but at the same time, mrs. svitlana, at the beginning of the program you said that putin is mentally healthy, but not everyone agrees with this, psychiatrists say that at the current stage, vladimir vladimirovich's mental illness has simply worsened, there is a quote, putin has been paranoid for the past 15 years, 180% of russians support their president, which means the mental illness of the nation, russians are classic zombies these are the words of mykola goraguli and the psychiatrist we are in direct contact with us and we can talk about it in more detail with him good day p mykola, we welcome you greetings good day greetings mr. mykola i want to start with you with the question why did you decide that putin is mentally unhealthy, what are the signs of this ? a very respectable person

managed to get the soviet union to go through all the authorities to collect 9 signatures in order to connect the water supply with waste ostensibly for the good of the city and only about the frame stopped this man, it was in the distant somewhere in 74th in the 75th year since then, i i realized that such emotional ideas and paranoid abilities are very contagious, because the man emanates the father's mental energy , with which he subordinates all his actions to only one goal, so such valuable ideas are one of symptoms of a mental illness, well, for silhouette reasons, i can’t give a complete diagnosis, but uh, understand putin, a mental illness that was

a hidden phase and uh, which was already fully revealed when he reached the property, and you know it’s like that, it’s uh, the same one difficult, the most difficult exam for a person and that's all er, all those er mental troubles that exist. at this moment, they can grow, which is what happened to putin today, from my point of view, he has a very valuable idea that unites the union with the soviet union, which he was very worried about. misses the fact that there is no soviet union and he has all the means to convey his obsessive idea to everyone around him. and due to the fact that he has a mass, everyone is massive he has information under his authority, so he broadcasts his ideas, he

really broadcasts on the internet not only to russia but also to the whole world and that from that rush i went there once for two sundays in greece i watched it only once there were people because there was no ukrainian channel listen i came from kharkiv i know what was happening there it was the 15th year but i i have already begun to doubt what the sieves are doing there, so i have been working with information for a very long time, and moreover, i define what information is, moreover, i define what the soul of a person is, so i understand that the main effort that putin applies in in this world, it is not only to kill , but also to win the souls of your er-er your own well with his mental illness and he wants russia to do it very successfully, i want to clarify

, here we are trying to talk about the mental disorder of the russian authorities, putin's entourage in a broader context, yes, the people who bring today's situation into the public space in russia, who talk about the same lavrov, the same solovyov skabeevs the other uh, these are all people, so to speak, and to what extent are they in a state of uh, such a repeated mental disorder, moving for putin's ideology, to what extent do they, from your point of view, consciously carry uh, this context around the world, or they understand that this is complete absurdity. this is complete , well, we are together, but trying to get some of their own dividends from this, they are talking about all this and saying what we hear, i understood before this idea of ​​putin,

what's more, i'll tell you in nuremberg in the distant 46th year, when the trial was taking place, and in the 45th, it was not even the scaffold, the hitlerites went and did not understand the reasons above. i heard the higher officials and they did not understand why we did everything , we did it everything is right according to the law. well, the jew. are they people and that's all you see, they went to another photo, they did n't understand, they didn't understand, they didn't understand why they were being taken to the scaffold, that's what induction is, induction is a term like psychiatry, when obsessive ideas pass from one person to another , that's why i, uh for quite some time now, for several decades, i have been saying that people in power should undergo a

specialized psychiatric examination, because it is the government that makes it possible to broadcast their ideas and induce their ideas on the people who trusted the government, precisely because we will leave if we start implementing such initiatives who will sit, i say, i say that we will be left without a parliament if we start conducting a psychiatric examination, i was before and the fact that now sometimes these are epic methods are surgical methods and these and those are effective, the main thing is that the health remains, that the person is healthy, that's it the main thing is for the body to be healthy and the soul to be healthy, i.e. for the country to be healthy. in our studio, ms. svitlana is a political psychologist. she listened to what you said and has her own opinion on this matter, panislav. well, not

that i just wanted my opinion directly, in principle well, what can i say about that? that's the thing that why is he in general, we ask ourselves the question, is putin healthy? yes, i think that it would make sense in the only case if his mental state was such that it was the reason for his removal from power due to incapacity, and i i don't know , mykola. how do you rate it? you're still a psychiatrist, i'm not, but it seems to me from the outside that uh, in this sense. in this sense, yes, as a reason to be recognized as incompetent , removed from power. he is not a sick person. yes, he is not. that is, in this sense, he is a completely mentally healthy person which can be responsible for its actions, can still plan to bring others down and bear the answer. well, no, that's another thing.

well, theoretically, if there was such a possibility. but no, that 's not the problem, the problem is and putin and his entourage and the people who serve this regime and they do not stop from the fact that they are healthy, they do not stop from being healthy or mostly not present to be mortally dangerous, with mortally dangerous yes for the surrounding world for people from other countries for their own own people, in the end, this is the problem and how to solve this problem, how to deal with the very fact that they are dangerous for clarification, how to operate on this, clinical and clinical, and this term is not very helpful here, you understand, it is interesting yes, mykola, i am took part in various psychiatric examinations, forensic examinations, including post-mortem examinations, i.e., well

, there is no personality anymore. and it is necessary to determine whether or not she had a schedule at all. i uh, i assert that vladimir vladimirovich putin has such a mental disorder can not name it, but from my point of view, and i can defend my point of view in any court, i can defend myself before the congress of psychiatrists. if a panel of psychiatrists or an expert commission appointed by the united nations recognizes this, recognizes him as mentally ill, then it doesn't matter, listen, it doesn't matter whether we can suspend him or not. formalizing this status of the fact that now he is only lazy and does not say that putin is not full

of reason, but that's all true and if it is already a formal status of mentally ill ukraine , this will be enough for the dear military dear citizen of russia to think about whether it is necessary to fulfill the requirements mentally a sick person, and the status of a mentally ill person can be assigned at the request of the court and or another law enforcement structure there, and this status must be substantiated, and we heard it . so mental diagnosis it seems to me that there is such a very big trap that we ourselves can drive ourselves into when we the whole world recognizes putin's madness, we get a situation when at some point the russian top leadership of the state will say , friends, yes, he is really crazy, we are not

to blame that's all he will tell him this he issued criminal orders and all the people will say that's all putin - at last they'll hang him on the red square of some fifth understudy and that's the end of it, they'll say everything come on everything russia is fine let's go and stand on his the place in power is the same people who will keep the same agenda in their heads and will continue conceptually his development of ideas , that is why we are trying today on the air to talk more about a-a collective er-e collective state of russian vladyslav this is completely a-a because ah, what we are dealing with is more complicated, wider and more banal than the mental pathology of putin or even his entourage, yes, the world has not yet solved this problem, humanity has not yet been able to deal with it, this is what khan arenda wrote about the banality of evil, that is, on such a large scale catastrophes actually do not arise from the

mental pathology of the leader, it was just, you know, really, then we could have diagnosed putin, or any other person, at the time of coming to power, and given him a diagnosis if there really is some directly psychotic condition and even what is hinting, i understand, mykola, it could have been perceived even then, yes, when he was relatively compensated and relatively healthy. well , it’s just a child passing a commission, you can’t be the president, but the situation is it is much more difficult and that is why it seems to me that only thinking about putin as a healthy healthy person who, due to certain reasons of his own intentions, his own desires, his own, his own long stay in power, simply led the world to a catastrophe with them, not only him, but also the task before us stands before you, mykolaiv, including

before me, in general, before all specialists who look at social processes from a professional point of view, they are much more complicated, it goes far beyond the boundaries of ecological clinical diagnosis there of mental you understand the deviations because we are dealing with a real social pathology. and how the west tries to speak to a healthy person with putin and tries to speak cautiously, and it is sometimes surprising because they basically knew that he is selfish, he always tries to be strong, but we remember the times when i repeatedly tried to come to an agreement with hitler to talk about something, and history does not teach us how in this case it is better to talk to putin from the west, continue to try to persuade to discuss, explain your position, you don’t do you think that the west is too cautious in conversations with him? well, as far as i understand, no one talks to putin anymore, well , that is, there is no talk of talks anymore, the talks ended after buchi, in fact, by and large , something is happening with macron

all the time. the game is played by eh well nishol rather than scholz eh erdoğan eh but eh what are you talking about yes how like a meaningful exchange of ideas or opinions with an effort to reach something in common which has not happened for a long time eh relatively carefully i don't know if i'm careful because i'm we are constantly resisting nuclear and nuclear weapons, you understand not to be careful in the face of such a large-scale threat, you can’t understand throughout the entire adequate your adequate and yes, it is exactly medicine such an enemy and in that in this in this the drama of the world and putin is adequate and yet well, i'm sorry, but i think that in the clinical sense he is healthy. yes, he has paranoia, it's absolutely true, but the feather is not necessarily a manifestation of mental illness, it is a manifestation of uh-uh, deformation of the personality, which uh-uh, deformed

lasted for a long time stay in power this is also something that manifests in a person under the influence of a long stay in power, and in such a power, uh, merkel was also 16 years old. it seems to me that the chancellor is unchanged, but she just constantly went through the procedure of being taken over by a competitor, she took the seat, she constantly adjusted her position through the reverse communication with the voters putin did not receive feedback from the voters, he does not need it. the development of the german economy is needed, cheap gas is a normal, healthy desire of any person to be optimistic about risk assessment, do you still understand the task of defeating russia, but at the same time not provoking the use of nuclear weapons as possible be careful, well, when

you and i have not touched such countries yet, well, pathological or anomalous manifestations of public life, public and political life, as eyes of a private army, as weapons, are released absolutely against all procedures legal well, how is the law in russia, but everything, even for russia, is not too much, yes, according to people from the place uh, yes, from prison, equating them with the military, saturating their weapons, some uh, they have already served six months. they have already returned to public life is a-ah, well, you understand, there are also such threats. this is in spite of me. i am stupid. that is, we are standing on the verge of such a catastrophe . well, my god, here in ukraine, a catastrophe is happening here, but a catastrophe is still brewing on our borders. well, internal russian that there will be a russian society it is capable of realizing the reality of what we are. well, what is happening, because they

, in fact, and we talk about ours constantly from the first days, they are in the grip of these illusions and even 100 thousand russians killed because we all dreamed that the russians would leave after that they will storm the kremlin on the street, and it turns out that all the women who lost their husbands and sons, on the contrary, become putin's accomplices, they say that my father is my husband, my son, he died in the greatness of russia, and you all sit at home because of the wretched military commissars well, let's get to the weapons, that is, they are actually covering up, they have already realized inside that well, it seems to me that the deaths of their relatives are absurd, but they are not ready to admit it at all costs. putin does not know what will happen next with the russians . how can we continue to live with him ? what they were aware of, do you understand the thing a-a what a-a getting rid of these illusions in the captivity of ukrainian well ukrainian too but also different russian

society it can happen only because of a catastrophe only because of a catastrophe well that is only catastrophes can bring down these illusions that they are holding on to a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a - a. self-perception is what she thinks about herself yes, and how high is the need to think of herself as something good , yes, about good numbers, the subject is worthy there, worthy of attention, and how dramatically then he comes to the courthouse, the realization that he is not as good as your name is behave yourself and uhu, and in the end, as i see what is happening now, at what point is the russian government and russian society now, at

the point of all this extreme tension between their idea of ​​reality, of the world, of their place in the world, of their role in the world, and what reality is is actually the resistance that reality makes in that, first of all, ukraine , trying to show them a different russia , the russia that they really are, and in this and in this, there is a gap between the pretend and the real, which they still cannot overcome, not that they overcome it they are constantly expanding this tension, you understand the impact, they and the realities, it is constantly well, how do we stretch the risk, yes, stretch the spring yes , it is somewhere, as i feel, it can also be automatically somewhere on the borderline stretching and in and that's why the difference is so dramatic is manifested so much now without unconscious material that is what we tried to talk about today, but it seems to me that we would not have been able to

talk, that is, and the speech putin on the new year and its decorated mountains of christmas worship for one yes and everything that happens with propaganda, it all gives such a powerful leak of unconscious material , that is, this feeling of defeat, a catastrophe, a premonition of this, well, a premonition of the moral catastrophe on the threshold of which they are now and these colors it's hatred, that's what happened with chicherina yes, well, that's all a visual solution, and what are their fears, what is this fanatical, uh, phonetic attitude of some mothers to uh, what about home thoughts, what are you , what can you sacrifice your loved ones, well i.e. all of this demonstrates to us the colossal rise of this unconscious material, which is

already visible to us very much in the world, yes, to everyone. the plan is still a fence to talk about all the details, but during the broadcast you tried several times to start talking about ukraine and our society. i think that this is a great topic for our next broadcast and the catastrophe earlier and more useful, in fact, i agree , we will definitely talk about it, because we spend a lot of time on russia. but we are all waiting for a catastrophe on russian society with a russian match. from plivska svitlana chunihi, a political psychologist was visiting us, we hope you were interested

when the light goes out everywhere, they continue to fight for life every day, every hour, every second, during the war, hospitals became fortresses of light to heal not only the body through fatigue and pain, they continue to protect the light of hope, their reward is our smiles and hugs, their joy is another saved person they know that not everyone lives, that is why they protect the light inside us, we are grateful to the doctors who continue to save people despite the darkness outside the window, thank you i

love my the city, old, cozy streets, new , wide, noisy avenues, i love the smell of coffee in the morning in a cafe near the house, i love my family, i respect my neighbors, i love children's laughter on the playground in the park, i never get tired of watching the monitor carefully because this is my city, it's hard to stay tuned when you haven't slept for the third day, it's hard, but it's worth it if you have t2 reception today, your tuner doesn't accept all ukrainian channels to set up the reception of channels on the tuner or tv remote

press the menu button, go to the settings menu, select the auto search item , scan and press the button ok to save the search results if you need help go to the site or contact the tv masters in your region based on real events that happened in the most desirable country on the globe dubbed in the singing ukrainian language negative successes in the next year will not

end toilet paper i'm all the institution of the russian federation again damn get used to it volodya now only coming like this for the second time already the second time in a dream it's at least a warning suddenly it's mean and without announcement it's necessary everyone is running ahead of their pants i'm shitting what else new year's appeal and new year's ride on the ears, dementia, grandfather. and this is a must, let 's sprinkle the whole scum,

are there options without options, video on the days of st. nicholas he said that he personally has about you, but for the option, namely, 40 million wishes from ukrainians, wait oh, now change hello, colleagues, hello, the future of gaski zeka is beautiful, here the first one went, traditional , i have to speak with a new year's address to the people, i will not congratulate everyone , tell about the successes and victory on new year's

eve, i have to put it in my ears russians for success and victory, my friend left, i have no idea what the song was about, we didn’t like kherson, so to speak, you will give me the country of the substation . in general, i thought that if you all pressed here without translation, then you are no more dima, his new year's address, and gold words vladimirovich, the fourth is written,

it's good, i'll give you time until the evening, until the evening, go ahead . good afternoon, evgeniy viktorovich. hatu vertuheim write a new year there is someone who instructed me to write a piece of shit what are we doing with you эти военные и патриотины we are with you two boots when конечно могу только если ответиш на мой вопрос listen for a favor how then they say to the question a fork and in the eye or uras and

the experts have one minute to answer unexpectedly correctly and from where the answer has already had to be chosen and i want to remind the agent that we have the biggest and nuclear potential god block him already there on twitter hello i am santos. hello, my name is a squirrel. i do not fulfill the desired boy who is under sanctions

. by the way, it's also under the sun. come again. well, no, i'm too much, and he hasn't started it yet, necessarily