maksym galkin ah well, if you take a telegram channel or a site there, it’s full of show business and mass culture, but pugacheva kirkorov ah, they just mess with them. behind every step there is the instagram of pugacheva and maksym galkin . it’s just that they have a top, they have every story, every post, they show how everything is discussed . already now they are predicting that they will go to their e-e representatives of the lgbt community, of whom there are many and who are now serving simply unbelievably

. in short, lazarev will no longer exist, thank you, thank you, we have run out of lena chechenina in our time, well, actually, what can i say after they clean out all of them, only the crimean bridge of cinema, performed by the family, will remain simenyan margarita, which no one will ever watch , and this is good in principle, because many ukrainians were very influenced by this soft russian power through art. and now there is no russian art. everything is over. see you when i find a working store in three letters. it is closed. there is no light. please give me this

bouquet, you are so lucky. it does not disappear in our country. yes, the generator on the street is humming. for example, my husband and i have a family business up to uah 20,000, i understand it. thank you very much for the bouquet of support for the ukrainian veteran business. find out the details now on the website or by phone. watch this week's program judicial control with tatyana shustrava, political proteges, why the reform of the constitutional court ended up on the brink of an explosion of reform in depending on the constitutional court and the direct path to authoritarianism, whether ukraine will be able to maintain the status of a candidate for the eu, the parliament passed a

law that goes against the ricoh commission and what happened to the judges of the constitutional court who were dismissed before the new year? congratulations, this is judicial control and i am tetyana shustro's reform of the constitutional court on the verge of collapse. and the adopted law goes against the requirements of the european union, which ukraine promised to fulfill by receiving the status of a candidate country for the eu, what will happen next and will we continue the path of european integration now we will tell you in today's program, but first, before the news, the 19th conclave of judges of ukraine elected five members of the supreme council of justice, a key body of the judicial system, which is

responsible for the professionalism, impartiality and integrity of this body of judges . alla kotlevets, judge of the kharkiv court of appeal, olga popikova, judge of the northern court of appeal, oleksandr sasevich, judge of the lviv district administrative court and judge of the supreme court hryhoriy usyk, the congress of judges has not yet ended, and in the coming days he must appoint three more members of the council according to his quota. currently, the supreme council of justice has only seven members since the 21st and has been inactive for almost a year due to the absence of a sick person after the appointment of 8 new council members by the congress of judges will make 15 of them. and this will finally allow us to resume the work of the body. this task is to restore the functioning of the highest body of judicial governance. we

must complete this task. complaints against former judges of the holosiiv district court of kyiv, andrii novak and oleksandr bilyk, in which they were sentenced to seven and a half and seven years of imprisonment, respectively, according to the version of the investigation, ex-judge novak, with the mediation of the former judge of the same court, bilyk, received eight thousand dollars in illegal profit for the decision decision in a civil case during a search of a novice , firearms and military supplies were found for which he did not have the permission of the son and the court of appeal of the kyiv region valery finegaev evgeny finegaev was caught drunk driving again, this is not the first time, and not even the second time , the permissible number two is zero. a year ago, the patrol police already stopped finegaev for drunk driving. the dnipro district court of

kyiv imposed a fine on the judge's son with the deprivation of the right to drive a vehicle for a year. however, fingaiv decided not to comply with the court decision and continued to drive his car. in october, his lawyer appealed to the court to admit that the decision on the imposition of a fine and deprivation of the right to drive cannot be enforced by the new head of the cassation court. larisa rogach became the economic court member of the supreme court of ukraine for the next four years. at the meeting of judges, 22 out of 42 judges voted for her. larisa rogach replaced judge bohdan lviv in this position, who was dismissed due to the presence of russian citizenship, however, the new head of the cassation economic court has no less questions in the 17th year, the public council of integrity recognized rogach as not meeting the criteria of integrity, in particular

, she probably at least tolerated or was even involved in the practice of interfering in system of self-distribution of the court larisa rogach was also a member of a colleague and judges who did not satisfy the cassation appeal of the kyiv city council thereby obliging it to enter into a lease agreement for a plot of land near st. sophia cathedral for the construction of a high-rise building, this construction threatened sofia in 2016 the panel chaired by larisa rogach issued a decision which led to the allocation of land for the estate of yury ivanyushchenko , known as mezhyhirya 2, despite the fact that most of the land plots belong to the lands of the nature reserve fund and on unfortunately, these are not all the questionable decisions of judge larisa rogach. the verkhovna rada adopted a law on changing the process of selecting judges of the constitutional court

of ukraine. the law creates an advisory group of experts. it will include six members, one each from the verkhovna rada of the president and the congress of judges of ukraine, one person from the venice commission and two persons are delegated by international organizations that provide assistance to ukraine in reforms of the rule of law, the group must analyze each candidate for compliance with the criteria of integrity and professional competence, and this should supposedly allow appointing worthy ones, but there is a significant point in the selection scheme, no participation of representatives of civil society is provided for, instead , representatives of the authorities continue to participate in the selection of judges. three of the six members of the commission are representatives of politics and the congress of judges, and the decision is made by a majority of votes of international experts are considered as a

priority. therefore, the threat of political involvement does not disappear, and only those who agree with the government will be able to become judges of the constitutional court of ukraine. head of the de jure foundation, mykhailo zhernakov, this means that no judge will go to the constitutional court if political attitudes do not raise their hands for him. to establish an independent selection procedure, we are establishing and cementing the political appointment procedure shortly before the adoption of the draft law on the competitive selection of judges of the constitutional court, three current employees of themis resigned at the same time wrote the statements of iryna zavhorodnya, serhiy sas and igor sdelenko, all of them involved in scandals with questionable integrity. it would seem that we can

talk about cleaning up the judicial system, but no , now the risks of disrupting the reform of the constitutional court, and even more so, and judicial reform in general , have significantly increased, we will figure out what the threat is together with the experts, but first we will tell you what the three former judges of the constitutional court remembered for their positions, this is serhiy sas. he came to the constitutional court in march 2014 in the wake of the revolution before that, he was a people's deputy and one of the active members of the party yulia tymoshenko's homeland as a judge sas was remembered for his critical conclusions about zelenskyi's land reform in 2020, he even addressed a statement to the people's deputies in which he urged not to allow ukrainians to be deprived of national wealth ihor snidenko sat down in the

seat of the judge of the sas in march 2014, he was appointed by the verkhovna rada based on the quota of the svoboda party, before that he worked in the institute of legislation of the verkhovna rada, became famous sdelenko in october 2020, he was the speaker in the case of the cancellation of responsibility for the illegal enrichment of officials, then the constitutional court, by its decision, canceled the criminal responsibility of declaring false information and also blocked the work of the national agency for the prevention of corruption in the control of the wealth of civil servants and their punishment for perjury in declarations and not an explanation of the acquired assets , it is not excluded that such a decision was supported by judge sdelenko for personal reasons in 2019 nazk recorded a violation of the

anti-corruption legislation by sdelenko, he did not timely report significant changes in his property status, in particular, he did not timely indicate uah 330,000 of income, all three of them voted for sdelenko zavhorodnya, they voted for the decision to cancel the declaration , in fact illegal, absolutely unconstitutional, in the evening almost immediately after the decision was made by the constitutional by the court from the official e-mail box of the judge to the official of the nazk who handed him the report on the commission of an offense related to corruption a letter arrived in french and now athos said, wrapping himself in tears and putting on

his hat, now that i have pulled the viper's teeth out of you, bite if you can, alexander dumas, three musketeers in script, so thank you, gentlemen, and convey my greetings to mr. ann, and the inscription of judicial ethics, and at least for now, judge ihor snidenko resigned. he can still sit in the judge's chair again and we hope that in this case his biography will be well researched and the members of the already reformed higher qualification commission of judges will give a fair assessment of his actions convey means greetings p n type to mr. novikov is meant and what now viper when i pulled out your teeth try to bite me that is, the honorable gentleman directly admitted from his work mail that he did everything in order to nail down the authority

to zacap on him to decide there are some protocols, how and which ones they sent him before that. that is, this is also a huge conflict of interests. yes, and he should be responsible for this. the third judge of the constitutional court of ukraine, who decided to resign. in 2018, before that, she worked in the railway district court. in october 2020, zavhorodnya also supported the repeal of the anti-corruption reform and the decision of the constitutional court on the abolition of criminal liability for lying in declarations and the closure of the register of declarations and electronic declarations for protection. more interesting story because her powers have only just begun in the 18th year, and she should not have left her post for quite a long time, now why did she resign

, that is, irina zavgorodna knows that she has husband of a citizen of russia. he is retired, but expertly buys expensive real estate in the center of kyiv worth hundreds of thousands of dollars. two years ago, the husband of iryna zavhorodnya bought 124 square meters in the center of the capital in the elite complex novopecherski lypky. the estimated cost of such an apartment without renovation is almost uah 13 million. area with renovation from uah 14 million, according to the information of our colleagues, two years before that, in 2018, the judge's husband bought 54 square meters in those lypki for allegedly 1 million 300,000 hryvnias, although nowadays prices for similar apartments in the same building start at almost four million hryvnias. at that time , according to the

declaration of the judge’s wife, serhii zavhorodny’s income was only 75,000 hryvnias per year from a pension fund in moscow. in 2019, iryna zavhorodnya declared 4 million 120,000 hryvnias and 2.7 million hryvnias in cash and another 3 million allegedly given by her 81-year-old mother. from the income, only a pension and give those millions to the relatives of the judges, we can assume that in october 2020, iryna zavhorodnya was personally interested in the disruption of the anti-corruption reform, and deprived of the right to check the declarations of officials, three judges of

the constitutional court with a dubious reputation due to the unknown origin of wealth and questions about integrity voluntarily went to resignation and allegedly made room for new and virtuous ones, yes, but not quite the impression. i think that is the case, they are clearing a special place for political appointees according to the quota of the parliament, all three judges were appointed according to the quota of the parliament. therefore, the parliament must also appoint three new ones, experts emphasize the significant risks of such reshuffles of the constitutional court 3 from the parliament, two hairpins of the congress of judges, this means that according to the procedure that was just adopted a-a to n five judges of the constitutional court are already controlled by the government, five more are added, and these are 10 judges out of 18. that is, this is the majority of the constitutional court. currently, the government controls

five judges of the constitutional court of ukraine five seats are vacant today, experts emphasize, taking into account the law on the appointment of judges adopted by the parliament, in a few months the authorities of ukraine will be able to control ten of the 18 officers of themis of the constitutional court, this means that it will be possible to hold early elections through the constitutional court, any changes to the constitution and any unconstitutional laws to create any body in the last few months, ukraine has immediately taken several steps back in the implementation of judicial reform against the background of the victorious of the high-profile liquidation of the scandalous district administrative court of kyiv, the parliament passed a law that contradicts the recommendations of the venice commission to the council of europe's highest body on constitutional law and the advice of the ambassadors

of the g7 countries . a direct path to authoritarianism in a consortium of ukrainian think tanks and analysts conducted an analysis of ukraine's implementation of the judicial reform, which is a key requirement for the adoption us to the european union according to the conclusions of experts since the summer. not the only eu criteria where ukraine has shown positive dynamics is the reform of the constitutional court, however, the parliament, by adopting a bill that contradicts the requirements of international partners, once again pushed ukraine back on its way to the eu. a number of public organizations appealed to president volodymyr zelenskyi from we hope that the judicial reform will not be disrupted and that ukraine will be able to maintain its

status as a candidate for membership of the european union. today i had all this judicial control and i am tetyana shustrova. if you know the facts of corruption in the judicial system of ukraine or you want to tell about an unscrupulous judge , write to me on facebook or to the e-mail whose address you see on your screens , we will meet in exactly a week, all the best we continue the search for eight-year-old margarita mityunina, who disappeared on october 5. last year, even then, in the uncontrolled territory of the kherson region, it so happened that the girl's parents lived separately, the mother in vinnytsia and the father in in the kherson region and before the war, margarita lived with her father, she went to school there

for a period and was with her father, the girl was studying and they did not want to take her out of her place of residence and that she should finish school and agreed to have with her father what would remain with her father in their home his father took her family for a period, he took them back to school during the holidays, and at the beginning of the war he took her back. that's how i started the war, and my mother was in the vinnytsia region. she could n't come because she had a newborn, and the baby was three months old. so, a girl ended up in the occupied territory of the kherson region and that is where she encountered the war. she lived with her father in the boryslav district in the village of red mayak. there, margarita met a girl of the same age, and this girl's mother, as it turned out, supported the russians and took part in the pseudo-referendum. and when the occupiers talked about escaping from the right bank of the kherson region, a woman also decided to go to the crimea and took with her not only her child but

also margarita when it comes to renting a rug, and the woman participated in the reference when our the armed forces began to approach this village, she decided to flee from this village and took her younger daughter and margarita with her, according to the locals, who apparently was going to flee to the crimea, but i know that margarita was apparently not missed. in october, there was information that a female collaborator with her child did run away but she left margarita unknown, where at first it was reported that the girl was stuck at some checkpoint in nova kakhovka, and later information appeared that the child was in transit and i began to contact her. i first corresponded with her at with this, and then explained that i am the class teacher and that i want to know what is up with this child. so we had a little conversation, at least because of the fact that her words were related to the information about the child, that she is currently in

the filtering example, for today borislav has already been released but margarita was never found, so it is possible that the girl was taken to the occupied peninsula. moreover, very recently, margarita's mother told us that a few days ago, a girl who looked like her daughter was seen in the crimea, and while all the details are being clarified, i want to note that there are never many details therefore, i appeal to the inhabitants of the peninsula , remember the face of margarita mityunina, the girl looks like she is 8 years old, she has light blond hair. she is quite sociable, so she can tell about herself and her relatives. the woman is already an adult in 2014. that is, she knows who she is, she knows her last name, mother, father she knows everything, little sister, she knows everything, if you know the fate of the girl, if anyone has seen her or knows where she might be, call now on the short number 116 000 from any ukrainian mobile operator, calls are free if

there is no way to call, write to the chat bot of the child search service in telegram. i also want to remind you that the search for 15-year-old yulia kurbel, who disappeared in the luhansk region in the city of severodonetsk, is ongoing. the connection with the child was cut off in march, when heavy shelling began there, then severodonetsk was occupied, so about the child has been in the ninth month, there is no news. i know that yuliya kurbel lived at 117 gagarina street, and here is the actual photo of the house in which she lived. on social networks if you suddenly know the fate of 15-year-old yulia kurbel or someone has seen the girl, immediately call us on the hotline of the magnolia children's search service at the short number 116,000. calls from all ukrainian mobile operators are free . if there is no way to call, write to

the search chatbot service children in the telegram , any information is important, this is our first room, the registration room is here, we have tea, coffee, it is possible to recharge gadgets here, we have a room for children, we have arranged it, it is so bright and cheerful, there is books, toys to have so that you can lie around, including er, pencils to draw, and in this room, in the next room, we have a room for the elderly so that the children do not disturb the elderly. if they want to

rest a little, this is one of the points of unbreakability arranged on the basis of the school in the shevchenkiv district of the capital. it has a separate entrance so as not to interfere with the educational process. it can accommodate up to 100 people at the same time. despite this, there are not many visitors here. this is my drawing of the flag of ukraine . ukraine, but i have it, that’s me, mom and dad, dad. i’m at war right now. well, i miss nothing. well, he used to come and sometimes he comes. arina is probably the only visitor here. she came on duty together with her mother, it was the school employees and representatives of the anti-terrorist defense 24 hours a day. people are accepted here, with the exception of air alarms, during an alarm , the point does not work, both

the staff of the point and visitors must be in a safe place in the shelter. therefore, we are closing and everyone is going to the shelter. some visitors are conditioned due to the lack of long-term outages in this area of ​​the city, there was no electricity for several days in a row. therefore, the gostomel police support point was visited by several hundred people a day. in the event of power outages, people can come here to warm up, drink tea, have a snack, and charge their phone gadgets in case of absence from here . you can always turn to the police for help, we are here 24 hours a day and this point is open 24 hours a day, we provide all police services if people want to make a complaint yes, we here they are accepted in the conditions of long blackouts , points of unbreakability turn into a

working office half a day i work at home while holding the battery and half the day i work at the point of unbreakability charging all the gadgets for teenagers, electronic devices are also important so schoolchildren bohdana kyrylo charge their phones here and can have a little rest and play there was no light in one of the games, we had charged power banks, and now everything is discharged, so they came to charge it . 412 unbreakable points, 530 more in kyiv itself , however, in the event of a long-term power outage, they will not be enough. there are millions of people in kyiv, so let's calculate for ourselves how many such points are needed in order to satisfy all needs. of course, this is physically

and even technically impossible. there for a permanent residence, let's say, but nevertheless , popular songs of yanu are used. in difficult moments when we have electricity , a lot of people turn to it precisely for recharging gadgets, the list of these points includes gas stations, pharmacies, shops, post offices that have generators and provide services exclusively for recharging, also most utility points do not have sterlinks, which makes it impossible to connect to the internet in the event of a blackout, but despite russia's constant attempts to damage our civil infrastructure, kyiv region and the capital are holding the situation is now stabilized and it can, and as a result of shelling as a result of the russian stage of attacks on the one hand, we will do everything to to ensure the operation of all systems, but

objectively, everything depends on the utility companies. the enemy of the energy sector has methodically attacked the capital for a whole week, precisely in the civil infrastructure, but the power outages do not frighten local residents, in particular gostomel, which was occupied by the russians near kyiv, the vast majority of the townspeople were forced to leave their homes so now, despite all the trials, people want to stay at home. i have already been in refugee status. i don't want to go anywhere, even though there is light, water and heat. i lived in austria in vienna, i am very grateful to the austrians and everyone who helped me, but home is better at home , even without light even