the soviet system, especially for the first time in the period yes, not for the civil war in russia at that time, then we will see that today nothing has changed, especially when we see the social basis of this revolution, what then do you understand today, nothing in 100 years this country is not changed the facade has changed a little to moscow, petersburg has been rebuilt, and big cities where skyscrapers have appeared, where some blessings of civilization have appeared, but european and american civilizations have not changed from the point of view of values, they have not changed from the point of view of everyday practices in the village, and as you and i saw even from the point of view of toilets, which did not appear in the village in russia, yes, and this means that the same people who are not educated, who are

marginalized, who live in a closed world, where their whole world is. this village and the great holy tsar who sits in the kremlin and the kremlin very far sometimes for many thousands of km, and this makes him even more sacralized and makes him sacred, sitting like zeus on this mountain, oh, god, forgive me , zeus, don’t hit me, oh, i mean, with lightning for this, oh, for this saying, and they him, well, they are his god they sleep, yes, but it is clear that propaganda and everything else works here, but it is also terribly ignorant, and that is why when they tell me that you, too, raised this question about putin, is only putin guilty, absolutely no, i am a thousand times sure that every russian is guilty even to this day every russian is very the simple way is the open internet to analyze and see, but this requires very serious serious work, yes, this is tinder, sit and read, i think that they will deal with this after

the civil war. unfree people that for them it is absolutely fear , we are also not completely free yet and will not be for a long time, but for this our soldiers are dying ah ah defense forces of ukraine . ourselves and our country and freedom and i hope we will appreciate it even more, but at least it is so difficult, so with blood, so sometimes with complete poverty, and even in the 90s, but please, in small steps until the 14th of the fourteenth more actively well, but all the time we are going to freedom and hmm well, i can say that i can breathe absolutely freely in ukraine and it

is absolutely a miracle that we allowed ourselves a lot of things that others definitely could not afford even there without money without europe, even being young and stupid, do you understand or even as old people we already allow ourselves to say oh no, well you're an older generation there don't tell us ay-ay-ay and the older ones are ak but we definitely go back to that and it's cool freedom is not rude not unforgiving yes but freedom from the point of view of the fact that you understand that you are a person and next to you is the same personality, i.e. when you are with students, you are not on equal footing. and you understand that these are your colleagues . that they are free and sometimes much smarter than you today. you are only narrow-minded to specialists. yes, these are people who were born with smartphones today. grown up know how to code and write different seems to be about unity about unity which, well, a lot of historians

say that ukrainians have not had such unity since the time of bohdan khmelnytskyi, and what about us after the victory, which will definitely not lose this unity yes, and summarizing how the war will end for ukraine we understood how it will end for russia, and what will happen to us, and ok , yes, unity, you know, i really hope that we will become a member of the european union, running ahead and right there, if you know the main one of the divisions, at least at the beginning. yes and well, to this day there is unity in diversity, and i think that even before the european union it corresponded to the ukrainian spirit from the point of view of how many different peoples of nationalities live within the framework of the guides on the territory of ukraine, and even within the framework of a single ukrainian nation, only when issuing visas from the ethnic yes, not to mention how different we all are from the point of view of

regional characteristics there hmm i don't know the cuisine of certain local traditions of everything else and this unites us and it's very cool and but we need to work on this. and i really want it from myself and from my neighbors and from all of us . and of course, from you, on whom the great power of the word depends, so that we do not lose this effort of work, it will be very difficult, very painful, we will get tired, but we have it preserve and increase work value our freedom work to ensure that the law exists and is valued and we all value it do not fight corruption continue and make our life as happy as possible and i am sure that we will win i am sure that what is really ahead

the most terrible day when we learn the whole bitter truth about this war. i mean how many people died, how many have not yet been found and everything else, but well, we are very strong. we are very cool and look at 400 years and even more. we are always restless geographically, one of the largest states of the world and we have always in ukrainian society, always in history , always since the period of bohdan khmelnytskyi, definitely and even earlier, the support of the army of ukraine has always been unbroken, that is, ukrainian society has always trusted the ukrainian army has always been trusted, this means that the ukrainian army was a part of ukrainian society and came out of ukrainian society and would protect ukrainian society and value ukrainian society and fight for the ukrainian

society that should be and that we should build, and we can all build and start with a simple how you told me to stop reading dostoevsky and to start reading oksana zabuzhko, to begin with, we thank you very much for the expert opinion for the fact that you have laid out everything on the shelves, anton lyagusha, candidate of history scientists were in our studio, the marathon continues, thank you, when the light goes out everywhere, they continue to fight for life every day, every day, every second during the war, and hospitals became fortresses of light, where they heal not only the body, but also the soul, in that and the pain in the flame of hope, their

reward is our smiles and embrace their joy , another saved person. they know the value of every life, that's why they keep the light inside us. we are grateful to the doctors who continue to save people despite the darkness outside the window. thank you, the nivrok era, the crazy times will pass, but for now, keep yourself in check through the darkness it is more visible in time, the destruction of people is the brightest, we hold on to the pile, even if it is made of beads , it is simple and not tired to stay away from a fatal mistake, the rains are severe in the flow in

the resource we follow the device keep the city, the generators do not buzz in his thousands of dreams, we hold on to the truth, we hold on to the thong for the duration of a long power outage always keep a charged radio receiver and an additional battery close at hand scan the air in the fm range and listen to find a marathon of the only news and listen to the official messages of the emergency services find out where seek help and alternative emergency contacts prepare now let's defeat the darkness together